Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1/7
2026:CGHC:23084
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 1929 of 2019
PAWAN
KUMAR
JHA
Reserved on: 14.05.2026
Delivered on: 15.07.2026
Uploaded on: 16.07.2026
Digitally
signed by
PAWAN
KUMAR JHA
•
ICICI Lumbard General Insurance Company Limited, Through Its Legal
Manager, Vanijya Bhawan, Ground Floor, Devendra Nagar, Raipur
Chhattisgarh...........Insurer
--- Appellant/ Non-applicant No. 2
versus
1. Suresh Jaiswal, S/o Dular Jaiswal, Aged About 25 Years R/o Village Ghughri,
P.S. And Tahsil Dabhra, District Janjgir Champa Chhattisgarh...........Claimant
2. Vijay Kumar Sidar S/o Ghasiya Ram Sidar, Aged About 35 Years R/o Village
Tilgi, P.S. And Tahsil Pussour, District Raigarh Chhattisgarh.............OwnerDriver of Vehicle No. CG13UF5990
3. Kamlesh Kumar S/o Dular Jaiswal, Aged About 29 Years R/o Village Ghughri,
P.S. And Tahsil Dabhra, District Janjgir Champa Chhattisgarh...............Owner
of Vehicle No. CG11AC2512
4. Branch Manager, Iffco Tokio General Insurance Company, Branch Office
Raigarh, Gourishankar Mandir Road, Raigarh Chhattisgarh.
---Respondents/ Non-applicants
MAC No. 242 of 2020
•
Suresh Jaiswal S/o Dular Jaiswal Aged About 26 Years R/o Village Ghughri,
Police Station And Tahsil Dabhra, District - Janjgir - Champa Chhattisgarh.
--- Appellant/ Claimant
versus
1. Vijay Kumar Sidar S/o Ghasiya Ram Sidar, Aged About 35 Years R/o Village
Tilgi, Police Station And Tahsil Pusour, District - Raigarh Chhattisgarh. (Non
Applicant No. 1)
2. Kamlesh Kumar S/o Dular Jaiswal Vehicle Owner, R/o Ghughri Police Station
And Tahsil Dabhra, District Jangir- Champa Chhattisgarh Taluka Dabhra,
District Jangir Champa Chhattisarh.
2/7
3. Branch Manager Efko Tokiyo General Insurance Company Branch Office
Raigarh Gaurishankar Mandir Road Raigarh Chhattisgarh Taluka Raigarh,
District Raigarh Chhattisgarh.
4. Branch Manager I.C.I.C.I Lombard Insurance Company Brance Office Raipur,
District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
---Respondents/ Non-applicants
____________________________________________________________
In MAC No. 1929 of 2019
For Appellant
For Respondent No. 1
For Respondent No. 2
For Respondent No. 4
: Mr. Sourabh Gupta, Advocate on behalf of
Mr. Sourabh Sharma, Advocate
: Mr. Pradeep Kumar Jogi, Advocate
: Mr. Ravi Kumar Banjare, Advocate on behalf of
Mr. Manoj Kumar Jaiswal, Advocate
: Ms. Shrejal Gupta, Advocate on behalf of Mr.
Vaibhav Shukla, Advocate
In MAC No. 242 of 2020
For Appellant
For Respondent No. 1
For Respondent No. 3
For Respondent No. 4
: Mr. Pradeep Kumar Jogi, Advocate
: Mr. Ravi Kumar Banjare, Advocate on behalf
of Mr. Manoj Kumar Jaiswal, Advocate
: Mr. Pravesh Sahu, Advocate on behalf of Mr.
P.R. Patankar, Advocate
: Mr. Sourabh Gupta, Advocate on behalf of
Mr. Sourabh Sharma, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
C.A.V. Order
1.
As both these appeals are being filed under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “Act of 1988”), challenging the legality and
sustainability of the impugned award dated 15.03.2019 passed by Learned
First Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Raigarh, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh (for short “Claims Tribunal”) in Claim Case No. 85/2017, they
are heard together and decided by this common order.
2.
In claim case No. 85/2017, Claims Tribunal had allowed the application filed
by Suresh Jaiswal (appellant in MAC No. 242/2020) in part and awarded total
sum of Rs. 7,70,200 as compensation, fastening liability upon non-applicant
No. 2-Insurance Company (appellant in MAC No. 1971/2019).
3.
Brief facts of the case for disposal of these appeals are that on 18.10.2015 at
about 10:00 am, Suresh Jaiswal/ claimant was travelling on his motorcycle
3/7
from village Ghughri to Baramkela on motorcycle bearing No. CG11AC2512.
On the way, another motorcycle bearing No. CG13UF5990 (hereinafter
referred to as “offending motorcycle”) dashed the motorcycle of claimant. In
the said accident, claimant Suresh Jaiswal suffered grievous injuries over his
person. He was taken to hospital at Baramkela from where he was referred
to Jindal hospital, Raigarh and had also taken treatment at Ramkrishna
Hospital, Raipur. He suffered grievous injuries over his hand and later on
suffered permanent disability. Claimant thereafter filed an application under
Section 166 of the Act of 1988 seeking compensation of Rs. 50,40,000 in
total against non-applicants therein, ie., driver of offending motorcycle,
insurer of offending motorcycle and owner and insurer of motorcycle driven
by claimant. In the claim application, it was pleaded that claimant on the date
of accident was working as agricultural labourer and earning Rs. 15,000 per
month.
4.
Non-applicant No. 1/ owner-cum-driver of the offending motorcycle submitted
reply denying the facts pleaded therein. It was also pleaded that the accident
was a result of self negligence on the part of claimant. Offending motorcycle
was insured with non-applicant No. 2.
5.
Non-applicant No. 2-Insurer submitted its separate reply and has denied the
pleadings with regard to the employment and earnings of claimant. Injuries
stated to have been suffered by claimant is also denied. Accident was a
result of self-negligence and that at the time of accident offending motorcycle
was being driven in breach of policy conditions as the driver of offending
motorcycle was not possessed with valid and effective driving licence.
6.
Non-applicant No. 3/ owner of vehicle driven by claimant has also denied the
facts pleaded therein and further pleaded that the accident was a result of
self-negligence on the part of claimant.
7.
Non-applicant No. 4/ Insurer of motorcycle driven by claimant has also
submitted reply denying the facts pleaded therein. It is pleaded that the
4/7
compensation sought for is highly exaggerated, accident was a result of selfnegligence on the part of claimant and that claimant himself was driver of the
vehicle insured by it.
8.
Learned Claims Tribunal based on the pleadings made has formulated as
many as five issues for consideration and upon conclusion of trial of claim
case had allowed the claim application in part, recorded a finding that the
appellant suffered 40% permanent disability on his hand and after computing
compensation on different heads had awarded sum of Rs. 7,70,200.
9.
Learned counsel for appellant-Insurance Company would submit that the
Claims Tribunal erred in fastening liability upon it. The said finding recorded
by the Claims Tribunal is perverse to the evidence available on record. The
amount of compensation awarded is highly exaggerated. It is also contended
that accident was not reported to the concerned police station and further
that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent act of claimant and
therefore the liability fastened upon appellant-insurance company is
erroneous. He also contended that there was head-on-collision between two
motorcycles and therefore there is contributory negligence on the part of
claimant to the extent of 50% but the Claims Tribunal failed to consider this
aspect that the accident is on account of self-negligence on the part of
claimant.
10.
Claimant/ appellant in MAC No. 242/2020 would submit that the Claims
Tribunal has rightly come to conclusion that the offending motorcycle insured
by non-applicant No. 2 was involved in accident and upon appreciation of
evidence has rightly awarded the compensation to claimant. He however
would submit that less amount of compensation is awarded. It is contended
that the Claims Tribunal has not awarded compensation towards loss of
future prospects in the facts of the case where claimant suffered permanent
disability as held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of National Insurance
5/7
Company Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi, reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680. The doctor
who examined the claimant has issued certificate to the extent of 40%
permanent disability and therefore the Claims Tribunal ought to have
awarded compensation towards loss of future prospects also.
The
compensation awarded on other heads is also on lower side.
11.
I have heard learned counsel for the respective parties and also perused the
record of claim case.
12.
Perusal of impugned award would show that the Claims Tribunal has given a
finding that on the date of accident driver of both the vehicles drove the
motorcycle without precaution and have negligently caused accident. Upon
perusal of the issues framed would show that the Claims Tribunal has not
formulated any issue with regard to whether there was contributory
negligence. The issue with regard to contributory negligence in the facts of
the case was necessary when drivers of both motorcycles have filed
separate claim applications, one from which these appeals are arising in
claim case No. 85/2017 and another claim application bearing claim case No.
21/2017. In both the claim cases, issue has been framed whether nonapplicant No. 1 on the date of accident drove the motorcycle rashly and
negligently and in both the cases this issue has been decided in affirmative.
Non framing of issue towards negligence in the facts of the case, in the
opinion of this Court, appears to be fatal.
13.
Claims Tribunal on deciding the issue with regard to 40% permanent
disability has considered the evidence of doctor, AW-2, who issued
permanent disability certificate Ext. P-13, had concluded that claimants
suffered 40% permanent disability and computed compensation accordingly
but had not awarded compensation towards future prospects. Loss of future
prospects in case of permanent disability has been considered by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Chandramani Nanda vs. Sarat Chandra Swain & Anr.
6/7
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2859 wherein the Court has held that the
claimant who suffered permanent disability is also entitled for the loss of
future prospects and held thus:“14.3
However, the Tribunal and the High Court
both have failed to consider the fact that the appellant
is also entitled for enhancement on account of future
prospects. Hence, in line with the law laid down in
National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi,
given the age of appellant was 32 years at the time of
accident, he is entitled to 40% future prospects.”
14.
In view of the aforementioned decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court the
injured/claimant who suffered permanent disability, is entitle for addition of
loss of future prospects based on the age of the deceased as held by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National Insurance Company Ltd.
vs. Pranay Sethi, reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680. For adding compensation
towards future prospects Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that where the
claimant or deceased was less than 40 years and not in permanent
employment, 40% of the assessed income is to be added towards loss of
future prospects but the Claims Tribunal erred in not adding any
compensation towards loss of future prospects. Claims Tribunal has also
erred in assessing income of claimant as Rs. 4,500 per month in the facts of
the case on lower side.
15.
As Claims Tribunal has not formulated issue with regard to contributory
negligence in the facts of the case, I am of the considered view that the
impugned award passed by the Claims Tribunal is not sustainable and
accordingly the award passed in claim case No. 85/2017 dated 15.03.2019 is
not sustainable and it is hereby set aside. The matter is remitted back to the
concerned Claims Tribunal for deciding the claim case No. 85/2017 afresh
after framing additional issue of contributory negligence. It goes without
saying that as the additional issue is to be framed, the parties will be at liberty
to lead further evidence.
7/7
16.
Parties are directed to appear before the Claims Tribunal on 18.08.2026.
17.
Consequently, MAC No. 1929/2019 is allowed in part.
18.
In view of decision made in MAC No. 1929/2019, MAC No. 242/2020 filed by
claimant seeking enhancement of amount of compensation is not required
any consideration on merits, accordingly it is also disposed of in light of
decision in MAC No. 1929/2019.
Sd/-
(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
pwn
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review