Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:69
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 1st JUNE, 2016
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.A. No.34 of 2015
Appellant
:
Suresh Chettri,
S/o Late Ran Bahadur Chettri,
R/o Phungla Busty,
P.S. Namchi,
South Sikkim.
[Presently residing at Tingley Busty,
Bermoik, Temi P.S., South Sikkim]
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Appeal under Section 374(2) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. Jigme P. Bhutia, Legal Aid Counsel for the Appellant.
Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Additional Public Prosecutor with
Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Public Prosecutor for the StateRespondent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
By filing this Appeal, the Appellant seeks to assail the
Judgment and Order on Sentence of the Court of the Learned
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
Sessions Judge, Special Division – II, East Sikkim at Gangtok, dated
31-10-2015 in Sessions Trial Case No.04 of 2015, convicting the
Appellant under Section 304 Part II of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(for short “IPC”) and sentencing him to undergo rigorous
imprisonment of five years and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees
five thousand) only, with a default stipulation.
2.
The Prosecution version is that the Complainant (now
deceased), on 06-02-2014 lodged a Complaint before the Officer-inCharge, Pakyong P.S., informing therein that on 04-02-2014 her
husband, the Appellant herein, came home in an intoxicated state,
assaulted her, burnt her original documents, verbally abused her
mother and broke the door and window to her mother’s house. That
she was unable to report the matter on the same date due to body
ache. The report was recorded as G.D. Entry No.106 of the Police
Station and the Complainant forwarded to the Pakyong PHC along
with a Police escort, for medical examination. The Medical Officer
who examined the victim recorded the injuries to be “Simple” in
nature. However, on 08-02-2014, the Complainant was admitted to
the Central Referral Hospital, Tadong (for short “CRH”) in a critical
condition. The District Magistrate and the Medical Officer in charge
were requested to record the statement of the victim under Section
32 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (for short “the Evidence Act”).
The Police collected her Medical Report on 18-02-2014 from the CRH,
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
Tadong, where the nature of injuries were recorded as grievous, due
to internal bleeding. Consequently, suo motu FIR was registered by
the SHO as Pakyong P.S. Case No.06/2014, dated 18-02-2014, under
Section 325 of the IPC, against the Appellant and endorsed to P.W.
18, the Investigating Officer (for short “the I.O.”), for investigation.
The Accused was arrested on 19-02-2014 from Tingley, South Sikkim
and enlarged on bail by the Police. On 23-02-2014, the victim was
discharged
from
CRH,
Tadong
and
admitted
to
Nivedita
Multispecialty Hospital, Pradhan Nagar, Siliguri, West Bengal, for
higher medical treatment, where on 30-03-2014, she passed away.
Thereafter, the I.O. converted the offence under Section 325 of the
IPC to Sections 302/498‘A’ of the IPC and on completion of
investigation, submitted Charge-sheet against the Appellant under
the above Sections of Law, on 20-08-2014.
The Appellant was
rearrested on 27-08-2014 and released by the Magistrate on 01-122014, in terms of Section 167(2) of the Code of the Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C.”).
3.
Investigation revealed that the victim was a Teacher in
the Government Secondary School, Phungla, South Sikkim, where
she met the Appellant around the year 2004 and despite opposition,
married him.
Later, the Appellant obtained employment as a
“Safaikaramchari” in the Government Senior Secondary School,
Pacheykhani, East Sikkim and they started residing in a rented room
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
after the victim’s transfer from South Sikkim, but regular fights
ensued between them, both being drinkers. Complaints of physical
assault by the Appellant, on the victim, were resolved by family
members and the Area Panchayat. This continued for a prolonged
period without the victim initiating any action against the
Appellant. On 03-02-2014, the Appellant, reportedly spent the night
with the victim’s uncle who was unwell, at Pacheykhani PHC, and on
04-02-2014 when the victim and her mother came visiting, the
Appellant went to the market and consumed alcohol. Later, all of
them including the patient, returned home and the victim entered
her room to watch television with P.W.2 and P.W.3 where the
Appellant followed and verbally abused her in front of the children
while assaulting her with fists and blows. The frightened children
ran out from the house but watched the incident through the
window of the room, while P.W.3 her nephew, ran to the house of
P.W.1, the mother of the victim (his grandmother), located nearby
and called her. The victim ran into the kitchen to save herself and
P.W.1 on her arrival pleaded with the Appellant to stop the assault,
to no avail. The victim escaped and went to the house of P.W.5 at
around 8 p.m., where she narrated the incident to her. On 05-022014, being too weak to go out of the house, she lodged the
Complaint Exhibit 18 at the Police Station only on 06-02-2014,
accompanied by P.W.5. On 07-02-2014, the victim complained of
severe headache with pain in her abdomen and hands and remained
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
bed ridden the whole day. The next day, 08-02-2014, she informed
P.W.5 that she was going to the Hospital but later villagers informed
P.W.5 that the victim was resting in a nearby shed. P.W.5 rushed to
the house of P.W.1 and along with her took the victim to CRH,
Tadong, where the victim’s condition was declared to be critical and
she was put on ventilator. On 23-02-2014 she was admitted to a
Siliguri Hospital where she died on 30-03-2014.
4.
The Learned Trial Court after hearing the Counsel for
the parties found prima facie materials to frame charge against the
Appellant under Section 304 Part I and Section 498A of the IPC, to
which the Appellant pleaded “not guilty” and claimed trial.
5.
In a bid to prove its case, the Prosecution examined
eighteen witnesses.
After considering and analysing the entire
evidence on record, the Learned Trial Court passed the impugned
Judgment and Order on Sentence. The Appellant was acquitted of
the offence under Section 498‘A’ of the IPC.
6.
I have heard the rival submissions put forth by Learned
Counsel for both parties at length and given anxious consideration
to the same. I have also carefully perused the evidence and entire
documents on record as well as the impugned Judgment and Order
on Sentence. Thus, what falls for consideration before this Court is
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
whether the Appellant was rightly convicted by the Learned Trial
Court in light of the evidence on record.
7.
In the first limb of his argument, Learned Legal Aid
Counsel for the Appellant before this Court urged that the Learned
Trial Court failed to appreciate that the instant case was wrongly
registered on suo motu basis by the SHO, Pakyong P.S. on 18-02-2014,
when the earliest information Exhibit 18 was recorded in GD Entry
No.106, dated 06-02-2014 leading to two FIRs in the matter.
That,
Exhibit 18 does not reveal that the victim was severely beaten up by
her husband as sought to be made out by P.W.17 the SHO which
P.W.18, the I.O. has also failed to support.
8.
Countering this argument the stand of the Learned
Additional Public Prosecutor was that on receipt of Exhibit 18 GD
Entry was made, Notice issued to the Appellant to report at the
Police Station and the victim sent for medical examination. As the
injury was recorded as “Simple” no further steps were taken. No
formal FIR was drawn up on the basis of Exhibit 18 but the Police
deemed it appropriate to make preliminary enquiries as the assault
was by her husband. Later, the victim was admitted to CRH, Tadong
in a critical condition and on collection of Medical Report by the
Police, suo motu FIR was registered against the Appellant under
Section 325 of the IPC.
Hence, Exhibit 21 is the only FIR in the
matter, on the basis of which investigation was launched. Relying
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
on the decision in Lalita Kumari vs. Government of Uttar Pradesh
and Others1 it was urged by the State-Respondent that the Police
have the powers to conduct a preliminary inquiry in matrimonial
disputes, after a Complaint is lodged, before embarking
on an
investigation.
9.
Having considered the submissions on this point, it
would be appropriate first to refer to Section 154 of the Cr.P.C. which
pertains to information in Cognizable offences and, inter alia, lays
down that every information relating to the commission of a
Cognizable offence, if given orally to an officer in charge of a police
station, shall be reduced to writing by him or under his direction.
Hence, the registration of an FIR is mandatory under Section 154 of
the Cr.P.C., if the information so furnished discloses commission of a
Cognizable offence. This Section affords no discretion to a police
officer to hold a preliminary enquiry. On the heels of this provision,
Section 156 of the Cr.P.C. deals with the powers of Police to
investigate into Cognizable offences. Under this Section the Police
have a statutory right to investigate into any alleged Cognizable
offence without any authority from a Magistrate.
10.
Section 155 of the Cr.P.C., on the other hand, pertains to
information as to Non-Cognizable cases and investigation of such
cases and provides that when information is given to an Officer-in1. (2014) 2 SCC 1
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
Charge of a Police Station of the commission within the limits of
such station of a Non-Cognizable offence, he shall enter or cause to
be entered the substance of the information in a book to be kept by
such officer, in such form, as the State Government may prescribe in
this behalf and refer the informant to the Magistrate.
11.
While bearing the above provisions in mind, we may
refer to Exhibit 18, the Complaint filed by the deceased before the
Police Station which bears the stamp of the Pakyong P.S. indicating
G. D. Entry No.106, dated 06-02-2014. In the first instance, while
examining the contents, although the Complainant states that she
was beaten up by the Appellant, in the latter portion of the
Complaint her prayer roughly translated to English from the Nepali
vernacular would be “……………. the Officer-in-Charge, issue a strict
command to the Appellant to go away and not to enter my house,
which would thus be beneficial to me”. The Police on receipt of
Exhibit 18 sent her for medical examination to the Pakyong PHC, the
nearest medical support. The Doctor P.W. 12, found no external
injuries save tenderness on her back and opined that the injury was
“Simple” vide Exhibit 7.
Consequently, the offence fell under
Section 323 of the IPC, a Non-Cognizable offence.
In such a
circumstance, reference can be made to Section 155(2) which enjoins
upon the Police Officer not to investigate a Non-Cognizable case
without the order of a Magistrate having power to try such case or
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
commit the case for trial. Thus, finding that the offence was NonCognizable the Police correctly made a G.D. Entry but did not
embark upon an investigation being devoid of such powers without
Magisterial directions. In the above situation, relying on the ratio of
Lalita Kumari vs. Government of Uttar Pradesh and Others 1 (supra),
it is clear that the Police can exercise the discretion of holding a
preliminary inquiry when the offence is one involving a matrimonial
dispute as in the instant case. Subsequently, when the Police learnt
that the victim was in a critical condition in CRH, Tadong, Exhibit 21,
a suo motu FIR, was lodged by the SHO Pakyong P.S. against the
Appellant under Section 325 of the IPC duly registered, and endorsed
to P.W.18 for investigation.
Hence, it is evident that Exhibit 21,
which revealed a Cognizable offence, is the only FIR in the matter.
12.
The next argument that was placed by the Appellant is
that not only are P.W.2 and P.W.3 child witnesses but there are
material contradictions in their statements as recorded under
Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. and in their evidence in Court, besides
which their statements during investigation was recorded by P.W.18,
I.O., over the telephone, raising a question on their identities.
Before the Court both P.Ws deposed that the Appellant gave a blow
on their aunt’s stomach, which allegation, however, finds no place in
their statement to the Police. It is also contended that P.W.2 has
admitted that prior to coming to Court she had a talk with her
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
grandmother P.W.1, about the case, which is a clear indication that
she was tutored.
It was, per contra, argued that P.W.2 and P.W.3
were not confronted with their Section 161 Cr.P.C. statements in the
Court by reading out the relevant portions and, therefore, the
witness was unaware as to which statement was sought to be
contradicted by the Appellant, besides which there is no proof of
tutoring. Hence, this argument of the Appellant was not tenable.
13.
In this context, we may refer to the provisions of
Section 160 of the Cr.P.C. which is the Police Officer’s power to
require attendance of witnesses during investigation. Any Police
Officer, making an investigation under Chapter XII of the Cr.P.C. may
by order in writing, require the attendance before himself of any
person who appears to be acquainted with the facts and
circumstances of the case and such person shall attend as so
required.
The Proviso to the Section debars a Police Officer from
requiring the attendance of any male person under the age of fifteen
years or above the age of sixty-five years or a woman, or a mentally
or physically disabled person at any place other than their
residence. From the evidence of P.W.3 the minor witness, duly
confirmed by the evidence of P.W.18, the I.O. herself, it is clear that
the Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. statement of the two minor witnesses
were recorded by the I.O. telephonically. It does indeed appear to be
a novel method engineered by the I.O. to record statements, duly
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
circumventing the specific provisions of the Proviso to Section 160
of the Cr.P.C. apparently in a nonchalant and lackadaisical manner
scant regard being paid to the consequences, even when the offence
was one allegedly under Section 302 of the IPC, by the summation of
the Police themselves. Apparently, the I.O. deemed it below her
dignity to go to the house of P.W.2 and P.W.3.
She has also
unabashedly admitted that since she has taken the statement of the
two child witnesses over the telephone she could not say for sure as
to whether it was the same witnesses who had witnessed the
incident in the house of the victim. The only witnesses for the
Prosecution, to the alleged assault on the stomach of the victim, by
the Appellant, are P.W.2 and P.W.3.
Although a statement under
Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. is not substantive evidence but it can be
used for contradiction, as provided under Section 145 of the
Evidence Act hence, the importance attached to it.
14.
On perusal of the impugned Judgment, it is evident that
the Learned Trial Court has taken into consideration the evidence of
P.W.2 and P.W.3 with regard to the assault on the victim. On the
touchstone of the admission of the I.O. as reflected hereinabove,
would the Prosecution be in a position to vouch confidently on the
identity of P.W.2 and P.W.3.
When P.W.18 herself is unable to
establish the identity of the P.W.2 and P.W.3, would it be just and
reasonable for the Court to rely on the evidence of such witnesses?
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
Where is the guarantee that they are not witnesses manufactured by
P.W.1 and P.W.7 for the purposes of this case? Would a reasonable
doubt not arise, in the absence of identity, that they never witnessed
the incident but were meticulously tutored and furnished as
witnesses? In such a circumstance, the alleged ocular evidence of
P.W.2 and P.W.3 cannot at all be taken into consideration to the
prejudice of the Appellant, their identity being shrouded in mystery,
on account of the fact that the I.O. has never seen them. Thus, the
Learned Sessions Judge has erred in considering their evidence and
has in fact failed to discuss this aspect in his Judgment.
It is,
therefore, unconscionable for this Court to consider the evidence of
P.W.2 and P.W.3 without proof of their identity. There is no option
but to throw out their evidence from the purview of consideration.
15.
The next argument put forth by the Appellant was that
there are different versions in the Medical Reports, viz., Exhibit 7,
the first Medical Report of the victim, Exhibit 14, the Wound
Certificate issued by the CRH, Tadong on 15-02-2014 after examining
the patient on 08-02-2014, and Exhibit 15 prepared by P.W.15. The
Doctor, P.W.12 who first examined the victim has opined that the
victim only suffered from simple injury as per Exhibit 7, whereas
Exhibit 14 records several injuries on the victim and opines that the
injuries is grievous, Exhibit 17 issued by the same Hospital endorses
the above opinion. Exhibit 15 records that the victim was diagnosed
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
with severe sepsis and multiple organ dysfunction system.
That,
thereafter Exhibit 29 clearly indicates that the cause of death was
due to “B/L Bronchopneumonia with ARDS Septicaemia” and the
manner of death was recorded as “Natural”, therefore, not as a
consequence of any injury. That it is inconceivable as to how on 0602-2014 no injuries were recorded in Exhibit 7 but vide Exhibit 14
after two intervening days the victim was found to have sustained
grievous injuries.
The discrepancies in the medical documents,
therefore, raises a doubt with regard to the Prosecution case. The
counter
argument advanced by
Learned Additional
Public
Prosecutor was that the assault was witnessed by P.W.2 and P.W.3,
thus there is no question of there having been no injury on the
victim. That it is the right of the Court to act on the testimony of
one Doctor and prefer the testimony of the Medical Officer whose
evidence accords with the Prosecution version. To buttress this
argument, reliance was placed by the Additional Public Prosecutor
on Makan Jivan and Others vs. The State of Gujarat2.
16.
Having considered the arguments of the Learned
Additional Public Prosecutor, I have also carefully perused Exhibits
7, 14, 15, 17 and 29. I have to agree with Learned Counsel for the
Appellant that it is inconceivable as to how a cut injury over the
right hand of the victim, recorded in Exhibit 14 could have escaped
2. (1971) 3 SCC 297
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
the notice of P.W.12, the first examining Doctor who in fact
examined the victim on the third day after the incident. It is also
difficult to believe that ecchymosis (discolouration of skin resulting
from bleeding underneath) over her right forearm could have been
missed by P.W.12.
The failure of the victim to inform the Doctor
that she was assaulted by her husband and was suffering from any
abdominal pain raises another doubt. Exhibit 15, the Report of
P.W.15 is reflective of the fact that the victim was admitted in the
Siliguri Hospital with a past history of assault about two months
back, the details of which he admits were not provided. It cannot be
Comprehended as to why the person who accompanied the victim
did not provide details of the assault.
Exhibit 27 is the “Case
Summary” recorded by the CRH, wherein it is, inter alia, stated that
the patient was brought by P.W.7 (her sister) with an alleged history
of physical assault. Surprisingly the name of the assailant has not
been disclosed by P.W.7 to the concerned Doctor. The discrepancies
in Exhibit 7 and Exhibit 14 are too divergent to ignore, in the
backdrop of the fact that the alleged assault took place on 04-022014, whereas grievous injury was found only on 08-02-2014, thereby
failing to link the injuries to the alleged assault by the Appellant.
That apart, there is no proof to substantiate the evidence of P.W.5
that the victim spent the night in her house. No other witness has
supported this evidence of P.W.5 neither has the victim herself
mentioned this in Exhibit 3, allegedly her dying declaration.
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
17.
State of Sikkim
Exhibit 26, the sketch map of the place of occurrence
reveals that the house of P.W.1 is located close to the victim’s house.
After such a dreadful assault as claimed by the Prosecution and
P.W.1, it is but natural that the protective instincts of P.W.1 as a
mother and nurturer comes to the fore, thus the question arises as
to why the victim sought to take shelter in the house of a third
person, viz., P.W.5, instead of the house of P.W.1, which apart from
being her mother’s house was also located close by. Another aspect
that raises a doubt in the Prosecution case is that P.W.1 deposed of a
visit to the PHC on 07-02-2014, along with the victim consequent to
which the Doctor of Pakyong PHC referred the victim to STNM
Hospital. To the contrary, no records of the Hospital exists to
support this, neither are there any referral documents, in addition
to which P.W.12, the Doctor at the PHC, does not support this
version of P.W.1 as she asserts that she did not examine the victim
after 06-02-2014. In this context, it would also be appropriate to
refer to Exhibit 1, an apology letter signed by the Appellant on 0502-2013, in the presence of P.W.1 as well as the Area Panchayat and
three independent witnesses. It has been explained by the Learned
Additional Public Prosecutor that the date has been wrongly entered
in the document as 05-02-2013 but ought to read as 05-02-2014. In
the light of the said explanation, the contents of Exhibit P1 are duly
perused. This document pertains to an apology by the Appellant for
his mistake and an undertaking by him not to break the door and
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
window to the house of his mother-in-law (P.W.1) or not to use
abusive words against her. He also undertakes not to use abusive
language or to attack his sister-in-law Sashikala. The letter nowhere
reflects the assault on the victim. If P.W.1 was present when Exhibit
1 was prepared it cannot be fathomed as to why she did not insist on
including the apology of the Appellant in connection with the
assault on the victim, if such assault had indeed taken place.
That
apart, Exhibits 9, 11 and 13, the Medical Report of the Appellant
indicates no external injuries on him.
18.
Besides, the above inconsistencies, P.W.1 did not
personally know that the victim had gone to the house of P.W.5 after
the assault but deposed that on the following day she learnt that the
victim had spent the night with P.W.5. It was only on the third day
that P.W.5 came to her house and told her that the victim was in a
critical condition, the third day being, 07-02-2014, the incident
having occurred on 04-02-2014. Being the mother of the victim this
situation appears incongruous.
19.
Exhibit 14 and Exhibit 17 the Wound Certificates and
Exhibit 15 letter addressed to P.W.15 to the I.O., make no mention of
the Appellant as the assailant. Assuming that the victim was critical
and unable to speak, nothing prevented P.W.1 and the relatives who
had accompanied the victim to give the history of the injuries and
the reasons thereof but they have refrained from doing so. In such
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
circumstances, it becomes difficult to accept the Prosecution version
in totality that injuries found on the victim were caused by the
Appellant. In any event, it is well-settled Law that “6.
............ The golden thread which runs
through the web of administration of justice in
criminal cases is that if two views are possible on the
evidence adduced in the case, one pointing to the
guilt of the accused and the other to his innocence,
the view which is favourable to the accused should be
adopted. The paramount consideration of the court is
to ensure that miscarriage of justice is prevented. A
miscarriage of justice which may arise from acquittal
of the guilty is no less than from the conviction of an
innocent. In a case where admissible evidence is
ignored, a duty is cast upon the appellate court to
reappreciate the evidence even where the accused
has been acquitted, for the purpose of ascertaining as
to whether any of the accused committed any offence
or not.”3
20.
The next leg of the argument of the Learned Counsel for
the Appellant was that Exhibit 3, the dying declaration, of the victim
allegedly scribed by the victim herself nowhere mentions that the
Appellant had caused the injuries. For that matter, Exhibit 18 the
alleged Complaint of the victim dated 06-02-2014 also does not
indicate that the Appellant assaulted her severely on her stomach.
Per contra it is the contention of the Learned Additional Public
Prosecutor that in the first instance, Exhibit 3 clearly contains the
name of the Appellant, who according to the victim, tortured him
and that she had no peace. That in addition to Exhibit 3, reliance
can be placed on Exhibit 18 inasmuch if a Complaint is lodged and
3. Basappa vs. State of Karnataka : (2014) 5 SCC 154
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
the victim succumbs to her injuries, the Complaint can be treated as
a dying declaration.
On this point, reliance was placed on Babulal
and Others vs. State of M.P. 4 and Baldev Singh vs. State of Punjab5.
21.
Having considered the arguments, I have carefully
perused Exhibit 3.
The general rule for acceptance of evidence
under Section 32 of the Evidence Act is that no better evidence
exists. In the first instance the victim appears to have scribed
Exhibit 3 in the presence of P.W.10.
This witness has clearly
admitted that he had not issued any Certificate of Fitness to the
effect that the victim was in a fit state of mind at the time of
recording her dying declaration but the patient, as per P.W.10, was
not administered sedatives at the time of scribing Exhibit 3.
Assuming that a Certificate of Mental Fitness is not required
nevertheless considering the medical condition of the victim, her
injuries, being on ventilator and unable to speak due to the endo
tracheal tube inserted in situ for assisted ventilation, one can well
imagine the trauma she was undergoing and consequently her
mental condition. Under no circumstances would such a person be
in a proper frame of mind. This is clearly depicted in Exhibit 3,
which is an inchoate document in pidgin English which, however,
does not lay the blame of assault on 04-02-2014 at the door of the
Appellant. In fact, there is no whisper at all of the incident of
4. (2003) 12 SCC 490
5. (1990) 4 SCC 692
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
04-02-2014, her constant refrain in Exhibit 3 being that the Appellant
had tortured her of which her friends, Panchayat and Police were
aware. It is on record that regular fights ensued between the couple.
But, she gives no inkling of the incident of assault of 04-02-2014
thereby lending no credence to the Prosecution case by her
statement. In fact, in Exhibit 3, she admits to have taken high
pressure medicines carelessly, on account of which she had
breathing difficulty.
22.
Along with Exhibit 3, I also deem it essential to refer to
Exhibit 4 to assess the mental condition of the victim. According to
P.W.11 another Doctor at CRH, Tadong, on the requisition of the I.O.,
he preserved the statements scribed by the victim, whenever her
condition allowed her, as she was intubated and on medical
ventilation support.
Exhibit 4, in five pages, are allegedly the
statements scribed by the victim. These statements appear to have
been recorded by a person who is delirious and probably in a state of
hallucination as she has written that while entering her house she
heard the sound of hens clucking and was told that there were boys
from the village. Needless to add that at the relevant time she was
in Hospital. On a careful analysis of Exhibits 3 and 4, I do not
consider it either just or reasonable to rely on Exhibit 3 as a dying
declaration, being incoherent as it is and secondly making no
mention of the relevant incident or blaming the Appellant for the
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
State of Sikkim
injuries on her person. Added to all of the above is, the evidence of
P.W.7, P.W.17 and P.W.18 stating that after the incident the
Appellant was not seen in the locality. This has to be considered
along with the fact that the victim was examined on 06-02-2014 and
her injury recorded as “Simple”. The admission of P.W.1 that in fact
a Title Suit was pending between the deceased and her brothers
before the Civil Judge, East at Gangtok, is also to be borne in mind.
23.
Thus, while summing up the entire matter, I am of the
considered opinion that the Prosecution case stands negated on
account of all the inconsistencies and doubts raised hereinabove in
detail. Hence, I am constrained to opine that the Prosecution has
not been able to link the injuries on the victim as having been
caused by the Appellant.
24.
Resultant, the Prosecution case fails and the impugned
Judgment of the Learned Trial Court convicting the Appellant under
Section 304 Part II of the IPC and the consequent sentence is set
aside. Appellant is acquitted of the charge under Section 304 Part II
of the IPC. He be set at liberty forthwith.
25.
Appeal is allowed.
26.
Fine, if any, deposited by the Appellant in terms of the
impugned Order on Sentence, be reimbursed to him.
2016:SHC:69
Crl.A No.34 of 2015
Suresh Chettri vs.
27.
State of Sikkim
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Court
below for information and compliance along with the records.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
01-06-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review