Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17798/2019
1.
Surendra Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Jagdish Prasad Sharma,
Aged About 36 Years, R/o 12/17-C, Behind Madrasi Baba
Ki Bagichi, Kagdiwara, Brahmpuri, Jaipur (Rajasthan).
2.
Kushal Katara S/o Shri Hare Krishn Katara, Aged About
29 Years, R/o Plot No. 361, Gautam Path, Ramnagar,
Sodala, Jaipur (Rajasthan).
3.
Smt. Sanju Dubey W/o Shri Mahesh Chand Dubey, Aged
About
Years,
R/o
Keshavpura,
Sector-4,
Kota
(Rajasthan).
4.
Smt. Ruchi Gautam W/o Shri Lokesh Gautam, Aged About
38 Years, R/o Plot 40, Kotadi, Goverdhanpura, Kota,
(Rajasthan).
5.
Naresh Kumar Joshi S/o Shri Satya Narayan Joshi, Aged
About 31 Years, R/o Chandawato Ka Bas, Sojat City, Pali
(Rajasthan)
6.
Smt. Hemlata Rathore W/o Shri Girdhar Singh, Aged
About 32 Years, R/o Plot No. 18, Gautam Path, Ramnagar,
Sodala, Jaipur (Rajasthan).
7.
Smt. Rekha Shukla W/o Shri Manoj Tiwari, Aged About 31
Years, R/o 272/32, Hanuman Gali, Bhantipura, Dholpur
(Rajasthan).
8.
Smt. Arti Mishra W/o Shri Shyam Dixit, Aged About 32
Years, R/o Plot No. E-51, Jawahar Nagar, Bharatpur
(Rajasthan).
9.
Laxmikant Sain S/o Jairam Sain, Aged About 36 Years,
R/o Ward No. 27, Iti Road, Badabas, Kotputli, Jaipur
(Rajasthan).
10.
Smt. Kusum Sharma W/o Shri Mishri Lal, Aged About 46
Years,
Near
Swastic
Cinema,
Gali
No.2,
Kankroli,
Rajsamand (Rajasthan).
11.
Navneet Khateek S/o Shri Mohan Lal Khateek, Aged
About
Years,
R/o
Khutaria,
Tehsil
Nathdwara,
Rajsamand (Rajasthan).
12.
Smt. Manohar Kunwar Dewda W/o Shri Mahendra Singh,
Aged About 40 Years, R/o Sameshwar Road, Sadalpur,
Sirohi (Rajasthan)
(2 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
13.
[CW-17798/2019]
Smt. Manorama Sharma W/o Shri Govind Sharma, Aged
About 30 Years, R/o Vyas Colony, Lalsot Road, Dausa
(Rajasthan).
----Petitioners
Versus
1.
State
Of
Rajasthan,
Through
Principal
Secretary,
Government Of Rajasthan, Medical, Health And Family
Welfare Department Cum Managing Director National
Health Mission, Rajasthan.
2.
Mission Director, National Health Mission, Rajasthan,
Department Of Medical, Health And Family Welfare,
Swasthaya Bhawan, Tilak Marg, C-Scheme, Jaipur.
3.
Project
Director,
National
Health
Mission
(Nhm),
Rajasthan State Health Society, Swasthaya Bhawan, Tilak
Nagar, C-Scheme, Jaipur.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. C.P. Sharma with
Ms. Santosh Sharma
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Archit Bohra, AGC with
Ms. Sweekriti Sharma
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK KUMAR JAIN
Order
07/01/2026
1.
Instant writ petition is preferred by petitioners with following
prayer:
"(i).
by
an
appropriate
writ
order
or
direction, the respondents may kindly be
directed to pay the full salary and other
benefits
petitioners
involve
any
directly
mediator
i.e.
without
to
placement
agencies/N.G.O., as envisaged by the Central
Government for their posts.
(3 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
[CW-17798/2019]
ii). by an appropriate writ order or direction,
the respondents be directed to not replace
the
petitioners
with
the
other
set
of
contractual employees."
2.
During course of submissions, it has been apprised to the
Court that petitioner No. 2 Kushal Katara S/o Shri Hare
Krishn Katara, petitioner No.3 Smt. Sanju Dubey W/o Shri
Mahesh Chand Dubey, petitioner No. 4 Smt. Ruchi Gautam
W/o Shri Lokesh Gautam, petitioner No. 6 Smt. Hemlata
Rathore W/o Shri Girdhar Singh, petitioner No. 8 Smt. Arti
Mishra W/o Shri Shyam Dixit and petitioner No. 9 Laxmikant
Sain S/o Jairam Sain have left their job during pendency of
petition and they are not working under the scheme.
Learned counsel for respondent has also apprised the court
that petitioner No.10 Kusum Sharma and petitioner No. 11
Navneet Khateek were engaged directly under a contract.
Considering aforesaid the cause pleaded with regard to
petitioner Nos. 2 Kushal Katara S/o Shri Hare Krishn Katara,
petitioner No.3 Smt. Sanju Dubey W/o Shri Mahesh Chand
Dubey, petitioner No. 4 Smt. Ruchi Gautam W/o Shri Lokesh
Gautam, petitioner No. 6 Smt. Hemlata Rathore W/o Shri
Girdhar Singh, petitioner No. 8 Smt. Arti Mishra W/o Shri
Shyam Dixit, petitioner No. 9 Laxmikant Sain S/o Jairam
Sain is extinguished and petition is disposed of qua these
petitioners. Now we are considering petition with regard to
petitioner Nos. 1 Surendra Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Jagdish
Prasad Sharma, petitioner No. 5 Naresh Kumar Joshi S/o
Shri Satya Narayan Joshi, petitioner No. 7 Smt. Rekha
(4 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
[CW-17798/2019]
Shukla W/o Shri Manoj Tiwari, petitioner No. 12 Smt.
Manohar Kunwar Dewda W/o Shri Mahendra Singh and
petitioner No. 13 Smt. Manorama Sharma W/o Shri Govind
Sharma.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners, while placing reliance
upon the judgment dated 19.01.2021 passed in S.B. Civil
Writ Petition No. 7273/2020 Jai Prakash Ghanchi and Ors.
Vs. State of Rajasthan and Ors. by a Coordinate Bench at
the Principal Seat, Jodhpur, submitted that under the
National Health Mission (NHM) the petitioners were engaged
on the post of RMNCH/Family Planning Counselor, but
contrary to the directions, the petitioners were engaged
through
a
submitted
human
that
resource
said
service
engagement
provider.
has
issued
He
also
certain
directions for direct engagement through Rajasthan Medical
Relief Society (RMRS) as per Government order dated
29.02.2020.
4.
He further placed reliance upon the judgments in the cases
of Bhilwara Dugdh Utpadak Sahakari S. Ltd. vs. Vinod
Kumar Sharma (Dead) by LRs, reported in AIR 2011
SC 3546, and Jaggo vs. Union of India & Ors., reported
as 2024 INSC 1034, and submitted that to avoid liability
under various labour statutes, employers often resort to
subterfuge
by
showing
that
employees
are
actually
employees of a contractor. He also submitted that labour
statutes are meant to protect the interest of workmen, but
contrary to the object behind enactment of these statutes,
(5 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
[CW-17798/2019]
the services of the petitioners were engaged through a
service provider.
5.
Aforesaid contentions were opposed by learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondents. He submitted that
the services of the petitioners were engaged through an
agency and do not have any direct nexus with the
respondents. He further placed reliance upon the judgment
dated 06.12.2017 passed in D.B. Civil Special Appeal
No. 1017/2017, State of Rajasthan vs. Surendra
Kumar Gujar & Ors., and submitted that while considering
the judgment in case of Surendra Kumar Gujar vs. State
of Rajasthan, reported in 2017 (2) RLW 1055 (Raj.),
the Division Bench set aside the order passed by the learned
Single Judge, which had directed to lay down a procedure
and constitute a nodal agency for conducting examinations
for hiring employees on contract basis.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material placed on record along with the judgments referred
by learned counsel for parties.
7.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioners were
engaged under the National Health Mission (NHM), a scheme
sponsored by the Central Government and implemented
through
the
State
engaged
through
a
Government.
human
The
resource
petitioners
service
were
provider;
however, due to difficulties faced by contractual employees
engaged through agencies, the Government took a decision
on 01.03.2016 to engage contractual employees directly and
not through any agency.
(6 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
8.
The
petitioners
have
[CW-17798/2019]
approached
this
Court
seeking
implementation of the said directions. During the course of
arguments, learned counsel for the respondents candidly
admitted that petitioner Nos. 10 and 11 were directly given
appointment
on
contract
pursuant
to
directions
dated
01.03.2016 issued by the Directorate. Learned counsel
further referred to subsequent directions dated 21.05.2020
and 11.06.2021, whereby engagement through RMRS was
prohibited.
9.
The issue raised herein clearly indicates that the direction
dated 01.03.2016 was implemented with regard to two of
the petitioners, but the remaining petitioners were not
considered pursuant to the said direction, meaning thereby
that
a
discriminatory
practice
was
adopted
by
the
respondents, which is evident from the reply submitted by
them.
10.
In the case of Jai Prakash Ghanchi vs. State of
Rajasthan & Ors. (supra), a Coordinate Bench at the
Principal Seat, Jodhpur, while considering the judgment
dated 20.03.2017 passed in S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.
953/2017 (Pankaj Kumar Upadhyay vs. State of
Rajasthan & Ors.), wherein services of such individuals
were directed to be continued till requirement subsists, and
also considering the circular, whereby direct contractual
engagement
through
Rajasthan
Medical
Relief
Society
(RMRS) was permitted, allowed the writ petition.
11.
In the case of Bhilwara Dugdh Utpadak Sahakari S. Ltd.
vs. Vinod Kumar Sharma (Dead) by LRs (supra),
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
(7 of 8)
[CW-17798/2019]
Hon’ble Supreme Court has considered the growing practice
of employers engaging workers through agencies so as to
subvert the provisions of labour laws. In the case of Jaggo
vs. Union of India and Ors. (supra), after considering the
judgment in State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi, (2006) 4
SCC 1, it has been held that the Government and its
instrumentalities should lead by example in providing fair
and equitable employment.
12.
In the case of Surendra Kumar Gujar (supra), the learned
Single Judge of this Court deprecated the practice of
engagement through service agencies and issued certain
directions; however, the said judgment was set aside by the
Division Bench in State of Rajasthan vs. Surendra Kumar
Gujar & Ors. (supra), and the matter was remanded back.
13.
Having taken note of the discriminatory practice and also the
prevalent circular at the time of engagement of the
petitioners, it appears that the respondents have not
considered the case of the remaining petitioners. Thus,
selective consideration amounts to discrimination and is
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India,
therefore, the writ petition is liable to be allowed.
14.
Accordingly Writ Petition preferred by petitioner No. 1
Surendra Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Jagdish Prasad
Sharma, petitioner No. 5 Naresh Kumar Joshi S/o Shri
Satya Narayan Joshi, petitioner No. 7 Smt. Rekha
Shukla W/o Shri Manoj Tiwari, petitioner No. 12 Smt.
Manohar Kunwar Dewda W/o Shri Mahendra Singh
and petitioner No. 13 Smt. Manorama Sharma W/o
(8 of 8)
[2026:RJ-JP:11954]
Shri
Govind
Sharma
are
[CW-17798/2019]
hereby
allowed,
and
the
respondents-are directed to engage these petitioners directly
on contractual basis in accordance with the directions dated
01.03.2016 issued by the Directorate. Needless to say, the
services of these petitioners shall be renewed periodically till
the requirement subsists and their services are found
satisfactory or till regular appointment is made.
15.
The writ petitions of petitioner No No. 2, Kushal Katara
S/o Shri Hare Krishn Katara, petitioner No.3 Smt.
Sanju
Dubey
W/o
Shri
Mahesh
Chand
Dubey,
petitioner No. 4 Smt. Ruchi Gautam W/o Shri Lokesh
Gautam, petitioner No. 6 Smt. Hemlata Rathore W/o
Shri Girdhar Singh, petitioner No. 8 Smt. Arti Mishra
W/o Shri Shyam Dixit, petitioner No. 9 Laxmikant Sain
S/o Jairam Sain petitioner No.10 Kusum Sharma and
petitioner No. 11 Navneet Khateek are hereby dismissed,
and they are not entitled for any relief from this Court.
16.
Misc. application, if any, stands disposed of.
(ASHOK KUMAR JAIN),J
PREETI VALECHA /16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review