Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 45
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case:-
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
CM No. 6637/2026
Dr. Surbhi Sharma, age 33 years D/o Sh. Satish Sharma,
W/o Varun Sharma, R/o House No.10, Bhawani Nagar,
District Jammu.
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Achal Sharma, Advocate
Vs
1. UT of J&K, Commissioner/Secretary to Government,
Health and Medical Education Department,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar.
2. UT of J&K, Commissioner/Secretary to Government,
Finance Department, Civil Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar.
3. Principal, Government Medical College, Jammu.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Coram:
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE MOKSHA KHAJURIA KAZMI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
(19.09.2026)
CM No. 6637/2026
01.
For the reasons stated in the application coupled with the submissions
made at the Bar, the application is allowed and the amended prayer part of
the writ petition is taken on record.
02.
Application is disposed of.
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
‘There is no role in life more essential and more eternal than that of
motherhood.’
M.Russell Ballard.
03.
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
Motherhood is a divine process of creation of nurturing a life within self
and bringing it into this world. This is a biological and spiritual process
which teaches this world patience, resilience, empathy, humility,
selflessness and protective existence, as motherhood. Maternity leave is a
benefit provided to support working woman during their pregnancy and
childbirth. The primary purpose of maternity leave is to ensure the health
and well-being of working female employees.
04.
In this petition, the petitioner herein is seeking to quash Communication
No. ME-GEN/187/2025-01(E:7642802) dated 14.10.2025 (Annexure-I) to
the extent of denying the benefit of pay and allowances to the petitioner
during the period of maternity leave; with a direction upon the
respondents to release forthwith the withheld salary and allowances of the
petitioner for the period of maternity leave availed and the extended
period of residency corresponding to the number of days of maternity
leave, as held in the judgment in WP(C) No. 3509/2025 titled “Dr.
Sonakshi Gupta & Ors vs UT of J&K & Ors.”
FACTUAL MATRIX
05.
The petitioner herein is aggrieved of the communication No. MEGEN/187/2025-01(E:7642802) dated 14.10.2025, issued by Respondent
No.1, whereby it has been advised that Senior Residents/Tutors shall not
be entitled to pay and allowances during the period of Maternity/Paternity
Leave.
06.
Petitioner came to be appointed as Registrar/Demonstrator in the
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
discipline of Pathology in Government Medical College, Jammu vide
Order No. 369 of 2022 dated 15.12.2022, she submitted her joining report
on 16.12.2022 and was blessed with baby on 12.08.2025. She applied for
sanction of Maternity Leave as per Rules to the Principal Government
Medical College, Jammu, it was sanctioned in favour of the petitioner for
period of 180 days w.e.f 21.08.2025 to 16.02.2026 vide Order No. 389 of
2025 dated 15.10.2025.
07.
Petitioner was appointed as Senior Resident/Tutor under the J&K Medical
and Dental Education (Appointment on Academic Arrangement Basis)
Rules, 2020, as such, the appointment of the petitioner is stated to be
against the sanctioned Government for a fixed tenure and not as mere
trainee. It is stated that in the year 2024, the Respondent No.1 in
supersession of all previous orders and in conformity with the norms of
the National Medical Commission and the National Board of
Examinations, issued Government Order No. 451-JK(HME) of 2024
dated 08.07.2024, by virtue of which, it was, inter alia provided that
Postgraduate Students, Senior Residents/Tutors and DNB PG Students in
Government Medical Colleges of J&K shall be entitled to specified
categories of leave including maternity and paternity leave. It is stated
that the Rule 41of the Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services (Leave) Rules,
1979 amended vide SRO 353 of 2015, unequivocally provides that during
maternity leave, a woman employee shall be paid leave salary equal to the
pay drawn immediately prior to proceeding on leave.
08.
It is further stated that once the Government Order dated 08.07.2024 has
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
adopted Rule 41 for Senior Residents/Registrars/Tutors, the statutory
entitlement to ‘paid maternity leave’ stood extended to the petitioner. The
respondents, as such, cannot by a mere administrative communication,
dilute, curtail or amend a statutory benefit. All Senior Residents who were
on maternity leave were paid salary w.e.f 08.07.2024 and were permitted
to avail the full six-month maternity leave contemplated under Rule 41.
The petitioner, being similarly situated, was also entitled to be paid full
‘paid maternity leave’ in terms of the said statutory provision but at no
stage, the respondents have ever notified or indicated that the petitioner
would be denied salary during the extended period. The abrupt
deprivation of salary has caused severe financial hardship to the petitioner
and her family, including her newborn child.
09.
It is stated that the petitioner has already completed her maternity leave
and had also undergone the extended period of residency mandated solely
on account of her having availed maternity leave under Rule 41. The
salary has been stopped pursuant to the impugned communication, which,
as per the petitioner, is unconstitutional and contrary to the statutory
framework governing the petitioner’s appointment.
10.
The petitioner herein has challenged the impugned communication dated
14.10.2025 on the ground that the appointment of the petitioner as
Registrar/Demonstrator/Senior Resident/Tutor strictly governs in terms of
the J&K Medical and Dental Education (Appointment on Academic
Arrangement Basis) Rules, 2020 and Rule 2(c) defines “post” as a
Government post against which engagement is made. Apart from that, the
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
Government Order No. 451-JK(ME) of 2024 dated 08.07.2024 expressly
adopts Government rules and regulations for governing the maternity
benefits to the petitioner. Rule 41 unequivocally mandates that during
maternity leave a woman employee shall be paid salary equal to the pay
drawn immediately before proceeding on leave, as such, the impugned
communication dated 14.10.2025, as per the petitioner, nullifies a
statutory entitlement by a mere administrative advisory, which cannot
override, curtail or amend a statutory benefit conferred under Rule 41.
11.
The petitioner herein has based her claim on the judgment passed in
WP(C) No. 3509/2025 titled “Dr. Sonakshi Gupta & Ors vs UT of J&K &
Ors.” dated 10.07.2026, wherein the communication dated 14.10.2025
has been set aside to the extent of denying the benefit of pay and
allowances to the petitioners therein during the period of maternity
leave/paternity leave. For facility of reference, para 14 of the aforesaid
judgment is reproduced as under:
“14. In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court is of the
considered view that the communication dated 14.10.2025,
issued by respondent No.1 to the extent denying the benefit
of pay and allowances to the petitioners during the period of
maternity leave/paternity leave, is liable to be quashed and is
accordingly quashed. Respondent No.1 is also directed to
grant full pay and allowances to the petitioners during the
period of maternity leave and also during the extended period
of residency corresponding to the number of days of
maternity leave”.
12.
Per Contra Mr. Raman Sharma, learned Sr. AAG representing the
respondents has fairly conceded to the prayer made by the petitioner in
this petition on account of the fact that this petition is similar and is
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
covered in terms of the judgment titled “Dr. Sonakshi Gupta & Ors vs UT
of J&K & Ors.” mentioned (supra).
13.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on record.
14.
The appointment of the petitioner as Registrar/Demonstrator in the
discipline of Pathology in Government Medical College, Jammu is
governed in terms of the J&K Medical and Dental Education
(Appointment on Academic Arrangement Basis) Rules, 2020. In terms of
Government Order No. 451-JK(HME) of 2024 dated 08.07.2024,
governing leave entitlement for Postgraduate Students and Senior
Residents/Tutors Students, executing their assignments in Government
Medical Colleges of J&K, Postgraduate Students and DNB PG Students,
are entitled to the following kinds of leave:
“1. Leave permissible for Senior Residents/Tutors:
(a) There shall be weekly one-day off (subject to exigencies
of work). In addition, a Senior Resident/Tutor shall be
eligible for Twenty (20) days’ Casual Leave. Five (05)
days Academic Leave per year shall be admissible subject
to the relevance of the programme to the course.
(b) Female Senior Residents/Tutors shall be allowed
Maternity Leave, MTP/Abortion Leave as per existing
Government rules and regulations.
(c) Male Senior Residents/Tutors shall be allowed Paternity
Leave as per existing Government rules and Regulations.”
15.
SRO-353 dated 06.10.2015 amending Rule 41 of the Jammu and Kashmir
Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1979, for ready reference, is reproduced as
under:
“1. For rule 41, the following rule shall be substituted, namely:–
“41(1). Maternity Leave.––(i) A woman employee (including
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
an apprentice) may be granted Maternity leave by an
authority competent to grant leave for a period which may
extend up to 180 days from the date of its
commencement.
(ii) Maternity leave shall be available up to two
living children only.
(iii) Maternity leave not exceeding six weeks may
also be granted to a woman employee (irrespective of
number of children she has) in case of miscarriage
including abortion, on production of medical certificate as
laid down in rule 19.
(iv) During such period, she shall be paid leave
salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding
on leave.
(v) Maternity leave may be combined with leave of
any other kind.
(vi) Maternity leave shall not be debited against leave
account.”
16.
The Rules mentioned (supra) clearly reflect that a woman employee may
be granted Maternity Leave by an authority competent to grant leave for a
period which may extend upto 180 days from the date of its
commencement. During such period, she shall be paid leave salary equal
to the pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave. The Female
Senior Residents/Tutors have also been allowed Maternity Leave, as per
existing Government Rules and Regulations in terms of Government
Order dated 08.07.2024.
17.
Rule 41(1) of the Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services (Leave) Rules,
1979, (amended via SRO 353 of 2015) clearly provides for 180 days of
Maternity Leave, a female employee has an absolute right to be paid a
leave salary equal to the pay drawn immediately before proceeding on
leave.
18.
The petitioner has challenged the impugned Order dated 14.10.2025, to
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
the extent it denies her the benefit of pay and allowances during the
period of maternity leave on account of the fact that she had not executed
her course or assignment during the said period. The issue raised in the
present petition is no longer res integra and already stands considered and
adjudicated upon by this Court in WP(C) No. 3509/2025 titled Dr.
Sonakshi Gupta & Ors. v. UT of J&K & Ors, decided on 10.07.2026.
In the said judgment, this Court, while considering the very same
communication dated 14.10.2025 and the denial of pay and allowances to
Senior Residents/Tutors during Maternity Leave, held that the entitlement
to maternity leave could not be defeated on the ground of the
tenure/course-based nature of the engagement. The Court, accordingly,
quashed the impugned communication to the extent it denied pay and
allowances during the period of maternity leave and directed the
respondents to grant full pay and allowances for the maternity-leave
period as well as for the corresponding extended period of residency.
19.
In “Hamsaanandini Nanduri vs Union of India & Ors”, reported in
2026 INSC, 246, the Apex Court has held that “the protection of the
Maternity Leave is a basic human right, as it recognizes conditions that
are necessary for the full development of human personality and
realization of equality. It embodies an essential component required to
promote equality at workplace and safeguards maternal and child health.
Maternity benefit or the payment in lieu of such leave is intended to
support women during the phase of early motherhood by providing
economic security when they are most engaged in the care and nurture of
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
a young child. This act of support recognizes that motherhood entails
sustained physical, emotional, and social exertion which demands time,
financial stability and resources”.
20.
The underlying objective of the Government Order No. 451-JK(HME) of
2024 dated 08.07.2024 and the Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services
(Leave) Rules, 1979 is to advance social justice and serves multiple
purposes including enabling the mother’s physical recovery, facilitating
the nurturing care of the child and ensuring the level of her previous
efficiency and output. It also ensures that the women are treated with
dignity at the workplace and protected from apprehension of victimization
on account of forced absence during maternity.
21.
In “K Umadevi vs Government of Tamil Nadu & Ors”, reported in 2025
LiveLaw (SC) 614, the Apex Court has held that “It is not just
motherhood but also childhood that require special attention. Health
issues of both mother as well as that of the child are to be kept in
consideration while providing maternity leave. Concept of maternity
leave is matter of not just fair play and social justice but is also a
Constitutional guarantee to the women employees of this Country towards
fulfillment whereof the State is bound to act.”
22.
In view of the above, this petition is disposed of at the threshold with the
consent of the leaned counsel for the parties thereby setting aside the
communication dated 14.10.2025 issued by Respondent No.1 to the extent
of denying the benefit of pay and allowances to the petitioner during the
period of Maternity Leave. The Respondent No.1 is directed to grant full
WP(C) No. 2944/2026
pay and allowances to the petitioner during the period of Maternity Leave
and also during the extended period of residency corresponding to the
number of days of maternity leave.
23.
Disposed of.
(MOKSHA KHAJURIA KAZMI)
JUDGE
JAMMU
19.09.2026
Vijay
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
Vijay Kumar
2026.09.22 10:23
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review