Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010266172025
2026:GAU-AS:5033
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Writ Petition (C) No. 6863/2025
Surajit Rabha, S/o Tangun Rabha, R/o Village –
Geruapar, P.O. – Dongpar, District – Baksa, Assam,
781368.
……………Petitioner
-Versus-
1.
Bodoland Territorial Council (BTC) represented by its
Principal Secretary, Bodoland Secretariat Complex,
Bodofa Nwgwr, Kokrajhar - 783371.
2.
The
Secretary,
Environment
&
Bodoland
Forest
Territorial
Council,
Department,
Bodoland
Secretariat Complex, Bodofa Nwgwr, Kokrajhar –
783371.
3.
The Additional Chief Conservator of Forest –cumCHD, BTC, Kokrjhar - 783371.
4.
The Divisional Forest Officer, Baksa Forest Division,
Mushalpur, Baksa - 781372.
……………….Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANISH CHOUDHURY
Advocates :
Petitioners
:
Mr. S. Hoque, Advocate
Respondent nos. 1 & 2
:
Ms. N. Choudhury, Standing Counsel, BTC
Respondent nos. 3 & 4
:
Mr.
R.R.
Gogoi,
Standing
Environment & Forest Department
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
02.04.2026
Counsel,
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment?
:
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced ?
:
Yes
JUDGMENT &ORDER
Heard Mr. S. Hoque, learned counsel for the petitioner; Ms. N. Choudhury,
learned Standing Counsel, Bodoland Territorial Council [BTC]; and Mr. R.R.
Gogoi, learned Standing Counsel, Environment & Forest Department.
2.
The instant writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been
preferred seeking a direction in the nature of mandamus to the respondent
authorities, more particularly, the Divisional Forest Office, Baksa Forest Division,
Mushalpur [the respondent no. 4] to settle a Minor Mineral Concession area,
‘Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13’ forthwith in favour of the petitioner in terms of a
Notice Inviting Tender [NIT] dated 25.08.2025 by setting aside and quashing a
decision conveyed by the Executive Member, Bodoland Territorial Council [BTC]
vide an Office Letter dated 12.11.2025 addressed to the Additional Chief
Conservator of Forest -cum- CHD, BTC [the respondent no. 3].
3.
The facts which are not in dispute, can be exposited at first, in order to
appreciate the issues involved in the writ petition. By a Notice Inviting Tender
[NIT] dated 25.08.2025, the respondent no. 4 invited sealed tenders with validity
period of 180 days for grant of Mineral Concession as per the provisions of the
Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013 in certain specified Minor Mineral
Concession areas [Mahals] within the Baksa Forest Division as per the schedule
mentioned therein. One of the Mahals in which the Mineral Concession was to be
granted by the NIT dated 25.08.2025 was ‘Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13’ for the
contract period : 2025-2032. It was informed to the bidders that the NIT
contained details of the Minor Mineral Concession area [Mahal] along with the
terms and conditions of grant and the same could be procured from the office of
the respondent no. 4 during working hours on payment of a sum of Rs. 1,000/by demand draft of the State Bank of India [SBI] payable in favour of the
respondent no. 1.
4.
As per the NIT, the last date of submission of sealed tenders was up to 02-00
p.m., 18.09.2025. In response to the NIT dated 25.08.2025, three bidders
including the petitioner, submitted their sealed tenders for settlement of the
Minor Mineral Concession area, ‘Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13’. The tenders so
received were opened and evaluated by a Bid Quotation Committee under the
Chairmanship of the respondent no. 4 on 04.10.2025 in the office of the
respondent no. 4. After opening of the bids, the Bid Quotation Committee
prepared a Comparative Statement and recorded its comments as regards
submission of essential documents / certificates, etc., by the respective
participant bidder. Upon evaluation, the Bid Quotation Committee found that the
petitioner with a tendered amount of Rs. 18,50,000/- emerged as the highest
valid bidder [H-1]. The other two participant bidders’ tendered amounts were
same, Rs. 18,20,000/-. Upon consideration, the Bid Quotation Committee
decided to approve the bid of the petitioner and to allot Barnadi Sand Mahal No.
13 to him after observance of all official formalities.
5.
The decision taken by the Bid Quotation Committee stood forwarded to the
respondent no. 2 for approval. The respondent no. 2 vide an Office Letter dated
06.11.2025 conveyed to the respondent no. 3 that the Competent Authority in
the Bodoland Territorial Counsel [BTC] had approved the highest quoted tender
as per the Comparative Statement, that is, the tender of the petitioner for
Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13. The respondent no. 3 vide an Office Letter dated
13.11.2025 wrote to the respondent no. 4 that the BTC had approved the
highest quoted rate in the Comparative Statement prepared for the Minor Mineral
Concession area, Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13 and for grant of the Minor Mineral
Concession contract in favour of the petitioner. The respondent no. 4 was
thereby requested to take necessary steps to settle the Minor Mineral Concession
area from his end as per the Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013.
6.
It is the case of the petitioner that after 13.11.2025, the petitioner was waiting
with legitimate expectation that the Minor Mineral Concession area, Barnadi Sand
Mahal No. 13 would be granted to him with the issuance of a Letter of Award /
Letter of Acceptance. But to his surprise, the petitioner came to learn that an
Executive Member of the BTC vide an Office Letter no. GEN-01/2025-26/82
dated 12.11.2025 wrote to the respondent no. 3 to make necessary arrangement
for cancellation of allotment of the Minor Mineral Concession area, Barnadi Sand
Mahal No. 13 in terms of the Comparative Statement prepared by the Bid
Quotation Committee and to re-process the matter for allotment of Barnadi Sand
Mahal No. 13 in favour of one Sri Dinesh Boro.
7.
As the decision amounted to implied cancellation of the bidding process initiated
by the NIT dated 25.08.2025, the petitioner has instituted the instant writ
petition seeking inter alia setting aside and quashing of the Office Letter dated
12.11.2025 of the Executive Member, Bodoland Territorial Council [BTC], which
was addressed to the Additional Chief Conservator of Forest -cum- CHD, BTC
[the respondent no. 3]. A direction in the nature of mandamus to the respondent
authorities, more particular, the Divisional Forest Office, Baksa Forest Division,
Mushalpur [the respondent no. 4] has also been sought for to settle a Minor
Mineral Concession area, Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13 forthwith in favour of the
petitioner in terms of a Notice Inviting Tender [NIT] dated 25.08.2025
8.
As against such reliefs sought for by the petitioner in the writ petition, the
respondent BTC authorities have contended that the bidding process initiated by
the NIT dated 25.08.2025 has been decided to be cancelled and therefore, the
petitioner does not have any right to seek such reliefs. In order to test the
contentions of the parties, the reasons for which the bidding process has been
recalled are to be examined.
9.
The stand taken by the respondent BTC authorities in the affidavit-in-opposition
is to the effect that in a Meeting of the Executive Council of the Bodoland
Territorial Council [BTC], held on 09.12.2025, it has been found that by the
publication of NITs, bidding processes were initiated for grant of Minor Mineral
Concessions for a number of Mineral Concession areas [Mahals] by inviting
sealed tenders. But, e-Auction process was not adopted. The Executive Council,
BTC took a decision to adopt e-Auction process for grant Mineral Concession in
Minor Mineral Concession areas [Mahals] to successful bidders in its territorial
jurisdiction.
10.
The Parliament had enacted the Mines and Minerals [Development and
Regulation] Act, 1957 [‘the MMDR Act’, for short] to provide for development and
regulation of mines and minerals under the control of the Union. As per definition
provided in Section 3[e] in the MMDR Act, ‘minor minerals’ means building
stones, gravel, ordinary clay, ordinary sand other than sand for prescribed
purposes, and any other mineral which the Central Government may, by
notification in the Official Gazette declare to be a minor mineral. Section 15 of
the MMDR Act has provided the power to the State Governments to make rules
in respect of minor minerals. As per sub-section [1] of Section 15, the State
Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, make rules for regulating
the grant of quarry leases, mining leases or other mineral concessions in respect
of minor minerals and for purposes connected therewith. Sub-section [1A] of
Section 15 has prescribed that in particular and without prejudice to the
generality of the power provided in sub-section [1], the rules may provide for all
or any of the matters contained in sub-clause [a] to sub-clause [o] thereof.
Section 23C has provided power to the State Government to make rules for
preventing illegal mining, transportation and storage of minerals.
11.
In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section [1] of Section 15 and Section
23C of the MMDR Act, the State Government had made a set of rules, ‘the
‘Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013’ [‘the Rules, 2013’, for short] vide
a Notification no. PEM.83/2009/Pt.-1/627, which was published in the Assam
Gazette on 16.03.2013. In Rule 2[q] of the Rules, 2013, ‘mineral concession’ has
been defined as a mining lease or a mining contract or permit in respect of
mineral and includes quarry permits and other mineral concession permitting the
mining of minor mineral in accordance with the provisions of Rules, 2013. As per
Rule 2[r], ‘mining contract’ means a mining contract given on behalf of the
Government to carry, win work and carry away any minor minerals specified
therein through a bidding process. ‘Schedule’, as per Rule 2[cc], means a
schedule appended to the Rules, 2013. In the schedule of the Rules, 2013, sand,
gravel and stone are included in the list of minor minerals.
12.
When the Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013 were originally made in
the year 2013, the procedure for inviting competitive bids/auctions and
payments was included in Chapter - 6. Originally, Rule 32[1], Rule 33[1] and
Rule 34[2] used to read as under :32[1] Save in the cases specifically mentioned under these rules and
where such mineral concessions may be granted on application, all
mining of contract or leases / contracts / permits shall be granted
through transparent process of inviting competitive bids /open
auction.
33[1] The competent authority shall upfront determine the reserve
price in each case where the mineral concession are granted through
competitive bidding /open auction, as the case may be.
34[2] In addition to the publication of notice in writing,
competitive bid /open auction under sub-rule [1] above, the gist
of such notice, along with the schedule for inviting bid/holding
open auctions shall also be published in one daily newspaper
having circulation in the area.
13.
Subsequently vide a Notification no. PEM.47/2018/16 dated 26.10.2018, a
number of amendments were brought in the Assam Minor Mineral Concession
Rules, 2013 by the Assam Minor Mineral Concession [Amendment] Rules, 2018.
The Notification dated 26.10.2018 was published in the Assam Gazette in its
Issue no. 515 dated 29.10.2018. By the Assam Minor Mineral Concession
[Amendment] Rules, 2018, amendments were brought in Rule 32[1], Rule 33[1]
and Rule 34[2]. After amendments, Rule 32[1], Rule 33[1] and Rule 34[2] read
as under :32[1] Save in the cases specifically mentioned under these rules and
where such mineral concessions may be granted on application, all
mining of contract or leases / contracts / permits shall be granted
through transparent process of inviting e-Auction.
33[1] The competent authority shall upfront determine the reserve
price in each case where the mineral concession are granted through
e-Auction.
34[2] In addition to the publication of notice in writing, e-Auction
under sub-rule [1] above, the gist of such notice, alongwith the
schedule for e-Auction, shall also be published in one daily
newspaper having circulation in the area.
14.
Rule 1[2] of the Assam Minor Mineral Concession [Amendment] Rules, 2018 had
prescribed that the amendments would come into force on the date of their
publication in the Official Gazette. Therefore, the Assam Minor Mineral
Concession [Amendment] Rules, 2018 had come into force on and from
29.10.2018. By the said amendments, the rule-makers had made it clear that on
and from 29.10.2018, any process of grant of mining contract or mineral
concession of minor minerals has to be mandatorily conducted only through the
e-Auction mode.
15.
It is too settled a law that where law requires a thing to be done in a certain
manner or where a power is given to do a certain thing in a certain manner, the
thing must be done in that way or manner or not at all and other methods of
performance are necessarily forbidden. The legal maxim, ‘Expressio Unius Est
Exclusio Alterius,’ means ‘the express mention of one thing implies the exclusion
of another.’ It is a principle of statutory interpretation that when a legal
document or statute lists specific items, things not listed are intentionally
excluded, aiding courts in determining intent. It simply means that if a statute
provides for a thing to be done in a particular way then it has to be done in that
manner only and in no other manner. All manners other than the statutorily
prescribed manner are necessarily forbidden.
16.
In the NIT dated 25.08.2025, it was specifically mentioned that the Minor Mineral
Concession area, Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13 would be settled as per the
provisions of the Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013. Yet, the
respondent BTC authorities did not take recourse to a bidding process through
the e-Auction mode. The BTC or the respondent no. 4 was under statutory
obligation to initiate the bidding process for grant mining contract / mineral
concession of sand from Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13 only through e-Auction
mode and in no other mode. As by the NIT dated 25.08.2025, sealed tenders
were only invited to be submitted in the office of the respondent no. 4 and
tenders not invited to be submitted on-line through e-Auction mode, the decision
to cancel the bidding process initiated through the NIT dated 25.08.2025 and to
initiate the bidding process through the e-Auction mode is therefore, found in
conformity with the Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013, as amended
by the Assam Minor Mineral Concession [Amendment] Rules, 2018 and this Court
finds no reason to take any exception to the said decision.
17.
In the case in hand, the petitioner submitted his sealed tender in physical mode
which was found to be responsive and he had emerged as successful bidder in
the bidding process. No Letter of Intent [LoI] was issued to the petitioner
thereafter. Therefore, no Letter of Award was issued in favour of the petitioner
during the subsequent period and no contract agreement also was entered into
with him.
18.
As per Rule 2[o] of the Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013, as
amended, ‘Letter of Intent’ [LoI] means a ‘Letter of Intent’ issued to the
successful bidder on acceptance of the bid for grant of mining lease or contract
or permit or mineral concession under these rules. Rule 37 has inter alia
mentioned that on acceptance of the bid of the highest bidder by the competent
authority, a Letter of Intent [LoI] would be issued in favour of the successful
bidder. The said rule has further provided that after compliance of formalities like
deposit of the balance amount of bid security, an agreement would be executed
with the Letter of Intent [LoI] holder.
19.
In the case in hand, upon evaluation of the bids of the three participant bidders,
the Bid Quotation Committee had found the bid of the petitioner to be responsive
to the NIT dated 25.08.2025. As the petitioner had quoted the highest bid value
of Rs. 18,50,000/-, he was adjudged as the highest valid bidder [H-1] by the Bid
Quotation Committee. Thereafter, the Competent Authority in the BTC had
accorded approval to the bid of the petitioner for settlement of the Minor Mineral
Concession area, Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13 in favour of the petitioner. By the
Office Letter dated 13.11.2025, the respondent no. 3 had directed the
respondent no. 4 to take necessary steps for settlement of the Minor Mineral
Concession area, Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13 as per the provisions of the Assam
Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013.
20.
In sub-rule [3] of Rule 37 of the Rules, 2013, the process for completion of the
various stages for grant of Mineral Concession has been provided for. It is
prescribed that on completion of the bidding process, the highest bidder shall
has to deposit an amount equal to 10% of the annual bid amount as ‘initial bid
security’ before expiry of the period allowed. The amount deposited towards the
‘initial bid security’ would be adjusted as part of the bid security on acceptance
of the bid by the Competent Authority and a Letter of Intent [LoI] would be
issued in favour of the successful bidder. The Letter of Intent [LoI] holder has to
deposit the balance amount of bid security i.e. equal to 15% before expiry of the
period allowed. It is after the deposit of the entire bid security, the parties would
execute a contract agreement to allow the successful bidder to operate the
concerned Minor Mineral Concession area.
21.
It is settled that a Letter of Intent [LoI] merely indicates a party's intention to
enter into a contract with the other party in future. A Letter of Intent [LoI] is not
intended to bind either party ultimately to enter into any contract. Even after
issuance of a Letter of Intent [LoI], it cannot be said that there is a binding legal
relationship between the parties at that stage. In the case in hand, with no
Letter of Intent [LoI] issued in favour of the petitioner with the possibility of
execution of a contract, it is clear that there was no formation of contract
between the parties at that point of time. In other words, there was no
concluded contract between the parties for the petitioner to claim that a right
has been vested in him to operate the Minor Mineral Concession area, Barnadi
Sand Mahal No. 13.
22.
The question which has, therefore, arises is whether any right of the petitioner
has been infringed due to the decision of the respondent BTC authorities not to
proceed with the bidding process initiated by the NIT dated 25.08.2025. A bidder
participating in a bidding process has no other right except the right to equality
and fair treatment in the matter of evaluation of competitive bids offered by
interested persons in response to notice inviting tenders in a transparent
manner. Submission of a tender in response to a notice inviting tender is no
more than making an offer which the State or its instrumentalities / agencies are
under no obligation to accept. The bidders participating in the tender process
cannot insist that their tenders should be accepted simply because a given
tender is the highest or lowest depending upon whether the contract is for sale
of public property or for execution of works on behalf of the Government. In the
matter of award of contracts, the Government and its instrumentalities /
agencies have to act reasonably and fairly at all points of time and it is only to
that extent, a bidder has an enforceable right in the Court which is competent to
examine whether the aggrieved party has been treated unfairly or discriminated
against to the detriment of public interest [Ref : Maa Binda Express Carrier and
another vs. North-East Frontier Railway and others, (2014) 3 SCC 760].
23.
The decision to cancel a tender process is purely an administrative decision and
such decision is neither judicial nor quasi judicial. It is not necessary to observe
the principle of natural justice and it is not required to give reasons for the
decision to cancel a tender process if it be a State or an instrumentalities /
agency of the State. The State or its instrumentalities / agencies are entitled to
give reasons in the counter to the writ petition.
24.
The decision of the Executive Council, BTC to settle Minor Mineral Concession
area, Barndadi Sand Mahal No. 13 through the e-Auction mode was in
compliance of the Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013, as amended.
There is nothing in the materials on record that such decision of the Executive
Council, BTC is influenced by the Office Letter dated 12.11.2025 of the Executive
Member, BTC addressed to the respondent no. 3. There is no materials on record
to suggest that the statutory authorities in the BTC vested with the power,
authority and jurisdiction to grant Mineral Concession in Barnadi Sand Mahal No.
13 had acted in any manner based on the Letter dated 12.11.2025.
25.
The petitioner has sought to contend that since the bid value was below Rs.
20,00,000/-, it is not mandatory on the part of the respondent BTC authorities to
initiate the bidding process for settlement of the Minor Mineral Concession area,
Barnadi Sand Mahal No. 13 through the e-Auction mode. To support such
contention, the learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to an Office
Memorandum dated 08.01.2024 of the Finance Department, Government of
Assam wherein it has been made mandatory to procure goods and services
valued above Rs. 20,00,000/- through Assam Tenders Procurement Portal,
https://assamtenders.gov.in. As per the Office Memorandum dated 08.01.2024,
it is not mandatory to procure goods and services valued less than Rs.
20,00,000/-
through
the
Assam
Tenders
Procurement
Portal,
https://assamtenders.gov.in. The said contention of the petitioner is not
acceptable for the reason that the Assam Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2013,
as amended, by the Assam Minor Mineral Concession [Amendment] Rules, 2018
is a self-contained code. It has been made mandatory in the Assam Minor
Mineral Concession Rules, 2013, as amended, by the Assam Minor Mineral
Concession [Amendment] Rules, 2018, that on and from 29.10.2018, any bidding
process for grant of Mineral Concession for any Minor Mineral Concession area
can only be completed through the e-Auction mode. Any deviation from eAuction mode is not permissible and therefore, the procedure mentioned in the
Office Memorandum dated 08.01.2024 cannot be made applicable to a process
which is to be statutorily settled only through the e-Auction mode. An executive
instruction in the form of an Office Memorandum cannot supplant any statutory
rules.
26.
When in the light of the afore-stated propositions of law the decision to cancel
the bidding process initiated by the NIT dated 25.08.2025, as resolved by the
Executive Council of the BTC in its Meeting held on 09.12.2025, is examined, the
decision to cancel the bidding process is not found to be one, which requires any
interference for the reasons already discussed hereinabove. The petitioner as the
successful bidder at the time of the decision to cancel the bidding process had no
vested right to claim that there was any binding relationship in view of any
concluded contract with regard to the Minor Mineral Concession area, Barnadi
Sand Mahal No. 13. In order to create any binding relationship, the parties did
not travel to the last mile post, which would have been reached only with the
final acceptance of the bid. As the manner in which the bidding process was
initiated was illegal due to its non-initiation through e-Auction mode, the decision
to cancel the bidding process initiated by the NIT dated 25.08.2025 does not call
for any interference. Consequently, the writ petition is found unmerited and is
liable to be dismissed. It is accordingly dismissed. Recalling the interim order, the
writ petition is dismissed.
27.
During the bidding process, that is, from the time of publication of the NIT on
25.08.2025 to the decision of the Executive Council, BTC taken in its Meeting
held on 09.12.2025, to cancel the process the petitioner as the successful bidder
had complied with all the conditions mentioned in the NIT. If the petitioner had
deposited any amount towards earnest money, bid security, etc. to the
respondent BTC authorities during the bidding process, there is no reason for the
respondent BTC to retain any such amount received from the petitioner for any
further period, in the absence of any non-compliance on the part of the
petitioner. Therefore, the amount, if any, deposited by the petitioner towards
earnest money, bid security, etc. if still retained by the respondent BTC
authorities, is to be returned to the petitioner within a period of one month from
today. In the event the amount is not returned within a period of one month,
then the same shall carry interest @ 6% till the date of return.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Basumatary
Date: 2026.04.06 18:29:27
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review