Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:39-DB
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appeal Jurisdiction)
DATED : 13TH APRIL, 2016
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------D. B. : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNIL KUMAR SINHA, CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
in
Crl.A. No.04 of 2015 (Jail Appeal)
Appellant
:
Suraj Rai @ Suresh,
S/o Dhan Bahadur Rai,
R/o Chissopani,
South Sikkim.
[Presently in Central Prison,
Rongyek, East Sikkim]
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
Application under Section 5 of
the Limitation Act, 1963
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate (Senior Legal Aid Counsel) with Ms.
Tamanna Chhetri, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel) for the Appellant.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Public Prosecutor with Mr. S. K. Chettri and
Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Public Prosecutors for the State.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The instant Application has been filed by the Appellant
seeking condonation of delay for a period of 14 years and 7 months
in filing the Appeal against the Judgment and Order of Sentence of
the Learned Court of Sessions (S & W) Sikkim at Namchi, dated 1108-2000 in Criminal Case No.9 of 1996.
2.
For clarity, the sequence of events before this Court is
narrated hereunder;
On hearing the Senior Counsel for the Appellant, it emerged
that he had been engaged through the Sikkim State Legal Services
Authority on 27-11-2014 and had filed the Appeal on 05-03-2015
whereas the impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence was dated
11-08-2000. No records being available before this Court to indicate
what transpired between 11-08-2000 till November, 2013, i.e., the
date of re-arrest of the Appellant, the Senior Counsel sought
sometime to clarify. This was done on 26-05-2015 and taken on
record wherein the main ground urged for seeking condonation of
delay was that a copy of the impugned Judgment and Order were not
supplied to the Appellant. As no endorsement appeared either in
the original Judgment or in the relevant Order Sheet of the Learned
Trial Court on this aspect, a Report was called for from the
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
concerned Court seeking clarification. A Report was submitted by
the Learned Sessions Judge on 05-08-2015 based on the records
before him, explaining that a certified copy of the Judgment was
made over to the Counsel of the Accused/Appellant Shri Bandhan
Rai on 21-08-2000 pursuant to his application dated 18-08-2000.
3.
On the prayer of the Learned Senior Counsel to file
some documents in support of his application seeking condonation,
this was allowed and on 05-03-2016 he filed an application duly
supported by an affidavit sworn by Advocate Shri Bandhan Rai to the
effect that after he submitted an application on 18-08-2000 for
supply of certified copy of the impugned Judgment and it was made
over him on 21-08-2000. Thereafter, he remained out of touch with
the Appellant who was at the State Jail at Gangtok, as such, he could
not send the certified copy of the Judgment to him.
4.
While placing his verbal submissions, Learned Senior
Counsel contended that apart from non-receipt of the impugned
Judgment and Order by the Appellant, the delay also occurred as the
Sikkim State Legal Services Authority appointed him on 27-11-2014
and copy of the case records for preparing the Appeal was made
over to him on 02-01-2015 after which he took some time to prepare
the matter. That the Appellant once committed to Jail, was told by
inmates that he would be incarcerated for life on which after jail
breaking he fled therefrom the Jail on 12-10-2000. That, he went to
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
Taplayjung in Nepal, spent three years therein, obtained a Nepalese
Passport and left for Malaysia, where he worked as a Carpenter for
two and half years and returned to Nepal. He spent another year in
Nepal before leaving for Dubai where he worked for another four
years. In the year 2000, on his return to Nepal and being unable to
live there, returned to Sikkim in 2010 and lived in Sombaria, West
Sikkim, from where he shifted to Jorethang, South Sikkim. On 0111-2013, when he was in a Bank at Jorethang he was re-arrested,
produced before the Learned Trial Court, and on 02-11-2013
committed to the State Jail to serve out his sentence.
That, as he
remained in the Jail, he was unable to assist the Counsel in collecting
the files to enable drafting of the Appeal which was another of the
reasons for the delay in the instant Appeal.
5.
Learned Senior Counsel for the Appellant while urging
his ground for condonation drew the attention of this Court to the
decisions in Madhav Hayawadanrao Hoskot
vs. State of
Maharashtra1 and Dilip S. Dahanukar vs. Kotak Mahindra Co. Ltd.
and Another2
and submitted that the right to Appeal is implicit in
Article 21 of the Constitution of India which provides that no person
shall be deprived of his life and liberty except according to
procedure established by Law.
6.
The Learned Public Prosecutor refuting the grounds put
forth by the Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the Appellant
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
1. (1978) 3 SCC 544
2. (2007) 6 SCC 528
has failed to set out ‘sufficient cause’ for the delay as breaking Jail
and fleeing, when sentenced for a crime, is no ground for seeking
condonation of delay for a long period extending to 14 years and 7
months, for most of which he remained out of the country. Besides
he has misled the concerned Authorities by his acts of obtaining
Nepalese Passport and travelling abroad when he was not entitled to
it. On his return to Sikkim in 2010, he did not deem it necessary to
surrender before the Police but remained at large and was rearrested at Jorethang, South Sikkim on 01-11-2013 by the Police and
produced before the Court on 02-11-2013. Thus, the application
being devoid of merit ought to be dismissed outright.
7.
We have heard the Learned Counsel at length and given
due consideration to the rival contentions.
8.
Vide the impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence
dated 11-08-2000 of the Learned Sessions Judge (S & W) in Namchi in
Criminal Case No.9 of 1996, the Appellant was convicted under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) and
sentenced to undergo life imprisonment and to pay a fine of
Rs.2,000/- (Rupees two thousand) only, in default, to undergo
further imprisonment of two months. He was further convicted
under Section 201 of the IPC and sentenced to undergo
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
imprisonment for four years and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/- (Rupees
one thousand) only, with a default clause of imprisonment.
9.
While addressing the arguments of Senior Counsel for
the Appellant it has to be stated that the facts in Dilip S. Dahanukar2
are distinguishable from the facts in the instant case inasmuch as in
that case the Appellants had been convicted under Section 138 of the
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. On appeal against the Judgment,
the Appellants were directed to deposit a sum of Rs.5,00,000/(Rupees five lakhs) only, each within four weeks of the date of order.
Before the Hon’ble Apex Court it was agitated that the right to
prefer an Appeal being a constitutional right in terms of Article 21
of the constitution of India, no condition could have been imposed
in respect thereof or for suspension of sentence. No question of
delay had arisen there contrary to the case in hand here.
10.
What requires consideration, therefore, is whether the
conduct of the Appellant was bona fide and whether he has been
able to establish ‘sufficient cause’ for his delay to be condoned.
11.
It has been laid down in Collector, Land Acquisition,
Anantnag and Another vs. Mst. Katiji and Others3 that everyday’s
delay must be explained does not mean that a pedantic approach
should be made but there should be a justice-oriented approach. In
sum and substance this means that Courts are to give priority to
meting out justice on the merits of a case. At the same time one
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
3. (1987) 2 SCC 107
cannot overlook the aspect that the bona fides of the Appellant has
to be looked into by the Court.
12.
In Esha Bhattacharjee
vs. Managing Committee of
Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and Others4 it has been laid down,
inter alia, that –
13.
(i)
Lack of bona fides imputable to a party seeking
condonation of delay is a significant and relevant fact.
(ii)
The conduct, behaviour and attitude of a party relating
to its inaction or negligence are relevant factors to be
taken into consideration. It is so as the fundamental
principle is that the courts are required to weigh the
scale of balance of justice in respect of both parties and
the said principle cannot be given a total go by in the
name of liberal approach.
(iii)
It is to be borne in mind that no one gets away with
fraud, misrepresentation or interpolation by taking
recourse to the technicalities of law of limitation.
(iv)
The entire gamut of facts are to be carefully scrutinised
and the approach should be based on the paradigm of
judicial discretion which is founded on objective
reasoning and not on individual perception.
(v)
The increasing tendency to perceive delay as a nonserious matter and, hence, lackadaisical propensity can
be exhibited in a nonchalant manner requires to be
curbed, of course, within legal parameters.
It may also be pointed out that the Apex Court in
Basawaraj & Another vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer5 while
relying on the decision of Madanlal vs. Shyamlal6 and Ram Nath Sao
alias Ram Nath Sahu & Others vs. Gobardhan Sao & Others7, held that“11. The expression “sufficient cause” should
be given a liberal interpretation to ensure that
substantial justice is done, but only so long as
negligence, inaction or lack of bona fides cannot be
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
4. (2013) 12 SCC 649
5. (2013) 14 SCC 81
6. (2002) 1 SCC 535
7. (2002) 3 SCC 195
imputed to the party concerned, whether or not
sufficient cause has been furnished, can be decided on
the facts of a particular case and no straitjacket formula
is possible.
12.
It is a settled legal proposition that law of
limitation may harshly affect a particular party but it
has to be applied with all its rigour when the statute so
prescribes. The court has no power to extend the period
of limitation on equitable grounds. “A result flowing
from a statutory provision is never an evil. A court has
no power to ignore that provision to relieve what it
considers a distress resulting from its operation.” The
statutory provision may cause hardship or
inconvenience to a particular party but the court has no
choice but to enforce it giving full effect to the same.
The legal maxim dura lex sed lex which means “the law
is hard but it is the law”, stands attracted in such a
situation. It has consistently been held that,
“inconvenience is not” a decisive factor to be
considered while interpreting a statute.”
[emphasis supplied]
14.
Bearing the above in mind, although an argument may
be raised that the Judgment and Order of Sentence was not made
over to the Appellant on the date of pronouncement and his Counsel
subsequently applied for it on 18-08-2000 and copy was received by
him on 21-08-2000, it is no one’s case that the said Counsel did not
represent the Accused when the Counsel had applied for a copy. It is
assumed that he has acted under the instructions of the Appellant.
It is also no one’s case that the Appellant himself was not present in
the Court, which would in any event be an incongruous situation,
the very fact of his presence implies his knowledge of the assailed
Judgment and Sentence. Delay of 14 years and 7 months has largely
been due to the conduct of the Appellant, i.e., of him having broken
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
the Jail and escaped pursuant to which he embarked on his
adventure of living outside the country on a Passport to which he
was not legally entitled. This point not being the subject-matter of
discussion is not being delved into.
15.
Thereafter, it is also evident that although he returned
to Sikkim in the year 2010 and engaged himself in doing petty
contracts he failed to let his conscience rule him and surrender
either before the Police or before the convicting Court. Hence, the
conduct of the Appellant is by no means beyond reproach.
Consequently, although this Court is conscious that the Appellant
has statutory and substantive rights under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India, however, this Court while exercising
discretionary powers, has to give due weight to the legal position as
postulated in Basawaraj5 as also the statutory provisions which
cannot be expanded to accommodate the Appellant.
16.
In conclusion, from the discussions hereinabove, the
conduct of the Appellant does not reveal any bona fides
consequently, we are constrained to and do reject the application for
condonation of delay.
17.
Ordered accordingly.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
( Sunil Kumar Sinha )
2016:SHC:39-DB
Crl.M.Appl. No.09 of 2015
Suraj Rai @ Suresh vs. State of Sikkim
Judge
Chief Justice
13-04-2016
13-04-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
Internet : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review