Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed
by
SHAYNA
KADRI
2026:CGHC:3727
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 8986 of 2023
1 - Suraj Bai Rathiya W/o Bhupendra Singh Rathiya Aged About 25
Years Caste Kanwar, Resident Of Chainpur, Tahsil Kartala, Korba,
District : Korba, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Durga Bai Rathiya W/o Devendra Prakash Rathiya Aged About 27
Years Caste Kanwar, Resident Of Chianpur, Tahsil Kartala, Korba,
District : Korba, Chhattisgarh
2 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat Kartala,, District : Korba,
Chhattisgarh
3 - Project Officer Integrated Child Development Project Kartala, District
: Korba, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Pushpendra Kumar Patel, Advocate
For State
: Mr. Anway Tiwari, Panel Lawyer
For Resp. No. 1 : Mr. Shahdev Yadav, Advocate appearing
on behalf of Mr. C. J. K. Rao, Advocate
SB- Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
21/01/2026
1.
The present writ petition is being filed seeking following reliefs:-
2.
“(i)
That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to call for the entire records pertaining
to the petitioner's case.
(ii)
That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to issue writ/or writs/order/or orders,
to quash impugned order dated 10.10.2023
(Annexure P-1) passed by the learned Upper
Commissioner Bilaspur Division Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh, in Appeal case no. 63/A89/2022-2023, interest of justice.
(iii)
Any other relief which may be suitable in the
facts and circumstances of the case including
cost of the petition, may also be granted.”
Facts of the case, in a nutshell, are that the respondent No. 1
preferred
a
Commissioner,
revision
petition
Bilaspur
before
Division,
the
Bilaspur,
learned
Upper
Chhattisgarh,
challenging the order dated 18.05.2023 passed by the learned
Collector, Korba, Chhattisgarh. Respondent No. 2 had issued an
advertisement for the post of Aanganwadi Worker pursuant to
letter dated 02.04.2008. In response to the said advertisement,
the petitioner applied for the post of Aanganwadi Worker,
possessing all requisite qualifications as prescribed under the
terms and conditions of the advertisement. After due verification
of all relevant documents, the petitioner was duly selected and
appointed on the post of Aanganwadi Worker vide order dated
16.09.2022. In compliance thereof, the petitioner joined her duties
on 20.09.2022. Respondent No. 1 preferred an appeal before the
learned Collector, Korba, against the appointment order dated
16.09.2022. After due consideration of the material available on
record, the learned Collector rejected the said appeal vide order
dated 18.05.2023. Being aggrieved by the order dated 18.05.2023
passed by the learned Collector, Korba, respondent No. 1 filed a
revision petition before the learned Upper Commissioner, Bilaspur
Division,
Bilaspur,
Commissioner,
Chhattisgarh.
without
properly
The
learned
appreciating
the
Upper
material
available on record, allowed the revision petition vide impugned
order dated 10.10.2023 passed in Appeal Case No. 63/A89/2022-2023. The impugned order dated 10.10.2023 passed by
the learned Upper Commissioner is illegal, erroneous, arbitrary,
and contrary to settled principles of law, and has been passed
without proper consideration of the facts and evidence on record.
The petitioner has no efficacious or alternative remedy available
except to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court.
Hence, the present petition is being filed.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
order dated 10.10.2023 (Annexure P-1) passed by the learned
Upper Commissioner, Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh, is
wholly illegal, erroneous, arbitrary, and contrary to law, and
therefore deserves to be quashed and set aside.
It is further
submitted that the petitioner had applied for the post of
Aanganwadi Worker along with all requisite documents strictly in
accordance with the terms and conditions of the advertisement.
Upon due verification of the said documents, the petitioner was
found fully eligible and entitled for selection and appointment as
per the applicable rules and guidelines. Learned counsel submits
that respondent No. 2, after proper scrutiny and satisfaction that
the petitioner fulfilled all eligibility criteria as per the guidelines
issued by the State Government, appointed the petitioner to the
post of Aanganwadi Worker vide order dated 16.09.2022. It is
submitted that the learned Collector, Korba, while deciding the
appeal preferred by respondent No. 1, duly considered the entire
material available on record and rightly rejected the appeal vide
order dated 18.05.2023, thereby affirming the lawful appointment
of the petitioner. Learned counsel submits that the learned Upper
Commissioner,
while
passing
the
impugned
order
dated
10.10.2023, failed to consider the relevant documents and
material placed on record by the petitioner and, without proper
appreciation of facts and law, wrongly allowed the revision petition
preferred by respondent No. 1, which is unsustainable in the eyes
of law. It is further submitted that as per the guidelines of the
State Government, the petitioner was validly selected and
appointed to the post of Aanganwadi Worker and has been
continuously discharging her duties since the date of appointment.
Her performance has been satisfactory and there has been no
complaint whatsoever against her functioning. Learned counsel
submits that respondent No. 1 did not fulfill the terms and
conditions of the advertisement and has raised frivolous and
baseless objections solely with an intent to harass and mentally
torture the petitioner, which is impermissible in law. It is submitted
that the learned Upper Commissioner ought to have adopted a
liberal, fair, and judicious approach while deciding the revision
petition, particularly when the petitioner’s appointment had
already been upheld by the learned Collector after due
consideration. Learned counsel submits that the impugned order
is arbitrary, illegal, and contrary to the material available on record
and the documents submitted by the petitioner, and therefore
suffers from serious infirmities warranting interference by this
Court. In view of the aforesaid facts and settled position of law, it
is submitted that the impugned order dated 10.10.2023 has been
passed in an arbitrary manner and is liable to be quashed.
4.
Learned State Counsel submits that the order passed by the
learned Commissioner is well-merited, reasoned, and passed in
accordance with law, and therefore does not call for any
reconsideration or interference by this Court. It is submitted that
respondent No. 1 had duly filed his residential certificate before
the concerned authority within the relevant stage of the
proceedings. However, the said document was not properly
considered by the competent authority while taking the initial
decision. Learned State Counsel further submits that the learned
Commissioner has rightly appreciated this factual aspect and,
upon finding that a relevant document had been ignored, has
correctly exercised revisional jurisdiction and interfered with the
earlier order. It is submitted that the impugned order does not
suffer from any illegality, perversity, or arbitrariness and has been
passed after due consideration of the material available on record.
In view of the aforesaid submissions, learned State Counsel prays
that the writ petition, being devoid of merit, deserves to be
dismissed.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No. 1 submits
that the impugned order passed by the learned Commissioner is a
well-reasoned, lawful, and speaking order, passed after due
consideration of each and every relevant aspect of the matter and
the material available on record. It is submitted that the learned
Commissioner has correctly appreciated the factual and legal
position and has examined the entire record in detail before
arriving at the conclusion. The findings recorded in the impugned
order are based on proper appreciation of evidence and do not
suffer from any perversity or arbitrariness.
Learned counsel
further submits that the learned Commissioner has rightly taken
note of the fact that the requisite documents relating to the
residential certificate were produced during the pendency of the
proceedings and prior to the decision taken by the Chief
Executive Officer. Therefore, the requirement under the relevant
guidelines stood duly complied with. It is submitted that since the
necessary documents were placed on record within the
permissible stage of the proceedings, no illegality or procedural
irregularity can be attributed to the order passed by the learned
Commissioner. Learned counsel submits that the impugned order
has been passed strictly in accordance with law, after affording
due opportunity of hearing to all concerned parties, and therefore
does not warrant any interference by this Court in exercise of its
extraordinary jurisdiction. In view of the above, learned counsel
for respondent No. 1 prays that the writ petition deserves to be
dismissed as being devoid of merit.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also
perused the documents enclosed along with the petition.
7.
From a bare perusal of the order dated 18.05.2023 passed by the
Collector, Korba, as well as the revisional order dated 10.10.2023
passed by the Additional Commissioner, Bilaspur Division, it is
evident that when the appeal was preferred by the petitioner
against the appointment of respondent No.1, the first appellate
authority i.e., the Collector, Korba, examined the matter in detail
and addressed the objections raised by the petitioner. The
Collector recorded a finding that the petitioner had failed to submit
a valid residential certificate at the time of filing the application
and during the stage of claim-objection, and that instead, a
subsequent residential certificate was produced, which was duly
verified by the evaluation/selection committee. On that basis, the
Collector concluded that the petitioner was not entitled to
appointment and that the appointment order dated 16.09.2022
issued in favour of respondent No.1 did not suffer from any
illegality or infirmity, and accordingly dismissed the appeal.
8.
When the aforesaid order was assailed before the Additional
Commissioner in revision, the revisional authority, while exercising
limited supervisory jurisdiction, re-examined the entire matter in
detail. Though the scope of revisional jurisdiction is confined to
examining the legality, propriety, or correctness of the impugned
order, the Additional Commissioner, upon consideration of rival
submissions and the documents produced by both parties, found
that the Collector had failed to properly appreciate the grievance
raised by respondent No.1. It was specifically observed that the
earlier residential certificate of respondent No.1 had been issued
during the Jansamasya Niwaran process, wherein the name of
the village was incorrectly recorded as Taraimar instead of
Chainpur. Upon noticing the said anomaly during the claimobjection stage, respondent No.1 promptly sought rectification
and also produced supporting documents including ration card,
voter identity card, Aadhaar card, and other relevant certificates,
all of which consistently reflected her residence as Village
Chainpur. An affidavit was also filed clarifying the factual position.
The Additional Commissioner, upon comprehensive evaluation of
the material on record, rightly concluded that respondent No.1
was a resident of Village Chainpur and that the discrepancy in the
earlier residential certificate was purely clerical in nature, which
stood subsequently rectified. The revisional authority further held
that the Collector had failed to consider these crucial documents
and had, therefore, passed an arbitrary and illegal order,
warranting interference. Accordingly, the revision was allowed by
a detailed and reasoned order.
9.
From a careful perusal of the revisional order, it is manifest that
the Additional Commissioner has duly examined the entire
controversy relating to the residential certificate and has assigned
cogent and convincing reasons while recording findings in favour
of respondent No.1. The conclusions arrived at are based on
proper appreciation of evidence and relevant material on record,
and no perversity, arbitrariness, or illegality can be attributed
thereto.
10.
Upon due consideration, this Court does not find the present case
to be a fit one for exercise of jurisdiction under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India. The impugned order passed by
the Additional Commissioner is well-reasoned, lawful, and based
on objective evaluation of the material available on record. Each
and every relevant aspect has been examined in detail, and the
findings recorded do not suffer from any legal infirmity warranting
interference.
11.
It is trite law that in exercise of writ jurisdiction, this Court does not
sit as a Court of appeal to re-appreciate evidence or substitute its
own conclusions unless the impugned order suffers from manifest
illegality, perversity, or jurisdictional error. In the present case, no
such infirmity is demonstrated. The Collector, while cancelling the
candidature of respondent No.1, failed to consider the entirety of
the documentary evidence, whereas the Additional Commissioner
has passed a comprehensive, reasoned, and speaking order. In
view of the same, the scope of interference under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution is not attracted.
12.
Accordingly, the writ petition, being devoid of merit, is liable to be
and is hereby dismissed.
No order as to costs
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Shayna
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review