Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 1272/2020
Pronounced on 14.08.2026
Uploaded on 14.08.2026
Sunita Devi and Ors
...……….Petitioner(s)
Through: - Mr. R.K Jain, Sr. Adv with Assisting counsel
Vs.
Union territory of J&K & Ors
……….Respondent(s)
Through: - Ms. Mrinal, Assisting counsel to
Mrs. Monika Kohli, sr. AAG for R-1, 3 &4
Mr. F.S Bhat, Advocate for R-5 to 8.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. Through the medium of the instant writ petition, having been filed
in terms of provisions of Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
the petitioners have sought the issuance of writ of certiorari for
quashing the order dated 23.07.2020 passed by the respondent
No.2-Ld J&K Special Tribunal, Jammu, while hearing the Revision
petition against the order dated 25.05.2004 passed by the respondent
No.3-Ld Financial Commissioner with powers of Agrarian Reforms
Commissioner, Jammu.
2. The case of the petitioners is that their ancestor Ichru @ Achroo,
was the tenant of land comprising under Khasra Nos. 81, 82,83 and
84 situated at Toph Sherkhania Tehsil and District, Jammu
(hereinafter referred to as subject land) prior to 1950 and thereafter
also continued to be in the cultivating possession of the subject
land under his the then landlord Shri Raj Kumar Jai chand. That the
father of Shri Raj Kumar Jai chand was the then ―RAJA‖ of
Chenanie, (now part of the District Udhampur) and was a big
landlord having more than 3266 kanals of land situated at different
locations including village Rawalpora Tehsil Shri Pratap Singhpora
(Kashmir). That upon coming into the operation of the Big Landed
Estates Abolition Act (BLEAA for short) BK 2007 (1950 AD), the
ancestor of the private respondent’s i.e the Landlord namely Shri
Raj Kumar Jai chand as well as his brother Shri Raj Kumar Terath
Chand selected their respective units of land measuring 182 kanals
each, permissible to be retained
accordingly, two separate
under the BLEAA. That
mutations came to be attested
with
respect to the units of the land selected by Sh. Raj Kumar Jai chand
and his brother Shr. Raj Kumar Terath chand, which fact also
amounted to the partition of land in between
the said two
brothers/land owners. That the subject land was not selected by Sh.
Rajkumar Jai Chand and the same continued to be cultivated by
their (petitioners) ancestor Ichru@ Achroo who retained physical
possession of the same during his life time whereafter the same is
held continuously by them (petitioners).
That their ancestor
Ichru @ Achroo was entitled
to be
conferred the ownership rights vis-a-vis the subject land under the
operation of the BLEAA but due to non-cooperative attitude of the
Revenue Authorities, same got delayed during his lifetime. That
their said ancestor Ichru was a poor and illiterate person who
moved from pillar to post so as to get the due benefit of BLEAA
but unfortunately, he could not succeed until he died.
That however, during the lifetime of their said ancestor being,
the tiller of the subject land and before the ownership rights in
terms of Section 5 of the BLEAA could be conferred upon him in
respect of the subject land being in excess of ceiling units and also
being not identified/selected
within the ceiling units by the
landlords, the J&K Agrarian Reforms Act 1976 (hereinafter referred
to as the Agrarian
Act for short) came to be legislated
and
enforced, extinguishing the rights of the land owners not found in
personal cultivation of the land as on 1st Sept. 1971. That their
ancestor Achroo also became qualified for conferment of ownership
rights in respect of the subject land under the operation of the
Agrarian Act who accordingly requested the concerned authorities
for conferment of such right in respect of the subject land for his
being in cultivating physical possession of the same on 1 st Sept
1971 and much prior to that. That the then concerned revenue
authorities upon being satisfied regarding the subject land being in
physical cultivating possession of their said ancestor attested the
mutation u/s 4 of the Act in his favour, under No. 2672.
That, however, the ancestor of the private respondents-Shri
Rajkumar Jai Chand claimed to have prayed for resumption of the
subject matter by invoking the provisions of Section 7 of the
Agrarian Act. That no notice of such resumption application was
served upon the said ancestor of the petitioners-Achroo or even to
them (petitioners). That however, the respondent No.4-Tehsildar
Jammu, North Janipur, rejected the said application for resumption
vide Mutation No.2813 dated 24.11.81. The said order of rejection
of resumption dated 24.11.1981 came to be questioned by the
ancestor of the private respondents Sh. Rajkumar Jai chand/exlandlord, in an appeal before the respondent no.3-Financial
Commissioner with powers of Agrarian Reforms Commissioner,
Jammu. The appeal was accepted by the respondent No.3 vide his
order dated 07.08.1997 and the case was remanded
back to
respondent No.4-Tehsildar for holding a fresh enquiry.
That in the meantime and pursuant
to mutation No. 2672
already attested u/s 4 of the Agrarian Act, a mutation u/s 8 of the
Act under No. 2735 also came to be attested in favour of the
aforesaid ancestor of the petitioners i.e Ichru @ Achroo, conferring
upon him the rights of ownership viz-a-vis the subject land.
That the Mutation No. 2735 u/s 8 of the Agrarian Act came to
be questioned in appeal before the learned appellate authority which
accepted the appeal, set aside the mutation No. 2735 u/s 8 of the
Agrarian Act, vide its order dated 24.07.2001 and remanded the
case back to Tehsildar Settlement, Jammu with a direction that
proceedings u/s 8 of the Agrarian Act in respect of the subject land
be conducted after and subject to the conclusion of the proceedings
u/s 7 of the Agrarian Act, already directed by the said authority vide
its remand order dated 7th of August, 1997.
That the aforesaid order dated 24.07.2001 of the Appellate
Authority also came to be challenged by them (petitioners) before
the respondent No.2-J&K Special Tribunal, Jammu through the
medium of a revision petition. The respondent No.2 i.e the learned
Special Tribunal, Jammu vide its order dated 04.02.2003 declined
to interfere in the order dated 24.07.2001 of the learned Appellate
Authority with the observations that impugned order dated
24.07.2001 is a remand order and not a final one with the further
observation that dispute between the parties u/s 7 of the Act
pertaining to resumption is still pending between them/
That the Tehsildar concerned vide his order dated 22.02.2001,
again dismissed the application of Sh. Raj Kumar Jai chand by
holding him not entitled to the resumption of the subject land on
the ground among others that ex-owner had sold some land.
That subsequently the legal heirs of Sh. Raj Kumar Jai chand
namely Kanta Kumari (daughter) and Balbahader chand (son),
questioned the order dated 22.02.2001, whereby the Tehsildar
Settlement, Jammu maintained the rejection of resumption
application filed by their ancestor late Rajkumar Jai chand through
an appeal bearing file No. 304 before the respondent No.3Commissioner Agrarian Reforms (Financial Commissioner).
That they (petitioners) filed a transfer application before the
respondent No.2 seeking transfer of the appeal to some other
competent court as they noticed the inclination of the then learned
Financial Commissioner towards Appellants in the said appeal i.e
Kanta Kumari and Balbahadur chand. That para-wise reply was
called by the respondent no.2 from the learned Appellate Court, but
during the pendency of the transfer petition, the respondent No.3
hurried to dispose of the appeal by its order dated 25.05.2004
allegedly in a biased manner.
That the petitioners challenged the order dated 25.05.2004 of
the respondent No.3 in a revision petition before the respondent
No.2 which was dismissed on illegal and unjustified grounds, vide
impugned order dated 23.07.2020.
That they i.e petitioners, have now been left with no remedy but
to invoke the writ jurisdiction of this Court seeking the issuance of a
writ of certiorari for quashing the orders dated 25.05.2004 and
23.07.2020, respectively, passed by respondent Nos. 3 and 2, as also
a writ of prohibition for prohibiting the respondents from interfering
with the petitioners' peaceful possession and enjoyment of the
subject land.
That they have also sought issuance of any other writs,
directions which this court may deem fit and proper in the facts
and circumstance of the case.
3. The petitioners have assailed the impugned orders on the grounds
inter alia that:(i)
The respondent No.2 i.e. Ld Special Tribunal, Jammu was
required to await the result of writ petition No. 904/2010
which was subjudice before this court. That subsequent
to the passing of the order dated
25.05.2004, the
respondent No.2 vide its order dated 23.04.2010 passed on
their (petitioners) application ordered the summoning of
the resumption form alleged to had been filed by Sh. Raj
Kumar Jai chand-predecessor in-interest of respondents 5
to 8 as well as the connected record of the Tehsildar
concerned. That on 07.06.2010, the respondent No.2
reviewed its earlier order dated 23.04.2010 by which the
record of resumption application was summoned. That the
order dated 07.06.2010 of the respondent No.2
was
questioned by them (petitioners) in writ petition OWP
904/2010 which petition is still pending in this court. That
the fact of the pendency of the writ petition despite being
brought to the notice of the respondent No.2 did not make
any sound.
(ii) That the
observations/directions issued by respondent
No.2 in the impugned order dated 23.07.2020 are without
jurisdiction and thus, liable to be quashed. That the
respondent No.2 which has kept
open the issue of
resumption to be adjudicated by the respondent No.4 i.e,
Tehsildar Khas, Jammu
should not have issued the
command to him to attest a mutation under section 7 of the
Agrarian Act and handover the possession of the subject
land to private respondents. That the grant of simultaneous
liberty to the respondent No.4 to seek the assistance of law
Enforcement Agency in case of any necessity was not
justified.
(iii) That Tehsildar concerned was supposed to have been given
a liberty to conduct adjudication in respect of the fact
whether the ancestor of private respondents had transferred
the land at Srinagar after 1st Sept 1971.
(iv) That the resumption application was devoid of any merit as
per the requirements of section-7 of the Agrarian Act. That
the respondent No.4 as per the provisions of the Agrarian
Act and the Rules
of 1977 framed there-under was
required to conduct
an enquiry after affording an
opportunity of being heard to both the parties.
(v) That it has remained their categoric stand during all the
proceedings that the ancestor of the private respondent Sh.
Raj Kumar Jai chand was not entitled to resume on the
ground that he and his family members were income tax
payers and secondly, the ex-owner had transferred the
land after 1st day of Sept 1971, thus, disqualified for
resumption of land.
(vi) That the direction issued by the respondent No.2 for
attestation of mutation u/s 7 of the Agrarian Act in favour
of the legal heirs of Sh. Raj Kumar Jai chand, suffers from
material illegalities, irregularities rendering the impugned
order unsustainable under law. That there was no question
of resumption of subject land as the same already stood
escheated to the State under the operation of the BLEAA.
That the ancestor of the private respondent had already
lost its ownership viz-a-viz the subject land.
(vii) That the respondent no.2 during proceedings of the
revision petition before it and after hearing the learned
counsel for the parties passed the order dated 23.04.2010
for summoning of the record which was material for
arriving at a just decision
but later on the
tribunal
reviewed its order.
(viii)That there is no provision guaranteeing the reviewing of
the own order by the Authorities under the Act. That the
alleged resumption form was a material document required
to be examined by the respondent No.2 in terms of the date
of presentation of the same and the details made therein.
That said remand form was required to be as per Form
No.5 prescribed under the Agrarian Reforms Rules, 1977.
(ix) That the respondent No.2 committed an illegality in
reviewing its earlier order dated 23.4.2010 vide subsequent
order dated 07.06.2010 thereby declining the summoning
of the original record particularly the alleged resumption
form supposed to be containing details of the land as well
as the date of submission of the same, thereby rendering
the order impugned to be unsustainable in the eyes of law.
(x) That no record was before the respondent no.2 where from
it, could have arrived at a conclusion regarding the date of
submission of the resumption form, as well as the contents
of the same. That there was also no record before the
respondent no.2 on the basis of which, the Tribunal could
have satisfied itself that the ancestor of the private
respondent made selection of the land at Top Sherkhania,
Jammu and which Khasra numbers were sought to be
resumed.
(xi) That the impugned orders suffer from material illegalities
and irregularities which are apparent on the face of record
and are thus liable to be quashed.
(xii) That the respondents 2 & 3 were not justified in issuing
direction to the respondent No.4 for attestation of a
Mutation u/s 7,
when no adjudication on the alleged
application U/s 7 had been held and further no opportunity
was offered to the ancestor of the petitioners i.e. Ichru or to
the petitioners after his death to contest the said resumption
application.
(xiii)That the respondent No.2 i.e Special Tribunal Jammu did
not return any finding on the issues raised in the revision
petition as well as agitated through the written arguments.
(xiv) That the learned Special Tribunal (respondent No.2) did
not appreciate the facto legal issue raised in the revision
petition to the effect that the appeal before the respondent
No.3 i.e. Financial Commissioner with powers of Agrarian
Reforms Commissioner, Jammu was hopelessly time
barred and the authority concerned hurried to decide the
appeal on merits without first addressing the application,
for condonation of delay.
(xv) That in terms of the provisions of Order 41 Rule 3 A CPC,
the Appellate Court acquires jurisdiction to decide the
appeal only subject to the outcome of the condonation of
delay application, therefore, the impugned
order dated
25.05.2004 passed by respondent No.3 was without
jurisdiction which fact was under estimated
by the
respondent No.2. That the respondent No.2 did not
consider such important question of law and hurried to
dismiss the revision petition filed by the predecessor ininterest of the petitioners against the mandatory provisions
contained in Order 41 Rule 3A CPC.
(xvi) That the revision petition, giving rise to the impugned
order dated 23.07.2020, was pending before
the Ld
Judicial Member of the Tribunal i.e. Bench No.2 and the
Respondent No.2 through its Chairman withdrew the case
from the Bench No.2 and assigned the same to its own
Bench without notice to the petitioners particularly when
the Judicial Member was functioning.
(xvii) That on 9th of July 2020 when the case was taken up by
the respondent No.2 for hearing, the junior counsel of the
petitioners appeared and requested to supply him a copy of
transfer application for filing the objections which was not
done and instead the case was kept open for orders with
the direction to the junior counsel of the petitioners to
submit his written arguments on or before 20.07.2020.
(xviii) That the written arguments as directed were submitted
and the respondent No.2 while sitting at Srinagar decided
the case
dismissing the revision
petition through
impugned
order dated 2307.2020 without affording an
opportunity of being heard to the petitioners to argue the
case orally.
(xix) That the respondent No.2 did not consider the written
submissions/arguments submitted by their counsel which
were supported by the documentary proof as well as the
judgments of this Court in respect of the, issues involved,
which constitutes a circumstance warranting quashment
of the impugned order dated 23.07.2020.
(xx) That the respondent No.2 mainly based its judgment on the
order dated 04.03.2003 passed by it while hearing the
earlier revision petition that was filed by their predecessor
in-interest against the order of respondent No.3 by virtue of
which the said respondent No.3 set aside the Mutation No.
2735 attested in favour of their predecessor in-interest u/s
8 of the Agrarian Act.
(xxi) That
the respondent No.2 upheld
the order of the
Appellate Court i.e. Respondent No.3 based on the ground
that no mutation u/s 8 can be attested
unless the
proceedings u/s 7 for resumption of the subject land, were
concluded.
(xxii) That there was no dispute u/s 7 of the Agrarian Act
before the learned Special Tribunal (respondent No.2)
which on one hand directed that Mutation u/s 8 of Agrarian
Act in favour of the predecessor in-interest of the
petitioners was premature and o n the other hand in the
same order held that predecessor in-interest of respondents
was entitled to resume the subject land.
(xxiii) That the respondent No.2 did not consider the fact that
his predecessor in office/court while recording the order
dated 04.02.2003 was dealing with the dispute pertaining
to mutation u/s 8 of the Agrarian Act being Mutation No.
2735 dated 01.01.1982 and not the dispute u/s 7 of the
Agrarian Act.
(xxiv) That the observation of the respondent No.2 i.e. Special
Tribunal Jammu regarding the operation of the resjudicata
is illegal as the controversy involved in the litigation i.e.
revision petition giving rise to the order impugned dated
23.07.2020 was in terms of Section 7 of the Agrarian Act.
(xxv) That, except for the present writ petition, no other writ
petition has been filed challenging the impugned order
dated 23.07.2020. That OWP No. 904/2010 had challenged
the order dated 07.06.2010, which was passed during the
pendency of the revision petition.
4. The contesting
private respondents
5 to 8 through their
reply/objections have resisted the instant petition on the ground
inter alia, that :(i)
The writ petition is not maintainable because no question
of law or public interest was pleaded either in the revision
petition or in the
arguments
by the petitioners,
the
existence/agitation whereof was the sine quo none for
filing the
revision petition, in terms of provisions of
Section 21 (2) of the Agrarian Act.
(ii) That the petitioners cannot go beyond their pleadings in the
writ petition filed before this court by invoking its extra
ordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India.
(iii) That the contention of the predecessor in-interest of the
petitioners namely
Ichru @ Achroo agitated
by him
during his life time and thereafter by the present
petitioners before the concerned authorities to the effect
that Raj Kumar Jai chand,-- the ex-land owner and the
predecessor in-interest of the private respondents had not
mentioned
the subject
Khasra numbers of which he
sought resumption, in his Unit of 182 Kanals under
BLEAA, is not justified because the aforesaid Raj Kumar
Jai chand had filed the necessary application before the
authorities and the subject Khasra numbers were included
in his unit of 182 kanals of land.
(vi) That the ex-owner Raj Kumar Jaichand had indicated the
old Khasra numbers instead of new Khasra numbers which
were allotted to the land in question during the settlement
proceedings in the years 1979-80 B.K. That Raj Kumar Jai
chand had no other land in village Toph-Sherkhania Tehsil
Jammu except the subject land.
(iv) That the ancestor of petitioners—Achroo had categorically
admitted the relationship of land lord and tenant between
him and the Raj Kumar Jai chand by filing an application
before the Tehsildar Jammu requesting therein
for
effecting the correction in entries in register of khasra
Girdawari for the years 1967-1977 in the quantum of rent
of the subject land comprised under khasra numbers
81,82,83 and 84.
(v) That the petitioners have now taken a belated stand
during the second round of litigation to the effect that
subject land was not included in the unit of 182 kanals
selected by the Raj Kumar Jai chand and as such they
(private respondents) are not the owners of the land in
question.
(vi) That at the time of attestation of mutation u/s 4 of Agrarian
Act, the petitioner’s ancestor admitted the
private
respondent’s—ancestor as his land lord.
(vii) That section 32 of the Agrarian Act provides that the said
Act has an overriding effect on all other previous laws,
therefore, no plea can be taken under BLEAA during the
proceedings under Agrarian Act. That the relationship of
land lord and tenant is to be determined by entry of khasra
Girdawari of Kharief 1971. That admittedly Raj Kumar
Jaichand was recorded as land lord of the subject land in
the year 1971, therefore, no other plea is admissible. That
otherwise also Achroo –ancestor of petitioners and the
original tenant has admitted the relationship of land lord
and tenant between the parties to the writ petition.
(viii) That the proceedings under the BLEAA pending, if any,
have to abate as no fresh proceedings under any other Act
in contravention of the Agrarian Act can be initiated.
(ix) That as per the provisions of Section 42 of the Agrarian
Act, the provisions of BLEAA so far as they are
inconsistent with the provisions of Agrarian Act cease to
apply and pending inconsistent proceedings before courts
or revenue officers shall abate.
(x) That the contention of the petitioners that appeal before the
Respondent No.3 was filed beyond the period of limitation
and the learned appellate authority decided the appeal
without condoning the delay is not justified, because the
appeal was filed within the period of limitation from the
date of knowledge of the impugned order.
(xi) That they i.e. private respondents obtained the knowledge
of the impugned order on 09.10.2001 and the appeal was
filed on 16.10.2001 when two to three days were spent in
obtaining the certified copies.
(xii) That no question of law or public importance is involved in
the case. That jurisdiction under article 226 of the
constitution of India may not be exercised by this court to
alter the finding of facts arrived at by the J&K Special
Tribunal, Agrarian Reforms Commissioner (Financial
Commissioner J&K and the Tehsildar) Jammu.
(xiii) That all the rules including the rule 21 of J&K Agrarian
Reforms Rules 1977 have been complied with by the
authorities concerned.
(xiv) That Raj Kumar Jai Chand was not an income tax payer.
(xv) That no land has been transferred by Raj Kumar Jai chand
after the year 1971.
(xvi) That respondents 2 & 3 have passed the justified orders
and did not violate the principles of natural justice.
(xvii) That petitioners and their ancestor were afforded
sufficient opportunity of hearing and to contest the
application u/s 7 of the Agrarian Act.
5. It is needful to mention that having regard to the fact of real contest
between the petitioners and the private respondents 5 to 8, the
respondents 2 and 3, being quasi-judicial authorities, the submission
of the Ld. State Counsel made before the Court at the hearing of the
case on 20.08.2024 that no counter affidavit to the petition is needed
to be filed on behalf of the said official respondents was agreed
with.
6. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties in respect of the
matter and considered their rival contentions.
7. Perused the record of the instant petition, especially memo of writ
petition, reply filed by the contesting private respondents and the
copies of the orders passed from time to time by the revenue
authorities
as well as the learned Special Tribunal
at Jammu
especially the orders dated 4.7.2003, 25.05.2004 and 23.07.2020.
8. The case has really a chequered history. This multi rounded
litigation dates back from the enactment of J&K, BLEAA 2007 (Svt
1950 AD) and has engaged many generations. Some laxity
in
addressing the issues involved in the case post enactment and
enforcement of J&K BLEAA 1950 AD and J&K Agrarian Reforms
Act 1976, in time and strictly as per the law with the involvement
of both sides may be a cause of burning issue.
9. It has remained the stand of the ancestor of the petitioners-Ichru @
Achroo during his life time that the subject land comprised under
Khasra Nos. 81,82,83 and 84 situated at the then Revenue Estate
Top Sherkhinia Tehsil Jammu was under his cultivation as a tenant
prior to 1950 AD.
That his landlords, Shri Rajkumar Jai Chand and his brother,
Shri Rajkumar Teerath Chand, were the sons of the then ―Raja‖ of
Chenani, (now part of District Udhampur) and were owing more
than 3266 kanals of land situated at different locations. That upon
coming into the operation of the BLEAA, they selected their
respective Units of land to the extent of 182 kanals each permissible
to be retained by them under the BLEAA, with the attestation of
two separate Mutations in their favour.
That the subject land was not selected by them in their Units
which continued to remain under his tenancy, thus entitled him to
be conferred the ownership in respect of the same in view of the
Section 5 of the BLEAA. That he ran from pillar to post for getting
ownership vis-a-vis subject land in terms of the provisions of
Section 5 of BLEAA, but could not get justice. That meanwhile the
Agrarian Act came to be legislated and enforced with effect from
13-7-1978. That being in the continued and uninterrupted tenancy
of the subject land right from 1950 AD, (2007 Svt), as well as on
Kharif 1971, he got qualified to be conferred with the ownership
rights vis-a-vis the same in terms of the provisions of sections 4 and
8 of the Agrarian Act.
That after approaching the authorities under the Agrarian Act,
Mutation under Section 4 in respect of the subject land came to be
attested in his favour. That being an illiterate and helpless person,
he was not conferred with the full ownership rights with the
attestation of mutation under Section 8 of the Agrarian Act, as in the
meanwhile the ancestor of the private respondents, Shri Rajkumar
Jai Chand, purportedly filed the resumption application which was
rejected by the then Tehsildar vide his order dated 24-11-1981. The
ancestor of private respondents preferred an appeal before
respondent No. 3, i.e., Appellate authority, which vide order dated
9-8-1987, remanded the matter back to respondent No. 4, i.e.,
Tehsildar concerned, for appropriate verification and passing of
orders. It is his further stand that thereafter in continuation to the
attestation of the mutation under Section 4 of the Agrarian Act in
his favour, the mutation under Section 8 of the Act also came to be
attested in his favour, which was however assailed before the
Appellate Authority, i.e., respondent No. 3, which vide order dated
24-7-2001 again remanded the matter to respondent No. 4 with the
direction that the attestation of mutation under Section 8 be
considered after and subject to the conclusion of resumption
proceedings already remanded back.
That he, preferred a revision before respondent No. 2, i.e., the
learned Special Tribunal at Jammu, assailing the second remand
order of 24-7-2001 of the Appellate Authority. That however the
learned Special Tribunal vide order dated 4.2.2003 dismissed the
revision while agreeing with the order dated 24-7-2001 of the
Appellate Authority (respondent No. 3). It has remained the further
stand of the petitioners that thereafter the legal heirs of Shri.
Rajkumar Jai Chand assailed the order dated 22-2-2001 of the
Tehsildar concerned, maintaining the rejection of the resumption
application before the Appellate Authority, i.e., respondent No. 3,
which despite the pendency of the transfer application before
respondent No. 2, disposed of the appeal in a biased manner vide
order dated 25-05-2004, impugned in the petition before this court.
That subsequently the challenge to the earlier impugned order
of respondent No. 3 dated 25-05-2004 before respondent No. 2, i.e.,
Special Tribunal at Jammu, also failed through the second
impugned order dated 23-7-2020.
10. The petitioners have thrown challenge to the impugned order dated
23-7-2020 of the respondent No. 2 mainly on the ground that the
result of the writ petition No. 904-2010 pending before this court
was not awaited; that the adjudication of the issue of the
resumption, despite being kept open by all the authorities, there was
no justification for directing the attestation of mutation under
Section 7 of the Agrarian Act in favour of the private respondents
with the direction for handing over the possession of the subject
land to them, being illegal and unwarranted; that the respondent No.
4, i.e. Tehsildar concerned, twice rejected the resumption
application/form of the ancestor of private respondents as being hit
by the essential requirements laid down under Section 7 of the
Agrarian Act, and the issue, despite being directed to be relooked as
per the remand orders, was not awaited, and the final impugned
order dated 23-7-2020 came to be passed by the learned Special
Tribunal by directing the attestation of the mutation and the handing
over of the possession of the subject land to the private respondents,
even with availing help of law enforcement agencies.
11. As hereinbefore mentioned, the contesting private respondents
resisted the instant writ petition on the main grounds inter alia, that
no substantial question of law or public importance being the sine
qua non for invoking the revisional jurisdiction of the Jammu
Special Tribunal as envisaged under the then position of law, under
Section 21 (2) of Agrarian Act was involved in the matter; that the
ancestor of the private respondent, Shri Rajkumar Jai Chand, had
mentioned the old Khasra numbers of the estate at Top Sherkhania
and had not left the subject land as alleged; that the ancestor of
petitioners has all along admitted his position as a tenant of the
subject land; that in terms of provisions of Section 32 of the
Agrarian Act, the legislation has an overriding effect on all other
laws and, therefore, no plea could have been undertaken under
BLEAA during the proceedings under Agrarian Act; that Rajkumar
Jai Chand was not an income taxpayer and no land has been
transferred by him after the year 1971.
12. What of essence emerges from the alleged factual aspects of the
case is that the issue of resumption already decided by the Tehsildar
concerned by rejecting the claim for the same was not revisited and
given a relook upon the remand orders dated 07-08-1997 and 24-072001 of the learned Appellate Authority i.e. respondent No. 3.
The respondent No. 3, i.e. the Appellate Authority, vide
impugned order dated 25-05-2004, makes an observation to the
effect of resolution of disputed questions by the learned Special
Tribunal at page 5 of the judgment. The said Para is reproduced for
ready reference:―Keeping in view the order of the Special Tribunal
reproduced above, the first question is solved by the Spl.
Tribunal that R.K Jai chand was not an income tax payee.
Second question is also solved by the same order of Spl.
Tribunal that Balbhader Chand had a separate family and
his income cannot be taken into account in the instant case.
Regarding third question, the right of resuming the land
granted by the statue accrued to R.K Jai Chand on the date
of filing the resumption application.‖
However, a perusal of order dated 4-2-003 of the learned
Special Tribunal (respondent No. 2), inter alia, reads that, “further,
it is mandatory that the mutation under Section 8 should be attested
after decision of the resumption application under Section 7, but it
is on record that while resumption application was pending,
mutation under Section 8 was attested in this case”.
13. The petitioners have also pleaded in the instant writ petition that
respondent No. 3 allowed the appeal through impugned order dated
25-5-2004 without deciding the question of limitation, as the appeal
was grossly time-barred.
14. The contention of the contesting private respondents that their
ancestor Rajkumar Jai Chand selected the subject land also in his
unit of 182 kanals by mentioning the old khasra numbers, does not
sound well, because had the same been done, the subject land would
have been covered under the mutation already affected in terms of
the provision of section 4 of the BLEAA.
Section 7 of the Agrarian Act, which lays down the law
regarding ―the Resumption for bonafide personal cultivation‖ by exlandlord, prescribes various prerequisite qualifications and the issue
of resumption does not seem to have been properly addressed by the
authorities. Vide orders dated 7-8-1997 and 24-7-2001, the
appellate authority remanded the matter for fresh enquiry in respect
of entitlement of resumption. The order dated 22-2-2001 passed by
the Tehsildar concerned is alleged by private contesting respondents
as predated. The impugned orders have conspicuously deliberated
upon the orders dated 24.11.1981 and 22-2-2001 purported to have
been passed by the Tehsildar concerned while rejecting the
resumption application/form. The copies of the said orders are not
also placed on the record file. It is reiterated that the issue of
resumption needs to be properly adjudicated upon, in the light of
law regulating the said issue. The court has gone through the case
law relied upon by both the sides.
The impugned orders seem to be suffering from arbitrariness.
Principles of natural justice do not seem to have been observed in
spirit
by
the
authorities
while
dealing
with
the
rival
claims/contentions.
The matter needs to be revisited on the facto legal basis while
keeping in mind the basic objects of Agrarian Act providing for
transfer of land to tillers and right for Resumption under some
justified circumstances.
The Agrarian Act was passed to transfer land ownership to
actual cultivators, abolish absentee landlordism, set strict ceilings
on land holdings, and ensure better, more productive utilization of
agricultural land in the erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir.
Under the scheme of Agrarian Act, Resumption is not an
absolute right; it is bound by severe conditions to ensure that
provision is not exploited to evict tillers unfairly.
15. For the foregoing discussion, the court in exercise of its
extraordinary writ jurisdiction vested in it under the provisions of
Article 226 of the Constitution of India is of the opinion that it may
meet the ends of justice in case the impugned orders dated 25-52004 and 23-7-2020 respectively passed by respondent No. 3 and 2
are set aside and the matter is remanded back to the respondent No.
3, i.e. the Appellate Authority, (Financial Commissioner with
powers of Agrarian Commissioner at Jammu), for fresh adjudication
of the appeal bearing file number 304 instituted on 16-10-2001
titled ―Kanta Kumari and another versus Ram Lal and others”, in
accordance with the law and the observations made by this court
after hearing the learned counsel for both the parties in detail. The
learned appellate authority shall bring on record the legal heirs of
the deceased parties, if any, on both the sides upon due verification.
It is also felt to meet the ends of justice in case pending fresh
adjudication of the appeal by respondent No. 3 as hereinbefore
opined; status quo is directed to be maintained with respect to the
subject land.
16. It is accordingly ordered.
17. The parties shall appear before the Court of respondent No. 3 at
Jammu on 10th of September, 2026.
18. The scanned record from the learned authorities below shall be sent
back along with copies of this order.
19. Disposed of.
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
Srinagar:
14.08.2026.
“Ayaz‖
Jt. Registrar/Secretary
i)
ii)
Whether approved for reporting.
Whether the judgment/order is speaking.
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review