Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. A. No. 07 of 2016
Sunil Rai,
Son of Late Hari Rai,
Resident of Sanchari Bazar,
Ward No. 1, Jhapa,
Nepal.
… Revisionist
versus
State of Sikkim
… Respondent
Appeal under Section 374 (2) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973.
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. S.S. Hamal and Ms. Dechen Bhutia, Advocates
for the Appellant.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Additional Public Prosecutor with
Mr. Santosh Kr. Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Assistant
Public Prosecutors for the State.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
JUDGMENT
(26.09.2016)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The instant Appeal, filed under Section 374 (2) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “Cr. P.C.”), is
directed against the conviction and sentence vide judgment
dated 29.12.2014, whereunder and whereby the appellant was
held guilty of offences committed under Sections 489-B and
489-C of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) and
sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 5
(five) years and to pay a fine of Rs.5000/- under Section 489-B
IPC and further to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of
2 (two) years under Section 489-C IPC. In default to make the
payment of fine, he was further directed to undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of 2 (two) months.
2.
Provenance of the case leading to the trial and
conviction of the appellant/convict as aforestated is that the
appellant/convict went to the shop of one Riwan Muslim at
Nayabazar, Gyalshing to purchase recharge voucher for his
mobile phone at around 1630 hrs. on 31.07.2013. He tendered
a currency note of Rs.500/-, which was noticed by the shop
owner as fake. Thereafter, the appellant replaced the same by
another note which was found to be genuine. On 01.08.2013,
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
he was found at a tea stall of one Binod Bihari.
The
complainant tried to enquire about the currency note. Initially
the appellant/convict informed that he came from Chamgoan,
Namchi.
However, on further enquiry, the appellant/convict
disclosed his correct name as Sunil Rai and ran away from the
shop. He was caught and handed over to the Gyalshing Police
Outpost.
Immediately some officials of Union Bank of India
were brought to examine 6 notes of Rs.500/- denomination
found in his possession.
The Bank officials reported that the
said notes were counterfeit. An FIR was accordingly lodged on
01.08.2013 with Gyalshing Police Station under Sections 489-B
and 489-C/34 IPC vide FIR No. 40/2013.
Thereafter, the
police initiated investigation and raided the room No. 102 of
Hotel
Attri
on
01.08.2013
at
10.30
appellant/convict was allegedly staying.
AM
wherein
the
On search, one black
purse containing 2 notes of Rs.1000/-, 6 notes of Rs.500/denominations were sized from him and further 98 counterfeit
notes of Rs.500/- denomination were also seized from the room.
A personal body search was made, wherein one more fake
currency note of Rs.500/- was seized. Reception entry register
was also seized.
The appellant/convict in his statement
submitted that he was a resident of Birtamore, Sanchari Bazar,
Ward No. 1, Zilla Jhapa, East Nepal.
He was visiting Sikkim
frequently to meet his girlfriend Roma Rai, resident of Melli,
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Tathang, West Sikkim.
According to the appellant, on the
evening of 29.07.2013 he boarded a bus for Kakarivitta from
Jhapa bus stand to meet his girlfriend at Khetchupari, West
Sikkim. On 30.07.2013, he arrived at Kakarivitta and met one
Suresh Bengali for exchange of Rs.88,000/- Nepal Currency
(NC) notes to Rs.55,000/- Indian Currency (IC) notes.
It was
further revealed that on 31.07.2013 the appellant/convict
reached Siliguri from Kakarvitta, wherefrom he boarded a bus
for
Pelling
and
reached
Gyalshing
and
tried
to
go
to
Khetchupari, however, not finding a vehicle, he stayed in Hotel
Attri.
The appellant/convict was charged for committing an
offence of using counterfeit currency-notes under Section 489-B
IPC on 31.07.2013 at around 1630 hrs and being in possession
of counterfeit currency-notes on 31.07.2013 at around 1630 hrs
under Section 489-C IPC.
Needless to state herein that no
charges were framed in respect of discovery of currency-notes
from room No. 102 of Hotel Attri on 01.08.2013, as allegedly
the
appellant
was
31.07/01.08.2013.
staying
in
the
said
room
on
Tea shop owner namely, Binod Kr. Prasad
(PW-2), mobile shop owner, Riwan-Ul-Haque (PW-3), Phur
Tshering Lepcha (PW-4), an employee of Union Bank of India,
who identified the notes, Ms. Joshna Chettri (PW-5), Assistant
Manager, Hotel Attri, Dy. S.P. K.B. Gadaily, OC/CID (PW-6),
Ram Bdr. Subba (PW-7), witness of seizure memos and other
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
police officers were examined. Entry into hotel room as per the
reception register is 31.07.2013 that indicates departure date
on 31.07.2013 itself. The Receptionist in her first examinationin-chief submitted that the appellant/convict was admitted to
the hotel on 01.08.2013 at around 05.30 pm and left the room
on the following date.
Subsequently, when the matter was
remitted back for examination of entry reception register, which
was not examined despite having been seized in the trial, it was
stated by her that the appellant/convict came to the hotel Attri
on 31.07.2013 and was allotted room No. 102 and stayed
overnight.
The police searched the room and seized the hotel
entry reception register from her possession.
3.
The trial Court after having examined all the aspects
of the matter, came to the conclusion that the two currencynotes of Rs.1000/- denomination and 105 currency-notes of
Rs.500/- found in his possession as well as in the room were
counterfeit.
It was further held by the Court below that the
appellant/convict had full knowledge about the nature of the
currency-notes, which were fake and had full intention to use
the same.
The appellant was, accordingly, convicted and
sentenced as aforestated.
4.
Mr. S.S. Hamal, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant/convict would submit that the prosecution has failed
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
to establish a case beyond reasonable doubt. It is further urged
that on having come to know that the appellant/convict was
given Indian Currency-notes of a sum of Rs.55,000/- in
exchange of Rs.88,000/- Nepal Currency-notes, by one Suresh
Bengali, no attempt was made on the part of the prosecution to
examine the said Suresh Bengali.
It is further contended that
learned trial Court has held that the appellant/convict knew that
the currency-notes in his possession were counterfeit without
there being any cogent and credible evidence.
The prosecution
has failed to establish that the appellant/convict had given a
fake note of Rs.500/- with the intention to use the same as the
said note was fake, the appellant/convict has immediately given
the other note for mobile charging, which was found to be
genuine.
The appellant/convict was formally arrested on
01.08.2013 and a total 104 notes of Rs.500/- denomination and
2 notes of Rs.1000/- denomination were seized from the hotel
room, wherein the seizure memo indicates seizure of total 105
notes, and it is a substantial discrepancy. It was alleged that 76
nos.
of
Spasmoproxyvon
capsules
were
seized
from
the
possession of the appellant, but the same was never examined
and proved by the prosecution during the trial.
It is also not
proved that the appellant was the occupant of room No. 102 at
the time when search and seizure of said notes were made by
the police.
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
5.
Per contra, supporting the conviction and sentence,
Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Additional Public Prosecutor, would
contend that possession of aforestated counterfeit currencynotes and also attempt to use the same would establish that the
appellant knew the nature of the notes and had full knowledge
and intention to use the same. Small discrepancies in respect of
entry into hotel are not fatal to the case of the prosecution.
6.
pleadings,
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the
examined
the
depositions
and
other
relevant
documents annexed hereto.
7.
In the course of arguments, it was stated that the
entry reception register of the hotel, which was seized during
the search was not produced and examined by the trial Court.
Accordingly, on the application made by Mr. Sonam Tenzing
Bhutia, Sr. Supdt. of Police/CID, Sikkim Police on 08.06.2016,
this Court vide order dated 14.06.2016 directed the trial Court
to examine the hotel entry register seized at the time of search
and submit the report.
The witnesses were re-examined and
cross-examined by the trial Court and immediately submitted its
report accordingly by an order dated 29.07.2016.
8.
On re-examination, it is fully established that the
appellant/convict had taken entry into the hotel on 31.07.2013
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
and stayed overnight in room No. 102, wherein the police seized
counterfeit currency-notes.
The appellant/convict could not
explain the presence of such notes in his room, thus, there was
no error in holding that the said fake notes found in the room
were in possession of the appellant/convict.
The receptionist
has clearly stated in her earlier as well as subsequent statement
in respect of entry of appellant/convict in hotel on 31.07.2013
for overnight stay. A mere mistake in the entry register, which
was on perusal, found that there were mistakes in other entries
also, cannot be held as fatal to the case of the prosecution. All
the witnesses examined by the prosecution, in whose presence
the said currency-notes were seized, were consistent and there
was no discrepancy.
The bank officials, shopkeeper etc. were
also consistent in their deposition in respect of the possession of
such currency-notes by the appellant and also an attempt was
made by him to use the same while purchasing the mobile
recharge.
9.
The question as to whether non-framing of charges
in respect of recovery of counterfeit currency-notes from the
room in occupation of the appellant can defeat the case of the
prosecution, particularly when the accused was given full
opportunity to explain the possession of fake currency-notes in
the room.
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
10.
The issue of non-framing of relevant charges came
up for consideration in Gurpreet Singh vs. State of Punjab1,
the Supreme Court held as under: “16. In the present case, it cannot be said that the
accused persons were prejudiced merely because charge
was framed under Section 302 IPC simpliciter and no
charge was framed under Section 302 read with Section
34 IPC. From the evidence of two eyewitnesses, namely,
PWs 2 and 3 it would appear that the accused persons
shared the common intention to cause death of the
victim. They were cross-examined at length from all
possible angles and from the suggestions that were put
forth to the eyewitnesses, we are fully satisfied that the
accused persons were not in any manner prejudiced in
their defence. That apart, in their examination under
Section 313 of the Code, the appellants were specifically
told that they along with the other accused persons
armed with kirpan came to the place of occurrence and
assaulted the deceased whereafter they fled away which
shows that the appellants shared the common intention
to cause death of the deceased.”
11.
In Sanichar
Sahni
vs.
State
of
Bihar2, the
Supreme Court held as under: “25. A Constitution Bench of this Court in Willie
(William) Slaney v. State of M.P. : AIR 1956 SC 116
considered the issue of non-framing of charges properly
and conviction of an accused for the offences for which
he has not been charged and reached the conclusion as
under:
“86. … In such a situation, the absence of
a charge under one or other of the various heads
of criminal liability for the offence cannot be said
to be fatal by itself, and before a conviction for
the substantive offence, without a charge, can be
set aside, prejudice will have to be made out. …
87.
… If it is so grave that prejudice will
necessarily be implied or imported, it may be
described as an illegality. If the seriousness of the
----------------------------1 (2005) 12 SCC 615
2 (2009) 7 SCC 198
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
omission is of a lesser degree, it will be an
irregularity and prejudice by way of failure of
justice will have to be established.”
26.
This Court in Gurpreet Singh v. State of Punjab :
(2005) 12 SCC 615 referred to and relied upon its earlier
judgments in Willie (William) Slaney and State of A.P. v.
Thakkidiram Reddy : (1998) 6 SCC 554 and held that
unless there is failure of justice and thereby the cause of
the accused has been prejudiced, no interference is
required if the conviction can be upheld on the evidence
led against the accused. The Court should not interfere
unless it is established that the accused persons were in
any way prejudiced due to the errors and omissions in
framing the charges against him. A similar view has
been reiterated by this Court in Ramji Singh v. State of
Bihar : (2001) 9 SCC 528.
27.
Therefore, the law on the issue can be
summarized to the effect that unless the convict is able
to establish that defect in framing the charges has
caused real prejudice to him and that the was not
informed as to what was the real case against him and
that he could not defend himself properly, no
interference is required on mere technicalities.
Conviction order in fact is to be tested on the touchstone
of prejudice theory.
12.
In the facts of the case, the appellant/convict was
given full opportunity and had full knowledge about the
allegation of possession of fake currency-notes, which was
seized from the hotel room wherein he stayed.
Thus, non-
framing of charge cannot be held as fatal to the case of the
prosecution as the appellant/convict was not prejudiced for nonframing of charge in respect of seizure of fake currency-notes
from the room.
13.
judicial
Mr. S.S. Hamal, learned counsel, referring to a
pronouncement
laid
by
the
Supreme
Court
in
Umashanker vs. State of Chhattisgarh3, would contend that
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
mere possession of fake currency note is not enough to
prosecute the accused unless it is proved that the accused had
full knowledge of the nature of the notes and has an intention to
use the same. The Supreme Court, while examining the ambit
and scope of provisions of Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC, held
as under: “8.
A perusal of the provisions, extracted above,
shows that mens rea of offences under Section 489-B
and 489-C is, “knowing or having reason to believe the
currency-notes or bank-notes are forged or counterfeit”.
Without the afore-mentioned mens rea selling, buying or
receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in
or using as genuine forged or counterfeit currency-notes
or bank-notes is not enough to constitute offence under
Section 489-B of I.P.C. So also possessing or even
intending to use any forged or counterfeit currencynotes or bank-notes is not sufficient to make out a case
under Section 489-C in the absence of the mens rea,
noted above. No material is brought on record by the
prosecution to show that the appellant had the requisite
mens rea. The High Court, however, completely missed
this aspect. The learned trial Judge on the basis of the
evidence of PW 2, PW 4 and PW 7 that they were able to
make out that currency note alleged to have been given
to PW 4, was fake “presumed” such a mens rea. On the
date of the incident the appellant was said to be 18
years old student. On the facts of this case the
presumption drawn by the trial Court is not warranted
under section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not
shown that any specific question with regard to the
currency-notes being fake or counterfeit was put to the
appellant in his examination under Section 313 of
Criminal Procedure Code. On these facts we have no
option but to hold that the charges framed under
Sections 489-B and 489-C are not proved. We,
therefore, set aside the conviction and sentence passed
on the appellant under Sections 489-B and 489-C of
I.P.C. and acquit him of the said charges [See : M.
Mammutti v. State of Karnataka : AIR 1979 SC 1705.”
-------------------------3 AIR 2001 SC 3074
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
14.
Further reliance was made by Mr. Hamal on a
decision rendered by the Bombay High Court in Mohd.
Farooque
Yusuf
Chaiwala
&
Others
vs.
State
of
Maharashtra4, wherein a Division Bench of the Bombay High
Court held as under: “28. Thus, to bring home the charge of offences
punishable under Sections 489B and 489C of the IPC the
prosecution is required to establish, inter alia, that the
accused knew (or had reason to believe) the notes in
question to be counterfeit or forged. The prosecution is
also required to establish that the accused intended to
use the same as genuine. It is true that such knowledge
or existence of reason to believe, can be proved by, or
can be inferred, only from circumstantial evidence. In
this case, the prosecution has not been able to point out
the evidence or circumstances showing that each of the
Appellants had knowledge that the notes were
counterfeit or that each of them wanted to use the same
as genuine. If there were any such circumstances
appearing in the evidence of the prosecution, such
circumstances should have been put to the Appellants
during their examination under Section 313 of the Code.
No such circumstances were put to any of the Appellants
by the trial Court, presumably because the trial Court
did not consider this aspect of the matter. In fact, the
trial Court also did not put the report received from the
India Security Press, Nasik to any of the Appellants in
their examination under Section 313 of the Code. Such
circumstances, namely viz. evidence showing that the
notes in question were counterfeit and the evidence and
circumstances suggesting that the accused knew the
same should have been put to the Appellants. The
Appellants were therefore not given an opportunity to
offer any explanation about these aspects, which were
held as ‘proved’ against them, by the trial Court.”
15.
In Panna Lal Gupta vs. State of Sikkim5, relied on
by Mr. Hamal, a Division Bench of this Court held that it is for
------------------------------4 2011 (3) Crimes 307 (Bom.)
5 2010 Crl. L.J. 825
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
the prosecution to establish that the appellant possess fake
currency-notes knowingly or having reason to believe the same
to be forged or counterfeit to attract conviction under the
provisions of Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC.
The relevant
paragraphs read as under: “21. In view of the above circumstances, the possibility
of the fake currency-notes having been given to him by
the customers in the course of his business and he being
a layman could not suspect the said currency-notes to
be fake cannot be ruled out. It is hardly necessary to
observe that mere possession of forged note is not an
offence. The offence is directed against trafficking in
fake notes and what is essential is that apart from
possessing the fake notes, the appellant must know of
its falsity and having known uses them. The appellant
must have known or at least must have had reason to
believe that the notes were counterfeited. It is also the
requirement of law that the possession must be
accompanied by intention to use that as genuine.
Nothing has been brought on record by way of even
collateral circumstances to show that the appellant had
intention to use the fake notes as genuine. On the other
hand, as already noted above, it cannot be said on the
basis of the materials on record that the appellant knew
or had reason to believe that the currency-notes he was
dealing with were counterfeited and issued such notes
as genuine.
22.
Under the circumstances, we have no hesitation
to hold that the appellant did not possess those
currency-notes knowingly or having reason to believe
the same to be forged and counterfeit and trafficked
such notes as genuine. In view of this, we are of the
firm opinion to hold that the prosecution has failed to
prove its case against the appellant under Sections 489B and 489-C of the IPC beyond reasonable doubt.
Accordingly, in our opinion, the impugned conviction and
sentence call for interference of this Court.”
16.
Referring and relying on a decision of the Supreme
Court in Hiralal Pandey and Others vs. State of Uttar
Pradesh6, Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor
----------------------------6
(2012) 5 SCC 216
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
would contend that the conviction cannot be set aside on the
ground of every irregularity or illegality in the matter of
investigation, unless the lapses on the part of the investigation
are such as to cast reasonable doubt about the prosecution
story or seriously prejudice the defence of the accused.
17.
clinchingly
As
discussed
established
hereinabove,
that
the
the
prosecution
appellant/convict
was
has
in
possession of fake currency-notes, in total, 2 notes of Rs.1000/and 104 notes of Rs.500/- denominations (IC).
18.
It is a well settled principle of law as eloquent from
the preceding paragraphs that to constitute an offence under
the provisions of Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC, there are three
essential ingredients. Firstly, the accused must be in possession
of any forged or counterfeit currency-note or bank-note;
secondly, having knowledge or having reason to believe the
same are forged or counterfeit and thirdly have an intention to
use the same as genuine.
The first ingredient of having
possession of fake currency-notes is well established as six
Rs.500/- denomination IC notes were discovered from his body
(person), two Rs.1000/- denomination IC note from his purse
and remaining 98 currency-notes (IC) from the room which was
under his occupation. The appellant/convict had full knowledge
about the nature of fake currency notes. The appellant/convict
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
has no other explanation except that he had obtained them
from one Suresh Bengali in exchange of NC notes for a sum of
Rs.88,000/-.
The third ingredient i.e. intention to use it as
genuine is also established from the credible and strong
circumstantial
evidences.
During
the
investigation,
the
appellant/convict has come up with the plea that the appellant/
convict was a resident of India, initially on being accosted by
one police officer namely Sagar Subedi. Thereafter, on further
investigation, it was revealed by him that he was a resident of
Birtamore, Sanchari Bazar, Ward No. 1, Zilla Jhapa, East Nepal.
He further stated in the statement during enquiry that he used
to come to meet his girlfriend namely, Roma Rai. Roma Rai was
produced for examination before the trial Court and the
appellant/ convict declined to examine her to establish that she
was his friend and used to come to meet her frequently.
The
purpose of coming and staying was fully shattered as no
attempt was made by the appellant/convict to explain, except
that he used to come to meet his girlfriend, who was produced
by the prosecution but not examined by the appellant/convict.
The second instance to establish that the appellant/convict had
the intention to use the said fake currency-notes as genuine is
that when the fake currency-note of Rs.500/- was returned by
the mobile shop owner, immediately he handed over another
genuine note without any discussion and on the second day on
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
being asked by the police officer about the currency-notes and
his whereabouts, he ran away.
Initially, he attempted to
mislead the police officer by saying that he was an Indian
citizen. Thirdly, he was put a specific question in the course of
his examination under the provisions of Section 313 Cr. P.C.,
the appellant/convict did not reiterate his earlier stand that he
had obtained the said fake currency-notes from one Suresh
Bengali and also did not insist on examination of said Suresh
Bengali. In all, he had given a general denial on all queries put
to him. Intention to use fake currency-notes, having knowledge
of it, was not denied.
19.
For the reasons mentioned hereinabove, it is well
established that all the three ingredients required to constitute
the offence under the said provisions of Sections 489-B and
489-C IPC have been established and the appellant/convict was
in possession of fake currency-notes, knowingly with intention
to use the same as genuine.
20.
In the aforestated circumstance, I do not find any
reason to interfere with the finding of conviction and sentence
awarded by the trial Court.
dismissed.
Resultantly, the appeal is
2016:SHC:149
Crl. A. No. 07/2016
Sunil Rai vs. State of Sikkim
21.
The Court records be remitted back forthwith to the
Court below.
Sd/-
Chief Justice
26.09.2016
jk
Approved for Reporting
: Yes/No.
Internet
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review