Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:814
Serial No. 47
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 379 of 2025
Date of Decision: 09.09.2025
Mr. Sunil Kumar Savita
S/o Shri. Nandu Lal Sharma
Commandant, 67 BN CRPF,
East Khasi Hills, Shillong, Meghalaya
:::Petitioner
-Vs1.Union of India,
Through the Secretary, Ministry of Home
Affairs, North Block, Government of India,
New Delhi – 110001
2.Director General,
Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF),
Directorate General, Block No. 1, CRPF,
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-11000
3.Inspector General, CRPF,
North East Sector, Shillong,
Meghalaya
:::Respondents.
2025:MLHC:814
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Thapa, Adv.
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. M. Myrchiang, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The petitioner who is posted as Commandant, 67BF CRPF,
Shillong, being aggrieved with the impugned transfer order dated
28.08.2025, is before this Court, assailing the same on the ground that the
transfer is premature, inasmuch as, as per the Standing Order – 05/2022
dated 27.09.2022, governing the transfer policy for Group ‘A’ Gazetted
Officers, the normal tenure of posting is 3(three) years subject to
administrative or operational which requires the transfer of an officer at
any time to a suitable place. Further, ground taken to assail the transfer, is
that though there is a preliminary inquiry regarding allegations against the
2025:MLHC:814
writ petitioner on a complaint received confidentially, the impugned order
does not disclose any administrative exigency or involvement of any public
interest, but has been issued malafide in an arbitrary manner.
2.
When the instant matter was taken up by this Court, instructions
were called for from the learned DSGI, Dr. N. Mozika, who has placed
before the Court written instructions dated 04.09.2025 and 08.09.2025. On
a perusal of the written instructions, which have been taken on record, it is
seen that the main reason attributed for the transfer, is due to instances of
inter-personal conflict between the petitioner and one Shri. Sanjeev Kumar,
the Second-in-Command of 67BN Shillong, which has come to the notice
of the DIG (Ops/Int & Trg) NES, DIG Range, Guwahati and IG NES. As
there was no improvement in the matter, and due to the extremely strained
relationship between the Commandant and Second-in-Command, it was
recommended that both officers be transferred out from 67BN, as soon as
possible. The instructions also state that the transfer has been done after
considering all the aspects of the case, where even counselling by the
Senior Officers to both of them, and exhausting all remedies to improve the
situation failed to improve the situation, and the transfer was necessary in
order to maintain good discipline and morale of the jawans of 67BN, as
well as, administrative and operational requirements of the force. In so far
as the Standing Order No. 05/2022 is concerned, it is stated that as the
2025:MLHC:814
transfer is due to administrative and operational reasons, Para – 5(b) of the
Standing Order provides for the same.
3.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Thapa,
learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the impugned transfer
suffers from serious illegalities, inasmuch as, apart from being violative of
the Standing Order is also vitiated, inasmuch as, the reasons attributed for
the transfer is not due to administrative or operational reasons, but in fact,
is punitive in nature. The learned Senior counsel has submitted that the
inter-personal conflict, is due to the fact that the Second-in-Command
suffers from mental illness and in this context, has referred to a Unit
Behavioural Report for Psychiatric Case, regarding an incident of suicidal
intention on 31.07.2025, by the Second-in-Command, Shri. Sanjeev
Kumar. It is further submitted that for the mental condition of the Secondin Command, the petitioner has been victimized and as such, the transfer is
malafide and liable to be interfered with by this Court.
4.
On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, and on consideration
of the facts and materials, it is first to be kept in mind that in matters of
transfer, the scope of judicial review is limited to examining as to whether
the transfer is visited with malafides, punitive, or in clear violation of
statutory provisions. In the instant case, the petitioner has alleged that the
Standing Order No. 05/2022 has been violated, as he has served in the
2025:MLHC:814
present station for only about 2(two) years, whereas, it has been stipulated
that normal tenure under the policy would be 3(three) years, subject to the
provisions of Para – 5(b). For the sake of convenience Clause – 5 of the
Standing Order No. 05/2022, with regard to tenure of posting is reproduced
hereinbelow.
“STANDING ORDER – 05/2022
Subject :-
Transfer policy for Group ‘A’ Gazetted Officers (GD : 2-I/C
to DIG), Engineering and Medical Officers
5.
Tenure of Posting
(a) The normal tenure of all officers under this policy will be
03 years subject to the provisions of para 5 (b) of this S.O.
(b) As CRPF is Central Armed Police Force of GoI
constituted under Special Act and is tasked with important
operational duties regarding maintenance of security of the
nation,
therefore
there
are
certain
operational
and
administrative requirements of the Force. In view of such
requirements, any officer may be posted to any Unit or office
at any point of time. The above policy does not create any
right for any officer for posting to a particular place or for a
particular tenure as mentioned in Para – 5(a).
If during the posting of any officer it comes to the notice
of the supervisory/senior authorities that officer needs to be
transferred out at any time from present place due to
2025:MLHC:814
administrative or operational reasons, then the concerned
authority may transfer such officer at any time to a suitable
place.”
5.
A perusal of Clause – 5(b) quoted above, clearly shows that for
certain operational and administrative requirements of the force, any officer
may be posted to any unit or office at any point of time. This Clause has
also underlined the fact, that the policy does not create any right for any
officer, for posting to a particular place, or for a particular tenure as
mentioned in Clause – 5(a), quoted above. As such, the Standing Order
does not cloak the writ petitioner with any legally enforceable right, on the
ground that he has not completed the normal tenure of posting.
6.
On the other aspect that is the reason for the transfer as observed
hereinabove, from the written instructions, the same was due to interpersonal conflicts between the petitioner and the Second-in-Command
which could not be resolved, and the transfer was necessitated in the said
circumstances in the interest of the force. Though, efforts have been made
by the petitioner to show that he is blameless in this episode, and that the
dispute or conflict was due to the mental condition of the Second-inCommand, who has also been transferred, this Court will not venture to
further examine the matter, on the contentions of the petitioner, but
observes that, no case of the transfer being visited by malafides, or that the
2025:MLHC:814
same is punitive in nature or prejudicial to public interest has been made
out. The matter regarding the preliminary enquiry, not being central to the
issue, also does not warrant any deliberation on its legality or illegality.
7.
In the context of the instant case, reference can be made to the recent
judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Pubi Lombi vs. State of
Arunachal Pradesh & Ors. reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 279,
wherein in Paragraphs – 9 to 14, reproduced hereinbelow, various
judgments on the law governing transfers have been illustrated.
“9. In the case of Union of India v. S.L. Abbas, (1993) 4 SCC 357, it
is clearly observed by this Court that the scope of judicial review is
only available when there is a clear violation of statutory provision
or the transfer is persuaded by malafide, non-observation of
executive instructions does not confer a legally enforceable right to
an employee holding a transferable post. The relevant paragraph
reads as under:
“7. Who should be transferred where, is a matter for the
appropriate authority to decide. Unless the order of transfer is
vitiated by mala fides or is made in violation of any statutory
provisions, the court cannot interfere with it. While ordering
the transfer, there is no doubt, the authority must keep in mind
the guidelines issued by the Government on the subject……..”
10. Further, following the footsteps of S.L. Abbas (supra) this Court
in the case of Union of India v. N.P. Thomas, 1993 Supp (1) SCC
704 held that the interference by the Court in an order of transfer on
the instance of an employee holding a transferrable post without any
violation of statutory provision is not permissible.
2025:MLHC:814
11. This Court further curtailed the scope of judicial review in the
case of N.K. Singh v. Union of India, (1994) 6 SCC 98 holding that
the person challenging the transfer ought to prove on facts that such
transfer is prejudicial to public interest. It was further reiterated that
interference is only justified in a case of malafide or infraction of any
professed norm or principle. Moreover, in the cases where the career
prospects of a person challenging transfer remain unaffected and no
detriment is caused, interference to the transfer must be eschewed. It
is further held that the evidence requires to prove such transfer is
prejudicial and in absence thereof interference is not warranted. The
law reiterated by this Court is reproduced, in following words:—
“9. Transfer of a public servant from a significant post can be
prejudicial to public interest only if the transfer was avoidable
and the successor is not suitable for the post. Suitability is a
matter for objective assessment by the hierarchical superiors
in administration. To introduce and rely on the element of
prejudice to public interest as a vitiating factor of the transfer
of a public servant, it must be first pleaded and proved that the
replacement was by a person not suitable for the important
post and the transfer was avoidable. Unless this is pleaded and
proved at the threshold, no further inquiry into this aspect is
necessary and its absence is sufficient to exclude this factor
from consideration as a vitiating element in the impugned
transfer. Accordingly, this aspect requires consideration at the
outset.
XXX
XXX
XXX
“23. …….Unless the decision is vitiated by mala fides or
infraction of any professed norm or principle governing the
transfer, which alone can be scrutinised judicially, there are no
judicially manageable standards for scrutinising all transfers
and the courts lack the necessary expertise for personnel
management of all government departments. This must be left,
in public interest, to the departmental heads subject to the
limited judicial scrutiny indicated.”
2025:MLHC:814
“24. …Challenge in courts of a transfer when the career
prospects remain unaffected and there is no detriment to the
government servant must be eschewed and interference by
courts should be rare, only when a judicially manageable and
permissible ground is made out. This litigation was illadvised.”
12. The issue involved in the present case is somewhat similar in the
case of Mohd. Masood Ahmad v. State of U.P., (2007) 8 SCC
150 wherein this Court in paragraph 8 has observed as thus:—
“8. ….. In our opinion, even if the allegation of the appellant is
correct that he was transferred on the recommendation of an
MLA, that by itself would not vitiate the transfer order. After
all, it is the duty of the representatives of the people in the
legislature to express the grievances of the people and if there
is any complaint against an official the State Government is
certainly within its jurisdiction to transfer such an
employee……”
13. It is not tangential to mention that this Court in the case of State
of Punjab v. Joginder Singh Dhatt, (1990) 2 SCC 661 : AIR 1993 SC
2486 observed as thus:—
“3……..It is entirely for the employer to decide when, where
and at what point of time a public servant is transferred from
his present posting………”
14. It is also imperative to refer the judgment of this Court in the case
of Ratnagiri Gas and Power Private Limited v. RDS Projects
Limited, (2013) 1 SCC 524 where it reiterated one of the pertinent
principles of administrative law is that when allegations of malafide
are made, the persons against whom the same are levelled need to be
impleaded as parties to the proceedings to enable them to answer.
The relevant excerpt is reproduced as thus:
2025:MLHC:814
“27. There is yet another aspect which cannot be ignored. As
and when allegations of mala fides are made, the persons
against whom the same are levelled need to be impleaded as
parties to the proceedings to enable them to answer the charge.
In the absence of the person concerned as a party in his/her
individual capacity it will neither be fair nor proper to record
a finding that malice in fact had vitiated the action taken by the
authority concerned……..”
8.
As such, in view of the findings and discussions made hereinabove,
no case is made out for any interference with the impugned transfer order
and the writ petition is accordingly dismissed, however, with no order as to
costs.
Chief Justice (Acting)
Meghalaya
09.09.2025
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2025.09.09 16:40:26 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review