Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra-ordinary Jurisdiction)
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Limited
Plot No. 107-108, Namli Block,
P.O. Ranipool, East Sikkim,
Sikkim-737135
…
Petitioner
Versus
1.
Union of India
Through the Secretary,
Department of Revenue,
Ministry of Finance,
North Block, New Delhhi-110001
2.
The Assistant Commissioner, Gangtok Division,
Siliguri CGST and CX Commissionerate
Indira By-Pass Road, Near District Court,
Sichey, East Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101
3.
The Joint Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise
Siliguri CGST and Central Excise (Appeal) Commissionerate,
Central Revenue Building, 4th Floor,
Haren Mukherjee Road, Hakimpara,
Siliguri-734001
4.
The Commissioner,
CGST and Central Excise,
Siliguri Commissionerate
Central Revenue Building, 4th Floor,
Haren Mukherjee Road, Hakimpara,
Siliguri-734001
…
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Rahul Tangri, Ms. Gita Bista and Mr. Vivek Jain,
Advocates.
For the respondents :
Mr. B.K. Gupta, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
19.11.2020
Date of judgment
:
19.11.2020
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
( Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ )
Heard Mr. Rahul Tangri, learned Counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. B.K. Gupta, learned Counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.
The petitioner is a Private Limited Company engaged in the supply
of patented and propriety medicines falling under Chapter 29 and 30 of the
Customs Tariff Act, 1975, made applicable to the supplies made under the
Central Goods and Services Act, 2017 (for short, the CGST Act). It has two
Units in the State of Sikkim, one of which is located at Nandok Block and
the other at Namli Block, which will, hereinafter be referred to as Unit-I and
Unit-II, respectively. Both the Units are registered under General Sales Tax
Index (GSTI) vide GSTI number.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that during the month of August,
2017 two consignments of pine bark extract and Crospovidone NF were
transferred by the petitioner from Unit-II to Unit-I. As the transfer did not
qualify as supply in terms of Section 7 of the CGST Act, such transfer ought
to have been effected under the cover of a delivery challan but,
inadvertently two invoices bearing No. S 11725000335 dated 14.08.2017
and S 11725000354 dated 17.08.2017 came to be issued. Having realized
the mistake, the transfers were not declared as “outward supply” in the
Form GSTR-01 for the month of August, 2017. However, at the time of
filing of the GSTR-3B return for the month in question, the petitioner
inadvertently took these two invoices into consideration and discharged
GST amounting to Rs.15,82,938.72 and Rs.1,659.42, respectively, totalling
Rs.15,84,598/-. Subsequently, the petitioner filed an online application
dated 01.12.2018 in Form GST RFD-01A under Section 54 of the CGST Act
seeking refund of such amount. The acknowledgment copy along with all
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
annexures including a copy of the certificate of Chartered Accountant
certifying that the petitioner had not passed incidence of tax to any other
person was physically delivered before respondent no.2 on 04.12.2018.
Respondent no.2, thereafter issued a Show Cause Notice (for short, SCN)
dated 08.03.2019 for rejection of application for refund in Form GSTRFD-08
with reference to Rule 92(3) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules,
2017 (for short, the CGST Rules), asking the petitioner to show cause
within 15 days from the date of receipt of notice with further direction to
appear before the Assistant Commissioner of Gangtok Division, Siliguri GST
Commissionerate on 27.03.2019, indicating therein that in case the
petitioner failed to furnish the reply or failed to appear as stipulated, the
case would be decided ex-parte on the basis of available records on merit.
4.
The petitioner submitted reply dated 27.03.2019 to the SCN for
rejection of application for refund and had requested for processing the
refund claim on the basis of clarification and reply furnished by sanctioning
the amount in cash or by sanctioning direct credit in the Input Tax Credit
(for short, ITC) credit ledger on portal of the amounts in question in their
respective heads of GST Taxes. Representative of the petitioner also
appeared for personal hearing in terms of SCN and thereafter, respondent
no.2 passed an order dated 01.04.2019/02.04.2019 in Form – GST-RFD-06
under Rule 92(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 read with Section 54 and Section
56 of the CGST Act rejecting the prayer holding that there was no provision
under GST Act and GST Rules for refund of excess payment of tax, if
payment was made through ITC.
5.
An appeal was preferred by the petitioner before the Commissioner
(Appeals), CGST and Central Excise, Siliguri on 01.07.2019, who passed an
order dated 11.09.2019 holding that the ground of rejection of the refund
claim in the impugned order was erroneous. However, after an examination
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
as to whether or not any excess payment of tax had actually occurred in
the case, rejected the appeal by holding that there is no requirement of
refund.
6.
Therefore, recourse is taken to redress the grievance of the
petitioner by filing this writ petition before this Court, as no Goods and
Services Tax Appellate Tribunal had been constituted to entertain an appeal
under Section 112 of the CGST Act.
7.
Mr. Rahul Tangri, learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that
the impugned order dated 11.09.2019 that travelled beyond the grounds
cited in the SCN dated 08.03.2019, and therefore, the impugned order is
violative of principles of natural justice. It is submitted by him that once
the reason for rejection of the prayer for refund was found to be erroneous,
the appeal of the petitioner ought to have been allowed. It is submitted
that the findings recorded by the Appellate Authority that the petitioner had
rectified the error committed in payment of tax in GSTR-3B for the month
of August, 2017 in the GSTR-1 of the respective month and that the
petitioner had carried forward the excess amount of tax to the next
month’s return to be offset against the output tax liability of that month are
perverse. It is submitted that an analysis and scrutiny of GSTR-1, GSTR2A and GSTR-3B of the petitioner for the month of September, 2017 would
demonstrate that there was no adjustment of tax paid in excess in the
month of August, 2017 against GST liability for the month of September,
2017, in any form. Mr. Tangri submits that though in the normal course,
GSTR-1 was required to be filed before GSTR-3B, filing of GSTR-1 was
deferred by the authorities and the petitioner and all others falling under
GST Act was required to submit GSTR-3B before filing GSTR-1. He has
submitted that
reliance placed on the Circular No. 7/7/2017-GST dated
01.09.2017 issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs (presently
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
known as Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs), which was issued
to address the difficulties faced by the assesses regarding the system
based
reconciliation
of
forms
GSTR-1,
GSTR-2
and
GSTR-3B,
was
suspended by Circular No. 26/26/2017-GST dated 29.12.2017 indicating
therein
that
system
based
Circular
dated
01.09.2017
can
be
operationalized only after the relevant notification is issued, which,
however, has not been issued till date. He submits that it was also laid
down in the said Circular dated 29.12.2017 that excess amount of tax paid
in a month by mistake may be adjusted in returns in Form GSTR-3B of
subsequent months and in cases where such adjustment is not feasible,
refund can be claimed. He has submitted that the Circulars issued by the
Board are binding on the Department and that the petitioner had fulfilled all
the conditions precedent in terms of Section 54 of CGST Act and CGST
Rules to obtain refund or tax paid in excess. Learned counsel submits that
in the circumstances of the case, tax paid inadvertently by the petitioner
has been appropriated and retained by the department without any
authority of law.
8.
Mr. Tangri has strenuously urged that the petitioner had not
adjusted the excess tax amount paid and therefore, this Court may pass
appropriate orders directing the respondents to refund the tax along with
interest as envisaged under Section 56 of the CGST Act.
9.
Mr. B.K. Gupta, learned counsel for the respondents, abiding by the
stand taken in the affidavit filed on behalf of respondent nos. 1 to 4,
supports the impugned order dated 11.09.2019 and contends that order
dated 11.09.2019 is not beyond the scope of SCN dated 08.03.2019 as it
was noted therein that there is no evidence of payment of tax. He has
submitted that Section 107(11) of the CGST Act empowers the Appellate
Authority to pass order, confirming, modifying or annulling the decision or
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
order of the Adjudicating Authority after making such further inquiry as
may be considered necessary. The two invoices in respect of which refund
had been claimed having been issued in the month of August, 2017, there
is no illegality in placing reliance on the said Circular dated 01.09.2017 as
the same was very much in force at that point of time. It is submitted by
him that the petitioner was required to adjust the error following the steps
outlined in the Circular dated 29.12.2017. He has also reiterated the finding
recorded by the Appellate Authority that the excess payment of tax in
GSTR-3B is not actually an excess payment of tax as it can be auto
adjusted in the subsequent months. However, the appellant did not adjust
its excess payment of tax in subsequent months.
10.
In reply, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that while it was
alleged in the SCN that there was no evidence of excess tax paid, in the
impugned order dated 11.09.2019, it is held that the petitioner had
rectified the error by carrying forward the excess payment of taxes to the
next month’s return against the output tax liability in terms of the Circular
dated 01.09.2017 which goes to show that the petitioner had, in fact, paid
taxes in excess for the month of August, 2017. He has contended that the
power of the Appellate Authority cannot be stretched to permit the
Appellate Authority to make further inquiry in respect of a matter which is
not part of SCN and any such further inquiry conducted beyond the SCN
will fall foul of the principles of natural justice. It is submitted by him that
even while making such inquiry no documents or explanations were sought
for from the petitioner. He has contended that on surmises and conjectures
and on presumption, the Appellate Authority had passed the impugned
order without even verifying as to whether, in reality, the excess tax paid
was adjusted in subsequent months.
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
11.
Learned counsel submits that due to non-operationalization of
adjustment feature in the GST portal and also because of lack of clarity as
to how to adjust, adjustment was not carried out by the petitioner, and
therefore, refund application was submitted in terms of Section 54 of the
CGST Act. It is also contended that the Circulars did not provide details as
to how to make adjustments. That there were deficiencies in the GST portal
is fortified by the fact that time limit for filing GSTR-1 return for the month
of August, 2017 was extended up to 10.01.2018 and then again up to
31.03.2018 and the petitioner had filed GSTR-1 only on 29.12.2017. He
has argued that there being no doubt regarding excess payment of tax by
the petitioner as also non-adjustment of the same by the petitioner in the
subsequent months, refund claim made by the petitioner merits to be
allowed.
12.
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and have perused the materials on record.
13.
In the SCN dated 08.03.2017, it was stated that refund application
is liable to be rejected on the following reasons:
“(i)
On scrutiny of cash ledger in GST portal for the relevant period
of refund, it has been noticed that the said refund claim has not been
debited from the cash ledger. There is also not any evidence of
Excess payment of tax as declared in refund claim. As such it appears
that it is contrary to the provisions of Section 16, Section 31 and
Section 54 of the CGST Act, 2017 and Rules 36, 46 and 89 of the
CGST Rules, 2017.
(ii)
As per Section 34 of CGST Act, 2017 along with Circulars No.
17/17/2017-GST
dated
15.11.2017,
24/24/2017-GST
dated
21.12.2017 and 37/11/2018-GST dated 15.03.2018, you failed to
submit the requisite documents such as - all the invoices (in original)
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
for the purpose of evidencing the supply of goods made and Delivery
of challan (in original) for the purpose of evidencing that this was
only movement of goods to one unit to another, payment particulars,
statement in respect of excess payment of tax etc. as per the
instruction given in Circular No. 37/11/2018-GST dated 15.03.2018
and required declarations also as stated in the said circular of
refund.”
14.
Both the above points were required to be clarified by the
petitioner.
The
petitioner
had,
accordingly,
submitted
its
reply
on
27.03.2019 and representative of the petitioner had also appeared for
personal hearing before respondent no. 2. The operative portion of the
order dated 01.04.2019/02.04.2019 reads as follows:
“I, hereby reject an amount of Rs.15,84,599/- (Rupees fifteen
lakhs eighty four thousand five hundred and ninety nine) only
to
M/s
Sun
Pharma
Laboratories
Ltd.,
having
GSTIN
11AACCS61631Z4 under Rule 92 (1) of the CGST Rules, 2017
read with Section 54 and 56 of CGST Act, 2017, since, there is
no provision under GST Act and GST Rules for refund of excess
payment of tax, if payment made through Input Tax Credit”.
15.
The order seems to suggest that there was excess payment of tax.
However, prayer for refund was rejected on the ground that there is no
provision under GST Act and GST Rules for refund of excess payment of
tax, if such payment is made through ITC. As noted earlier, the Appellate
Authority in its order dated 11.09.2019 had categorically held that the
ground of rejection of refund claim in the impugned order is erroneous. It
would be relevant to extract paragraphs 8, 9 and 10 (recorded as
paragraph 9 again) of the order of the Appellate Authority, which read as
under:
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
“8.
I have carefully gone through the records of the case
including the submission made by the appellant. I fully agree
with the contention of the appellant that GST laws do not
distinguish between the mode of payment of excess tax for the
purpose of refund. Therefore, the ground of rejection of the
refund claim in the impugned order is erroneous. However, it is
required to examine whether or not any excess payament of
tax has actually occurred in the instant case. On comparison of
the details of all invoices considered while discharging GST
liability in GSTR-3B for the month of Aug. 2017 and details of
invoices as uploaded in GSTR-1 for the month of Aug. 2017, it
is seen that two invoices in respect of which refund has been
claimed in the instant case, have been taken for tax liability in
GSTR-3B, but those invoices were not uploaded in GSTR-1 of
the respective month. In this respect it is pertinent to mention
following two paras of C.B.E. & C. Circular No. 7/7/2017-GST.
dated 1-9-2017:“Correction of erroneous details furnished in FORM GSTR3B:
6. In case the registered person intends to amend any
details furnished in FORM GSTR3B, it may be done in the
FORM GSTR-1 or FORM GSTR-2, as the case may be. For
example, while preparing and furnishing the details in
FORM GSTR-1, if the outward supplies have been under
reported or excess reported in FORM GSTR-3B, the same
may be correctly reported in the FORM GSTR-1. Similarly,
if the details of inward supplies or the eligible ITC have
been reported less or more than what they should have
been, the same may be reported correctly in the FORM
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
GSTR-2. This will get reflected in the revised output tax
liability or eligible ITC, as the case may be, of the
registered person. The details furnished in FORM GSTR-1
and FORM GSTR-2 will be auto-populated and reflected in
the return in FORM GSTR-3 for that particular month.
Reduction in output tax liability:
10. Where the output tax liability of the registered person
as per the details furnished in FORM GSTR-1 and FORM
GSTR-2 is less than the output tax liability as per the
details furnished in the FORM GSTR-3B and the same is
not offset by a corresponding reduction in the input tax
credit to which he is entitled, the excess shall be carried
forward to the next month’s return to be offset against
the output liability of the next month by the taxpayer
when he signs and submits the return in FORM GSTR-3.
However, simultaneously, if there is a decrease in the
eligible input tax credit, the same will be adjusted against
the above mentioned reduction in output tax liability and
the balance, if any, of the reduction in output tax liability
shall be carried forward to the next month’s return to be
offset against the output liability of the next month.”
9.
It is evident from the above two paras that
payment of tax in GSTR-3B is not final. If any error is crept in
it, there is the chance of rectifying it at the time of submission
of GSTR-1 and GSTR-2. In the instance case, the appellant
have rectified their error in tax payment in GSTR-3B for the
month of Aug. 17 in the GSTR-1 of the respective month, and
the excess payment of tax has been carried forward to the next
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
month’s return to be offset against the output tax liability of
that month. Thus, any excess payment of tax in GSTR-3B is not
actually an excess payment of tax as it will be auto adjusted
subsequently by the system.
9.
In view of the discussion as mentioned in para(s) 8
and 9 above, there is no requirement of refund in the instance
case, and so I reject the instant appeal submitted by the
appellant. The instant appeal is disposed off accordingly.”
16.
We are unable to accept the submission of learned counsel for the
petitioner that once the order of the Adjudicating Authority was held to be
erroneous by the Appellate Authority, the Appellate Authority ought to have
allowed refund of excess tax paid by allowing the appeal of the petitioner
(the appellant) without any further consideration.
17.
Relevant part of section 107(11) of CGST Act,2017 reads as under:
(11) The Appellate Authority shall, after making such further
inquiry as may be necessary, pass such order, as it thinks just
and proper, confirming, modifying or annulling the decision or
order appealed against but shall not refer the case back to the
adjudicating authority that passed the said decision or order.
18.
Having regard to the contour and ambit of section 107 (11) of
CGST Act, in our considered opinion, the Appellate Authority cannot be
faulted for undertaking an enquiry even after observing that the order of
the Adjudicating Authority was erroneous because the Appellate Authority
has to decide whether the petitioner has made out a case for grant of
refund. The Adjudicating Authority had only scrutinized the cash ledger in
GST portal for the relevant period of refund. In the reply to the SCN, the
petitioner had stated that the GST liability for the month of August, 2017
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
had been discharged by debiting from ITC credit ledger to the extent of its
availability and the balance liability was paid from cash ledger for the
month and that since there is no requirement of debiting invoice-wise
liability from the said ledger, the same may not be visible on the portal.
The Appellate Authority concluded that the petitioner had rectified their
error in tax payment in GSTR-3B for the month of August, 2017 in the
GSTR-1 of the respective month, and the excess payment of tax had been
carried forward to the next month’s return to be offset against the output
tax liability for that month. In other words, the Appellate Authority had
acknowledged that there was an error in payment of tax in GSTR-3B for the
month of August 2017 and that there was an excess payment of tax.
Submission of Mr.Tangri that the inquiry conducted by the Appellate
Authority was beyond the scope of SCN cannot be accepted. Two questions
had arisen for consideration before the Appellate Authority: (i) whether
there was excess payment of tax by the petitioner, and (ii) whether the
petitioner is entitled for refund. Once it was held that there was excess
payment of tax, obviously, the issue that would engage attention is as to
whether refund ought to be granted. It is in that context the question of
adjustment had come to the fore and therefore, it cannot be said that the
inquiry conducted by the Appellate Authority do not have even any remote
nexus with the SCN.
19.
However, it does not appear from the order of the Appellate
Authority that the Appellate Authority had perused and examined GSTR-1,
GSTR-2 and GSTR-3B for the month of September, 2017 to actually find
out whether excess payment of tax had been carried forward to be offset
against the output tax liability of that month. It was presumed by the
Appellate Authority that the petitioner had rectified the error in the GSTR-1
for the month of August, 2017 and that the excess payment of tax had
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
been carried forward in the return of September, 2017. On that
presumption, it was held that excess payment of tax in GSTR-3B is not
actually an excess payment of tax as it will be auto adjusted by the system
and therefore, there is no requirement of refund. No finding has been
recorded that, subsequently, excess payment of tax had been auto
adjusted. It is to be noted that by the time Appellate Authority had passed
the order, more than two years had elapsed. It is also significant to note
that in the affidavit of respondent nos.1 to 4, a statement is made in
paragraph 23 that the petitioner had not adjusted excess payment in
corresponding months, which is contrary to the observation of the Appellate
Authority.
20.
It is the positive case of the petitioner that excess payment of tax
had not been carried forward to the subsequent months. The Appellate
Authority, in the context of a claim for refund for excess payment of tax,
may be justified to look into contemporaneous materials, but in such a
circumstance, it will be imperative and mandatory for the Appellate
Authority to afford an opportunity to the petitioner (appellant) to furnish its
comments on the aspects on which the Appellate Authority would like to
examine the matter by way of further enquiry.
21.
It appears from a reading of the order dated 11.09.2019 of the
Appellate Authority that only argument that was advanced by the petitioner
(appellant) was with regard to the finding recorded by the Adjudicating
Authority and on no other point. The Appellate Authority, in the instance
case, was required to grant the petitioner an opportunity to explain its
stand on GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B as also the Circulars. We are of the opinion
that the impugned order militates against the principles of natural justice.
Accordingly, the order dated 11.09.2019 is set aside and quashed.
W.P.(C) No. 09 of 2020
Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors.
22.
We do not consider it appropriate to embark upon an inquiry to
examine the claim of the petitioner that excess payment of tax has not
been carried forward or that the same has not been adjusted. These are
matters to be reconsidered by the Appellate Authority. It will not be
necessary for the Appellate Authority to indicate the aspects that it would
like to examine, as the same are self-evident from the order dated
11.09.2019.
23.
In that view of the matter, the petitioner is permitted to file a
representation dealing with the aspects as reflected in paragraphs 8, 9 and
10 of the order dated 11.09.2019 and such representation would be filed
within a period of eight weeks from today before the Appellate Authority.
After the representation is filed, an opportunity shall be granted to the
representative/counsel for the petitioner for hearing and thereafter, the
Appellate Authority shall pass a fresh order with expedition and without any
delay regarding the claim made by the petitioner for refund.
24.
The writ petition is allowed with the above directions and
observations. No cost.
( Judge )
jk
( Chief Justice )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review