Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ORISSA HIGH COURT : CUTTACK
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
An application under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution of
India.
***
Sumitra Sahu
…
Petitioner.
-VERSUSState of Odisha & Another
…
Opposite Parties.
Counsel appeared for the parties:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Debasish Samal, Advocate
For the Opposite Parties
: Mr. G. Mohanty, Standing Counsel.
P R E S E N T:
HONOURABLE
MR. JUSTICE ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA
Date of Hearing : 05.01.2026 :: Date of Judgment : 15.01.2026
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
J UDGMENT
ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA, J.—
1.
This writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 has been filed by the petitioner
praying for directing the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar (O.P. No.2)
for preparation of the R.o.R of the case land in the name of the
petitioner correcting
the
same
from
the
name
of
the
Government to the name of the petitioner and also correcting
the Kisam thereof from Chhota Jungle to its status as it was
in the previous R.o.R in the name of the petitioner.
2.
The case land is plot No.1198/1731/1939 Ac.0.125
decimals under Khata No.325/315 (Annxure-3) in MouzaPatharagadia under Chandaka P.S., which corresponds to
Sabik Plot No.1198 under Sabik Khata No.420, which
corresponds to Hal plot No.4712 & 4713 under Hal Khata
No.2239 (Annexure-6).
The case of the petitioner is that, one Bansi @ Bansidhar
Nayak was allotted for an area of Ac.1.500 decimals from
Sabik Plot No.1198 under Sabik Khata No.420 in MouzaPatharagadia under Chandaka Police Station in the district of
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Khordha as per W.L. Case No.2916/1974 and since the date
of
allotment
of
the
said
land
through
W.L.
Case
No.2916/1974, the said allottee Bansi @ Bansidhar Nayak
was in possession over the same. The R.o.R thereof was
prepared in the name of Bansi @ Bansidhar Nayak as per
Khata No.325/99, Plot No.1198/1731 for an area of Ac.1.500
decimals (as per Annexure-1).
The said Bansi @ Bansidhar Nayak was paying rent for
the same and he was obtaining the rent receipts for the same.
Thereafter, Bansi @ Bansidhar Nayak sold the case land i.e.
for an area of Ac.0.125 decimals of land out of Ac.1.500
decimals from plot No.1198/1731 under Khata No.325/99 to
the petitioner by executing and registering a sale deed vide
sale deed No.4108 dated 07.05.1986 as per Annexure-2 and
delivered possession thereof and since then, the petitioner
had/has been possessing the said case land i.e. Ac.0.125
decimals out of Ac.1.500 decimals of plot No.1198/1731.
Thereafter, the petitioner mutated her purchased land
(which
was
purchased
through
R.S.D.
No.4108
dated
07.05.1986) through Mutation Case No.965/1990 and as per
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Order passed in the Mutation Case No.965/1990, a separate
R.o.R vide Khata No.325/315, Plot No.1198/1731/1939
Ac.0.125 decimals as per Annexure-3 was prepared in the
name of the petitioner indicating/reflecting the Kisam thereof
as Sarada Tini.
Thereafter, surprisingly, in a suo moto Lease Revision
Case
No.923/1998,
the
Addl.
District
Magistrate,
Bhubaneswar cancelled to the lease of the case land, which
was granted in W.L. Case No.2916 of 1974 as per Order dated
11.08.1998
vide
Annexure-4,
to
which,
the
petitioner
challenged, by filing the writ petition vide WP(C) No.1461 of
2006.
The said Writ Petition filed by the petitioner was allowed
by this Court and the Order dated 11.08.1998 passed by the
A.D.M., Bhubaneswar in Lease Revision Case No.923/1998
was quashed as per Order dated 13.02.2006 (Annexure-5)
passed in WP(C) No.1461 of 2006.
3.
During settlement operation, the settlement authorities
recorded the case land illegally and erroneously in the name of
the Government under Abada Jogya Anabadi Khata as per
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Annexure-6 indicating the Kisam thereof erroneously as
“Chotta Jungle”. In fact, the case land was/is under the
possession of the petitioner having its Kisam as Sarada Tini,
as reflected in the R.o.R vide Annexure-3 as Sarada Tini. For
which, the recording of the case land by the settlement
authorities in the name of the Government changing its Kisam
ignoring
the
settlement
of
the
same
in
W.L.
Case
No.2916/1974 in favour of the vendor of the petitioner and
the confirmation of the same by the High Court in WP(C)
No.1461 of 2006 as per Annexure-5 and superseding the
order passed by the High Court on dated 13.02.2006 in WP(C)
No.1461 of 2006 are baseless.
For which, without getting any way, the petitioner filed
this writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India praying for directing the Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar (O.P. No.2) for preparation of the R.o.R of the
case land in the name of the petitioner correcting the same
from the name of the Government as well as correcting the
Kisam thereof from Chotta Jungle to Sarada Tini on the
ground that, the settlement authorities had no power or
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
jurisdiction to record the case land in the name of the
Government as well as to change the Kisam thereof indicated
in the previous R.o.R vide Annexure-3.
4.
I have already heard from the learned counsel for the
petitioner and the learned Standing Counsel for the State.
5.
On the basis of the rival submissions of the learned
counsels of both the sides, the crux of this writ petition is
that,
I. Whether the preparation of the R.o.R of the case land
vide Annexure-6 in the name of the Government by the
Settlement Authorities in spite of the confirmation of the
order of settlement of the case land passed in W.L. Case
No.2916/1974 ignoring the R.o.R of the same vide
Khata No.325/315 plot No.1198/1731/1939 (Annexure3) which was in the name of the petitioner is lawful?
II.
Whether after final publication of the Hal R.o.R
vide Annexure-6 in the name of the Government, the
Writ Court has power or authority to direct the
Tahasildar for recording of the case land in the name of
the petitioner quashing the recording of the same in the
name of the Government even in absence of any
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
approach of the petitioner to the Revisional Authority
under Section 15 (b) of the O.S & S. Act, 1958?
6.
In order to have the just decision of this Writ Petition, the
above two formulated questions fixed for determination are
required to be discussed and analyzed one after another
serially and chronologically hereunder:
7.
So far as the first point i.e. Whether the preparation of the
R.o.R of the case land vide Annexure-6 in the name of the
Government by the Settlement Authorities in spite of the
confirmation of the order of settlement of the case land passed
in W.L. Case No.2916/1974 ignoring the R.o.R of the same vide
Khata
No.325/315
plot No.1198/1731/1939
(Annexure-3)
which was in the name of the petitioner was lawful is
concerned,
It is the undisputed case of the parties that, the case
land was allotted in favour of the vendor of the petitioner i.e.
Bansi @ Bansidhar Nayak in W.L. Case No.2916 of 1974.
The R.o.R of the case land was prepared in the name of
Bansi @ Bansidhar Nayak as per Khata No.325/99 plot
No.1198/1731 (Annexure-1).
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Thereafter, the said Bansi @ Bansidhar Nayak sold the
case land to the petitioner through R.S.D. dated 07.05.1986 as
per Annexure-2.
After purchasing the case land through Annexure-2, the
petitioner mutated the case land to her name as per Mutation
Case No.965/1990 and as per the order passed in the
Mutation Case No.965/1990, separate R.o.R vide Khata
No.325/315 as per Annexure-3 was prepared in the name of
the petitioner. The petitioner was paying the rent of the same
in her name through rent receipts as per Annexure-3 series.
8.
Thereafter, the A.D.M, Bhubaneswar has cancelled to the
order of settlement of land in W.L. Case No.2916/1974 as per
order dated 11.08.1998 passed in Lease Revision Case
No.923/1998. The said order dated 11.08.1998 of the A.D.M,
Bhubaneswar was quashed by this Court as per Order dated
13.02.2006 passed in WP(C) No.1461/2006 vide Annexure-5.
That order of confirmation of the lease in W.L. Case
No.2916/1974 by the High Court as per Order dated
13.02.2006 in WP(C) No.1461 of 2006 has already been
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
reached in its finality due to non-challenge to the same by the
State/Government.
9.
When
the
case
land
was
settled
in
W.L.
Case
No.2916/1974 as per Odisha Government Land Settlement Act
and the R.o.R thereof was prepared in the name of the
petitioner as per Annexure-3 as per the Order of the
Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar passed in Mutation Case No.965 of
1990, then, at this juncture, the settlement authorities had no
power or jurisdiction under law for recording the case land in
the name of the Government superseding the order of
settlement
made
under
the
OGLS
Act
in
W.L.
Case
No.2916/1974 and confirmation of the said settlement passed
by the High Court on dated 13.02.2006 in WP(C) No.1461 of
2006.
On this aspect, the propositions of law has already been
clarified in the ratio of the following decisions:
(I) In a case between Shri Jadu Bhoi & Shri Padma Bhoi
Vs. State of Orissa reported in JBR (XV) Part IV Page 50
that, unless the lease is cancelled, the land should be
recorded in the name of the petitioner i.e. in whose name
the land was allotted.
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
(II) In a case between Mrs. Sneha Mohanty Vs. State of
Odisha decided in WP(C) No.18936 of 2013 on dated
20.08.2013 (DB) that, the Settlement Authorities has no
jurisdiction to review the order passed by the revisional
authority in a proceeding under the OGLS Act regarding
lease of Government land.
(III) In the cases between Nilendri Mohanty Vs. State
decided in WP(C) No.8402 of 2014 on dated 04.07.2014
(DB), Kamala Basini Mohanty Vs. State of Orissa
decided in WP(C) No.8237 of 2014 on dated 04.07.2014
(DB), Kapaleswar Firms Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of Odisha
decided in WP(C) No.11165 of 2014 on dated 08.07.2014
(DB) and Tridev Kodamasingh Vs. State of Odisha
decided in WP(C) No.4596 of 2014 on dated 27.10.2014
(DB) that, the leases granted either under the OGLS Act or
under any other appropriate law, unless and until the said
leases are set aside or declared invalid by the competent
authority under the appropriate statute, the leases cannot
be said to be invalid.
Unless and until a lease is either set aside or leasehold
lands are resumed by the order of the competent authority,
the Settlement Authorities are bound by the lease orders
and have no jurisdiction to question the validity of the lease
concerned.
(IV) In a case between Padmanav Prusty Vs. State of
Odisha decided in WP(C) No.12776 of 2014 on dated
06.04.2018 (DB) that, it was none of the business of the
Assistant Settlement Officer to go into the question of
correctness of lease and direct to change the draft record.
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Because, the authority under the OGLS Act, lease principle
or Government Grants Act under which there are hierarchy
of authorities to take cognizance of any irregularity and
illegality and the said authority can pass the order of
cancellation under the concerned statute.
The Settlement Officer is not authorized to encroach
upon the authority as prescribed under other revenue laws
to behave like appellate authority to cancel the lease. For
which, the impugned order passed by the Assistant
Settlement Officer is without jurisdiction and wholly
erroneous.
(V) In a case between Narottam Rath Vs. State of Odisha
and Another decided in WP(C) No.1608 of 2014 on dated
02.01.2023 (DB) that, the ASOs exercised ‘suo motu
powers’ to override the orders of the ADM under the OGLS
Act
in
favour
of
the
predecessors-in-interest
of
the
Petitioners and refused to record their names in the ROR
despite there being no objections to the draft publication of
the ROR.
ASO cannot declare any order under OLGS Act as an
illegal.
Such
action
of
the
ASO
is
illegal
and
without
jurisdiction. Because, the ASO has no jurisdiction to pass
any order touching the OGLS Act. So, his order for
recording the case land in the name of the Government is
held as without jurisdiction, for which, the said order of
ASO is held as void and non-est in the eye of law.
(VI) In a case between Ranjit Kumar Mohanty Vs. State of
Odisha & Others decided in WP(C) No.5876 of 2014 on
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
dated 22.09.2025 that, there is no provision under the
OS&S Act, 1958 empowering the Authorities created under
OS&S Act, 1958 to cancel a lease granted under the OGLS
Act.
So, by ignoring the order passed by the authorities
under the OLGS Act, the ASO acted without jurisidiction in
directing to record the case land in favour of the State. For
which, the order of the settlement authorities for recording
of the case land in the name of the State is void.
Therefore, relegating the Petitioner to file a revision
under Section 15(b) of the OS&S Act, 1958 will serve no
purpose and thereby the Petitioner will be further harassed
in facing unnecessary litigations.
Since, the settlement proceeding has already been over
and the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar is the custodian of the
revenue records together with the fact that, the concerned
Tahasildar has the power under Rule 34 of Odisha Survey
and Settlement Rules, 1962 to correct the entries in the
ROR pursuant to the direction of a Court, for which, it is
directed that, the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar shall issue ROR
of the case land in favour of the Petitioner, if moved by the
Petitioner, preferably within a period of 30 days from the
date of production of the certified copy of the order.
(VII) In a case between Lily Nanda Vs. State of Odisha
reported in 2018(I)OLR 559 that, when the Settlement
Authorities conveniently avoided the settlement made under
the O.G.L.S. Act ignoring the same, which was not
permissible under law, and when the impugned orders
have, in effect, resulted in cancelling the lease granted in
favour of the beneficiary, which was not within the domain
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
of the settlement authorities, then, the impugned orders are
without jurisdiction and the same are void, illegal and nonest in the eye of law.
(VIII) In a case between Vijay Krishna Poultry Pvt. Ltd.
Vs. State of Odisha decided in WP(C) No.8774 of 2019 on
dated 18.06.2021 that, when, Settlement Authorities has
passed the orders without recognizing the settlement of the
land under the provisions of the O.G.L.S. Act and when the
authorities under the OS&S Act, 1958 cannot sit over the
settlement made under the O.G.L.S. Act, then, it is held
that,
the
Settlement
Authorities
have
acted
without
jurisdiction in passing the impugned order and as such, the
final publication of the R.O.Rs. under Section 12-B of the
Act, 1958 pursuant to the void orders is not sustainable
under law.
10. Herein
this
matter
at
hand,
when
indirectly
the
settlement authorities have ignored the order of allotment of
the case land under OGLS Act and the confirmation of the
same by the High Court in WP(C) No.1461 of 2006 in fvaour of
the vendor of the petitioner, then, at this juncture, in view of
the principles of law enunciated in the ratio of the aforesaid
decisions, the preparation of the R.o.R of the case land vide
Annexure-6 in the name of the Government under Khata
No.2239 in respect of the case land is void and non-est under
law and the said R.o.R vide Annexure-6 prepared under
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Section 12-B of the OS&S Act, 1958 vide Annexure-6 in the
name of the Government in respect of the case land is not
sustainable under law.
11. So far as the 2nd point i.e. Whether after final
publication of the Hal R.o.R vide Annexure-6 in the name of the
Government, the Writ Court has power or authority to direct the
Tahasildar for recording of the case land in the name of the
petitioner quashing the recording of the same in the name of the
Government even in absence of any approach of the petitioner to
the Revisional Authority under Section 15 (b) of the O.S & S. Act,
1958 is concerned:
As per the amendment of the Rule 34 of the OS&S Rules,
1962 and due to insertion of Clause (g) in the said rule 34 of
the OS&S Rules, 1962 on the basis of the Notification No.4773
dated 12.11.2025 of the R & DM Department of the
Government of Odisha, all the Tahasildars of the entire State
are empowered/authorized under law for correction of the
finally published R.o.R of the case land on the basis of the
registered transfer deed executed even prior to the publication
of the final R.o.R by way of initiation of a Mutation Case.
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Here in this matter at hand, when the registered sale
deed No.4108 dated 07.05.1986 vide Annexure-2 is in favour
of the petitioner in respect of the case land and the said
Annexure-2 was executed by her vendor Bansi @ Bansidhar
Nayak in favour of the petitioner on dated 07.05.1986 prior to
the final publication of the final R.o.R of the case land by the
settlement authorities vide Annexure-6 and when as per the
discussions and observations made above in the forgoing Point
No.1, it has already been held that, the preparation of the final
R.o.R of the case land in respect of Hal Plot No.4712 & 4713
under Hal Khata No.2239 is void and illegal, then, at this
juncture, in view of the findings and observations made in the
forgoing point No.1 as well as aforesaid notification No.4773
dated 12.11.2025 of the R & DM Department of the
Government of Odisha due to insertion of Clause (g) into the
Rule
of
the
OS&S
Rules,
1962,
the
Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar is empowered under law for correction of the
R.o.R of the case land from the name of the Government to the
name of the petitioner initiating a Mutation Case on the basis
of the Registered sale deed No.4108 dated 07.05.1986 vide
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
Annexure-2 instead of approaching the Revisional Authority
under Section 15(b) of the OS&S Act, 1958.
12. On the basis of the findings and observations made in
the aforesaid point Nos.1 and 2, it can be directed to the
Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar (Opp. Party No.2) for preparation of
the R.o.R of the case land in the name of the petitioner
correcting the same from the name of the Government as well
as correcting the Kisam thereof from Chotta Jungle to its
status as it was earlier in the previous R.o.R vide Annexure-3
under Khata No.325/315 Plot No.1198/1731/1939.
13. Therefore, there is merit in the writ petition filed by the
petitioner. The same is to be allowed.
14. In result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner is
allowed on contest.
15. The Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar (Opp. Party No.2) is
directed for correction of the R.o.R and Kisam of the case land
vide Plot Nos.4712 & 4713 in total Ac. 0.125 decimals from the
name of the Government to the name of the petitioner and the
Kisam thereof from Chotta Jungle to Sarada Tini through
initiation of a Mutation Case on the basis of production of the
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
certified copy of this Judgment before the Opp. Party No.2 and
to dispose of the said Mutation Case finally within one month
of its registration.
16. As such, this writ petition filed by the petitioner is
disposed of finally.
(ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA)
JUDGE
High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
The 15 .01. 2026// Rati Ranjan Nayak
Sr. Stenographer
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RATI RANJAN NAYAK
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC
Date: 16-Jan-2026 19:26:14
WP(C) No.37026 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review