Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 26th JULY, 2018
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Petitioner
:
Mrs. Suman Rai,
W/o Shanker Pradhan,
GNM/Staff Nurse,
R/o Pani House,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
State of Sikkim
Through the Director General-cum-Secretary,
Health Care, Human Service and Family
Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
2.
The Secretary,
Department of Personnel, Adm.
Reforms, Training and Public Grievances,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
3.
Mrs. Paden Bhutia,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at Mangan,
P.O. & P.S. Mangan,
North Sikkim.
4.
Mrs. Pema Donka Bhutia,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Resigned from the service.
5.
Mrs. Deepa Silwal,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
6.
Mrs. Leena Rai,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at Namchi,
P.O. & P.S. Namchi,
South Sikkim.
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
7.
Mrs. Chitrakala Sharma,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
8.
Mrs. Durga Pokhrel Sharma,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at Namchi,
P.O. & P.S. Namchi,
South Sikkim.
9.
Ms. Kokila Sharma,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at Singtam,
P.O. & P.S. Singtam,
South Sikkim.
10.
Mrs. Palden Bhutia,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at Singtam,
P.O. & P.S. Singtam,
South Sikkim.
11.
Ms. Tsheten Donka Bhutia,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
12.
Mrs. Tashi Doma Bhutia,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
13.
Mrs. Ruma Tamang,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
14.
Ms. Sandya Gurung,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
15.
Mrs. Monika Chettri,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
16.
Mrs. Nawang Doma Bhutia,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
17.
Mrs. Chundu Subba,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
18.
Ms. Rupa Sharma,
Staff Nurse, Batch 1996,
Presently posted at District Hospital at STNM,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Application under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa and Ms. Mon Maya Subba, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate, Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant
Government Advocate and Ms. Neera Thapa (Legal Retainer, HC, HS
& FWD) for the State-State-Respondents No.1 and 2.
Dr. (Mrs.) Doma T. Bhutia, Advocate for Respondents No.3, 5 to 14
and 16 to 18.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
The apple of discord between the parties herein is the
alleged downgrading in the seniority of the Petitioner in her service,
in which, on appointment she was placed at Serial No.3 vide Office
Order No.896/M./H&FW dated 21-05-1996. Consequently, in the
consolidated list indicating appointment of Nurses made from 1979
to 1996 vide communication No.277/H.&F.W. dated 19-11-1996,
she found place at Serial No.68 while continuing to remain at Serial
No.3 of the 1996 batch. However, vide Notification No.13/H&F.W.
dated 09-09-2002, unbeknownst to her she was relegated to Serial
No.75 in the consolidated list and to Serial No.17 of the batch of
1996, without notice to her of such action. Thus, claiming violation
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
of her fundamental rights as guaranteed under Articles 14, 15, 16
and 21 of the Constitution of India, the Petitioner is before this
Court seeking redressal, inter alia, as follows;
(a)
an order directing the Respondents to comply with the
communication dated 19-11-1996 along with seniority
list and to act strictly in accordance with the said Office
Order in maintaining the seniority;
(b)
an order directing the Respondents to set aside the
communications dated 22-09-2016 and 11-11-2016,
along with provisional seniority list and Notification
bearing
No.13/H&F.W.,
dated
09-09-2002
of
the
Respondent No.1;
(c)
After perusal of the records, causes shown if any and
upon hearing the parties to make the Rule Absolute
and/or pass any other order/orders/
directions as
deemed fit and proper for the ends of justice;
(d)
Direct the Respondents No.1 and 2 to pass necessary
orders for publishing a fresh seniority list as per Rules
by maintaining the inter se seniority of the 1996 batch
according to the merit list.
2.
For clarity, we may briefly advert to the facts of the case
as per the Petitioner. Vide Office Memorandum bearing Memo No.
533/M/H&FW/M, dated 15-05-1996, the Petitioner was offered
appointment to the post of General Nursing and Midwifery (for short
“GNM”), by the Respondent No.1, as a direct recruit in the scale of
pay of Rs.1410-30-1560/40-1800/50-2300, per month.
Pursuant
thereto on 21-05-1996 an Office Order bearing No.896/M./H&FW
came to be issued by the Respondent No.1 appointing the Petitioner
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
with sixteen others as Staff Nurses. The name of the Petitioner was
placed at Serial No.3 in the seniority list in the said batch of
appointments.
On 25-05-1996 the Petitioner reported for duty at
the District Hospital, Namchi, duly filing her joining report. Later, on
19-11-1996, letter No.277/H.&FW. was issued by the Respondent
No.1 to the Petitioner along with a consolidated seniority list of Staff
Nurses appointed from 1979 to 1996, placing the Petitioner at Serial
No.68. The communication sought acceptance or objection of the
seniority within fifteen days from the date of issuance of the letter
failing which it would be presumed that the seniority therein was
accepted
and
no
future
requests
for
alteration/addition
or
modification would be entertained. This seniority list came to be
accepted by all the seventeen new employees who had joined
service as Staff Nurses. In the year 2016, however, the Petitioner
along with others came to learn that a new seniority list of Staff
Nurses was to be prepared with no notice to them. The Petitioner
on 12-09-2016 made a representation to the Respondent No.1 along
with another Applicant, Sancha Maya Rai, seeking maintenance of
their seniority in terms of the list of 1996. In response thereto, the
Respondent No.1 vide letter dated 22-09-2016 informed her that
the inter se seniority list appended with the letter, had been notified
vide Notification No.13/H&F.W. on 09-09-2002 which was to be
adhered to.
That, while the Petitioner had been placed at Serial
No.3 at the time of appointment in 1996, in the consolidated
seniority list she had found place at Serial No.68, but in the list of
2002 she was relegated to Serial No.75. It is her contention that
the alleged seniority list is not proper, neither is it as per Rules.
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Following the aforestated response of the Respondent No.1 dated
22-09-2016, the Petitioner again preferred a representation on 2609-2016 to the Respondent No.1 reiterating her request for
maintenance of her seniority.
However, on 11-11-2016, a letter
came to be issued by the Respondent No.1 to the Chief Medical
Officers of the four District Hospitals and the Director-cum-Medical
Superintendent,
STNM
Hospital,
informing
therein
that
the
Department was in the process of notifying inter se seniority list of
Staff Nurses under the Sikkim Subordinate Nursing Service.
The
Officers were requested to circulate the enclosed provisional
seniority list amongst the concerned Nurses to enable submission of
their respective claims/objections, if any, in writing within fifteen
days from the date of issuance of the letter. In the said list, for the
1996 appointments the Petitioner found herself listed at Serial No.16
(Respondent No.4 having resigned in the interim) instead of Serial
No.3 as earlier, while those who had been placed below her now
found place above her.
Hence, she objected to the Provisional
seniority list of 2016, vide communication dated 21-11-2016 to the
Respondent
No.1,
in
addition
to
which
she
preferred
a
representation before the Hon‟ble Chief Minister of Sikkim who
requested the Respondent No.2 to consider her case. She also filed
an application under the Right to Information Act, 2005 to the State
Public Information Officer (SPIO) of the Respondent No.1 on 02-052017 who, inter alia, informed of her that the concerned File could
not be located in the Department the matter being twenty-one years
old. Aggrieved, the Petitioner on 10-06-2017 sent a legal notice to
the Respondent No.1 to which the Respondent No.1 expressed
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
inability to correct the seniority list as notified on 09-09-2002.
Hence, the instant Petition seeking the aforestated reliefs.
3.
Respondent No.1 and Respondent No.2 filed a joint
Counter-Affidavit.
While denying and disputing the claims of the
Petitioner, inter alia, averred therein that the seniority list which was
circulated vide Memo No.277/H.&F.W. dated 19-11-1996 was
erroneous as the date of appointment of the Petitioner was wrongly
recorded as “23-05-1996” instead of “21-05-1996”.
A fresh
seniority list was thus prepared and notified on 09-09-2002 duly
maintaining the inter se seniority with effect from the date of joining
of duty by the appointees and circulated to them and the respective
Chief Medical Officers of all the Districts. That, the said seniority list
has been accepted for the last fifteen years based on which a series
of promotions and redesignations have been effected besides
assigning duty roster and higher responsibilities in the Hospital, to
which the Petitioner till date had not objected. It was also averred
that the seniority list of 1996 was not notified while the seniority list
as per Notification of 2002 was circulated to all concerned.
Admitting to issuance of letter dated 11-11-2016 it was pointed out
that this letter has since been rescinded, as the Notification of 2002
pertaining to seniority was already in existence.
That, as the
grounds set out by the Petitioner are not sustainable in the eyes of
law besides which the Petitioner has approached this Court
belatedly, the Petition is liable to be dismissed outright.
4.
Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and 16 to 18 too filed a
common Counter-Affidavit denying that the Office Order dated 21-
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
05-1996 was ever a merit list. Seeking a dismissal of the Petition, it
was averred that no written test or viva voce was conducted during
such appointment which infact was made on account of a large
number of vacancies of Staff Nurses at that point in time. Hence a
common appointment order was issued by the Respondents No.1
and 2 for all the Staff Nurses including the Petitioner based on those
who had a Certificate of Nursing Course.
The list was prepared
District-wise in order to ascertain the number of staff belonging to
various Districts to facilitate transfers to the concerned District
Hospitals. That, the said Respondents joined their duties 2-3 days
prior to the Petitioner who joined only on 25-05-1996, and it is a
settled principle of law that the initial date of joining is the criteria
for basing inter se seniority. In the event that the date of joining is
identical
then
the
age
of the
person would
be
taken into
consideration, placing the older person at a higher rank in seniority.
That, the Sikkim State Nursing Service Rules, 1997 (hereinafter
“Nursing Service Rules”), categorically lays down that the inter se
seniority of the members of the service shall be determined in
accordance with the Sikkim State Services (Regulation of Seniority)
Rules, 1980 (hereinafter “Regulation of Seniority Rules”).
That,
under the Regulation of Seniority Rules it is provided that the
seniority of persons who are appointed to the service by a method
other than by selection or by examination shall be determined ad
hoc by the State Government by a special order. No such special
order was issued nor was the seniority list notified in a Government
Gazette or Circular. That, infact due to several errors appearing in
the list of 1996 necessary rectifications were made by preparation of
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
the list in 2002. Following the inter se seniority list of 2002 the
Attendance Register of the Nurses are maintained as per the Wards
attended to by them.
The Respondents are thus in the Special
Neonatal Care Unit (SNCU) and the Dialysis Unit, indicative of their
seniority. That, infact a Screening Test of all Staff Nurses was done
by the State-Respondents based on the inter se seniority list of
2002 whereupon Office Order dated 14-11-2016 was issued which
remained unassailed by the Petitioner thereby waiving her right to
challenge the inter se seniority list of 2002.
A number of
promotions of the batch of 1996 have been effected based on the
inter se seniority list of 2002, hence, the Petition is liable to be
dismissed also on the grounds of estoppel, waiver and acquiescence.
5.
In Rejoinder, the Petitioner would draw the attention of
this Court to Rule 8(a) of the Sikkim Government Establishment
Rules, 1974 (hereinafter “Establishment Rules”) and aver that in
consideration of the said Rules the Petitioner having been selected
as Staff Nurse by direct recruitment would be placed in the inter se
seniority on the basis of the selection list. Assistance was also taken
of Rule 4(d) of the Regulation of Seniority Rules.
That, infact the
Petitioner had applied for the post of Staff Nurse after it was
advertised by the Respondent No.1 as evident from their RTI
response, followed by an interview of applicants, marks awarded by
the Selection Committee and their names arranged in accordance
with the marks obtained by them.
To buttress this point, reliance
was placed on a letter dated 23-02-1995 issued by the Respondent
No.1 calling one Sanchamaya Rai for an interview, on her
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
application for appointment as GNM.
Thus, the seniority so settled
cannot be withdrawn without operation of a valid law and a mere
fortuitous chance of reporting for duty earlier would not alter the
ranking given by the Selection Board, hence the prayers in the Writ
Petition be granted.
6.
Canvassing his arguments on behalf of the Petitioner,
Learned Counsel while drawing attention to the Notifications of 1996
and
referred
to
hereinabove,
would
contend
that
the
Respondents had acted arbitrarily and contrary to law by placing the
Petitioner below her actual position in the seniority list.
That the
Respondents are required to strictly adhere to the provisions of the
Establishment Rules, Regulation of Seniority Rules and Nursing
Service Rules. Infact, the Establishment Rules clearly lays down at
Rule 8(d) that once the inter se seniority of a Government Servant
in one grade is determined, it shall not be disturbed unless and until
he is either promoted to the next higher post or is reduced in rank
under the provisions of the procedure for disciplinary action. That,
the Petitioner joined duty at Namchi Hospital within the time limits
prescribed by the Authority and as there was no gross delay her
inter se seniority cannot be affected. The Petitioner had never been
informed by the Respondent No.1 that seniority would be on the
basis of the date of joining and they cannot now take the said plea
when merit was the criteria considered for placing the Petitioner at
Serial No.3 of the list of 1996. It was urged that where a statute
requires a particular act to be done in a particular manner, the act
has to be done in that manner alone and every word of the statute
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
has to be given its due meaning. Support was garnered from the
ratio in Competent Authority vs. Barangore Jute Factory and Others1.
While contending that the Rules ought to be strictly complied with
by the concerned Department, attention of this Court was drawn to
the decision in State of Kerala and Others vs. K. Prasad and Another2.
While relying on P. Mohan Reddy vs. E.A.A. Charles and Others3 it was
canvassed that the Petitioner has the right to her seniority being
determined in accordance with the Rules which existed when she
entered service.
That the question of re-determination of the
seniority in the cadre did not arise as there was no amendment to
the Rules pertaining to seniority.
Assailing the contention of the
Respondent No.1 that seniority was based on the date of joining,
strength was drawn from Chairman Puri Gramya Bank and Another vs.
Ananda Chandra Das and Others4 and Suresh Chandra Jha vs. State of
Bihar and Others5.
Drawing succour from Rajasthan State Industrial
Development
Investment
and
Corporation
vs.
Cooperative Housing Society, Jaipur and Others6
Subhash
Sindhi
it was argued that
Notification of 2002 which had no legal sanction cannot override the
Rules pertaining to seniority which are already in place. While
fending of the argument of the Respondents that the Petitioner has
approached the Court belatedly and was therefore not entitled to the
reliefs, the attention of this Court was invited to R. M. Ramual vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and Others 7.
(2005) 13 SCC 477
(2007) 7 SCC 140
(2001) 4 SCC 433
(1994) 6 SCC 301
(2007) 1 SCC 405
(2013) 5 SCC 427
(1989) 1 SCC 285
That, the Petitioner was in
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
ignorance of the seniority list of 2002 as it was not notified in the
Government Gazette and only the letter dated 11-11-2016 brought
this fact to the notice of the Petitioner.
It was further contended
that the response dated 29-05-2017 of the ASPIO of the Respondent
No.1 would clearly indicate that the promotion of Staff Nurses of the
1996 batch has not been effected although it is proposed to be,
based on the seniority list of 09-09-2002, which reveals that the
averment of the Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and 16 to 18 that
promotions have taken place is misleading. Hence, the prayers in
the Writ Petition be granted.
7.
Countering the arguments of Learned Counsel for the
Petitioner, Learned Senior Government Advocate would contend that
17 candidates were appointed in the year 1996 as against 43 vacant
posts of GNM that year thereby implying that the appointments
were made without any interview or Selection Test, the qualification
of the candidates being the sole consideration. Merely because the
name of the Petitioner appeared at Serial No.3 it could not be
interpreted as her inter se seniority. Moreover, seniority would be
reckoned from the date of joining and evidently the Petitioner joined
service only on 25-05-1996 as against others who admittedly joined
prior to her in time. Besides, should the date of joining be the same
then the date of birth and thereby the age of the candidate would be
the factor for consideration while fixing seniority. That, infact in the
year 1996 there were no Rules to follow for guidance on seniority
and the list was prepared at random, apart from which seniority is
not a fundamental right, but merely a civil right. Support on these
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
aspects was drawn from Bimlesh Tanwar vs. State of Haryana and
Others8.
Forwarding the argument that the Petition was filed
belatedly rendering the Petitioner guilty of laches, attention was
drawn to P. S. Sadasivaswamy vs. State of Tamil Nadu9. That, in the
instant case despite knowledge of the re-fixation of inter se seniority
in 2002 the Petitioner has approached this Court only in the year
2017, fifteen years after such exercise.
While arguing that the
Court can only enquire into whether the Rule laid down by the State
is arbitrary and irrational leading to inequality of opportunity
amongst employees belonging to the same class, reliance was
placed on Reserve Bank of India vs. N. C. Paliwal and Others10. It was
urged that in view of the grounds put forth, the Petition be
dismissed.
8.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and
16 to 18, while reiterating the averments made in her CounterAffidavit would refute the stance of the Petitioner strenuously and
contend that the Petition is liable to be dismissed, firstly on account
of the delay and laches, towards this end reliance was placed on
Vijay Kumar Kaul and Others vs. Union of India and Others11.
That the
Petitioner cannot claim ignorance of the Notification of 2002 being
undeniably aware that several Nurses of the same batch, some of
whom were working with
her, have
been redesignated and
consequently given higher responsibilities on the basis of the said
(2003) 5 SCC 604
(1975) 1 SCC 152
(1976) 4 SCC 838
(2012) 7 SCC 610
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Notification. That the averments made by the Respondents be given
due consideration and the Petition be dismissed.
9.
Submissions made at the bar were heard in extenso and
given anxious consideration. The pleadings and all documents
appended thereto have been carefully perused. What falls for
consideration before this Court is,
(i)
Whether the seniority of the Petitioner is to be
determined by the Office Order No.896/M./H&FW
dated
21-05-1996
followed
by
letter
bearing
No.277/H.&F.W. dated 19-11-1996, or would it be
determined by Notification No.13/H&F.W. dated
09-09-2002.
(ii)
Whether the Petition is liable to be dismissed on
account of delay and laches.
10.
Addressing the first question, a perusal of the Office
Order bearing No.896/M./H&FW, dated 21-05-1996 (Annexure P-2),
appointing the Petitioner as Staff Nurse with sixteen others, places
her name at Serial No.3 of the list of appointed candidates.
Indubitably the Petitioner joined on 25-05-1996 as against some
others who joined prior in time. Nevertheless, this Office Order was
followed by a letter to the Petitioner bearing No.277/H&F.W., dated
19-11-1996, which reads, inter alia, as follows;
“……………………………………………………………………….
I am forwarding herewith the seniority list with
relevant details for your perusal and acceptance
thereof.
Your acceptance or objection of any should be
submitted within 15 days from the date of issue of this
letter else it will be presumed that you have accepted
your seniority maintained by the Department and no
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
future request for alteration/ addition, modification of
the same will be entertained.
……………………………………………………………….”
The seniority list was appended to the letter addressed to the
Petitioner, for perusal and acceptance and included the names of
Staff Nurses appointed from 06-04-1979 to 18-08-1996.
In the
batch of 1996 alone, of the said list, the Petitioner‟s name found
place at Serial No.3 whereas in the overall rank in seniority she was
listed at Serial No.68.
The objection of the Petitioner was to be
submitted within fifteen days, if no such objection was forthcoming
it would be presumed that the seniority listed therein had been
accepted. It is no one‟s case that there was any objection from any
quarter within the given period of fifteen days, hence it would not be
erroneous to assume that the inter se seniority was decided in terms
of the list appended to the letter.
At this juncture, it would be
worthwhile considering whether the argument of the Respondents
that the date of joining would be the basis for computing seniority
can be countenanced. It would be advantageous to extract Rule 8
of the Establishment Rules which provides as follows;
“8.
Seniority.-
(a)
Direct recruits.-
(i) While making selection for direct
recruitment, the authority concerned while
making recommendations shall arrange the
names of the selected candidates in the order of
merit assigned to them by the authority. If all
the candidates join duty or training courses, as
the case may be, within the time limits
prescribed, inter-se seniority will be fixed in the
same order in which their names are placed at
the time of selection. Extension of the period of
training or probation in any individual case by
the Government shall not affect the inter-se
seniority.
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
……………..………………………………….……………..
(ii)
………………………………………
(b)
……………………………………….
(c)
………………………………………
(d) Once the inter-se seniority of a
Government Servant in one grade is determined,
it shall not be disturbed unless and until he is
either promoted to the next higher post or is
reduced in rank under the provision of the
procedure for disciplinary action.”
[emphasis supplied]
11.
The aforestated Rule at 8(a)(i) clearly lays down that
the names of the selected candidates shall be in the order of merit
assigned to them by the Authority. The Rule also provides that if all
the candidates joined duty within the time limit prescribed the inter
se seniority will be fixed in the same order in which their names are
placed at the time of selection. On examining Annexure P1 which is
a Memorandum bearing Memo No.533/M/H&FW/M dated 15-051996 and Office Order No.896/M./H&FW dated 21-05-1996 the
documents nowhere prescribe the time limit by which date the
Petitioner or her colleagues were to join duty. The order of
appointment having been issued on 21-05-1996 and the Petitioner
having joined duty on 25-05-1996 appears to have been considered
as reasonable time since the Authorities raised no objection. Rule
8(d) of the same Rules provides that the inter se seniority so
arranged shall not be disturbed unless the concerned person is
promoted or reduced in rank. What needs to be pointed out here is
that none of the seventeen appointees of 1996 objected to the name
of the Petitioner being placed at Serial No.3 in terms of Office Order
dated 21-05-1996 and communication dated 19-11-1996. Pausing
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
here for a minute, it would be appropriate to distinguish between
“merit” and “date of joining”.
Merit as per the Cambridge English
Dictionary would be “the advantages something has compared to
something else” while the date of joining obviously is the date on
which a person would join duty.
Merely because a person who is
placed lower in the merit list joins duty promptly on issuance of
appointment letter would not entitle that person placement at a
higher position than what he/she was placed on selection on merit.
Although it is the stance of the State-Respondents that seventeen
candidates were appointed as against a vacancy of forty-three
qualification
being
the
sole
consideration,
no
document
to
substantiate this contention finds place in the records. The Petitioner
for her part has submitted a letter issued to one Sancha Maya Rai in
1995 calling her for an interview for the Post of GNM. Although this
is indeed a tenuous argument, but it raises a reasonable probability
that an interview could similarly have been held for the 1996 batch.
12.
In Chairman Puri Gramya Bank (supra) the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court held that;
“12. ……………….. It is settled law that if more
than one are selected, the seniority is as per ranking of
the direct recruits subject to the adjustment of the
candidates selected on applying the rule of reservation
and the roster. By mere fortuitous chance of reporting
to duty earlier would not alter the ranking given by the
Selection Board and the arranged one as per roster.
The High Court is, therefore, wholly wrong in its
conclusion that the seniority shall be determined on the
basis of the joining reports given by the candidates
selected for appointment by direct recruitment and
length of service on its basis. The view, therefore, is
wrong. ……………………………………..”
[emphasis supplied]
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
13.
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
In Suresh Chandra Jha (supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court while considering whether seniority ought to be based on
merit or according to the date of joining held that;
“6. There is no dispute that the appellant was
ranked higher to Respondent 8. There is also no
dispute that in the appointment letter the appellant
was given six weeks' time to join. Merely because
Respondent 8 joined earlier that did not in any way
affect the merit placement.”
[emphasis supplied]
14.
We may now beneficially turn to Rule 4(d) and 4(f) of
the Regulation of Seniority Rules, which provides as follows;
“4.
Determination of seniority.-The seniority
of the members of the Service shall be determined
separately in respect of each Service in the manner
specified below,(a)
………………………………………………………….
(b)
………………………………………………………….
(c)
………………………………………………………….
(d)
The relative seniority inter-se of persons
recruited by selection shall be determined on the
basis of the order in which their names are
arranged in the selection list prepared in
consultation with the Commission:
Provided that where persons promoted
initially on a temporary basis are subsequently
appointed to the Service on a substantive basis
in an order different from the order of merit
indicated at the time of their temporary
promotion, seniority shall follow the order of
subsequent appointment and not the original
order of merit.
……………………………………………………………………
(f)
The seniority of persons who are
appointed to the Service by a method other than
by selection or by examination shall be
determined ad-hoc by the State Government by
a special order.”
[emphasis supplied]
These Rules in addition to the Establishment Rules supra,
elucidate the method of determining seniority. It was contended by
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Learned Counsel for Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and 16 to 18 that
Rule 4(f) of Regulation of Seniority Rules supra was applicable
herein, requiring a special order by the Government to determine
seniority as the Petitioner was appointed neither by way of selection
nor examination, but on possession of qualification.
That as no
special order issued her seniority could not have been determined in
1996. It would be apposite to reiterate here that the Respondents
have not been able to establish absence of interview or selection
test for appointment of the Petitioner.
While considering the
response given by the ASPIO of the Respondent No.1, to a question
put by the Petitioner vide her letter dated 02-05-2017 as follows;
“7(i) What are the provision/Rules under which
the Staff Nurses were appointed as per the O.O.
NO.895/M/H&FW dated 21.05.1996?”
The response dated 29-05-2017 of the ASPIO was as follows;
“01.
The basis of appointment is the rules prevalent
at the time and as per the advertisement notice
issued. The matter being of 21 years old (sic),
the department is unable to locate file, hence,
note sheets are unavailable.”
[emphasis supplied]
It goes without saying that the response being from the ASPIO
of the Respondent No.1 given under an RTI Application of the
Petitioner is deemed to be correct.
Since the appointment was
made in response to an advertisement, it can safely be assumed
that some semblance of a selection process was complied with. This
therefore sets to rest the speculation that the appointment was not
on merit consequently Rule 4(f) of the Regulation of Seniority Rules
could not be applicable.
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The law enunciated in the above extracted ratio sets to rest
the arguments of the Respondents on this aspect, inasmuch as the
date of joining cannot be reckoned for computing seniority.
15.
Counsel
The argument advanced by Learned Senior Government
urging
that
no
Rules
were
available
to
guide
the
Respondents on the question of seniority deserves no consideration
and cannot be countenanced in view of the truth that stares one in
the face in the form of the Regulation of Seniority Rules 1980 and
the Establishment Rules 1974, while the appointments admittedly
were of the year 1996. Undoubtedly the aforestated Rules ought to
have guided the Respondent on determination of seniority even in
the absence of the Nursing Service Rules which came to be enacted
only in 1997 and applied in proprio vigore with regard to the inter se
seniority of the persons selected.
16.
In K. Prasad (supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while
considering the sanctity of Rules would hold as follows;
“10. ………………. In view of such comprehensive
procedure laid down in the statute, an application for
upgradation has necessarily to be made and considered
strictly in a manner in consonance with the Rules. It
needs little emphasis that the Rules are meant to be
and have to be complied with and enforced
scrupulously. Waiver or even relaxation of any rule,
unless such power exists under the rules, is bound to
provide scope for discrimination, arbitrariness and
favouritism, which is totally opposed to the rule of law
and our constitutional values. It goes without saying
that even an executive order is required to be made
strictly in consonance with the rules. Therefore, when
an executive order is called in question, while
exercising the power of judicial review the Court is
required to see whether the Government has departed
from such rules and if so, the action, of the
Government is liable to be struck down.”
[emphasis supplied]
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
In terms of the aforesaid observation it is clear that the StateRespondents were required to abide by the mandate of law
pertaining to seniority in terms of the Rules and principles of law
extracted hereinabove and discussed.
In P. Mohan Reddy (supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
17.
held that;
“17. A conspectus of the aforesaid decisions of
this Court would indicate that even though an
employee cannot claim to have a vested right to have a
particular position in any grade, but all the same he
has the right of his seniority being determined in
accordance with the Rules which remained in force at
the time when he was borne in the cadre. ……………...”
We may look for succour to Rule 8(d) of the Establishment
Rules which dealing with this facet which provides that inter se
seniority cannot be meddled with once determined as already
discussed and which is not being reiterated here to prevent prolixity.
18.
In R. M. Ramual (supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has
held that;
“17. ………………………….. It is true that the final
seniority list was sent to the Central Government and
presumably it was approved, but because a seniority
list has been approved by the Central Government, it
cannot be laid down as a rule of law that even though
it has been illegally prepared in violation of the
directions of the Central Government itself to the
prejudice of the officer or officers concerned, it cannot
be challenged. Normally, when a seniority list has
been made final, it should not be allowed to be
challenged. But when a seniority list is prepared
ignoring all just principles and also the rules framed or
directions given by appropriate authority, seriously
affecting any officer, it is always liable to be examined
and set aside by the court. We are, therefore, unable
to accept the contention of the learned counsel for
Respondent 4 that the seniority list having been made
final after the approval of the Central Government
cannot be challenged by the appellant.”
[emphasis supplied]
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The observation supra would urge the Authorities to ensure
that seniority list is prepared keeping in view “just” principles.
19.
In Rajasthan State Industrial Development and Investment
Corporation (supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that;
“27. Executive instructions which have no
statutory force, cannot override the law. Therefore, any
notice, circular, guidelines, etc. which run contrary to
statutory laws cannot be enforced. [Vide B.N.
Nagarajan v. State of Mysore [AIR 1966 SC 1942] , Sant
Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan [AIR 1967 SC 1910]
, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) [(2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006
SCC (L&S) 753 : AIR 2006 SC 1806] and Mahadeo Bhau
Khilare (Mane) v. State of Maharashtra [(2007) 5 SCC 524 :
(2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 194].]”
While on this point, it is relevant to consider that in the first
instance after the seniority list was maintained in terms of the letter
dated 25-11-1996 there appears to be no amendment to the Rules
nor was there any Circular pertaining to change in the seniority,
besides which it needs no reiteration that executive instructions
cannot override the law.
The argument of the Respondents No.1
and 2 that the list of 1996 required rectification as the Petitioner‟s
date of appointment was recorded as “23-05-1996” instead of “2105-1996” is rather fragile and incredulous. Inarguably a letter dated
11-11-2016 was issued by the Respondent No.1 informing the
concerned officials of the intention of the Department to prepare an
inter
se
seniority
list
of
Staff
Nurses
in
2016.
No
such
communication or intention of resettlement of seniority appears to
have been issued in 2002.
20.
That, having been said a meticulous scrutiny of the
Nursing Service Rules, at Rule 13, clearly contemplates as follows;
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
“13.
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The inter-se-seniority of the member of the
service shall be determined in accordance with
the Sikkim State Service (Regulation of
Seniority) Rules, 1980.”
This Rule needs no further clarification suffice it to state that
the inter se seniority of the Nurses was to be determined in terms of
the Regulation of Seniority Rules which has already been discussed.
21.
It also becomes imperative to mull over the averment of
the Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and 16 to 18 which was as follows;
“13.
That the Screening Test of all the Staff Nurses
was done by the State Respondents based on
the Inter-Se-Seniority list of 2002, thereafter
Office Order 14/11/2016 was issued. The said
Screening Test was also neither challenge (sic)
nor protested by the petitioner. Said fact the
petitioner has waive her right (sic) to protest &
challenge the inter-se-seniority list of 2002 and
not knowing the seniority list of 2002 is
incorrect.”
No evidence exists of a screening test neither is it averred or
argued by the Respondents No.1 and 2. The Office Order dated 1411-2016 is bereft of allusion to any screening test. This averment
thus appears to be a figment of the imagination of the answering
Respondents, in the absence of substantiation by documentary
evidence. Another averment of the Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and
16 to 18 that draws the attention of this Court is that the seniority
of the Respondents is evident from the fact that they are in charge
of the SNCU and Dialysis Ward. On this count, Annexure P7 would
reveal that even the Petitioner is posted at the SNCU/NICU, would
this therefore bring her at par with the Respondents despite their
arguments to the contrary? That apart, the averments of the said
Respondents clearly indicate that Respondents No.7 and 18, have
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
been redesignated as “Sister-in-Charge” of different Wards not
promoted.
As per the Concise Oxford English Dictionary, Twelfth
Edition, Oxford University Press, the meaning of „redesignate‟ would
be “give (someone or something) a different official name,
description or title”
While, the meaning of „promotion‟ would be
“the action of raising someone to a higher position or rank”.
Redesignation is surely not equivalent to promoting a person and
there ought not to be any confusion on the nomenclature employed.
22.
The contention of the Respondents supra, that the
Nurses of the 1996 batch have been promoted has to be taken with
a pinch of salt, as a careful perusal of the documents on record
would reveal that promotions have been given to Staff Nurses
employed in the year 1981 up to 1994 which by no stretch of the
imagination included the 1996 batch. It is pertinent to mention here
that on 27-10-2017, this Court in I.A. No.02 of 2017 on a prayer of
the intervenors being Staff Nurses of 1995, inter alia, ordered as
follows;
“5.
In view of the detailed submission reflected
herein, it is evident that promotion with regard to the
Intervenors/Applicants who were appointed in the year
1995 is not in contest and if steps are taken for their
promotion, no prejudice will be caused to the
Petitioner. Accordingly, the State-Respondents No.1
and 2, if so advised, may proceed with the promotional
matter of the Intervenors/Applicants. The Order dated
14.7.2017, is modified accordingly”
Towards this, we may also rely on the response of the ASPIO
dated 29-05-2017 to the query of the Petitioner which states as
follows;
“08.
The promotion of staff nurse (sic) has not been
executed.
However, the promotion of Staff
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Nurses is proposed to be based as per Seniority
List published vide Notification No.13/H&FW;
Dated 09.09.2002. (Copy enclosed at flag „B‟)”
[emphasis supplied]
The argument supra of the Respondents thus merits no
consideration, being fallacious.
23.
It is the specific argument of the Respondent No.1 that
Notification of 2002 having been duly notified in the Department
would have precedence over the 1996 Notification and the Petitioner
cannot now claim ignorance.
Having perused the Notification
No.13/H&F.W. dated 09-09-2002, it emerges therein that a copy
each of the Notification has been made over to “All persons
concerned in the enclosed list” and to Authorities listed therein and,
File and Guard File.
What the Respondent No.1 has failed to
establish is whether all concerned persons had ever received the
said Notification. For that matter, Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and 16
to 18 have also failed to substantiate by any documentary evidence
or averment in that context that a copy of the Notification of 2002
was made over to them or received by them at any point in time.
The process of Departmental Notification has not been elucidated by
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 and 2. Over and above
the aforestated circumstances there is also no prior correspondence,
Office Circular or Notice to the concerned persons informing them
that inter se seniority was being restructured in the year 2002 as
against the seniority existing in 1996, thereby depriving them an
opportunity to put forth their stance.
As already pointed out the
rescinded letter of 11-11-2016 has offered such an opportunity
when such a process was being considered in 2006.
Hence, on the
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
existence of such lacuna and the foregoing discussions, in my
considered opinion, the Notification of 2002 cannot be said to have
any precedence over the Notification of 1996.
24.
While addressing the question of laches, reliance was
placed by the Respondents No.3, 5 to 14 and 16 to 18, on Vijay
Kumar Kaul (supra), which enumerates the proposition that a litigant
who invokes the jurisdiction of a Court claiming seniority has to
approach the Court at the earliest. In the matter at hand it emerges
with clarity that the Petitioner learnt of resettlement of seniority
only in 2016 which fact could not be countered by the Respondents.
Respondents
No.1
and
have
issued
Notification
of
unbeknownst to the Petitioner, they cannot therefore impute
knowledge of their act to her. Since she learnt of the resettlement
of seniority in 2016 which is supported by the letter of 11-11-2016,
which admittedly has been rescinded by the Respondents No.1 and
2, the conclusion thereof is that there has been no delay in the
Petitioner invoking the jurisdiction of this Court.
We may usefully
recall the ratiocination in R. M. Ramual (supra) already extracted
hereinabove observing, inter alia, that a seniority list illegally
prepared to the prejudice of Officer or Officers is always liable to be
examined and set aside by the Court.
25.
In conclusion, assuming a restructuring of the seniority
was necessitated on account of the error on the part of the
Respondent No.1 as claimed, such change ought not to prejudice
the Petitioner who was placed at Serial No.3 of the seniority in her
batch prior to the change made by the Notification of 2002. Indeed
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
the power that vests on the Respondents No.1 and 2 to fix inter se
seniority is not being questioned, but such an exercise cannot be
arbitrary or discriminatory and thereby offend the constitutional
safeguards.
In Anil Kumar Vitthal Shete and Others vs. State of
Maharashtra and Another12 the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed as
follows;
“33. From the above decisions, it is clear that it
is always open to an employer to adopt a policy for
fixing service conditions of his employees. Such policy,
however, must be in consonance with the Constitution
and should not be arbitrary, unreasonable or otherwise
objectionable. …………………………………………….”
26.
In the instant matter, the determination of seniority in
terms of Notification No.13/H&F.W. dated 09-09-2002 in view of the
foregoing
detailed
discussions
is
evidently
unreasonable
and
arbitrary.
27.
Consequently, Notification No.13/H&F.W. dated 09-09-
2002 is set aside as also the communication dated 22-09-2016.
28.
The Respondents No.1 and 2 shall comply strictly with
the seniority as laid out vide communication bearing No.277/H.&FW.
dated 19-11-1996.
29.
No order need issue for communication dated 11-11-
2016 or the consequences that would have flown from it, in view of
the correspondence having
No.2.
(2006) 12 SCC 148
been rescinded by the Respondent
WP(C) No.35 of 2017
Suman Rai
30.
Writ
Petition
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
is
allowed
and
stands
disposed
accordingly.
31.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Acting Chief Justice
26-07-2018
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
of
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review