Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE T.R.RAVI
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 31720 OF 2023
PETITIONER:
SUKUMAR K PANIKKER
PROPRIETOR, M/S SHREE INDUSTRIES,
B 370, OBEROI GARDEN ESTATE
CHANDIVALI FARM ROAD, CHANDIVALI,
ANDHERI EAST, MUMBAI, PIN - 400072
BY ADVS.
SRI.RENJITH THAMPAN (SR.)
SRI.V.M.KRISHNAKUMAR
SRI.P.S.SIDHARTHAN
RESPONDENT:
THE TRAVANCORE SUGARS AND CHEMICALS LTD
THIRUVALLA, VALANJAVATTOM.P.O,
PATHANAMTHITTA - 689104
REP.BY MANAGING DIRECTOR.
BY ADV SRI.P.K.RAKESH KUMAR
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
10.06.2024, THE COURT ON 08.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
T.R. RAVI, J.
-------------------------------------------W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
-------------------------------------------Dated this the 8th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
The writ petition has been filed praying for directions to the
respondent to refund the earnest money deposit and to release the
Bank Guarantee furnished by the petitioner, covered by Ext.P1.
2.
The
petitioner
entered
into
Ext.P1
agreement
on
01.07.2021 for supplying 13.5 lakh litres of Extra Neutral Alcohol (ENA
for short) to the respondent for the period 01.07.2021 to 31.12.2021,
pursuant to a tender floated by the respondent on 17.5.2021. The
petitioner had furnished Rs.7,50,000/- as Earnest Money Deposit
(EMD)
on
02.06.2021
Rs.6,75,000/-
on
and
a
08.09.2021.
bank
As
guarantee
per
Ext.P1
for
a
and
the
sum
of
tender
specifications "the supply of ENA shall be commenced as soon as the
agreement is executed and as per the supply order placed by the
respondent”. Though the agreement was executed, no supply orders
were placed by the respondent till 28.09.2021, submits the petitioner.
It is also submitted that the respondent placed supply orders for 2.10
lakh litres on 28.9.2021, 1 lakh litres on 22.11.2021, 1.80 lakh litres
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
on 25.11.2021, and 3 lakh litres on 26.12.2021, totalling to 7.9 lakh
litres, out of the promised quantity of 13.5.lakh litres. On 31.12.2021,
the date of expiry of the agreement, an order for 3.2 lakh litres is
stated to have been placed and the same was received by the
petitioner only after the period stipulated in Ext.P1, on 07.01.2022.
According to the petitioner, the respondents did not satisfy their part
of the contract and did not place orders for the entire quantity covered
by Ext.P1, within the stipulated time.
3.
The petitioner requested for return of the EMD amount of
Rs.7,50,000/- and the release of the Bank Guarantee for Rs.6,75,000/by letters dated 19.01.2022, 02.02.2022, 21.04.2022, 08.10.2022 and
30.01.2023. Thereafter, a request was made to the Managing Director
of 1st respondent on 10.5.2023, for the refund of the said amount and
release of bank guarantee. The writ petition has been filed in the
above circumstances.
4.
The respondent, which is a Government-owned company,
has filed a counter affidavit. It is stated that the tender was floated for
a requirement of 54 lakh litres of ENA and 10 bidders participated. M/s
Som Distilleries Pvt.Ltd, M/s Woodpecker Distilleries and Breweries
Pvt.Ltd, and the petitioner were the L1, L2 and L3 bidders respectively,
and it was decided to issue supply orders to the above-named
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
companies in the ratio of 2:1:1, which in quantity translates to 27 lakh
litres, 13.5 litres and 13.5 litres respectively. Ext.P1 was entered into
thereafter. It is admitted that a security deposit of Rs.7.5 lakhs was
made, which was to be refunded only on satisfactory completion of the
contract. It is also admitted that a Bank Guarantee was furnished as
required. The respondent contends that, as per the terms of the
agreement, the respondent has the right to recover any loss or
damage that may be incurred due to the non-execution of the
agreement and consequent non-supply of ENA at the agreed rate, from
the petitioner. It is admitted that as per Ext P1 agreement, the
respondent has to intimate their requirement and the petitioner should
thereafter, furnish their route of transportation, source and quantity of
ENA to the respondent. On receipt of the above information, the
respondent is to apply to the Excise department for NOC and permit. It
is also admitted that on receipt of NOC and permit from the Excise
department, the respondent must send the originals through courier to
the petitioner, who in turn must lift, transport and deliver the required
quantity. The supply of 8.5 lakh litres of ENA is admitted. The
respondent has also stated the reasons why they could not place the
orders immediately after Ext.P1 agreement. The justification for the
delay need not be considered in these proceedings. It is stated that on
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
6.12.2021, the respondent requested the petitioner to send route and
source of the ENA of 300000 lakh litres for applying for NOC and
permit from the Excise Department and that reminders sent on
16.12.2021 and 21.12.2021 did not evoke any response. It is stated
further that on 22.12.21, the respondent sent an urgent request for
400000 lakh litres of ENA and a reminder on 23.12.2021, that the
required route and source were furnished on 24.12.2021 and the
respondent applied for NOC and permit on 26.12.2021. On 30.12.2021
the Excise Commissioner issued NOC and permit for 2 lakh litres with
permit validity till 29.03.2022. It is submitted that the petitioner did
not supply the quantity. The respondent claims to have incurred a loss
of Rs.12,77,416/-. It is hence claimed that the respondent has the
right to recover the loss with interest from the EMD and the Bank
Guarantee furnished by the petitioner. It is contended that as per the
terms of Ext.P1 agreement, all disputes arising out of Ext.P1
agreement are to be raised in the courts in Pathanamthitta District,
and a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is not the
remedy.
5.
The petitioner has filed a reply to the counter affidavit
stating that, to his knowledge, there has been no production loss for
the respondent due to the non-supply of ENA and hence they are not
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
entitled to recover any damages for the loss. The respondent has
thereafter produced the audit report of the respondent as an additional
document, to show the position as per their accounts.
6.
Heard Sri.Renjith Thampan, Senior Advocate on instructions
by Sri.V.M.Krishnakumar, on behalf of the petitioner and Sri.P.K.Rakesh
Kumar, Standing Counsel for the respondent.
7.
The facts are not much in dispute.
As per Ext.P1, the
agreement was to supply 13.5 lakh litres ENA, from 01.07.2021 to
31.12.2021 as per the supply order issued by the respondent.
According to the petitioner, before the expiry of the agreement on
31.12.2021, the respondent had placed supply orders for 7.9 lakh
litres of ENA only, and the said quantity had been supplied by the
petitioner. It is seen that even after the expiry of the agreement on
31.12.2021, the respondent had placed a supply order on 07.01.2022.
According to the petitioner, he is not bound to comply with the said
supply order.
The petitioner submits that except for supplying a
quantity of 2.4 lakh litres, the rest of the quantity had been supplied.
It is in the above circumstances that the petitioner has requested the
refund of the EMD and the release of the Bank Guarantee. The writ
petition itself was filed after more than 18 months of the expiry of the
period stipulated in Ext.P1.
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
8.
A reading of Ext.P1 agreement would show that the
petitioner had to confirm the name of the supplier distillery, quantity
etc. to the respondent in writing based on the delivery schedule given
by the respondent so that NOC and import permits from Kerala Excise
Department can be arranged in time by the respondent at their cost.
Clause 12 of the agreement further says that in case of delay on the
part of the petitioner in confirming the name of the supplying distillery,
the responsibility will be solely that of the petitioner and the petitioner
will be liable for the losses that may be sustained by the respondent
due to the delay in the supply. The case of the respondent is that on
06.12.2021, they had requested the petitioner to send route and
source of 3 lakh litres of ENA for applying for NOC and permit from the
Excise Department.
Reminder is stated to have been sent on
16.12.2021 and when no response was offered by the petitioner, the
respondent had again sent an urgent reminder on 21.12.2021.
It is
stated that on 22.12.2021, the respondent sent an urgent request for
4 lakh litres of ENA and sent a reminder on 23.12.2021. It is stated
that the petitioner provided the route and source only on 24.12.2021
and thereafter the respondent had applied for NOC and permit on
26.12.2021. The NOC, received on 30.12.2021 for 2 lakh litres having
permit validity upto 29.03.2022, is stated to have been sent to the
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
petitioner by courier.
It is hence submitted that the petitioner was
under the legal obligation to supply 2 lakh litres of ENA as per Ext.P1
agreement itself. It is contended that even the said quantity was not
fully supplied. The above facts are not seriously disputed. However, it
is contended that even with the additional quantity required, the total
order issued comes only to 10.09 lakh litres out of the agreed quantity
of 13.5 lakh litres.
9.
The main contention of the respondent is that the petitioner
has to approach the competent civil court since these are disputed
matters relating to a contract, which cannot be agitated under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
judgment
of
a
learned
Single
Reliance is placed on Ext.R1(f)
Judge
of
this
Court
in
WP(C)
No.37921/2008, which relates to a claim by another supplier of ENA of
the respondent.
This Court held that adjudication into inter se
liabilities has to be done by a competent authority and cannot be the
subject matter of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
The counsel for the petitioner relied on the decision of a learned Single
Judge of this Court in Julie Sabu V. State Election Commission,
Tvm. (2024 (2) KHC 106) to submit that there can be no illegality in
entertaining a writ petition when there are no disputed questions of
fact. Reliance was also placed on a judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
Court in Deputy Commissioner, Central Excise and Another V.
Sushil and Company (2016 (13) SCC 223) to canvas the said
contention.
The counsel also relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Municipal Committee Katra V. Ashwani Kumar
(2024 KHC OnLine 8219), wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court had
held that disputes arising out of purely contractual obligations cannot
be entertained by the High Court in exercise of its extraordinary
jurisdiction under Article 226.
Reliance was also placed on the
decision in Union of India and Others V. M/s.Puna Hilda [(2021
KHC OnLine 6426 = (2021 (10) SCC 690)]. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the said decision held that a dispute arising out of terms of a
contract or a breach of a contract has to be settled by the ordinary
principles of the law of contract and the mere fact that one of the
parties to the agreement is a statutory or public body will not by itself
make a difference.
The said observation was an extract from an
earlier judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kerala State
Electricity Board & Another V. Kurien E. Kalathil & Others (2000
(6) SCC 293), wherein it was held that such matters cannot be
decided in a petition under Article 226.
10.
Having gone through the pleadings on either side, it cannot
be said that there are no disputed facts in the case on hand. I find
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
considerable force in the contention raised by the respondent that
these are not matters that can be settled in a writ petition under
Article 226. The petitioner has to approach the competent civil court
for relief.
11.
The writ petition fails and is dismissed, without prejudice to
the right of the petitioner to approach the competent civil court and
the period spent before this Court in this writ petition shall be excluded
for calculating the period of limitation.
Sd/-
T.R. RAVI
JUDGE
Pn/dsn
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 31720/2023
PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE AGREEMENT DATED
01.07.2021
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT DATED 02.06.2021
EVIDENCING DEPOSIT OF EARNEST MONEY
DEPOSIT OF RS.7,50,000/
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT DATED 08.09.2021
FOR FURNISHING BANK GUARANTEE OF
RS.6,75,000/-
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER SENT BY THE
PETITIONER TO THE RESPONDENT DATED
10.05.2023
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF LETTER ISSUED BY THE
TRAVANCORE SUGARS AND CHEMICALS LTD,
LETTER NO.TSCL/CMD/ENA/RE-TENDER/2022-2023
DATED 27.07.2023
RESPONDENTS' EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1 (a)
PHOTOCOPY OF THE TENDER CONDITIONS FOR
SUPPLY OF ENA DATED 17.5.21
Exhibit R1 (b)
PHOTOCOPY OF THE EMAIL COMMUNICATION DATED
6.12.21
Exhibit R1 (c)
PHOTOCOPY OF THE EMAIL COMMUNICATION DATED
NIL
Exhibit R1 (d)
PHOTOCOPY OF THE NOC BEARING NO:
NOCIPS/2021/01022 DATED 30.12.21
Exhibit R1 (e)
PHOTOCOPY OF THE NOC BEARING NO:
NOCIPS/2021/01023 DATED 30.12.21
W.P.(C). No.31720 of 2023
2025:KER:29926
Exhibit R1 (f)
PHOTOCOPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN WP (C) NO:
37921/2008 DATED 5.2.15
Exhibit R1 (G)
PHOTOCOPY OF THE AUDIT INSPECTION REPORT
BEARING NO: AMG-II/HQ II/A/12-9058/ 202123/38 DATED: 05.01.2024 OF THE ACCOUNTANT
GENERAL OF KERALA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review