Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16990/2025
Sukhbir Singh Sidhu S/o Sh. Mahendra Singh Sidhu, Proprietor Of M/s
Sukhbir Singh Sidhu, Registered Office: B-30, Raghav Marg, Hanuman
Nagar, Khatipura, Jaipur - 302012 (Rajasthan).
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation (RSRTC), through
its Chairman, Parivahan Marg, Chomu House, Jaipur - 302001
(Rajasthan).
2.
The General Manager, (Bus Body), Rajasthan State Road
Transport
Corporation
(RSRTC),
Parivahan
Marg,
Chomu
House, Jaipur - 302001 (Rajasthan).
3.
Executive
Director
(Engineering),
Rajasthan
State
Road
Transport Corporation (RSRTC), Head Offce, Parivahan Marg,
Chomu House, Jaipur - 302001 (Rajasthan).
4.
Azad Roadways Partnership Firm, through its authorised
partner, Booth No. 46, Anaj Mandi, Banur, Dist. Mohali,
Punajb-140601.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Narendra Kumar Pareek with
Mr. Kartavya Singh Shekhawat
Mr. Ajay Singh
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Ankit Bishnoi
Mr. Prateek Mathur
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAMEER JAIN
Order
Arguments concluded on
07.05.2026
Order reserved on
07.05.2026
Full Order or operative part pronounced
Full Order
Pronounced on
27.05.2026
1.
In the present writ petition, the scope of the controversy involved,
albeit not limited to, is broadly and predominantly defined by the
challenge raised qua the arbitrary, discriminatory, and illegal action of
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
(2 of 9)
[CW-16990/2025]
the respondent-Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation (for short,
‘RSRTC’) in frustrating the tender process for hiring of Non-AC 2x2
Starline BS-VI diesel fuel buses on kilometer basis, by conducting postbid price negotiations and subsequently awarding the contract to the L-2
bidder-respondent No.4 contrary to the explicit statutory prohibitions as
enshrined under the Rajasthan Transparency in Public Procurement Act,
2012 (for short, ‘RTPP Act’).
2.
The present writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, seeking the following prayers:
“(i) by issuing an appropriate writ, order or direction
quash and set aside the impugned action of the
Respondent Corporation in issuing the Letter of
Intent (LOI) to the L-2 bidder in respect of
Tender No.F5/HO/EDE/BB/HV/24/660, being
arbitrary, illegal, and contrary to the provisions of the
Rajasthan Transparency in Public Procurement Act,
2012 and the rules framed thereunder.
(ii) Direct the Respondent Corporation to act in
accordance with law by honouring the outcome of the
tender process and to issue the Letter of Intent (LOI)
in favour of the Petitioner, who has been declared as
the L-1 bidder after due technical and financial
evaluation and negotiation.
(iii) Declare that the Petitioner is entitled to all
consequential benefits, including award of work and
execution of contract, arising out of the said tender
process.
(iv) Pass any other or further order(s) that this
Hon’ble Court may deem just, fit, and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the present case, in the
interest of justice.
(v) Cost of the writ petition may kindly be awarded to
the Petitioner.”
FACTUAL MATRIX OF THE LIS AT HAND:
3.
Before adverting to the rival submissions and entering upon the
realm of arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the respective
parties, it is considered apposite to delineate the factual background
and the circumstances, in a nutshell, which have culminated in the
present adjudication:
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
3.1
(3 of 9)
[CW-16990/2025]
The respondent-RSRTC issued a Notice Inviting Tender dated
16.12.2024 for the hiring of Non-AC 2x2 Star Line BS-VI diesel fuel
buses on kilometer basis. The petitioner, a sole proprietorship concern,
participated in the said tender process.
3.2. After successfully filing an appeal under Section 38 of the RTPP
Act and being declared eligible, the petitioner qualified under both the
technical and financial bids and was formally declared as the L-1
(lowest) bidder at a price of Rs. 15.49 per kilometer.
3.3. Post the declaration of the financial bids, the petitioner was called
by the respondent-RSRTC vide letter dated 20.05.2025 to participate in
price negotiations. In pursuance of the same, the petitioner vide letter
dated 26.05.2025 offered a negotiated price of Rs. 15.25 per kilometre.
3.4
In the month of June 2025, the respondent-RSRTC proceeded to
issue the Letter of Intent (LOI) in favour of respondent No. 4-the L-2
bidder, who had agreed during the parallel negotiations to lower its rate
to Rs. 13.00 per kilometer, which was lower than the negotiated rate of
Rs. 15.25 per kilometer offered by the petitioner. Aggrieved by the
award of the contract to the L-2 bidder, the petitioner has approached
this Court by filing the present writ petition.
SUBMISSIONS PUT FORTH ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES:
4.
At the outset, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
the action of the respondent-RSRTC in bypassing the L-1 bidder and
conducting post-bid price negotiations is patently illegal, discriminatory,
and contrary to the explicit statutory provisions of the RTPP Act and the
rules framed thereunder.
5.
It was submitted that Section 15 of the RTPP Act categorically
prohibits price negotiations with any bidder after the opening of
financial bids, subject to narrow statutory exceptions, such as Sections
31 and 35, which do not apply to the present open bidding process.
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
(4 of 9)
[CW-16990/2025]
Therefore, the action of the respondents in carrying out negotiations is
entirely ultra vires and beyond their statutory jurisdiction.
6.
It was further submitted that once the petitioner was declared the
successful L-1 bidder, the respondents were under a legal obligation to
award the contract to the petitioner, and that the State authorities
cannot run contrary to the provisions of the parent Act. In support of
the contentions made insofar, learned counsel placed reliance on the
landmark judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Tata Cellular v.
Union of India, reported in (1994) 6 SCC 651 and submitted that the
writ petition is maintainable as the administrative action of the
respondents is tainted with gross arbitrariness and legal infirmity.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel Mr. Prateek Mathur, appearing on
behalf of the respondent-RSRTC vehemently opposed the present writ
petition and raised a preliminary objection regarding its maintainability.
It was submitted that judicial review is highly restricted in commercial
and contractual matters, and that the Writ Court cannot sit as an
appellate authority over the financial and business decisions of the
Corporation.
8.
It was next submitted that the tender document explicitly
contained a clause reserving the sole discretion of the RSRTC to accept
or reject any bid at any stage. It was argued that in the larger interest
of the Corporation, price negotiations were conducted with both the L-1
and L-2 bidders in a fair and transparent manner. It was further
submitted that while the petitioner refused to offer any rate below Rs.
15.25 per kilometer, the L-2 bidder-respondent No.4 agreed to perform
the contract at the rate of Rs. 13.00 per kilometer, thereby saving
substantial public revenue for the Corporation.
9.
To justify the procedure of the price negotiations carried out by
the respondents, reliance has been placed upon Rule 70(3) of the
(5 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
[CW-16990/2025]
Rajasthan Transparency in Public Procurement Rules, 2013 and it was
next
submitted
that
the
petitioner
actively
participated
in
the
negotiation proceedings without any demur, and having failed to match
the lowest offer, is now hit by the principles of estoppel and
acquiescence. In regard of the aforesaid contentions, learned counsel
relied upon the judgment dated 05.12.2024 passed by the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court at the Principal Seat, Jodhpur in S.B. Civil Writ
Petition No. 17666/2024 titled Mahadev Stone Crusher v. State
of Rajasthan & Ors., wherein it has categorically been held that if a
bidder participates in post-bid negotiations, they cannot subsequently
challenge the rejection of their bid and the same will be hit by the
principles of estoppel.
DISCUSSION AND FINDINGS:
10.
Having heard the rival arguments advanced by learned counsel for
the parties at length, considering the judgments cited at Bar, and upon
an assiduous perusal of the material available on record, including the
administrative records of the respondent-Corporation, this Court has
formulated the following views:
11.
As a threshold matter, this Court must address the preliminary
objection regarding the maintainability of the writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution of India. While it is a settled principle that courts
must exercise judicial restraint in commercial and contractual matters,
as public authorities require a certain degree of administrative flexibility,
it is equally trite that executive actions must strictly conform to the rule
of law. When a statutory body acts in flagrant disregard of a parent
legislation, the Writ Court is not only competent but is duty bound to
interfere to correct such a patent legal infirmity. Hence, the present writ
petition is maintainable.
(6 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
12.
[CW-16990/2025]
Adverting to the nitty-gritty of the instant dispute, the primary
question of law
to
be
adjudicated
is
whether
the
respondent-
Corporation, by incorporating terms in its bid document, can permit
post-bid price negotiations in direct contravention of the parent statute.
For better adjudication of the matter at hand, it is apposite to analyze
the mandate as enshrined under Section 15 of the RTPP Act, 2012,
which is reproduced as under:
“15. Price negotiations.- Save as otherwise provided
in Section 31 or Section 35 or in such circumstances
and subject to such conditions as may be
prescribed, no price negotiation shall be held by a
procuring entity with a bidder with respect to a bid
presented by him.”
(emphasis supplied)
13.
This Court has also analyzed the impugned condition as enshrined
under the tender document and the same has been reproduced as
under:
“The procuring entity shall award the contract to the
bidder whose offer has been determined to be the
lowest or most advantageous and if the bidder has
been determined to be qualified to perform the
contract satisfactorily on the basis of qualification
criteria fixed for the bidders in the bidding
document for the subject matter of procurement i.e.
hiring of buses on kilometer basis.”
(emphasis supplied)
14.
An assiduous analysis of the statutory scheme reveals that the
provisions enshrine under Section 15 of the RTPP Act allows price
negotiations only in exceptional circumstances under Sections 31 and
35, which pertain uniquely to emergent tenders and sole-bidder/singlesource procurement. The present tender, being an open competitive
bidding process, falls squarely within the restrictive mandate of Section
15 of the RTPP Act.
15.
or
It is a settled proposition of law that the instructions, guidelines,
tender
conditions
issued
by
the
State
authorities
and
its
(7 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
[CW-16990/2025]
instrumentalities cannot march contrary to, bypass, or override the
explicit provisions of the parent Act. If a bid condition or a rule runs
contrary to the parent statute, the same is ultra vires, void, and nonest. In regard of the aforesaid observations, this Court places reliance
upon the judgments encapsulated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Laghu Udyog Bharati v. Union of India, (1999) 6 SCC 418,
Collector
of
Central
Excise,
Vadodara
v.
Dhiren
Chemical
Industries, (2002) 2 SCC 127, and subsequently clarified by the
Hon'ble Constitution Bench in Commissioner of Central Excise,
Bolpur v. Ratan Melting & Wire Industries,(2008) 13 SCC 1,
wherein the settled position of law has been unequivocally reiterated
that subordinate legislation, administrative circulars, guidelines, or
executive instructions cannot override, bypass, or supplant the explicit
statutory provisions of law. Therefore, the terms and conditions of the
bid document permitting post-bid negotiations in an open tender are
void and the same are not sustainable in the eyes of law.
16.
The respondents have contended that the petitioner, having
participated
in
the
negotiation
meetings
on
20.05.2025
and
26.05.2025, is hit by the principles of estoppel and acquiescence and
the reliance in regard of the aforesaid submissions has been placed
upon the judgment of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Mahadev
Stone Crusher (supra). This Court notes that while the principles of
estoppel and acquiescence are relevant, it is equally trite that there can
be no estoppel against a statute, and therefore, this Court is of the
considered view that statutory violation of Section 15 of the RTPP Act
cannot be validated or cured by the mere participation of a bidder in an
illegal negotiation process.
17.
However, this Court cannot shut its eyes to the subsequent
developments and the element of delay and laches in the present case.
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
(8 of 9)
[CW-16990/2025]
It is pertinent to note that the Letter of Intent (LOI) was issued to
respondent No. 4 in the month of June 2025 and the petitioner, despite
being aware of the same, chose to approach this Court only in the
month of October 2025, after an unexplained lapse of approximately
four months. In the intervening period, much water has flown under the
bridge; the LOI has already been issued, the performance has
commenced, and the commercial operations are currently ongoing.
18.
Taking note of the fact that in commercial and public utility
contracts, time is of the absolute essence, this Court is of the view that
disrupting the public transportation services at this belated stage by
quashing an awarded contract would cause immense inconvenience to
the general public and the same will result in severe administrative
chaos.
19.
Moreover, considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
case at hand, this Court is of the opinion that the public interest in the
continuous operation of RSRTC buses must be balanced against the
technical violation of the procurement law, especially when the actions
of the respondent-RSRTC were guided by the bona fide objective of
saving substantial public revenue by securing a rate of Rs. 13.00 per
km against the petitioner’s offer of Rs. 15.25 per km.
CONCLUSION:
20.
In light of the aforesaid, this Court deems it apposite to note that
while the present writ petition cannot be allowed to the extent of
quashing the concluded contract due to the efflux of time, the flagrant
disregard of the RTPP Act by a State instrumentality such as the RSRTC
cannot be condoned. The statutory safeguard under Section 15 of the
RTPP Act was enacted to prevent arbitrary, non-transparent, and
corrupt practices in public procurement. Bypassing this statutory
[2026:RJ-JP:22234]
(9 of 9)
[CW-16990/2025]
mandate by incorporating contrary terms in bid documents strikes at
the very root of public accountability.
21.
In view of the foregoing discussions, findings and considering the
peculiar and unique nature of facts and circumstances involved in the
present case, this Court answers the point of law in favour of the
petitioner and holds that post-bid price negotiations in open competitive
bidding tenders are strictly prohibited and illegal as per the provisions
enshrined under Section 15 of the RTPP Act, 2012.
22.
Accordingly, the present writ petition is disposed in light of the
aforesaid observations. However, this Court refrains from interfering
with the ongoing contract of respondent No.4 due to delay, laches, and
subsequent developments.
23.
The respondent-RSRTC is hereby directed to strictly abide by the
provisions of Section 15 of the RTPP Act, 2012, in all future open
bidding tenders, and is restrained from incorporating any terms,
conditions, or guidelines in its bid documents that permit post-bid price
negotiations contrary to the parent Act.
24.
It is cautiously made clear that the present judgment shall not be
treated as binding precedent qua the work order issued in furtherance
of the Notice Inviting Tender/Bid processes.
25.
With the above observations and directions, the writ petition
stands disposed of. Pending applications, if any, shall also stand
disposed. No order as to costs.
(SAMEER JAIN),J
DEEPAK/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review