Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:26989
Digitally signed
by AJAY KUMAR
DWIVEDI
DN: cn=AJAY KUMAR
DWIVEDI, ou=HIGH
COURT, o=HIGH
COURT OF
CHHATTISGARH,
st=Chhattisgarh,
c=IN
Date: 2026.07.02
14:36:30 +0530
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ORDER RESERVED ON : 22/06/2026
ORDER DELIVERED ON : 02 /07/2026
WP(S) No. 9695 of 2023
Hemnidhi Patel S/o Shri Surajcharan Patel Aged About 55 Years,
Terminated Patwari, P.H. No.38, Tahsil Kharsiya, District Raigarh, Presently
Resident Of Village and Post Gorra, Police Station Kotra Road, Tahsil
Pussaur, District Raigarh (C.G.)
--- Petitioner.
-Versus-
1. The State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Revenue And Disaster
Management Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur,
Atal Nagar, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2. The Commissioner Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur (C.G.)
3. The Collector Raigarh, District : Raigarh, Chhattisgarh
4. The Sub-Divisional Officer (Revenue) Kharsiya / Disciplinary Authority
Tahsil Kharsiya, District : Raigarh, Chhattisgarh
5. The Tahsildar-Cum-Departmental Enquiry Officer Tahsil Kharsiya, District :
Raigarh, Chhattisgarh
6. The Naib Tahsildar Kharsiya-Cum-Departmental Enquiry Presenting Officer,
Tahsil Kharsiya, District : Raigarh, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondents.
WITH
WPS No. 9767 of 2023
Sukhan Say Sidar S/o Shri Gotharam Sidar, Aged About 61 Years,
Terminated Patwari, P.H. No. 29, Tahsil Lailunga, District- Raigarh, Presently
R/o Village Rudukela, Post, Police Station and Tahsil Lailunga, DistrictRaigarh, Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner.
-Versus1. The State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Revenue And Disaster
Management Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava Raipur,
Atal Nagar, District- Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2. The Commissioner Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
3. The Collector Raigarh, District- Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
4. The Sub-Divisional Officer (Revenue) Lailunga/disciplinary Authority
Tahsil- Kharsiya, District- Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
5. The Incharge Officer Of Land Record Branch Raigarh-Cum-Departmental
Enquiry Officer, Collectorate, District- Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
6. The Tahsildar Lailunga-Cum-Departmental Enquiry Presenting Officer,
Tahsil Lailunga, District- Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondents.
(cause title downloaded from CIS Periphery)
For Petitioners
:
Mr. Roop Ram Naik, Advocate.
For Respondents
:
Mr. Dilman Rati Minj, Dy. AG with Mr. Mayur
/State
Khandelwal, Panel Lawyer.
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi)
C.A.V. Order
1. Since both the petitions involve common questions of law and fact, and arise
from almost similar factual backgrounds wherein the petitioners were
terminated on the same date for identical reasons, both petitions have been
heard together and are being disposed of by this common order.
2. By way of the present petition the petitioners are seeking following reliefs:"10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue an appropriate writ/order to quash/set-aside the
impugned order dated 15.05.2023 (Annexure-P/1), passed
by the respondent No.2 (Commissioner) in which order
dated 21.12.2020 passed by respondent No.3 (Collector)
and order dated 28.07.2017 passed by the respondent No.4
(Disciplinary Authority) has been merged.
10.2 That, any appropriate writ, direction or order may
kindly be passed in favour of the petitioner, which Hon'ble
Court deems fit in the circumstances of the case."
3. WPS NO.9695/2023 (HEMNIDHI PATEL) - The petitioner, appointed as a
Patwari in 1995, was placed under suspension on 11.12.2015, by
Respondent No. 4. While suspended, a departmental enquiry was initiated
against him on 11.01.2016, involving a charge-sheet concerning a 'Benami
sale purchase' and tribal land' transactions, wherein the petitioner was
required to submit a 22 point report. During the enquiry, the petitioner’s
repeated requests to provide defence documents were ignored. On
01.04.2017, the Enquiry Officer recorded prosecution witness statements in
the absence of the presenting officer. The petitioner has also approached the
High Court by filing WPS No.1774/2017 which was disposed of on
17.04.2017 on the ground that since enquiry proceeding is going on and it
will open for the petitioner to raise the issue in appeal if eventuality arises.
The petitioner further pleaded that the enquiry was conducted in gross
violation of natural justice, alleging that his statements were forcefully
recorded, necessary defence documents were withheld, and he was denied a
fair opportunity to cross-examine prosecution witnesses. Based on an
enquiry report dated 22.04.2017, that found him guilty of the alleged
charges, and acting on the specific directions of the office of Collector,
Respondent No. 4 issued a final order terminating the petitioner from
service 28.07.2017. According to the petitioner, the petitioner’s subsequent
departmental appeals were consistently dismissed, first by the Collector on
21.12.2020, due to a self-stated lack of jurisdiction because the termination
was done on his own prior directions, and later by the Commissioner on
15.05.2023, who upheld the order of the disciplinary Authority, Collector.
Hence, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition to challenge the
validity of the disciplinary proceedings and his consequential termination
and prayed for relief mentioned above.
4. WPS NO.9767/2023 (SUKHAN SAY SIDAR) - The petitioner, appointed as a
Patwari on 23.09.1992, served in various circles within District Raigarh
before being suspended on 16.12.2015. Following the revocation of his
suspension on 06.02.2017, a Departmental Enquiry (DE) was initiated
against him on 20.03.2017 based on allegations of involving a charge-sheet
concerning a 'Benami sale-purchase' and tribal land' transactions, wherein
the petitioner was required to submit 22 point reports. The petitioner also
claimed that the enquiry was conducted in gross violation of natural justice,
alleging that his statements were forcefully recorded, necessary defence
documents were withheld, and he was denied a fair opportunity to crossexamine prosecution witnesses. The petitioner has also approached the High
Court by filing WPS No.1787/2017 which was disposed of on 17.04.2017 on
the ground that since enquiry proceeding is going on and it will open for the
petitioner to raise the issue in appeal if eventuality arises. However, he was
terminated from service on 28.07.2017 by respondent no. 4 under explicit
directions from respondent no. 3 (Collector) based on enquiry report.
According to the petitioner, his subsequent departmental appeals were
consistently dismissed, first by the Collector on 21.12.2020, due to a selfstated lack of jurisdiction because the termination was done on his own
prior directions, and later by the Commissioner on 15.05.2023, who upheld
the order of the disciplinary Authority, Collector. Hence, the petitioner has
filed the present writ petition to challenge the validity of the disciplinary
proceedings and his consequential termination and prayed for relief
mentioned above.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner in respect of WPS NO. 9695/2023
(Hemnidhi Patel) would submit that the imputation of charges levelled
against the petitioner was vague and based on false allegations. No specific
misconduct or misbehavior was mentioned against the petitioner in
connection with charges pertaining to the alleged 'Benami sale purchase' of
tribal persons. As per the charge levelled against the petitioners, they
indulged in the illegal sale and purchase of land of Village Kunkuni, but no
list of documents was supplied to the petitioners except a copy of the letters
and the enquiry report. He further submits that during the crossexamination of the departmental enquiry, no such documents which were
allegedly prepared by the petitioner have been exhibited. No opportunity for
cross-examination of departmental witnesses had been provided, thus
principle of natural justice has not been followed.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner in respect of WPS NO. 9767/2023
(Sukhan Say Sidar) would submit that in this case, statements of
departmental witnesses, who were the chairman/members of the Enquiry
Committee, were prepared and submitted before the Enquiry Officer on
01.04.2017. Since necessary documents were not provided to the petitioner,
he sought time for the cross-examination of the witnesses. He also submits
that though the petitioner was provided an opportunity of crossexamination, but no documents were provided to him enabling him to
properly defend himself. He also submits that the statements of
departmental witnesses in the form of affidavits were prepared on
27.03.2017, but on the same day, the petitioner filed an application for
providing a copy of the documents vide Annexure-P/5, but only some
documents were provided to him on 28.03.2017 i.e., after the recording of
the chief-examination and cross-examination of the departmental witnesses.
7. Learned counsel in respect of both the petitioners submits that no proper
opportunity of hearing was provided to the petitioners before passing the
order of major penalty. Furthermore, no evidence has been produced by the
respondent/Authorities to prove the involvement of the petitioners in the
alleged illegal sale/purchase of tribal land. He further submits that after the
submission of the enquiry report by the Enquiry Officer, the SDO Revenue
Lelunga/Kharsia forwarded the same to the Collector, Raigarh, but the
Collector suggested the removal of the petitioners. He submits that since the
Collector is not the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioners, he could not
have passed such an order; rather, the SDO (Revenue) Lelunga/Kharsia was
the Disciplinary Authority. However, the SDO (Revenue) Lelunga/Kharsia,
without application of mind, imposed a major penalty upon the petitioners
by the impugned order dated 28.07.2017 on the basis of the order given by
the Collector, Raigarh, which is completely illegal and arbitrary.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioners further submit that the petitioners were
discharging their duties with honesty and sincerity, but they have been
terminated from their service in an arbitrary and illegal manner, and yet
they have also not attained the age of superannuation. In support of his
contention, he places reliance on the judgments of Union of India Vs. Ram
Lakhan Sharma1 - Anil Gilurker Vs. Bilaspur Raipur Kshetriya Gramin Bank
and another2 and Union of India Vs. Gyan Chand Chattar 3. He lastly submits
1(2018) 7 SCC 670
2(2011) 14 SCC 379
3(2009) 12 SCC 78
that it is well-settled law that when disciplinary action is taken against an
employee, the inquiry must strictly follow official rules and the principles of
natural justice, which mean giving the employee a fair and proper hearing,
and the charges brought against them must be clear, specific, and detailed,
spelling out exactly what they did wrong and when. If the accusations are
vague or general, the employee cannot properly defend themselves. Because
of this, the entire inquiry cannot stand up in court and would be dismissed.
However, no such law has been followed by the Authorities in the present
case. Therefore, the impugned orders may be set aside and the petitioners
may be reinstated in service with back-wages and consequential service
benefits.
9. Respondent/State has filed its reply. Learned State counsel referring to its
reply would submit that the petitioner Hemnidhi Patel had filed document
Annexure-P/7 dated 27.03.2017, whereby he has requested for the supply of
documents, and documents were supplied to him on the same day, which is
also clear from the note-sheets dated 27.03.2017 and 01.04.2017. Further,
he himself had endorsed in the margin of the note-sheet that he received the
copy of the receipts 'विक्रय नकल' & 'नामांतरण पंजी'; despite that, the petitioner
did not cross-examine the departmental witnesses on 01.04.2017. Therefore,
the application/prayer by him seeking time to cross-examine witnesses has
been rightly rejected and, as such, it cannot be said that a due opportunity
of hearing was not provided.
10. Learned State counsel, in respect of petitioner Sukhan Say Sidar, submits
that the petitioner himself had cross-examined the departmental witnesses
on 27.03.2017. The learned State counsel fairly submits that after the cross-
examination of the witnesses, the document was supplied to him on the next
date of hearing, i.e., 28.03.2017, which has been endorsed in the application
(Annexure-R/2) itself.
11. Learned State counsel submits that in both cases, after a due enquiry
conducted by the 6-member team of Revenue/Government officials, it was
found that the petitioners indulged in illegal sale/purchase transactions of
tribal land with outside people, for which they prepared revenue documents
which were found proved in the departmental proceedings. The learned
State counsel further submits that the petitioners failed to raise any sound
defence in their statements and were unable to counter the charges levelled
against them. The petitioners were afforded a full opportunity of hearing
and principle of natural justice has been duly followed. Hence, the major
penalty of removal was imposed on the petitioners after following due
procedure under Rule 10 of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Classification,
Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as the "Rules,
1966"). In view of such submissions, he prays to dismiss both the writ
petitions.
12. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents placed
with the petition(s) with utmost circumspection.
13. The petitioners' case involves two land record officials i.e. who were
appointed as Patwaris. Both the petitioners had long careers serving in
District Raigarh before they were terminated on the same day i.e.
28.07.2017 for the same allegations which relates to illegal Benami land
sales in Kunkuni village. Before proceed with the matter it would apt to
peruse the allegations/charges levelled against the Petitioner - Hemnidhi
Patel by the Sub Divisional Officer (R) Kharsiya and Petitioner- Sukhan Say
Sidar by the Sub Divisional Officer (R) Lailunga, which is reproduced as
under:HEMLATA NIDHI PATEL
आरोप पत्र
श्री हेमनिधि पटेल निलंबित पटवारी ह०नं० 38 तहसील खरसिया द्वारा पूर्व
पटवारी ह०नं 13 में पदस्थापना के समय ग्राम कु नकुनी के आदिवासियों की भूमियों के
बेनामी क्रय-विक्रय में संलिप्त रहे ।
अनुविभागीय अधिकारी (रा.)
खरसिया
आरोप विवरण पत्र
आप पटवारी ह०नं० 26 तहसील खरसिया में पदस्थ रहने के दौरान खरसिया
तहसील आदिवासी ब्लाक होने के बावजूद भी ग्राम कुनकुनी के आदिवासी कृषकों की भूमि
को कुनकुनी से बाहर रहने वाले अनुसचि
ू त जनजाति के व्यक्तियों को आपके द्वारा बिक्री
छांट नकल दी जा कर आदिवासियों की भूमि बेनामी क्रय करने में सहयोग की गई है जो
कलेक्टर रायगढ़ के पत्र क्रं. 12231/वित्त-स्था./2015 दिनांक 01.01.2015 के साथ
संलग्न जाँच प्रतिवेदन से प्रमाणित है।
अनुविभागीय अधिकारी (रा.)
खरसिया
****
SUKHAN SAY SIDAR
आरोप पत्र
श्री सुखनसाय सिदार पटवारी तत्कालीन पटवारी तहसील खरसिया एवं वर्तमान
पटवारी तहसील लैलूंगा जिला रायगढ़ ग्राम कुनकुनी तहसील खरसिया के आदिवासियों
की भूमियों के बेनामी क्रय-विक्रय मामले में संलिप्त रहे ।
अनुविभागीय अधिकारी (रा.)
लैलूंगा
आरोप विवरण पत्र
आप तहसील खरसिया में पटवारी के पद पर पदस्थ रहने के दौरान खरसिया
तहसील आदिवासी ब्लॉक होने के बावजूद भी ग्राम कुनकुनी तहसील खरसिया के
आदिवासियों की भूमि कुनकुनी से बाहर रहने वाले अनुसूचित जनजातियों के व्यक्तियों को
आपके द्वारा बिक्री छांट नकल दी जाकर आदिवासियों के भूमि के बेनामी क्रय-विक्रय
मामले में संलिप्त रहे हैं जो कलेक्टर रायगढ़ के पत्र क्रमांक 12231/वित्त-स्था./2015
दिनांक 01.10.2015 के साथ संलग्न जांच प्रतिवेदन दिनांक 04.08.2015 से प्रमाणित है
।
अनुविभागीय अधिकारी (रा.)
लैलूंगा
14. The provisions for charge-sheet of imputation has been provided in Rule
14(3) of the Rules 1966 which is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:-
"Rule 14(3) - Preparation of charge-sheet.
(3)Where it is proposed to hold an inquiry against a
Government servant under this rule and Rule 15, the
disciplinary authority shall draw up or cause to be drawn up(i)
the substance of the imputation of misconduct or
misbehaviour into definite and distinct articles of charge;
(ii)
a statement of the imputations of misconduct or
misbehaviour in support of each article of charge, which shall
contain :(a)a statement of all relevant facts including any admission or
confession made by the Government servant;
(b)a list of documents by which, and a list of witnesses by
whom, the articles of charge are proposed to be sustained."
15. Bare perusal of aforesaid charges, statements of imputations reproduced
above and perusal of Rule 14(3) would show that only vague allegations
were made against the petitioners that they had indulged in alleged illegal
Benami sale purchase of land of tribals. The imputations of charge only
reveal that they prepare alleged "Bikri Chhant" and provided the same to the
persons, but nothing has been mentioned in the charge and the statement of
imputation that what is the Khasra number of area of the land, who were
the tribal owners and that to whom alleged Bikri Chhant was provided by
the petitioners. On such allegations, the disciplinary Authority has called
upon the petitioners to submit their defence statement in reply to the
charges. This Court fails to appreciate how the petitioners could have
submitted their written statement in defence in respect of charges and how a
fair enquiry could be held unless they were furnished with the particulars of
the alleged land of tribal persons and what document was executed in
respect of alleged indulgence of petitioners. In case of Surath Chandra
Chakrabarty Vs. Sate of W.B.4 the Hon'ble Supreme Court while considering
the vague imputation charges observed as under in Para 5:"5.....The grounds on which it is proposed to take action
have to be reduced to the form of a definite charge or
charges which have to be communicated to the person
charged together with a statement of the allegations on
which each charge is based and any other circumstance
which is proposed to be taken into consideration in passing
orders has also to be stated. This rule embodies a principle
which is one of the basic contents of a reasonable or
adequate opportunity for defending oneself. If a person is
not told clearly and definitely what the allegations are on
which the charges preferred against him are founded he
cannot possibly, by projecting his own imagination,
discover all the facts and circumstances that may be in the
contemplation of the authorities to be established against
him."
16. The aforesaid finding has been further reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in
Anil Gilurker Vs. Bilaspur Raipur Kshetriya Gramin Bank and
another5.
17. Needless to say, in the present case, all the departmental witnesses
examined by the Enquiry Officer were either the Chairman or members of
the Enquiry Committee, and the persons who had prepared the enquiry
report itself.
18. Further, as per the list of documents provided to the petitioners along with
the charge-sheet, the only documents provided were the enquiry report and
letter(s) of the Collector. However, no document was found to have been
provided to the petitioners which they had allegedly prepared, i.e., "Bikri
4 1970 (3) SCC 548
5(2011) 14 SCC 379
Chhant", or any other document prepared by them to show their indulgence
in the alleged sale and purchase transaction.
19. During the course of the enquiry, the petitioner Hemnidhi Patel filed an
application dated 27.03.2017 (Annexure-P/7) to provide documents to him.
In this regard, though in the enquiry note-sheet dated 01.04.2017 it has
been mentioned that the documents sought by him were not provided to
him on 27.03.2017, in the note-sheet dated 27.03.2017 it was endorsed by
him with regard to the receipt of copies of the sale deed and 'Namantaran
Panji'. However, nothing transpires from the charge and imputation of
charge as to what was the petitioner's involvement in respect of the
preparation of the alleged sale deed and 'Namantaran Panji'. Furthermore,
the alleged sale deed and 'Namantaran Panji' have neither been filed nor
proved by any of the departmental witnesses.
20. In the case of Petitioner Sukhan Say Sidar, he had filed an application for
providing copies of documents vide Annexure-P/5 (Annexure-R/2) on
27.03.2017, but the endorsement with regard to the receipt of documents
made by him in the aforesaid application shows that the documents were
provided to him on 28.03.2017, whereas the departmental witnesses were
examined on 27.03.2017. Thus, the documents were provided to him after
the recording of the examination-in-chief and cross-examination of the
departmental witnesses, which cannot be said to be a fair trial provided to
the petitioner.
21. In both the cases, as per the imputations of charge, they provided 'Bikri
Chhant' of lands of tribals for illegal sale and purchase transactions to the
outside persons of Village Kunkuni, but the 'Bikri Chhant' allegedly prepared
by the petitioners has also neither been filed nor proved or exhibited by the
departmental witnesses, which is evident from the examination-in-chief of
the departmental witnesses.
22. Moreover, in the case of Hemnidhi Patel, the examination of departmental
witnesses was recorded on 01.04.2017, but on that date, the petitioner filed
an application (Annexure-P/3) for grant of time for cross-examination of the
witnesses on the ground that he had filed an application under the RTI Act
on 29.03.2017 seeking some documents which had not been received by
him; therefore, he sought time to cross-examine the departmental witnesses,
but the same was rejected by the Enquiry Officer and subsequently the
matter was posted for recording of his statement.
23. Though in the case of Petitioner Sukhan Say Sidar, he was provided an
opportunity for cross-examination of the departmental witnesses, as has
been observed above, the statements of the departmental witnesses were
recorded on 27.03.2017, but despite an application filed by him to provide
copies of some documents, he was provided the same on the next date, i.e.,
28.03.2017, which is not justifiable.
24. In the case of Union of India and others Vs. S. K. Kapoor 6 the Hon'ble
Supreme categorically observed that "it is a settled principle of natural
justice that any material is to be relied upon in departmental proceedings, a
copy of the same must be supplied in advance to the charge sheeted
employee so that he may have a chance to rebut the same".
25. It is also apt to note here that all the departmental witnesses examined by
the Presenting Officer or Enquiry Officer were either the Chairman or
members of the Enquiry Committee itself who prepared the enquiry report.
(2011) 4 SCC 589
Thus, the status of such witnesses remained to be interested witnesses, as
they had already submitted a report against the petitioners.
26. The procedure with regard to recording of statement of witnesses is
provided in Rule 14(14) and 14(15) of the Rules, 1966 which reads thus:“Rule 14. (14) – Appearance of prosecution evidence and
witnesses.
14. (14) On the date fixed for the inquiry, the oral and
documentary evidence by which the articles of charge are
proposed to be proved shall be produced by or on behalf of the
disciplinary authority. The witnesses shall be examined by or on
behalf of the Officer and may be cross-examined by or on behalf
of the Government servant. The Presenting Officer shall be
entitled to re-examine the witnesses on any points on which
they have been cross-examined but not on any new matter,
without the leave of the inquiring authority. The inquiring
authority may also put such questions to the witnesses as it
thinks fit.
“Rule 14. (15) – Production of additional documents and
witnesses.
14.(15) If it shall appear necessary before the close of the case
on behalf of the disciplinary authority, the inquiring authority
may, in its discretion, allow the Presenting Officer, to produce
evidence not included in the list given to the Government
servant or may itself call for new evidence or recall and reexamine any witness and in such case the Government servant
shall be entitled to have if he demands it, a copy of the list of
further evidence proposed to be produced and an adjournment
of the inquiry for three clear days before the production of such
new evidence, exclusive of the day of adjournment and the day
to which the enquiry is adjourned. The inquiring authority shall
give the Government servant an opportunity of inspecting such
documents before they are taken on the record. The inquiring
authority may also allow the Government servant to produce
new evidence, if it is of the opinion that the production of such
evidence is necessary in the interest of justice.
Note. - New evidence shall not be permitted or called for or any
witness shall not be recalled to fill up any gap in the evidence.
Such evidence may be called for only when there is an inherent
lacuna or defect in the evidence which has been produced
originally.
27. After analysis of the structural mandate of Rule 14 of Rules, 1966, it reveals
a strict, sequential statutory framework designed to safeguard the principles
of natural justice during a departmental inquiry. Once a delinquent
employee denies the charges, sub-rule (14) places the absolute burden of
proof on the disciplinary authority to produce its oral and documentary
evidence first, granting the government servant an explicit right to crossexamine those prosecution witnesses.
28. In the instant case, as has been observed in the preceding paragraphs,
neither the alleged documents 'Bikri Chhant' had been provided to the
petitioners along with a copy of the charge-sheet, nor had those documents
been filed, exhibited, or proved by the Presenting Officer during the course
of the enquiry. Even due opportunity of cross-examination was not provided
to the Petitioner Hemnidhi Patel, whereas the Petitioner Sukhan Say Sidar,
though provided an opportunity to examine the departmental witnesses, was
provided the documents sought by him to be relied upon in his defence only
after the cross-examination of the witnesses. Thus, such lacunae and lapses
in the departmental enquiry proceedings, resulting in a major penalty,
cannot be appreciated, and it cannot be said that Rules 14(14) and 14(15)
of the Rules of 1966 were duly complied with and that the principles of
natural justice have been followed by the Enquiry Officer.
29. The Hon'ble Supreme in the case of Union of India Vs. Gyan Chand Chattar7,
after considering the various judgments observed that enquiry is to be
conducted against any person giving strict adherence to the statutory
provisions and principles of natural justice and held in Para 35 as under:"35.
In view of the above, law can be summarized that an
enquiry is to be conducted against any person giving strict
adherence to the statutory provisions and principles of
natural justice. The charges should be specific, definite and
giving details of the incident which formed the basis of
charges. No enquiry can be sustained on vague charges.
Enquiry has to be conducted fairly, objectively and not
subjectively.
Finding
unreasonable,
nor
the
should
same
not
be
should
perverse
be
based
or
on
conjunctures and surmises. There is a distinction in proof
and suspicion. Every act or omission on the part of the
delinquent cannot be a misconduct The authority must
record reasons for arriving at the finding of fact in the
context of the statute defining the misconduct."
30. Similarly, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sawai Singh Vs. State of
Rajasthan8 observed that even in a domestic enquiry, the charge must be
clear, definite and specific as it would be difficult for any delinquent to meet
the vague charges. Evidence adduced should not be perfunctory even if the
delinquent does not take the defence or make a protest against that the
charges are vague, that does not save the enquiry from being vitiated for the
reason that there must be fair play in action, particularly, in respect of an
order involving adverse or penal consequences.
31. In view of the aforesaid discussion made herein-above and the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, this Court finds that there are glaring
7(2009) 12 SCC 78
(1986) 3 SCC 454
deficiencies
in
the
departmental
enquiry
proceedings.
The
respondents/Authorities failed to produce, exhibit, and prove any specific
revenue documents and land records that were allegedly prepared or
manipulated by the petitioners to prove their indulgence in the alleged
illegal sale and purchase transactions of lands of tribals. It appears that
instead of introducing direct evidence, the Enquiry Officer relied entirely on
an enquiry report prepared by a six-member committee. Further, a major
penalty has been inflicted upon the petitioners, i.e., terminating them from
service, only on account of a direction given by the Collector, Raigarh to the
concerned Sub Divisional Officer (Revenue) Lailunga/Kharsiya, whereas the
Collector himself was not the disciplinary authority of the petitioners. The
aforesaid fact makes it clear that the major penalty of removal from service
has
been
inflicted
upon
the
petitioners
by
the
disciplinary
authority/concerned Sub Divisional Officer (Revenue) without application of
mind.
32. Hence, the manner in which the enquiry was conducted against the
petitioners right from the issuance of the charge-sheet is not in accordance
with the provisions contained in Rule 14 of the Rules of 1966, and the
enquiry is against the well-established law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court as mentioned in the preceding paragraphs. Therefore, the
impugned order of termination is not sustainable and same deserves to be
set-aside.
33. As a result, the impugned termination order dated 28.07.2017 against the
petitioners passed by the Disciplinary Authority, Sub Divisional Officer (R)
Lailunga and Kharsiya, respectively, in both cases are hereby quashed/setaside.
34. Consequently, the Appellate orders dated 21.12.2020 passed by the
Collector, Raigarh and subsequent order dated 15.05.2023 passed by the
Commissioner, Bilaspur Division, in both the cases respectively, are hereby
quashed/set aside.
35. The petitioners are entitled for reinstatement in service. However, they are
not entitled for monitory benefit for intervening period i.e. the date of
termination and reinstatement, but the said intervening period shall be
counted for other benefits i.e. notional promotion, seniority etc. in
accordance with applicable rules. Further, in case if any petitioner has
crossed the age of superannuation, then consequences shall follow as above,
in accordance with applicable rules.
36. The respondents are directed to reinstate the petitioners in service within a
period of 30 days from today.
37. Learned State counsel is directed to inform about this order to the
Respondents/Authorities forthwith.
38. The Writ Petitions are allowed the extent indicated above.
Sd/(Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi)
Judge
Ajay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review