Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
SECOND APPEAL NO: 582 OF 2025
Appeal Under Section 100 of CPC aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree
dated 09-06-2025 in A.S.No. 94 of 2024 on the file of the Court of the ll Additional
Chief Judge, City Civil Court at Hyderabad, confirming the judgment and decree
dated 15-02-2024 in O.S. No. 457 of 2014 on the file of the Court of the Vll Senior
Civil Judge, City Civil Court at Hyderabad.
Between:
Sudershan B.Singal, S/o Bajranglal Singal, Aged about 63 years, Occ. Business,
Proprietor of Broadways Logistics, 85D, Mohammed Ali Road, Masid Bandar West,
Mumbai, Maharastra-400003.
...APPELLANT/ AppellanUDefendant
AND
Powertex Tools Company Private Limited, Rep.by its firlanaging Director, Sri
Laxminarayan Gupta, S/o. Late Jawarlal Gupta, R/o 19-2-239111318, lndustrial Estate,
Chandulal Baradari, Hyderabad-500064. ...RESPONDENTS/ RespondenU
Plaintiff
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant stay of
all further proceedings pursuant to the Judgment and Decree, dated 15-02-2O24 in
O.S.No. 457 of 2014 on the file of the Hon'ble Vll Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court
at Hyderabad, confirmed by Judgment and Decree, dated 09-06-2025 passed in
A.S.No. 94 of 2024 on the file of the Hon'ble ll Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court
at Hyderabad, pending final disposal of the Second Appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant: SRl. PAPAIAH PEDDAKULA
Counsel for the Respondent:
The Court made the following ORDER:
THT] (]OURT[-OR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AI'HYDERABAI)
TI{E IIONoTTI{AI}LE SMT,. JTISTICI. RE,NT]KA YAITA
St-( OND APP[],.\l- No.5tl2 of 2025
9'rl l)AY oF .IANUARY ,2026
lletu ccn :
Sr"rdershlrn B. Si rrgal
Appe I I ant/appe I lant/def-endant
aud
Powertcr Tools Comparrr l)rivate Linrited
...Respondent/respondent/plaintitT
,I U D(]
\I E \T:
llcard Sri I\4. Papaiah Peddakula, leanre'd counsel lbr the appellant,
on adnrission. I)crused thc lccord
2.
l'his Se-concl Appeal is preferred aggrievcd by the judgrnent and
decree passed l,v tlre learrrcd II Additional Chie I Judge, City Civil Clourt at
Hyderabad (tbr short'the l]irst Appellate Court") in A.S.No.94 <tf 2024,
dated 09 06 1015 conflrrning the .ludgment and decree passcd by the
leanrecl \'ll Seniol Civil .ludge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad (forshort'the
I-rial Cotrfl')in O.S.No.457 of 2014, dated 15.02.2024, wherein, suit filed
,t
RY,J
sA 582 2025
for recovery of arnount of Rs. 1,84,593/- with interest @24Yo per annum
fiom 23.1 1.201 I till the date of realization has been dismissed.
3.
A perusal ol'the plaint shou,s that the suit for recovcry of rnoney was
t'iled on account of damage of goods that occun'ed in the rnonth of
November, 2011. The incident occurred when thc appellant herein handed
over goods imported from China to the respondent ftlr transportation in
f-our (4) lorries on l6.ll.20ll as per LRs bearing Nos.9WBIIW 50050,
9WBHW 50202, 9WBHW 50204 and 9WBHW 5010-i respectively. Out of
said lorries, three (3) lorries have reached the destination propcrly but the
4'h lorry did not arrive at Hyderabad Lill 22.1I .20 I I . On 23. I I .20 I I , the 4th
lorry bearing No.MH 258-9395 surprisingly came to l{yderabad and
shockingly delivered goods with shortage. The appellant's Manager made
endorsement on the backside about the short delivcry ofgoods and damage
to goods.
4.
'l'he appellant's Manager made endorsement on the backside
mentioning about the short delivery of l7 cartons t 4 carton goods in loose
condition. Further, the appellant opened the sealed carton and found many
goods were broken and damaged. A complaint was made to the respondent
I
on 10. 12.2011 about the said short delivery of goods and darnage to the
I
RY,.I
sA s82 2025
recejvccl goods. C)n 19.04.2012. a written remainder was also sent but
respondcnt did not repll and also did not pay the value of damaged and
shorl clclivcled goods. On 04.05.1012. the respondent had sent a letter
stating that total goods ri'ere delivered in good condition and therefbre,
demandcd liciglrt charucs. Further, on 07.05.2012, the lespondent stated
tl'rat the concerued lorrl u'l'rich delivered damaged goods has tnet i.vith an
accitierrt lbr u hich thc orvner of' the lorry lodged complaint and that the
resl-ronclcnt is not bound to pav the value of shoft delivcrcd goods and
danragcci goods. In that context, reference is rnade to the lonl receipt
w'hich is titled ''CI,ARRIER'S RISK/OWNERS RISK". Accordin-q to the
appellani, *herr -'ou'uer's lisk" is r-rot struck off, the goods are transpofted
at "carricr's risk". lrurthcr', the lorry receipt shall be deemed to have been
issued at CAIIRIEI{'S IIISK ONLY and therefore, suit tbr recovery of
monel is flled. The suit *,as adjLrdicated on merits and the judgment dated
I5.01.1024 uas passed against the appellant. It is held by the Trial Court
that thcre rvas r.ro opposition to the allegation made by the appellant about
the shortage ol 17 cartons and darnage to the goods. Therefore, It 1S
concludcd that tl'rere is shofiage of goods and damage to some of the goods.
Further. thc
-lrial
Clourl procceded to consider whether the respondent had
liable to pav llic cost of shorlage of goods or damaged goods. In that
t'
I
i
RY,J
sA 582 l02s
context, Exs.A4 to A7 consignrnent receipts vide L.l{.Nos.50050, 50202,
50204.50205 ar.rd Clause No. I olall the reccipts werc perused. rvherein, it
is clearlr stipulated as tbllorvs:
"[1'the transport opcrator does not dclcte one ol'the trv<l inscriptiorrs
on thc face of thc lorrl, receipt namely carrier's risk/orvner's risk. the
lorrl receipt shall bc deemed to have becn issucd a1 carricr's risk
on lr ."
5.
On thc basis of abovc extract. sincc the u,ord 'owner's risk' u,as not
struck oll-, thc l'rial Court held that thc carricr ulone has to b!'ar tlre burden.
Since there was no striking ol any ol thc nords, it is concluded that no
I
I
evidence is adduced by the appctlant to show that the goods \\'cre
I
transported at oruer's risk and that rnore particularl), in [:xs.A4 to A7,
I
there is spccific rllention that in casc of non-selectiorr, it is deenred that the
goods were transported at carrier's risk. In view ol the same. the suit has
been disrnissed and on a sin'rilar ground, tl're Appcal Suit hirs beetr
dismissed by the First Appellate Court. Aggricvcd b1'thc sanrc. the present
Second Appeal is preferred by raising the lollowing substarltial questions
of law:
a) Whethcr the Courts beloi.v erred in lar.v irt holdine that thc
carricr assumed liability trercly bccattsc tltc s'ords "ou'ttcr's
riskicarricr's risk" wcrc not struck ol'l- in thc invoice. s'ithout
any proved contract, agrcctncnt. or acccptancc as rcquircd
i
t
\
A
RY,J
sA 582 2025
under Sections 10" li and 14 ol the Indian Contract Act.
i
I87l'l
b) \\'hcthcr thc linclings ol'thc Courts below fastening liabilitl,
on lhe carricr. in iihscncc ol' any' rvrittcn or oral contract
sptcilicallr lixine thc risk on thc carrier, are contrary to
Sce tiorrs 7l-ri ol' thc ('ontract Act. rvhich mandatc prool'ol'
hrcirch antl prool' ol' c()ntraclual obligation before irnposiug
I
lilhilitr.'
C)
\\'hctlrel tlrt'C'ourls hclorv rnisdirected themselves in law b1'
:hitiirre the burdcrr ol'proof-upon the carrier rvhen under
Sections i() l- l0i trl the Evidcncc Act, it rvas lbr the
I.l.rirrt il'l e,'rsi!.1n,)r l() lrrr)\c an (jxpress conlract itttposirtl
calrier's risk'.'
d
) \\'hcthcr thc Cotrrls he-lorr erred in drawing an adverse
inll'rcrrcc asainst tlrc curric:r rnercly based on non-striking ol'
prc-printcd uords on un invoicc, rvhich is not a documcnt
c\ccr.ltL-d l.r.r tlre earricr and docs not constitute a binding
c(,lltract.)
c
) \\ hcthcr thc ('()urls belou,' cornmitted an error ol larv b1irrPotlills u 'dccrnctl carricr's risk'doctrine in the absencc ol'
lun\ stiltutor\ provision under the Contract Act, Carriers Act.
()r'.rir\ [rin(lins lcell principlc pcrmitting such presumption?
f) \\'hctlrcl tllc ('()urts bcln,v errcd in holding that non-striking
ol g.r1r11i1.111. irr a prc-printed invoice constitutes a concluded
coIlracl ir posing liabilitl,'. rvhcn scttled law prohibits
crcating crrutractual obligations hy implication or
prcsunrption'l
g) \\,hctlrcl thc ('otrlts hclou rnisapplicd Sections 6 and 9 of
thc Carricrs Act lrr presunrinq carrier's risk withoul the
plai nti 11' cstabl ishing nc-ail i gence, ntisconduct, deticicncy of'
scrr icc. or brcach as rcquired undcr law?
h
) Whethc'r thc (lourls bclorv erred in holding the carrier liable
u ilhout r.stablishins cnlrustment, condition of goods at
dr.'livcr1 . and thc cxact rnanner o['loss, thereby contravoning
nrandat.rr rct;trirc,re,ts undcr the Carricrs Act?
i
RY,J
Sz\ 582 l0l5
i) Whcther the findings ol both Courts arc pcrverse and
contrary 1o the evidence on record, inasmuch as the liability
rvas fastcned solcll' on the basis of rn ambiguous remark in
thc invoicc that s,as ncither prepared hl thc carricr nor
supl'loflcd br anr contractual tcrrns.'
.i) Whethcr tlre Courts belorr' lailed to considcr that tlrc inr oicc
is a unilatcral docurlent trithe consignor and (annot bind the
carrier unless erprcssll, accepted as pcr lau''.)
k) Whether the Clourts below erred in larv in treating silcnce or
non- striking of' u,ords in a third-partr document as
acccptance under Sectiorl 7 of thc Contract Act. rihcn
acceptance nlust be absolute. unqualilled. and
cornmunicatcd'l
l) Whcther thc Courts belo*' ignored tlre settlctl principlc that
no contractual liability can arise rvithout c()nscnsus ad idsrn.
and thcrcb)' arrived at findings opposcd to tlndarrental
principles ol' contract larv?
ni) Whcther the Courls belor,v rnisapplicd legal prcsunrptions
under the llvidence Act in assurning asscnt to risk
conclitions. therebl' creating liabilitl'contrar\ to thc statutory
schcnre under thc Contract Act and Carricrs Act?
6.
A Second Appeal can be entertained only when there are substantial
questions of law raised before this Court. as contemplated under Section
100 of CPC. Thc l{on'ble Supreme Court of India in Hemavathi v. V.
Hombegowda' hetd that High Court can entellain a regular Second Appeat
purely on a 'substantial' question of law not even a question of law or a
question of fact. Further, as per the judgment of this Court in Syed Abdul
i '(202s)s scc 442
I
RY,J
sA 582 2025
Qutldus r. K. \'ija1a Larnri2. the Apex Court in Gurdev Kaur v. Kakil
held that thc Iligh ('ourt sitting ir.r Second Appeal cannot examine the
evidencc oncc usuin as.r third trial Clourt and the porvcr undcr Section I00
CPC is verl' linrited rnrl it can be exercised onlv u,here a substantial
question ol'lau is raiscci and tl'll fbr consideration. The evidence can be
appreciated irr a Seconcl ,,\ppcal rvhen tlrere are perverse ftndings on
account of'r.ron-crrrrsiclcrirtion ol'relevant cvidence or findings given on the
basis of irrclcrrnt luctors. \\/hcn lhe current case is considered, the dispute
ir-rvolves an accitle nt to u lon'r' bearing No.MH 25 R 9395. On account ol'
the accident. thcrc ri,as ltrss o1'goLrds terured as shortage ofgoods. Further,
irt some cart()n\. thtrrrsh tlre carfu)ns rvere sealed frorn outside, goods inside
u,ere clarr utqccl
.
Therc' is no rlis;'rutc about the occurrence ol the accident or shofiage
and danrage to tht- goods transpoftcd in lorry bearing No.MH 25 B 9395
vide [-.1{ No ()\\'l}ll\\"
5 010_i
issued br, respondent. The only tactual
question that is irrr olr ecl is u ho rs liable to bear the cost ol'such loss which
occurred duc to th.'accicient. l'hc l-actual issue to be decided was whether
the goods wcrc trallsl)orted at owner's risk or carrier's risk. In that regard,
': 2024 scc onLine Ts 18G
'(zooz) r scc sqo
ri
RY,J
sA 582 2025
heavy reliance is placed on Exs.A:l to ,A7 i.e. oliginal L.Rs bearing
Nos.50050, 50202, 50204, 50205, al dated 16. I 1.201 I issr-red by
respondent. Said lorry re'ceipts contain Terms and Conditions ol Carriagc
Carrier's Risk or Owenr's Risk, rvherein, at Serial No.l, it is rncntioned
that in case transport operator does nut clclcte one o{'the fir'o inscriplions on the
face ol thc lorrv rcccipt. narnely CARItlFll{'S RISK/OWNEI{'S RISK. the lorrl'
rcccipl shall be decmed to hare been issued at CAITRIER'S I{lSK onh.
8.
Thus. lactual finding giver.r b-v-, the Trial Court as well as the First
Appellate Corrrt is based on docunientary evidence. There is a concurrcnt
I
tinding b_r' the Trial Coun and the First Appellate Coufl about the
transpoflation ofgoods at carrier's risk since canier's risk rvas not deleted
I
by the transpotler. Such being the case. in view of thc concurrent f-actual
I
I
findings giverr, this Couft cannot re-assess or re-examine the sarne point in
the Second Appeal.
9.
Corning to the aspect of the questions raised in the guise of
substantial questions of lalv, they are all related to the t-actual f rnding about
at whose liability the goods were transpofted with clever drafting invoh'ing
sections of Contract Act, Evidence Act and Carriers Act. No amount ol
'l
clever drafiing can camoullage finclings invited about the findings of lact
)
)
I
RY.J
sA 582 2025
given b1 the First Appclllte Court and the Trial court. This coutt, thereflore,
sees llo meril in the substantial (lucstions of law raised by the appellant for
tlre purpose ol'cnterlainirrg thc Se cond Appcal and thc sarne is liable to be
dismisscd.
10. ln the rr'sult. thc Scconrl Appcal is disnrissed at the stage of
admission. 'I'here shall lrc no ordcr.rs to costs
Pendinq rrriscellirneorrs ap|licetions. il-any. shall stancl closed.
".'S,1'+'cE8,Sf;tR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The ll Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court at
I
I
Hyderabad
2. TheVll Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court at Hyderabad.
3. One CC to Sri papaiah peddakula, Advocate
tOpUCI
4. Two CD Copies
kuliba
W
HIGH COURT
DATED:09/0112026
,(
1HE
.i, .: '1".
Lr.'\,,
/;\
\t
\P
l:
tr
2 3
1-
2,lj''
t
\ rO
*
JUDGMENT
SA.No.582 of 2025
DISMISSING THE SECOND APPEAL AT THE
STAGE OF ADMISSION
WITHOUT COSTS
b
,{
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review