Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.170 of 2022
Subrata Majumder, S/o Sri Chandan Majumder, R/o Town Indranagar, P.ODhaleswar, P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799007.
……......... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. The Tripura State Pollution Control Board to be represented by the Member
Secretary, Tripura State Pollution Control Board, P.N. Complex, Gorkhabasti,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. The Member Secretary, Tripura State Pollution Control Board, P.N. Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
3. The Chairman, Tripura State Pollution Control Board, P.N. Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. The Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries, Government of Tripura, P.N.
Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
…….... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate,
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate.
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Date of hearing and judgment : 19thMarch, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting : YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Kawsik Nath, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr. Ratan Datta,
learned counsel for the respondents.
[2]
Writ petitioner has been proceeded against under memorandum of
charges dated 19th September, 2022 for alleged misconduct in terms of Rule 14
of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965. He approached the writ Court with the main and
primary ground of challenge that respondent No.2 is not competent to act as a
disciplinary authority under the Tripura State Pollution Control Board
(TSPCB) as he is a serving Scientist B in TSPCB. He has not been appointed in
terms of Section 4(2)(f) and Section 12 of the Water (Prevention & Control of
Pollution) Act, 1974. There has been no delegation of authority in terms of
Section 12(3) (b) of the Act. The writ petitioner has also raised a ground that
respondent No.2, not being a full time Member Secretary, cannot be the
Disciplinary Authority in terms of Rule 12(2)(b) of the CCS(CCA) Rules,
1965. The writ Court dealt with both these issues and declined to interfere in
the matter. The opinion of the writ Court contained in paragraph Nos.5 to 23
are being extracted hereunder:
―5. I have pondered over the erudite submissions canvassed by learned counsel
appearing for the parties and considered the legal positions.
6. “Disciplinary Authority” is defined under Rule 2(g) of CCS Rules which means
the authority competent under the CCS Rules to impose on a Government servant
any of the penalties specified in Rule 11of CCS Rules. Rule 12 of CCS Rules
prescribes the powers and functions of the disciplinary authorities, which reads as
under:
―12. DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITIES:
(1) The President may impose any of the penalties specified in Rule 11 on any
Government servant.
(2) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-rule (1), but subject to the provisions
of sub-rule (4), any of the penalties specified in Rule 11 may be imposed on –
(a) a member of a Central Civil Service other than the General Central Service, by
the appointing authority or the authority specified in the schedule in this behalf or by
any other authority empowered in this behalf by a general or special order of the
President;
(b) a person appointed to a Central Civil Post included in the General Central
Service, by the authority specified in this behalf by a general or special order of the
President or, where no such order has been made, by the appointing authority or the
authority specified in the Schedule in this behalf.
(3) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
(4)) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
EXPLANATION 1) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
EXPLANATION 2) *** *** ***
*** *** ***
*** *** ***
7. On plain reading, it appears that Rule 12(2)(b) of the CCS Rules is relevant to the
issue in controversy. Rule 12(2)(b) clearly lays down that a person can be appointed
to a civil post by the authority under special order of the President or, where any
such order has been made by the appointing authority.
8. To clarify the meaning attached to the expression ―disciplinary authority‖, the
Government of India issued certain orders. One of such orders relates to the officers
performing current duties of a post. It says that an officer appointed to perform the
current duties of an appointment can exercise administrative or financial power
vested in the full-fledged incumbent of the post, but he cannot exercise statutory
powers, whether those powers are derived direct from an Act of Parliament [G.I.,
M.H.A., O.M. No. F. 7/14/16-Ests. (A), dated 24th January, 1963].
Another order speaks that where appointment to hold the current duties of a
post involves the exercise of statutory or such other powers conferred on the holders
of the post, the appointment should also be notified in the gazette. [G.I., M.F. O.M.
No. F. 12(2)-E, II.(A) 60, dated 15th October, 1960].
9. From the above orders, it becomes clear that an officer appointed to perform the
current duties of a post cannot be treated as full-fledged incumbent of the post and
he cannot exercise statutory powers. However, statutory or such other powers can be
conferred on the holders of the post if such appointment of the officers is notified in
the gazette. To sum up, an officer merely looking after the current duties of a higher
officer is not competent to exercise the power of disciplinary authority or the
appellate authority of the latter, unless and until the appointment of such officer is
made by appointing authority being duly notified in the official gazette.
10. At this juncture, I have taken note of the scheme of the Water Act of 1974,
which is a central act. It becomes apparent that in pursuance of clause 1 of Article 22
of the Constitution of India, resolutions had been passed by all the houses of the
legislature of the States of Assam, Bihar, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh,
Jammu & Kashmir, Karnataka, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Tripura and
West Bengal to the effect that the matters relating to prevention and control of water
pollution and the maintaining or restoring of wholesomeness of water should be
regulated in those States by the Law of Parliament.
11. Sub-section (2) of Section 1 of the Water Act of 1974 envisages that it was
applied in the first instance to the State of Tripura including other States, as
aforesaid. Sub-section (3) of Section 1 of the Water Act of 1974 provides that it
came into force at once to the aforesaid States. Section 4(2)(f) of the Water Act of
1974 is required to be noticed in the context of the case. It provides that:
―4. Constitution of State Boards.— (1) The State Government shall, with effect from
such date, as it may, by notification in the Official Gazette, appoint, constitute a
[State Pollution Control Board], under such name as may be specified in the
notification, to exercise the powers conferred on and perform the functions assigned
to that Board under this Act.
(2) A State Board shall consist of the following members, namely:—
(a) xxxxx
(b) xxxxx
(c) xxxxx
(d) xxxxx
(e) xxxxx
[(f) a full-time member-secretary, possessing qualifications, knowledge and
experience of scientific, engineering or management aspects of pollution control, to
be appointed by the State Government.]‖
12. It is noticed that clause (f) of sub-section (2) of Section 4 was not enacted in the
original Water Act of 1974. Clause (f) was inserted by the Amendment Act 53 of
1988 in the original enacted Act of 1974 and it came into force in the State of
Tripura w.e.f. 29.08.1988.
13. Now, if both CCS Rules and Water Act of 1974 are conjointly read, it is
crystallized that the law as conceptualized for the posts of ―Current duties and fulltime Member Secretary‖ is quite distinct and created on different connotations. The
two posts should not be mistaken as equivalent. While Rule 12 of CCS Rules speaks
of officers merely performing current duties of a post, the concept of the post of fulltime Member Secretary embodied in Section 4(2)(f) of the Water Act of 1974 is to
give the said post a statutory flavour. A full-time Member Secretary is a statutory
post incorporated in the Act of 1974 by Act 53 of 1988 especially for the States of
Tripura, Himachal Pradesh and Union Territories to fulfill certain objects the
respective governments wanted to achieve.
14. That apart, it is apparent that under Section 4(2)(f) of the Act of 1974, the State
Government is statutorily empowered to appoint a full-time Member Secretary
having qualification, knowledge and experience of scientific, engineering or
management aspects of pollution control. In other words, the State Government is
the appointing authority of a full-time member secretary of Tripura State Pollution
Control Board.
15. Now what is culled out that a full-time Member Secretary being appointed by the
State Government can exercise all statutory powers which includes the power of
disciplinary authority as contemplated under Rule 12(2)(b) of CCS Rules apart from
the powers conferred upon him, and perform the functions assigned to him in the
interest of the State Pollution Control Board.
16. Coming to the context of the present case, the Government of Tripura
constituted State Pollution Control Board under the nomenclature Tripura State
Pollution Control Board (for short, „TSPCB‟) at the behest of the Department of
Science, Technology and Environment in terms of Section 4(1) of the Water Act of
1974. To run and govern the TSPCB, the State Government has appointed Dr. Bishu
Karmakar as a full-time Member Secretary of the Board. It is not disputed that Dr.
Bishu Karmakar possesses all necessary qualifications, knowledge and experience in
the field of pollution control. It is admitted that Member Secretary is the disciplinary
authority of TSPCB and can exercise the powers of disciplinary authority as
embodied in Rule 12(2)(b) of CCS Rules.
17. In the case on hand, the State Government being the appointing authority issued
necessary order appointing Dr. Bishu Karmakar as full-time Member Secretary by
way notification published in the official gazette. The notification for appointment
of Dr. Karmakar may be reproduced here-inbelow, for convenience, in extenso:―No. 1966
Registered No. N.E. 930
TRIPURA GAZETTEE
Published by Authority
EXTRAORDINARY ISSUE
Agartala, Thursday, September 19, 2019 A.D. Bhadra 28, 1941 S.E.
PART-1- Orders and Notifications by the Government of Tripura
The High Court, Government Treasury etc.
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY & ENVIRONMENT
No. F.11(68)/DSTE/CC/Pt-I/5597-606
Dated, Agartala the 7th September, 2019
In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (f) of sub-section (2) of section (4) of
the Water (Prevention and control of pollution)Act of 1974 (Act 6 of 1974) and in
the interest of public service, the Governor, Tripura is pleased to order that Shri
Bishu Karmakar, scientist-B, Tripura State Pollution Control Board shall hold the
charge of Member Secretary in the Tripura State Pollution Control Board (TSPCB)
on full time basis with immediate effect and until further orders. Any other work
assigned to him in the Board shall be re-assigned to other officer9s) in the TSPCB,
Ex-post facto approval is also accorded to assignment of the charge of Member
Secretary, TSPCB to Shri Bishu Karmakar, Scientist-B in addition to his assigned
duties w.e.f. 13.08.2019.
By order of the Governor
Sd/(Shailendra Singh)
Special Secretary to the
Government of Tripura‖
18. The tenure of appointment of Dr. Bishu Karmakar has been further extended
vide notification dated 6/05/2021 which is also notified in the official gazette of the
Government of Tripura. The notification dated 6/05/2021 is reproduced here-inbelow:
―No. 1135
Registered No. N.E. 930
TRIPURA GAZETTEE
Published by Authority
EXTRAORDINARY ISSUE
Agartala, Thursday, June 30, 2022 A.D. Asadha 9, 1944 S.E.
PART-1- Orders and Notifications by the Government of Tripura
The High Court, Government Treasury etc.
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY & ENVIRONMENT BIGYAN,
PRAJUKTI O PARIVESH BHAWAN
GORKHABASTI: P.N. COMPLEX
AGARTALA:TRIPURA
No.F.8(1)/DSTE/ENV/Pt-IX/3106-166
Dated, 06/05/2021
NOTIFICATION
In partial modification of the Notification No. F.11(68)/DSTE/CC/Pt-1/5597606 dated 07.09.2019 issued by the Department of Science, Technology &
Environment, Government of Tripura, Shri Bishu Karmakar, Scientist-B, Tripura
State Pollution Control Board (TSPCB) holding the Charge of the Member
Secretary, TSPCB on full time basis will continue to hold the Charge of the Member
Secretary, TSPCB on full time basis till completion of the recruitment process of the
eligible candidates to this post of Member Secretary as per the ―Tripura State
Pollution Control Board [Prevention & Control of water Pollution (Amendment)]
Rules, 2021.
This is issued with the approval of Hon’ble Council of Ministers, Govt. of
Tripura vide Memorandum No. F.1(1)-GA(CAB)/2021-C dated 23.04.2021.
Sd/(Saradindu Choudhury)
Secretary
Govt. of Tripura‖
19. The above notifications crystallize that the appointment of Dr. Bishu Karmakar
has been made in exercise of the powers conferred under clause(f) Sub-section 2 of
Section 4 of the Water Act of 1974 by the order of the Governor.
That the Member Secretary of TSPCB can exercise all statutory powers and
perform all statutory duties as disciplinary authority in the interest of TSPCB as
contemplated under Rule 12(2)(b) of the CCS Rules has not been disputed by
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. To reiterate, it is the only grievance of
the petitioner that Dr. Bishu Karmakar not being appointed through regular
recruitment process and merely holding the post temporarily acted as disciplinary
authority, which is not permissible under Rule 12 of CCS Rules, since, according to
learned counsel for the petitioner, this power is exclusively vested with a permanent
i.e. regularly appointed Member Secretary.
20. I am constrained to say that Mr. Nath, learned counsel fails to visualize the
distinctive features as regards the appointment of the officers performing current
duties of the higher post and the full-time Member Secretary under TSPCB and
misconstrued both Rule 12(2)(b) of the CCS Rules and Section 4(2)(f) of the Water
Act of 1974.
21. I have already stated and analyzed the law that the post of full-time Member
Secretary under TSPCB is a post recognized under the statute (Water Act of 1974).
The incumbent Officer of the said post being duly appointed under Section 4(2)(f) of
the Water Act of 1974 as enumerated here-in-above can exercise all statutory
powers derived direct from the Act of Parliament or rules made under various
Articles of the Constitution in addition to the performance of normal day to day
administrative or financial function. Needless to say that CCS Rules, 1965 is framed
in exercise of the powers conferred by proviso to Article 309 and clause (5) of
Article 148 of the Constitution of India.
22. As a sequel, I do not find any infirmity or legal impediment in the order passed
under impugned memorandum dated 19/09/2022 by Dr. Bishu Karmakar, the fulltime Member Secretary of TSPCB to hold inquiry under Rule 14 of CCS (CC&A)
Rules, 1965 against the petitioner herein.
23. Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of merit.
However, there shall be no order as to costs‖
[3]
Since the writ petition was dismissed, the writ petitioner is before
us in appeal. In appeal the same grounds of challenge have been reiterated
relying upon the Section 4(2)(f) and Section 12 of the Water (Prevention &
Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 read with Rule 12(2)(b) of CCS (CC&A) Rules,
1965.
[4]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the writ petitioner,
has placed reliance on the following decisions in support of his plea that the
person holding current charge cannot perform statutory duties:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
[5]
Ajaib Singh versus Gurbachan Singh and others reported
in AIR 1965 SC 1619.
Union of India and another versus Raghuwar Pal Singh
reported in AIR 2018 SC 1411.
Girja Shankar Shukla versus Sub-Divisional Officer,
Harda and others reported in AIR 1973 MP 104 (FB).
It is submitted that the decision of the full bench of Madhya
Pradesh High Court has been referred to in the case of Ramakant Shripad Sinai
Advalpalkar versus Union of India and others reported in 1991 Supp(2) SCC
733 and affirmed. Based on this submission learned senior counsel for the writ
petitioner submits that the respondent No.2 is incompetent to hold a disciplinary
enquiry against the writ petitioner who is serving as a Scientist-B in TSPCB.
Therefore, the impugned judgment deserves to be set aside. The memorandum
of charges issued against the petitioner dated 19.09.2022 be also quashed.
[6]
Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel for the respondent has taken this
Court to the averments made in the counter affidavit before the writ Court. He
submits that the learned writ Court has duly taken note of the nonfiction issued
in exercise of Section 4(2)(f) of the Water (Prevention & Control of Pollution)
Act, 1974 whereby the petitioner was appointed on full time basis as a Member
Secretary of the TSPCB till further orders with the rider that any other work
assigned to him in the Board shall be re-assigned to other officers in the
TSPCB. This notification dated 07.09.2019 has been issued in the name of the
Governor by the Department of Science Technology & Environment,
Government of Tripura which is competent to take such a decision. He has also
referred to the subsequent notification dated 06.05.2021 which was also taken
note of by the learned Single Judge whereby one Shri Bishu Karmakar,
Scientist-B, TSPCB who is holding the charge of respondent No.2 that is
Member Secretary, TSPCB has been allowed to continue to hold the charge of
the Member Secretary, TSPCB on full time basis till completion of the
recruitment process of the eligible candidates to this post of Member Secretary
as per the ―Tripura State Pollution Control Board [Prevention & Control of
Water Pollution (Amendment)] Rules, 2021. He submits that both these
notifications have been duly notified and are issued upon the approval of the
Hon’ble Council of Ministers of the Government of Tripura.
[7]
Learned counsel for the respondent has also referred to the
notification of the central Government contained in O.M. dated 15th October,
1960 and the O.M. dated 24th January, 1963 both of which have been taken
note of by the learned Single Judge to hold that Sri Bishu Karmakar holds the
post of respondent No.2-Member Secretary, TSPCB. He has been appointed as
a full time Member Secretary and is empowered to exercise statutory powers.
He submits that therefore the legal competence of the present incumbent to the
post of respondent No.2 cannot be disputed. He is empowered not only to
perform administrative and financial duties but also all statutory duties of the
post of Member Secretary, TSPCB in view of the conferment of power upon
him in terms of Section 4(2)(f) read with Section 12 of the Water (Prevention
& Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 including that of the disciplinary authority in
respect of the writ petitioner.
[8]
We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant pleadings placed from record. We have
also gone through the impugned judgment rendered by the learned writ Court.
The appointment of Sri Bishu Karmakar has been made on full time basis by
decision of the Council of Ministers of the Government of Tripura in exercise
of powers under Section 4(2)(f) of the Water (Prevention & Control of
Pollution) Act, 1974 and duly notified in the extraordinary Gazette. He is not
appointed on current charge basis which could confine his discharge of duties
to routine administrative and financial matters only. This appointment has been
made till a full time Member Secretary is appointed through direct recruitment.
We have gone through the findings and reasons recorded by the learned writ
Court. We approve of the reasons rendered by the writ Court on both the issues
concerning the appointment of Sri Bishu Karmakar, as Member Secretary,
TSPCB, i.e. respondent No.2. Section 4(2)(f) deals with the constitution of the
Central Board & the State Board and Section 12 of the Water (Prevention &
Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 contains the terms & conditions of service of
the Member Secretary of the Board. These provisions are to be interpreted in a
manner that serves the object and purpose of the Act. Under these provisions,
the State Government has been empowered to appoint and constitute a State
Pollution Control Board to exercise the powers conferred and perform the
functions assigned to the board under the Act by way of a notification. The
notification of the State Government appointing Sri Bishu Karmakar as a
Scientist-B under the Tripura State Pollution Control Board on full time basis
to discharge the functions of the Member Secretary, TSPCB is not under
challenge. As such, the incumbent appointed by a statutory exercise of power
by the State Government is fully empowered to discharge the functions of a
full time Member Secretary of the State Pollution Control Board and also to act
as a disciplinary authority over the employees subordinate to him. As such, we
fully endorse the view expressed by the learned Writ Court.
[9]
Learned senior counsel for the writ petitioner has relied upon the
decisions rendered by the Apex Court in the case of Ajaib Singh versus
Gurbachan Singh and others reported in AIR 1965 SC 1619; Union of India
and another versus Raghuwar Pal Singh reported in AIR 2018 SC 1411 and
Girja Shankar Shukla versus Sub-Divisional Officer, Harda and others
reported in AIR 1973 MP 104 (FB). The case of Ajaib Singh (Supra) relates to
Preventive Detention Act, 1950 wherein the District Magistrate only is
empowered to pass an order of detention and to review the detention order. An
officer of the rank of Additional District Magistrate (ADM) could not have
exercised the statutory power conferred upon District Magistrate during vacancy
in the office of the District Magistrate, more so, since powers of detention
cannot be exercised by any officer below the rank of District Magistrate. The
instant judgment is, therefore, not applicable to the present case. The decision
relates to the power exercisable under the Preventive Detention Act, 1950
therefore, is not applicable to the present case. In the case of Union of India and
another (supra) we find that one H.S. Rathore was made the Director-in-charge
without approval of the competent authority while he was an Agriculture
Officer. He had proceeded to make certain appointments exceeding his
authority. In those circumstances, the Apex Court by referring to the office
memorandum dated 24.01.1963 issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs held
that an officer appointed to perform the current duties of an appointment can
only exercise administrative or financial powers but he cannot exercise statutory
powers derived from acts of parliament or Rules & Regulations. In the present
case the appointment of Sri Bishu Karmakar has been made by exercise of
statutory power by the State Government on the basis of the decision of the
Council of Ministers, on full time basis. As such, the instant decision also does
not apply to the case at hand. Similarly, in case of Girja Shankar Shukla
(supra) it is noticeable that the incumbent Shri Arun Kumar Kshetrapal was
holding the current duty charge of the post when the Collector had proceeded on
leave. Shri Arun Kumar Kshetrapal, Sub-Divisional Officer was placed in current
charge of the duties of Collector during that period when the elections were held to
the post of President and Vice President of the Municipal Council. In those
circumstances, the learned Full Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court after
referring to the provisions of Section 55 of the Madhya Pradesh
Municipalities Act and the Madhya Pradesh General Clauses Act held that the
Sub-Divisional Officer holding current charge was competent to exercise the
statutory powers conferred on the Collector under Section 55 of the Act.
However, at the same time it was made clear that but for the statutory provisions
the
Sub-Divisional
Officer
would
be
competent
to
discharge
the
administrative functions but not the statutory functions attached to the post. The
decision therefore does not apply to the case at hand. Therefore, we do not find
any substance in the grounds of appeal. Accordingly, the instant appeal is
dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(S. D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Munna S MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2024.04.02 17:08:01 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review