Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC040000022026
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/2/2026
Subodh Kuamr Rai
Son of Shri Ramji Rai, resident of Mir Mir Tinali, PO and PS Pasighat, East Siang
District, Arunachal Pradesh 791102
VERSUS
The Arunachal Pradesh Rural Bank and Anr
a joint undertaking of Govt of India, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh and State Bank of
India Naharlagun, 791110, represented by its Board of Directors, having its Head
Office at E Sector, Shiva Mandir Road, PO and PS Naharlagun, Papum Pare District,
Arunachala Pradesh 791110
2:The Chairman cum Disciplinary Authority
Age: 0
Occupation :
Arunachal Pradesh Rural bank
Head Office at E Sector
Shiva mandir Road
PO and PS Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh 79111
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Bedanta Kaushik, Petitioner in Person,Takar Bagang,Pankaj Borah
Advocate for the Respondent : Teto Taba, SC (Rural Bank)
BEFORE
Hon’ble MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
Page No.# 2/14
Advocates for the petitioner
: Subodh Kumar Rai - in person
Advocates for the respondents
: Shri T. Taba, SC-AP Rural Bank
Date on which judgment is reserved :
31.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment:
07.04.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the
judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced? : Yes
Judgment & Order (oral)
The present case was listed in the admission column and the petitioner in
person has expressed urgency in the matter and requested for taking up of the
same for disposal at the admission stage. The same not being opposed by the
learned counsel for the respondent – Bank, the matter is accordingly taken up
for final hearing at the admission stage.
2.
The instant writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India have
been filed seeking the following relief:
“PRAYER
In the premises aforesaid, it is therefore prayer that that Your Lordship's
would be graciously pleased to admit this Writ Petition, call for the records
and issue rule, calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why:
1) A Writ in the nature of Certiorari and/or any other writ, order or
direction should not be issued to set aside and quash the impugned
order of termination dated 30/04/2025;
2) A Writ in the nature of Mandamus should not be issued directing
Page No.# 3/14
the Respondent authorities to rescind the order dated 30/04/2025
thereby reinstate the petitioner to his post;
3) A Writ in the nature of Mandamus should not be issued directing
the respondent authorities to pay his back wages along with all
accrued
allowance,
benefit
and
other
entitlements
w.e.f.
01.05.2025;
4) A writ in the nature of Mandamus should not be issued directing
the respondent authorities to refund the amount of Rs 93,000/deducted from his monthly pursuant to order dated 30.04.2025.
5) And/or be pleased to pass such further order / orders as your
Lordships may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case.”
3.
As per the facts projected, the petitioner was appointed in the Arunachal
Pradesh Rural Bank (hereinafter the Bank) on 03.01.2022 as Assistant Manager
on probation for a period of two years. In April, 2023 he was posted at the
Bhalukpung Branch as the Branch Manager. On 29.03.2025, the petitioner was
served with a letter calling for explanation (explanation letter) regarding certain
irregularities which were detected and the same was replied to by the petitioner.
Thereafter, the impugned order dated 30.04.2025 was passed whereby he was
terminated from his service. It is the aforesaid action, which is the subject
matter of challenge in the present writ petition.
4.
I have heard the petitioner in person. I have also heard Shri T. Taba,
learned counsel for the respondent – Bank.
5.
The petitioner has submitted that while on probation, he was posted as a
Branch Manager of the Bhalukpung Branch without providing any training and
Page No.# 4/14
adequate support staff. He had also contended that the probation period, as per
the Rules was two years which is extendable by one year whereafter, the
services are required to be confirmed and, in this regard, there is default on the
part of the Bank in not passing appropriate orders of confirmation of service. He
has also submitted that there is a vast difference between the letter dated
29.03.2025 calling for explanation and the reasons cited in the impugned order
of termination dated 30.04.2025. He has submitted that new factors have been
taken into consideration by the respondent - Bank while passing the termination
order which were not part of the letter dated 29.03.2025.
6.
The petitioner has also submitted that in the investigation carried out,
there is no element of any fraudulent activity and also there was no mention of
the amount of Rs.93,000/-. Rather, there was only an indication of an amount of
Rs.9500.92. Under such circumstance, the respondent Bank could not have
directed deduction of the amount of Rs.93,000/-. He has also submitted that
after expiry of initial period of two years from the date of his appointment, the
probation period was extended and if there were any allegations earlier, the
probation would not have been extended. He has also contended that there has
been violation of Article 311 of the Constitution of India and Regulation 39 of
the AP Rural Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulation, 2010
(hereinafter, Regulation of 2010). Lastly, he has contended that the termination
letter is stigmatic which would be a hindrance for the petitioner in applying in
any other job.
7.
In support of his submission that there is a difference between the
explanation letter and the order of termination vis-à-vis the allegations, the
petitioner has relied upon the case of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in
2025 INSC 1212 [Ravi Oraon Vs. State of Jharkhand] and the following
Page No.# 5/14
observations have been pressed into service:
“33. The present is akin to a situation where the noticee successfully
defends the charge against him but is made to suffer civil consequences
because the notifier finds the noticee guilty of a different charge in
respect whereof he is not put to notice. In such a case, the finding of guilt
which is at variance with the original charge without proper opportunity to
respond offends due process and renders any order or action
unsustainable.”
8.
Reliance has also been placed upon a judgment of the Hon’ble Madhya
Pradesh High Court in the case reported as 2024: MPHC:JBP:47153 [Govind
Singh Lodhi Vs. Union of India]. In the said case, certain observations have
been made that public sector banks are to ensure that newly recruited officers
who are under probation are not entrusted with the job of recommendation and
process of loans.
9.
Per contra, Shri Taba, the learned counsel for the respondent Bank has
submitted that the impugned action has been taken by following the due
process of law and by giving the petitioner adequate opportunity. He has
submitted that gross irregularities were detected in the duties discharged by the
petitioner including opening of fictitious account in the name of one Sargary
Basumatary and another account in the name of the Branch itself by using the
PAN and TAN of the Branch.
10.
By drawing the attention of this Court to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by
the respondent Bank, the learned counsel for the Bank has submitted that
admittedly, the service of the petitioner is governed by the Regulation of 2010.
In the appointment letter dated 03.01.2022 itself, there was a clear stipulation
Page No.# 6/14
that the services would be on probation for a period of two years and
confirmation would be subjected to various conditions. For ready reference,
Clause 3(g) of the appointment order is extracted hereinbelow:
“g). You will be put on Probation for 2(two) year and confirmation in the
Bank will be subject to satisfactory report on your work, punctuality,
intelligence, moral character etc. from the official under whom you will be
serving and receipt of satisfactory Police Verification Report, regarding
your character and antecedents.”
11.
The learned counsel for the Bank has referred to Regulation 8 which
pertains to Probation and Regulation 9 which pertains to Confirmation. It is
submitted that the period of probation would be two years which is extendable
for a period not exceeding one year. Regulation 9 provides that an officer would
be confirmed if, in the opinion of the appointing authority, he has satisfactorily
completed his probation. It is also provided in Clause 9(2) that if appointing
authority is of the opinion that the officer is not fit for confirmation, his services
may be terminated by giving one month notice.
12.
The learned counsel for the Bank has submitted that since the beginning
of his appointment, the conduct of the petitioner has not been above board and
there were show-cause notices / explanation call on a numerous occasion and
the said aspect is brought on record. He submits that the impugned action is
fully justified and is in the interest of public. On the aspect of alleged difference
between the explanation letter and termination letter, the learned counsel for
the Bank has submitted that after the explanation letter was issued, a factfinding investigation was carried out when many fraudulent activities were
detected. He has also referred to Regulation 39 which lays down that for facts
admitted, enquiry, per se is not mandatory.
Page No.# 7/14
13.
The rival contentions advanced by learned counsel for the parties have
been duly considered and the materials placed before this Court have been
carefully examined.
14.
From the records and the pleadings, the following facts, which are
undisputed, emerge. The petitioner was appointed as an Assistant Manager of
the respondent – Bank on probation vide an order dated 03.01.2022 for two
years and the impugned order of termination dated 30.04.2025 is preceded by
an order of calling for explanation dated 29.03.2025. It is not in dispute that the
proceeding was at the stage when the petitioner was still under probation as
there is no clause of deemed probation in the Regulations. On the contrary,
there is a specific clause in the appointment letter namely, Clause 3(g) which
lays down that after expiry of the probation period, the Bank may confirm the
services which would be subject to satisfactory report on the work. In this
regard, the Regulations contain specific provisions, both for Probation and
Confirmation. For ready reference Regulation 9 is extracted hereinbelow:
“9.
Confirmation:-
(1) An officer or employee shall be confirmed in the service of the Bank if
in the opinion of the Appointing Authority, the officer or employee has
satisfactorily completed his probation.
(2) Where during the period of probation, including the period of
extension of probation, if any, the Appointing Authority is of the opinion
that the officer or employee, as the case may be, is not fit for
confirmation in the said post,(a) In the case of a directly appointed officer or employee, his
services may be terminated after giving one month's notice or pay in
Page No.# 8/14
lieu thereof;
(b) In the case of an employee, promotion from Group 'B' to scale 1
of Group 'A' or from Group 'C' to Group 'B', he may be reverted to
the post from which he was promoted.”
15.
A bare perusal of the aforesaid Regulation would reveal that if in the
opinion of the appointing authority, an officer or employee is not fit for
confirmation, his services may be terminated by giving one month notice or pay
in lieu thereof. In the instant case, it is not in dispute that the impugned order
of termination dated 30.04.2025 fulfills the aforesaid condition.
16.
With regard to the submission advanced by the petitioner that there is a
difference between the letter dated 29.03.2025 of calling for explanation and
the impugned termination order dated 30.04.2025, this Court is inclined to
accept the submission advanced on behalf of the Bank that in the fact-finding
investigation, many new things had surfaced. This Court has also noted that
the present proceeding initiated vide the explanation letter dated 29.03.2025
was not the maiden proceeding and within the short period of appointment of
the petitioner, that too while being in probation there has been many other
charges. Though the preceding incidents may be argued to have no impact on
the impugned termination order, this Court has noted from the records that the
earlier allegations were accepted by the petitioner. In this regard, various
communications including the letter dated 25.05.2023 issued by the petitioner
(page 186 of the records) would show that the petitioner has clearly admitted
his fault. There is no denial whatsoever regarding issuance of those
communications including the letter dated 25.03.2023. In fact, the admissions
are found to be categorical. For ready reference, the admissions are extracted
hereinbelow:
Page No.# 9/14
“To,
The Chairman Sir
Arunachal Pradesh Rural Bank
Head Office-Naharlagun
Arunachal Pradesh-791110
Sub-An Earnest Request To Withdraw My Termination.
RESPECTED CHAIRMAN SIR,
I agree that my indiscipline at my work place brings a question to my
carrier as a Banker but I promise I will work hard from now and will work
for the interests of the branch. Please forgive me for once and I promise I
will regain the reputational image of the branch a continue to work
sincerely for this org.
As asked following are my answers for the acts of misconduct against
various points of L.NO-37/639
1. I apologize for it.
2. I have changed my attitude and from now I shall follow the branch
timings from 9 am to 5pm.
3. I don't find it correct.
4. From now I shall follow all my guidelines and shall never repeat this
mistake of leaving the station without prior information to Head Office.
5. Distance from Daporijo to Bhalukpong is 500+ kms and I was not
getting carriage service so quicki I took the Preparatory leave. I apologize
for not informing about this.
6. It was serious act of misconduct. I promise I shall not repeat it at any
Page No.# 10/14
cost.
7. I know leaving my branch without informing higher authority and also
submitting of both vault to the cashier is not justifiable. I promise I shall
not repeat this mistake.
8. As only two staffs are here so it becomes necessary to share the id and
password because in m situations the maker and checker has to be done
by one staff.
9. I shall strictly following my timings and shall abide by all my duties
from now.
10. The difference of RS 20,000 Is excess in balance acc. I've consult IT
team. When it is found out RS19000 will go in GLCOM acc and remaining
RS 1000 will go in vault.
11.a) Smti Yanu Taso, is already avalling a shg loan facility in one shg acc.
She has asked me to fund her new shg loan on previous docs and also
without visiting the site, so I have declined her request. In regards to this
she has complained I guess. Moreover, I will communicate her and will
clarify all her doubts again.
b) Most of the KYCs has been taken and remaining will be submitted soon
as confirmed by ANU JEBISON President of THRIZINO BLOCK.
d) All scanning done.
e) All Specimen photograph and signature upload completed.
I shall attend every phone calls from now.
12. I admit my mistake. And I promise to come early to the branch from
now.
Page No.# 11/14
I agree that being a Branch Manager my Indiscipline and misconducts is
very detrimental to this organization. My deepest apologies to Chairman
sir, HR team and every co-worker. I've learnt a lot from my mistakes. I
promise I will work for the betterment of this org. I commit to bring
improvement in myself Thus, it's my request to Chairman sir to withdraw
my termination and give me a chance to prove me. I will work sincerely to
become an efficient employee for this org.
Please consider to give me a chance and withdraw my termination letter. I
shall be highly obliged to you.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/- illegible
25-05-2013
Subodh Kr Ral
JMGS-1
APRB, BHALUKPONG”
17.
The level of integrity, honesty and diligence of a Bank Officer / Employee
is higher than any other Officer / Employee of other Departments as they are
entrusted in discharging duties in fiduciary capacity. It is the public money which
are dealt by the Bank in trust and therefore, the doctrine of public trust is fully
applicable so far as Bank Officer / Employee are concerned. In this regard,
reliance can be placed on the decision of the State Bank of India & Ors Vs.
Ramesh Dinkar Punde reported in (2006) 7 SCC 212 wherein the following
observations have been made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court:
21.
Confronted with the facts and the position of law, learned counsel
for the respondent submitted that leniency may be shown to the
respondent having regard to long years of service rendered by the
respondent to the Bank. We are unable to countenance with such
Page No.# 12/14
submission. As already said, the respondent being a bank officer holds a
position of trust where honesty and integrity are inbuilt requirements of
functioning and it would not be proper to deal with the matter leniently.
The respondent was a Manager of the Bank and it needs to be
emphasised that in the banking business absolute devotion, diligence,
integrity and honesty needs to be preserved by every bank employee and
in
particular
the
bank
officer
so
that
the
confidence
of
the
public/depositors is not impaired. It is for this reason that when a bank
officer commits misconduct, as in the present case, for his personal ends
and against the interest of the bank and the depositors, he must be dealt
with iron hands and he does not deserve to be dealt with leniently. “
18.
It is a settled law acting beyond one’s authority, particularly by a Bank
employee is itself a misconduct when it is found to be recurring. In this
connection, one may gainfully rely to the case of Disciplinary Authority-
Cum-Regional Manager Vs. the Disciplinary Nikunja Bihari Patnaik
reported in (1996) 9 SCC 69wherein the following observations have been
made:
“... True, it is that in some cases, no loss has resulted from such acts. It is
also true that in some other instances such acts have yielded profit to the
Bank but it is equally true that in some other instances, the funds of the
Bank have been placed in jeopardy; the advances have become sticky and
irrecoverable. It is not a single act; it is a course of action spreading over
a sufficiently long period and involving a large number of transactions. In
the case of a Bank - for that matter, in the case of any other organization
- every officer/employee is supposed to act within the limits of his
authority. If each officer/ employee is allowed to act beyond his authority,
Page No.# 13/14
the discipline of the organisation/bank will disappear; the functioning of
the Bank would become chaotic and unmanageable. Each officer of the
Bank cannot be allowed to carve out his own little empire wherein he
dispenses favours and largesse. No organization, more particularly, a Bank
can function properly and effectively if its officers and employees do not
observe the prescribed norms and discipline. Such indiscipline cannot be
condoned on the specious ground that it was not actuated by ulterior
motives or by extraneous considerations. The very act of acting beyond
authority - that too a course of conduct spread over a sufficiently long
period and involving innumerable instances - is by itself a misconduct.
Such acts, if permitted, may bring in profit in some cases but they may
also lead to huge losses. Such adventures are not given to the employees
of Banks which deal with public funds. If what we hear about the reasons
for the collapse of Barings Bank is true, it is attributable to the acts of one
of its employees, Nick Leeson, a minor officer stationed at Singapore, who
was allowed by his superiors to act far beyond his authority. As mentioned
hereinbefore, the very discipline of an organization and more particularly,
a Bank is dependent upon each of its employees and officers acting and
operating within their allotted sphere. Acting beyond one's authority is by
itself a breach of discipline and a breach of Regulation 3. It constitutes
misconduct within the meaning of Regulation 24. No further proof of loss
is really necessary though as a matter of fact, in this case there are
findings that several advances and over-drawals allowed by the
respondent
beyond
his
authority
have
become
sticky
and
irrecoverable. ...”
19.
As regards the challenge to the act of recovery of Rs.93,000/-, this Court
Page No.# 14/14
has noted that the impugned order dated 30.04.2025 has taken into
consideration all the different instances wherein the misconduct of the petitioner
becomes apparent. Amongst the allegations, there is a very serious allegation of
opening an account in the name and Branch of the Bank itself by using the PAN
and TAN and the same are not denied. This Court is of the opinion that under
such facts and circumstances, the respondent – Bank has rather taken a softer
approach in terminating the services in accordance with Regulation 9(a) and has
not lodged any police complaint. This Court is accordingly not inclined to direct
refund of any amount.
20.
The petitioner, towards the last part of his submission has expressed his
apprehension of prejudice in case he applies for any other job. This Court has
given its anxious consideration to the aspect. The impugned order dated
30.04.2025 is ultimately issued as per Regulation 9(a) of the Rules which is in
connection with confirmation or otherwise of an officer under probation. In that
view of the matter, this Court is of the opinion that interest of justice would be
served by directing that the impugned termination order dated 30.04.2025 is to
be deemed as a termination simpliciter which would not have any impact if the
petitioner applies for any other jobs as per his qualification and suitability.
21.
The writ petition accordingly stands disposed of in the manner indicated
above.
22.
No order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review