Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury
WPA 27206 of 2025
KARTICK SAHA
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS
with
WPA 1791 of 2026
DEBITALA CO-OPERATIVE LABOUR CONTRACT AND
CONSTRUCTION SOCIETY LTD AND ANR.
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS.
with
WPA 1792 of2026
DIPANKAR SAHA
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS.
with
WPA 1794 of 2026
BIDYUT SARKAR
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS.
with
WPA 27208 of 2025
PRASUN GUHA
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS.
with
WPA 27209 of 2025
ASHISH KARMAKAR
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS.
WPA 27206 of 2025
with
WPA 27210 of 2025
SUBHOMOY DUTTA
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS.
with
WPA 8530 of 2026
GEETANJALI CO-OPERATIVE CONTRACT AND CONSTRUCTION
SOCIETY LIMITED AND ANR.
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS
with
WPA 4841 of 2026
INVENTION CO-OPERATIVE LABOUR CONTRACT AND
CONSTRUCTION SOCIETY LIMITED AND ANR.
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS
with
WPA 4843 of 2026
CORTES INFRASTRUCTURE AND ANR.
VS
RAIGANJ MUNICIPALITY AND ORS
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Gautam Kumar Thakur
For the Administrator/
Municipality
:
Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Suman Banerjee
For the State
in WPA 27206/2025
:
Mr. Dinesh Chandra Singh
Mr. Ghanshyam Pandey
For the State
in WPA 1791/2026
:
Mr. Dipendra Narayan Roy, Ld. GP
Ms. Susmita Saha
Mr. Sourav Haldar
For the State
in WPA 27210/2025
:
Ms. Swastika Dutta
Mr. Mainak Chandra
For the State
in WPA 8530/2026
:
Mr. Sovan Mukherjee
Ms. Sneha Chatterjee
WPA 27206 of 2025
For the State
in WPA 1794/2026
WPA/1792/2026
WPA 27208/2025
:
Mr. Shiv Shankar Banerjee
Mr. A. Narayan Banerjee
Mr. G. Acharyya
For the State
in WPA 27209 of 2025
:
Ms. Suchitra Sinha Chatterjee
Heard on
:
19.08.2026 & 21.09.2026.
Judgment on
:
21.09.2026.
Raja Basu Chowdhury, J (Oral):
1. The instant batch of writ petitions are taken up for consideration together
as the same concern a common cause.
2. The petitioners claim to be either contractors or are proprietors of
concerns who are engaged in the business of civil engineering works. The
petitioners claim to have executed certain works on the basis of work
orders issued by the Raiganj Municipality. It is also the petitioners’
contention that though after execution of the works they had prayed for
disbursement of bills, unfortunately, according to the petitioners due to
dissolution of the Municipal Board, the State Government had appointed
the
Sub-Divisional
Officer,
Raiganj,
as
an
administrator
of
the
municipality. The newly appointed administrator had enquired into
diverse allegations, including the allegation against the erstwhile
Chairman in awarding work orders in violation of the established norms
and prescribed procedure.
3. According to the petitioners, criminal proceedings were also initiated
which culminated into a criminal trial and upon conclusion of trial, the
Chairman was ultimately acquitted by the competent Court by an order
WPA 27206 of 2025
dated 30th April, 2024. The petitioners would complain that by reasons of
pendency of the criminal proceedings, the legitimate dues of the
petitioners were withheld. According to the petitioners, immediately upon
conclusion of the work as aforesaid under the different wards of the
municipality, the then Chief Engineer, Municipal Engineer Directorate (in
short, MED) passed an order on 21st December, 2018, directing the
Executive Engineer (MED) Raiganj Division to enquire into and make field
level enquiry of 269 number of schemes which had already been
implemented during the Chairmanship of the erstwhile Chairman.
Following the above, a report was submitted by the Executive Engineer
(MED), Government of West Bengal, with the Chief Engineer, MED,
Bikash Bhawan, by a cover letter dated 16th May, 2019.
4. The learned advocate representing the petitioners by drawing attention of
this Court to the aforementioned report would submit that as per enquiry
report, the status of works against the respective works executed by the
petitioners would show that the same had duly been completed. To
morefully appreciate the same, the names of the petitioners, their serial
numbers along with NIT particulars and the work status are extracted
from the enquiry report: Names of the
Petitioners
Serial No. – NIT Particulars
Work Status
WPA 27206 of 2025
KARTICK SAHA
143 – 600/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 01/02/16
Gr.M.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
145 – 600/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 01/02/16
Gr.M.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
146 – 600/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 01/02/16
Gr.N.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
WPA 27206 of 2025
WPA 1791 of 2026
DEBITALA COOPERATIVE LABOUR
CONTRACT AND
CONSTRUCTION
SOCIETY LTD AND
ANR.
WPA 1792 of 2026
DIPANKAR SAHA
WPA 1794 of 2026
BIDYUT SARKAR
147 – 600/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 01/02/16
Gr.L.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
207 – 42/PWD-II/RM/2015, Dt. 14/07/15
Gr.C
All work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
209 – 42/PWD-II/RM/2015, Dt. 14/07/15
Gr.C
All work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
11 – 35/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 02.05.2015
Gr.AD.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Service
141 – 440/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 02/11/15
Gr.P.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
144 – 600/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 1/2/2016
Gr.G.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
167 – 615/PWD-III/RM/2015-16
Dt. 10/02/2016 Gr.P.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Accounts
Section
180 – 401/PWD-III/RM/2014-15
Dt. 04/02/2015 Gr.A
Partially completed and (1st
RA) bill submitted to the
Accounts Section
239 – 440/PWD-III/RM/2015-16, Grp - N.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
243 – 600/PWD-III/RM/2015-16, Grp - G.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
240 – 440/PWD-III/RM/2015-16, Grp - X.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
Work has been completed and
Forwarded to Account Section
14 – 494/PWD-III/RM/2013 Dt. 06/11/2013
Gr.E.
201 – 43/PWD-II/RM/-15 Dt. 15/12/2015
Gr.A.
Work has been completed and
Forwarded to Account Section
for bill payment
All work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
202 – 45/PWD-II/RM/15, Dt. 26/05/2016,
Gr.F.
All work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
228 – 42/PWD-II/RM/2015, Dt. 14/07/2015,
Gr-G.
All work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
area
192 – 06(1)/PWD/RM/15, Dt. 28/05/15, Gr.Y
WPA 27208 of 2025
PRASUN GUHA
21 –160/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt. 30.06.2015,
Gr. E.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
28 – 35/PWD-II/RM/2015-16 Dt. 02/05/2015,
Gr. AE.
Work has been completed and
forwarded to the Account
Section
48 – 162/PWD-111/RM/2015-16 Dt.
30/06/2015, Gr. C.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
54 – 160/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Dt.
30/06/2015, Gr. A.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
203 – 45/PWD-II/RM/15 Dt. 26/05/2016, Gr.
F.
All Work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
254 – 569/PWD-III/RM/2015-16 Gr-K.
WPA 27209 of 2025
ASHISH KARMAKAR
WPA 27206 of 2025
205 – 43/PWD-II/RM/15 Dt. 15/12/2015, Gr.
G.
–
475/PWD-III/RM/2015-16
08/12/15, Gr. A.
Dated
All Work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
All Work has been completed
and also submitted in Account
Section since a long period
28 – 35/PWD-II/RM/2015-16
Dt. 02/05/2015 Gr.AE
Work has been completed and
forwarded to the Account
Section
250 – 615/PWD-III/RM/2015-16
Grp-N
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
264 – 75/PWD-III/RM/2016-17
Grp. B
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
WPA 8530 of 2026
GEETANJALI COOPERATIVE
CONTRACT AND
CONSTRUCTION
SOCIETY LIMITED
AND ANR.
25 – 123/PWD-III/RM/2015-16
Dt: 11/06/2015
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
224 – 35/PWD-III/RM/2015-16
Dt 02/05/2015, Gr. V.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
WPA 4841 of 2025
INVENTION COOPERATIVE LABOUR
CONTRACT AND
CONSTRUCTION
SOCIETY LIMITED
AND ANR.
27 – 375/PWD-III/RM/2014-15
Dt: 06/01/2015, Grp. H
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
41 – 201(AYPWD-III/RM/2015-16
Dt: 14/07/2015, Grp. B.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section for bill payment
52 – 238(10)/PWD/RM/13
Dt: 10/02/14, Gr. C.
Work has been completed and
forwarded to the Account
Section
62 – 435/PWD-111/RM/2014-15
Dt: 07/03/2013, Gr. C.
Work has been completed and
bill submitted to the Account
Section
75 – 436/PWD-III/RM/2015-16
Dt: 07/03/2015.
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
109 – 434/PWD-III/RM/2014-15
Dt: 07/03/2015
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
125 – 35/PWDII/RM/15-16,
De 02/11/15 Gr. AB
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
139 – 440/PWD-III/RM/2015-16,
Dt. 02/11/2015 Gr. G
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
185 – 06(1)/PWD/RM/15,
Dt. 28/05/15 Gr. J
Work has been completed and
Forwarded to Account Section
for bill payment
186 – 06(1)/PWD/RM/15,
Dt. 28/05/15 Gr. H
Work has been completed and
Forwarded to Account Section
for bill payment
222 – 365/PWD-III/RM/2015-16,
Dt. 07/09/2015 Gr. A
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
232 – 160/PWD-III/RM/2015-16,
Gr. P
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
234 – 160/PWD-III/RM/2015-16,
Gr. R
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
WPA 27210 of 2025
SUBHOMOY DUTTA
WPA 27206 of 2025
WPA 4843 of 2026
CORTES
INFRASTRUCTURE
AND ANR.
267 – 100(10)/PWD/RM 16, Dt. 10/2/16
Gr. D
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section for bill payment
268 – 100(10)/PWD/RM 16, Dt. 10/2/16
Gr. D
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section for bill payment
86 – 440/PWD-III/RM/2014-15
Dt: 2/11/2015, Gr. AC
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
225 – 440/PWD-III/RM/2015-16,
Dt. 02/11/2015, Gr - AB
Work completed and bill
submitted to the Account
Section
5. By relying on the above chart, it is submitted that in identical set of facts
one of the contractors had approached this Court in WPA 17176 of 2023.
The said writ petition was disposed of by directing the Principal
Secretary, Department of Urban Development and Municipal Affairs to
take a decision in the matter. Following the aforesaid, the concerned
Secretary to the Government of West Bengal had passed an order dated
18th December, 2023 by observing as under:“ On examination of the submission of the petitioners,
representatives
of
the
Raiganj
Municipality
and
available office records/documents, it appears that;
(i) The works in question were undertaken by Raiganj
Municipality out of its own capacity. As per official
record, it is found that no Administrative Approval and
Financial Sanction (AA& FS) was issued from this
Department. Hence, this Department cannot take any
liability
for
Administrative
payment
Approval
of
works
and
for
Financial
which
no
Sanction
(AA&FS) was taken by the municipality.
(ii) After several years of completion of the said works,
the Municipality approached before this Department for
release of fund. The procedure followed for execution of
the works as beyond existing financial and technical
norms, hence a physical enquiry was directed to be
WPA 27206 of 2025
conducted by Municipal Engineering Directorate vide
this
Department’s
letter
no.
147(Law)-C12/M/3S-
37/2018 dated 16.08.2018. Therefore, it could not be
considered for post-facto approval.
(iii) The enquiry was conducted on 16.05.2019 by the
Municipal Engineering Directorate under the Urban
Development
and
Municipal
Affairs
Department,
Government of West Bengal.
(iv) The Raiganj Municipality, being the Respondent
No.1 was the Tender issuing authority and the work
order was issued by the respondent no.1.
(v) At the time of conducting the enquiry by the
Municipal Engineering Directorate under the Urban
Development
and
Municipal
Affairs
Department,
Government of West Bengal, the respondent no.1 was
duly informed prior to the same and the Chairman of the
Respondent no.1 has duly endorsed the concluding page
of the enquiry report.
(vi) The enquiry report was also forwarded to the
respondent no.1 by the Executive Engineer, Dinajpur
Division, Municipal Engineering Directorate vide a Memo
bearing
No.
MED/DJP/67/V-3/2016,
Pt.
dated
16.05.2019.
(vii) As per present prevailing procedure, before
commencing a scheme/project the concerned Urban
Local Bodies is to submit a Detailed Project Report (DPR)
properly vetted by the Competent Authority with
updated G.S.T. rate along with a copy of Resolution of
Board
of
Councillors
for
obtaining
Administrative
Approval and Financial Sanction (AA&FS). In the instant
case, this procedure had not been followed by Rauganj
Municipality. After several years of completion of the
said works, the Municipality approached before this
Department for release of fund which cannot be
considered at present on post facto basis.
WPA 27206 of 2025
In view of the above, it is stated that the liability to clear
the dues to the petitioner for the works executed by
Raiganj Municipality on its own initiative without prior
approval
of
State
Government,
is
upon
Raiganj
Municipality itself. State Government cannot take the
liability to release of fund for implementation of schemes
for which no Administrative Approval and Financial
Sanction (AA&FS) was issued. ”
6. Being aggrieved with the denial of liability by the State on the ground that
the works executed by the petitioner therein at the instance of the
Raiganj Municipality were without the approval of the Government and as
such the Government cannot be held liable to release the funds for
implementation of scheme for which no Administrative Approval and
Financial Sanction (AA&FS) was issued, a writ petition was filed before
this Court which was registered as WPA 3255 of 2024. By an order dated
17th April, 2025, a Coordinate Bench of this Court while taking note of
the peculiar facts and noting that in a welfare State, the Government is
expected to play a parental role towards its citizens, particularly in
matters concerning welfare, protection and infrastructure development,
and following the principles and the doctrine of parens patriae and also
noting that the municipality functions as a parastatal body acting on
behalf of the State in a delegated capacity and in the given facts there can
be no dispute that the benefits of the works which had been completed
without any objection regarding quality or process, are presently being
enjoyed by the citizens of the State, directed the Principal Secretary,
WPA 27206 of 2025
Government of West Bengal to ensure that the verified amount is
disbursed in favour of the petitioner within the time frame specified.
7. Being aggrieved, the Raiganj Municipality preferred an appeal which was
registered as MAT 896 of 2025. By an order dated 14th July, 2025, the
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court had directed the Principal Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of West Bengal to be arrayed as
party respondent to the said proceedings.
The appeal thereafter was
heard and was dismissed by the said order, inter alia, observing as
follows:
“What has weighed with this Court in agreeing with the Single
Bench is that the completion certificate of the works has been issued
by the State. An authority under
the State has conducted an
enquiry. An official of the Municipal Affairs Department of the State,
inter alia, has issued a report dated 16th May, 2019 which has
clearly found that the work entrusted and undertaken by the
petitioner have been completed. The State could not prove in the
criminal trial against the erstwhile Chairman any of the allegations
against him. Indeed, the State has preferred an appeal against the
order of acquittal before this Court.
In the backdrop of the above facts, especially that the writ petitioner
has completed works in question and has delivered the same to the
satisfaction of the State Government, the State Government in terms
of the principles of unjust enrichment, quantum meruit under Section
70 of the Contract Act is liable to the writ petitioner. The State cannot
absolve itself of its liability in the backdrop of the above.
The State cannot unjustly enrich itself for works done for its benefit.
The citizens of the Municipality used and continue to use the works
done. Roads, public buildings and the hospitals constructed by the
writ petitioner. Criminal proceedings against the then Chairman
have failed in the first instance.
WPA 27206 of 2025
The principle of quantum merit would apply in the cases of works
done without a contract. There is in such cases a deemed/implied
agreement with the State. The Doctrine of Public Trust also comes to
play in the facts of this case.
The principle against unjust enrichment and restitution have been
explained at Paragraph 8 of the decision of the Supreme Court in the
case of Mahabir Kishore and Ors. Vs. State of MP reported in (1989)
4 SCC 1.
“8. The question is what was the law applicable to the case.
“Nul ne doit senrichir aux depens des autres”—No one ought to
enrich himself at the expense of others. This doctrine at one
stage of English common law was remedied by “indebitatus
assumpsit” which action lay for money “had and received to
the use of the plaintiff”. It lay to recover money paid under a
mistake, or extorted from the plaintiff by duress of his goods, or
paid to the defendant on a consideration which totally failed.
On abolition of “indebitatus assumpsit” courts used to imply a
promise to pay which, however, in course of time was held to
be purely fictitious. Lord Mansfied in Moses v. Macferlan
[(1760) 2 Burr 1005, 1012] explained the juridical basis of the
action for money “had and received” thus: “This kind of
equitable action, to recover back money, which ought not in
justice to be kept, is very beneficial, and therefore much
encouraged. It lies only for money which, „ex aequo et bono‟,
the defendant ought to refund; it does not lie for money paid by
the plaintiff, which is claimed of him as payable in point of
honour and honesty, although it could not have been recovered
from him by any course of law; as in payment of a debt barred
by the Statute of Limitations, or contracted during his infancy,
or to the extent of principal and legal interest upon a usurious
contract, or, for money fairly lost at play; because in all these
cases, the defendant may retain it with a safe conscience,
though by positive law he was barred from recovering. But it
lies for money paid by mistake; or upon a consideration which
happens to fail; or for money got through imposition (express or
WPA 27206 of 2025
implied); or extortion; or oppression; or an undue advantage
taken of the plaintiff's situation, contrary to laws made for the
protection of persons under those circumstances. In one word,
the gist of this kind of action is, that the defendant, upon the
circumstances of the case, is obliged by the ties of natural
justice and equity to refund the money.”
There is one argument that comes to the mind of this Court that
could have been advanced by the State. Matters of this nature must
be decided in a civil proceeding by trial and evidence. Exceptions
thereto have been carved out in the decision of the Supreme Court in
the case of ABL International Ltd. and Anr. Vs. Export Credit
Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. and Ors. reported in (2004) 3
SCC 553 and narrowed down to some extent in the case of Joshi
Technologies International Inc. Vs. Union of India reported in (2015)
7 SCC 728 .
This case, in the opinion of this Court, clearly falls within such
exception.
For the reasons stated hereinabove, the appeal fails and hereby
dismissed. Consequently, all connected pending applications, if any,
are also dismissed.
The impugned order is modified to a limited extent that the Raiganj
Municipality shall be liable to pay the appellant as directed by the
Single Bench upon funds being put in by the State.
The Principal Secretary, Department of Urban Development and
Municipal Affairs, Government of West Bengal, the Principal
Secretary, Department of Finance, Government of West Bengal and
the Chairman, Raiganj Municipality shall be responsible for
complying with this order.
Needless to mention that the direction of the Single Bench that the
quantum of claim of the writ petitioner may be reassessed by the
Principal
Secretary,
Department
of
Urban
Development
and
Municipal Affairs, Government of West Bengal, Principal Secretary,
Department of Finance, Government of West Bengal and the
Chairman, Raiganj Municipality.
WPA 27206 of 2025
The time frame for complying with the above is extended by a period
of one month from date.”
8. The matter did not rest there, the Government did not comply with the
direction for ensuring payment. A review application was filed by the
Principal Secretary, Department of Urban Development and Municipal
Affairs, Government of West Bengal which was registered as RVW 285 of
2025, the same was taken up for consideration by keeping the contempt
application pending. Though, the explanation provided for delay was not
acceptable, however, the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court for the
ends of justice by condoning the delay by an order dated 19th September,
2025 had taken up the hearing of the review application. The review was
filed primarily on the ground that the Raiganj Municipality had not taken
prior approval under Section 73(A) of the West Bengal Municipal Act,
1993 (hereinafter referred to as the “said Act”) prior to issuance of the
work
order
and
the
completion
certificate
to
the
appellant
for
implementation of 271 schemes within the municipality. The Hon’ble
Division Bench of this Court by the aforesaid order was however, pleased
to observe that construction work for which tender was floated and
awarded to the petitioner was for construction of roads, hostels and other
municipal buildings for the benefit of the citizens of Raiganj Municipality.
The work in question also covered under 271 schemes within the
municipality and was sponsored by the State Government. As such the
State was obliged to fund under Section 71(A) of the said Act. The issue of
seeking approval of the State Government had already been dealt with in
WPA 27206 of 2025
the judgment dated 14th July, 2025 and also noting that the State itself
had conducted an enquiry into the matter, the Court found that there
was no sufficient ground for maintaining the review from the order dated
14th July, 2025 and accordingly, dismissed the same.
9. Records would reveal that this Court by order dated 11th February 2026
had directed the municipality to take instructions on the aforesaid
enquiry report appearing in the writ petition. The municipality was also
directed to ascertain as to whether the works were executed. Pursuant to
such direction, the municipality had filed a report on 1st August 2026.
10.
In such report the municipality has confirmed the factum of
execution of the work. Since then, the matter has been taken up for final
consideration. Mr. Banerjee, learned advocate appearing for the State has
drawn attention of this Court to Section 72 of the said Act and would
submit that the municipal authorities are not incompetent and not
powerless to generate funds in fact, the municipal authorities are also
empowered to seek loan for defraying their expenses and as such the
State Government cannot be saddled with the liability to make payment
of the expense incurred by the municipality. He has next by drawing
attention of this Court to the order passed by the Division Bench of this
Court had attempted to submit that the works executed in such case
were covered under the Scheme though in the present case, the works
are not covered under the Scheme. He has also drawn attention of this
Court the provisions of Section 429 as also the provisions of Section 75 of
the said Act and would submit in the given facts the State Government
WPA 27206 of 2025
cannot be saddled with the responsibility to make payment for the
expenses incurred by the municipality.
11.
Reliance has also been placed by Mr. Banerjee on the judgment
delivered in the case of Madhoor Buildwell Private Limited v. Yeola
Municipal Council & Ors., reported in (2019) 9 SCC 350, to highlight
the fact that without appropriate approval from the Government the
Government cannot be made liable for the expenses incurred. To
distinguish the judgment delivered in the case of Raiganj Municipality
& Ors. v. Nandalal Saha & Ors., in MAT 896 of 2025, he has placed
before this Court an unreported judgment delivered in the case of the
State of West Bengal & Ors. v. I Sustain Energy Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. in
FMA 385 of 2023 and the case of Amjad Hossain v. State of West
Bengal & Ors., having neutral citation 2025:CHC-JP:201. The above
judgments have been relied on to hold out that the municipality has
ample power to generate own funds and as such the State Government
cannot be made liable.
12.
Mr. Bhattacharya, learned senior standing counsel appearing for
the municipality has drawn attention of this Court to the report filed by
the executive engineer, would submit from the aforesaid repot it would be
apparent that though, the works were executed apart from having a few
several works vetted to Zilla Parishad, the other works were not approved
by the State Government. Insofar as the execution of work is concerned,
he would submit that since municipality have themselves confirmed the
execution of works, he has nothing to add.
WPA 27206 of 2025
13.
Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective
parties and having considered the materials on record in the instant case,
though Mr. Banerjee, learned advocate has attempted to distinguish the
case of Nandalal Saha (supra) by claiming that the works executed
therein were covered by 271 Schemes, I find that the enquiry report itself
demonstrates that the works which forms subject matter of the writ
petition are covered under the self-same enquiry report.
14.
Further, the Division Bench has already considered the scope and
effect of non-grant of prior approval under Section 73A of the said Act
and has arrived at a finding that since the works were covered under the
Scheme within the municipality and as sponsored by the State
Government, the State Government is obliged to provide funds therefor
under Section 71A of the said Act. The issue of seeking prior approval by
the State Government had already been dealt with in the judgment dated
14th July, 2025, and also noting that the State itself has conducted an
enquiry in the matter, the Division Bench found that there was no
sufficient ground for maintaining the review from the order dated 14th
July, 2025 and had accordingly dismissed the same.
15.
From the respective reports filed in Court and the submissions
made, it would be apparent that there is no administrative approval and
financial sanction.
It is, however, not in dispute that an enquiry had
been conducted by the State in respect of the works which have been
executed and are covered under the Scheme. The respondents have also
acknowledged the same by filing the report under the signature of the
WPA 27206 of 2025
Executive Officer. The relevant portions of the reports are extracted
hereinbelow:
WPA 17206 of 2025
WPA 1791 of 2026
WPA 1792 of 2026
WPA 27206 of 2025
WPA 1794 of 2026
WPA 27208 of 2025
WPA 27209 of 2025
WPA 4841 of 2026
WPA 27206 of 2025
WPA 4843 of 2026
WPA 27210 of 2025
WPA 8530 of 2026
16.
Though Mr. Banerjee learned advocate appearing for the State has
attempted to raise the issue that there is no scope for this Court to direct
the State to make payment, I find that all the aforesaid issues have been
duly covered in the judgment delivered by the Division Bench in the case
of Nandalal Saha (supra). I also find that the petitioners’ case lies on
WPA 27206 of 2025
the same footing. Admittedly, in the instant case, under the self-same
enquiry, the works executed by the petitioners have been identified, the
same is noted hereinabove in the chart. The defence of the State as
regards non-grant of administrative approval and financial sanction has
also been considered and overruled by the Coordinate Bench and the
same also has the approval of the Hon’ble Division Bench. Further noting
that it is not in dispute that the works executed by the petitioners are
without any objection for any quarter and are being enjoyed by the
residents of the municipality, I am of the view, in the given facts, it shall
be appropriate to direct the Member Secretary, Department of Urban
Development and Municipal Affairs, Government of West Bengal,
Principal Secretary, Department of Finance, Government of West Bengal
and the Chairman/Administrator Raiganj Municipality and or any one in
control of Raiganj Municipality to disburse the admitted amount as
reflected in the report of the municipality in favour of the petitioners on
an expeditious basis. The above direction is being issued in the peculiar
facts despite noting that the West Bengal Municipal Act, 1993 provides
for financial assistance by the State, but without entering into the realm
as to how the state would adjust the said sum, in the light of the
observations made in the case of I Sustain Energy (supra) and Yeola
Municipal Council (supra).
17.
However,
the
concerned
authorities
including
the
Principal
Secretary, Department of Municipal affairs and Principal Secretary,
Finance Government of West Bengal and the Chairman/ administrator or
WPA 27206 of 2025
any person in control of the Raiganj Municipality shall be at liberty to reassess the quantum in accordance with law. In any event, no legitimate
dues shall be held back. The payment as directed should be made within
a period of 2 months from the date of communication of this order.
18.
With the above observations and directions, these writ petitions are
disposed of.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
Saswata/sayandeep
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review