The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. With the aforestated directions, the present writ petition is disposed of.
19. There shall be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
17.03.2026
Sl. No. 286
Ct No. 24
SG
WPA 26954 of 2025
Subham Bose & Ors.
Vs
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Soumya Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Sumitava Chakraborty,
Ms. Bratati Pramanick.
…for the petitioners
Mr. D.N. Maiti,
Ritick Chowdhury,
Mr. A. Santra.
…for respondent nos. 2 to 5
Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacharyay.
Mr. Barnamoy Basak.
…for respondent no. 6
Mr. Swapan Dutta,
Mr. Dipankar Dasgupta,
Ms. Debdooti Dutta.
...for the State
1.
Pleadings filed by the parties be kept with the
record.
2.
The petitioners are students who have taken
admission in the respondent no. 6 in a course which will
grant a degree as Bachelor in Hospital Administration
(BHA). This course has no involvement of any medicinal
or medical practice or knowledge of any medical or even
any allied subject. This course would merely give a
person a right to work in a hospital on the administrative
side. Even on the administrative side, it could be a far
lesser job related to almost ministerial work. It does not
call for any desk job or decision making in any manner
whatsoever. The petitioners, 28 in number had applied
for and obtained admission into the respondent no. 6 in
March, 2025 and has been participating in the classes
conducted for the degree in BHA.
3.
None of the petitioners are JENPAS qualified and
had taken admission to the college directly. Interestingly,
the college has 60 seats for this BHA degree, out of which
only 12 were filled up. There were 48 seats empty when
the petitioners were admitted as students in the college.
The petitioners had applied for registration in March,
2025 for the first semester examination, which had been
denied to them by the university as they were not
JENPAS qualified. Though the said refusal was not
challenged
by
the
petitioners,
the
university
had
sometime in September, 2025 indicated to the college
that the entire process of registration of the petitioners
was under consideration before the technical department
and the university would revert back to the college once
such verification was done. There is no further e-mail or
response from the university pursuant to the e-mail of
September 27, 2025.
4.
At this juncture while sitting for the third
semester (the second semester has also passed) that the
petitioners have approached this Court by way of this
writ petition sometime in November, 2025.
5.
Mr. Majumder, learned senior advocate appearing
for the petitioners has raised only two issues. First, that
there have been earlier instances in 2022 and 2023 when
by way of notifications for the respective years nonJENPAS qualified students have been permitted to
undertake the examination upon registration being
directed by the university. The second issue is that the
requirement of the petitioners is a mere 10+2 (passed in
English) qualification. The nature of the job that will be
discharged by the students obtaining the BHA degree will
be ministerial in nature, hence does not require any
further qualification than as aforestated as specified in
the information bulletin published by the West Bengal
Joint Entrance Examination Board (WBJEE).
6.
Mr. Bhattacharyay appearing for the respondent
no. 6 has submitted that total number of seats of the
college 60 was vacant, except for the 12 seats which have
been filled up pursuant to counselling and mop up
rounds by counselling by JENPAS qualified students.
Hence, 48 seats were empty and would remain empty for
the entire 3-year course. In fact, he also submits that the
college had also informed the university that such
students were being admitted, who are not JENPAS
qualified. Mr. Bhattacharyay submits that the petitioners
were admitted much after the admissions of JENPAS
students
had
closed
and
there
was
no
further
opportunity of any students being admitted. Ostensibly
there were no other students who could have been
admitted into the vacant seats of the college, It also
appears from his submission that this is the only college
which
offers
this
sort
of
course
in
hospital
administration.
7.
Learned advocate appearing for the respondent
nos. 2 to 5 submits that the earlier notifications of the
year 2022-23 relaxing the admission rules and indeed
permitting non-JENPAS students to be admitted to the
colleges affiliated to the university was a one-time
measure, principally relating to the Covid period. Second
he submits that the Ordinance 126 of the West Bengal
University of Health Science, 2003 (hereinafter 8the said
statute9) prohibits admission of any non-JENPAS student
to any of the college and hence registration with the
university.
8.
He also submits that the petitioners ought to have
approached this Court in March, 2025 when they were
refused the opportunity to take examination for the first
semester. Thus, this belated approach by the petitioners
should not be entertained.
9.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties
and considered the documents on record. There is no
doubt that the college is the mischief maker. The college
ought not to have taken students who were not JENPAS
qualified under any circumstances, which would not have
created the present situation.
10.
The
submissions
made
by
learned
counsel
appearing for the respondent nos. 2 to 5 are correct
inasmuch as it is impermissible in law to admit nonJENPAS
qualified
students
and
the
same
should
ordinarily not be allowed. In the present case, it is a pure
question of balancing the equities. The number of seats
in the college of about 60 would have all remained vacant
throughout the entire course, except for the 12 which
were filled by JENPAS qualified students. Thus, 48 seats
would remain vacant. The college chose to admit these 28
petitioners who were not JENPAS qualified to fill up 28 of
the 48 seats. Even at present there are 20 vacant seats in
the college.
11.
The university under Ordinance 127 of the said
statute is obliged to maintain its register which would
truly reflect the number of students in each college along
with particular of such students as mandated therein.
The university by its e-mail of 27.09.2025 had relayed to
the college that it was in the process of verifying the
particulars of the students and would revert back once
such verification was completed. The petitioners on the
basis of this verification being done by the university had
chosen not to approach this Court, relying on the fact
that upon verification, their names could have been
included in the register of the university. Hence, the
delayed approach albeit the instant writ petition in
November, 2025.
12.
The
admission
of
the
petitioners
or
their
consequential registration with the university thereby
permitting them to participate in the third semester
examination
and
also
take
the
first
semester
examination, if permitted by the college, will not prejudice
any other students in other manner whatsoever. The
continuation of the petitioners in the college from March,
2025 till date has not been challenged by any person nor
has the university ever challenged the admission of the
students in the college on the ground that they are not
duly qualified. On the contrary, the university had sought
to revert back upon verification, which they never did.
13.
It can thus safely be assumed that there is no
other student more eligible than the petitioners or as
eligible or better placed as the petitioners whose rights
would be defeated or even prejudiced, if the petitioners
are permitted to be registered with the university and
consequentially to sit for the semester examination.
14.
The balancing of equities is such that 28 seats in
a college, which would otherwise remain vacant for the
entire course is being occupied by students who are
qualified in terms of the eligibility criteria provided in the
information bulletin, by the WBJEE. Balancing of equities
is students pursuing a course to meet its logical end by
way of examination to pursue a career. These equities as
against a technical issue that the petitioners approached
the Court belatedly, a further issue that the petitioners
are not JENPAS qualified or that they were not validly
admitted by the college authorities. The balance of the
equities seems clear enough. The interest, rights and
careers of aspiring students ought to be protected. More
so, in this case, since the petitioners are not depriving
any other better or atleast equally placed students in any
manner.
15.
In
view
of
the
aforestated
discussions
and
observations, I direct the university the respondent nos. 2
to 5 particularly respondent no. 3 to register the
petitioners by March 25, 2026 to enable the petitioners to
sit for the examination of the third semester and first
semester, if permitted, to be held on March 30, 2026.
16.
I make it clear that this order is being passed in
the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, which
does not in any manner condone the acts of commission
and/or omission of the college authorities.
17.
I make it clear that this order will not create a
precedence in future for students admitted in the similar
manner by this particular college or by any other college
in violation of the laid down procedure.
18.
With the aforestated directions, the present writ
petition is disposed of.
19.
There shall be no order as to costs.
20.
Let urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties on usual
undertaking.
(Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review