Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE D. K. SINGH
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
SUBHADRAMMA T.G.,
AGED 56 YEARS, D/O. GOPALAN T.K.,
ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER, FOOD CORPORATION OF
INDIA, REGIONAL OFFICE, NO.10,
EAST END MAIN ROAD, 4TH ‘T’ BLOCK, JAYANAGAR,
BANGALORE – 560041, RESIDING AT ANANDHU BHAVAN,
SREENARAYANA ROAD, ETTUVEEDU VILLA, KOCHUPALLI,
NADAKKAVU P.O., UDAYAMPEROOR, MANAKUNNAM,
ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682307.
BY ADV.
K. SANDESH RAJA
RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF FOOD AND PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
MINISTRY OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS, FOOD AND PUBLIC
DISTRIBUTION DEPARTMENT OF FOOD & PD,
KRISHI BHAWAN, NEW DELHI, PIN – 110001.
THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF TRIBAL AFFAIRS, RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD,
SHASTRI BHAWAN, NEW DELHI, PIN – 110001.
FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY THE CHAIRMAN & MANAGING DIRECTOR,
BARKHAMBA LANE, HEADQUARTERS, NEW DELHI,
PIN – 110001.
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
BY ADV.
JOSE KURIAKOSE (VILANGATTIL)
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON 26.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
D. K. SINGH, J.
-------------------------W.P.(C) No. 7688 of 2024
------------------------Dated this the 26th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
1.
The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioner being
aggrieved by the decision taken in Exhibit P-1 whereby the petitioner
has been compulsorily retired from the post of Assistant General
Manager in the Food Corporation of India (FCI) under Regulation
22(2) of FCI Staff Regulations, 1971 w.e.f. 19.05.2023. In view of the
notice, the petitioner was directed to be paid three months salary.
2.
The petitioner has also challenged the decision of the Appellate
Authority, the Managing Director of the FCI, whereby the petitioner’s
appeal against the order dated 19.05.2023 was rejected and,
thereafter, the decision of the Review Committee dated 04.05.2023
has been challenged in the said writ petition.
3.
The petitioner started her career in the FCI as Typist Grade – III
pursuant to the selection conducted by the FCI in Special
Recruitment of Scheduled Tribe in the year 1989.
Her career
progressed in the FCI, and she reached the level of Assistant Grade -
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
I in the year 2001. Thereafter she came to the Managerial cadre and
was promoted as Assistant Manager against the quota earmarked for
Scheduled Tribes in the year 2004 and thereafter she was promoted
as Assistant General Manager in the year 2014 against the vacancy
earmarked for the Scheduled Tribes.
4.
The FCI, after examining the work, conduct and APRs of the
petitioner, had decided to retire the petitioner from the services of
the FCI vide the order dated 19.05.2023 and the said order was
affirmed by the Appellate Authority and Review Committee.
5.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the
Circular dated 09.07.2021 issued by the FCI Headquarters which laid
down certain norms for conducting the review of the corporation
employees for strengthening of administration under Regulation
22(2) of FCI (Staff) Regulations, 1971. The aforesaid Circular has
been issued on the basis of the OM issued by the DoPT dated
28.08.2020. Clause 10 of the said Circular provides Broad Criteria to
be
followed
by
the
Review
Committee
while
making
recommendations for premature retirement of the employee of the
Corporation. Clause 10 of the Circular in Exhibit P-5 on reproduction
would read as under;
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
10.
Broad Criteria to be followed by the Review Committee:- The
broad criteria to be followed by the Review Committee while making the
recommendations are as follows:(i) Corporation employees whose integrity is doubtful shall be
retired.
(ii) Corporation employees found to be ineffective shall also be
retired. The basic consideration in identifying such Corporation
employees should be their fitness/competence to continue in
the post held.
(iii) No Corporation employee should ordinarily be retired on
ground of ineffectiveness, if, in any event, he would be retiring on
superannuation within a period of one year from the date of
consideration of his case. However, in case where there is a
sudden and steep fall in the competence, efficiency or
effectiveness of a Corporation employee, it would be open to
review such a case also for premature retirement. The said
instruction of not retiring the Corporation employee within one
year on the ground of ineffectiveness except in case of sudden
and steep fall in his performance is relevant only when he is
proposed to be retired on the ground of ineffectiveness, but not
on the ground of doubtful integrity.
(iv) No Corporation employee should ordinarily be retired on
ground of ineffectiveness, if, his service during the preceding 5
years or where he has been promoted to a higher post during
that 5 year period, his service in the highest post, has been found
satisfactory. There is no such stipulation, however, where the
Corporation employee is to be retired on grounds of doubtful
integrity. In case of those Corporation employees who have
been promoted during the last 5 years, the previous entries in
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
the APARs may be taken into account if he was promoted on the
basis of seniority cum fitness, and not on the basis of merit.
(v) The entire service record of a Corporation employee should
be considered at the time of review. The expression ‘service
record’ refers to all relevant records and therefore, the review
should not be confined to the consideration of the APAR dossier.
The personal file of the Corporation employee may contain
valuable material. Similarly, his work and performance could
also be assessed by looking into files dealt with by him or in any
papers or reports prepared and submitted by him. It would be
useful if the concerned Internal Committee puts together all the
data available about Corporation employee and prepares a
comprehensive brief for consideration
by the Review
Committee. Even uncommunicated remarks in the APARs may
be taken into consideration.
6.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that none of the
Annual Performance Assessment Reports (APARs) of the petitioner
would disclose that her integrity was doubtful. The petitioner was
awarded grading of ‘good’ or ‘fair’ and, therefore, it cannot be said
that the petitioner’s performance was ineffective. The entire service
record of the petitioner would disclose that the petitioner has been
always graded ‘fair’ and ‘good’ and the Review Committee without
considering these aspects, has rejected the review on the grounds
which are not germane on the service record of the petitioner. The
learned Counsel, therefore, submits that the decision of the
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
Corporation to prematurely retire the petitioner is against the
Circular in Exhibit P-5 as well as the Judgments in M. S. Bindra v.
Union of India and others [1998 KHC 1184] and State of Gujarat and
another v. Suryakant Chunilal Shah [1999 KHC 920].
7.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner has also placed on
record some of the APARs of the petitioner which are for the years
2019 to 2022. Even the APARs cited by the petitioner from
01.01.2019 to 23.09.2019 would disclose the comment as ‘there is
need for considerable improvement’ and in respect of the integrity it
was mentioned that ‘adverse not reported so far’ and overall grading
was given as ‘fair’ by the Reporting Officer. However, this was
modified by the Reviewing Officer as ‘good’ and the same grading
was given by the accepting authority. The remark column suggests
that ‘there is need for considerable improvement’. It is also said that
‘No initiative was taken. Needed continuous reminders from superiors.
The work will be accumulated for continuous period and there were
complaints from subordinates and peers.’ It also suggests that ‘the
officer need to make improvement in many aspects.’
8.
In respect of the APARs from 02.09.2020 to 31.12.2020, the
integrity has been certified as ‘reliable’ and the grading has been
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
given by the Reporting Officer as ‘good’ which has been confirmed by
the Reviewing Officer and Accepting Officer. In respect of the APARs
from 01.01.2021 to 17.09.2021, the integrity of the petitioner has
been certified as ‘reliable’ and overall grading was given as ‘good’ by
the Reporting Officer which was confirmed by the Reviewing Officer
and Accepting Officer. In respect of the APARs from 01.01.2022 to
31.03.2022 (for a period of three months), the petitioner has been
given grading ‘very good’ by the Reporting Officer, however, the
Reviewing Officer has not given overall grading, but in a scale of 1 to
10, the petitioner has been given 7.09 marks and the Accepting
Officer has given 7 marks.
9.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner, therefore, submits that
the petitioner’s work and conduct cannot be said that it lacks
integrity, or the petitioner has become deadwood in the
organization. The submission is that no reasonable person can reach
the conclusion that the petitioner has become deadwood after
considering the APARs and the decision to retire her prematurely is
against the settled norms and is liable to be set aside.
10.
The learned Counsel for the respondent Corporation, however,
submits that the petitioner has not produced the entire APARs and if
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
the APARs from 2015 onwards are considered, the overall service
records of the petitioner would suggest that the petitioner has been
‘underperforming’ throughout and in several occasions her integrity
has not been found ‘beyond doubt’. In the APAR for the year 2015,
the comments of the Reporting Officer are as follows;
“The officer had to be pushed for work as she is not self
propelling. Due to lack of knowledge of work procedures and
circulars, it is really difficult to extract work from the Officer.
The Officer remained as statics collector and could not
contribute any ideas in any file, of her own. A thorough
training and orientation is recommended as there is no
knowledge of the field operations or knowledge about
operation decision. She mostly remain on leave.’
However, the integrity was certified as ‘good’ and overall grading was
given ‘fair’ which was the view of the Reviewing Officer and the
Accepting Officer.
11.
The APAR of 2016 would disclose that the Reporting Officer has
found the petitioner’s integrity as ‘sincere’ and overall grading was
‘good’. However, the Reviewing Officer has noticed ‘nothing found
appreciable. She is a routine worker. Requires improvement in her skill
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
and administration’ and same was concurred by the Accepting Officer.
In the APAR of 2017, the Reporting Officer noted ‘there were
considerable delay in processing matters which causes action from
various commissions/courts.
Routine performance. No initiatives.
Requires continuous reminders even for routine works. Requires to
improve liasoning with subordinates.’ Against integrity it was written
‘nothing adverse’ and overall grading was ‘fair’ which was also the
view of the Reviewing Officer.
The Reviewing Officer, in its
comments, also noted ‘nothing found to be mentioned. But need to
improve her performance a lot’. Overall grading was ‘fair’ and it was
accepted by the Accepting Officer. In 2018 APAR, the Reporting
Officer noted ‘no initiative. Need constant reminders. Dependent upon
subordinates.
Many important matters delayed causing notices.’
Overall grading was given as ‘fair’, which was modified as ‘good’ by
the Reviewing Officer and the Accepting Officer has given the overall
grading ‘fair’.
12.
Regulation 22(2) A (iii) of the FCI Staff Regulation, 1971 which
are relevant for the purposes of decision of this case is extracted
hereunder;
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
“22(2)A(iii) Where the order of premature retirement is set aside by a
Court of Law with specific directions in regard to regulation of the
period between the date of premature retirement and the date of
reinstatement and no further appeal is proposed to be filed, the
aforesaid period shall be regulated in accordance with the directions of
the Court.”
13.
The work and performance of the employees is reviewed to find
out the ‘deadwoods’ and ‘black sheep’ and it is found from the overall
assessment of the work, conduct and service records of an employee
that an employee has become deadwood, such an employee has to
prematurely retire from the organization so that work and
performance of the organization does not suffer because of such an
employee has become deadwood or he/she is black sheep in the
organization.
14.
It is not only APARs which are required to be considered for
taking a decision that whether an employee has become deadwood
but, his overall work and conduct during service is required to be
evaluated to reach the conclusion that whether his/her continuation
in the organization would contribute to the growth of the
organization or not.
15.
This Court has taken note of the APARs of the petitioner just to
find out whether the decision taken by the Reviewing Authority is
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
based on the relevant criteria or it is based on irrelevant
consideration.
From the extract of the APARs itself, it would
demonstrate that the petitioner who was holding a higher post i.e.
the post of Assistant General Manager lacks initiative and needs
continuous improvement. The comments in the APARs, year after
year, would suggest that there was lack of any initiative on the part
of the petitioner, and she has become deadwood in the organization.
Therefore, I am of the considered view that the decision of the
Review Committee to retire the petitioner prematurely do not suffer
from any illegality or perversity which require this Court to interfere
with and, thus, the present writ petition is hereby dismissed.
Sd/-
D. K. SINGH
JUDGE
Svn
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 7688/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.FCI HQ-E-1/5/2023ESTT1(COMP.NO.156861) DATED 19/5/2023
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.FCI HQ-E-1/5/2023ESTTI (COMP NO.15681) DATED 06/07/2023
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
REPRESENTATION
DATED
21/10/2023 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER TO THE
1ST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE CIRCULAR NO.EP-01-2021-24
DATED 9TH JULY 2021 ISSUED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE
REVIEW COMMITTEE DATED NIL ALONG WITH THE NOTE
FILED ISSUED UNDER THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT
TO THE PETITIONER
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.FCI HQ-E-1/5/2023ESTT
1-PART(2)
(COMP.NO.198218)
DATED
9/10/2023 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.FCI
1016/39/2023-ESTT
1(COMP.NO.201006)
9/10/2023 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.ZO
(N)27.0032/3/2023-E-1-ZO NORTH DATED 10/10/2023
ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.
ZO
(N)27.0032/3/2023-E-1-ZO NORTH DATED 13/10/2023
ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
DATED
23/5/2023
HQ-EDATED
W.P.(C) NO. 7688 OF 2024
2025:KER:26140
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.
ZO
(N)27.0032/3/2023-E-1-ZO NORTH DATED 13/10/2023
ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P12
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.FCI
1016/34/2023-ESTT
1(COMP.NO.198660)
9/10/2023 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P13
TRUE COPY OF THE APAR OF THE PETITIONER FOR THE
PERIOD FROM 1/1/2019 TO 23/9/2019
EXHIBIT P14
A TRUE COPY OF THE APAR OF THE PETITIONER FOR
THE PERIOD FROM 2/9/2020 TO 31/12/2020
EXHIBIT P15
TRUE COPY OF THE APAR OF THE PETITIONER FOR THE
PERIOD FROM 1/1/2021 TO 17/9/2021
EXHIBIT P16
TRUE COPY OF THE APAR OF THE PETITIONER FOR THE
PERIOD FROM 1/1/2022 TO 31/3/2022
HQ-EDATED
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R3(A) THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.FCI HQ-E1016/58/2022-ESTT 1 DATED 16-01-2023 ISSUED BY
FCI HQRS.
EXHIBIT R3(B) THE TRUE COPY OF DPOT OFFICE
NO.25013/03/2019-ESTT.A-IV DATED
ISSUED BY GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
MEMORANDUM
28-08-2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review