Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment Reserved on: 19.05.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 25.05.2026
+
CRL.A. 409/2017
STATE
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Utkarsh, APP for the State.
versus
BHAGAT SINGH
.....Respondent
Through:
None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA
JUDGMENT
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA, J.
1.
In this appeal filed under Section 378(1) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (the Cr.P.C.), the respondent/State in Sl.
No. 317/3 of 2012 on the file of the Metropolitan Magistrate,
South East, New Delhi, assails the judgment dated 05.03.2016 as
per which the sole accused has been acquitted of the offences
punishable under Sections 279, 337 and 304A of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (IPC).
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
2.
The prosecution case is that, on 02.05.2011, at about
11:00 AM at Main Ring Road, Ashram, towards ITO, beneath
Barapulla Flyover, Sarai Kale Khan, New Delhi, while PW2 was
riding motor cycle bearing Reg. No. UP-14 AV-4661 with his wife
and son as pillion riders, the accused, the driver of DTC bus
bearing registration no. DL1PC9325 drove the vehicle in a rash
and negligent manner so as to endanger human life and personal
safety of others and hit the motorcycle as a result of which all three
were thrown on to the road causing injuries to them. Mamta, the
wife of PW2, succumbed to death due to the seriousness of the
injuries sustained. Hence, as per the charge sheet/final report, the
accused was alleged to have committed the offences punishable
under Sections 279, 337 and 304A IPC.
3.
On the basis of Ext. PW2/A FIS/FIR of PW2, given on
02.05.2011, crime no. 156/1999, Sunlight Colony Police Station,
was registered for commission of offences punishable under
Sections 279 and 304A IPC by Meena Arora, Woman Head-
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
Constable
(W/HC),
PW7,
Assistant
Sub-Inspector
(ASI),
conducted investigation into the crime and on completion of the
same, filed the charge-sheet/final report alleging the commission
of the offences punishable under the aforementioned Sections.
4.
When the accused was produced before the trial court,
all the copies of the prosecution records were furnished to him as
contemplated under Section 207 Cr.P.C. The particulars of the
offences punishable under Sections 279, 337 and 304A IPC, as
contemplated under Section 251 Cr.P.C., was read over and
explained to the accused, to which he pleaded not guilty.
5.
On behalf of the prosecution, PWs. 1 to 7 were
examined and Ext. PW1/A-B, Ext. PW2/A-B, Ext. PW3/A-C, Ext.
PW4/A, Ext. PW 5/A-B, Ext. PW6/A, Ext. PW7/A-C, Ex. PA/1 to
PA/3, Ext.A-1 to A-5 were marked in support of the case.
6.
After the close of the prosecution evidence, the accused
was questioned under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. regarding the
incriminating circumstances appearing against him in the evidence
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
of the prosecution. The accused denied all those circumstances and
maintained his innocence. The accused submitted that it is a false
case and that the prosecution version is contrary to what actually
transpired. According to the accused, his vehicle was moving
ahead while the motorcycle of PW2 was behind his bus and was
trying to overtake his vehicle. He noticed in the right-side rearview mirror that the motorcycle had lost its balance following
which PW2 fell on the road.
7.
No oral or documentary evidence was adduced by the
accused.
8.
Upon consideration of the oral and documentary
evidence on record, and after hearing both sides, the trial court,
vide the impugned judgement dated 05.03.2016, acquitted the
accused under Section 255(1) Cr.P.C. of the offences punishable
under Sections 279, 337 and 304A IPC. Aggrieved, the
respondent/State has preferred this appeal.
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
9.
The learned Additional Public Prosecutor, appearing on
behalf of the State, submitted that the trial court failed to properly
appreciate the cogent ocular and medical evidence available on
record. The testimony of PW2 clearly establishes that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the accused. His
testimony stood duly corroborated by Ext. PA II to PA IV MLCs
of the injured persons and Ext. PA V Post Mortem Report of the
deceased.
10. It was submitted by the learned counsel for the
respondent/accused that there is no infirmity in the impugned
judgment calling for an interference by this Court.
11. Heard both sides and perused the records.
12. The only point that arises for consideration in the
present appeal is whether there is any infirmity in the impugned
judgment calling for an interference by this Court.
13. I make a brief reference to the oral and documentary
evidence relied on by the prosecution in support of the case. Ext.
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
PW2/A, the FIS/FIR of PW2 recorded in Hindi roughly translated
reads thus:- “…Today morning at around 7:30 AM, I was going to
Kalkaji Temple to perform prayers along with my wife and child
on motorcycle number UP-14 AV-4661. After performing prayers,
we were returning on the said motorcycle to my brother-in-law's
place at Chhayarsa village. At around 11:00 AM, when we
reached near the S.K. Khan underpass / Flyover, a red-coloured
DTC bus, bearing registration number DL-1PC-9325, coming
from behind, being driven by its driver (the accused) at a very high
speed, rashly and negligently, overtook us while brushing against
the front handle of my motorcycle. Due to this, the balance of the
motorcycle was lost. My wife's head hit the bus, and she fell onto
the road. I and my son also fell down along with the motorcycle.
My wife's head hit the road hard, because of which she started
bleeding heavily from her head and mouth. My son Gauravint also
sustained internal injuries. The bus driver stopped the bus at a
short distance ahead. Upon inquiry, his name was found to be
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
Bhagat Singh, son of Shri Ranveer Singh, resident of Village/Post:
JasaurKheri, District: Jhajjar, Haryana. A passing public vehicle
(TSR/Auto) was stopped, in which my wife and child were placed
along with me. I admitted my wife and child to the Trauma Centre,
AIIMS for treatment, where the doctor declared my wife dead. The
aforementioned bus driver, by driving his bus rashly, negligently,
and at a high speed, has caused injuries to my wife Mamta and my
boy Gauravint, aged about 10 months. Legal action should be
taken against the DTC Bus Driver.”
(Emphasis supplied)
14. PW2, when examined, deposed that on 02.05.2011, he
along with his wife Mamta and their 10 month old son was
travelling on motorcycle bearing no. UP 14AV 4661 from the
house of his brother-in-law at Ghaziabad towards Kalkaji Mandir.
By about 11:00 AM, when they reached Main Ring Road, Ashram
towards ITO near Barapula Flyover, a red colour DTC bus bearing
registration no. DL 1PC 9325 came from behind at a very high
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
speed and in a rash and negligent manner and struck against the
left side handle of his motorcycle, due to which, the motorcycle
lost balance causing all of them to fall on the road. In the course of
the fall, his wife’s head struck against the body of the bus. PW2
further deposed that his wife sustained a serious injury and she
started bleeding profusely from her forehead. The driver of the bus
had stopped his vehicle and so he saw the driver. Thereafter,
someone informed the police. He shifted his wife and son to
AIIMS Hospital in a three-seater auto rickshaw (TSR), where his
wife was declared dead.
14.1.
PW2 in his cross examination deposed that there
was no heavy traffic on the Ring Road at the time of the incident
and that he was driving the motorcycle at a speed of about 40
kmph. PW2 denied the suggestion that the offending bus was
going much ahead of him and that some other vehicle had caused
the accident. He also denied the suggestion that the accused had
come to their help and had shifted them to the roadside.
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
15. PW1,
Motor
Vehicle
Inspector,
produced
the
Mechanical inspection report of the offending vehicle and the
motorcycle of PW2 which are Ext. PW1/A and Ext. PW1/B
respectively.
16. The offence under Section 279 IPC is made out when a
person drives or rides any vehicle on any public way in a manner
so rash or negligent as to endanger human life, or to be likely to
cause hurt or injury to any person. Section 337 IPC says that
whoever causes hurt to any person by doing any act so rashly or
negligently as to endanger human life, or the personal safety of
others, is liable to be punished. The offence under Section 304A
IPC is attracted when death of any person is caused by doing any
rash or negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide. To bring
a case of homicide under Section 304A IPC, the following
conditions must exist, namely, (i) there must be death of the person
in question; (ii) the accused must have caused such death; and (iii)
that such act of the accused was rash or negligent and that it does
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
not amount to culpable homicide. The section deals with homicidal
death by rash or negligent act.
17. As held in Naresh Giri v. State of Madhya Pradesh
(2008) 1 SCC 791, Section 304A IPC applies to cases where there
is no intention to cause death and no knowledge that the act done
in all probability will cause death. The provision is directed at
offences outside the range of Sections 299 and 300 IPC. Section
304A IPC applies only to such acts which are rash and negligent
and are directly the cause of the death of another person.
Negligence and rashness are essential elements under Section
304A IPC.
18. The criminality as far as rash acts are concerned, lies in
running the risk of doing such an act with recklessness or
indifference as to the consequences. Criminal negligence occurs
when there is gross and culpable neglect or failure to exercise the
required care and precaution to guard against injury, either to the
public generally or to an individual in particular, which, having
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
regard to all the circumstances, was the imperative duty of the
accused person to have adopted. In other words, negligence is the
omission to do something which a reasonable man, guided upon
the considerations which ordinarily regulate the conduct of human
affairs, would do, or, the doing of something which a prudent and
reasonable man would not do.
19. Having thus reminded myself the law on the point, I
will now consider whether the evidence on record is sufficient to
find the accused guilty of the offences charged against him. Ext.
PW7/B Site plan is seen prepared by PW7, the Investigation
Officer (IO). The note given at the bottom of the plan in Hindi
roughly translated reads thus:- “Mark A shows the place where the
driver of the DTC bus hit the side of the motorcycle, due to which
the woman sitting behind on the motorcycle fell onto the road and
where blood was present. Mark B shows the place where the
motorcycle was found parked near the pavement. Mark C is the
spot where the DTC Bus was found parked after the accident. The
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
total width of the road going from Ashram to ITO is 40 feet. The
distance of the accident spot from the central divider is 28 feet,
and the distance of the accident spot from the pavement is 12 feet.
The DTC Bus and motorcycle were both found parked near the
pavement. From the spot of the accident, the distance of the bus
was 23 feet and the distance of the motorcycle was 7 feet”.
20. Therefore, going by the site plan, point Ⓐ shown in the
site plan is the place where the accident took place. But point Ⓐ in
the site plan has been shown inside two dotted lines, which portion
is noted as ‘ganda nala’. Therefore, is point Ⓐ inside the ganda
nala? Neither PW2, the injured, nor the prosecution has such a
case.
21. Further, as per the site plan, the width of the road
running in the north-south direction is 40 feet. The incident is
alleged to have taken place 12 feet away from the pavement.
This, I believe, is point Ⓐ in the site plan. With this in mind, I will
refer to the evidence of PW2. In Ext. PW2/A FIS/FIR, the DTC
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
bus driven by the accused came from behind at a very high speed
in a rash and negligent manner, overtook his motorcycle and in the
process of overtaking the motorcycle, brushed against the front
handle of the motorcycle. If that be so, the accused must have
overtaken motorcycle being ridden by PW2 through the right side
as PW2 has no case that the accused had attempted to overtake his
vehicle from the wrong side or from the left side. If the overtaking
was done from the right side, then it must have been the right
handle of the motorcycle that had brushed against the bus.
However, PW2 in the box has an entirely different case. He
deposed that on the said day, the bus driven by the accused came
from behind at a very high speed and in a rash and negligent
manner and brushed against the left side handle of his motorcycle
due to which he lost balance and all of them had fallen on the
ground. If the appellant/accused had tried to overtake the bus
through the right side as stated by PW2 in the FIS/FIR, I fail to
understand how the left handle of the motorcycle brushed against
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
the bus resulting in the motorcycle losing its balance. Apart from
the testimony of PW2, there are no other eye witnesses to the
incident. The site plan as well as the testimony of PW2 is
insufficient to find the accused/ respondent guilty of the offences
charged against him.
22. In such circumstances, I find that the trial court was
justified in acquitting the accused. I find no infirmity calling for
interference by this Court.
23. In the result, the appeal is dismissed.
24. Application(s), if any, pending, shall stand closed.
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA
(JUDGE)
MAY 25, 2026
kd
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
14:55:17
CRL.A. 409/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review