Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Court No.2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
I.A No.01 of 2018
IN
Crl. L.P No.02 of 2018
…..Petitioner/Applicant
State of Sikkim
VERSUS
….Respondent
Tenzing Bhutia
Date: 14/09/2018
CORAM :
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, A.C.J
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
For Petitioner/Applicant
:
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Govt. Advocate
with Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Govt.
Advocate, Mr. S.K Chhetri and Ms. Pollin Rai,
Asst. Govt. Advocate.
For Respondent
:
Ms. Gita Bista, Legal Aid Counsel.
Pradhan, J.
1.
This is an application for condonation of delay in filing Leave to
Appeal and Memorandum of Appeal under Section 5 of the
Limitation Act, 1963.
2.
The explanation given by the Applicant-State of Sikkim is :“That the impugned judgment acquitting the respondent was passed on
30.11.2017. An application for the certified copy of the said judgment was
applied on 26.12.2017. The certified copy was made ready and delivered on
the same day i.e. on 26.12.2017. As such appeal is required to be filed within
90 days i.e. on or before 28.02.2018, there is 73 (seventy three) days delay
in filing the leave to appeal and memorandum of appeal. On 14.02.2018
Superintendent of Police (South) Sikkim had opined to file an appeal and
forwarded the file to ADGP Law and Order. Thereafter on 15.02.2018 ADGP
headquarter forwarded the file to Law Officer Police for comments. On
17.02.2018 Law Officer of Police had opined to file an appeal and forwarded
the file to ADGP. Thereafter, on 19.02.2018 ADGP Law and Order forwarded
the file to Director General of Police, Government of Sikkim. Then the file was
forwarded by the Director General of Police to Ld. Addl. Advocate General for
his opinion on 21.02.2018. Thereafter, on 21.02.2018 the Ld. Addl. Advocate
General forwarded the file to Sr. Government Advocate /PP for obtaining his
opinion in the instant matter. The Sr. Government Advocate/PP while
perusing the Judgment dated 30.11.2017 it was found that het Judgment
was underlined in many places and same would not be acceptable by the
Court No.2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
Registry of the Hon’ble High Court of Sikkim when the same is filed with the
appeal. Therefore, Sr. Government Advocate/PP office of the Advocate
General advised the Investigating Officer of the case to apply once again the
certified copy of the judgment from the Ld. Sessions Court, Namchi, South
Sikkim. And the Investigating Officer again applied for the certified copy of
the judgment on 05.03.2018 and the same was delivered on 07.03.2018. On
24.02.2018 the Sr. Government Advocate/PP had given his opinion and
forwarded the file to Ld. Addl. Advocate General. Thereafter, Ld. Addl.
Advocate General taking into the consideration the evidence highlighted by
the Ld. Sr. Government Advocate/PP in his opinion had advised to file an
appeal against the order of acquittal. Thereafter, on 26.02.2018 Ld. Addl.
Advocate General forwarded the file to Director General of Police for
government approval. On 28.02.2018 Director General of Police forwarded the
file to Addl. Chief Secretary had forwarded the file to Hon’ble Chief Minister
for approval. Thereafter, the Hon’ble Chief Minister had approved the file on
14.03.2018 and sent back to Chief Secretary, Government of Sikkim. On
15.03.2018 Chief Secretary, Government of Sikkim forwarded the file to DGP.
Thereafter, on 19.03.2018 DGP forwarded the file to ADGP Law and Order
and ADGP Law and Order forwarded the file to Superintendent of Police,
South, Namchi. Thereafter, on 03.04.2018 Superintendent of Police, Sought,
Namchi sent the file to Ld. Sr. Government Advocate, office of the Advocate
General for filing an appeal. That Superintendent of Police, Namchi could not
send the file to Ld. Sr. Government Advocate in time as the Superintendent of
Police, South, Namchi was on official training at New Delhi for a week. Then
the office of the Advocate General received the file only on 04.04.2018.
Thereafter, on the same date i.e. 04.04.2018 Ld. Sr. Government Advocate
handed over the file to Asst. Public Prosecutor for drafting of the
memorandum of Appeal, Leave to Appeal and Condonation of delay. The
Asst. Public Prosecutor prepared and drafted the memorandum of Appeal,
Leave to Appeal and Condonation of delay and on 19.04.2018 placed before
the Ld. Sr. Government Advocate cum PP could not vet the drafts of
memorandum of Appeal, Leave to Appeal and Condonation of delay due to
day to day continuous hearing before this Hon’ble Court. Thereafter, due to
unavoidable work of Ld. Sr. Government Advocate cum PP from 01.05.2018 to
05.05.2018 could not vet the draft memorandum of Appeal, Leave to Appeal
and Condonation of delay was settled by the Ld. Sr. Government Advocatecum-PP.”
3.
The Respondent has filed his reply/objection to the application
for condonation of delay in which it is submitted that the
Applicant has failed to explain delay of 26 days for the period
30.11.2017 to 26.12.2017, since admittedly, the Applicant had
applied for the certified copy of the impugned Judgment dated
30.11.2017 only on 26.12.2017.
Court No.2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
4.
The Respondent would also contest the application for
condonation of delay on the ground that no explanation has
been provided by the Applicant for the period 26.12.2017 to
14.02.2018 for not filing the Appeal within period prescribed.
5.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Senior Government Advocate
would honestly submit that it is true that the Applicant has
not explained the period between 30.11.2017 to 26.12.2017,
the period of nearly 26 days in the application. However, he
would submit that since it is the duty of the Public Prosecutor
or the Court Inspector to apply for the certified copy of the
Judgment passed in a criminal case, evidently, it was an error
committed by the Prosecution in failing to apply for certified
copy during the said period.
6.
After applying for a copy of the impugned Judgment dated
30.11.2017 only on 26.12.2017 as per the explanation given in
the paragraph quoted above it was only on 4.02.2018 that the
Superintendent of Police opined to file the appeal and
forwarded the file to Additional Director General of Police, Law
and Order (ADGP. This makes it clear that the Prosecution
took the period 26.12.2017 to 14.02.2018 to get the opinion
from the Superintendent of Police. Whether the Prosecution
promptly placed the file for opinion of Superintendent of Police
on time immediately after obtaining the copy of the impugned
Judgment on 26.12.2017 or the Superintendent of Police took
that much time to render his opinion is not clear from the
application. However, it is certain that the Prosecution took the
period 26.12.2017 to 14.02.2018 to get the opinion of the
Superintendent of Police.
7.
Mr. Karma Thinlay would rely upon the Judgment of the
Supreme Court in re: Esha Bhattacharjee v. Managing
Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy & Ors. reported in
(2013) 12 SCC 649 and submit that there is a distinction
between inordinate delay and delay of short duration or few
days and that it is only in the former case of inordinate delay
that doctrine of prejudice may be attracted and for a delay of
short duration the doctrine of prejudice may not be attracted.
It is submitted that the inordinate delay warrants strict
Court No.2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
approach and a delay of short duration warrants liberal
delineation. Mr. Karma Thinlay would submit that the delay of
73 day cannot be termed as inordinate delay especially after
the explanation given.
8.
A perusal of the application reflects bureaucratic impediments
in
the
process
of
seeking
administration
of
justice.
Unfortunately, this is the process which has been followed due
to which time is taken for the movement of file from one officer
to other seeking opinions, views and approvals. The Limitation
Act, 1963 does not provide any concession to the Government.
However, the fact that process of approval seeking in the
Government does travel from one office to the other and back
and forth until decision is finally taken seems to be usual and
thus, cannot be ignored. The Court may not approve all these
bureaucratic impediments but unfortunately, cannot also
ignore that due to this process which has been practiced delay
does occur. In a criminal case the State represents the victim
of crime. The delay caused due to the process of seeking
approval in this manner, almost usual for Government offices,
leading to a delay of 73 days cannot to our mind be an
impediment for the State of Sikkim seeking justice. The cause
of justice cannot be impeded by the slow approach or even the
lethargy of those officers whose ground the Applicant-State of
Sikkim seeks condonation of.
The delay of 73 days read with
the explanation given by the State Applicant would not amount
to gross negligence or deliberate inaction or lack of bona fides
imputable to the State of Sikkim-the Applicant. In this view of
the matter ‘sufficient cause’ has been shown by the Applicant
to condone the delay in preferring the present Leave to Appeal
and the Appeal.
9.
In view of the aforesaid, the delay is condoned. Application is
allowed.
10.
I.A stands disposed.
Judge
14-09-2018
Avi/
Acting Chief Justice
14-09-2018
Index : Yes / No
Internet : Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review