Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Criminal Appeal Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------D.B.:
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. A. No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim
.… Appellant
versus
Suren Rai,
S/o Shri Dhan Bahadur Rai,
R/o Near Karmatar Junior High School,
Darjeeling – West Bengal.
…. Convict
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr.
Karma
Thinlay,
Additional
Public
Prosecutor,
Mr.
Thinlay
Dorjee
Bhutia,
Additional Public Prosecutor and Mr. S.K
Chettri, Assistant Public Prosecutor for the
Appellant.
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Bhola
Nath Sharma, Advocate for the Convict.
------------------------------------------------------------------------ORDER ON SENTENCE
(21.06.2018)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
Heard Mr. Karma Thinlay, Learned Additional Public
Prosecutor as well as Mr. B. Sharma, Learned Senior
Advocate for the convict on sentence.
2.
Mr. Karma Thinlay would draw the attention of this
Court particularly to paragraph 1 and 117 of the judgment
of conviction in the present case and submit that the crime
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
being homicidal and gruesome inflicting multiple chop
wounds on the neck with the “khukuri” which caused the
death of 27 years old youth the sentence must be adequate.
He would draw the attention of this Court to the conduct of
the convict after the assault of having run away while the
victim was still alive to submit that the commission of the
heinous act should necessarily attract the sentence of life
as envisaged by paragraph 1 of Section 304
IPC. He would
rely upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in re:
State of M.P. v. Ghanshyam Singh1 as well as Alister Anthony
Pareira v. State of Maharashtra2 to buttress his submissions.
3.
Per contra Mr. B. Sharma would submit that while
imposing sentence it would be important to keep in mind
the age and the antecedents of the convict. He would
submit that at the time of the alleged crime in the year
2013 he was 27 years old and as such would be only 32
years of age now. He would further submit that there is no
allegation of any criminal antecedent of the convict by the
prosecution. Mr. B. Sharma would also submit that the
convict has already undergone 4 years and 9 months in
custody counting the period of his incarceration between
the date of his arrest on 24.05.2013 till the date of his
release a day after his acquittal by the Learned Sessions
Judge on 29.02.2016 and thereafter on his arrest on
(2003) 8 SCC 13
(2012) 2 SCC 648
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
22.07.2016 after the order of this Court for his arrest dated
22.07.2016 till date. He would submit that the convict had
travelled to Sikkim to earn a living to take care of his poor
parents from the neighbouring State and his further
incarceration would cause immense hardship leaving his
aging parents without any help in their time of need.
Accordingly, Mr. B. Sharma would pray for set off from the
period already undergone in custody. He would rely upon
the judgment of the Supreme Court in re: Pritam Chauhan v.
State (Govt. Of NCT Delhi)3.
4.
In re: Ghanshyam Singh (supra) the Supreme Court
would examine a sentence of about 2 years and fine of
₹15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) imposed in a case
where the accused was found guilty of offence punishable
under Section 304 Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) imposed
by the High Court. The accused was found guilty of using a
gun on the victim firing two shots, one on his leg and the
other on the abdomen due to which the victim succumbed
to his injuries subsequently. The Supreme Court would
agree with the conclusion of the High Court about the
applicability of Section 304 Part I of the IPC. On the
question of proper sentence the Supreme Court would hold:
“11.
The
law
regulates
social
interests,
arbitrates
conflicting claims and demands. Security of persons and
(2014) 9 SCC 637
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
property of the people is an essential function of the State. It
could be achieved through instrumentality of criminal law.
Undoubtedly, there is a cross-cultural conflict where living law
must find an answer to the new challenges and the courts are
required to mould the sentencing system to meet the challenges.
The contagion of lawlessness would undermine social order and
lay it in ruins. Protection of society and stamping out criminal
proclivity must be the object of law which must be achieved by
imposing appropriate sentence. Therefore, law as a cornerstone
of the edifice of “order” should meet the challenges confronting
the society. Friedman in his Law in Changing Society stated that,
“State of criminal law continues to be — as it should be — a
decisive reflection of social consciousness of society.” Therefore,
in operating the sentencing system, law should adopt the
corrective machinery or the deterrence based on factual matrix.
By deft modulation sentencing process has to be stern where it
should be, and tempered with mercy where it warrants to be.
The facts and given circumstances in each case, the nature of the
crime, the manner in which it was planned and committed, the
motive for commission of the crime, the conduct of the accused,
the
nature
of
weapons
used
and
all
other
attending
circumstances are relevant facts which would enter into the area
of consideration. For instance, a murder committed due to deepseated mutual and personal rivalry may not call for penalty of
death. But an organised crime or mass murder of innocent people
would call for imposition of death sentence as deterrence. In
Mahesh v. State of M.P. [(1987) 3 SCC 80 : 1987 SCC (Cri) 379 :
(1987) 2 SCR 710] this Court while refusing to reduce the death
sentence observed thus: (SCC p. 82, para 6)
It will be a mockery of justice to permit the accused
to escape the extreme penalty of law when faced with
such evidence and such cruel acts. To give the lesser
punishment for the accused would be to render the
justicing system of the country suspect. The common man
will lose faith in courts. In such cases, he understands and
appreciates the language of deterrence more than the
reformative jargon.”
xxxxxxxxxxxx
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
“15. After giving due consideration to the facts and
circumstances of each case, for deciding just and appropriate
sentence to be awarded for an offence, the aggravating and
mitigating factors and circumstances in which a crime has been
committed are to be delicately balanced on the basis of really
relevant circumstances in a dispassionate manner by the court.
Such act of balancing is indeed a difficult task. It has been very
aptly indicated in Dennis Councle McGautha v. State of
California [402 US 183 : 28 L Ed 2d 711 (1971)] that no formula
of a foolproof nature is possible that would provide a reasonable
criterion in determining a just and appropriate punishment in the
infinite variety of circumstances that may affect the gravity of the
crime. In the absence of any foolproof formula which may provide
any basis for reasonable criteria to correctly assess various
circumstances germane to the consideration of gravity of crime,
the discretionary judgment in the facts of each case is the only
way in which such judgment may be equitably distinguished.”
xxxxxxxxxxxx
“20. Taking into account all the relevant aspects of this
case in the background of principles governing award of
appropriate sentence, we feel that even on a liberal approach,
custodial sentence of 6 years would serve the ends of justice.
While fixing the sentence we have taken note of the fine imposed
which remains unaltered. It is said to have been paid. There was
a stipulation for 2 years' RI in case of default. The respondent,
who is on bail, shall surrender to custody to serve the balance of
sentence.”
5.
In re: Alister Anthony Pareira (supra) the Supreme
Court would examine a case of drunken driving in which
the High Court had set aside the acquittal of the Appellant
under Section 304 IPC and convicted him for the offences
under Section 304 Part II, Section 338 and Section 337 IPC
and sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
three years for the offence punishable under Section 304
Part II IPC with a fine of ₹ 5.00 lakhs. On account of the
offence under Section 338 IPC, the Appellant was sentence
to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a term of one year
and for the offence under Section 337 IPC rigorous
imprisonment for six months. The Supreme Court would
hold:
“84. Sentencing is an important task in the matters of
crime. One of the prime objectives of the criminal law is
imposition of appropriate, adequate, just and proportionate
sentence commensurate with the nature and gravity of crime and
the manner in which the crime is done. There is no straitjacket
formula for sentencing an accused on proof of crime. The courts
have evolved certain principles: the twin objective of the
sentencing policy is deterrence and correction. What sentence
would meet the ends of justice depends on the facts and
circumstances of each case and the court must keep in mind the
gravity of the crime, motive for the crime, nature of the offence
and all other attendant circumstances.
85. The principle of proportionality in sentencing a crimedoer is well entrenched in criminal jurisprudence. As a matter of
law, proportion between crime and punishment bears most
relevant influence in determination of sentencing the crime-doer.
The court has to take into consideration all aspects including
social interest and consciousness of the society for award of
appropriate sentence.”
xxxxxxxxxxxx
“97. The facts and circumstances of the case which have
been proved by the prosecution in bringing home the guilt of the
accused under Section 304 Part II IPC undoubtedly show a
despicable
aggravated
offence
warranting
punishment
proportionate to the crime. Seven precious human lives were lost
by the act of the accused. For an offence like this which has been
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
proved against the appellant, sentence of three years awarded
by the High Court is too meagre and not adequate but since no
appeal has been preferred by the State, we refrain from
considering the matter for enhancement. By letting the appellant
away on the sentence already undergone i.e. two months in a
case like this, in our view, would be travesty of justice and
highly unjust, unfair, improper and disproportionate to the
gravity of crime. It is true that the appellant has paid
compensation of Rs 8,50,000 but no amount of compensation
could relieve the families of victims from the constant agony. As a
matter of fact, the High Court had been quite considerate and
lenient in awarding to the appellant sentence of three years for
an offence under Section 304 Part II IPC where seven persons
were killed.”
6.
In re: Pritam Chauhan (supra) the Supreme Court
would examine a case in which the accused had been
convicted for assault by knife causing two injuries on arm
of the victim and convicted under Section 307 IPC by the
Trial Court which conviction was altered by the High Court
under Section 326 IPC with consequential modification of
the sentence to rigorous imprisonment for a period of two
years and a fine of ₹ 50,000/- as compensation of the
victim. This was not a case where the victim had died due
to the repeated blows inflicting upon the victim. The assault
had caused grievous injury on his left forearm with deep
extensive damage to most of the muscles and the back of
his left forearm. Apart from the above there was another
wound on the palm of his right hand. The Supreme Court
would hold:
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
“5. The punishment contemplated under Section 326 IPC is
imprisonment for life or with imprisonment of either description
for a term which may extend to ten years, along with fine. In a
recent pronouncement of this Court in Gopal Singh v. State of
Uttarakhand [(2013) 7 SCC 545 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 608] it has
been held that the “principle of just punishment” is the bedrock
of sentencing in respect of a criminal offence. The wide discretion
that is vested in the courts in matters of sentencing must be
exercised on rational parameters in the light of the totality of the
facts of any given case. The doctrine of proportionality has to be
invoked in the context of the facts in which the crime had been
committed, the antecedents of the accused, the age of the
accused and such other relevant factors.
6. In the present case, considering that the appellantaccused had gone to his house to fetch a knife and, thereafter,
had given repeated blows to the victim resulting in multiple
grievous injuries, we are of the view that the sentence of two
years' rigorous imprisonment is just and adequate and will not
require any modification. The submission of the learned counsel
for the appellant that the appellant is willing to pay higher
compensation under Section 357 IPC also cannot be accepted
inasmuch as the provisions of Section 357 operate independently
of the specific penal provisions of the Code under which the court
is required to sentence an offender.”
7.
We have given our anxious consideration to the facts
of the present case as well as the submissions made by the
Learned Counsels for the parties.
8.
The sentence must keep the twin objective of the
sentencing policy which is deterrence and correction. We
had come to the conclusion that the convict is guilty of the
offence punishable under paragraph 1 of Section 304 IPC.
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
9.
In view of the submissions made by the Learned
Counsels appearing for the parties and keeping in mind the
facts and circumstances of the case we are of the view that
the sentence of 6 years with a fine of ₹ 25,000/- (Twenty
Five Thousand) only and in default, to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for one year would be appropriate, adequate,
just and proportionate sentence commensurate with the
nature and gravity of crime and the manner in which the
crime was done. Set-off be given to the convict in respect of
the period during which he was in jail in connection with
this case. If the fine amount is recovered, the same shall be
paid to the minor daughter of the deceased, resident of
Thalthaley, Karmatar, District Darjeeling, West Bengal as
compensation. The convict is in judicial custody. He shall
continue there to serve out the rest of his sentence. During
the period of his custody the prison authorities may
consider helping the convict with anger management by
providing him with professional help.
10. Mr. Karma Thinlay informs this Court that the victim
has his dependent parents as well as a minor daughter.
Under
the
Sikkim
Compensation
to
Victims
or
His
Dependents Schemes, 2011 the Sikkim State Legal Services
Authority (SSLSA) is directed to pay compensation of ₹ 1.00
lakh to the minor daughter. Out of the said amount an
amount of ₹ 75000/- (Rupees Seventy Five Thousand) shall
Crl. Appeal No. 17 of 2016
State of Sikkim vs. Suren Rai
be deposited in fixed deposit in the name of the minor
daughter payable to her on attaining majority. If the minor
does not have any bank account the SSLSA shall ensure
that the guardian of the minor shall open the said fixed
deposit in her name. The rest of the amount of ₹25,000/(Rupees Twenty Five Thousand) shall be deposited in the
account of the guardian of the minor which shall be used
by the guardian for the sole purpose of her education,
health and welfare. This amount shall be accountable to the
SSLSA
which
shall
call
for
periodic
reports
of
the
expenditure from the guardian till exhausted. A further
amount of ₹1.00 lakh shall be paid to the parents of the
victim.
11. A certified copy of this order shall be furnished
forthwith to the convict. Certified copy of the order on
sentence along with the records shall be remitted to the
Court of the Learned Sessions Judge, West Sikkim at
Gyalshing.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
21.06.2018
to
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
(Meenakshi M. Rai)
Judge
21.06.2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review