Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(CIVIL EXTRA ORDINARY JURISDICTION)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Single Bench: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
....
Petitioner
....
Respondent
Versus
National Human Rights Commission,
Through the Secretary General,
National Human Rights Commission,
Manav Adhikar Bhawan,
Block-C, GPO Complex,
INA, New Delhi – 110023.
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
---------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Hissey Gyaltsen, Assistant Government Advocate for the
petitioner.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
( 03.12.2021)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
Heard Mr. Hissey Gyaltsen, learned Assistant Government
Advocate.
2.
The State of Sikkim has preferred this writ petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking a writ for setting aside
the show cause notice dated 13.01.2021 and orders dated 9.6.2021
and 14.9.2021, passed by the National Human Rights Commission
(NHRC) in NHRC Case No. 1/21/3/2020-jcd relating to the suicide of
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
an under trial prisoner (UTP) Roshan Chettri in District Jail, Namchi,
as being arbitrary and illegal.
3.
On 13.01.2021, the NHRC issued a show cause notice to
the Chief Secretary of the petitioner stating, inter alia, that the
Commission had received intimation on 06.05.2020 from the Jailor,
District Jail, Namchi, Sikkim, regarding suicide by the UTP Roshan
Chettri (aged about 27 years), son of Shri Dilip Chettri in the prison on
04.04.2020. The show cause notice also records that the Investigation
Division of NHRC after collecting/analyzing relevant reports/records
has submitted that the deceased UTP was a covid-19 positive patient
and was in quarantine along with another UTP. On 04.04.2020, at 11
a.m., the deceased made an attempt to commit suicide by hanging
on the door of his cell with the help of cloth of the blanket
provided to him but that act was noticed by his cell mate who
caught hold his body and called out for help. Subsequently, jail
authorities arrived and brought him down by cutting the blanket
cloth. He was immediately shifted to hospital wherein he died
during the treatment. The inquest and the Post Mortem
Examination (PME) revealed no injury on the body of the
deceased other than ligature marks, the cause of death was
asphyxia due to hanging. The Magisterial Enquiry Report (MER)
conducted by the learned Judicial Magistrate, South Sikkim,
Namchi, concluded that no medical negligence and foul play was
found in the death of the deceased and that he committed
suicide by hanging.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
4.
The show cause notice further recorded that vide
direction dated 11.12.2020, the Commission after considering
the relevant reports had considered and directed as under:“Prima facie, the deceased committed suicide in
day time i.e. at 11:10 AM. Ensuring the safety and
security of inmates who are under care and
custody of the prison is one of the prime duties of
the authorities concerned in which it failed. Had the
prison authorities been vigilant enough, this
incident could have been avoided and the precious
life would have been saved. Hence, the State is
vicariously liable to compensate the next of kin of
the deceased under trial prisoner.”
5.
The
show
cause
notice
thereafter
required
the
petitioner to show cause as to why monetary compensation of
Rs.3,75,000/- should not be recommended under section 18(a)(i)
of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, to be paid to the
next of kin of the deceased Roshan Chettri.
6.
On 05.03.2021, the petitioner responded to the show
cause notice stating that no case of negligence on the part of jail
administration was found during the judicial enquiry by the
learned Judicial Magistrate, South Sikkim at Namchi. The
petitioner also forwarded the following documents to the NHRC:“(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
The detailed report of DIGP, State Central
Prison, Rongyek received vide letter dated
No.
463/GOS/PRISON/2021
dated
25/02/2021;
Letter to the Ld. CJM, South District by the
Jailer,
Sub
Jail,
Namchi
regarding
commission of suicide by UTP Roshan
Chhetri;
final enquiry report of Ld. JM, Namchi u/s
176 of Cr.PC. 1973;
Warrant of Commitment to Judicial Custody;
Report submitted to the Sikkim Human
Rights Commission;
First Information Report;
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
(vii)
(viii)
(ix)
(x)
(xi)
7.
Inquest Form u/s 174 of Cr.PC of Namchi
Police Station;
Inquest Report u/s 176 of Cr.PC of Judicial
Magistrate, Namchi;
Post Mortem Report of the deceased Roshan
Chettri;
Statement of witnesses taken by the Police;
Final Report of a reported case of unnatural
dead (sic „death‟) u/s 174 of Cr.PC. 1973.”
In the meanwhile, Dilip Chettri, father of the deceased
Roshan Chettri, filed a Writ Petition (Civil) No. 02 of 2021 (Dilip
Chettri vs. State of Sikkim & Others) under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. The writ petition prayed for a direction
upon the state respondents to pay compensation to the tune of
Rs.20,00,000/- as well as for an independent investigation of the
incident of the alleged suicide by a retired judge or a government
officer or any other person as deemed fit. The writ petition was
taken up on 12.03.2021 by the learned Single Bench of this
court and the following order was passed:“After hearing Learned Counsel for the Petitioner
and duly considering the matter, this Writ Petition
deserves to be and is dismissed in limine.”
8.
Thereafter, the NHRC vide communication dated
09.06.2021 addressed to the Chief Secretary of the petitioner,
informed that the Commission on 09.06.2021 had directed as
follows:“……………….. In the instant case, the Commission
had received an intimation on 06.05.2020 from
Jailor Dist. Jail Namchi, Sikkim regarding suicide
by under trial prisoner Roshan Chhetari (aged
about 27 year), S/o Dilip Chhetrari in the prison on
04.04.2020.
Vide proceeding dated 24.04.2021, the Commission
observed and directed as under-
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
“Pursuant to the directions of the Commission,
letter dated 05.03.2021 has been submitted by the
Joint Director (Confdl.), Home Department, Govt. of
Sikkim who has submitted the detailed report,
Letter to Ld. CJM, South District, final enquiry
report, warrant of commitment to judicial custody,
report submitted to Sikkim Human Rights
Commission, First Information Report, Inquest form
and report, post mortem report of the deceased,
statement of witnesses, final report of a reported
case of unnatural death U/sec. 174 Cr.P.C. As per
the attached detailed report of the DIGP, State
Central Prison dated 25.02.2021, the authority has
relied upon the judicial enquiry and the final report
filed by the P.S. Namchi, which does not establish
any negligence on the part of the jail
administration, district prison, Namchi.
The Commission has taken note of the contents of
the reports/reply to the show cause notice
submitted by the authorities and has also
considered the facts and circumstances of the case.
Admittedly the prisoner was in the care and
custody of the State and it was the bounden duty
of the State to ensure his safety. It is also an
admitted fact that he had committed suicide in day
time i.e. at 11:10 AM so had the prison authorities
been vigilant enough, this incident could have been
avoided and a precious life would have been
saved. Hence, the Commission is not inclined to
review its order of payment of monetary
compensation of Rs.3,75,000/- (Rs. Three Lakhs
Seventy Five Thousand only) to the NoK of the
aforesaid deceased UTP and hence confirms its
recommendation.
The Chief Secretary, Govt. of Sikkim is directed to
submit the proof of payment of monetary
compensation of Rs.3,75,000/- (Rupees Three
Lakhs Seventy-Five Thousand only) to the NoK of
the deceased UTP within six weeks failing which
the Commission will be constrained to invoke its
coercive power u/s 13 of the PHR Act, 1993 calling
for the personal appearance of the authority
concerned before the Commission.”
The Commission observes that the requisite reports
from aforesaid authority is still awaited.
In normal circumstances, such non responsive
attitude towards direction of the Commission would
have invited issuance of summons u/s 13 of the
PHR Act, 1993 calling for his personal appearance
before the Commission, but in view of the pandemic
situation in the country, last opportunity is being
given to the Chief Secretary, Govt. of Sikkim for
submission of requisite compliance report along
with proof of payment within four weeks failing
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
which the Commission would be constrained to
invoke its coercive power u/s 13 of the PHR Act,
1993 calling for the personal appearance of the
authority
concerned
before
the
Commission.………………………..”
9.
On 16.07.2021, the petitioner wrote to the NHRC
informing them, inter alia, that a Writ Petition (Civil) No. 02 of
2021 (supra) was filed by the father of the deceased before this
court on 09.03.2021 praying for compensation which came up
for hearing on 12.03.2021 and this court after hearing the
learned counsel for the petitioner dismissed it in limine “on merit
of the case and duly considering the matter”. The petitioner thus
urged the NHRC that the petitioner may be exempted from
payment of compensation as the proceeding before the NHRC
was barred by the principle of res judicata.
10.
On
14.09.2021,
the
NHRC
made
another
communication to the Chief Secretary of the petitioner stating
that on that day the Commission directed as follows:“The present matter pertains to intimation
regarding death of UTP Roshan of District Jail
Namchi, Sikkim.
In continuation of earlier proceedings vide
proceedings dated 26.07.2021 this Commission
has observed/directed as under:“In the instant case, the Commission had received
an intimation on 06.05.2020 from Jailor Dist. Jail
Namchi, Sikkim regarding suicide by under trial
prisoner Roshan Chhetari (aged about 27 year),
S/o Sh. Dilip Chhetari in the prison on 04.04.2020.
The Commission observes that the matter is
pending for want of compliance report along with
proof of payment of monetary compensation of
Rs.3,75,000/- (Rupees Three Lakhs Seventy-Five
Thousand only) to be paid to the NOK of the
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
deceased UTP Roshan Chhetari (aged about 27
year), S/o Sh. Dilip Chhetari who committed suicide
in the prison on 04.04.2020.
Registry is directed to issue final reminder to the
Chief Secretary, Govt. of Sikkim for submission of
compliance report along with the proof of payment
within four weeks failing which the Commission
shall be constrained to invoke its coercive power
u/s 13 of the PHR Act, 1993 calling for the personal
appearance of the authority concerned before the
Commission.”
Thus this Commission has sought the compliance
report regarding the payment of monetary
compensation of Rs.3,75,000/- to the NOK of
deceased UTP. Pursuant to same a report dated
16.07.2021 is received from Joint Director (Home
Department), Sikkim vide which he has submitted
that since the writ petition of the victim‟s father has
already been dismissed by Hon‟ble Sikkim High
Court, the Commission shall review its order and
State Govt. be exempted from the payment of
compensation as directed by the NHRC. It is
pertinent to observe here that vide proceedings
dated
09.06.2021
this
Commission
has
categorically declined the request of review of
concerned State Government. This Commission has
observed that:“The Commission has taken note of the contents of
the reports/reply to the sow cause notice submitted
by the authorities and has also considered the
facts and circumstances of the case. Admittedly,
the prisoner was in the care and custody of the
State and it was the bounden duty of the State to
ensure his safety. It is also an admitted fact that he
had committed suicide in day time i.e. at 11.10 AM
so had the prison authorities been vigilant enough,
this incident could have been avoided and a
precious life would have been saved. Hence, the
Commission is not inclined to review its order of
payment
of
monetary
compensation
of
Rs.3,75,000/- (Rs. Three Lakhs Seventy Five
Thousand only) to the NOK of the aforesaid
deceased
UTP
and
hence
confirms
its
recommendation.”
Thus this plea of the concerned authority has
already been declined. In view of same the Chief
Secretary, Govt. of Sikkim is recommended to pay
the compensation to the NOK of deceased of
Rs.3,75,000/- and submit a report in this regard
within eight weeks.”
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
11.
that
The NHRC vide the above communication requested
the
additional/compete
report
as
directed
by
the
Commission in the matter be sent latest by 19.11.2021 for
further consideration by the Commission.
12.
The petitioner aggrieved by the issuance of the show
cause notice and the impugned orders dated 09.06.2021 and
14.09.2021 has approached this court on eleven grounds.
13.
On perusal of the grounds and hearing the learned
counsel, it is clear that the petitioner is primarily aggrieved on
five counts. The petitioner is aggrieved that inspite of the
dismissal of W.P.(C) No. 02 of 2021 (supra) by this court, the
NHRC has passed the impugned orders which was barred by the
principle of res judicata; that the show cause notice and the
impugned orders did not disclose the commission of violation of
human rights by the police authorities or the negligence of the
police authorities in prevention of violation of human rights; that
the NHRC could not have entertained the complaint under
Regulation 9(xi) and 9(xii) of the National Human Rights
Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 1994; and that the NHRC
did not consider the final inquiry report dated 20.05.2021 of the
learned Judicial Magistrate and the final report of the Namchi
Police Station. It is further argued that merely because suicide
took place during the day, it does not in any manner corroborate
or substantiate that there was any negligence on the part of the
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
police authorities. Each of these grounds shall be considered
separately.
14.
The admitted facts are that show cause notice was
issued on 13.1.2021; the father of the deceased UTP Roshan
Chettri filed W.P.(C) No. 02 of 2021 (supra) on 09.03.2021 which
was dismissed in limine on 12.03.2021. The impugned orders
were thereafter passed by the NHRC.
15.
In Dario and others vs. State of Uttar Pradesh1, the
Supreme Court held as under:“19. We must now proceed to state our conclusion
on the preliminary objection raised by the
respondents. We hold that if a writ petition filed by
a party under Art. 226 is considered on the merits
as a contested matter and is dismissed the
decision thus pronounced would continue to bind
the parties unless it is otherwise modified or
reversed by appeal or other appropriate
proceedings permissible under the Constitution. It
would not be open to a party to ignore the said
judgment and move this Court under Art. 32 by an
original petition made on the same facts and for
obtaining the same or similar orders or writs. If the
petition filed in the High Court under Art. 226 is
dismissed not on the merits but because of the
laches of the party applying for the writ or because
it is held that the party had an alternative remedy
available to it, then the dismissal of the writ
petition would not constitute a bar to a subsequent
petition under Art. 32 except in cases where and if
the facts thus found by the High Court may
themselves be relevant even under Art. 32. If a writ
petition is dismissed in limine and an order is
pronounced in that behalf, whether or not the
dismissal would constitute a bar would depend
upon the nature of the order. If the order is on the
merits it would be a bar; if the order shows that the
dismissal was for the reason that the petitioner
was guilty of laches or that he had an alternative
remedy it would not be a bar, except in cases
which we have already indicated. If the petition is
1 AIR 1961 SC 1457
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
dismissed in limine without passing a speaking
order then such dismissal cannot be treated as
creating a bar of res judicata. It is true that, prima
facie, dismissal in limine even without passing a
speaking order in that behalf may strongly suggest
that the Court took the view that there was no
substance in the petition at all; but in the absence
of a speaking order it would not be easy to decide
what factors weighed in the mind of the Court and
that makes it difficult and unsafe to hold that such
a summary dismissal is a dismissal on merits and
as such constitutes a bar of res judicata against a
similar petition filed under Art. 32. If the petition is
dismissed as withdrawn it cannot be a bar to a
subsequent petition under Art. 32, because in such
a case there has been no decision on the merits by
the Court. We wish to make it clear that the
conclusions thus reached by us are confined only to
the point of res judicata which has been argued as
a preliminary issue in these writ petitions and no
other. ..................................................................”
16.
Thus, it is clear that if the petition is dismissed in
limine without passing a speaking order then such dismissal
cannot be treated as creating a bar of res judicata and although,
prima facie, dismissal in limine even without passing a speaking
order in that behalf may strongly suggest that the court took the
view that there was no substance in the petition at all, but in the
absence of the speaking order it would not be easy to decide what
factors weighed in the mind of the court and that makes it
difficult and unsafe to hold that such a summary dismissal is a
dismissal on merits and as such constitutes a bar of res judicata.
In the present case, this court is of the opinion that there is no
such issue. The order passed by the learned Single Bench on
12/03/2021 clearly records that it was dismissed, in fact, in
limine. The pronouncement of the learned Single Bench was
absolutely clear. It was a dismissal in limine. In view of the clear
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
pronouncement of the Supreme Court, the dismissal of the writ
petition in limine does not act as res judicata against the
proceedings before the NHRC.
17.
The next point urged by the learned counsel is the show
cause notice as well as the impugned orders not disclosing the
commission of violation of human rights by the police authorities or
the negligence of the police authorities in prevention of violation
of human rights. It is quite evident that the Commission was of the
firm view on both facts and law. The fact that the UTP committed
suicide during the day at 11:10 a.m. in the jail is not disputed by the
petitioner. The NHRC records that “ensuring the safety and security of
the inmates who are under care and custody of the prison is one of the
prime duties of the authorities concerned”. This cannot be disputed. It
is quite obvious that had the jail authorities been vigilant enough, as
observed by the NHRC, this incident could have been avoided and the
precious life would have been saved. The State is vicariously liable to
compensate the next of kin of the deceased UTP. It is not the case of
the petitioner that the jail was not under its control when the incident
happened in the manner described and admittedly inside the jail.
There cannot be any doubt that the responsibility of ensuring the
safety of the inmates during the day or in the night as long as they are
in the prison is upon the said authorities. It may not have been at the
instance of any of the jail officers that the suicide was committed but
the fact that the incident has happened inside the jail makes the
petitioner vicariously liable.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
18.
The National Human Rights Commission (Procedure)
Regulations, 1994 as amended, provides in Regulation 9 that in
certain cases complaints are not ordinarily entertainable. It provides
that the Commission may dismiss in limini complaints of various
nature as enumerated below:“(i) illegible;
(ii) vague, anonymous or pseudonymous;
(iii) trivial or frivolous;
(iv) barred under section 36(1) of the Act;
(v) barred under section 36(2) of the Act;
(vi) allegation is not against any public servant;
(vii) the issue raised relates to civil dispute, such as
property rights, contractual obligations and the like;
(viii) the issue raised relates to service matters;
(ix) the issue raised relates to labour/industrial
disputes;
(x) allegations do not make out any specific
violation of human rights;
(xi) matter is sub judice before a Court/Tribunal;
(xii) matter is covered by a judicial verdict/decision
of the Commission;
(xiii) where it is only a copy of the complaint
addressed to some other authority;
(xiv) the matter is outside the purview of the
Commission on any other ground.”
19.
Regulation 9(xi) relates to matter which are sub judice
before the court or tribunal. The admitted facts as pleaded do not
reflect that the NHRC entertained the complaint when the matter
was sub judice before this court. Regulation 9(xii) relates to
matter which is covered by the judicial verdict or decision of the
Commission. The arguments made by the learned counsel for the
petitioner relates to the dismissal of the writ petition in limine
which has already been discussed in detail above. Therefore,
even this ground does not help the petitioner’s case.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2021
State of Sikkim vs. National Human Rights Commission
20.
The final inquiry report passed by the learned
Judicial Magistrate, South Sikkim, Namchi, relates to the
procedure under section 176 of the Cr.P.C. and the final report of
the Namchi Police Station relates to the procedure under section
174 Cr.P.C. Both did not deal with the issue before the NHRC.
Consequently, this ground is also devoid of merits.
21.
Having examined each of the grounds raised by the
petitioner, this court is of the considered view that the present
writ petition is misconceived and is liable to be dismissed.
22.
It is accordingly ordered.
23.
Pending
interlocutory
application
also
stands
disposed of.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting : Yes/No
Internet
: Yes/No
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review