Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 10.04.2019
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAI KUMAR BIST, JUDGE
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. Appeal No.16 of 2018
Appellant
:
State of Sikkim
versus
Respondent
:
Kamal Subba,
Philim, Pastar Zilla,
Ward No. 08, Nepal.
Present address:
Lower Samdong,
East Sikkim.
Application under Section 378 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Public Prosecutor, Mr. Karma Thinlay
Namgyal with Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Additional Public
Prosecutors and Mr. S. K. Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai,
Assistant Public Prosecutors for the State/Appellant.
Mr. Tashi R. Barfungpa, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel) with
Mr. Ugang Lepcha, Advocate for the RespondentAccused/Opposite Party.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
Dissatisfied with the Judgment of acquittal, the
State/Appellant (hereinafter the “Appellant”) is before this
Court praying that the impugned Judgment dated 30.06.2017
of the learned Sessions Judge, East at Gangtok in Sessions
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
Trial Case No. 28 of 2015 (State vs. Kamal Subba), be set
aside.
The
learned
Respondent/Accused
trial
Court
(hereinafter
the
had
acquitted
“accused”)
of
the
the
charge under Section 304 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(hereinafter the “IPC”).
2.
Forwarding his arguments for the State, Learned
Additional Public Prosecutor would submit that the evidence of
P.W.1 Dhan Kumari Rai, wife of the deceased Bhakta Bahadur
Rai, reveals that the accused had in fact two days prior to the
date of the incident gone to the house of the deceased and
threatened to kill him. It was also in her evidence that the
accused used to quarrel and fight with her husband often.
That, the investigation of P.W.14, S.I. Tshering D. Bhutia, the
Investigating Officer (for short “I.O.”) clearly indicates that a
scuffle had ensued between the accused and the deceased en
route to their house on which the accused had pushed the
deceased off the road into the culvert below resulting in his
death. That, the evidence of P.W.9, Police Inspector, Sonam
Wangdi Bhutia, was duly supported by the evidence of P.W.8,
Assistant Sub Inspector, C.D. Subba and P.W.14, I.O.
concluding that the accused was responsible for the death of
the deceased. That, the evidence of P.W.12, Raj Bahadur
Subba and P.W.13, Dhan Maya Subba, who are husband and
wife, reveals that the accused had helped them plough their
field for paddy cultivation on the relevant day. That, in the
evening the deceased and accused came to the residence of
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
P.W.12 where they shared food and some alcohol. Thereafter
both the deceased and the accused left his residence together
on the relevant night. P.W.13 has supported the evidence of
P.W.12. The next morning the body of the deceased was
discovered at the “kholcha” (culvert). That, the “last seen
theory” comes into play here as P.W.12 and P.W.13 have
both deposed that the accused and the deceased left their
house together. That,
the Statement of the accused under
Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for
short “Cr.P.C.”) reveals that he was responsible for the death
of the deceased. Relying on the provisions of Section 106 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (for short “Evidence Act”) it
was contended that the burden of proving his whereabouts at
the relevant time as per this provision lies on the accused
which he has failed to discharge, hence the matter ought not
to have ended in an acquittal. That, in view of the arguments
put forth, the Judgment of acquittal be set aside.
3.
Learned Counsel for the accused would submit
that the Appellant in the first instance has failed to prove its
case beyond a reasonable doubt. No proof whatsoever
emanates from the evidence of the Prosecution Witnesses
that the accused was responsible for the death of the
deceased. That, reliance on the evidence of P.W.8 serves no
purpose as it is his conclusion based on investigation done by
him after the U.D. Case was endorsed to him but the
conclusion has been arrived at without any proof whatsoever.
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
That, invoking Section 106 of the Evidence Act is of no
assistance to the Appellant as in the first instance the
Prosecution is required to prove its case beyond a reasonable
doubt. That, Statement recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C.
can only be utilized for the purpose of corroboration and the
evidence of none of the witnesses throws light on the
Prosecution case. It concludes that the Judgment of the
learned trial Court warrants no interference as there can be
no moral conviction and suspicion cannot take the place of
proof, besides which no motive has been imputed on the
accused.
4.
We have carefully heard the rival contentions
placed by Learned Counsel in extenso and given it due
consideration. We have also carefully perused all documents
on record and the impugned Judgment.
5.
In order to gauge the correct circumstances it
would be essential to briefly advert to the facts of the case.
6.
On 14.07.2015, P.W.8 lodged FIR Exhibit 11, to
the effect that during the investigation of Singtam P.S. U.D.
Case No. 18 of 2015, dated 12.07.2015, under Section 174 of
the Cr.P.C. pertaining to the death of one Bhakta Bahadur
Rai, it was revealed that the deceased had been ploughing
the field of Raj Bahadur Subba (P.W.12) on 11.07.2015 and
12.07.2015. After completing the day's work he went to the
house of P.W.12 along with the accused and drank locally
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
brewed alcohol. Thereafter at around 21:30 Hrs, both the
deceased and the accused left together for their respective
houses in a drunken state. On the way back a scuffle ensued
between the two of them where the accused pushed the
deceased from the edge of the road to the culvert below
resulting in the death of Bhakta Bahadur Rai. Based on this
complaint, Singtam P.S. Case No. 51 of 2015, dated
14.07.2015, under Section 304 of the IPC was registered and
endorsed to the I.O. P.W.14 for investigation. The I.O. during
investigation reached the same conclusion as P.W.8 upon
which Charge-Sheet came to be filed against the accused
under Section 304 IPC read with Section 14 of the Foreigner's
Act, 1946. The learned trial Court framed charge against the
accused under Section 304 IPC to which he entered a plea of
“not guilty,” consequent upon which fourteen Prosecution
Witnesses were examined. The accused was afforded an
opportunity to explain the circumstances appearing against
him in the evidence as provided by Section 313 Cr.P.C. to
which he responded that he was unaware of the incident and
that he was innocent. The learned trial Court considered all
evidence on record and reached the finding of innocence of
the accused and acquitted him of the offence charged with,
which is thus being assailed herein.
7.
On
careful
perusal
of
the
evidence
of
the
Prosecution Witnesses it is evident that only P.W.1, the wife
of the deceased, has tried to implicate the accused in the
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
incident. Her statement is to the effect that, “At that time, I
saw the accused proceeding towards the paddy field of his
brother carrying a kodali (agricultural equipment) with him. I
confronted the accused with the information given to me by
Kunti Babu regarding my husband having returned back from
his house along with him and enquired from him about the
whereabouts of my husband. The accused left the place
abruptly and proceeded towards the residence of our landlord
Narayan Sardar.” It is the Prosecution case that this witness
had specifically stated that “The accused had come near my
house about two days before the incident in a drunken state.
He was swearing that he would kill my husband. We had
finished planting the paddy on that day. Two days later, the
incident occurred. The accused used to quarrel and fight with
my husband often.” In the first instance, it would also be
relevant to notice that P.W.1 has not stated as to why her
husband and the accused had recurrent quarrels and why he
would threaten to kill her husband. It is apparent that she has
made this allegation only because “Kunti Babu” had told her
that her husband had returned on the previous evening from
his house along with the accused. Merely because the accused
chose not to communicate with her when she approached him
with a query does not mean that he was guilty of the offence
or that the offence can be foisted on him. That apart, none of
the
other
Prosecution
Prosecution case.
Witnesses
have
supported
the
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
8.
P.W.2, Passang Lepcha, could shed no light on the
incident and he also could not identify who the deceased was.
P.W.3, Mitrawati Bhattarai, the wife of P.W.4, Narayan Prasad
Bhattarai, has stated that she and P.W.4 came to know about
the death of the deceased from P.W.12, the elder brother of
the accused, on the day following the evening that the
deceased had gone missing from his residence. This witness
was also unable to shed light on which date exactly the
deceased was missing from his house. That, the accused also
had in fact come to their house i.e. of P.W.3 and P.W.4 and
told them that the deceased was found lying in the “kholcha”
(culvert) below the road at Samdong. That, upon such
information, P.W.4 went to the place of occurrence to verify
the matter. P.W.4 also stated that on 14.07.2015 the accused
came to his residence at around 8.30 a.m. to 9 a.m. and
informed him that the deceased had been missing since the
previous evening. At the same time the elder brother of the
accused arrived at the house of P.W.4 and reported that the
dead body of the deceased was found at “Guay Kholcha” not
far from the house of P.W.4. Thereafter he informed P.W.5,
Dheraj Bhattarai, member of the Panchayat of SamdungKambal GPU. This evidence was duly substantiated by P.W.5
who, for his part informed the Makha Out Post about the
sighting of the body at “Guay Kholcha” and then he went to
the place of occurrence. P.W.6, Dr. Sandhya Rai, who
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
conducted the post mortem examination of the deceased
found the following injuries;
“Post mortem examination of the
deceased revealed the following:
1. There was cut injury on the scalpOccipitoparietal region of the skull. The
underlying skull was fractured. Length and
depth of the cut was 2x1 inches.
2. Fracture of right humerus-upper 1/3
with displacement.
3. Fracture of left lower 1/3 femur.
4. Cut injury over right forehead
measuring around 1x2 inches just above right
eyebrow.
5. Cut injury 1 inch long along the line of
left eyebrow.”
In her opinion, the cause of death was due to head injury
(massive intra cranial haemorrhage) with multiple long bone
fractures. That, such injuries could occur when a person is
assaulted by a group of men, by a fall from a height and in a
motor accident. The accused was also examined by P.W.6
whereupon she found no recent or fresh injury visible
externally on the person of the accused, thereby in our
considered opinion this rules out a scuffle between the
accused and the deceased. As is well established, the
evidence of a Doctor is an opinion and from what P.W.6 has
stated nothing emerges to establish that the death of the
deceased was the result of a scuffle.
9.
Although
the
Prosecution
sought
to
rely
on
Section 164 Cr.P.C. Statement of the accused, it may be
reiterated that while explaining the object of recording
Statements under Section 164 of the Cr.P.C., the Hon’ble
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
Supreme Court in R. Shaji vs. State of Kerala1 observed as
follows;
“27. So far as the statement of witnesses
recorded under Section 164 is concerned, the
object is twofold; in the first place, to deter the
witness from changing his stand by denying the
contents of his previously recorded statement;
and secondly, to tide over immunity from
prosecution by the witness under Section 164. A
proposition to the effect that if a statement of a
witness is recorded under Section 164, his
evidence in court should be discarded, is not at
all warranted. (Vide Jogendra Nahak v. State of
Orissa [(2000) 1 SCC 272 : 2000 SCC (Cri) 210 :
AIR 1999 SC 2565] and CCE v. Duncan Agro
Industries Ltd. [(2000) 7 SCC 53 : 2000 SCC (Cri)
1275])
28. Section 157 of the Evidence Act
makes it clear that a statement recorded under
Section 164 CrPC can be relied upon for the
purpose of corroborating statements made by
witnesses in the committal court or even to
contradict the same. As the defence had no
opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses
whose statements are recorded under Section
164 CrPC, such statements cannot be treated as
substantive evidence.”
Evidence
under
Section
evidence,
it
only
can
be
Cr.P.C.
used
for
is
not
the
substantial
purposes
of
corroboration.
10.
P.W.8 the In-Charge, Makha Out Post sought to
insert a new twist in the Prosecution case by stating under
cross-examination that the accused and the deceased had
entered into a scuffle over an argument of the accused having
extra marital relations with the wife of the deceased. This is
indeed a bolt from the blue as the I.O., P.W.14 has nowhere
in her investigation corroborated the statement or indicated
(2013) 14 SCC 266
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
that her investigation also revealed such a fact. The evidence
of the other Prosecution Witnesses are of no assistance for
the Prosecution case.
11.
So far as Section 106 of the Evidence Act is
concerned, this provision is not intended to relieve any person
of the duty or burden cast on them under Section 101 of the
Evidence Act. Section 106 of the Evidence Act cannot be used
to shift the onus. This Section applies only when the defence
of the accused depends on his proving the fact established
within his knowledge and of nobody else. The Prosecution has
to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt before they can
take shelter under the provisions of Section 106 of the
Evidence Act. In this regard, if we are to revert to the
evidence of P.W.12 and P.W.13 all that they have stated is
both the deceased and the accused left their residence
together
on
the
relevant
evening.
In
the
absence
of
investigation to prove that the deceased and accused were
headed for a particular place together and this was in the
knowledge
of
P.W.12
and
P.W.13,
the
only
possible
interpretation is that they stepped out of the house together.
It was stated by P.W.1, the wife of the deceased, that the
accused was residing with the landlord who is referred to as
“Narayan Sardar” in the village. P.W.4 is the said “Narayan
Sardar,” he resides in Lower Samdong and has stated that
the accused used to reside with his brother in the adjoining
village at Kambal, while the deceased used to reside in the
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
land of the witness along with his family. P.W.3 has
specifically stated that the deceased who was cultivating their
field was residing at Lower Samdong, while the accused was
residing with his brother at Kambal. P.W.10, Yesh Raj
Bhattarai, has stated that the deceased was his neighbor in
the village i.e. Samdong, and the accused was also a resident
of
their
village,
under
cross-examination
however
this
evidence stood demolished as the witness has clarified that
the accused was not a permanent resident of their village and
he had seen him occasionally in the house of his neighbours.
Although the evidence of P.W.1. that the accused was
residing
with
“Narayan
Sardar”
was
supported
by
the
evidence of P.W.12, Raj Bahadur Subba and P.W.13, Dhan
Maya Subba, who have stated that during the period relating
to the incident the accused was residing in the house of
P.W.4, P.W.4 for his part has stated otherwise as discussed
supra. According to the I.O., P.W.14, the accused was
residing at Lower Samdong one month prior to the incident.
She has not clarified as to whether he was living at the same
place
during
the
time
of
the
incident.
There
is thus
contradictory evidence with regard to the lodgings of the
accused. The investigation has not thrown any light on the
distance between village Kambal and Lower Samdong or
whether the two villages fall in the same route which would
prompt the accused and the deceased to return home
together from the house of P.W.12.
Crl.A.No.16 of 2018
State of Sikkim vs. Kamal Subba
12.
It is not the Prosecution case that P.W.12 and
P.W.13 were aware that they continued their journey together
to their respective houses together. This was for the
Prosecution to have established. The “last seen theory”
cannot
be
invoked
to
establish
that
the
offence
was
committed by the accused since no one has witnessed them
continuing their walk together. It is not denied that both were
inebriated when they left the house of P.W.12 and P.W.13. In
consideration of the evidence on record and the fact that the
Prosecution has failed to discharge the burden cast on it, we
find that the Judgment of the learned trial Court brooks no
interference.
13.
Appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.
14.
Accused be released from custody forthwith and
discharged from his bail bonds.
15.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned trial
Court, for information.
16.
Lower Court records be remitted forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
10.04.2019
10.04.2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ml
( Vijai Kumar Bist )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review