Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
,
W.A. No.48 of 2025
State of Odisha & another
….
Appellants
Mr. S.B. Mohanty, AGA
-versusAshok Kumar Mohanty &
….
Respondents
another
Mr. M.K. Mohanty, Advocate
CORAM:
JUSTICE KRISHNA SHRIPAD DIXIT
JUSTICE CHITTARANJAN DASH
Date of Hearing & Date of Judgment: 21.04.2026
Chittaranjan Dash, J.
1.
By means of this Intra-Court appeal, the Appellants-State of
Odisha and its functionaries call in question the judgment dated
09.10.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No.19549 of
2019, whereby the writ petition was allowed, the rejection order dated
04.04.2018 was set aside, and a direction was issued for regularisation
of the services of Respondent No.1 with consequential benefits.
2.
The background facts are that Respondent No.1 was initially
engaged as Town Bus Conductor in Balasore Municipality on DLR
basis on 02.07.1993. Upon discontinuance of the town bus service, he
was continued in employment and assigned duties as Tax Collector
under the Municipality. According to the Appellants, such engagement
was neither against a sanctioned post nor through a regular recruitment
process. Respondent No.1 had earlier approached this Court in W.P.(C)
W.A. No.48 of 2025
No.18477 of 2017 seeking consideration of his claim for regularisation.
Pursuant thereto, the competent authority, by order dated 04.04.2018,
rejected the claim on the ground that he had been engaged after the cutoff date prescribed under the relevant policy. Assailing the said
rejection, Respondent No.1 filed W.P.(C) No.19549 of 2019, which
came to be allowed by the learned Single Judge with a direction to
regularise his services upon completion of ten years together with
consequential benefits. Aggrieved thereby, the present appeal has been
preferred.
3.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and upon perusal
of the materials placed on record, this Court finds no infirmity in the
judgment passed by the learned Single Judge warranting interference in
the present Intra-Court appeal.
4.
The principal submission advanced by the learned Additional
Government Advocate, placing reliance upon Madan Singh and others
vs. State of Haryana and others, 2026 INSC 379, is that Respondent
No.1 was not initially engaged against a sanctioned post and, therefore,
could not have been granted the relief of regularisation. Though the
said objection appears plausible in the abstract, it cannot be accepted
divorced from the peculiar facts of the present case. It is not in dispute
that Respondent No.1 entered service in the year 1993 and has
continued to serve for more than thirty-three years. Throughout this
extended period, the authorities have availed his services in different
capacities, without any allegation of misconduct, inefficiency or
adverse service record. In such circumstances, where the employer
itself has continuously utilised the services of an employee for decades
in relation to recurring public functions, the technical plea regarding
W.A. No.48 of 2025
absence of sanctioned post loses much of its force and cannot be
permitted to defeat an equitable claim at this belated stage.
5.
In Dharam Singh & Ors. vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.,
2025 INSC 998, relying upon the earlier decisions in Jaggo vs. Union
of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826, Shripal & another vs. Nagar
Nigam, Ghaziabad, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 221, State of Karnataka vs.
Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1,the Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated the
constitutional obligation of the State as a model employer and
deprecated the continued extraction of regular labour under temporary
arrangements. The relevant paragraphs are extracted hereinbelow:
17. Before concluding, we think it necessary to recall that
the State (here referring to both the Union and the State
governments) is not a mere market participant but a
constitutional employer. It cannot balance budgets on the
backs of those who perform the most basic and recurring
public functions. Where work recurs day after day and year
after year, the establishment must reflect that reality in its
sanctioned strength and engagement practices. The longterm extraction of regular labour under temporary labels
corrodes confidence in public administration and offends the
promise of equal protection. Financial stringency certainly
has a place in public policy, but it is not a talisman that
overrides fairness, reason and the duty to organise work on
lawful lines.
18. Moreover, it must necessarily be noted that “ad-hocism”
thrives where administration is opaque. The State
Departments must keep and produce accurate establishment
registers, muster rolls and outsourcing arrangements, and
they must explain, with evidence, why they prefer precarious
engagement over sanctioned posts where the work is
perennial. If “constraint” is invoked, the record should show
what alternatives were considered, why similarly placed
workers were treated differently, and how the chosen course
aligns with Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of
India. Sensitivity to the human consequences of prolonged
insecurity is not sentimentality. It is a constitutional
discipline that should inform every decision affecting those
who keep public offices running.
W.A. No.48 of 2025
19. Having regard to the long, undisputed service of the
appellants, the admitted perennial nature of their duties, and
the material indicating vacancies and comparator
regularisations, we issue the following directions:
i. Regularization and creation of Supernumerary posts:
All appellants shall stand regularized with effect from
24.04.2002, the date on which the High Court directed a
fresh recommendation by the Commission and a fresh
decision by the State on sanctioning posts for the appellants.
For this purpose, the State and the successor establishment
(U.P. Education Services Selection Commission) shall create
supernumerary posts in the corresponding cadres, Class-III
(Driver or equivalent) and Class-IV (Peon/Attendant/Guard
or equivalent) without any caveats or preconditions. On
regularization, each appellant shall be placed at not less than
the minimum of the regular pay-scale for the post, with
protection of last-drawn wages if higher and the appellants
shall be entitled to the subsequent increments in the pay
scale as per the pay grade. For seniority and promotion,
service shall count from the date of regularization as given
above.
ii. Financial consequences and arrears: Each appellant
shall be paid as arrears the full difference between (a) the
pay and admissible allowances at the minimum of the
regular pay-level for the post from time to time, and (b) the
amounts actually paid, for the period from 24.04.2002 until
the date of regularization /retirement/death, as the case may
be. Amounts already paid under previous interim directions
shall be so adjusted. The net arrears shall be released within
three months and if in default, the unpaid amount shall carry
compound interest at 6% per annum from the date of default
until payment.
iii. Retired appellants: Any appellant who has already
retired shall be granted regularization with effect from
24.04.2002 until the date of superannuation for pay fixation,
arrears under clause (ii), and recalculation of pension,
gratuity and other terminal dues. The revised pension and
terminal dues shall be paid within three months of this
Judgement.
iv. Deceased appellants: In the case of Appellant No. 5 and
any other appellant who has died during pendency, his/her
legal representatives on record shall be paid the arrears under
clause (ii) up to the date of death, together with all
W.A. No.48 of 2025
terminal/retiral dues recalculated consistently with clause (i),
within three months of this Judgement.
v. Compliance affidavit: The Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Government of Uttar Pradesh, or the
Secretary of the U.P. Education Services Selection
Commission or the prevalent competent authority, shall file
an affidavit of compliance before this Court within four
months of this Judgement.
6.
The ratio of the aforesaid decision squarely applies to the
present case. If the nature of work justified continuous utilisation of
Respondent No.1 for decades together, the employer cannot now rely
solely upon defects in the initial mode of engagement, particularly
when the necessity of such service stood established over time.
7.
The objection regarding discontinuity or break in service is
equally without substance. The materials on record indicate that upon
cessation of town bus operations, Respondent No.1 was retained and
deployed in other wings, including as Tax Collector. Mere change in
duties or transition from one local/governmental establishment to
another, while remaining in public service, cannot be construed as an
actual break in service. Continuity must be assessed in substance and
not by formal description.
8.
In Prem Chand and Ors. vs. State of Punjab and Anr., 2026
LiveLaw (SC) 394, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that artificial or
notional breaks cannot be relied upon to deny regularisation where the
employee was repeatedly re-engaged and continued to discharge duties
to the satisfaction of the authorities. The Court observed as follows:
“16. Having considered the submissions made by the parties
and upon perusing the materials on record, we are of the
considered opinion that the Appellants are entitled to the
relief of regularization of their services.
17. At the outset, it must be noted that it is not the case of the
Respondents that the Appellants do not possess the requisite
W.A. No.48 of 2025
qualifications for the post in question or that the requisite
vacancies are unavailable. It is also an admitted fact that the
appointments were made against existing vacancies and not
against supernumerary or surplus posts created artificially.
18. The core question that falls for consideration is whether
the Appellants are covered under the policy instructions
dated 26.05.2003, 15.12.2006 and 18.03.2011 issued by the
State of Punjab for regularization of ad hoc employees. It is
not disputed that the Appellants were appointed before
13.06.1996. The Respondents have sought to exclude the
Appellants solely on the ground that their service tenures
contained breaks ranging from 5 to 187 days. Therefore, it
has been argued that their engagements were not continuous,
making them ineligible under the policy. Furthermore, it has
been argued that they are also ineligible under the policy
dated 18.03.2011 as the Appellants were no longer in service
when it came into force.
19. We are unable to agree with this reasoning as it has come
on record that a large number of similarly placed employees
have been regularized in various departments of the State
Government in view of the policy instructions dated
26.05.2003 and15.12.2006 in spite of the fact that there were
breaks in their service as in the case of the present
Appellants. The details of as many as 46 ad hoc employees
who were given the benefit of the policies have been brought
forward who had breaks ranging from a period of 64 to 334
days i.e. periods longer than that in the case of the
Appellants. This fact has not been disputed by the
Respondents. Therefore, a case for parity is made out as the
Appellants have service record with breaks ranging from
merely 5 to 187 days. The State cannot selectively deny the
application of the policy to the Appellants, who are
identically situated with these persons, with no cogent
justification.
20. Moreover, the breaks in service relied upon by the
Respondents to deny regularization are, on a closer
examination, artificial in nature. The Appellants were
consistently re-engaged, save for short breaks, and continued
to discharge their duties to the satisfaction of the appointing
authorities on the same posts. The breaks do not reflect any
genuine abandonment of service or voluntary cessation of
employment. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the long
service of the Appellants cannot be disregarded in lieu of
artificial breaks and by leveling the initial employment as ad
hoc.”
W.A. No.48 of 2025
9.
Applying the aforesaid principle, this Court is of the considered
view that any notional break, if at all existing in the service career of
Respondent No.1, deserves to be ignored. There is nothing on record to
indicate abandonment of service or voluntary cessation. On the
contrary, the continuity of engagement over the years unmistakably
demonstrates that the authorities themselves treated his services as
necessary and continuing.
10.
That apart, the learned Single Judge has rightly noticed that
similarly situated employees had been extended benefits of
regularisation. The State is expected to act fairly and consistently.
Selective invocation of technical pleas against one employee, after
extracting service for more than three decades, would go against the
constitutional mandate of equality.
11.
For all the aforesaid reasons, this Court finds itself in agreement
with the reasoning and conclusions recorded by the learned Single
Judge in W.P.(C) No.19549 of 2019. The impugned judgment does not
suffer from any perversity, legal infirmity or jurisdictional error so as to
call for appellate interference.
12.
Accordingly, the Writ Appeal, being devoid of merit, stands
dismissed. Consequently, all pending I.As., if any, shall stand disposed
of.
(Chittaranjan Dash)
Judge
(Krishna Shripad Dixit)
Judge
Bijay/Sarbani
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SARBANI DASH
Designation: Junior Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:45:39
W.A. No.48 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review