Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
FAO No. 20 of 2026
The Divisional Railway
.....
Manager, East Coast Railway,
Khurda
-versusGitanjali Behera & Ors.
.....
Appellant
Mr. D.N. Pattnayak, SPC
Respondents
Mr. S. Satpathy, Advocate
(Respondent Nos. 1 to 4)
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
ORDER
24.07.2026
Order No.03
1. This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
2. Heard Mr. D.N. Pattnayak, learned Sr. Panel Counsel appearing
for the Appellant and Mr. S. Satpathy, learned counsel appearing for
the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4.
3. The present appeal has been filed by the Appellant-Railway
challenging judgment dtd.28.10.2025 so passed by the Commissioner
for Employees Compensation-cum-Joint Labour Commissioner
HQRS, Bhubaneswar in E.C. Case No. 8 of 2022. Vide the said
judgment, learned Commissioner while allowing the claim
application so filed by the Claimants-Respondents, directed the
Appellant-Railway
to
pay
the
compensation
amount
of
Rs.53,33,656/- along with interest @ 12% per annum from the date
of accident till the date of actual payment, failing which 50% penalty
Page 1 of 6.
along with interest @ 12% interest on the total awarded amount shall
be realised.
4. Learned Senior Panel Counsel appearing for the Appellant while
assailing the impugned judgment, vehemently contended that the
deceased was working as a Senior Goods Guard under the Railway
and on the relevant date and time, he died while on duty because of
severe heart attack. Accordingly, it is contended that since the
deceased died due to heart attack, it cannot be held that he died
because of any injury sustained by accident in course of his
employment in terms of the provisions contained under Sec. 3 of the
Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923.
4.1. It is also contended that even though such a plea was taken by
the Railways before the learned Commissioner, but without proper
appreciation of the same, learned Commissioner allowed the claim
application by passing the impugned judgment dtd.28.10.2025 under
Annexure-1.
4.2. Not only that in support of his submission, learned Sr. Panel
Counsel also relied on a decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Special Leave Petition (C) No. 29239 of 2019 (The Chairman,
Vaidyanath Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. & Anr. Vs. Shantabai
& Anr.) disposed of on 13.02.2025. Hon’ble Apex Court in Para 15,
16 & 17 of the Judgment has held as follows:“15. The word “accident” generally denotes an event that takes
place without one’s foresight or expectation; an event which
proceeds from an unknown cause, or is an unusual effect of a
known cause, and therefore not expected; chance, casualty,
contingency (Webster Dictionary).
Page 2 of 6.
16. In other words, an “accident” being an unforeseen event
causing a misfortune or loss is different from an omission which
is as a result of negligence or misconduct. Therefore, the
expression “accident” means an untoward mishap which is not
expected or designed. In the context of the Act under
consideration, the term “accident” for the purpose of seeking
compensation for personal injuries sustained would include any
injury which is not designed by the workman himself. Thus, the
word “accident” would include all mishaps occurring by
chance or caused unintentionally and events happening due to
unforeseen circumstances under Section 3(1) of the Act. It must
be interpreted as mishap or “untoward event not expected or
designed” in the popular and ordinary sense. If the injury or
death occurred without designed on the part of the workman
then the death or injury would be by accident, although it was
brought about by a heart attack or some other cause to be found
in the condition of the workmen himself. The expression
“accident” not being defined under the Act must be interpreted
to be an untoward event which is not expected or designed;
therefore, an accident means unintended and unexpected
occurrence which produces hurt or loss. The interpretation of
the word “accident” must be in the popular and ordinary sense
and not in a technical sense. Thus, the expression “accident”
arising out of and in the course of his employment in Section
3(1) of the Act must be so interpreted as to establish that (1) at
the time of the accident he was in fact engaged in the duties of
his employment; (2) that it occurred at the place where he was
performing those duties; and (3) that the immediate act which
led to the accident is not so remote from the sphere of his duties
so as to be regarded as something foreign to them.
17. In Shakuntala Chandrakant Shreshti vs. Prabhakar Maruti
Garvali & Another, (2007) 11 SCC 668, while applying Section
3 of the Act, this Court observed that the tests attracting the
provision of Section 3 of the Act would require the following
principle to be proved:
(1) There must be a causal connection between the injury
and the accident and the accident and the work done in
the course of employment.
(2) The onus is upon the applicant to show that it was the
work and the resulting strain which contributed to or
aggravated the injury.
(3) If the evidence brought on records establishes a
greater probability which satisfies a reasonable man that
the work contributed to the causing of the personal injury,
Page 3 of 6.
it would be enough for the workman to succeed, but the
same would depend upon the fact of each case.”
4.3. Mr. S. Satpathy, learned counsel appearing for the ClaimantsRespondents on the other hand while does not dispute that the
deceased died due to heart attack on the fateful date, but contended
that since the deceased died while on duty and discharging the duty
being the holder of a technical post, the claim application was rightly
entertained by the learned Commissioner with passing of the
impugned judgment.
4.4. Learned counsel appearing for the Claimants-Respondents also
placed reliance on the aforesaid decision, more particularly Para 17,
18 & 19 of the Judgement, which reads as follows:“17. In Shakuntala Chandrakant Shreshti vs. Prabhakar Maruti
Garvali & Another, (2007) 11 SCC 668, while applying Section
3 of the Act, this Court observed that the tests attracting the
provision of Section 3 of the Act would require the following
principle to be proved:
(1) There must be a causal connection between the injury
and the accident and the accident and the work done in
the course of employment.
(2) The onus is upon the applicant to show that it was the
work and the resulting strain which contributed to or
aggravated the injury.
(3) If the evidence brought on records establishes a
greater probability which satisfies a reasonable man that
the work contributed to the causing of the personal injury,
it would be enough for the workman to succeed, but the
same would depend upon the fact of each case.
18. In the said case, taking note of the fact that the deceased
died as a result of heart attack and he was working as a helper,
it was observed that per se the duties would not be such which
would cause stress and strain. If an additional duty was
required to be performed by the deceased, the same was
Page 4 of 6.
required to be clearly stated. In the facts of the said case, this
Court declined to grant any relief and observed that the case did
not fall within the scope and ambit of Section 3 of the Act.
19. We have considered the aforesaid judgments in light of the
facts of the present case and perused the material on record.
Having regard to the nature of the job that the deceased was
performing as a Quadruple mate in the appellant-Factory and
the cause of his death, we find that there was a causal
connection between the death and the nature of the job that the
deceased workman was discharging in the appellant-factory.”
5. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties,
considering the submission made and the fact which is not disputed
that the deceased was working as a Senior Goods Guard, he died
while in duty because of severe heart attack. The Claimants claiming
compensation in terms of the provisions contained under Sec. 3 of
the Act, made the application in E.C. Case No. 8/2022. The same
was allowed vide the impugned judgment dtd.28.10.2025 under
Annexure-1.
5.1. Placing reliance on the provisions contained under Sec. 3 of the
Act and the decision in the case of The Chairman, Vaidyanath
Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. so cited (supra), this Court is of the
view that the matter requires a fresh adjudication by the learned
Commissioner. It is also the view of this Court that the provisions
contained under Sec. 3 of the Act has not been properly appreciated
by the learned Commissioner while deciding the issue in favour of
the Claimants and so also the view expressed by the Apex Court in
the above noted decision.
Page 5 of 6.
5.2. In that view of the matter, this Court while quashing the
impugned judgment dtd.28.10.2025 under Annexure-1, remits the
same to the learned Commissioner for fresh disposal in accordance
with law and by following the decision in the case of The Chairman,
Vaidyanath Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd..
5.3. This Court directs learned Commissioner to decide the issue
afresh as expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of four
(4) months from the date of receipt of this order. Both the Parties are
directed to cooperate for disposal of the matter.
6. The appeal accordingly stands disposed of.
(BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY)
Judge
Sneha
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SNEHANJALI PARIDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 27-Jul-2026 17:21:58
Page 6 of 6.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review