Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 30
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 47 of 2020
Date of Decision: 15.03.2023
State of Meghalaya
Vs.
Abhijit Basumatary
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S. Sen, Sr. GA with
Mr. A. Kharwanlang, GA.
For the Respondent(s)
-
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Oral:
1.
The State of Meghalaya as petitioner by way of the instant
petition is before this Court, challenging the order dated 09.01.2020
(published on 10.01.2020), passed by the Chairman, Meghalaya
Lokayukta in Complaint Case No. 1 of 2020, and also order dated
03.02.2020, passed in Misc. Application arising out of Complaint Case
No. 1 of 2020. The ground of challenge is that, the said orders were
passed in patent violation of the statutory provisions of the Meghalaya
Lokayukta Act, 2014, the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946,
various Supreme Court orders and against the Principles of Natural
Justice.
2.
This petition as per the Cause Title has been preferred under
Article 226 read with Article 227 of the Constitution. However, at the
stage of arguments, on queries from the Court and as the Chairman,
Meghalaya Lokayukta has not been impleaded as a party respondent, the
petitioner has elected to maintain the petition only under Article 227 of
the Constitution, to question the impugned orders on excess of
jurisdiction and assumption of powers of a constitutional Court by the
Lokayukta Meghalaya.
3.
Though appearance has been made on behalf of the
respondents, after 25.04.2022, the respondents were not represented and
the counsel appearing for them, subsequently withdrew from the case. It
has also been further reported that the respondent No. 2, who was
impleaded by order dated 02.03.2020, has also died. Accordingly, as
several dates have passed, and the respondent No. 1, seeming not
interested in appearing in the case, the matter is being heard ex-parte.
4.
Mr. S. Sen, learned Senior GA assisted by Mr. A. Kharwanlang,
learned GA for the petitioner submits that the respondent No. 1, had filed
a complaint before the Chairman, Meghalaya Lokayukta containing
vague, omnibus and general allegations of illegal transportation of coal
and betel nuts from Meghalaya to Assam, and that the complaint was
bereft of any material particulars or supporting evidence. He submits
that, without causing any notice to the petitioner, or any of the
officers/persons name in the complaint, the Lokayukta passed the
impugned order dated 09.01.2020, directing the Superintendent Police,
CBI, Shillong, to cause a preliminary inquiry into the alleged extortion
by officials on duty, from loaded trucks. By the said order he submits,
the Chief Secretary was also directed to take appropriate measures to root
out the alleged racket, and to effect immediate transfer of the officers
whose names were found in the list. Though a Misc. Application was
filed by the petitioner for modification of the order dated 09.01.2020, the
learned Senior GA submits that the same was dismissed vide order dated
03.02.2022, wherein several unfounded aspersions were also made.
5.
The challenge to the impugned orders as submitted by the
learned Senior GA, is on the non-compliance of the procedure laid down
under Section 20 of the Meghalaya Lokayukta Act, 2014 (herein referred
to as the Act), apart from violation of Sections 28 and 32. Further
grounds taken is the non-adherence to the provisions of Section 15 of the
Act, and also the lack of jurisdiction of the CBI to inquire or investigate.
The learned counsel has elaborated his contentions as follows;
(i)
On Non-compliance of Sections 20 and 28:- it is submitted
that, on receipt of a complaint, the Lokayukta in the event he decides
to proceed, shall order a preliminary inquiry by its Inquiry Wing or
any agency (including any Special Investigation Agency), and that till
such time any Inquiry Wing is constituted by the Lokayukta, the State
Government shall make available such officers as may be required.
However, he submits the Lokayukta acted in excess of jurisdiction, by
directing the CBI to conduct an inquiry, when such power is not vested
by the Act, unlike the Lokpal Act, 2013, which specifically includes
this agency.
(ii)
On the Violation of Section 32 of the Act:- it is submitted that
Section 32 of the Act provides that, if the Lokayukta is prima facie
satisfied on the basis of evidence that, the continuation of a public
servant in his post will adversely affect such preliminary inquiry, he
may recommend the transfer or suspension of such public servant,
which is ordinarily accepted by the State Government, but which is
however, also empowered to disregard such recommendations by
recording reasons in writing. In the present case he submits, the
respondent No. 1, had made allegations against 71 entities without any
specific allegations, wherein only 8 were serving under the
Government of Meghalaya, the entertainment of complaints against
officials who are not under the State of Meghalaya and the directions
of transfer are therefore, without jurisdiction and unsustainable as per
the Act.
(iii)
Non-adherence to Section 15:- it is submitted that, as the
respondent had claimed to have filed a writ petition before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court being WP(C) No. 1289 of 2019 and also lodged
complaints with the CBI containing the same allegations of
corruption, as when the complaint was filed before the Lokayukta, the
mandate of Section 15 of the Act disables the Lokayukta, from
considering the matter which is pending consideration before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and other authorities.
(iv)
Directions of CBI:- it has been submitted that, the Lokayukta
failed to consider that the direction for the CBI inquiry can only be
issued in rare and exceptional cases, inspite of the submissions of the
counsel for the CBI before the Lokayukta, that there are no specific
guidelines with regard to action to be taken by the CBI branches, with
regard to registration of cases for inquiry and corruption cases in the
State. It has been further submitted that, the Lokayukta failed to
consider that, under Section 6 of the Delhi Special Police
Establishment Act, 1946, no member could exercise powers and
jurisdiction in any area of a State without the consent of the concerned
State Government.
6.
The learned counsel has also impressed upon the fact that, the
impugned order dated 09.01.2020 (10.01.2020) was passed ex-parte in
complete violation of the Principles of Natural Justice, and that the
impugned orders passed by the Chairman, Meghalaya Lokayukta apart
from being bad in law are beyond jurisdiction, contrary to statutory
provisions of the Act, as also the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act,
1946, and as such suffers from severe jurisdictional errors which has
caused grave miscarriage of justice.
7.
Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner, it is seen that
the grievance centers around the manner in which the Chairman of the
Meghalaya Lokayukta, has exercised its powers, and as contended by the
petitioner, is allegedly in violation of the Act itself, and without
jurisdiction. A perusal of the complaint dated 13.12.2019, which has
occasioned the proceedings, does not reveal any specific information or
materials, but, broad allegations have been made therein, about
illegalities from the year 2015 onwards, in the transportation of coal and
trade of betel nuts, apart from the enumeration of 71 persons, some by
name, who were not public officials and the rest without names but by
designation. The Lokayukta by the first impugned order it is noted,
summarily registered a case and issued directions for a preliminary
inquiry by the CBI, and also for immediate transfer of officials. The
impugned order dated 09.01.2020 (10.01.2020) is reproduced
hereinbelow;
Meghalaya Lokayukta
Dated Shillong, the 10th January, 2020
No. MEGHLok.18/2020/65
ORDER
(09/01/2020)
Complainant : Mr. Abhijit Basumatary
Vrs
Respondent : Superintendent of Police, Khliehriat District & others.
This petition filed by a resident of Meghalaya speaks about
the racket in the export and import of goods, particularly coal, betel nut,
boulders etc., which are being transported in violation of existing Central
and State law, mostly from East Jaintia Hills through different points and
Check Gates across the Indo-Bangladesh Border covering the district of
Borak Valley in Assam and Khliehriat district in the State of Meghalaya
by a network being set up by some dishonest businessmen in collusion with
some unscrupulous civil and police officials belonging to Geology and
Mining, Transport, Supply, Sale Tax departments of the State and Central
and custom department.
The petitioner dares to disclose names of the officials and
individuals allegedly involved in the racket vide a list enclosed with the
complaint petition.
The petitioner also dares to give details of Modus Operandi
adopted by the racketeers.
It is alleged that some officials on duty of the aforesaid
departments demand and take bribe for allowing the loaded trucks without
necessary papers plying in those areas, even without challans, across the
Check gates and thereby causing huge loss of revenue which is estimated
approximately at Rs.1000 Crores to the State. Further, it is alleged that the
said officials running since 2015, could not be stopped and the authorities
concerned have taken no step to stop the racket despite repeated
representations made from time to time.
Having considered the alleged involvement of some high
ranking civil and police officials and also taking into account the fact that
this Lokayukta at present is not having an Enquiry Wing of its own, I deem
it fit and proper to get the matter enquired by an Independent Agency like
the CBI and get the Preliminary Report at the earliest to proceed further.
Accordingly, I direct the SP, CBI, Shillong, to cause an Inquiry into the
matter and submit the preliminary report within a period of 15 days from
the date of receipt of necessary papers from the Secretary of this
Commission.
In the meantime, I direct the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya to look into the matter and take appropriate
measures to root out the alleged racket.
I also direct the Chief Secretary to effect immediate transfer
of the officials under the establishment of different departments of
Meghalaya whose names find places in the list furnished by the petitioner
within 10 days to facilitate uninterrupted Enquiry by the CBI.
The Chief Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya is
further directed to take effective measures to protect the bonafide
businessmen and run their business without harassment from the
unscrupulous officials and racketeers. The Chief Secretary shall submit
an action taken report within 15 days from today.
Let a case be registered and proceed in accordance with the
provisions under the Meghalaya Lokayukta Act, 2014.
Show cause notice shall be served upon all concerned parties
after receipt of the Preliminary Inquiry Report.
Sd/(P.K. Musahary,)
Chairperson, Meghalaya Lokayukta
No. MEGHLok.18/2020/65-A
Dated Shillong, the 10th January, 2020
Copy to:1. The P.S to the Chief Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, for
kind information of the Chief Secretary.
2. The S.P CBI Shillong, for information and necessary action.
3. The Superintendent of Police, Khliehriat District, Respondent, for
information.
4. Mr. Abhijit Basumatary, Complainant, for information.
(R. Rapthap, IAS)
Secretary, Meghalaya Lokayukta”
8.
As contended by the counsel for the petitioner, it is also noted
that inspite of the application of the petitioner for recall of modification
of the order dated 10.01.2020, the Chairman, Meghalaya Lokayukta
rejected the same and maintained the same stand. At this juncture, it
would be apposite to refer to the relevant provisions of the Meghalaya
Lokayukta Act, to examine as to whether the Chairman had indeed
exceeded his jurisdiction, as vested by law in issuing the impugned
orders. Sections 11, 15, 20, 28 and 32 which are relevant, are reproduced
hereinbelow.
“11. (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in
any law for the time being in force, the Lokayukta
shall constitute an Inquiry Wing headed by the
Director of Inquiry for the purpose of conducting
preliminary inquiry into any offence alleged to
have been committed by a public servant
punishable under the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988:
Provided that till such time the Inquiry
Wing is constituted by the Lokayukta, the State
Government shall make available such number
of officers and other staff from such of its
Departments, as may be required by the
Lokayukta, for conducting preliminary inquiry
under this Act.
(2) For the purposes of assisting the
Lokayukta in conducting a preliminary inquiry
under this Act, the officers of the Inquiry Wing
not below the rank of Under Secretary to that
Government, shall have the same powers as are
conferred upon the Lokayukta under section 88.
15. In case any matter or proceeding related to
allegation of corruption under the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988 has been pending before
any court or committee of the State Legislature
or
before
any
other
authority
prior
to
commencement
of
Act
or
prior
to
commencement
of any
inquiry
after
the
this
commencement of this Act, such matter or
proceeding shall be continued before such court,
committee or authority.
20. (1) The Lokayukta shall, on receipt of a
complaint, first decide whether to proceed in the
matter or close the same and if the Lokayukta
decides to proceed further, it shall order the
preliminary inquiry against any public servant by
its Inquiry Wing or any agency (including any
special
investigation
agency)
to
ascertain
whether there exist a prima facie case for
proceeding in the matter.
(2) ……………….
(3) …………….
(a) …………..
(b) ……………..
(c) ………………
(4) ………………….
(5) ……………….
(6) ……………………
(7) ……………
(a) ………….
(b…………..
(8) ………………
(a) ……………….
(b) ……………..
(9) ………………
(10) ……………
(11) ……………..
(12) …………………….
28. (1) The Lokayukta may, for the purpose of
conducting
any
preliminary
inquiry
or
investigation, utilise the services of any officer or
organisation or investigation agency of the State
Government.
(2) ………….
(a) …………….
(b) ………………
(c) ……………..
(3) ………………..
32. (1) Where the Lokayukta, while making a
preliminary
inquiry
into
allegations
of
corruption, is prima facie satisfied, on the basis
of evidence available, that –
(a) the continuance of the public servant
referred to in clause (d) or clause (e) of subsection (1) of section 14 in his post while
conducting the preliminary inquiry is likely to
affect such preliminary inquiry adversely; or
(b) the public servant referred to in clause
(a) is likely to destroy or in any way tamper with
the evidence or influence witnesses, then, the
Lokayukta may recommend
to the State
Government for transfer or suspension of such
public servant from the post held by him till such
period as may be specified in the order.
(2) The State Government shall ordinarily
accept the recommendation of the Lokayukta
made under sub-section (1), except for the
reasons to be recorded in writing in a case where
it is not feasible for administrative reasons.”
[Emphasis supplied]
9.
Section 11 as quoted above, speaks of the Inquiry Wing for the
purposes of conducting preliminary inquiries into any offence alleged to
have been committed by a public servant, with the proviso that, till such
time the Inquiry Wing is constituted, the State Government shall make
available of such officers as may be required for conducting the
preliminary investigation. In the instant case, it is noted the Chairman,
Meghalaya Lokayukta without resorting to this proviso had immediately
directed the CBI to conduct the preliminary investigation.
10.
Sections 20 and 28 read together which provides the procedure,
should the Lokayukta decide to proceed on a complaint, also seems to
have not been adhered to, inasmuch as, recourse has not been taken to
the use of officers of the State for inquiry and though the Delhi Special
Police Establishment Act,1946 is not mentioned in Section 20, as has
been done specifically in the Lokpal Act, the direction for preliminary
inquiry by the CBI was issued, which appears to be misplaced.
11.
The direction of the mass transfer of officers, as ordered by the
impugned orders also runs contrary to the provisions of Section 32(2) of
the Act, inasmuch as, allegations have been made against 71 entities
including complaints against officials of the Assam Government, over
which the Meghalaya Lokayukta lacks jurisdiction and further in so far,
as the officers of the State of Meghalaya were concerned, no reasons
were recorded or any material referred to, before directing the en masse
transfer of all the officials mentioned in the complaint.
12.
Apart from the impugned orders being beyond the scope of the
provisions of the Act, the impugned order dated 10.01.2020, was also
passed ex parte, without hearing the concerned respondents.
13.
The proceedings before the Meghalaya Lokayukta therefore,
which were initiated by the impugned orders dated 10.01.2020 and
03.02.2020, being without jurisdiction and contrary to the statutory
provisions of the Meghalaya Lokayukta Act, 2014, are therefore liable
to be interfered with in exercise of supervisory powers under Article 227
of the Constitution.
14.
Accordingly,
the
impugned
orders
dated
(10.01.2020) and 03.02.2020, are quashed and set aside.
09.01.2020
15.
The instant petition is allowed and disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
15.03.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review