The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. In view of the above, no case has been made out by the petitioners for interfering with the impugned order dated 09.08.2023 and hence, the criminal petition stands dismissed. Judge Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:589
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Petn. No. 104 of 2023
Date of Order: 01.07.2024
1. State of Meghalaya
Represented by, The Secretary
Govt. of Meghalaya, Police
Department (Home)
Vs.
Shri Traiborlang Khongrymmai
S/o. P. Khyriem,
R/o. Laitmawsiang village.
East Khasi Hills District,
Shillong.
2. The Officer-In-Charge
Sohra Police Station
East Khasi Hills District, Shillong.
….. Petitioners.
……. Respondent/ Accused.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. T.L. Jyrwa, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:589
JUDGMENT & ORDER
1.
This criminal petition is filed challenging the impugned order dated
09.08.2023 passed by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Sohra SubDivision, East Khasi Hills District in GR Case No. 1(1) of 2015
(renumbered as GR. No. 1(A) 2021) under Section 403/406/409/420 IPC
whereby the application filed by the respondent under Section 311 Cr.PC
for recalling the PW-2 was allowed.
2.
The respondent as accused is facing trial in GR Case No. 1(1) of
2015 under Section 403/406/409/420 IPC pending before the Court of the
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Sohra. In the said trial, as many as 18
prosecution witnesses were examined. Before the recording of the
statement of the respondent under Section 313 Cr.PC, an application
under Section 311 Cr.PC was filed on behalf of the respondent seeking
recall of PW 2 for re-examination which was allowed by the Trial Court
by order dated 09.08.2023. Assailing the said order of the Trial Court, the
State has filed the present criminal petition.
3.
Mr. N.D. Chullai , learned AAG appearing for the petitioners
submits that recalling of PW-2 on the ground that the previous counsel
did not put certain question to the said witness cannot be a valid ground
under Section 311 Cr.PC. He submits that mere change of counsel or
incompetence of counsel cannot be a legally justifiable ground for
recalling of witness in a criminal trial. He further submits that the reason
2024:MLHC:589
cited in the application for recall and the observation made by the learned
Trial Court in the impugned order dated 09.08.2023 do not project
existence of any strong and valid reason for allowing the application. He
contends that the PW-2 was thoroughly examined by the prosecution as
well as the defence and hence there was no justifiable reason for the Trial
Court to allow the application of the respondent. The learned AAG places
reliance on the decisions of the Apex Court reported in (2016) 2 SSC 402,
State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Shiv Kumar Yadav and Anr. (para 15, 17 and
27) to contend that recall of witness on the ground that cross examination
was not proper for reasons attributable to a counsel is not a valid ground
and there cannot be a rule that a re-trial must follow on every change of
counsel. He submits that the impugned order is passed in defiance of the
settled principle of law and is liable to be set aside and quashed.
4.
Mr. T.L. Jyrwa, learned counsel for the respondent, on the other
hand submits that recall has not been sought only on the ground of
change of counsel but also for correcting some bonafide error which was
committed by not putting question on certain factual aspect of the case to
the PW-2. He submits that PW-2 is a vital witness in the matter and in
absence of disclosure of certain factual aspect by him, the trial cannot
come to a correct conclusion. He further submits that the respondent No.2
was not represented by a counsel of his choice at the time when the PW-2
was examined by the Trial Court. He also submits that the Trial Court has
allowed the application for recall by passing a detailed and well-reasoned
order by taking into consideration all the relevant aspect of the matter.
The learned counsel submits that the accused in a criminal trial deserves
2024:MLHC:589
to get fairest opportunity to prove his innocence in the trial. To buttress
his argument, the learned counsel has referred to a decision of the Apex
Court reported in (2013) 14 SCC 461, Rajaram Prasad Yadav Vs. State
of Bihar and Anr., (para 15.6) and submits that the impugned order does
not suffer from any illegality or infirmity requiring interference by this
Court.
5.
The materials on record reveals that the PW-2 was the Secretary of
the village as well as of the Village Water & Sanitation Committee
(VWSC) of Laitmawsiang village, which was the implementing agency
of scheme for Individual Household Latrines (IHHLs) and being the
Secretary had played vital role in withdrawal and disbursement of the
sanctioned amount of money along with the accused who was the then
Chairman of the Committee. The evidence of the said witness, as such, is
of utmost importance for determination of truth in the case. Although the
said witness was cross examined on behalf of the accused/respondent
herein by a legal aid counsel, but not by a counsel of his choice. The
reason stated by the respondent in his application of recall is that certain
question of facts, which are of vital importance, was not put to the PW-2
by the previous counsel and denial of opportunity to put such pertinent
questions on facts would greatly affect the outcome of the trial. It was
also asserted that no repetitive question would be put to the said witness
and the re-examination is sought for the purpose of gathering fresh
materials on facts strictly based on the knowledge of the witness. Thus,
the reasons cited therein appears to be for correction of bonafide error not
related to mere convenience.
2024:MLHC:589
6.
The learned Trial Court while passing the impugned order dated
09.08.2023, has taken into consideration the fact of the case as well as the
importance of the evidence of PW-2 in the matter. The Trial Court has
also taken into consideration relevant laws pertaining to recall of witness
and scope and ambit of power under Section 311 Cr.PC and thereafter, by
a reasoned order held that re-examination is required to shed more light to
the case and will help the court to arrive at a just decision to avoid
injustice and miscarriage of justice. There can be no doubt that at the
stage of trial, the trying court is best suited to judge the factual aspect of a
criminal trial and importance of each and every witness examined or to be
examined during the course of trial. Until and unless the Trial Court
commits a manifest error of fact or law, the decision taken by it in an
application under Section 311 Cr.PC should not be interfered with.
7.
The decision of State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Shiv Kumar Yadav and
Anr(supra) relied on by the learned AAG does not put an absolute bar on
recalling of a witness just because the application for recalling has been
preferred after the change of counsel. The proposition laid down therein,
says that a witness shall not be recalled on mere asking or on the ground
of change of counsel by citing reason attributable to previous counsel. It
is provided therein that a party is also permitted to correct its bonafide
error and may be entitled to further opportunity even when such
opportunity may be sought without any fault on the part of the opposite
party, plea for recall for advancing justice has to be bonafide and has to
be balanced carefully with other relevant consideration including uncalled
for hardship to the witness and uncalled for delay in the trial. It is also
2024:MLHC:589
provided that it has normally to be presumed that the counsel conducting
a case is competent particularly when a counsel is appointed by choice of
a litigant. In the instant, matter there is no dispute that the respondent was
represented by a legal aid counsel at the time when the PW-2 was
examined before the Trial Court and not by a counsel of his choice, hence
the presumption of competency of the Counsel is not automatic.
8.
The petitioners in this case have not challenged the impugned order
by contending that the recalling of witness will result in uncalled for
delay in the trial. It is also not the case of the petitioners that the passing
of impugned order has resulted in causing hardship to the witness.
Furthermore, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, it cannot
be said that the impugned order has the effect of extending undue
advantage to the respondent by causing prejudice to the case of the
prosecution.
9.
The paramount requirement for consideration to exercise
jurisdiction under Section 311 Cr.PC is whether calling of a witness is
necessary for the just decision of a case. The learned Trial Court in its
order dated 09.08.2023 has held that re-examination of PW-2 by the
accused person is a valid reason to enable the accused person to shed
more light to the case and to also prove his innocence and in other words,
it will help the court to arrive at a just decision and to avoid injustice and
miscarriage of justice. Since there exist a categorical finding that the reexamination of the PW-2 would help the Trial Court to arrive at a just
decision and there is no apparent reason to doubt the said finding, the
decision of the Trial Court cannot be faulted.
2024:MLHC:589
10.
In view of the above, no case has been made out by the petitioners
for interfering with the impugned order dated 09.08.2023 and hence, the
criminal petition stands dismissed.
Judge
Meghalaya
01.07.2024
“ N. Swer, Stenographer, Gr-II ”
NATHANIEL SWER SWER
Date: 2024.07.01 16:01:45 +05'30'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review