Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Cril.Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Chief Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur, Babupara Old Secretariat Building,
Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
2. The
Officer-in-Charge/Investigating
Officer,
Thoubal
Police
Station, Thoubal District, Manipur-795138.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus 1.
Mohammad Hussain @ Thoiba, aged about 32 years, S/o Md.
Zakir Hussain of Thoubal Wangkhem Muslim Mamang Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Yairipok, Thoubal District, Manipur.
2.
Kyaw Kyaw Niang @ Abdul Jabar @ Ula Sin of Kawhmu
Village, Moha Rangoon, Myanmar.
3.
Md. Ayub Khan, aged about 41 years, S/o (L) Md. Azizur
Rahaman of Yairipok Wangkhem Muslim Mamang Leikai, P.O.
& P.S. Yairipok, Thoubal District, Manipur.
4.
Md. Abdul Rajaque, aged about 35 years, S/o Abdul Rahim of
Yairipok Tulihal near Aam Walli Masajid, P.O. & P.S. Yairipok,
Thoubal District, Manipur.
5.
Mr. Jhutan Malakar @ Jhuthan Malakar, aged about 29 years,
S/o Mr. Shuamal Malakar of Kamalpur Village, P.O. anandpur,
P.S. PR Bari (Purana Raj Bari), Belonia District, South Tripura.
6.
Tanmoy Pal, aged about 22 years, S/o Tapan Kanti Pal of
Krishnapur Village Ward No. 7 Dhupirbond GP. P.S.
Dharmanagar, North Tripura.
7.
Biman Das, aged about 38 years, S/o (L) Bimal Das @ Dimal
Chandra Das of South Ramnagar Itkhalapoara near Mahindra
Workshop, P.S. West Agartala, P.O. Agartala, West Tripura A/p
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 1
Gandhigram Kathaltali Village near Tripureswari Mandir
English School, P.O. Gandhigram, P.S. Airport, West Tripura
District.
8.
Abdul Hashim, aged about 42 years, S/o Abu Tahar Nia of
Rajnagar Village, P.O. Ramnagar, P.S. West Agartala, West
Tripura District, A/p Bhadramishipara Village, P.O. NIT
Agartala, P.S. Jirania, West Tripura District.
9.
Saikh Muhamad Ahnsan, aged about 39 years, S/o MV Ahmed
of Phoudel Mayai Leikai, P.O. Thoubal, P.S. Yairipok, Thoubal
District, Manipur.
........Respondent/s
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. M. Devananda Addl. AG (Spl.PP)
& Ms. N. Jotsna, Advocate.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. HS. Paonam, Sr. Adv. assisted by
Ms.
Lekhakumari,
Adv;
Mr.
L.
Shashibhusan, Sr. Adv. assisted by
Ms. Kangungailui Kamei, Adv; Mr. H.
Nabachandra, Adv.; Mr. S. Jhaljit, Adv.
Date of Hearing
::
17.04.2023/19.04.2023/06.02.2024/
04.03.2024/03.04.2024/02.05.2024/
06.05.2024/
Date of Judgment and Order
::
03.06.2024
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. A.G. assisted by Ms.
Jyotsana, learned counsel for the petitioners/State; Mr. HS. Paonam,
learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. Lekhakumari, Advocate; Mr. L.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 2
Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. Kangungailui Kamei,
Advocate; Mr. S. Jhalajit, learned counsel; and Mr. H. Nabakumar, learned
counsel for the respondents/accused persons.
[2]
Vide order dated 29.04.2024 in SLP(Crl.) No. 1536 of 2024 filed
by the respondent/accused No.2 herein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court desired
this Court to decide the revision petition filed by the State against the
discharge order as expeditiously as possible and in any case, by the end of
May, 2024. Accordingly, this case was listed on 30.05.2024 for
pronouncement of judgment. However, due to sudden flash flood in Manipur,
there were no court sittings on 30 & 31 May, 2024 and the case is again
listed on 03.06.2024, the next working day available, for pronouncement of
judgment.
[3]
The present Revision Petition has been filed under Section 397
CrPC read with Section 36-B of the ND&PS Act, against the discharge order
dated 20.01.2021 passed by the learned Special Judge (ND&PS) Thoubal
in Spl. T. Case No. 12 of 2020 in connection with FIR No. 94(8) 2019 TBL
Police Station under Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) ND&PS Act added Section 468
IPC and in the ex-parte interim prayed U/S 482 of the CrPC read with Section
36-B of the ND&PS Act for issuing a warrant directing the accused be
arrested by any Sub-ordinate Court and lodge them to prison pending the
disposal of the above referred revision petition. The respondent Nos. 1 to 9
are accused Nos. 1 to 9 before the court below. The point for
determination in the present case is whether the ingredients for the
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 3
offences punishable under Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) ND&PS Act and
Section 468 IPC are made out against the accused persons or not.
[4]
The brief facts of the case are that on 24.08.2019 at about 1:10
am, the Thoubal District Police with the assistance of the members of
Phoudel Keirambi Youths Club, Phoudel Keirambi intercepted one Tata Di
vehicle bearing Regd. No. MN06LA-2847 at IVR (Inter Village Road) of
Phoudel Keirambi Mathak Leikai under the jurisdiction of Yairipok PS and
the driver was identified as Mohammad Hussain (accused No. 1) and some
suspected illegal items were recovered from the said vehicle, around 40,000
(forty thousand) Nos. of suspected WY tablets. The accused No. 1 was
arrested by observing all the formalities. From the disclosure of the accused
No. 1, one international drug smuggler, namely Mr. Kyaw Kyaw Naing @
Abdul Rahim (accused No. 2) was arrested from Imphal International Airport,
Tulihal and recovered from him Indian Currency Rs. 60,000/- in cash, 15
Nos. of 100 denomination US Dollars, one 1000 Kyat, one 5000 kyat, one
100 kyat, one 20 kyat, one 20 taka, one passport being No. SMB110ED with
Burma SIM card and one Samsung Duos being No. 6909503887, two pint
out e-ticket, one boarding pass issued in the name of Niang Kyaw Yaw being
Flight No. 6E 939, one Indian E-VISA being ID No. 1002v0851519.
[5]
Again, from the disclosure of accused No. 1, one person
namely Md. Ayub Khan (accused No. 3) was arrested from Yairipok Lamkhai
on 24.08.2019 at about 1:40 pm and seized one Maruti 800 being Regd. No.
DL2CAF-0821 and two mobile handsets, one Nokia being Mobile No.
9874512487 and one Redmi mobile phone handset being No. 9366342176.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 4
Further, from the disclosure of accused No. 1, arrested one Md. Abdul
Rajaque (accused No. 4) from Yairipok Lamkhai on 24.08.2019 at around
2:15 pm as he was also accomplice with accused No. 1 in the transport of
narcotic substance. As such, a regular case was registered being FIR No.
94(8)2019 TBL PS U/s 22(c)/29/60(3) ND & PS Act.
[6]
On 27.08.2019, seized one Saving Bank Account Pass Book
being No. 86021011002909 in the name of accused No. 1 of Vijiya Bank,
MG Avenue (Saikul) Branch from the rented house of accused No. 1 and
one Biman Das (accused No. 7) had deposited money to the said bank
account of accused No. 1 and on further checking of the passbook and
deposit slip, accused No. 1 received a sum of Rs. 2,20,000/- on different
dates from his business partner like Jhutan Malakar @ Jhuthan Malakar
(accused No. 5) and Biman Das (accused No. 7). It is also stated that
accused persons namely Jhutan Malakar (accused No. 5), Tanmoy Pal
(accused No. 6) and Mohammed Hussain (accused No. 1) had checked in
on 21.04.2019 and checked out on 22.04.2019 from PHOU-OI-BEE Hotel,
North AOC Imphal East District along with Kyaw Kyaw Naing @ Md. Abdul
Rahim (accused No. 2) as they were the same business partners. The
accused persons were interrogated one after another and on interrogation
of the accused persons, it revealed that the accused No. 2 hired accused
No. 1’s Tata DI to transport 30 rolls of carpet at the rate of Rs. 30,000/- only
as a transport charge from Moreh to Silchar. On reaching Silchar, they met
Abdul Hashim (accused No. 8) and handed over the carpets and fruits to
him.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 5
[7]
On 03.09.2019, the accused persons namely accused Nos. 1,
2, 3 & 4 were produced before the Court and remanded them into judicial
custody and on interrogation, it was disclosed that the accused Nos. 5, 6, 7
& 8 were also business partners of the other accused persons and involved
in the same case. The accused Nos. 5 & 6 were arrested on 19.09.2019 from
the house of accused No. 5 with the assistance of PR Bari Police Station,
South Tripura. Thereafter, accused Nos. 5 & 6 were produced before the
Court of Spl. Judge, Belonia, South Tripura on 20.09.2019. Further, the
accused persons were produced before the Spl. Court (ND & PS), Thoubal
and remanded into police custody till 03.10.2019. During the police custody,
the arrested accused persons i.e. accused Nos. 5 & 6, were interrogated one
after another. On interrogation of the accused persons, they admitted that
they were the accomplice of the other accused persons.
On further
investigation of the accused persons, one Saikh Muhamed Ahnsan (accused
No. 9) was arrested in connection with FIR No. 535 of Silchar P.S. dated
16.02.2020 U/s 120-B/489(B)/489(C) IPC and remanded into judicial
custody by the Court of CJM, Cachar, Silchar on 21.02.2020. Thereafter,
production warrant of the accused No. 9 was issued by the Spl. Court (ND &
PS), Thoubal vide order dated 20.02.2020 and on 24.02.2020, he was
released from Silchar Central Jail and on 26.02.2020, he was produced
before the Spl. Court (ND & PS), Thoubal and remanded into police custody
till 03.03.2020.
[8]
Vide impugned the order dated 20.01.2021 passed by learned
Special Judge (ND&PS), Thoubal in Spl.T. Case No.12 of 2020, the accused
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 6
persons (respondents herein) were discharged from the charges punishable
under Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) ND&PS Act and Section 468 IPC. The
grounds for discharging the accused persons are- (i) change of place of
occurrence, and (ii) non-compliance of the mandatory provisions of Sections
41, 42 and 50 of ND&PS Act. The relevant para recording the reasons for
the discharge are reproduced below:
“29. The changing/shifting of place of occurrence from IVR of
Phoudel Kairembi Mathak Leikai to inside the campus of Thoubal
PS suffers from illegalities which is not sustainable in the eyes of
law. And I do not come across any provision of law about the
changing of place of occurrence in the Chapters of Criminal
Procedure Code as well as in the special Act of ND&PS Act and
Rules. The place and time of occurrence is the backbone and from
these, the investigation has to begin. In the instant case, the
search, seizure and arrest were made without complying the
provisions of Sec. 41(2), Sec. 42(1) and 50 of the ND&PS Act.
……………………………………………..
32.
In such serious case, it is very unfortunate on the part of
the investigating team to discard and over looked the mandatory
provisions of law laid down in Cr.P.C. and ND&PS Act, particularly
the changing/shifting of place of occurrence as recorded in the
FIR. The case has been charge sheeted through proper channel
by the I.O. of the case through the O.C. Thoubal P.S., the SDPOThoubal, the Addl. SP(LO) Thoubal, the Superintendent of Police,
Thoubal and the Addl. S.P.(P), Manipur and ultimately reached
this Court.
33.
Wadded through all the materials on record, the
documents and the relevant case laws discussed above, it is
made crystal clear that the seizing officer has violated the
mandatory provisions of Sec. 42(1)(d) of the ND&PS Act and their
non-compliance would render the investigation illegal. As per
record, search, seizure and arrest were made by the complainant
without giving/recording the grounds of his belief, so it is
mandatory to invoke the proviso to Sec. 42(1) which is made in
the case of State of Manipur vs. Beikhokim @ Veikhokin Kukini:
1996 (II) GLT 449 Full Bench that “the proviso to Sec. 42(1) if such
officer has to carry search between sunset and sunrise, he must
record the grounds of his belief.” As such, there are so many
infirmities, loopholes and lacuna in the investigation of the case
which leads failure to the prosecution case. Ld. Spl. PP cannot
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 7
convince the Court in the course of hearing that there occurs no
lacuna in the legal formalities during investigation of the case such
as changing/shifting of place of occurrence and drawal of rough
sketch map of the premises of Thoubal Police Stattion.
34.
Considering all these, I am of the opinion that there is no
sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused persons.
Hence, all the accused persons are discharged from the
liabilities of the case. Surety bonds (if any) stand cancelled and
the security deposit (if) any be returned accordingly.”
[9]
Being aggrieved by the impugned order of the Special Trial
Court, the present Criminal Revision Petition has been filed mainly amongst
the following grounds:
(i)
The Ld. Trial Court has misconstrued the facts of the
present case and also the relevant provision of law by
applying Section 42 (1) of ND&PS Act, without satisfying
the two components of Section 42 of the ND&PS Act,
1985.
(ii)
The Ld. Trial Court has misinterpreted the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court by misquoting the relevant
provision of law.
(iii)
The Ld. Trial Court has failed to satisfy herself to the
correctness, legality & propriety of the impugned order
passed by herself.
(iv)
The accused No. 2 being the citizen of Myanmar has
tried to leave the State of Manipur after the present
impugned discharge order of the Ld. Trial Court. All the
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 8
accused persons in the present case has been trying to
hamper the evidence and also try to leave the State of
Manipur as no trial be done or completed against them..
(v)
The Ld. Trial Court has passed impugned order by
misusing its inherent power by apparent obvious
reasons.
[10]
Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG was empowered as
Special PP to conduct the present case on behalf of the prosecution vide
order dated 28.04.2023 issued by the Deputy Secretary (Law), Government
of Manipur under the provisions of Section 24(8) CrPC. Learned Spl. PP
submits that the learned Special Court (ND&PS), Thoubal has committed
manifest error in discharging the accused persons who were members of a
syndicate of trans border racket dealing in illegal drug trafficking led by a
foreign national. The syndicate operates over the areas extending from
Myanmar to India (passing through Manipur, Assam, Nagaland & Tripura) to
Bangladesh and is active for a long period. As disclosed during the course
of investigation, it has been revealed that before the seizure and arrest made
in the present case, many consignments were delivered through this route
by the same syndicate. In the present case, the seizure is of 40,000 WY
tablets concealed in 100 rolls of carpets and the said lot was transported
from Moreh by a Bolero vehicle and transferred to the seized Tata DI vehicle
at Yairipok Phoudel. It is pointed out that the only grounds cited for
discharging the accused persons are – (i) for changing/shifting the place of
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 9
occurrence and (ii) non-compliance of the mandatory provisions of Sections
41, 42 and 50 of ND&PS Act, 1985.
[11]
Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG submits that the
assumption by the trial Court that the place of occurrence is at IVR of
Phoudel Keirambi Mathak Leikai under the jurisdiction of Yairipok PS, has
been made without any substance. Learned Addl. AG draws the attention of
this Court to the provisions of Sections 177 and 178 CrPC which provide for
place of trial and occurrence of an offence. He explains that as per Section
177 of CrPC for single offence, the place of trial shall be in a court within
whose jurisdiction the offence was committed, such as place of murder or
place of theft, etc. However, under Section 178 of CrPC for continuing
offence and/or where the offence was partly committed in one place and
partly in another place, any of the courts within whose jurisdiction the offence
was partly committed, shall have jurisdiction to conduct the trial. It is
highlighted that the offence of transportation of any psychotropic substances
of commercial quantity punishable under Section 22(c) of ND&PS Act was
initiated at Moreh where the 40,000 WY tablets were loaded in a Bolero pickup vehicle and then transferred to the Tata DI goods vehicle bearing
registration No. MN 06LA 2847 by A-1, A-3 & A-4 at Thoubal Wangkhem.
The contrabands were detected by the locals when the vehicle broke down
and subsequently transferred to Thoubal PS for safety and the seizure was
made in the campus of Thoubal PS in presence of witnesses. It is submitted
that the offence was initiated at Moreh (in Indian territory), continued at
Thoubal Wangkhem (reloading from Bolero vehicle to Tata DI vehicle),
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 10
detected by the local villagers at IVR of Phoudel and the seizure was made
at Thoubal PS. Learned Addl. AG has pointed out that the offence was not
completed and still was continuing and would be completed on successful
transportation of the narcotic drugs to Bangladesh through Assam and
Tripura. It is clarified that IVR at Phoudel is not the only place of occurrence.
Since it is a continuing offence, the campus of Thoubal PS can be treated
as a place of occurrence within the ambit of Section 178 CrPC, as the seizure
of the WY tablets was done there. It is submitted that the finding of the
learned Special Judge with regard to shifting of place of occurrence is
without any substance and it has failed to appreciate the provisions of
Section 178 CrPC correctly.
[12]
With regard to the second point of violation of mandatory
provisions of Sections 41, 42 and 50 of ND&PS Act, it pointed out that the
same is to be examined during trial on appreciation of evidence and
materials relied by the prosecution. It is submitted that such factual aspects
cannot be presumed at the stage of charge hearing. On merit also, Mr. M.
Devananda, learned Addl. AG argues that the provisions of Sections 41 and
42 of ND&PS Act will not be applicable to the facts of the present case. It is
pointed out that for application of Sections 41 & 42, there should be a prior
knowledge or information of existence of contraband in any building,
conveyance or closed place and prescribe procedures for entry and search
of such place and make arrests and seizures therefrom. It is submitted that
in the facts of the present case, the provision of Section 43 of the Act will be
applicable where the seizure of contraband is from a public place or
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 11
conveyance on chance search without any prior information of such
contraband. It is further reiterated that the provisions of Section 50 of the Act
will not be applicable as the search and seizure was from vehicle and not
from any person.
[13]
Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG relies on the following
case laws to fortify his argument:
(i)
Umar Abdul Sakoor Sorathia v. Intelligence Officer,
Narcotic Control Bureau, (2000) 1 SCC 138: Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that while framing charge, the court is only to examine
the materials produced by the prosecution on record and is not to
examine minutely them.
(ii)
State of T.N. v. R. Soundirarasu, (2023) 6 SCC 768:
Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the principles to be followed in
framing of charge under Sections 239 and 240 of CrPC. It was
held that at the stage of charge hearing, the only exercise to be
taken is whether on consideration of the police report and
documents filed by the prosecution, the allegations against the
accused can be said groundless or not.
(iii)
Ghulam Hassan Beigh v. Mohd. Maqbool Magrey,
(2022) 12 SCC 657, Hon’ble Supreme Court re-iterated the
principles to be followed in charge hearing, ie, to examine whether
the materials filed by the prosecution disclose the ingredients of
the alleged offence or not.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 12
(iv)
Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460:
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that existence of materials
constituting the offence is sine qua non for framing charge. It may
be even weaker than a prima facie case. Existence of material
constituting the offence is sufficient for framing charge. However,
sufficiency of such materials for conviction is to be examined only
in trial and not at the stage of charge hearing.
(v)
Krishna Kanwar v. State of Rajasthan, (2004) 2 SCC
608: Hon’ble Supreme Court held that in case of search and
seizure of vehicle found on random frisking, provisions of Section
43 of ND&PS Act will be applicable and Section 42 has no role as
there is no prior information of the contraband.
(vi)
State of Haryana v. Jarnail Singh, (2004) 5 SCC 188:
Hon’ble Supreme Court distinguished the difference between
Sections 42 and 43 of ND&PS Act. It was held that Section 42
deals with the entry, search and seizure in any building,
conveyance and closed space based on personal knowledge
while Section 43 deals with chance seizure from public place
without prior knowledge.
(vii)
Raju v. State of W.B., (2018) 9 SCC 708: Hon’ble
Supreme Court explained the intricate difference between
Sections 42 and 43 of ND&PS Act. Section 42 deals with entry,
search, arrest and seizure made on prior information from a
conveyance or closed place while Section 43 stipulates seizure of
contrabands from public place including conveyance.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 13
(viii)
Kallu
Khan
v.
State
of
Rajasthan:
MANU/SC/1221/2021: AIR 2022 SC 50: Where the search and
seizure was made from the vehicle used, by way of chance
recovery from public road, the provisions of Section 43 of the
ND&PS Act would apply.
(ix)
R. Maringchan Maring v. State of Manipur [Cri. Rev.
P. No. 2 of 2017; Judgment dated 22.04.2024; Coram: Mr.
Justice Siddharth Mridul, CJ, High Court of Manipur]:
MANU/MN/0038/2024: Relying on a catena of cases, this Court
has observed that at the stage of framing of charge, the court is to
examine whether there are sufficient materials to proceed against
the accused and in case of 50:50 situation, charges are to be
framed. Exercising the power under Section 397 CrPC of
superintendence over courts under its jurisdiction, High Court can
examine whether the proceeding of and/or the order on charge is
perverse or not. Para 29 is reproduced for better understanding.
29.
Considering
the
conspectus
of
the
decisions
discussed
hereinabove, the following legal position emerges with regard to the law on
charge; the revisional jurisdiction of the High Court; and the powers
exercisable by the High Court in revisional jurisdiction whilst dealing with
an order on charge:
(i) The jurisdiction of the Trial Court whilst exercising power
under Section 397 of the CrPC is limited.
(ii) At the stage of charge, the Trial Court has to merely peruse the
evidence in order to find out whether there is a sufficient ground for
proceeding against the accused or not.
(iii) If upon consideration of the material placed before it, the Trial
Court is satisfied that a prima facie case is made out against the
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 14
accused, it must proceed to frame charge in terms of Section 228 of
the CrPC.
(iv) The Trial Court cannot conduct a roving and fishing inquiry into
the evidence or a meticulous consideration thereof at this stage.
Marshalling and appreciation of evidence, and going into the
probative value of the material on record, is not in the domain of the
Court at the time of framing of charges.
(v) In other words, at the beginning and the initial stage of the trial,
the truth, veracity and effect of the evidence which the prosecution
proposes to adduce are not to be meticulously judged, and nor is any
weight to be attached to the probable defence of the accused. Thus,
a 'mini trial' is not to be conducted.
(vi) It is not obligatory for the Trial Court at the time of framing of
charges, to consider in any detail and weigh in a sensitive balance
whether the facts, if proved, would be incompatible with the
innocence of the accused or not. The standard of test and judgment
which is to be finally applied before recording a finding regarding the
guilt or otherwise of the accused is not exactly to be applied at the
stage of deciding the matter under Section 227 or Section 228 of the
CrPC.
(vii) Thus, it is axiomatic that at the initial stage if there is a
strong/grave suspicion which leads the Court to think that there is
ground for presuming that the accused has committed an offence,
then it is not open to the court to say that there is no sufficient ground
for proceeding against the accused.
(viii) The Trial Court may sift the evidence to determine whether the
facts emerging therefrom taken at their face value disclose the
existence of all the ingredients constituting the alleged offence or not.
(ix) Detailed orders are not necessary whilst framing charges and
contentious issues are not required to be answered by the Trial Court
at the stage of framing of charges.
(x) Only in a case where it is shown that the evidence which the
prosecution proposes to adduce to prove the guilt of the accused,
even if fully accepted before it is challenged in cross-examination or
rebutted by defence evidence cannot show that the accused
committed the crime, then and then alone the Court can discharge
the accused.
(xi) Further, if the scales of pan as to the guilt or innocence of the
accused are something like even at the initial stage of making an
order under Section 227 or Section 228, then, in such a situation,
ordinarily and generally, the order which will have to be made will be
one under Section 228 and not under Section 227 of the CrPC.
(xii) The provisions of section 397 of the CrPC empower the High
Court with supervisory jurisdiction to consider the correctness,
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 15
legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order and as to the
regularity of the proceedings of any inferior court.
(xiii) Revisional jurisdiction is severely restricted, and ought not to be
exercised in a routine and casual manner. It has to be exercised,
normally, without dwelling at length upon the facts and appraising the
evidence of the case.
(xiv) Further, the Court in revision ought to refrain from substituting
its own conclusion on an elaborate consideration of evidence.
(xv) Whilst in revisional jurisdiction, the High Court cannot enter into
the realm of appreciation of evidence at the stage of the framing of
the charges itself.
(xvi) The High Court, under statutory obligation, ought to be loath in
interfering at the stage of framing the charges against the accused,
merely on hypothesis, imagination and far-fetched reasons which in
law amount to interdicting the trial against the accused person. Thus,
self-restraint on the part of the High Court should be the rule unless
there is a glaring injustice staring the Court in the face.
(xvii) Revisional powers could be exercised only when it is shown
that, (a) there is a legal bar against the continuance of the criminal
proceedings; (b) the framing of charge or the facts as stated in the
first information report even if they are taken at the face value and
accepted in their entirety do not constitute the offence for which the
accused has been charged;(c) where the exercise of revisional power
is absolutely essential to prevent patent miscarriage of justice and for
correcting some grave error that might be committed by the
subordinate courts.
(xviii)Quashing of a charge is an exception to the rule of continuous
prosecution. Where the offence is even broadly satisfied, the Court
should be more inclined to permit continuation of prosecution rather
than its quashing at that initial stage. The Court is not expected to
marshal the records with a view to decide admissibility and reliability
of the documents or records but is an opinion formed prima facie.
[14]
In conclusion, learned Addl. AG emphasises that the provisions
of Section 41, 42 and 50 of the ND&PS Act will not be applicable to the facts
of the case in hand and the learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Thoubal was
wrong in discharging the accused persons when the seizure of the
contrabands from the accused persons at a public place, had been
established and they were closely participating in the transportation of the
contrabands. It is also submitted that applicability and non-compliance of the
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 16
mandatory provisions of Sections 41, 42 and 50 of the ND&PS Act are to be
decided during the trial on appreciation of evidence produced by both the
prosecution and the accused. There can be no presumption of such factual
aspects. On the question of shifting of place of occurrence, it has been
explained that the offence is a continuing one and it will culminate when the
contrabands cross border to Bangladesh and as such the campus of
Thoubal PS is also a place of occurrence and the trial Court was wrong in
discharging the accused persons on this ground also. It is highlighted that in
exercise of power conferred under Section 397 CrPC read with Section 36B ND&PS Act, this Court can interfere with the impugned order of discharge,
as the same is perverse on law as well on facts. It is prayed that the
impugned order be set aside the accused persons be directed to face trial
for the offences punishable under Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) ND&PS Act and
Section 468 IPC.
[15]
Mr. H. Nabachandra, learned counsel for respondent/accused
No. 6 submits that there is no error in the impugned order discharging the
accused persons, even not to speak of perversity. It is submitted that the
place of occurrence was at IVR of Phoudel and without any basis, the same
was shifted to the campus of Thoubal PS. There is an unexplained delay of
15 hours in registration of the FIR. It is also stated that the offence cannot
be said to a continuing act, once the contrabands had been detected at
Phoudel and hence no cause of action arose at the Thoubal PS. Reliance is
placed on the decisions reported as Golak Patel Volkart Ltd. V. Dundayya
Gurushiddaiah Hiremath: (1991) 2 SCC 141 regarding the concept of
continuing offence and Rajinder Singh v. State: 1999 (1) Crimes 271
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 17
(Delhi) regarding place of occurrence as the place where the offence was
actually committed. It is prayed that the revision petition be dismissed being
devoid of any merit.
[16]
Mr.
HS
Paonam,
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
respondent/accused Nos.3 & 4 adopts the submission of Mr. H.
Nabachandra, learned counsel for respondent No.6. He has further pointed
out that no seizure has been made from them and the accusation against
them is for facilitating in transport of narcotic substances. However, it is
pointed out that except for the statement of the complainant, no other
material is placed by the prosecution to connect respondent Nos.3 & 4 to the
crime. It is submitted that these materials will not be sufficient for proceeding
against the respondent/accused Nos. 3 & 4 and it is prayed that the revision
petition be dismissed with cost.
[17]
Mr. S. Jhaljit, learned counsel for the respondent/accused No.9
submits that his client was not arrested in connection with narcotic
substance. The allegation against the respondent No.9 is for his involvement
in manufacturing of a fake Aadhar card and he cannot be roped in a trial
under ND&PS Act. No material is placed by the prosecution to link the
respondent No.9 for the offence of conspiracy within the purview of Section
29 of ND&PS Act. Learned counsel relies on the decisions of (i) Sajjan
Kumar v. CBI, (2010) 9 SCC 368 for the principles of framing charge on
existence of materials constituting the offence and (ii) Sharif Ahmed and
Ors. vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors. (01.05.2024 - SC) :
MANU/SC/0368/2024: 2024 INSC 363, where Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that there should be clarity in the charge sheet so as to enable the accused
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 18
to understand the accusations against him. It is submitted that the materials
are not so clear with respect to the respondent/accused No.9 and it is prayed
that the revision petition be dismissed with heavy cost.
[18]
Mr. L. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel for the
respondent/accused No.2 submits that without any material, his client has
been branded as main accused. It is pointed out that there was no seizure
of contrabands from the possession of the respondent/accused No.2, except
for some currency notes and mobile phones. It is stated that these materials
are not sufficient to proceed against the respondent No.2 for the offences
under Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) ND&PS Act and Section 468 IPC. The other
accused are unknown to him. Further, it is reiterated that there is no material
in the charge sheet to indicate that the seized contrabands belong to the
respondent No.2.
[19]
In addition to the grounds of shifting of place of occurrence and
non-compliance of the mandatory provisions of Sections 41, 42 and 50 of
ND&PS Act as held by the learned Special Judge, Mr. L. Shashibhushan,
learned senior counsel for the respondent No.2 has also raised for the first
time the new plea of non-compliance of the stipulation under Section 52A of
ND&PS Act. It is explained that Section 52A(2) of ND&PS Act mandates a
competent officer to prepare an inventory of the seized narcotic drugs with
adequate particulars relevant to the identity of the seized drugs in any
proceeding and produce before a Magistrate for the purpose of certifying the
correctness of the inventory, taking relevant photographs in presence of the
Magistrate and due certification of the drawing of the samples in presence
of the Magistrate. Under sub-section (4), such inventory, the photographs of
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 19
narcotic substances and any list of samples drawn, will be primary evidence
in respect of such offence. It is pointed out that in the present case there is
a total non-compliance of the mandatory provisions of Section 52A of the
ND&PS Act and as such the seized contrabands cannot be treated as
primary evidence against the accused No.2 as well against other accused
persons. Accordingly, the trial will be vitiated and the accused persons could
have been discharged on this point also, even if the same was not
considered during the charge hearing.
[20]
Mr. L. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel for the
respondent/accused No.2 relies on the following decisions with regard to the
provisions of Sections 41, 42, 43 and 52A of ND&PS Act:
(i)
Yusuf
vs.
State
(13.10.2023
-
SC)
:
MANU/SC/1142/2023: AIR 2023 SC 5041, Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that non-compliance of the provisions of Section 52A
of ND&PS Act would vitiate the trial and conviction. In that case,
the sample was drawn in presence of the gazetted officer and not
before the Magistrate as contemplated under Section 52A(2) of
ND&PS Act.
(ii)
Union of India v. Mohanlal, (2016) 3 SCC 379, it is held
that provisions of Section 52A of ND&PS Act is mandatory.
Drawing of samples in presence of the Magistrate is mandatory.
(iii)
Mohammed Khalid and Ors. vs. The State of
Telangana (01.03.2024 - SC) : MANU/SC/0154/2024: 2024 INSC
158, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the provisions of Section
52A of ND&PS Act is mandatory and violation of such rule vitiates
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 20
the trial and hence the conviction. FSL report based on samples
drawn in violation of the provisions of Section 52A of the Act will
be a waste paper and cannot be read in evidence.
(iv)
Roy V.D. vs. State of Kerala (10.11.2000-SC):
MANU/SC/ 0693/2000: AIR 2001 SC 137, it is held that the
provisions of Sections 41 and 42 of ND&PS Act are mandatory
and their non-compliance will vitiate the trial.
(v)
Boota Singh v. State of Haryana, (2021) 19 SCC 606:
Difference between Sections 42 and 43 of ND&PS Act have been
explained. It was held that a private vehicle will not come within
the meaning of public place as mentioned in explanation to
Section 43 of the Act.
[21]
With respect to the principles to be followed in charge hearing,
Mr. L. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel refers to the following case
laws:
(vi)
Vishnu Kumar Shukla and Ors. vs. The State of Uttar
Pradesh and Ors. (28.11.2023 - SC) : MANU/SC/1268/2023:
AIR 2024 SC 90, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a duty is cast
on the courts to examine as to whether the documents and
materials placed on record disclose an offence or not.
(vii)
Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal, (1979) 3 SCC
4, Hon’ble Supreme Court laid down the principles to followed
while considering charge hearing as follows.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 21
10. Thus, on a consideration of the authorities mentioned above, the
following principles emerge:
(1) That the Judge while considering the question of framing the
charges under Section 227 of the Code has the undoubted power to
sift and weigh the evidence for the limited purpose of finding out
whether or not a prima facie case against the accused has been
made out.
(2) Where the materials placed before the Court disclose grave
suspicion against the accused which has not been properly explained
the Court will be fully justified in framing a charge and proceeding
with the trial.
(3) The test to determine a prima facie case would naturally depend
upon the facts of each case and it is difficult to lay down a rule of
universal application. By and large however if two views are equally
possible and the Judge is satisfied that the evidence produced before
him while giving rise to some suspicion but not grave suspicion
against the accused, he will be fully within his right to discharge the
accused.
(4) That in exercising his jurisdiction under Section 227 of the Code
the Judge which under the present Code is a senior and experienced
court cannot act merely as a Post Office or a mouthpiece of the
prosecution, but has to consider the broad probabilities of the case,
the total effect of the evidence and the documents produced before
the Court, any basic infirmities appearing in the case and so on. This
however does not mean that the Judge should make a roving enquiry
into the pros and cons of the matter and weigh the evidence as if he
was conducting a trial.
(viii)
Sajjan Kumar v. CBI, (2010) 9 SCC 368, Hon’ble
Supreme Court prescribed the essence in charge framing
proceeding as follows:
Exercise of jurisdiction under Sections 227 and 228 CrPC
21. On consideration of the authorities about the scope of Sections
227 and 228 of the Code, the following principles emerge:
(i) The Judge while considering the question of framing the charges
under Section 227 CrPC has the undoubted power to sift and weigh
the evidence for the limited purpose of finding out whether or not a
prima facie case against the accused has been made out. The test
to determine prima facie case would depend upon the facts of each
case.
(ii) Where the materials placed before the court disclose grave
suspicion against the accused which has not been properly
explained, the court will be fully justified in framing a charge and
proceeding with the trial.
(iii) The court cannot act merely as a post office or a mouthpiece of
the prosecution but has to consider the broad probabilities of the
case, the total effect of the evidence and the documents produced
before the court, any basic infirmities, etc. However, at this stage,
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 22
there cannot be a roving enquiry into the pros and cons of the matter
and weigh the evidence as if he was conducting a trial.
(iv) If on the basis of the material on record, the court could form an
opinion that the accused might have committed offence, it can frame
the charge, though for conviction the conclusion is required to be
proved beyond reasonable doubt that the accused has committed the
offence.
(v) At the time of framing of the charges, the probative value of the
material on record cannot be gone into but before framing a charge
the court must apply its judicial mind on the material placed on record
and must be satisfied that the commission of offence by the accused
was possible.
(vi) At the stage of Sections 227 and 228, the court is required to
evaluate the material and documents on record with a view to find out
if the facts emerging therefrom taken at their face value disclose the
existence of all the ingredients constituting the alleged offence. For
this limited purpose, sift the evidence as it cannot be expected even
at that initial stage to accept all that the prosecution states as gospel
truth even if it is opposed to common sense or the broad probabilities
of the case.
(vii) If two views are possible and one of them gives rise to suspicion
only, as distinguished from grave suspicion, the trial Judge will be
empowered to discharge the accused and at this stage, he is not to
see whether the trial will end in conviction or acquittal.
(ix)
Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel v. State of Gujarat,
(2019) 16 SCC 547, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that at the stage
of framing of charge, the court can sift evidence in order to satisfy
itself the materials are available for proceeding against the
accused.
(x)
Ghulam Hassan Beigh v. Mohd. Maqbool Magrey,
(2022) 12 SCC 657: Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that court
can sift materials at the stage of charge hearing as to see
existence of sufficient materials against the accused.
[22]
In conclusion, Mr. L. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel
for the respondent/accused No.2 submits that the materials collected in
violation of the mandatory provisions of Section 52A of the ND&PS Act for
not producing the samples for certification before the Magistrate cannot be
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 23
a primary source of evidence against the accused persons during the trial
and as such there are no valid materials to constitute the ingredients of the
offences alleged against the accused. It is submitted that in a charge hearing
proceeding, the court can examine whether there are valid materials against
the accused for proceeding further in a full-fledged trial. It is reiterated that
in view of the dictum of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases cited above,
there are no materials to constitute the offences under Sections
22(c)/29/60(3) ND&PS Act and Section 468 IPC. It is prayed that the revision
petition may also be dismissed for non-compliance of the mandatory
provisions of Section 52A of ND&PS Act.
[23]
Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG replies to the new plea of
violation of Section 52A of the Act raised by the accused No.2 that such plea
cannot be raised for the first time in the revision petition, as the trial Court
has not discussed the same. It is pointed out that revision petition is to be
confined to the grounds and materials considered by the court below. In any
case, it is stated that such plea of non-compliance of the mandatory statutory
provision has to be examined during the trial.
[24]
This Court has considered the materials on record including the
whole LCR, the submissions made at bar including the new plea and relevant
case laws. Before proceeding further, it will be fruitful to reproduce the
relevant provisions from various statutes as below:
CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, 1973 - (Central) :
Section 177 : Ordinary place of inquiry and trial.
Every offence shall ordinarily be inquired inland tried by a Court within
whose local jurisdiction it was committed.
Section 178 : Place of inquiry or trial
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 24
(a) When it is uncertain in which of several local areas an offence was
committed, or
(b) where an offence is committed partly in one local area and partly in
another, or
(c) where an offence is a continuing one, and continues to be committed in
more local areas than one, or
(d) where it consists of several acts done in different local areas, it may be
inquired into or tried by a Court having jurisdiction over any of such local
areas.
Section 227 : Discharge
If, upon consideration of the record of the case and the documents
submitted therewith, and after hearing the submissions of the accused and
the prosecution in this behalf, the Judge considers that there is not
sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused, he shall discharge
the accused and record his reasons for so doing.
Section 228 : Framing of charge
(1) If, after such consideration and hearing as aforesaid, the Judge is of
opinion that there is ground for presuming that the accused has committed
an offence which(a) is not exclusively triable by the Court of Session, he may, frame a
charge against the accused and, by order, transfer the case for trial to the
Chief Judicial Magistrate 3[or any other Judicial Magistrate of the first class
and direct the accused to appear before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, or,
as the case may be, the Judicial Magistrate of the first class, on such date
as he deems fit, and thereupon such Magistrate] shall try the offence in
accordance with the procedure for the trial of warrant-cases instituted on a
police report;
(b) is exclusively triable by the Court, he shall frame in writing a charge
against the accused.
(2) Where the Judge frames any charge under clause (b) of sub-section
(1), the charge shall be read and explained to the accused and the accused
shall be asked whether he pleads guilty of the offence charged or claims to
be tried.
NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT, 1985 (Central) :
Section 22 : Punishment for contravention in relation to psychotropic
substances
Whoever, in contravention of any provision of this Act or any rule or order
made or condition of licence granted thereunder, manufactures,
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 25
possesses, sells, purchases, transports, imports inter-State, exports interState or uses any psychotropic substance shall be punishable,-(a) where the contravention involves small quantity, with rigorous
imprisonment for a term which may extend to 1[one year], or with fine which
may extend to ten thousand rupees or with both;
(b) where the contravention involves quantity lesser than commercial
quantity but greater than small quantity, with rigorous imprisonment for a
term which may extend to ten years and with fine which may extend to one
lakh rupees;
(c) where the contravention involves commercial quantity, with rigorous
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than ten years but which
may extend to twenty years and shall also be liable to fine which shall not
be less than one lakh rupees but which may extend to two lakh rupees:
Provided that the court may, for reasons to be recorded in the judgment,
impose a fine exceeding two lakh rupees.
Section 29 : Punishment for abetment and criminal conspiracy
(1) Whoever abets, or is a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit an
offence punishable under this Chapter, shall, whether such offence be or
be not committed in consequence of such abetment or in pursuance of such
criminal conspiracy, and notwithstanding anything contained in section 116
of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), be punishable with the punishment
provided for the offence.
(2) A person abets, or is a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit, an
offence, within the meaning of this section, who, in India abets or is a party
to the criminal conspiracy to the commission of any act in a place without
and beyond India which-(a) would constitute an offence if committed within India; or
(b) under the laws of such place, is an offence relating to narcotic drugs or
psychotropic substances having all the legal conditions required to
constitute it such an offence the same as or analogous to the legal
conditions required to constitute it an offence punishable under this
Chapter, if committed within India.
Section 36A : Offences triable by Special Courts
…………………………………………………………………
(2) When trying an offence under this Act, a Special Court may also try an
offence other than an offence under this Act with which the accused may,
under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), be charged at the
same trial.
………………………………………………………………………
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 26
Section 60 : Liability of illicit drugs, substances, plants, articles and
conveyances to confiscation
(1) Whenever any offence punishable under this Act has been committed,
the narcotic drug, psychotropic substance, controlled substance, opium
poppy, coca plant, cannabis plant, materials, apparatus and utensils in
respect of which or by means of which such offence has been committed,
shall be liable to confiscation.
(2) Any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance 2[or controlled
substances] lawfully produced, imported inter-State, exported inter-State,
imported into India, transported, manufactured, possessed, used,
purchased or sold along with, or in addition to, any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance or controlled substances] which is liable to
confiscation under sub-section (1) and there receptacles, packages and
coverings in which any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance 2[or
controlled substances], materials, apparatus or utensils liable to
confiscation under sub-section (1) is found, and the other contents, if any,
of such receptacles or packages shall likewise be liable to confiscation.
(3) Any animal or conveyance used in carrying any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance or controlled substance], or any article liable to
confiscation under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) shall be liable to
confiscation, unless the owner of the animal or conveyance proves that it
was so used without the knowledge or connivance of the owner himself, his
agent, if any, and the person-in-charge of the animal or conveyance and
that each of them had taken all reasonable precautions against such use.
Section 41 : Power to issue warrant and authorisation
(1) A Metropolitan Magistrate or a Magistrate of the first class or any
Magistrate of the second-class specially empowered by the State
Government in this behalf, may issue a warrant for the arrest of any person
whom he has reason to believe to have committed any offence punishable
under this Act, or for the search, whether by day or by night, of any building,
conveyance or place in which he has reason to believe any narcotic drug
or psychotropic substance or controlled substance in respect of which an
offence punishable under this Act has been committed or any document or
other article which may furnish evidence of the commission of such offence
or any illegally acquired property or any document or other article which
may furnish evidence of holding any illegally acquired property which is
liable for seizure or freezing or forfeiture under Chapter VA of this Act is
kept or concealed.
(2) Any such officer of gazetted rank of the departments of central excise,
narcotics, customs, revenue intelligence or any other department of the
Central Government including the paramilitary forces or the armed forces
as is empowered in this behalf by general or special order by the Central
Government, or any such officer of the revenue, drugs control, excise,
police or any other department of a State Government as is empowered in
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 27
this behalf by general or special order of the State Government if he has
reason to believe from personal knowledge or information given by any
person and taken in writing that any person has committed an offence
punishable under this Act or that any narcotic drug or psychotropic
substance or controlled substance in respect of which any offence under
this Act has been committed or any document or other article which may
furnish evidence of the commission of such offence or any illegally acquired
property or any document or other article which may furnish evidence of
holding any illegally acquired property which is liable for seizure or freezing
or forfeiture under Chapter VA of this Act is kept or concealed in any
building, conveyance or place, may authorise any officer subordinate to him
but superior in rank to a peon, sepoy or a constable to arrest such a person
or search a building, conveyance or place whether by day or by night or
himself arrest such person or search a building, conveyance or place.
(3) The officer to whom a warrant under sub-section (1) is addressed and
the officer who authorised the arrest or search or the officer who is so
authorised under sub-section (2)shall have all the powers of an officer
acting under section 42.
Section 42 : Power of entry, search, seizure and arrest without warrant or
authorisation
(1) Any such officer (being an officer superior in rank to a peon, sepoy or
constable) of the departments of central excise, narcotics, customs,
revenue intelligence or any other department of the Central Government
including paramilitary forces or armed forces as is empowered in this behalf
by general or special order by the Central Government, or any such officer
(being an officer superior in rank to a peon, sepoy or constable) of the
revenue, drugs control, excise, police or any other department of a State
Government as is empowered in this behalf by general or special order of
the State Government, if he has reason to believe from persons knowledge
or information given by any person and taken down in writing that any
narcotic drug, or psychotropic substance, or controlled substance in
respect of which an offence punishable under this Act has been committed
or any document or other article which may furnish evidence of the
commission of such offence or any illegally acquired property or any
document or other article which may furnish evidence of holding any
illegally acquired property which is liable for seizure or freezing or forfeiture
under Chapter VA of this Act is kept or concealed in any building,
conveyance or enclosed place, may between sunrise and sunset,-(a) enter into and search any such building, conveyance or place;
(b) in case of resistance, break open any door and remove any obstacle to
such entry;
(c) seize such drug or substance and all materials used in the manufacture
thereof and any other article and any animal or conveyance which he has
reason to believe to be liable to confiscation under this Act and any
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 28
document or other article which he has reason to believe may furnish
evidence of the commission of any offence punishable under this Act or
furnish evidence of holding any illegally acquired property which is liable
for seizure or freezing or forfeiture under Chapter VA of this Act; and
(d) detain and search, and, if he thinks proper, arrest any person whom he
has reason to believe to have committed any offence punishable under this
Act:
Provided that in respect of holder of a licence for manufacture of
manufactured drugs or psychotropic substances or controlled substances
granted under this Act or any rule or order made thereunder, such power
shall be exercised by an officer not below the rank of sub-inspector:
Provided further that] if such officer has reason to believe that a search
warrant or authorisation cannot be obtained without affording opportunity
for the concealment of evidence or facility for the escape of an offender, he
may enter and search such building, conveyance or enclosed place at any
time between sunset and sunrise after recording the grounds of his belief.
(2) Where an officer takes down any information in writing under subsection (1) or records grounds for his belief under the proviso thereto, he
shall within seventy-two hours send a copy thereof to his immediate official
superior.
Section 43 : Power of seizure and arrest in public place
Any officer of any of the departments mentioned in section 42 may-(a) seize in any public place or in transit, any narcotic drug or psychotropic
substance or controlled substance in respect of which he has reason to
believe an offence punishable under this Act has been committed, and,
along with such drug or substance, any animal or conveyance or article
liable to confiscation under this Act, any document or other article which he
has reason to believe may furnish evidence of the commission of an
offence punishable under this Act or any document or other article which
may furnish evidence of holding any illegally acquired property which is
liable for seizure or freezing or forfeiture under Chapter VA of this Act;
(b) detain and search any person whom he has reason to believe to have
committed an offence punishable under this Act, and if such person has
any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance or controlled substance in his
possession and such possession appears to him to be unlawful, arrest him
and any other person in his company.
Explanation.--For the purposes of this section, the expression "public
place" includes any public conveyance, hotel, shop, or other place intended
for use by, or accessible to, the public.]
Section 50 : Conditions under which search of persons shall be conducted
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 29
(1) When any officer duly authorised under section 42 is about to search
any person under the provisions of section 41, section 42 or section 43, he
shall, if such person so requires, take such person without unnecessary
delay to the nearest Gazette Officer of any of the departments mentioned
in section 42 or to the nearest Magistrate.
(2) If such requisition is made, the officer may detain the person until he
can bring him before the Gazetted Officer or the Magistrate referred to in
subsection (1).
(3) The Gazette Officer or the Magistrate before whom any such person is
brought shall, if he sees no reasonable ground for search, forthwith
discharge the person but otherwise shall direct that search be made.
(4) No female shall be searched by anyone excepting a female.
(5) When an officer duly authorised under section 42 has reason to believe
that it is not possible to take the person to be searched to the nearest
Gazetted Officer or Magistrate without the possibility of the person to be
searched parting with possession of any narcotic drug or psychotropic
substance, or controlled substance or article or document, he may, instead
of taking such person to the nearest Gazette Officer or Magistrate, proceed
to search the person as provided under section 100 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974).
(6) After a search is conducted under sub-section (5), the officer shall
record the reasons for such belief which necessitated such search and
within seventy-two hours send a copy thereof to his immediate official
superior.
Section 52A : Disposal of seized narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances
(1) The Central Government may, having regard to the hazardous nature,
vulnerability to theft, substitution, constraint of proper storage space or any
other relevant consideration, in respect of any narcotic drugs, psychotropic
substances, controlled substances or conveyances, by notification in the
Official Gazette, specify such narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances,
controlled substances or conveyance or class of narcotic drugs, class of
psychotropic substances, class of controlled substances or conveyances,
which shall, as soon as may be after their seizure, be disposed of by such
officer and in such manner as that Government may, from time to time,
determine after following the procedure hereinafter specified.;]
(2) Where any 3[narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled
substances or conveyances] has been seized and forwarded to the officerin-charge of the nearest police station or to the officer empowered under
section 53, the officer referred to in sub-section (1) shall prepare an
inventory of such narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances containing
such details relating to their description, quality, quantity, mode of packing,
marks, numbers or such other identifying particulars of the narcotic drugs
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 30
or psychotropic substances or the packing in which they are packed,
country of origin and other particulars as the officer referred to in subsection (1) may consider relevant to the identity of the narcotic drugs or
psychotropic substances in any proceedings under this Act and make an
application, to any Magistrate for the purpose of-(a) certifying the correctness of the inventory so prepared; or
(b) taking, in the presence of such Magistrate, photographs of 4[such
drugs, substances or conveyances] and certifying such photographs as
true; or
(c) allowing to draw representative samples of such drugs or substances,
in the presence of such Magistrate and certifying the correctness of any list
of samples so drawn.
(3) Where an application is made under sub-section (2), the Magistrate
shall, as soon as may be, allow the application.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1
of 1872) or the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), every court
trying an offence under this Act, shall treat the inventory, the photographs
of narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyances] and any list of samples drawn under subsection (2) and
certified by the Magistrate, as primary evidence in respect of such offence.
INDIAN PENAL CODE, 1860 - (Central)
Section 415 : Cheating
Whoever, by deceiving any person, fraudulently or dishonestly induces the
person so deceived to deliver any property to any person, or to consent
that any person shall retain any property, or intentionally induces the
person so deceived to do or omit to do anything which he would not do or
omit if he were not so deceived, and which act or omission causes or is
likely to cause damage or harm to that person in body, mind, reputation or
property, is said to "cheat".
Explanation,--A dishonest concealment of facts is a deception within the
meaning of this section.
Section 463 : Forgery
Whoever makes any false documents or false electronic record or part of a
document or electronic record with intent to cause damage or injury, to the
public or to any person, or to support any claim or title, or to cause any
person to part with property, or to enter into any express or implied contract,
or with intent to commit fraud or that fraud may be committed, commits
forgery.
Section 468 : Forgery for purpose of cheating
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 31
Whoever commits forgery, intending that the document or electronic record
forged shall be used for the purpose of cheating, shall be punished with
imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven
years, and shall also be liable to fine.
[25]
From the above quoted provisions, it is clear that in case of
single offence, the place of trial will be at the court within which jurisdiction,
the alleged offence was committed as provided by Section 177 CrPC. In
case of continuing offence and/or where part of the offence was committed
at one place and another in another places, under the provision of Section
178 CrPC all the courts within whose jurisdiction the offence was partly
committed will have jurisdiction. What is stipulated by Chapter XIII of CrPC
(including Sections 177 and 178) is the jurisdiction of the court to conduct
trial of the offence which was committed within its jurisdiction. This chapter
refers to the jurisdiction of the court alone and does not mention about the
jurisdiction of police station. Admittedly, in the present case IVR at Phoudel
and the campus of Thoubal Police Station are within the jurisdiction of the
Special Court (ND&PS), Thoubal which is having territorial jurisdiction over
the revenue districts of Thoubal and Kakching. IVR at Phoudel and Thoubal
PS are within Thoubal district and as such the Special Court (ND&PS),
Thoubal has jurisdiction in view of Chapter XIII of CrPC. Further, the offence
of possession and transportation of narcotic substance of commercial
quantity is still a continuing offence. It started from Moreh border town in
Manipur and the drugs were to travel through Assam and Tripura before
reaching Bangladesh. This Court is of the opinion that the IVR at Phoudel
cannot be stated as the only place of occurrence. Accordingly, it is held that
the Special Court (ND&PS), Thoubal has committed manifest error in
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 32
concluding that the campus of Thoubal PS is not a place of occurrence. As
already observed, the Special Court (ND&PS), Thoubal will have jurisdiction
to try any offence committed within the territorial limits of Thoubal and
Kakching revenue districts. The Special Court was wrong in discharging the
accused persons on this ground.
[26]
It is the settled principle of law that in case of charge
proceeding, the court is only to examine the police report and the documents
relied by the prosecution as to whether the ingredients of the offences are
made out against the accused for proceeding further. The court cannot
indulge into a roving inquiry to dissect whether such materials are sufficient
for conviction or not. This is not in the realm of charge hearing. If necessary
ingredients of the offence are established on perusal of the materials on
record, the charge is to be framed. Sufficiency of materials is to be decided
during trial on appreciation of evidence. [Kindly see Amit Kapoor (supra)].
Whether a mandatory provision of law or precedent has been complied or
not is to be verified during trial on examination of the materials on record and
the depositions of witnesses. The non-compliance of statutory mandate, if
any, cannot be presumed by the court at the time of charge hearing. It is
repeated as the sake of repetition that during charge hearing the court is to
examine only as to whether the materials constituting the alleged offence are
disclosed in the police report and the relied documents. In the present case,
this Court is to examine whether the trial Court passed the discharge order
within these limits set by the statutory provisions and the precedents of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court as cited above.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 33
[27]
The second ground for discharge relied by the learned Special
Judge (ND&PS), Thoubal is for non-compliance of the mandatory provisions
of Sections 41, 42 and 50 of ND&PS Act. It is seen from the above cited
judgments passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that for the applicability of
Sections 41 and 42 of the Act, there should be a prior information or
knowledge to the competent officers mentioned in the provisions about the
possession and/or storage of narcotic substance in a conveyance, building
or closed area. Such information or knowledge should be taken down in
writing and should inform the higher officer before proceeding for search,
seizure and arrest. These processes are mandatory in nature and any
violation of such procedure will vitiate the trial. Section 50 deals with the
situation where body search is conducted in public place in presence of
gazetted officer. It is also the settled law that the person to be searched
under Section 50 of the Act should be informed about his right to be searched
in presence of a gazetted officer and this is a mandatory requirement. The
provisions of Section 43 of ND&PS Act will be attracted in case of chance
seizure of narcotic substance in transit or arrest in any public place. The
expression ‘public place’ includes any public conveyance, hotel, shop or
other place intended for use by or accessible to the public. As held in the
case of Kallu Khan (supra), Section 43 of the Act will be applicable where
the search and seizure is made from the vehicle used by way of chance
recovery from public place. Prior knowledge is not a mandatory requirement
of Section 43, unlike Sections 41 and 42 of ND&PS Act.
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 34
[28]
In the case in hand, there was no prior information or
knowledge about the carrying of the contrabands in the seized vehicle. The
contrabands were detected by the local people first and then by the police,
when the vehicle carrying them broke down at the IVR of Phoudel. Situated
such, the main ingredient for invoking the mandatory provisions of Sections
41 and 42 of the Act of having prior information about the carrying or storage
of the contrabands seems to be missing. The contrabands were detected by
the public and then by the police personnel of Thoubal PS by chance. If the
vehicle did not break down at the IVR of Phoudel, the contrabands could not
have been detected either by the local people or by the police. The present
case seems to fall within the ambit of the provisions of Section 43 of ND&PS
Act dealing with seizure on chance recovery. In the circumstances, this Court
is of the firmed opinion that the provisions of Sections 41 and 42 of the Act
may not be attracted and discharge on this ground is not warranted. The
applicability and violation of such mandatory provisions have to be examined
during the trial on minute appreciation of the materials on record and the
depositions of the witnesses. In a charge hearing proceeding, the court
ought not to have presumed the factual aspects which can be verified only
during the trial. What is to be done is to see whether the ingredients
constituting the alleged offences are made out from a bare reading of the
police report and the documents relied by the prosecution. Sufficiency and
admissibility of these documents are to be decided in the trial.
[29]
The next and ultimate step is to examine whether there are
materials produced by the prosecution for constituting the offences under
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 35
Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) of ND&PS Act and Section 468 IPC against the
accused persons or not.
[30]
Section 22(c) of ND&PS Act deals with manufacturing,
possession, selling, purchase, transportation, import & export of illegal drugs
in commercial quantity. In context of the present case, it is a case of
possession and transportation of illegal drugs. The drugs were seized from
the vehicle driven by the accused No.1. Section 29 of the Act explains the
abetment of and conspiracy for committing any offence under the Act. From
the statements of the witnesses and as disclosed during the investigation,
the accused No.3 & 4 helped the accused No.1 in shifting the seized drugs
from Bolero vehicle coming from Moreh to the Tata DI vehicle seized by the
police. Accused No.2, the alleged kingpin of the syndicate of trans border
drug trafficking, had closed connections with the other accused persons.
Accused Nos. 1, 5, 6, & 2 were also part of the cartel and they stayed in
Phou-Oi-Bee Hotel at Imphal from 21 to 22 April 2019 for preparation and
transportation of the drugs. There were many monetary transactions
amongst the accused persons as reflected in the bank statements filed by
the prosecution. Accused No.2 used the mobile phone number of the
accused No.9 for preparation of a fake Aadhar card for himself in the name
of one fictious person, namely Md. Abdul Manal of Thoubal Phoudel. As per
the police report, there were three transportations of the narcotic drugs by
this cartel prior to the present incident and all the accused persons had
closely been coordinating among themselves for smooth transportation of
the contrabands. Since the carrying of the narcotic substances in the seized
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 36
Tata DI vehicle was with the knowledge and participation of the accused
No.1, the ingredients of Section 60(3) of the Act would also be attracted.
[31]
This Court does not find any merit in the submission of Mr. S.
Jhaljit, learned counsel for the respondent/accused No.9 that he could not
be tried together with the other accused as his arrest was not related with
ND&PS case and no narcotic substance was seized from him. From the
police report, it is clear that accused No.9’s mobile number was used to apply
for a fake Aadhar card for the accused No.2 under a fictitious name. The
ingredients of Section 468 IPC are present. In exercising the power
conferred under Section 36-A(2) of the ND&PS Act read with Section 29 of
the Act, the Special Court has jurisdiction to conduct trial against the accused
No.9 for the offence under Section 468 IPC read with Section 29 ND&PS Act
along with other co-accused.
[32]
From the discussions made at para 30 & 31 above, it is evident
that the ingredients for the offences under Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) of ND&PS
Act and Section 468 IPC are made out against the accused persons who are
respondents herein. The applicability of the mandatory provisions and
admissibility of the materials relied by the prosecution are to be decided
during the trial and such factual aspects cannot be presumed by the court in
a charge hearing proceeding. Accordingly, the impugned order dated
20.01.2021 passed by the learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Thoubal in Spl.
T. Case No. 12 of 2020 discharging the accused persons is hereby set aside
with a direction to proceed with the trial, after framing charges under
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 37
Sections 22(c)/29/60(3) ND&PS Act and Section 468 IPC against the
accused persons.
[33]
It is made clear that this Court does not express any opinion on
the merits of the case including the applicability of Sections 41, 42, 43, 50 &
52A of ND&PS Act, except for deciding the revision petition and the trial
Court shall not be influenced by any of the observations made by this Court
on these points.
[34]
With these observations and directions, the revision petition is
allowed and misc. applications, if any, are also disposed of accordingly. No
cost.
[35]
Send a copy of this judgment/order to the learned Special
Judge (ND&PS), Thoubal for information and proceeding further as directed.
[36]
Send another copy of this judgment/order to the Secretary
General of the Hon’ble Supreme Court for placing the same in the file of SLP
(Crl.) No. 1536 of 2024 for kind information.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Kh. Joshua Maring
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
Digitally signed
by KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2024.06.03
11:56:43 +05'30'
Cril. Revision Petition No. 10 of 2021
Page 38
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review