Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 11TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
WRIT APPEAL NO. 2128 OF 2025 (KLR-LG)
BETWEEN:
Digitally signed
by MALA K N
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
Digitally
signed by
MALA K N
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
VIKASA SOUDHA, DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BENGALURU -560 001.
2.
THE SPECIAL DEPUTY
COMMISSIONER,
BENGALURU NORTH DISTRICT,
BEHIND KANDAYA BHAVAN, K.G. ROAD,
BENGALURU -560 009.
3.
THE TAHSILDAR,
BENGALURU EAST TALUK,
K.R.PURAM, DOORAVANINAGAR,
BENGALURU-560 036.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. B.RAVINDRANATH, AGA)
AND:
1.
SRI.N VISHWANATH,
S/O NARAPPA,
AGED 54 YEARS,
RESIDING AT NO.256,
BAJANE MANDIRA ROAD,
RAMPURA VILLAGE,
BIDARAHALLI HOBLI,
BENGALURU EAST -560 049.
-2-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
2.
SRI. N.VENKATESH,
S/O NARAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
RESIDING AT NO.256, BAJANE MANDIRA ROAD,
RAMPURA VILLAGE, BIDARAHALLI HOBLI,
BENGALURU EAST -560 049.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.S.R.KAMALCHARAN, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI.PRADEEP S. SAWKAR, ADVOCATE FOR R1 & R2)
THIS WRIT APPEAL FILED U/S 4 OF THE KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT ACT PRAYING TO A) SET ASIDE THE ORDER
DATED 11/06/2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE
IN WP NO.19987/2023 AND B)CONSEQUENTLY DISMISS THE
WRIT PETITION NO.19987/2023 FILED BY THE RESPONDENT
AND C)GRANT SUCH OTHER RELIEFS.
THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
ORDERS
ON
25.08.2026
AND
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE
H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN MADE THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
This intra-court appeal has been filed impugning the
Order dated 11.06.2025 passed by the learned Single
Judge
in
W.P.No.19987/2023
(KLR-LG)
whereby
the
learned Single Judge quashed the order dated 12.01.2021
passed by respondent No.2 in RRT(2)(E)CR.24/2015-16.
-3-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as per their status before the learned Single
Judge.
3.
Facts in a nutshell for adjudication of this
appeal are that the petitioners claim to be the owners and
in possession of the subject land forming part of Sy.No.34
of Kada Agrahara Village, Bidarahalli Hobli, Hoskote Taluk.
The
land
was
Smt.Kamalamma
certificates
originally
and
dated
granted
in
Smt.Nanjamma
14.12.1961
favour
under
and
of
grant
11.06.1962
respectively. Thereafter, the original grantees alienated
the
said
lands
19.02.1963
under
and
registered
29.09.1965
sale
and
the
deeds
dated
petitioners’
grandfather, Sri.Lakshmaiah, subsequently purchased the
entire extent of 40 acres in Sy.No.34 under a registered
sale
deed
dated
12.09.1967.
After
his
death,
the
petitioners and other family members partitioned the
property
under
a
registered
partition
deed
dated
31.03.2005, pursuant to which the revenue records were
mutated in their names.
Thereafter they continued in
-4-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
possession of the property and paid property taxes.
However, after several decades, the second respondent
initiated proceedings in RRT(2)(E)CR.24/2015-16 and by
order dated 12.01.2021, cancelled the original grants in
favour
of
Nanjamma
and
Kamalamma
and
ordered
resumption of the land by the Government. The petitioners
contend that the impugned order was passed despite their
long-standing possession and the registered documents
under which their predecessor had acquired the property.
4.
The principal grievance of the petitioners is that
the impugned order is arbitrary, illegal and violative of the
principles of natural justice. According to them, though
petitioner
No.1
appeared
through
counsel
and
filed
objections, the matter was thereafter reserved for orders
and without affording a proper and effective opportunity of
hearing
to
proceeded
the
to
petitioners,
pass
the
the
order
second
dated
respondent
12.01.2021
in
RRT(2)(E)CR.24/2015-16. It is further contended that the
second respondent was not justified in cancelling a grant
made nearly six decades earlier, particularly when the
-5-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
petitioners and their predecessors had been in possession
on
the
strength
corresponding
of
revenue
registered
entries.
The
documents
and
petitioners
also
dispute the finding that the grant documents were bogus
or fabricated. They contend that the alleged Official
Memorandum dated 12.06.1962 could not have been held
to be fabricated merely on the basis of the discrepancies
noticed by the authority, especially when the petitioners
had produced the original grant certificates, mutation
records, RTC extracts and registered sale deeds. They,
therefore, sought quashing of the order dated 12.01.2021
on the ground of non-application of mind, violation of
principles of natural justice, lack of jurisdiction and the
arbitrary exercise of power after an inordinate lapse of
time.
5.
The petitioners, accordingly, approached this
Court by filing W.P.No.19987/2023 under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India, seeking quashing of the
said order. The petitioners contended that the grant had
been made in the years 1961-62, that the property had
-6-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
thereafter been dealt with under registered sale deeds and
had ultimately come to the petitioners’ predecessor under
a registered sale deed dated 12.09.1967, followed by a
registered partition deed dated 31.03.2005. They further
contended that the revenue records continued in their
names and that the proceedings initiated by the second
respondent after several decades were impermissible,
apart from being in violation of the principles of natural
justice.
6.
rival
The learned Single Judge, after considering the
submissions
and
the
records,
allowed
W.P.No.19987/2023 by order dated 11.06.2025. The
learned
Single
proceedings
had
Judge
observed
that
the
impugned
been
initiated
suo
motu
after
an
inordinate lapse of about five decades from the date of the
original grant and held that the exercise of such revisional
power after an unreasonable and unexplained delay could
not be sustained. Relying upon the principles laid down in
the
decisions
concerning
exercise
of
quasi-
judicial/revisional powers within a reasonable period, the
-7-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
learned Single Judge held that delay and laches in
initiating the proceedings vitiated the impugned order.
Consequently, the writ petition was allowed and the order
dated
12.01.2021
respondent/Special
passed
by
the
second
Deputy
Commissioner
in
RRT(2)(E)CR.24/2015-16 was quashed.
7.
Aggrieved by the order passed by the learned
Single Judge, the State has preferred the present intracourt appeal.
8.
The
respondents–State
contend
that
the
learned Single Judge erred in allowing W.P.No.19987/2023
by proceeding on the premise that the proceedings
initiated by the second respondent were under Section
136(3) of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 (‘the
Act’), whereas the proceedings were in fact initiated under
Section 67(2) read with Section 136(3) of the Act.
8.1.
It is further contended that the learned Single
Judge ought to have appreciated that the dispute raised by
the petitioners involves serious questions concerning to
-8-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
the genuineness and validity of the grant certificates and
the title claimed by them, which are matters requiring
adjudication
before
the
competent
Civil
Court.
The
respondents further contend that the petitioners relied
upon the alleged grant certificates dated 14.12.1961 and
11.06.1962
in
favour
of
Smt.Kamalamma
and
Smt.Nanjamma respectively. It is the emphatic assertion
of the State that they were forged and fabricated and that
there were no corresponding entries relating to such
grants in the revenue records.
8.2. It is further urged by the respondents that the
learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the specific
finding recorded by the second respondent regarding the
absence
of
corresponding
revenue
entries
and
the
circumstances indicating that the alleged grant certificates
were subsequently created. The respondents would submit
that fraud and fabrication vitiate all proceedings and that
no right or title can be claimed on the basis of fraudulent
or
fabricated
documents.
The
learned
Single
Judge,
according to the respondents, ought not to have exercised
-9-
WA No. 2128 of 2025
the writ jurisdiction to adjudicate disputed questions of
fact relating to the validity of the grant and the title
claimed by the petitioners. It is, therefore, contended that
the impugned order dated 11.06.2025, whereby the order
dated 12.01.2021 passed by the second respondent in
RRT(2)(E)CR.24/2015-16 was quashed on the ground of
delay and laches, is unsustainable in law and on facts, and
is liable to be set aside.
9.
We
Government
have
heard
Advocate
the
for
learned
the
Additional
State
and
Sri.S.R.Kamalcharan, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners and perused the material available on record.
10.
Now
the
question
that
arises
for
our
consideration is,
“Weather the order of learned Single Judge
warrants interference in this intra-court appeal?*
11.
On a careful consideration of the material on
record, we are unable to sustain the view taken by the
learned Single Judge. The Special Deputy Commissioner,
- 10 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
while
passing
the
order
RRT(2)(E)CR.24/2015-16,
dated
has
12.01.2021
noticed
a
in
material
inconsistency between the Official Memorandum dated
12.06.1962 and the alleged grant certificates relied upon
by the petitioners. The grant certificates are stated to be
dated 14.12.1961 and 11.06.1962, whereas the Official
Memorandum, which is stated to be the basis for the grant
proceedings, was issued subsequently in point of time.
This chronological inconsistency goes to the very root of
the claim of grant.
12.
The significance of the discrepancy cannot be
brushed aside as a mere irregularity. If the Official
Memorandum dated 12.06.1962 is the document pursuant
to which the grant came to be made, there could not
ordinarily have been a grant certificate evidencing such
grant prior to the very memorandum on which the grant is
said to be founded. In other words, a grant certificate
dated 14.12.1961 cannot logically precede the Official
Memorandum dated 12.06.1962, if the latter is the
foundational
document
for
the
grant.
This
inherent
- 11 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
inconsistency casts a serious doubt on the genuineness
and provenance of the grant certificates and lends support
to
the
finding
recorded
by
the
Special
Deputy
Commissioner that the documents relied upon by the
petitioners could not be accepted at their face value.
13.
The subsequent sale deeds, mutation entries
and other revenue records cannot, by themselves, cure a
defect in the very source of title. The petitioners’ claim
traces back to the alleged original grants, and therefore,
when the genuineness of those grants is itself seriously
impeached by the documentary record, the subsequent
transactions cannot confer a better title than what the
original
grantees
possessed.
The
Special
Deputy
Commissioner has considered these aspects and recorded
findings on the basis of the material available before him.
We find no perversity or patent illegality in such findings
warranting interference in writ jurisdiction.
14.
The chronology of the documents assumes
considerable significance. The alleged grant certificate in
- 12 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
favour of Kamalamma is dated 14.12.1961, whereas the
Official Memorandum relied upon in support of the grant is
dated 12.06.1962. If the latter document constitutes the
sanction or foundational proceeding pursuant to which the
grant was made, the existence of a grant certificate dated
nearly
six
months
prior
thereto
becomes
inherently
inconsistent with the very basis of the alleged grant. Such
inconsistency
cannot
be
brushed
aside
as
a
mere
irregularity, particularly when the State has disputed the
genuineness
of
the
grant
corresponding
contemporaneous
documents
and
the
revenue
records
are
absent. The Special Deputy Commissioner was, therefore,
justified in examining the provenance of the documents
and in concluding that the alleged grant could not be
accepted merely on the strength of subsequent revenue
entries and transactions.
15.
At this juncture, it is relevant to refer to the
following judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for
the petitioners:
- 13 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
(i)
Joint
Collector
Ranga
Reddy
District
and
Another –vs- D.Narsing Rao and Others1;
(II) Shyamo Devi and Others –vs- State of U.P.
through Secretary and Others2.
16.
The judgment relied on in D.Narasing Rao’s
case (supra) does not, in our considered view, assist the
petitioners. The said judgment was rendered in the
peculiar facts of that case, where the revenue entries had
remained undisturbed for nearly five decades and the
authorities, despite having knowledge and opportunity to
examine the same, sought to exercise their suo motu
revisional power after an inordinate delay. The Supreme
Court, in that background, held that such belated exercise
of power was not permissible.
17.
The present case stands on a different footing.
Here, the Special Deputy Commissioner has not sought to
reopen the matter merely because of a change of opinion
with regard to an old revenue entry. The very grant
(2015) 3 SCC 695
2024 SCC OnLine SC 966
- 14 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
certificates relied upon by the petitioners are themselves
under serious doubt. In particular, there is a material
inconsistency between the alleged grant certificates and
the Official Memorandum dated 12.06.1962, which is
relied upon in support of the grant. If the Official
Memorandum
is
the
foundation
for
the
grant,
the
existence
a
grant
certificate
preceding
the
said
of
memorandum raises a serious and unexplained doubt as
to
the
genuineness
and
origin
of
the
entire
grant
certificates. Such a circumstance was not before the
Supreme Court in D.Narsing Rao’s case (supra).
18.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Shyamo Devi (supra) has held that where a statute
confers suo motu revisional power without prescribing any
specific period of limitation, such power has to be
exercised within a reasonable period, having regard to the
facts and circumstances of each case.
19.
In the present case, the proceedings cannot be
viewed as a mere attempt to reopen a decades-old
- 15 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
revenue entry on account of a change of opinion. The very
grant certificates relied upon by the petitioners are under
serious doubt. There is a material and unexplained
inconsistency between the alleged grant certificates and
the Official Memorandum dated 12.06.1962, which is
relied upon as the basis for the grant. In particular, the
alleged grant certificate dated 14.12.1961 is anterior to
the said Official Memorandum. If the Official Memorandum
is the foundation for the grant, the existence of a grant
certificate even prior thereto raises a serious question
regarding the genuineness and provenance of the grant
documents themselves. In such circumstances, the Special
Deputy Commissioner was justified in examining the
validity of the grant and in passing the order dated
12.01.2021.
20.
The principle that fraud vitiates all solemn acts,
as recognized by the Supreme Court in A.V. Papayya
Sastry v. Government of A.P.3, assumes significance in
(2007) 4 SCC 221
- 16 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
such circumstances.
The relevant portion is extracted
hereinbelow:
“Now, it is well settled principle of law that if
any judgment or order is obtained by fraud, it cannot
be said to be a judgment or order in law. Before
three
centuries,
Chief
Justice
Edward
Coke
proclaimed;
"Fraud avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or
temporal".
It is thus settled proposition of law that a
judgment, decree or order obtained by playing fraud
on the Court, Tribunal or Authority is a nullity and
non est in the eye of law. Such a judgment, decree
or order by the first Court or by the final Court has to
be treated as nullity by every Court, superior or
inferior. It can be challenged in any Court, at any
time, in appeal, revision, writ or even in collateral
proceedings. In the leading case of Lazarus Estates
Ltd. v. Beasley, (1956) 1 All ER 341 : (1956) 1 QB
702 : (1956) 2 WLR 502, Lord Denning observed:
"No judgment of a court, no order of a
Minister, can be allowed to stand, if it has been
obtained by fraud."
- 17 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
21.
different
This Court, speaking through one of us in a
combination,
in
State
of
Karnataka
-vs-
Sri.L.N.Govindaswamy4 and in Sri.V.Sreenivasaiah vs- State of Karnataka5 has reiterated the settled
principle that " Fraud avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical
or temporal". In doing so, this Court has followed the law
laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in A.V.Papayya
Sastry (supra) wherein it has been held that fraud
practised upon the Court strikes at the very foundation of
the judicial process and vitiates the proceedings. An order
or decree obtained by playing fraud upon the Court,
therefore, cannot be permitted to stand, for once fraud is
established, the very foundation on which the order rests
is destroyed and the resultant order loses its logical
sanctity.
22.
In the circumstances, the learned Single Judge
was not justified in setting aside the order of the Special
Deputy Commissioner merely by placing emphasis on the
lapse of time.
W.A.No.1333/2025 (KLR-RES)
W.A.No.791/2025 (LA-RES)
- 18 -
WA No. 2128 of 2025
The
inconsistency
Memorandum
and
the
between
grant
the
Official
certificates
is
a
substantive circumstance, which goes to the root of
the alleged grant and the passage of time cannot
legitimize a document whose very origin is doubtful.
We are, therefore, of the considered view that the
order
dated
12.01.2021
passed
by
the
Special
Deputy Commissioner in RRT(2)(E)CR.24/2015-16
deserves to be upheld.
Consequently, the order dated 11.06.2025 passed by
the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.19987/2023 is set
aside and the writ petition stands dismissed.
Resultantly, the Writ Appeal is allowed.
Sd/(D K SINGH)
JUDGE
Sd/(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE
KNM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review