Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.100249 OF 2020 (A)
C/W CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100060 OF 2020
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100084 OF 2020 AND
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100087 OF 2020
IN CRL.A NO. 100249/2020
BETWEEN:
VIJAYALAKSHMI
M KANKUPPI
VIJAYALAKSHMI M
KANKUPPI
Date: 2026.02.03
10:18:03 +0530
STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY THE
CIRCLE POLICE INSPECTOR,
BAGALKOT TOWN POLICE STATION,
DIST. BAGALKOT,
THROUGH THE ADDL. STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
ADVOCATE GENERAL OFFICE,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH.
&APPELLANT
(BY SRI. M.B. GUNDAWADE, ADDL. SPP)
AND:
1.
BASAVARAJ S/O. BAIREGOUDA ALAGUNDI,
AGE: 31 YEARS,
OCC. LAB TECHNICIAN,
2.
BASAVARAJ S/O. SHANKARAPPA HULLUR,
AGE: 27 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
3.
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
CHANNABASAPPA S/O. BASAPPA TOTAD,
AGE: 23 YEARS, OCC. CAR DRIVER,
ALL ARE R/O. NANDAKESHWAR,
BADAMI TALUK-587201.
&RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S.S. YADRAMI, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. S.C. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. SHIVANAND MALASHETTY, ADVOCATE AND
SRI. H. N. GULARADDI, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SRI. SANTOSH MALAGOUDAR, ADVOCATE FOR R3)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 378(1) AND
(3) OF CR.P.C., PRAYING TO GRANT LEAVE TO APPEAL AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER DATED 24/01/2020 PASSED BY THE II
ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BAGALKOTE IN
S.C.NO.19/2013 SO FAR IT RELATES TO ACQUITTAL OF
RESPONDENTS / ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTION 364(A) R/W SECTION 34 OF IPC (NOT CONVICTING UNDER
SECTION 364(A) R/W SECTION 34 OF IPC AND SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF CONVICTION FOR LESSER OFFENCE
DATED 24/01/2020 PASSED BY THE II ADDL. DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE, BAGALKOTE IN S.C.NO.19/2013 AND CONVICT
AND SENTENCE THE RESPONDENTS / ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCES
PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 364(A) R/W SECTION 34 OF IPC, IN
THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
IN CRL.A NO. 100060/2020
BETWEEN:
BASAVARAJ S/O. BAIREGOUDA ALAGUNDI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC. LAB TECHNICIAN,
R/O. NANDIKESHWAR, TAL. BADAMI,
DIST. BAGALKOTE, PIN: 587201.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S.S. YADRAMI, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. S.C. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
(BAGALKOTE TOWN POLICE STATION)
REPRESENTED BY THE STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS, DHARWAD.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. M.B. GUNDAWADE, ADDL. SPP)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374 (2) OF
CR.P.C., PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF
CONVICTION PASSED BY THE II ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS
JUDGE, BAGALKOTE FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTION 363 R/W SECTION 34 OF IPC AND SENTENCING HIM TO
UNDERGO RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT FOR 3 YEARS AND ALSO PAY
THE FINE OF RS.5,000-00 IN S.C.NO.19/2013 AND ACQUIT THE
APPELLANT / ACCUSED NO.1 FOR OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTION 363 R/W SECTION 34 OF IPC, IN THE INTERST OF JUSTICE.
IN CRL.A NO. 100084/2020
BETWEEN:
BASAVARAJ S/O. SHANKARAPPA HULLUR,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. NANDKESHWAR, TQ. BADAMI,
DIST. BAGALKOTE.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SHIVANAND MALASHETTY, ADVOCATE AND
SRI. H.N. GULARADDI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD,
THROUGH BAGALKOTE TOWN POLICE STATION,
TQ AND DIST: BAGALKOTE-587103.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. M.B. GUNDAWADE, ADDL. SPP)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374 (2) OF
CR.P.C., PRAYING TO CALL FOR RECORDS IN S.C. NO.19/2013 ON
THE FILE OF II ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSION JUDGE
BAGALKOTE AND ALLOW THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL BY SETTING ASIDE
THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF CONVICTION DATED 24.01.2020
PASSED BY THE II ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSION JUDGE
BAGALKOTE IN S.C. NO.19/2013 IN OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTION 363 R/W SECTION 34 IPC, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
AND EQUITY, IN SO FAR AS (A2) IS CONCERNED.
IN CRL.A NO. 100087/2020
BETWEEN:
SRI.CHANNABASAPPA S/O. BASAPPA TOTAD,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC. DRIVER,
R/O. NANDKESHWAR, TQ. BADAMI,
DIST. BAGALKOTE.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SANTOSH B. MALAGOUDAR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH PSI, BAGALKOTE TOWN POLICE STATION,
REPRESENTED BY ADDL. STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
SPP OFFICE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. M.B. GUNDAWADE, ADDL SPP)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374 (2) OF
CR.P.C., PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT OF
CONVICTION AND ORDER OF SENTENCE DATED 24/01/2020 PASSED
BY COURT OF II ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
BAGALKOTE IN SESSIONS CASE NO.19/2013, BY ALLOWING THIS
APPEAL, CONSEQUENTLY ACQUIT THE APPELLANT / ACCUSED NO.3
FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTIONS 363 R/W 34 OF
IPC LEVELED AGAINST HIM IN ABOVE MENTIONED CASE IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY, IN SO FAR AS APPELLANT IS
CONCERNED.
THESE CRIMINAL APPEALS COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
1.
These appeals arise out of the judgment and order
dated 24.01.2020 passed by the Court of II Additional District
and Sessions Judge, Bagalkot, in SC No.19/2013.
2.
Vide impugned judgment, the learned Sessions
Judge has held accused Nos.1 to 3 guilty of the offence
punishable under Section 363 read with Section 34 of the
Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred to as 8the IPC9, for
short) as against the charge framed against them under
Section 364A of IPC. For the convicted offence, the accused
have been sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 3
years and to pay a fine of ¹5,000/- each, in default of payment
of fine, to further undergo simple imprisonment for 6 months.
3.
Challenging the judgment and order of conviction
and sentence, accused No. 1 has preferred Criminal Appeal
No.100060/2020, accused No.2 has preferred Criminal Appeal
No.100084/2020 and accused No.3 has preferred Criminal
Appeal No. 100087/2020.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
4.
in
not
Feeling aggrieved by the judgment of the trial Court
convicting
the
accused
for
the
charged
offence
punishable under Section 364A of IPC, the State has preferred
Criminal Appeal No.100249 of 2020.
5.
We have heard the arguments of the learned senior
counsel
Sri. S.S. Yadrami appearing for the learned counsel
Sri. S.C. Hiremath for accused No.1, learned counsel Sri.
Shivanand Malashetty appearing for the learned counsel Sri.
H.N.Gularaddi for accused No.2, the learned counsel Sri.
Santosh Malagoudar appearing for accused No.3 and the
learned Additional SPP Sri. M.B. Gundawade appearing for the
State. Perused the evidence and material on record.
6.
It is the case of prosecution that on 24.12.2012 at
about 16.10 hours, within the limits of Bagalkot Town Police
Station, near Lions School, in furtherance of the common
intention, accused No.1 to 3 kidnapped CW.6- Aravind (PW.4)
aged
about
years,
in
a
car
bearing
registration
No.KA.34/MD.1231 and demanded a ransom of ¹25,00,000/from PW.3-Shivakumar Murigeppa Dandin, father of the child,
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
for his release and thereby committed an offence punishable
under Section 364A read with Section 34 of IPC.
7.
The law was set into motion by PW.1-Suresh
Sangappa Revadigar. A perusal of the complaint-Ex.P.1 reveals
that the victim was studying in third standard at Basaveswara
International Public School, Vidyagiri, Bagalkot. As usual, on
24.12.2012 at about 08.30 a.m., he left for school in the school
bus, but did not return at 04.00 p.m. Even at 05.00 p.m., when
he did not return home, his father Dr. Shivakumar Murigeppa
Dandin (PW.3) made a phone call to the school and came to
know that his son had already left the school. At about 05.30
p.m., his wife Dr.Archana (CW.5) received a phone call to her
mobile phone bearing number 9448960186 from telephone
number 08351-285405. The person who had called, asked her
to hand over the phone to her husband i.e. PW.3. When the
phone was handed over to PW.3, the person who called, told
PW.3 that they have kidnapped his son and demanded a
ransom
of
¹25,00,000/-
for
his
release,
failing
which,
threatened to kill the boy. They also informed that they would
call at about 07.00 p.m. When no further call was received at
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
07.00 p.m., PW.3 and others got panic and enquired with
another student by name Nisarga Kiran Kanthi (PW.5), who
was also travelling in the same bus. On enquiry, he informed
them that at about 04.10 p.m., the victim boy i.e. Aravinda had
got down from the bus and while alighting from the bus, a
silver colour Indica car with writing <Appaji= on its rear came
and the inmates of the said car took the victim in the said car.
Hence, complaint was lodged with the police.
8.
PW11-PSI of Bagalkote Town Police Station has
deposed in his evidence that on 24.12.2012 at about 09.15
p.m., PW.1 visited the police station and lodged a complaint as
per Ex.P.1, based on which he registered a case and forwarded
the FIR-Ex.P.6 to the jurisdictional Magistrate and then handed
over the investigation to the CPI-PW.10.
9.
PW.10
after
taking
over
the
investigation,
instructed the PSI to send wireless intimation, to collect
information about the kidnappers. PW.9, CPI of Kustagi Police
Station has deposed that on receiving the information from the
control room about the kidnap, he passed on the information to
the SHO of his police station and other police officials. He has
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
further deposed that while his staff were patrolling, at about
09.50 p.m., they noticed a Tata Indica car bearing registration
number KA.34/MD.1231 with the writing <Appaji= on its back
and also found the victim and the three accused in the said car.
Thereafter, the car as well as the accused were brought to the
police station and the matter was informed to PW.10 who came
to Kustagi police station and seized the said car (MO.5) as well
as 2 mobile phones (MO.1 and MO.2), a purse with cash of
¹2,700/- (MO.3) and a driving licence (MO.4) from the
accused, under mahazar-Exhibit P2. PW.10 continued the
investigation, recorded the statements of witnesses, conducted
mahazar at place from where the victim was kidnapped, the
telephone booth from where the accused made the ransom call
to PW.3 etc. On completion of investigation, charge sheet was
filed against the accused.
10.
In order to establish the guilt of the accused, the
prosecution in all examined 11 witnesses and got marked 6
documents as Ex.P-1 to P-6 and M.Os.1 to 5. On behalf of the
defence,
Exs.D1
and
D2
were
marked(portions
of
the
statements of PW.3 and PW.5 given before the IO). However,
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
the accused did not lead any evidence on their behalf. While
recording the 313 Cr.P.C. statement, accused No.1 filed written
statement stating that he was earlier working under PW.3 in his
hospital from 2006 and he left the job in the month of
September 2012 as he was not paid the salary for 6 months
and
whenever
he
demanded
the
salary,
he
was
being
threatened. Further stated that he went near the hospital of
PW.3 along with accused Nos.2 and 3, 2-3 times to demand
salary, hence, a false case was registered against him.
11.
The learned senior counsel Sri. S.S. Yadrami has
vehemently contended that the prosecution has utterly failed to
establish the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt and
in spite of that, the trial Court has erroneously convicted them
for the offence punishable under Section 363 of IPC. The
learned senior counsel contended that, when the charge under
Section 364A of IPC was not established, the trial Court was
not
justified
in
convicting
the
accused
for
the
offence
punishable under Section 363 of IPC. The contention of the
learned senior counsel is that, as per prosecution, initially, the
ransom call was received by CW.5-Archana, wife of PW.3 and
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
she being a material witness, has not been examined, which
throws a serious doubt on the genuineness of the prosecution
case regarding the ransom call made by the accused. He
contended that when PW3, father of the victim was very much
available and present in the house and having gone to the
police station, complaint was not lodged by him, on the other
hand, complaint was lodged by PW.1, admittedly an advocate.
He therefore contended that the complaint is on account of
deliberation, implicating accused No.1 as the prime accused as
he was demanding the salary due to him from PW.3.
12.
The learned senior counsel further contended that
PW.4 is aged only 9 years and being a child witness, he has
been tutored by PW.3 and other witnesses to give false
evidence. He contended that his evidence is not corroborated
by any other independent witnesses and the evidence of PW.5
does not inspire confidence of the court and a perusal of his
deposition does not show that he has seen any of the accused
kidnapping the victim or identifying them.
13.
The learned senior counsel further contented that
according to prosecution, the victim child was kidnapped while
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
returning to his house from school, whereas, the Investigating
Officer has not seized the school bag, tiffin box etc. Hence, the
entire prosecution case is doubtful. He contended that the
records of the wireless messages are not collected or placed by
the prosecution and even PW.9, namely the CPI of Kustagi
Police
Station
has
not
prepared
any
mahazar
while
apprehending the accused or seizing the car along with the
accused and the child. He contended that the station house
diary of Kustagi Police Station has not been placed on record to
show that in fact the Police attached to the said police station
have found the accused and the child together and they
brought them along with the car to the police station.
14.
The learned senior counsel has also contended that,
to establish the guilt of the accused for the charged offence
under Section 364A of IPC, the prosecution has not placed the
call detail records and not established as to who made the
ransom call. Reiterating the arguments, he contended that only
on account of admitted enmity with accused No.1, who was
demanding salary from PW.3, he has been falsely implicated in
this case along with the other accused.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
15.
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
The learned counsel appearing for accused No.2
and 3 have contended that insofar as the said accused there is
not an iota of evidence placed on record by the prosecution.
The said accused have no motive to commit any offence much
less the one alleged against them. Neither the victim boy or
other witnesses have identified the said accused as the one
who have either kidnapped the victim or were along with
accused No.1 at the time of incident. They contended that
according to prosecution, one of the accused made a ransom
call from the telephone booth of PW.8 and the accused went to
the petrol bunk wherein, PW.7 filled diesel to the car, but no
test identification parade was conducted so as to identify the
accused as the one who were in the car. Therefore, they
contended that the entire approach of the trial Court in
convicting accused Nos.2 and 3 is not only erroneous but also
perverse, which resulted in miscarriage of justice.
16.
The learned Additional SPP contented that the
charge is framed under Section 364A of IPC, whereas the trial
Court has convicted the accused for a lesser offence under
Section 363 IPC, in spite of there being sufficient evidence on
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
record to convict the accused for the charged offence.
He
contended that PW.3 has clearly deposed in his evidence that
the
accused
have
made
a
ransom
call
and
demanded
¹25,00,000/- for release of his son and the said evidence does
not
suffer
from
any
infirmity.
He
contended
that
non-
examination of CW.5, wife of PW.3, is not fatal to the
prosecution,
as, the demand of ransom was made by the
accused to
PW.3 and not CW.5. He contended that even
according to the defence, accused No.1 was working in the
hospital of PW.3 and he had left the job 6 months prior to the
incident in question and therefore, he was nurturing ill-will
against the family of PW.3. He, therefore, contended that, with
that motive, accused No.1 along with accused Nos.2 and 3
kidnapped the victim and made a ransom call to PW3. He
further contented that, the prosecution has got marked Ex.P.5
to show that the accused have made a call from the telephone
booth of PW.8 and the said witness has deposed about a person
coming to his telephone booth and making a call at the relevant
point of time. He further contended that the evidence of PW.7
would reveal that, on the relevant day, 3 accused had come to
Nidagundi petrol bunk, where he was working and filled diesel
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
to the car and he has identified the said three accused who
were present in the Court as the one who came in the car and
he has mentioned the registration number of the car.
17.
Learned Additional SPP further contended that
PW.4, the victim boy being the prime witness in this case, has
supported the case of prosecution and he has identified all the
three accused in the Court. In Ex.P1 itself it is stated that the
accused who kidnapped the child made a ransom call of
¹25,00,000/- which averment is corroborated by the evidence
of PW.1 as well as PW.3. Hence, he contended that the trial
Court ought to have convicted the accused for the charged
offence under Section 364A of IPC.
18.
It is the specific case of the prosecution that the
victim child was aged about 9 years and he was studying in
third standard at one Basaveshwara International School
situated at Vidyagiri, Bagalkot. He used to go to school by bus
in the morning and return at about 04.00 p.m. in the evening.
On the relevant day i.e., on 24.12.2012 as usual at around
08.30 a.m. he left for school, but did not return at 04.00 p.m. A
call was received by PW.3-father of the victim stating that his
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
son was kidnapped and the person who made the call
demanded a ransom of ¹25,00,000/- to release him.
19.
The learned counsel appearing for the accused tried
to contend that the prosecution has not placed any material to
show that the child was in fact studying in the school and on
the relevant day, he had gone to the school. The said
contention cannot be accepted as PW.1, PW.3 and PW.5 apart
from the victim-PW.4, have categorically deposed about the
said fact and there is nothing elicited from their crossexamination, to deny it.
Victim has clearly deposed that he
was pursuing his studies in Basaveshwara International School
and he was studying in the third standard. The same has not
been denied by the defence and even otherwise the material on
record placed by the prosecution in the form of oral evidence is
sufficient to hold that the victim child was in fact studying and
on the relevant day, he went to the school in the morning as
usual, but did not return in the evening at the usual time. The
cross-examination conducted to PW.4, the victim, to the effect
that he has not attended the school on the relevant day has
been categorically denied by the said witness.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
20.
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
According to the prosecution, at about 05.30 p.m.
in the evening, a call was received by CW.5-Dr.Archana,
mother of the victim, on her mobile phone from a number08351-285405. It is contended by the learned counsel for the
accused that the said Dr.Archana-CW.5 has not been examined
and therefore, the entire case of the prosecution is doubtful.
Firstly, it is not the case of the prosecution that the ransom
demand was made to CW.5, on the other hand as per Ex.P.1
after the phone was handed over to PW.3, the accused who
made the call, informed him about the kidnap of his son and
then demanded a ransom of ¹25,00,000/- for his release. Since
the accused had threatened PW.3 that the child would be killed,
if the ransom was not paid and since no call was received till
07.00 p.m., complaint was lodged. A perusal of Ex.P.1 goes to
show that, initially when the child did not return home even at
05.00 p.m., PW.3 made a call to the school enquiring about his
son and informed PW.1 i.e., the first informant about the
incident. The said PW.1 was very much present, when the call
was received. He has reiterated the complaint averments in his
evidence. It is stated that getting panic, they enquired about
the victim with another student by name Nisarga Kanti (PW.5),
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
who informed about the persons coming in a car and
kidnapping the victim. It is relevant to mention that in the
complaint itself it is stated that it was a silver colour Indica car
with a writing <Appaji= on its rear side.
21.
Even though motive for the kidnap has not been
mentioned in the complaint, as could be gathered from the
evidence adduced by the prosecution, it is clear that the motive
was attributed against accused No.1. It is the contention of the
defence that accused No.1 was earlier working under PW.3 in
his hospital and he was not paid salary for six months and since
he was demanding the salary, PW.3 has implicated in a false
case.
22.
From the evidence of PW.3, it can be seen that
accused was in fact working in his hospital earlier, but he was
removed from the job as his conduct was not satisfactory.
Though, PW.3 has denied that he had not paid the salary to the
accused, the material on record including the defence raised by
accused No.1 goes to show that all was not well between the
said accused and PW.3. Obviously, PW.3 or PW.1 were not
aware as to for what reason and by whom the child was
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
kidnapped, at the time of lodging the complaint. It is only after
the arrest of the accused, the motive was revealed. PW.3 in his
deposition has stated that accused No.1 was working as an
Assistant Laboratory Technician in his hospital and he had
worked for six years. About three months prior, since his
conduct was not good, he had removed him from the job.
Hence, insofar as accused No.1 is concerned, the prosecution
has been able to establish the motive for commission of the
offence.
23.
As could be seen from the evidence of PW.10-IO,
after registering the FIR, he flashed the news about the kidnap
through wireless messages to various police stations. PW.9
namely the C.P.I. of Kushtagi Police Station has deposed that
after receiving the wireless message, he instructed his staff to
trace the kidnappers and on the very same day i.e., on
24.12.2012 at about 09.50 p.m. while he and his staff were
searching for the culprits, they noticed the TATA Indica vehicle
bearing registration No.KA-34 MD-1231 parked at the auto
stand. They also noticed the child and three accused in the said
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
car. Immediately, they were taken to the police station and
then, he informed PW.10, the Investigation Officer in this case.
24.
A contention was raised by the defence that, at the
time of apprehending the accused at the auto stand and while
handing over them to PW.10-CPI of Bagalkot Police Station
along with the mobile phone, purse and cash, no mahazar was
conducted by PW.9 and therefore, the case of the prosecution
that the accused were found along with the boy in the car etc.,
is doubtful.
25.
It is relevant to mention that the case was
registered at Bagalkot Town police station and the investigation
was being conducted by PW.10. Hence, the question of drawing
a mahazar by PW.9 does not arise. Moreover, PW.9 has not
stated that he has seized the car, mobile phone, purse and
cash from the accused persons. On the other hand, he has
stated that he has handed over the accused along with the
articles and the car to PW.10. The mahazar, Ex.P2 under which
the above articles were seized was drawn by PW.10 in the
presence of panch witness, PW.2. PW.9 is a signatory to the
said mahazar.
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
HC-KAR
26.
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
It is also relevant to mention that the mobile
phones, purse or cash, which are seized from the accused, are
not material in this case. However, the car which was seized
under Ex.P2 is a crucial evidence. Though the registration
number of the car was not mentioned in Ex.P.1, it is stated that
the accused had taken the victim in a car with a writing
<Appaji= on the back side. A careful perusal of the evidence of
PW2, panch witness to Ex.P.2, shows that the silver colour
Indica car, which was seized in this case had a writing <Appaji=
on its back. This evidence of PW2, the panch witness finds
corroboration with the evidence of PW.5 who saw the victim
when he was being taken away in the said car. Even accepting
that PW.1 and PW.5 are related to PW.3, that itself is not a
ground to disbelieve the case of prosecution with regard to
kidnap of PW.4. Motive being a double-edged weapon, even
accepting the contention of the defence that PW.3 had not paid
six months salary to accused No.1, at the same time, this Court
can draw an inference that the said accused had a grouse
against PW.3 for not paying the salary and removing him from
the job.
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
27.
In this case, PW.4 being the victim child himself, is
a material witness. We have carefully perused the evidence of
PW.4.
From his evidence, it can be safely held that he was
kidnapped, when he was returning home, after alighting from
the bus. Further, from his evidence it can be gathered that he
was very well acquainted with accused No.1, as the said
accused was working under his father. PW.4 has stated in his
evidence that earlier accused No.1 used to take him for tuition
and to the bus stop etc., and he had gone with accused No.1 in
his vehicle many times. Hence, without raising any doubt he
accompanied accused No.1 in the car brought by him. PW.4 has
identified all the three accused who were present before the
court. The question that would arise is as to whether the
prosecution has established beyond reasonable doubt the
charges levelled against all the three accused either for the
offence under Sections 364A or 363 of IPC.
28.
To prove the charge under Section 364A IPC, the
prosecution has mainly relied on the testimony of PW.3 and
Ex.P5, apart from the evidence of PW.8. Further, to prove that
the accused after kidnap, have demanded ransom from PW.3,
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
the prosecution is mainly relying on the evidence of PW.1, PW.3
and PW.8. It is relevant to see that according to prosecution,
the accused made a phone call from the telephone booth
owned by PW.8. Except the oral evidence of PW.1 and PW.3,
there is no material placed on record that on the relevant day,
a call was made to the mobile phone of the wife of PW.3. To
show that a call was made from the telephone booth, the
prosecution examined PW.8, the owner of the said telephone
booth. Ex.P5 is the letter issued by the BSNL, which shows that
the telephone booth in respect of CCB PT 08351-285405 was
owned by the said PW.8. However, the call detail records
regarding call received to the mobile phone of CW.5, the wife of
PW.3 are not marked in evidence, to give an opportunity to the
defence to controvert the same. The relevant certificate is also
not produced and marked in that regard. PW.8 though stated
that one of the accused has made a call from his telephone
booth, he has not identified the said accused who made a call.
The evidence of the victim child is also not helpful to establish
the said charge.
Hence, the case of the prosecution that the
accused
a
made
ransom
call
of
Rs.25,00,000/-
is
not
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
established beyond reasonable doubt. In fact, the mobile phone
belonging to CW.5 was not at all seized in this case.
29.
The trial court while acquitting the accused for the
charged offence under Section 364A of IPC has taken into
consideration the above aspect. The trial Court has held that
there is no concrete evidence to believe the demand made by
the accused for ransom.
However, it is held that for non-
production of the said evidence, the entire case of the
prosecution cannot be brushed aside.
30.
The prosecution is placing reliance on the evidence
of PW.1, PW.3, PW.4, PW.5 and PW.7 to establish that the
accused has committed an offence of kidnap. As we have held
that the evidence is not sufficient to prove that the accused
have demanded a ransom of Rs.25,00,000/-, the evidence of
these witnesses are relevant to see as to whether the
prosecution has established the offence of kidnap.
31.
Section 361 of IPC reads as under:
<361.
Kidnapping
from
lawful
guardianship.4Whoever takes or entices any
minor under [sixteen] years of age if a male, or
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
under [eighteen] years of age if a female, or
any person of unsound mind, out of the keeping
of the lawful guardian of such minor or person
of unsound mind, without the consent of such
guardian, is said to kidnap such minor or person
from lawful guardianship.
32.
Section 363 of IPC reads as under:
<363. Punishment for kidnapping.4
Whoever kidnaps any person from [India] or
from lawful guardianship, shall be punished
with imprisonment of either description for a
term which may extend to seven years, and
shall also be liable to fine.=
with
33.
According to the prosecution, all the three accused
a
common
intention
kidnapped
the
victim/PW.4.
Admittedly, PW.1 and PW.3 are not the witnesses to the
kidnap. PW.5 is a student studying in the same school where
PW.4 was studying. According to the prosecution, he saw the
victim being taken away by the accused in the car. As per the
evidence of PW.5, he has seen some person talking to PW.4
before he was kidnapped. PW.5 has not identified any of the
accused. His evidence therefore, could be accepted to the fact
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
of kidnap of PW.4 in the car and not with regard to
identification of any of the accused.
34.
It is the contention of the learned Additional SPP
that PW.7, who was working in a petrol bunk has seen all the
three accused coming in the car to the petrol bunk where he
was working and filling diesel to the car. It is also contended by
him that all the three accused were apprehended together and
they were along with the boy in the car. Hence, he contended
that all the three accused shared a common intention to kidnap
the victim child.
35.
The prosecution has got examined PW6, owner of
the car in question. A perusal of his evidence goes to show that
his car was given to accused No.3 and at the relevant point of
time, the said accused was driving the car. In fact, the driving
licence of the said accused was seized under Ex.P2. However,
even accepting that accused No.2 and 3 were found along with
accused No.1 and the child in the car, without any convincing
or acceptable evidence, it cannot be said that even they are
either part of conspiracy to kidnap the child for ransom or they
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
shared a common intention to kidnap the child for the said
purpose.
36.
The prosecution has not proved by placing sufficient
material that one of these accused, namely, accused Nos.2 and
3 have made the ransom call, to connect them with the crime
or to show that they shared a common intention along with
accused No.1.
At the cost of repetition, the motive can be
attributed to accused No.1.
There is no motive for accused
Nos.2 and 3 to commit any offence. As already mentioned,
accused No.1 was very well acquainted with PW.4, the victim in
this case and he used to take the victim along with him. PW.4
has deposed that he had accompanied accused No.1 on several
occasions earlier. Further, it is not the case of prosecution that
the victim was forcibly taken in the car so as to attribute
accusation against accused Nos.2 and 3. The child accompanied
accused No.1 in the car without raising any suspicion and
therefore, it is probable that accused Nos.2 and 3 were
unaware of the intention of accused No.1 to kidnap him.
37.
We do find that there is some lapse on the part of
the Investigating Officer in not seizing the school bag or the
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
tiffin box. However, the said lapse itself is not a ground to
disbelieve the case of prosecution insofar as kidnap of the
victim.
We find from the evidence on record that there is
sufficient material insofar as accused No.1. However, insofar as
accused Nos.2 and 3 are concerned, they having shared
common intention with accused No.1 to kidnap the victim is not
proved beyond reasonable doubt. Insofar as accused No.1 is
concerned, particularly the evidence of PW.4 the victim is
sufficient to hold that the said accused has kidnapped him, a
minor aged about 9 years, away from the lawful guardianship.
The identification of accused No.1 by the child, who was well
acquainted with him, has to be accepted without any iota of
doubt.
38.
The contention of the learned Senior counsel that
when the main charge is not proved, the accused cannot be
convicted for lesser offence, cannot be accepted. The Trial
Court placing reliance on the judgment in the case of
Tarkeshwar Sahu vs. State of Bihar1, wherein it is held that
8when an accused is charged with major offence and the
(2006) 8 SCC 560
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
ingredients of the major offence are missing and ingredients of
minor offence are made out, then he may be convicted for the
minor offence even though he was not charged with it9, has
recorded conviction for the offence punishable under Section
363 of IPC. The said finding is in accordance with law.
However, we find that the oral and documentary evidence
adduced by the prosecution is not sufficient to hold accused
Nos.2 and 3 guilty even for the offence under Section 363 of
IPC. The conviction and sentence passed by the Trial Court
against the said accused is liable to be set aside.
39.
The trial Court has imposed a sentence of 3 years
rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs.5,000/- for the offence
punishable under Section 363 of IPC and default sentence for
non-payment of fine.
40.
The
learned senior
counsel appearing for
the
appellants would submit that accused No.1 is married and has
two minor children. His mother is no more and his father has
undergone bypass surgery. There is no one to look after them,
as he is the sole bread winner of the family.
Hence, he
submitted that if the accused is sent to prison, his family
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
members will be put to untold hardship. He further submitted
that accused No.1 has no criminal antecedents. Hence, prayed
that leniency may be shown by reducing the sentence of
imprisonment, enhancing the fine amount.
41.
The incident took place in the year 2012. 13 years
have elapsed. Accused No.1 was arrested on 25.12.2012 and
released on bail on 03.05.2013. He was in custody for about 4
months 9 days. It is not in dispute that the victim child was
not harmed even minutely after he was kidnapped.
accused has no criminal antecedents.
The
Keeping in view the
submission made by the learned senior counsel, sending the
accused to prison at this stage, will not serve any purpose.
Hence, the sentence already undergone by accused No.1 could
be held sufficient, by enhancing the fine amount.
42.
For the foregoing reasons, we pass the following:
ORDER
i)
Crl.A.No.100249/2020 is dismissed.
ii)
Crl.A.Nos.100084/2020 and 100087/2020 are
allowed.
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
iii)
The judgment and order dated 24.01.2020
passed by the learned II Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Bagalkote in S.C.No.90/2013
convicting and sentencing accused Nos.2 and 3
for the offence under Section 363 IPC is hereby
set aside. The said accused are acquitted.
iv)
The bail bonds of accused Nos.2 and 3 are
discharged.
v)
The fine amount, if any, deposited by them
shall be refunded.
vi)
Crl.A.No.100060/2020 is allowed in part.
vii) The judgment of conviction of accused No.1 for
the offence punishable under Section 363 of
IPC is hereby confirmed.
viii) The sentence is modified as under:
a.
Accused
No.1
is
sentenced
to
imprisonment already undergone by him.
b.
He
shall
pay
fine
of
Rs.1,00,000/-
(Rupees one lakh only) and in default of
payment of fine, shall undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of six months.
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:374-DB
CRL.A No. 100249 of 2020
C/W CRL.A No. 100060 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100084 of 2020
CRL.A.No.100087 of 2020
HC-KAR
c.
If the fine amount is deposited, the same
shall be paid to PW.4, who is now a
major.
SD/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
SD/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
Kmv upto para 18
SSP: Para 19 to 22 and 36 to end
RKM: Para 23 to 35
CT:PA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review