Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
MA No. 174/2015
Reserved On: 10th of September, 2026.
Pronounced On: 26th of September, 2026.
Uploaded On: 26th of September, 2026.
Whether the operative part or
full Judgment is pronounced:
Full.
1. Masood Ali Parry
S/O Qasim Ali Parray
R/O Nowpora, Srinagar
2. Mubashir Shuja Mir
S/O Abdul Rehman Mir
R/O Galwanpora, Budgam
3. Mohammed Qasim Malla
S/O Ghulam Mohammed Malla
R/O Diwar Yakhmanpora,
Tehsil Pattan, District Baramulla
Appellants 1 and 3 through their
Attorney Appellant No.2.
… Appellant(s)
Through: Mr Shafqat Nazir, Advocate with
Ms Atufa Farooq, Advocate.
V/S
1. State of Jammu & Kashmir (now UT),
Through Commissioner/ Secretary to Government,
Revenue Department, Civil Secretariat,
Srinagar.
2. District Collector, Baramulla.
3. Collector Land Acquisition ACR,
Baramulla.
4. Director General Armed Police,
J&K, Srinagar.
5. Commandant 10th Battalion IRP,
Parihaspora, Pattan.
6. Incharge Armed Police Complex,
Dewar Yakhmanpora,
Pattan, Baramulla.
… Respondents
Through: Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG with
Ms Nadiya Abdullah, Assisting Counsel.
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
Clubbed With:
RFA No. 11/2020
1. State of Jammu & Kashmir (now UT),
Through Commissioner/ Secretary to Govt.,
Revenue Department, Civil Secretariat,
Jammu/ Srinagar.
2. District Collector, Baramulla.
3. Collector Land Acquisition
(ACR), Baramulla.
4. D. G. Armed Police,
J&K, Jammu/ Srinagar.
5. Commandant 10th Bn. IRP,
Parihaspora, Pattan.
6. In-charge Armed Police Complex,
Diwar Yakhmanpora, Tehsil Pattan,
District Baramulla.
… Appellant(s)
Through: Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG with
Ms Nadiya Abdullah, Assisting Counsel.
V/S
1. Masood Ali Parray
S/O Qasim Ali Parray
R/O Nowpora, Srinagar
2. Mubashir Shuja Mir
S/O Abdul Rehman Mir
R/O Galwanpora, Budgam
3. Mohammad Qasim Malla
S/O Gh. Rasool Malla
R/O Diwar Yakhmanpora,
Tehsil Pattan, District Baramulla.
… Respondents
Through: Mr Shafqat Nazir, Advocate with
Ms Atufa Farooq, Advocate.
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(JUDGMENT)
01.
Since, in both these cross appeals Judgment dated 25th of June,
2015 passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Baramulla in a Land
Acquisition Reference filed under Section 18 of the J&K Land Acquisition
Act titled “Masood Ali Parray & Ors. v. State of J&K and Ors.” is
under challenge, therefore, it is proposed to decide both the appeals by this
common Judgment.
02.
Briefly stated, the facts leading to the filing of these appeals
are that, consequent upon the request made by Commandant 10 th BN, IRP,
Parihaspora for acquisition of land measuring 20 Kanals and 12 Marlas
situate in estate Diver Yakhmanpora, Tehsil Pattan and District Baramulla
covered under Survey Nos. 884, 895, 928, 937/ Min, 932, 896 and 898, the
Collector
Land
Acquisition,
Baramulla/
Assistant
Commissioner
(Revenue), Baramulla came to pass an Award dated 25th of March, 2010,
whereby the aforesaid land was acquired for the public purpose of
construction of Armed Police Complex at Diver Yakhmanpora, Tehsil
Pattan, District Baramulla, against the compensation of a sum of
₹82,92,500/- (rupees eighty two lacs, ninety two thousand and five
hundred) only.
03.
Feeling dissatisfied with and aggrieved of the aforesaid Award
passed by the Collector Land Acquisition (Revenue), Baramulla, the land
owners (Appellants in MA No. 174/2015 and Respondents in RFA No.
11/2020) filed an application under Section 18 of the Jammu & Kashmir
Land Acquisition Act, before the District Collector/ Deputy Commissioner,
Baramulla, who made Land Acquisition Reference to the Principal District
Court, Baramulla.
04.
The learned Principal District Court, Baramulla (for short
“Reference Court”), entered into reference by virtue of Civil Reference No.
13 on 5th of May, 2010. Accordingly, on the basis of pleadings of the
parties, the Reference Court framed the following two issues:
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
“1. Whether the compensation for the acquired land has not
been correctly fixed and awarded by the Collector? If yes,
what is the quantum of compensation to which the petitioners
are entitled to? OPP; and
2. To what relief the Petitioners are entitled to? OP Parties.”
05.
The Reference Court, thereafter, vide impugned Judgment
dated 25th of June, 2015, while deciding the aforesaid issues, observed that
taking into consideration the existing law on the subject, the summary of
oral and documentary evidence led, it is clear that the Collector has not
correctly assessed the quantum of market value and the compensation
payable thereof, and that, in view of the productivity and potentiality of the
land, the developmental activities in the area, the small distance of the land
from the National Highway and the tremendous importance of the tourists
and commercial activities, as deposed by the witness-retired Tehsildar, the
compensation amount of ₹6.50 lacs per Kanal inclusive of fruit bearing
trees was held to be the appropriate rate on which the Petitioners’ land
should be assessed. On the basis of the aforesaid observations, the
Reference Court decided the issues in favour of the Petitioners (Appellants
in MA No.174/2015) and against the Respondents (Appellants in RFA No.
11/2020) and granted the following relief in favour of the Petitioners
(Appellants in MA No. 174/2015):
“1. That the Respondents shall pay compensation to the
Petitioners from whom the land has been acquired at the rate
of Rs.6,50,000/- per kanal inclusive of fruit bearing trees plus
jabirana @ 15% together with interest @ 7% per annum on
the enhanced amount per kanal from the date of possession
of the acquired land; and
2. The amount of compensation already received by the
petitioners shall be deducted from the compensation allowed
to them in under noted reference.”
06.
Both the sides litigating before the Reference Court, i.e., the
land owners (Petitioners before the Reference Court) and the Government
(Respondents before the Reference Court), being aggrieved and dissatisfied
with the Judgment passed by the Reference Court, filed two separate
appeals against the said Judgment.
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
07.
The land owners have filed MA No. 174/2015, whereby they
are seeking setting aside of the impugned Judgment passed by the
Reference Court and are claiming enhancement of compensation to ₹15.00
lacs per kanal and also providing jobs to them. They have pleaded that the
Reference Court did not appreciate the evidence which they led during trial
and furnished sufficient proof in the form of depositions of witnesses and
documents/ letters/ reports of competent authorities, by virtue of which they
had established beyond any shadow of doubt that the prevalent market rate
of per kanal of land in the area was ₹.10.00 lacs, as on the date of
acquisition of their land and that same was also not rebutted by the other
side, but even then, the said important fact has been ignored by the
Reference Court, while passing the impugned Judgment; that the Appellants
are also entitled to enhancement of compensation, for the reason that the
Reference Court has not considered the situation and commercial utility of
the land, though the Appellants have proved the same to the hilt; that the
land in and around the acquired land of the Appellants has been in use for
commercial activities since last so many decades and with the development
of the State (now UT), the land of the Appellants could have fetched
considerable amount and its market value could have raised to tremendous
heights in near future, however, this important aspect of the matter has also
been overlooked by the Reference Court by not fixing the just
compensation.
08.
On the other hand, the Government has preferred RFA No.
11/2020 to assail the impugned Judgment passed by the Reference Court,
claiming that the compensation awarded is on the higher side. They have
pleaded that no such evidence, proof or record was produced by the
Claimants to demonstrate that the cost of the land in question would be
more than what was fixed by the Collector; that the land was proposed to be
acquired in 2007 and formally its possession was taken over in the year
2010 when the Award was passed by the Collector, thereby fixing the rate
as was prevalent at that point of time; that the compensation was fixed by
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
the Collector after conducting proper enquiry and following due procedure
as prescribed by the law/ rules governing the field; that the rates/
compensation fixed by the Reference Court, vide impugned Judgment, are/
is highly exorbitant/ inflated, besides the interest awarded is not
permissible, having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case.
09.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties, perused the pleadings
available on record and considered the matter.
10.
The Collector had awarded compensation @ ₹3.50 lacs per
Kanal for the acquired land in question and, on a reference made to the
Reference Court, the rate of compensation was enhanced from ₹3.50 lacs to
₹6.50 lacs per Kanal. Both the parties, having been dissatisfied and
aggrieved of the rate of compensation awarded by the Reference Court,
have filed the above titled two cross appeals.
11.
As per Section 23 of the J&K Land Acquisition Act, following
are the considerations to be taken note of by the Court for determining the
amount of compensation to be awarded for the land acquired under the
Land Acquisition Act:
“First, the market value of the land at the date of the
publication of the declaration relating thereto under Section 6;
Second, the damage sustained by the person interested
by reason of taking of any standing crop or trees which may be
on the land at the time of the Collector’s taking possession
thereof;
Third, the damage (if any) sustained by the person
interested at the time of the Collector’s taking possession of
the land by reason of severing such land from his other land;
Fourth, the damage (if any) sustained by the person
interested at the time of the Collector’s taking possession of
the land by reason of the acquisition injuriously affecting his
other property moveable or immoveable in any manner, or his
earnings;
Fifth, if in consequence of the acquisition of the land
by the Collector, the person interested is compelled to change
his residence or place of business, the reasonable expenses (if
any) incidental to such change; and
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
Sixth, the damage (if any) bona fide resulting from
diminution of the profits of the land between the time of the
publication of the declaration under Section 6, and the time of
the Collector’s taking possession of the land.”
In addition to the market value of the land, as prescribed
hereinabove, the Court, in every case, has to award a sum of fifteen per
centum on such market value in consideration of the compulsory nature of
the acquisition.
12.
On receiving indent for acquisition of the land measuring 20
Kanals and 12 Marlas falling in Survey Nos. 884, 895, 928, 937/ Min, 932,
896 and 898 situate in Diver Yakhmanpora, estate of Tehsil Pattan, District
Baramulla and issuance of requisite notification, the case was tabled for
finalization, through private negotiations, however, due to exorbitant rates
demanded by the land owners, it was decided to process the case under
compulsory land acquisition method. In view of above, the market value of
the land acquired has to be ascertained on the basis of the prevalent rate at
the time of publication of notice under the provisions of Section 6 of the
J&K Land Acquisition Act which, in the present case, had been issued by
the Deputy Commissioner, Baramulla on 19th of December, 2009.
13.
In order to buttress their claim for seeking enhancement of
compensation with respect to their landed property, the land owners had
brought on record oral as well as documentary evidence. They examined
Fida Hussain Reshi, Mukhtar Ahmad Malla, Mohammad Akbar Khawaja,
Sheikh Ghulam Rasool, Mohammad Akbar Mir, Nasrullah Shah and Syed
Mubashir Sajad, as their witnesses.
14.
PW-Fida Hussain Reshi had stated that, at the time of
acquisition of the land, the prevalent market rate was ₹14-15 lacs per Kanal
and that the acquired land was plain bearing fruit and non-fruit trees and
was situated about half a Kilometer from his residence. PW-Mukhtar
Ahmad Malla stated that the Government had taken over land from
farmers with small holdings, instead of taking it from a prominent politician
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
and religious leader, Molvi Ifitkhar Hussain Ansari, who had hundreds of
Kanals of land in the area and that, at the time of acquisition of the land, the
market rate was about ₹13-14 lacs per Kanal. PW-Mohammad Akbar
Khawaja also deposed in the manner PW-Mukhtar Ahmad Malla had
deposed.
15.
PW-Sheikh Ghulam Rasool, a retired Tehsildar and a
resident of Lar, Ganderbal, stated that he had served as Tehsildar, Pattan in
the year 2009 and during his posting, the notification for acquisition of the
land for Armed Police Headquarter had been issued; that he had inspected
the land which was plain as well as sloppy, bearing fruit as well as non-fruit
trees; that the market value of the land in the area was higher in view of
SSM group of Colleges, archeological buildings and a vast chunk of land in
the name of Molvi Iftikhar Hussain Ansari; that the sale deeds were shown
of less value in the area, there being no Government ceiling on the market
rate and that, as per his report sent to the Collector, the market rate of the
land was about ₹4.00 lacs per Kanal on an average, though people in the
area had indicated that the market rate was around ₹10.00 lacs per Kanal
and one of the persons had shown an agreement to sell with regard to land
comprising Survey No. 895 attested by Notary, proposed to be sold @
₹10.00 lacs per Kanal.
16.
PW-Mohammad Akbar Mir stated that he, as per sale
agreement dated 17th of September, 2006, had proposed to sell land
measuring 02 Kanals and 03 Marlas to one Mubashir Sajad @ ₹9.10 lacs
per Kanal and produced the copy of the sale agreement. PW-Nasrullah
Shah stated that he, as per sale agreement dated 29th of April, 2006, had
proposed to sell land measuring 02 Kanals comprising of Survey No. 876
against a consideration of ₹8.80 lacs per Kanal.
17.
Appellant No.2 in MA No. 174/2015, namely, Mubashir
Shuja, who is also Attorney Holder of other Appellants in the said MA,
deposed that his land had also been acquired along with land of the other
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
inhabitants and that he has been given Power of Attorney by the other land
owners to prosecute the case; that the market rate of the land in the area
from the years 2006-2009 was about ₹8.50 lacs to ₹10.00 lacs per Kanal;
and that the Collector had granted unjust compensation as against the
prevalent market rate of ₹10-13 lacs per Kanal, which has now exceeded to
₹20.00 lacs per Kanal.
18.
This is the sum and substance of the evidence led by the land
owners. No evidence, however, was led by the other side.
19.
It was the contention of the land owners, in their evidence, that
there has been inflation in the cost of land at Parihaspora because of
location of SSM College in its vicinity and its extension to a large area,
being the capital of Kashmir in olden days and that during the reign of
Mufti Mohammad Syed in 2002-2005, it was proposed that the capital of
Kashmir shall be shifted to Parihaspora, as such, on these counts, the cost of
land had gone very high. It was further pleaded by the land owners that the
place where the land in question was acquired by the Respondents is
famous for archeological monuments, besides, the land being highly valued
as the same bears fruit growing trees which was the source of livelihood of
the land owners. They had also pleaded that the land in question was plain
and not banjar, and that the witnesses examined by the land owners
deposed that the rate of the land in the year was ₹14-15 lacs per Kanal,
however, one of the witnesses deposed that in the year 2006, the land would
cost ₹8.80 lacs per Kanal.
20.
Apart from the oral evidence, the land owners had also placed
on record documentary evidence in the form of agreements to sell. In one of
the agreements, wherein one witness, namely, Nasrullah, had agreed to
purchase 02 Kanals of land @ ₹8.80 lacs per Kanal at Dewar Yakhmanpora
on 29th of April, 2006. Another sale agreement pertained to 02 Kanals and
03 Marlas of land situate in the same area, proposed to be sold for a
consideration of ₹9.10 lacs per Kanal in the year 2006. In the third sale
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
agreement, 10 Marlas of land situate in the same area, as that of the present
land owners, was proposed to be sold for an amount of ₹5.00 lacs in the
year 2009.
21.
The Reference Court, while evaluating the evidence available
on record, observed that the oral statements had given exaggerated figures
to the extent of ₹14-15 lacs per Kanal in the area, as against the rate
awarded by the Collector, and did not find the same as reliable, except
statement of one witness, who had deposed that the rate of the land for the
area in the vicinity of the acquired land was ₹8.80 lacs per Kanal. The
Reference Court also considered the sale agreements having been made in
the years 2005 and 2006 before the acquisition of the land in question and,
while deciding issue No.1, came to the conclusion that in view of the
productivity and potentiality of the land, the developmental activities in the
area, the small distance of the land from the National Highway and the
tremendous importance of the tourists and commercial activities, as
reported by a witness-retired Tehsildar, examined by the land owners, the
compensation amount of ₹6.50 lacs per Kanal, inclusive of fruit bearing
trees, was awarded.
22.
Having regard to the parameters contained in Section 23 of the
J&K Land Acquisition Act, 1990, in terms of which the subject land had
been acquired, the rates are to be determined on the basis of the market
value of the land to be assessed in the period when notification under
Section 6 of the Act was issued. Admittedly, in the present case, the
aforesaid notice had been issued in the year 2009, as such, the rates of the
acquired land are to be determined relating to the year 2009.
23.
Although, the witnesses examined by the land owners have
made statements that the prevalent market rate of the land in question was
in the range of ₹14-15 lacs per Kanal, however, the same could not be
substantiated by them without any sale deed executed on such rates with
regard to any land in the vicinity of the acquired land. The land owners
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
have succeeded to place on record certain sale agreements and examined
some of the persons who had executed these agreements with regard to
some land in the vicinity of the acquired land, however, none of the said
agreements, even if they are relied upon, has shown the land to have been
sold for the rates which are claimed by the land owners.
24.
The Collector had determined the rates of the land after spot
inspection and having regard to the location of the land being 3-4 KMs
away from the highway and keeping in view the report of the revenue
officers with regard to prevalent market rate for the last three years in the
area and awarded compensation @ ₹3.50 lacs per Kanal.
25.
The Reference Court, having regard to the oral and
documentary evidence led by the land owners and particularly keeping in
view the statement of PW-Sheikh Ghulam Rasool, a retired Tehsildar, who
at the relevant point of time was working as the jurisdictional Tehsildar and
had stated that though the market rate of the land as per record was about
₹4.00 lacs per Kanal on an average, however, the people had indicated that
the market rate was around ₹10.00 lacs per Kanal, raised the compensation
from ₹3.50 to ₹6.50 lacs per Kanal.
26.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the Reference Court
has determined just compensation on the basis of evidence led before it,
having regard to all the parameters, i.e., location, productivity, kind and the
prevalent market rate based on the agreements to sell produced by the land
owners and there being no evidence in rebuttal.
27.
In both the appeals filed by the contesting parties, the learned
Counsel appearing for the parties, have not succeeded to persuade this
Court as to how the rate fixed by the Reference Court was not proper,
particularly in the face of the documentary evidence in the shape of sale
agreements relating to the proximate time of the acquisition of the land in
question by the Collectorate.
MA No. 174/2015 c/w
RFA No. 11/2020
28.
The Reference Court has rightly discussed the evidence
brought on record by the land owners which remained unrebutted by the
other side and, rightly so, did not believe the exaggerated statements made
by the land owners and their witnesses with regard to rate of land of ₹14-15
lacs per Kanal, without any documentary evidence. Therefore, the
Reference Court has taken a correct view in the matter, based on the
documentary evidence to enhance the rate of compensation awarded by the
Collector from ₹3.50 lacs to ₹6.50 lacs per Kanal.
29.
Having regard to the foregoing reasons and the discussion
made hereinabove, the Appellants in both these appeals have failed to show
any good ground to either reduce or enhance the rate fixed by the Reference
Court with respect to the land in question. Besides, the evidence available
on record persuades this Court to take the same view as has been taken by
the Reference Court, in terms of the impugned Judgment.
30.
Viewed thus, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
Reference Court had rightly fixed the rate of compensation with respect to
the land to be awarded to the land owners while deciding issue No.1, as
such, the impugned Judgment passed by the Reference Court does not call
for any interference by this Court, invoking appellate jurisdiction. The
impugned Judgment passed by the Reference Court is, thus, upheld
31.
Resultantly, both these appeals are dismissed. Pending
application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of, accordingly. Interim
direction(s), if any, shall stand vacated in both the appeals.
32.
Registry to place a copy of this Judgment on both these
connected files and a copy thereof be forwarded to the Reference Court, for
information and record.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
September 26th, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review