Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
LPA No. 35/2024in
SWP No. 1264/2006
Reserved on: 29.08.2025
Pronounced on: 04.03.2026
Uploaded on: 05.03.2026
State of Jammu & Kashmir
through Commissioner/Secretary
to Government, Education Department,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/Jammu
Through:
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Mr. H. Aman Ali, Dy. AG.
V/s
1. Nasreen Shamus, Age 45 years,
D/o Shamus-ud-Din Tantry,
R/o Lal Bagh, Tehsil Handwara,
District Kupwara
2. Chairman, Service Selection
Board, Jammu/Srinagar
3. Secretary, Service Selection Board,
Jammu/Srinagar
Through:
....Respondent(s)
Mr. Pervaiz Lone, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Per: Sindhu Sharma-J
1.
This Letters Patent Appeal is directed against the judgment and order
dated 02.03.2016 passed by the learned Single Judge in a writ petition,
i.e.,SWP No. 1264/2006, titled ‘Nasreen Shamus vs. State of J&K & Ors.’
2.
Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the present appeal are that, the
J&K Services Selection Recruitment Board (for short, „SSRB‟), issued
Advertisement Notification No. 10 of 2005 dated 29.12.2005, inviting
applications for selection to the posts of Teachers in various districts of the
erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir, including 66 posts of Teachers in
LPA No. 35/2024
District Kupwara. The said notification was published in the local daily
newspaper „Roshini‟ on 05.01.2006. The break-up of the posts was as under:
District Cadre Kupwara
Total
3.
OM
SC
ST
RBA
ALC
SOC
66 Posts
The interviews for the eligible short-listed candidates from the
applicants were conducted from 16.09.2006 to 22.09.2006, while
interviews of shortlisted candidates handicapped category and shortlisted
in the supplementary open merit list were conducted on 18.10.2006 at Dak
Banglow, Kupwara. The respondent No. 1, did not figure in the list of
short-listed candidates and consequently, was not called for interview.
4.
Feeling aggrieved of the fact that she was denied participation in the
interview process, respondent No. 1 approached this Court by filing writ
petition i.e. SWP No. 1264/2006. The respondent No. 1 sought a direction
to the SSRB to conduct her interview for the post of Teacher advertised
vide Notification No. 10 of 2005 dated 29.12.2005, primarily on the
ground that she was not called for interview as the Selection Board has
resorted to shortlisting to her detriment. This shortlisting, according to
her, was not provided in the advertisement notice and has resulted in
depriving her opportunity of consideration in the interview process and
consequently, appointment for the post of Teacher in District Kupwara.
LPA No. 35/2024
The respondent No. 1, thus, in the writ petition, prayed the following
reliefs:
“(I) Mandamus commanding the respondents Service Selection
Board to conduct the interview of the petitioner for the advertised
post of Teacher as per Advertisement Notification No. 10 of 2005.
(II) Any other appropriate writ order or direction which the
Hon‟ble Court, deems fit and proper, in the peculiar circumstances
of the case, be issued in favour of the petitioner against the
respondents with costs.”
5.
The learned writ Court, while issuing notice in the petition on
25.09.2006, permitted respondent No. 1 to appear in the interview at her
own risk and responsibility subject to the condition that the interview
process for the post in question was still in progress. She was eligible in
terms of the applicable rules and norms and had actually applied for the
post.
6.
The writ petition was dismissed in default of appearance and interim
directions were vacated on 03.02.2007. The petition was subsequently
restored to its original number vide order dated 11.03.2009. During the
pendency of the aforesaid writ petition, the respondents-Board were
directed to file a status report indicating the date on which the interviews
for the post were conducted. This direction was issued in view of the
interim order dated 25.09.2006, directing interview of the respondent
No. 1.
7.
The Chairman, JKSSRB in the status report filed in compliance to
the order dated 15.10.2009 submitted that the interviews of shortlisted
candidates were conducted on 16.09.2006 to 22.09.2006. The interviews
of the handicapped category candidates and the candidates shortlisted
LPA No. 35/2024
under Open Merit were conducted on 18.10.2006. The interim order dated
25.09.2006 passed in SWP No. 1264/2006 was neither communicated to
them nor did the respondent present herself with the order, therefore, the
Board was not in a position to conduct her interview.
8.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No. 1 submits that this
Court, after considering their contentions, had directed the official
respondent Nos. 2 and 3 to conduct her interview, but despite the interim
order in her favour, the respondents-Board failed to comply with the
direction. The official respondents were directed to produce record to
show that respondent No. 1 had failed to serve the interim order upon the
official respondents in time for conducting her interview. It appears that
no record in this regard was produced, therefore, this Court, after
considering the nature of the controversy and the fact that the respondent
No. 1could not participate in the selection process, proceeded to decide
the writ petition on 02.03.2016.
9.
The writ petition was decided vide impugned judgment and order
dated 02.03.2016 by observing that since respondent No. 1 was precluded
from participating in the selection process by not complying with the
impugned order and held that she could have been selected for the post of
Teacher had she been allowed to participate in the said process, as such,
the petition was allowed with the following directions:
“Commissioner/Secretary to Government, Education Department
and Director School Education, Kashmir are directed to appoint the
petitioner on the available post of Teacher in District Kupwara.
Appointment order be issued within two weeks from the date a
copy of this order is served.
LPA No. 35/2024
For the purpose of appointment, petitioner would be deemed
to be within the prescribed age as at time of initiation of selection
process, she was within prescribed age.”
10. The appellants are aggrieved of the impugned judgment on the
ground that the learned Single Judge has travelled beyond the relief
claimed in the petition, as the only relief claimed by the respondent was
for conducting her interview to advertised post of teacher. The petition
has been decided without considering all the facts and the appellant was
directed
to
appoint
the
respondent
without
her
selection
or
recommendation by the Board.
11. It is further submitted that the appellant, being the indenting
department, had no role in the selection process and had issued
appointment orders only on the recommendations of the SSRB. Therefore,
in the absence of any recommendation from the SSRB in favour of
respondent No. 1, the impugned order could not have been implemented.
It is averred that respondent No. 1 was otherwise not entitled to
appointment, as neither her interview was conducted nor her selection was
recommended by the proforma respondents for issuance of appointment.
12. The disability certificate placed on record by respondent No. 1 which
was relied upon by the learned writ Court did not specify the percentage
of disability necessary for consideration under the handicapped category.
Apart from this, the respondent No. 1 did not place any material on record
to show that the interim order was duly served upon the respondents or
that they had failed to comply with the same. It is lastly submitted that the
writ petition involved disputed questions of fact and, therefore, was not
maintainable.
LPA No. 35/2024
13. The specific contention of the respondent in the writ petition was that
she had approached the respondent-Board for participation in interview
process but was denied the same on the plea that they had adopted
shortlisting criteria for interview without incorporating the relevant clause
in the advertisement notice. The respondent No. 1 submitted that
shortlisting is permissible if the same is mentioned in the advertisement
notice inviting applications. More specifically, the pleadings in para 8 of
the writ petition being relevant are reproduced below: “That in the advertisement notice inviting applications for direct recruitments
to jobs under the Govt. a clause has to be inserted regarding „short listing‟.
This condition has not been incorporated in the Advertisement Notice as such
the respondents Service Selection Board has been arbitrarily, without any
jurisdiction adopting a novel method of selection to the detriment of the
petitioner.”
14. The question which arises for consideration is whether it is open for
this Court to issue direction to appoint the respondent against the post of
teacher, for which, the respondent was neither shortlisted nor interviewed.
15. The respondents-Board had issued an advertisement for appointment
of 66 posts of Teachers in District Kupwara. The advertisement notice
provided the procedure for selection, which reads as under:(b)
A candidate can apply only in one District of his choice for District Cadre
posts and in one Division of his choice in respect of Divisional Cadre posts advertised
simultaneously. Provided that if any candidate applies for a post in more than one
District or Division, his candidature shall be considered only for the District or
Division in which he is ordinarily residing.
VI. PROCEDURE FOR SELECTION.
(a) The prescribed qualifications reflect the bare minimum requirement of the job and
mere possession thereof does not entitle the candidate to be called for interview.
Ordinarily the Board shall restrict the number of applicants to be admitted to
oral/written test to five times the number of vacancies after doing the preliminary
screening on the basis of marks obtained in the qualifying examination and grant
of weightage for the additional qualification/s beneficial for the job to be
undertaker in accordance with the criteria prescribed by the Board for the purpose
and as notified in the official gazette.
(b) Ordinarily the Board will issue call letters for interview to the eligible short listed
candidates specifying the venue (s) and date (s) for interview. In order to eliminate
the possibility of late of Non receipt of call letters on account of postal delay, the
Board shall give a wide publicity through print and electronic media about the
venue(s)/date(s) of interview for the eligible short listed candidates. Therefore, the
LPA No. 35/2024
candidatesare advised to keep in touch with the print and electronic media as also
the offices of the Board to ascertain the venue/date of interview. This is all the
more important as the Board shall not entertain any claim for non receipt/belated
receipt of call letters by any candidate for reasons whatsoever.”
16. The contention of the respondent No. 1 is that Board has resorted to
shortlisting without a specific clause being incorporated in the
advertisement notice is without any merit, as is evident from the
procedure for selection. The advertisement notice specifically provided
for procedure for selection and shortlisting of eligible candidates to five
times the number of candidates. The advertisement notice contained the
procedure of shortlisting and the respondent No. 1 did not obtain the
requisite merit of shortlisting. This apart, the respondent otherwise could
not claim appointment in view of the fact that the respondent having
participated in the selection process and taken a chance before the
selection authority could not turn around and challenge the same. The
entire edifice of the contentions raised by respondent No. 1 in the writ
petition was on a wrong premise that shortlisting clause was not
incorporated in the advertisement notice and she was arbitrarily denied
participation in the interview on that basis, which has violated her rights.
17. It is well settled that a candidate who consciously takes part in the
process of selection cannot be permitted to question the advertisement or
methodology adopted by the selection committee for making selection or
he/she having been declared unsuccessful in the shortlisting. The
unsuccessful candidate cannot turn around and challenge the recruitment
process as held in “Dhananjay Malik v. State of Uttranchal”, (2008) 4
SCC 171, which reads as under: - .
8. More particularly, this Court in the case of Madan Lal‟s (supra)
has pointed out that when the petitioners appeared at the oral
LPA No. 35/2024
9.
interview conducted by the Members concerned of the
Commission who interviewed the petitioners as well as the
contesting respondents concerned, the petitioners took a chance
to get themselves selected at the said oral interview. Therefore,
only because they did not find themselves to have emerged
successful as a result of their combined performance both at
written test and oral interview, they have filed writ petitions.
This Court further pointed out that if a candidate takes a
calculated chance and appears at the interview, then, only
because the result of the interview is not palatable to him, he
cannot turn round and subsequently contend that the process of
interview was unfair or the Selection Committee was not
properly constituted.
In the present case, as already pointed out, the writ petitionersrespondents herein participated in the selection process without
any demur; they are estopped from complaining that the
selection process was not in accordance with the Rules. If they
think that the advertisement and selection process were not in
accordance with the Rules they could have challenged the
advertisement and selection process without participating in the
selection process. This has not been so done.
18. Clause VI of the advertisement notice clearly stipulated that mere
possession of prescribed qualification would not entitle a candidate to be called
for interview. It was not the case of the respondent No. 1 that she possessed the
requisite merit and was still not called for interview. In fact, her submission was
that respondents have resorted to shortlisting which was not incorporated in the
advertisement notice. This is belied by advertisement notice. The learned Single
Judge, without considering the merit of the case, has appeared to have
proceeded only on the ground of non-compliance of interim order and directed
the appellant to appoint respondent No. 1 to the post of teacher.
19. We are unable to agree with the view of the learned Single Judge. The
respondent No. 1 was not called for interview because she did not possess the
requisite merit, thus, the respondent could not be appointed to the post for
which she was not shortlisted. The condition regarding shortlisting was duly
incorporated in the advertisement notice. Pursuant to the same, the
LPA No. 35/2024
respondents-Board conducted the selection process and invited candidates
for interview, and completed the selection process.
20. The only other issue which weighed with the learned Single Judge
was that despite interim order, the respondent was not interviewed.
However, in view of the specific affidavit of the Chairman of the Board
that the respondent did not appear before them while the interview process
was still continuing, and no contemporaneousrecord was put forth by the
respondent, no inference could be drawn against the selection authority.
Thus, the respondent having neither been shortlisted nor interviewed for
the post for which she lacked the requisite merit, no direction for
appointment of such a candidate could be issued.
21. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this appeal is
allowed and the impugned judgment dated 02.03.2016 is set aside.
Consequently, the writ petition is also dismissed.
(Shahzad Azeem)
Judge
(Sindhu Sharma)
Judge
Jammu:
04.03.2026
Michal Sharma/PS
Whether approved for reporting
Whether approved for reporting
:
:
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review