Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1112 of 1998
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MOOL CHAND TYAGI
==========================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
√
==========================================
STATE OF GUJARAT
Versus
NATHA NANAJI BHARWAD & ORS.
==========================================
Appearance:
MS JYOTI BHATT APP for the Appellant(s) No. 1
HCLS COMMITTEE(4998) for the Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No.
1,2,3,4
MR VIRAT G POPAT(3710) for the Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No.
1,2,3,4
PETITION/APPEAL WITHDRAWN/DISMISSED for the
Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No. 5
==========================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MOOL CHAND TYAGI
Date : 14/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK)
1.
The appellant - State of Gujarat has preferred this appeal under
Section 378(1)(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 against the
judgment and order dated 21.09.1998 passed by the learned Sessions
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
Judge, Rajkot in Sessions Case No. 181 of 1996, whereby the trial
Court has acquitted the original accused (respondents herein) from
the offences punishable under Sections 302, 364, 120B, 342, 114 etc
of the Indian Penal Code and under Section 135 of the Bombay Police
Act.
2.
Short facts of the prosecution case are that Vallabhbhai
Bijalbhai (deceased) was residing at Village: Bedala, who abducted
minor daughter of one Hakka Pola Bharwad namely Anuben on
15.06.1996, for which the FIR came to be lodged at Rajkot Taluka
Police Station. That keeping grudge, on 02.09.1996 at about 8.00 AM,
Vallabhbhai Bijalbhai was driving the Matador bearing registration No.
GJ-03-V-3756 and in between Village: Hadmatiya – Golida, accused
No.5 – Govind Lakhubhai Bharwad was standing on the road and
stopped the vehicle and boarded into Matador and when they reached
near Village: Dhadhiya, accused No.5, who was sitting in Matador,
tried to put his leg on the break and also tried to snatch the steering
from Vallabhbhai and in the event, accused No.5 pushed Vallabhbhai
from the vehicle and at that time accused No.1 tied both hands of
Vallabhbhai and inflicted the stick blow on the hands and legs, at that
time, accused No.4 was driving the Hero-Honda Motorcycle and
proceeded towards Village: Bedala at about 9.30 AM and they got
down from the motorcycle and accused No.1 threw Vallabhbhai on the
road and accused No.2 and 3 were inflicted stick blow on the hands
and legs of Vallabhbhai, due to which, he sustained injuries and
succumbed to the injury. Hence, a complaint was lodged by the
complainant before jurisdictional Police Station for the aforesaid
offences. The police prepared panchnama of the scene of offence and
after preparing the arrest panchnama, the accused came to be
arrested. On completion of investigation, charge sheet was submitted
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
into the Court of learned J.M.F.C.
2.1
The charge against the accused came to be framed by the trial
Court for the aforesaid offences against the accused. On being
explained it to them, the accused have denied having committed any
offence. The accused pleaded not guilty to the charge and pleaded for
trial and hence, the case was tried by the trial Court.
3.
It appears from the records that to prove the case, the
prosecution has examined the following witnesses:P.W. No.
Name of Witnesses
Exhibit
Dr.Anilkumar Gordhandas Patel
Dr.Jitendrabhai Jivrajbhai Joshi
Vinunagar Gulabgar Gosai
Nagjibhai Mangabhai
Chanabhai Mohanbhai Koli
Vasubhai Bhagvanbhai Koli
Dhanjibhai Jadavbhai
Ranchhodbhai Bijalbhai Koli
Shivabhai Bodhabhai Rathod
Rameshbhai Vaghjibhai
Girirshbhai Durlabhjibhai Luhana
Hothibhai Aamadbhai Sandhi
Rameshbhai Vashrambhai Aahir
Kamleshbhai Jayantibhai Lohana
Ahmedbhai Hasambhai Shaikh
Surajbhan Umaravsinh Yadav
Abhesinh Popatbhai Rathod
Ambashankarbhai Morarjibhai Pancholi
Rajendrasinh Ghanshyamsinh Vaghela
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
Ramvilas Shivpujansinh Sing
Mathurdas Prabhudas Ramanand
Rameshbhai Juesingbhai
4.
In addition to this, the prosecution has also produced the
following documentary evidence.
Sr. No.
Particulars
Exhibit
Postmortem note
Opinion of cause of death of the deceased
Letter written by Medical Officer to the Police
Inspector
Yadi for sending sealed bottle of blood sample of
deceased
Certificate of Dr. Joshi
for giving primary
treatment to deceased Vallabhbhai
Treatment case papers of deceased
Details of treatment given to deceased
Posthumous form sent along with the deadbody
Inquest panchnama
Recovery panchnama of the clothes of the
deceased
Arrest panchnama of accused No.5
Arrest panchnama of accused No.1, 2 and 3
Seizure panchnama of string
Seizure panchnama of Hero-Honda Motorcycle
Letter written to FSL
Forwarding Note sent along with letter
Report of sample of sealed sent to FSL for analysis
Letter written by Additional Police Commissioner to
the FSL
Receipt of Chemical Department
22, 23
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
Report of Chemical
65, 66
Order passed by PSI Shri Yadav
Map of scene of offence
Receipt regarding collecting the things from the
dead body of the deceased and sent the dead body
given to the brother of deceased.
Yadi written by Police Inspector to Medical Officer
Yadi written by PSI to Medical Officer for taking
medical certificate of Vallabhbhai Bijalbhai
Form with regard to sending things to the FSL
Details sent along with the same
Case paper of Vallabh Bijal
Form for sending things to the FSL
Arrest panchnama of accused No.4
Yadi written by PSI to Medical Officer for taking
blood sample
Notification of law and order
Panchnama of the scene of offence
Panchnama of the place where Vinugar Gulabgar
Sadhiya caught steering of the Matador
73, 74
Order with regard to handing over investigation to
Police Inspector by PSO
Entry with regard to receiving the message from
the Hospital for dying Vallabh Bijal during the
treatment
Letter for production of the accused before the
Magistrate
Remand application, which was rejected
Entry of Hospital Police Chowki with regard to
admission of Vallabh Bijal and dead
Letter written by PI to the Magistrate for addition in
charge
Yadi sent for adding Section 120(B) in the charge
Report of heavy offence
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
5.
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
Yadi of Hospital Police Chowki Register
Entry for admission in hospital for treatment to
Vallabh Bijal
After closure of the evidence, the statements of the accused
under section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 have been
recorded wherein they denied of having committed any offence and
have stated that they are innocent.
6.
After hearing both sides and considering the evidence on
records, the trial Court by impugned judgment and order has
acquitted the accused from all the charges levelled against them.
7.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforesaid judgment
and order of acquittal the appellant – State of Gujarat has preferred
this appeal.
8.
Heard Ms.Jyoti Bhatt, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for
the appellant – State of Gujarat and Mr.Viral Popat, learned counsel
appeared for the respondents – accused, however, he remained
absent.
9.
Ms.Bhatt, learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the
appellant – State of Gujarat has submitted the same facts which are
narrated in the memo of appeal and has also submitted that the
prosecution has examined witnesses and produced documentary
evidence, despite this fact, the trial Court has not considered the
same in its true and proper perspective in passing the judgment and
order of acquittal. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor, while
referring to the entire oral as well as documentary evidence, has
assailed the impugned judgment and order and submitted that the
trial Court has not taken into consideration the evidence connecting
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
the accused to the alleged offence in its proper perspective and even
the prosecution has been able to prove the charges levelled against
the accused.
9.1
While referring to the evidence of the witnesses and the
material collected against the accused, Ms.Bhatt, learned Additional
Public Prosecutor has submitted that the prosecution has established
the case against the accused by examining the witnesses, who have
supported the case of the prosecution, however, the trial Court has
discarded and disbelieved the evidence of these witnesses. Learned
Additional Public Prosecutor has submitted that the witnesses have
fully supported the case of the prosecution, however, the trial Court
has not appreciated the same and passed the judgment and order of
acquittal which is illegal and unjust.
9.2
Ms.Bhatt, learned Additional Public Prosecutor has submitted
that it is settled legal position that the evidence of a single witness is
sufficient for conviction if the same is reliable and trustworthy and in
the present case, though the evidence of all the witnesses are reliable
and trustworthy, without any cogent reason, the trial Court has
disbelieved and discarded the evidence of the witnesses.
9.3
Ms.Bhatt, learned Additional Public Prosecutor has further
submitted that the impugned judgment of acquittal is contrary to the
evidence on record, based on erroneous appreciation of material
evidence, and has resulted in a miscarriage of justice and the findings
recorded by the learned Trial Court are perverse and unsustainable in
law, thereby calling for interference by this Court in the exercise of its
appellate jurisdiction. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor has also
submitted that the learned Trial Court has materially erred in holding
that the prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
doubt and the findings recorded by the trial Court were therefore
perverse, illegal, and contrary to the evidence on record.
9.4
Ms.Bhatt,
learned
Additional
Public
Prosecutor,
while
appreciating the evidence of P.W.1 examined at Exhibit 15, who
performed the postmortem of the deceased, P.W.2 examined at
Exhibit 20, who treated the deceased and prepared MLC papers
before whom the deceased stated that he assaulted by accused with
pipe and because of that he found injury on the body of deceased,
P.W.8 examined at 30 and P.W.9 examined at 31, the trial Court has
considered the evidence and passed the impugned judgment and
order of acquittal, which is illegal, improper and erroneous. She has
submitted that
P.W.3, who was cleaner of Matador driven by the
deceased and accompanied at the time of incident, examined by the
prosecution, however, his evidence has not been appreciated by the
trial Court. She has submitted that the prosecution examined all
relevant witnesses, who were also examined by the defence and their
evidence has remained unshaken in their deposition.
9.5
According to learned Additional Public Prosecutor, the trial Court
ought to have convicted the accused and ought to have imposed
necessary sentence. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor has prayed
to allow the present appeal and to quash and set aside the impugned
judgment and order of acquittal.
10.
On perusal of the impugned judgment and order of acquittal
passed by the trial Court, the questions arise for determination are as
under:(1)
whether the trial Court has rightly justified in passing the
judgment and order of acquittal or not?
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
(2)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
whether the trial Court has rightly appreciated the oral as well
as documentary evidence led by the prosecution in recording
the reasons or not.
(3)
whether there is any illegality, irregularity and perversity in
the impugned judgment and order of acquittal or not.
11.
Considering the aforesaid submissions and aspects, this Court is
first required to examine the fact of the case. That Vallabhbhai
Bijalbhai (deceased) was residing at Village: Bedala, who abducted
minor daughter of one Hakka Pola Bharwad namely Anuben on
15.06.1996, for which the FIR came to be lodged at Rajkot Taluka
Police Station. That on 02.09.1996 at about 8.00 AM, the deceased
was driving the Matador bearing registration No. GJ-03-V-3756 and in
between Village: Hadmatiya – Golida, accused No.5 – Govind
Lakhubhai Bharwad was standing on the road and stopped the vehicle
and boarded into Matador and when they reached near Village:
Dhadhiya, accused No.5, who was sitting in Matador, tried to put his
leg on the break and also tried to snatch the steering from
Vallabhbhai and in the event, accused No.5 pushed the deceased
from the vehicle and accused No.1 tied both hands of deceased and
inflicted the stick blow on the hands and legs, at that time, accused
No.4 was driving the Hero-Honda Motorcycle and proceeded towards
Village: Bedala at about 9.30 AM and they got down from the
motorcycle and accused No.1 threw deceased on the road and
accused No.2 and 3 were inflicted stick blow on the hands and legs of
deceased, due to which, he sustained injuries and succumbed to the
injury.
12.
On perusal of the evidence of P.W.2, it appears that he
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
admitted that, since the deceased had been infused with blood, he
had noticed that there was no external bleeding injury on the body of
the deceased. However, he stated that, in the case of internal injuries,
bleeding was taking place internally. Now, in light of the evidence of
P.W.1, it appears that, in paragraph 11, he specifically deposed that
the injuries found on the body of the deceased were not on any vital
part of the body and were not likely to cause death.
13.
On perusal of the evidence of P.W.3, it emerges that he was not
declared hostile; however, his evidence requires close scrutiny. He
was the cleaner of the Matador, which was being driven by the
deceased. He deposed that accused No.5 was sitting inside the
Matador and tried to stop the vehicle by snatching the steering wheel
from the deceased. As a result, the deceased jumped from the
vehicle. Thereafter, the vehicle became uncontrolled and went into a
ditch, due to which the deceased sustained an injury to his leg. He
thereafter jumped from the vehicle and was unable to walk. In
paragraph 13 of his cross-examination, P.W.3 deposed that accused
No.5 was sitting inside the Matador, i.e. in the driver's cabin. Though
accused No.5 was present in the Trial Court, P.W.3 deposed that he
had not seen accused No.5 present in the Court. Even accused No.1
was not identified, and no Test Identification Parade was held by the
concerned Investigating Officer. Thus, P.W.3 was the first witness who
allegedly saw the incident. Thereafter, the injured was taken to the
hospital, and in sequence thereto, Dr. Joshi was the second person
before whom the deceased gave a history of the incident.
14.
From the evidence of P.W.4, who was the brother of the
deceased, it appears that he was informed by his brother that the
deceased, namely Vallabhbhai, had been beaten and was lying on the
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
road. Upon receiving the information, he reached the place and found
the deceased in a bleeding condition, with fractures to his right hand
and leg. Thereafter, he went in search of a vehicle to take the injured
to the hospital. In his cross-examination, P.W.4 admitted that the
injured had informed him that he had been beaten by Natha, Rama
and Chela with sticks. He also admitted that, although he had placed
the injured in a vehicle, no bloodstains were found on his clothes at
that time, whereas the clothes of his brother had bloodstains.
15.
On perusal of the evidence of P.W.5 and P.W.6, it appears that
they had been informed by one Shivabhai (P.W.9). On considering the
evidence of the brother of the deceased, Ranchhodbhai, vis-à-vis the
evidence of P.W.9, even if P.W.9 is considered to be a chance witness,
the conduct of Shivabhai does not appear to be natural. He saw the
injured in a bleeding condition, yet instead of providing any primary
treatment or taking immediate steps to assist him, he immediately
rushed to Village Bedala and informed the family members of the
deceased. There is no explanation as to how much time he took to
reach the village or when he returned to the spot. In fact, he projected
himself as a witness to the incident and stated that the deceased had
informed him that the three persons who were walking towards the
village had caused injuries to him with sticks. He deposed that he had
not seen the faces of all three accused persons and had only seen
them from behind. He further stated that none of the accused persons
had turned towards him. In his cross-examination, P.W.9 specifically
stated that none of the accused persons had turned towards him and
that he had not seen their faces.
16.
On perusal of the evidence of P.W.21, it appears that he was on
duty as a Police Constable at the Civil Hospital. He recorded the
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
statement of the deceased, which was sought to be treated as a dying
declaration. However, the said statement was not brought on record,
as P.W.21 deposed that he had destroyed the statement. This
constitutes the substance of the evidence of P.W.21.
17.
The evidence of P.W.21, the Head Police Constable posted at
the Civil Hospital, is important. He recorded the history of the incident
and made an entry thereof, which was in the nature of a factual
document and was sought to be treated as a statement amounting to
a dying declaration. However, the said document has not been
brought on record. This constitutes a serious lapse on the part of the
investigating agency and the police authorities who investigated the
crime in question.
18.
The cumulative effect of the prosecution evidence is that, upon
evaluating and examining the depositions of the witnesses, the
incident as narrated by them is not supported by either the oral or the
medical evidence led by the prosecution. If the injuries sustained by
the deceased are considered, they were not on any vital part of the
body. This is also supported by the deposition of P.W.1, who, in
paragraph 11, specifically stated that none of the injuries was likely to
cause death.
19.
So far as the involvement of accused Nos.4 and 5 is concerned,
no specific names were mentioned; rather, unknown persons were
referred to in connection with the incident. No Test Identification
Parade was held. Another aspect that requires consideration is the
deposition of P.W.8, who is the brother of the deceased. In paragraph
12 of his cross-examination, it has been specifically stated that blood
of the same group as that of the injured was not available and,
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
therefore, blood was procured from outside. While the blood was
being transfused into the deceased, his condition became serious and
thereafter he died. This raises a possibility that the deceased may
have succumbed to the injury due to complications arising from the
blood transfusion. From his evidence, it appears that the deceased
referred only to the names of three assailants, and no role was
attributed to accused Nos.4 and 5. The same fact was narrated by
P.W.9, who stated that he had seen three persons coming from the
direction of the sim and proceeding towards the village. When he
reached the deceased, the deceased informed him that three persons
had inflicted injuries on his legs and hands with sticks. However, this
aspect is not supported by the other evidence on record.
If the
history given by the deceased to the doctor is considered, the
deceased stated before the doctor that he had been beaten with an
iron pipe, whereas the witnesses have referred to the use of sticks.
The witnesses are ordinary villagers or cattle grazers who would
ordinarily be carrying sticks while grazing cattle.
20.
It also appears from the record that there is no satisfactory
explanation as to how the injured was untied or by whom he was
untied. The police did not recover the string from the spot. The Trial
Court, in paragraphs 60 and 61, has discussed the evidence of the
witnesses as well as the authorities cited at the Bar in detail. The Trial
Court also observed that the police had recovered the string from the
house of accused No.1 and that the same was recovered at the
instance of accused No.1. However, there was no evidence explaining
how the string reached the house of accused No.1, who had untied
the deceased, or from where the string had been brought. From the
evidence of the so-called eyewitnesses, it appears that they had not
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
seen any string in the hands of accused No.1 while accused Nos.1 and
3 were proceeding towards the village. Considering the overall facts
and evidence on record, the Trial Court, in paragraph 71, came to the
conclusion that the prosecution story was not believable.
21.
Looking to the evidence of the witnesses, namely, the near
relatives of the deceased and the chance witnesses, including
Shivabhai and another witness, it appears that their evidence does
not inspire confidence and lacks truthfulness. They are interested
witnesses/partisan witnesses. The evidence of the natural witness,
Vinugar, is completely contrary to the evidence of Ranchhodbhai, the
brother of the deceased, and the other witnesses. Vinugar also
referred to the name of one Govindbhai and another accused, neither
of whom was identified in Court. In the absence of any Test
Identification Parade, the evidence of such witnesses requires close
scrutiny. After considering the evidence of all these witnesses, the
Trial Court passed the impugned judgment and order. It is now well
settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Masalti, Munga Ram,
Bhagwati, Chandan Singh, Laxmi Prasad v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, reported in AIR 1965 SC 202, that the quality of evidence
is material and not merely the number of witnesses who give such
evidence. The Constitution Bench has enunciated the principles
governing the appreciation of the depositions of witnesses. It is true
that a conviction can be sustained only when the evidence on record
inspires confidence and establishes the prosecution case beyond
reasonable doubt. In the present case, the prosecution examined
twenty-two witnesses; however, none of their depositions inspires
confidence, and the truthfulness of their evidence is doubtful, as their
versions materially changed and their testimony was shaken during
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
cross-examination by the defence. The brother of the deceased,
Ranchhodbhai, and Shivabhai are partisan witnesses. Shivabhai is
also considered to be a chance witness, as he was grazing his cattle in
the nearby area and allegedly heard the shouting and screaming
when the persons were proceeding towards the village. He had not
seen their faces. However, when he enquired from the injured, the
injured allegedly informed him that the three persons proceeding
towards the village had inflicted injuries upon him. He, in turn,
informed the brother and other family members of the deceased.
Upon receiving the said information, they proceeded to the spot,
where they allegedly found the injured lying in a pool of blood. This
version is contrary to the medical evidence, as the doctor noticed that
there was no external bleeding and that blood was oozing internally
from the body of the deceased. In light of the aforesaid facts and the
principles enunciated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, so far as the
evidence of the witnesses is concerned, this Court is in complete
agreement with the findings recorded by the Trial Court. In view of the
above, we are of the opinion that the Trial Court has not committed
any error of fact or law in passing the impugned judgment and order.
We find no illegality or infirmity in the judgment and order passed by
the Trial Court.
22.
It is well settled by catena of decisions that an Appellate Court
has full power to review, re-appreciate and reconsider the evidence
upon which the order of acquittal is founded. However, Appellate
Court must bear in mind that in case of acquittal there is double
presumption in favour of the accused. Firstly, the presumption of
innocence is available to him under the fundamental principle of
criminal jurisprudence that every person shall be presumed to be
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
innocent unless he is proved guilty by a competent Court of law.
Secondly, the accused having secured his acquittal, the presumption
of their innocence is further reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened
by the trial Court.
23.
Further, if two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis
of the evidence on record, the Appellate Court should not disturb the
finding of acquittal recorded by the trial Court. Further, while
exercising the powers in appeal against the order of acquittal, the
Court of appeal would not ordinarily interfere with the order of
acquittal unless the approach of the lower Court is vitiated by some
manifest illegality and the conclusion arrived at would not be arrived
at by any reasonable person and, therefore, the decision is to be
characterized as perverse. Merely because two views are possible, the
Court of appeal would not take the view which would upset the
judgment delivered by the Court below. However, the Appellate Court
has a power to review the evidence if it is of the view that the
conclusion arrived at by the Court below is perverse and the Court has
committed a manifest error of law and ignored the material evidence
on record. A duty is cast upon the Appellate Court, in such
circumstances, to re-appreciate the evidence to arrive to a just
decision on the basis of material placed on record to find out whether
the accused are connected with the commission of the crime with
which they are charged.
24.
The scope and principles are enunciated by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in case of Chandrappa and others Vs. State of Karnataka
reported in (2007) 4 SCC 415, more particularly paragraph Nos.
42 and 43, which was subsequently re-affirmed by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Rajesh Prasad Vs. State of Bihar and
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
another, reported in [2022] 3 SCC 471, wherein, the Hon’ble Apex
Court has enunciated the general principles in case of acquittal, more
particularly in paragraph No. 26 the general principles are set out
by the Hon’ble Apex Court based upon various decisions of the
Hon’ble Apex Court. Then in case of
Babu
Sahebagouda
Rudragoudar Vs. State of Karnataka, reported in AIR 2024 SC
2252 = (2024) 8 SCC 149, the Hon'ble Apex Court has dealt with
the similar issue, more particularly, in paragraph Nos. 37 to 40.
Hence, we are in complete agreement with the findings recorded by
the trial Court.
25.
It is also worthwhile to refer to the recent decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ramesh vs. State of
Karnataka, reported in [2024] 9 SCC 169, wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held and observed in paras-20 and 21 as under:“20. At this stage, it would be relevant to refer to the
general principles culled out by this Court in Chandrappa
and others vs. State of Karnataka , regarding the power of
the appellate Court while dealing with an appeal against a
judgment of acquittal. The principles read thus:
“42. …. (1) An appellate court has full power to review,
reappreciate and reconsider the evidence upon which the
order of acquittal is founded.
(2) The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 puts no
limitation, restriction or condition on exercise of such
power and an appellate court on the evidence before it
may reach its own conclusion, both on questions of fact
and of law.
(3) Various expressions, such as, “substantial and
compelling reasons”, “good and sufficient grounds”, “very
strong circumstances”, “distorted conclusions”, “glaring
mistakes”, etc. are not intended to curtail extensive
powers of an appellate court in an appeal against acquittal.
Such phraseologies are more in the nature of “flourishes of
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
language” to emphasize the reluctance of an appellate
court to interfere with acquittal than to curtail the power of
the court to review the evidence and to come to its own
conclusion.
(4) An appellate court, however, must bear in mind that in
case of acquittal, there is double presumption in favour of
the accused. Firstly, the presumption of innocence is
available to him under the fundamental principle of
criminal jurisprudence that every person shall be presumed
to be innocent unless he is proved guilty by a competent
court of law. Secondly, the accused having secured his
acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is further
reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial court.
(5) If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis
of the evidence on record, the appellate court should not
disturb the finding of acquittal recorded by the trial court.
21. In Rajendra Prasad v. State of Bihar, a three-Judge
Bench of this Court pointed out that it would be essential
for the High Court, in an appeal against acquittal, to clearly
indicate firm and weighty grounds from the record for
discarding the reasons of the Trial Court in order to be able
to reach a contrary conclusion of guilt of the accused. It
was further observed that, in an appeal against acquittal, it
would not be legally sufficient for the High Court to take a
contrary view about the credibility of witnesses and it is
absolutely imperative that the High Court convincingly
finds it well-nigh impossible for the Trial Court to reject
their testimony. This was identified as the quintessence of
the jurisprudential aspect of criminal justice. Viewed in this
light, the brusque approach of the High Court in dealing
with the appeal, resulting in the conviction of Appellant
Nos. 1 and 2, reversing the cogent and well-considered
judgment of acquittal by the Trial Court giving them the
benefit of doubt, cannot be sustained.”
26.
Considering the entire evidence on record, it clearly appears
that there is no credible evidence to connect the present accused with
the alleged crime and the evidence on record is not so convincing to
prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused has committed the
alleged crime. Therefore, the accused cannot be convicted on the
R/CR.A/1112/1998(GJHC240326241998)
JUDGMENT DATED: 14/09/2026
evidence on record.
27.
On perusal of the impugned judgment and order, it clearly
transpires that the trial Court has not committed any error of fact and
law in appreciating the evidence on record and in acquitting the
accused from the charges levelled against them. Even on reappreciation of the evidence, it clearly transpires that the prosecution
has miserably failed to prove the charge levelled against the accused
beyond reasonable doubt. Therefore, the impugned judgment and
order of the trial Court is sustainable and the present appeal is liable
to be dismissed.
28.
In view of the above, the present appeal is devoid of merits and
it deserves to be dismissed. Resultantly, it is dismissed. The
impugned judgment and order of acquittal passed by the trial Court is
hereby
confirmed.
Bail
bond
stands
cancelled.
Record
and
proceedings be sent back to the concerned Trial Court forthwith.
(HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK,J)
(MOOL CHAND TYAGI, J)
V.R. PANCHAL
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review