Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 516 of 2003
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE SANJEEV J.THAKER
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
STATE OF GUJARAT
Versus
HARILAL @ HARIYA CHHOTUBHAI GAMIT
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR JK SHAH, APP for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MR.SUBHASH G BAROT(2619) for the Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE SANJEEV J.THAKER
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
Date : 09/01/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE SANJEEV J.THAKER)
1.
Feeling
aggrieved
by
and
dissatisfied
with
the
judgment and order of acquittal dated 28.10.2002, passed by
the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Navsari, in Sessions
Case No.11 of 2002, for the offences punishable under Section
302 of the Indian Penal Code, the appellant – State of
Gujarat has preferred this appeal under Section 378 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, “the Code”).
R/CR.A/516/2003
2.
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
The prosecution case as unfolded during the trial
before the lower Court is that the complainant-Manubhai
Babubhai Gamit is residing
taluka;
that
his
younger
with his family in Vansda
brother-Bachu
got
married
with
Gitaben before fifteen years and he has two sons out of the
said wedlock-Dharmesh and Tejas, out of whom, Tejas was
aged 6 and studying in first standard; that on 8.11.2001 at
17.30 hours, Tejas went missing from the verandah ( faliya)
and when he was not found inspite of great efforts, the
younger brother of the complainant informed about the same
in the police chowky of Unai outpost on 10.11.2001; that on
11.11.2001, the complainant’s brother Bachu and Arvind and
other persons went to Navsari in search of Tejas and the
complainant
was
searching
for
him
in
the
village;
the
complainant’s brother Sanmukh informed him that he last
saw
Tejas
on
8.11.2001
at
5.30
hours;
that
when
the
complainant was at home, Gulab Magan of the said faliya
came and informed one lady came to him and informed that
one
child’s
dead
body
is
found
in
the
isolated
well
of
Kishanbhai; therefore, the complainant, Gulabbhai, Chandan
Manji, Bhikha Devji, the complainant’s brother Sanmukh etc.
went to the field of Kishanbhai and saw in the well and
found that the dead body of Tejas was floating therein;
therefore,
the
complainant
filed
outpost.
the
complaint
in
Unai
R/CR.A/516/2003
3.
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
After investigation, sufficient prima facie evidence
was found against the accused person/s and therefore chargesheet was filed in the competent criminal Court. Since the
offence alleged against the accused person/s was exclusively
triable by the Court of Sessions, the learned Magistrate
committed the case to the Sessions Court where it came to
be registered as Sessions Case No.11 of 2002. The charge
was
framed
against
the
accused
person/s.
The
accused
pleaded not guilty and came to be tried.
4.
has
In order to bring home the charge, the prosecution
examined
documentary
witnesses
evidence
before
and
the
also
trial
produced
Court,
which
are
described in the impugned judgment.
5.
After hearing both the parties and after analysis
of evidence adduced by the prosecution, the learned trial
Judge acquitted the accused for the offences for which the
charge was framed, by holding that the prosecution has failed
to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt.
6.
Learned
APP
for
the
appellant
–
State
has
pointed out the facts of the case and having taken this Court
through both, oral and documentary evidence, recorded before
the learned trial Court, would submit that the learned trial
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
Court has failed to appreciate the evidence in true sense and
perspective; and that the trial Court has committed error in
acquitting the accused. It is submitted that the learned trial
Court
ought
not
to
have
given
much
emphasis
to
the
contradictions and/or omissions appearing in the evidence and
ought to have given weightage to the dots that connect the
accused with the offence in question.
the
learned
trial
Court
has
It is submitted that
erroneously
come
to
the
conclusion that the prosecution has failed to prove its case. It
is also submitted that the learned Judge ought to have seen
that
the
evidence
produced
on
record
is
reliable
and
believable and it was proved beyond reasonable doubt that
the accused had committed an offence in question. It is,
therefore, submitted that this Court may allow this appeal by
appreciating the evidence led before the learned trial Court.
7.
As
against
that,
learned
advocate
for
the
respondent/s would support the impugned judgment passed by
the learned trial Court and has submitted that the learned
trial Court has not committed any error in acquitting the
accused. The trial Court has taken possible view as the
prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable
doubt. Therefore, it is prayed to dismiss the present appeal
by confirming the impugned judgment and order passed by
the learned trial Court.
R/CR.A/516/2003
8.
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
In the aforesaid background, considering the oral
as well as documentary evidence on record, independently and
dispassionately and considering the impugned judgment and
order of the trial Court, the following aspects weighed with
the Court :
8.1
The prosecution has relied on the deposition of the
mother of the deceased viz., Gitaben Bachubhai Gamit, who
has
been
examined
as
P.W.2,
vide
Exh.15
and
if
her
deposition is taken into consideration, she has stated that she
married with Bachubhai and from the said marriage, she had
two children i.e. Dharmesh (elder son) and deceased Tejas
(younger son); and that at the time of incident, deceased
Tejas was studying in 1
st
standard and was six years old;
and that at the time of the incident, her husband was
staying in Surat and used to come to the village only once
in a month and when she used to go to Government borewell
to fill water, she used to meet accused over there and slowly
her relation with the accused was developed and they also
got physically involved with each other and during night
hours, the accused used to come to the residence of the said
witness - Gitaben and whenever the accused used to come at
night hours, she would wake up and go out and have
physical relation with the accused and the said witness –
Gitaben, who is a mother of the deceased Tejas, has also
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
stated that once she was sleeping with the accused, the son
of the deceased came to know and asked the witness that
why is the accused sleeping with her and at that point of
time, the said witness had informed the accused that the
deceased
Tejas
has
come
to
know
about
their
physical
intimacy and therefore he should not come to her residence
and at that point of time, the accused informed the deponent
- Gitaben that she should not worry; and that he will make
Tejas understand and she should continue to have physical
relation with the accused. The said witness has also further
stated that on 08.11.2001, the deceased’s son went missing
and the deponent i.e. the mother of the deceased, mother-inlaw, sister-in-law and elder sister-in-law (‘Jethani’) started
searching for deceased Tejas.
At around 9:00 p.m., when the accused came at
the
house
of
the
deponent
from
backdoor,
the
deponent
thought that the Tejas had come and therefore, she opened
the door and at that time, she saw the accused; and that
the accused informed her that, her son - Tejas is with him
as she has not kept physical relation with him since one
month and therefore, Tejas is in his possession; and that if
she will again keep physical relation with the accused, he
(the accused) will keep Tejas safe; and that upon assurance,
the deponent had kept physical relation with the accused.
Further,
the
accused
had
also
threatened
the
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
deponent that she should not inform this fact to anyone in
the family, otherwise he will kill Tejas and her.
In her cross-examination, the deponent also does
not explain as to why she did not file a missing complaint of
Tejas on the same day and filed a complaint on the next
day. There are lot of contradictions in the statement given by
her before the police and in her deposition. In her police
statement, she has not stated that the accused had told the
deponent that if she will keep physical relation with him, he
will treat Tejas well. She has also admitted that she had
informed the police of his relation with the accused only on
13.11.2001. The dead body of Tejas was found on 11.11.2001
and the police came on the next day.
8.2
If the deposition of P.W.1 - Manubhai Babubhai
Gamit, who has been examined vide Exh.8, is taken into
consideration vis-a-vis the complaint - Exh.9, in his crossexamination, P.W.1 has stated that he had not informed that
the accused had killed Tejas, because his brother’s wife Gitaben did not keep physical relation with the accused. He
has also stated that he is not aware as to how Tejas has
expired. He has also admitted in his cross-examination that
Tejas has been murdered just because he may not reveal the
relationship of the accused with Gitaben i.e. the mother of
Tejas.
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
If the deposition of P.W.2 - Gitaben (Exh.15) is
taken into consideration, she has stated that till 10
th
date,
she did not doubt on any person of murder of Tejas.
8.3
The father of Tejas - Bachubhai Gamit has been
examined as P.W.3, vide Exh.16. He has stated that on 9
th
date, when he had come home, his wife - Gitaben has not
informed him as to how Tejas was missing.
8.4
If
the
oral
evidence
of
P.W.7
-
Dr.Ravindra
Garasiya, who has been examined vide Exh.20, who has
conducted
the postmortem, is
taken into consideration,
it
transpires that the cause of death of deceased - Tejas was –
asphyxia due to strangulation (as per postmortem note –
Exh.21).
8.5
In the present case, there is no eye witness to the
incident. It is the case of the prosecution that the accused
had taken deceased - Tejas on his cycle on 08.11.2001.
The
prosecution
has
relied
on
the
evidence
of
P.W.5 - Sanmukhbhai Babubhai, who has been examined vide
Exh.18, P.W.4 -Babubhai Dhedabhai Gamit, who has been
examined vide Exh.17 and P.W.2 - Gitaben Bachubhai Gamit,
who has been examined vide Exh.15.
If the evidence of P.W.5 - Sanmukhbhai Babubhai
(Exh.18) is taken into consideration, he has stated that he
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
had seen deceased - Tejas when he had gone to graze the
cattle at 5:30 p.m. Whereas, P.W.4 – Babubhai Dhedabhai
Gamit (Exh.17) has stated that he had seen the accused with
deceased - Tejas at 6.00 p.m. Whereas, P.W.2 - Gitaben
Bachubhai Gamit (Exh.15) has stated that when she came
back at 6.30 p.m., Tejas had come and stated that the
accused was calling her and thereafter Tejas went for playing
and did not return.
The prosecution has not proved that after 6.30
p.m., the deceased - Tejas has been seen with the accused;
and that the prosecution has also not proved that after 6.30
p.m., the accused was with the deceased - Tejas.
8.6
The prosecution has mainly tried to put forward
their case by evidence of mother of the deceased – Tejas viz.,
Gitaben - P.W.2 (Exh.15). In her deposition, she has admitted
that she had physical relation with the accused; and that the
accused used to come and have physical relation with her;
and
that
since
last
one
month,
there
was
no
physical
relationship between them. The case of the prosecution was
that just because the said witness – P.W.2 has refused for
physical relation with the accused, the accused had taken
deceased - Tejas and then killed him.
The prosecution is trying to rely on extra judicial
confession of the fact that the accused had informed the said
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
witness (P.W.2) that he had taken the deceased - Tejas with
him.
However,
the
fact
remains
that
P.W.1
-
Manubhai
Babubhai Gamit (Exh.8) has clearly stated that on the date
when
Tejas
went
missing,
he
and
other
neighbours
had
gathered at the house of Tejas till 10 p.m and all had gone
to search for Tejas and for the entire night, they did not
sleep and searched for Tejas.
In
his
cross-examination,
P.W.4
–
Babubhai
Dhedabhai Gamit (P.W.17) has also clearly stated that in the
evening,
Tejas
did
not
come
home
and
everybody
was
searching for him.
P.W.5 – Sanmukhbhai Babubhai (Exh.18) has also
stated that Tejas had not come back and all were waiting at
the residence thinking that Tejas would come back.
It also transpires from the evidence of P.W.1 Manubhai
Babubhai
Gamit
(Exh.8)
that
around
p.m.,
Kishore had gone to telephonically inform the father of Tejas
and till the time he came back, everybody was waiting at
the
house
of
Tejas
i.e.
residence
of
P.W.2
–
Gitaben
Bachubhai Gamit. The said witness has also stated that
there is no backdoor entry in the house of P.W.2 - Gitaben
Bachubhai Gamit; and that there is only one door at the
front side.
8.7
In view of the aforesaid fact, the Sessions Court
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
has held that when the elders and others were there in the
house, it cannot be believed that the accused had come to
meet P.W.2 - Gitaben and had threatened her and had
physical
relation
with
her
when
the
entire
village
was
anxiously waiting for deceased – Tejas outside the house.
Therefore, the Sessions Court has rightly not considered the
version of P.W.2 – Gitaben Bachubhai Gamit, wherein she
has stated that the accused himself had informed her that he
has the custody of her son – Tejas. The prosecution has also
not proved that the accused was found near the Well, where
the dead body was found or that anybody had seen the
accused near the Well where the dead body was found. The
prosecution has also not been able to prove the ‘last seen
theory’. The fact remains that when the son - Tejas was
missing, her mother Gitaben (P.W.2) also did not inform to
any
of
the
family
members
about
the
said
fact.
Such
demeanor of Gitaben – P.W.2, who is a mother of the
deceased – Tejas, does not inspire confidence. There is also
no justification as to why Gitaben – P.W.2, a mother of the
deceased – Tejas, filed a complaint at a belated stage. There
is also no evidence of the presence of the accused near the
place where the dead body of the deceased was found. The
extra
judicial
confession
of
the
accused
also
cannot
be
believed in view of the fact that the evidence of P.W.2 –
Gitaben herself is doubtful. The prosecution has not been
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
able to prove the fact that on 08.11.2001, the accused had
called Gitaben and had informed her about the said fact that
her son - Tejas is with him.
9.1
In the Case of State of Rajasthan V/s Bhanwar
Singh Etc. Etc. reported in 2025(0) AIJEL-SC 75937, the
Apex Court has observed in paragraph 39 as under:
“39. This Court in Babu Sahebagouda
Rudragoudar
v.
State
of
Karnataka,
(2024) 8 SCC 149, reiterated following
principles governing interference by the
appellate
Court
with
a
judgment
of
acquittal:41. Thus, it is beyond the pale of doubt
that the scope of interference by an
appellate
court
for
reversing
the
judgment of acquittal recorded by the
trial court in favour of the accused has
to be exercised within the four corners
of the following principles:
41.1.
That
the
judgment
of
acquittal
suffers from patent perversity;
41.2. That the same is based on a
misreading/omission to consider material
evidence on record; and
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
41.3. That no two reasonable views are
possible and only the view consistent
with the guilt of the accused is possible
from the evidence available on record.
42. The appellate court, in order to
interfere with the judgment of acquittal
would have to record pertinent findings
on the above factors if it is inclined to
reverse
the
judgment
of
acquittal
rendered by the trial court.”
9.2
and
In the Case of Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar
Others
V/s
State
of
Karnataka
reported
in
2024(0)
AIJEL-SC 73556, the Apex Court has observed in paragraphs
37, 38 and 39 as under:
“37. This Court in the case of Rajesh
Prasad v. State of Bihar and Another,
(2022)
SCC
encapsulated
the
legal position covering the field after
considering
various
earlier
judgments
to
catena
and held as below: “29.
After
judgments,
following
referring
this Court
general
a
culled
principles
out
of
the
regarding
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
the powers of the appellate court while
dealing with an appeal against an order
of
acquittal
in
the
following
words:
[ Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka,
(2007) 4 SCC 415]
“42. From the above decisions, in our
considered view, the following general
principles
regarding
powers
of
the
appellate court while dealing with an
appeal
against
an
order
of
acquittal
emerge:
(1) An appellate court has full power to
review, reappreciate and reconsider the
evidence
upon
which
the
order
of
acquittal is founded.
(2) The Criminal Procedure Code, 1973
puts
no
limitation,
restriction
or
condition on exercise of such power and
an
appellate
court
on
the
evidence
before it may reach its own conclusion,
both on questions of fact and of law.
(3)
Various
expressions,
“substantial
and
“good
sufficient
and
compelling
such
as,
reasons”,
grounds”,
“very
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
strong
circumstances,”
“distorted
conclusions”, “glaring mistakes”, etc. are
not intended to curtail extensive powers
of
an
appellate
court
in
an
appeal
against acquittal. Such phraseologies are
more in the nature of “flourishes of
language” to emphasize the reluctance of
an
appellate
court
to
interfere
with
acquittal than to curtail the power of
the court to review the evidence and to
come to its own conclusion.
(4) An appellate court, however, must
bear in mind that in case of acquittal,
there is double presumption in favour of
the accused. Firstly, the presumption of
innocence is available to him under the
fundamental
principle
of
criminal
jurisprudence that every person shall be
presumed to be innocent unless he is
proved guilty by a competent court of
law.
Secondly,
the
accused
having
secured his acquittal, the presumption of
his
innocence
is
further
reinforced,
reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial
court.
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
(5) If two reasonable conclusions are
possible on the basis of the evidence on
record, the appellate court should not
disturb the finding of acquittal recorded
by the trial court.”.
38.
Further,
Sundara
in
the
case
of
H.D.
&
Ors.
v.
State
of
Karnataka, (2023) 9 SCC 581 this Court
summarized the principles governing the
exercise of appellate jurisdiction while
dealing with an appeal against acquittal
under Section 378 of CrPC as follows: “8.1.The acquittal of the accused further
strengthens
the
presumption
of
innocence;
8.2. The appellate court, while hearing
an appeal against acquittal, is entitled
to
reappreciate
the
oral
and
documentary evidence;
8.3. The appellate court, while deciding
an appeal against acquittal, after reappreciating the evidence, is required to
consider whether the view taken by the
trial
court
is
a
possible
view
which
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
could have been taken on the basis of
the evidence on record;
8.4. If the view taken is a possible
view,
the
appellate
court
cannot
overturn the order of acquittal on the
ground
that
another
view
was
also
possible; and
8.5. The appellate court can interfere
with the order of acquittal only if it
comes
to
finding
that
the
only
conclusion which can be recorded on the
basis of the evidence on record was
that
the
guilt
of
the
accused
was
proved beyond a reasonable doubt and
no other conclusion was possible.”
39. Thus, it is beyond the pale of doubt
that the scope of interference by an
appellate
Court
for
reversing
the
judgment of acquittal recorded by the
trial Court in favour of the accused has
to be exercised within the four corners
of the following principles:(a)
That
the
judgment
of
suffers from patent perversity;
acquittal
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
(b)
That
the
same
is
based
on
a
misreading/omission to consider material
evidence on record;
(c) That no two reasonable views are
possible and only the view consistent
with the guilt of the accused is possible
from the evidence available on record.”
In the Case of Ballu @ Balram @ Balmukund V/s
9.3
State
of
Madhra
Pradesh,
reported
in
2024(0)
AIJEL-SC
73457, the Apex Court has observed in paragraph 9 as
under:
“9. Apart from that, it is to be noted that
the present case is a case of reversal of
acquittal.
The
law
with
regard
to
interference by the Appellate Court is very
well
crystallized.
acquittal
impossible,
is
Unless
found
to
interference
the
finding
of
be
perverse
or
with
the
same
would not be warranted. Though, there are
a catena of judgments on the issue, we
will only refer to two judgments which the
High Court itself has reproduced in the
impugned
judgment,
which
are
as
reproduced below:
"13. In case of Sadhu Saran Singh vs.
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
State
of
U.P.
(2016)
SCC
397,
the
Supreme Court has held that:"In an appeal against acquittal where the
presumption of innocence in favour of the
accused is reinforced, the appellate Court
would interfere with the order of acquittal
only when there is perversity of fact and !
aw.
However,
we
believe
that
the
paramount consideration of the Court is to
do
substantial
justice
and
avoid
miscarriage of justice which can arise by
acquitting the accused who is guilty of an
offence. A miscarriage of justice that may
occur by the acquittal of the guilty is no
less
than
from
innocent.
the
conviction
Appellate
Court,
of
an
while
enunciating the principles with regard to
the scope of powers of the appellate Court
in an appeal against acquittal, has no
absolute restriction in law to review and
relook the entire evidence on which the
order of acquittal is founded."
14.
Similar,
In
case
of
Harljan
Bhala
Teja vs. State of Gujarat (2016) 12 SCC
665 , the Supreme Court has held that:"No
doubt,
where,
on
appreciation
of
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
evidence on record, two views are possible,
and the trial court has taken a view of
acquittal, the appellate court should not
interfere
with
the
same.
However,
this
does not mean that in all the cases where
the trial court has recorded acquittal, the
same should not be interfered with, even
if the view is perverse. Where the view
taken by the trial court is against the
weight of evidence on record, or perverse,
it is always open far the appellate court
to
express
the
right
conclusion
after
reappreciating the evidence If the charge
is
proved
beyond
reasonable
doubt
on
record, and convict the accused."
10.
Further, learned APP is not in a position to show
any evidence to take a contrary view in the matter or that
the approach of the Court below is vitiated by some manifest
illegality or that the decision is perverse or that the Court
below has ignored the material evidence on record. In above
view of the matter, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the Court below was completely justified in passing
impugned judgment and order.
11.
Considering
the
impugned
judgment,
the
trial
R/CR.A/516/2003
Court
has
connecting
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
recorded
the
that
accused
there
with
was
the
no
direct
incident
and
evidence
there
are
contradictions in the depositions of the prosecution witnesses.
In absence of the direct evidence, it cannot be proved that
the accused are involved in the offence. Further, the motive
of the accused behind the incident is not established. The
trial Court has rightly considered all the evidence on record
and passed the impugned judgment. The trial Court has
rightly evaluated the facts and the evidence on record.
12.
It is also a settled legal position that in acquittal
appeal, the appellate court is not required to re-write the
judgment
or
to
give
fresh
reasoning,
when
the
reasons
assigned by the Court below are found to be just and proper.
Such principle is down by the Apex Court in the case of
State of Karnataka Vs. Hemareddy, reported in AIR 1981 SC
1417 wherein it is held as under:
“…
This
Nandini
court
has
observed
Devi
V.
Bigendra
in
Girija
Nandini
Chaudhary (1967)1 SCR 93: (AIR 1967 SC
1124)
that
it
is
not
the
duty
of
the
appellate court when it agrees with the
view of the trial court on the evidence to
repeat the narration of the evidence or to
reiterate
the
reasons
given
by
the
trial
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
court expression of general agreement with
the reasons given by the Court the decision
of which is under appeal, will ordinarily
suffice.”
13.
Thus, in case the appellate court agrees with the
reasons and the opinion given by the lower court, then the
discussion of evidence at length is not necessary.
14.
In the case of Ram Kumar v. State of Haryana,
reported in AIR 1995 SC 280, Supreme Court has held as
under:
“The powers of the High Court in an appeal
from
order
evidence
of
and
acquittal
to
reach
own
its
reassess
the
conclusions
under Sections 378 and 379, Cr.P.C. are as
extensive as in any appeal against the order
of conviction. But as a rule of prudence, it
is desirable that the High Court should give
proper weight and consideration to the view
of
the
Trial
Court
with
regard
to
the
credibility of the witness, the presumption of
innocence in favour of the accused, the right
of the accused to the benefit of any doubt
and
the
slowness
of
appellate
Court
in
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
justifying a finding of fact arrived at by a
Judge who had the advantage of seeing the
witness. It is settled law that if the main
grounds
on
which
the
lower
Court
has
based its order acquitting the accused are
reasonable
and
plausible,
and
the
same
cannot entirely and effectively be dislodged
or demolished, the High Court should not
disturb the order of acquittal."
15.
As observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of Rajesh Singh & Others vs. State of Uttar Pradesh
reported
in
(2011)
SCC
and
in
the
case
of
Bhaiyamiyan Alias Jardar Khan and Another vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh reported in (2011) 6 SCC 394, while dealing
with the judgment of acquittal, unless reasoning by the trial
Court is found to be perverse, the acquittal cannot be upset.
It is further observed that High Court's interference in such
appeal in somewhat circumscribed and if the view taken by
the trial Court is possible on the evidence, the High Court
should stay its hands and not interfere in the matter in the
belief that if it had been the trial Court, it might have
taken a different view.
16.
In the case of Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka,
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
reported in (2007) 4 SCC 415, the Hon’ble Apex Court has
observed as under:
“42.
From
the
above
decisions,
in
our
considered
view,
the
following
general
principles regarding powers of the appellate
court while dealing with an appeal against
an order of acquittal emerge:
(1) An appellate court has full power to
review,
reappreciate
and
reconsider
the
evidence upon which the order of acquittal
is founded.
(2) The Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 puts
no
limitation,
restriction
or
condition
on
exercise of such power and an appellate
court on the evidence before it may reach
its own conclusion, both on questions of fact
and of law.
(3) Various expressions, such as, “substantial
and compelling reasons”, “good and sufficient
grounds”,
“very
strong
“distorted
conclusions”,
circumstances”,
“glaring
mistakes”,
etc. are not intended to curtail extensive
powers of an appellate court in an appeal
against
more
acquittal.
in
the
Such
nature
phraseologies
are
of
of
“flourishes
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
language” to emphasise the reluctance of an
appellate court to interfere with acquittal
than to curtail the power of the court to
review the evidence and to come to its own
conclusion.
(4) An appellate court, however, must bear
in mind that in case of acquittal, there is
double presumption in favour of the accused.
Firstly,
the
available
principle
every
presumption
of
innocence
to
him
the
fundamental
of
criminal
jurisprudence
person
shall
presumed
under
be
is
that
to
be
innocent unless he is proved guilty by a
competent
court
of
law.
Secondly,
the
accused having secured his acquittal, the
presumption
of
his
innocence
is
further
reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by
the trial court.
(5)
If
two
reasonable
conclusions
are
possible on the basis of the evidence on
record,
the
appellate
court
should
not
disturb the finding of acquittal recorded by
the trial court.”
17.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in the recent decision in
the case of Constable 907 Surendra Singh and Another V/s
State of Uttarakhand reported in (2025) 5 SCC 433, has held
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
in paragraph 24 as under:
“24. It could thus be seen that it is a
settled
legal
position
that
the
interference with the finding of acquittal
recorded
by
the
learned
trial
Judge
would be warranted by the High Court
only if the judgment of acquittal suffers
from patent perversity; that the same is
based
on
consider
a
misreading/omission
material
evidence
on
to
record;
and that no two reasonable views are
possible and only the view consistent
with the guilt of the accused is possible
from the evidence available on record.”
18.
Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances
of the case and law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
while considering the scope of appeal under Section 378 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 no case is made out to
interfere with the impugned judgment and order of acquittal.
19.
In view of above facts and circumstances of the
case, on our careful re-appreciation of the entire evidence, we
found
that
there
is
no
infirmity
or
irregularity
in
the
R/CR.A/516/2003
JUDGMENT DATED: 09/01/2026
findings of fact recorded by learned trial Court and under
the
circumstances,
the
learned
trial
Court
has
rightly
acquitted the respondent/s - accused for the elaborate reasons
stated in the impugned judgment and we also endorse the
view/finding
of
the
learned
trial
Court
leading
to
the
acquittal.
20.
In view of the above and for the reasons stated
above, the present Criminal Appeal fails to prove its case
and the same deserves to be dismissed and is dismissed,
accordingly.
Record
&
Proceedings
be
remitted
to
the
concerned trial Court forthwith.
(SANJEEV J.THAKER,J)
(L. S. PIRZADA, J)
SRILATHA
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review