Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:7581-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ACQA No. 752 of 2019
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Incharge Police Station Nandini
Nagar, District Durg Chhattisgarh, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
versus
1 - Purushottam Patel @ Gol S/o Rohit Patel, Aged About 24 Years,
R/o. Basghat Madesara, P.S. Nandini Nagar, District Durg Chhattisgarh,
District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
2 - Hemsingh Patel S/o Late Karan Singh, Aged About 40 Years, R/o.
Basghat Medesara, P.S. Nandini Nagar, District Durg Chhattisgarh,
District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
3 - Rohit Lodhi S/o Late Karan Singh, Aged About 52 Years, R/o.
Basghat Medesara, P.S. Nandini Nagar, District Durg Chhattisgarh,
District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant/State
: Mr. Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate.
For Respondents
: Mr. B.P. Singh, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
09-02-2026
MOHAMMED
AADIL KHAN
Date: 2026.02.11
19:53:25 +0530
1.
This acquittal appeal has been filed by the State against the
impugned judgment dated 27-05-2019 passed by the learned 4 th
Additional Sessions Judge, Durg, District Durg (C.G.) in S.T.
No.121/2017 whereby the learned trial Court has acquitted the
respondents/accused persons from the offence under Section 294
and 506B of the IPC and instead of Section 307/34 of the IPC
they have been convicted under Section 323/34 and 341/34 of the
IPC.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that on 03-05-2017 complainant
Ramavtar Patel PW-5 lodged a report Ex.-P/3 against the
respondents/accused persons that at about 10 a.m. when he was
returning from Pathariya along with the timber required for
construction of his new house, on the way the accused persons
wrongfully restrained them by saying that they will not permit to
pass through the way, threatened and abused them. When they
protested, the accused persons assaulted them by lathi, after
hearing his noise his father Gend Singh, elder brother Pukhraj,
uncle Dular and mother Kumari Bai came there and intervened.
The accused persons also assaulted them and accused Rohit
exhorted the other accused persons to kill all of them. He received
grievous injuries on his head, Dular received injuries by assault
made by accused Purushottam Patel by axe who has been taken
to Durg hospital. His mother and father have also received
injuries. The FIR has been registered under Section 294, 506B,
341, 307, 34 of the IPC. The injured persons, Ramavtar PW-5,
Dular Singh PW-3, Pukhraj, Kumari Bai PW-4 and Gend Singh
PW-2 were sent for their medical examination to CHC Ahiwara
where PW-11 Doctor Sushma Gond medically examined Kumari
Bai, Gend Singh and Dular Singh, Ramavtar, Pukhraj and gave
her report Ex.-P/9, P/10, P/11, P/12/Ex.-D/2 and Ex.-P/13
respectively. Spot map Ex.-P/2 was prepared by Patwari and Ex.P/4 was prepared by police. The T-shirt of injured Ramavtar Patel,
shirt of injured Gend Singh have been seized vide seizure memo
Ex.-P/5 and P/6. The accused Rohit Lodhi was arrested on 09-052017 and his memorandum statement was recorded and based
on his memorandum statement one bamboo club has been seized
vide seizure memo Ex.-P/8. The memorandum statement of
accused Purushottam Patel was recorded on 03-05-2017 which is
Ex.-P/14. The memorandum statement of Hem Singh was also
recorded which is Ex.-P/15. From the accused Purushottam Patel
axe has been seized vide seizure memo Ex.-P/16. From the
accused Hem Singh one bamboo club has been seized vide
seizure memo Ex.-P/17. From injured Dular Singh one full shirt
has been seized vide seizure memo Ex.-P/18. The clothes and
axe were sent for its query report to the doctor from where query
report Ex.-P/26 and P/27 were received and the doctor has opined
that the injury found on the body of Dular Singh could have been
caused by the axe, the injury caused to Ramavtar could have
been caused by hard and blunt object, the injury of Dular Singh is
grievous in nature so there was possibility of death of Dular Singh
due to excessive blood loss and the injury found on the injured is
a head injury. For confirmation of blood in the clothes they
referred it to chemical examination. The clothes were sent for its
FSL examination to State FSL, Raipur and after completion of
usual investigation charge sheet was filed against the accused
persons for the offence under Section 294, 323, 506B, 341, 307
and 34 of the IPC before the learned Judicial Magistrate First
Class Durg. The case was committed to the learned Sessions
Court Durg from where it has been transferred to the learned trial
Court.
3.
The learned trial Court has framed charge against the accused
persons for the offence under Section 341/34, 294, 506B and
307/34 of the IPC. The accused persons denied the charge and
claimed trial.
4.
In order to prove the charge against the respondents/accused
persons the prosecution has examined as many as 11 witnesses.
Statement of the accused persons under Section 313 of the
Cr.P.C. have also been recorded in which they have denied the
circumstances that appeared against them, pleaded innocence
and have submitted that they have been falsely implicated in the
offence. In support of their defence two defence witnesses
Purushottam Patel DW-1 and Chandrika Prasad Sahu DW-2 have
been examined by the accused persons.
5.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by
the parties, the learned trial Court acquitted the accused persons
from the offence under Section 294 and 506B of the IPC and
instead of convicting them for the offence under Section 307/34 of
the IPC they have been convicted for the offence under Section
323/34 and 341/34 of the IPC. Hence, this acquittal appeal.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that
there are sufficient evidence against the accused persons that
they caused grievous injuries to the body of Dular Singh with
intention to commit his murder. The grievous injury found on the
body of Dular Singh that too on vital part of his head which is
completely ignored by the learned trial Court. He would further
submit that in the offence under Section 307 of the IPC nature of
injuries is immaterial, but the intention coupled with some overt
act is to be seen, which is present in the case. The manner in
which the accused persons assaulted the injured persons clearly
demonstrates their intention that they determined to commit his
murder. From the evidence of the doctor and the injury report of
Dular Singh as well as the other injured persons the offence of
Section 307 of the IPC has duly been proved by the prosecution,
yet the learned trial Court instead of convicting the accused
persons for the offence under Section 307 of the IPC convicted
them for the offence under Section 323/34 of the IPC. He would
also submit that from the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
PW-2 Gend Singh, PW-3 Dular Singh, PW-4 Kumari Bai and PW5 Ramavtar the offence of Section 294, 506B of the IPC have duly
been proved, yet the accused persons have been acquitted.
Therefore, the acquittal appeal mayy be allowed and the accused
persons may be convicted under Section 307 of the IPC and be
sentenced accordingly.
7.
On
the
other
hand,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents/accused persons supported the impugned judgment
and would submit that after adverting the entire facts and
circumstances as well as the injury report of the injured persons
the learned trial Court has rightly passed the judgment of
conviction and sentence and the accused persons have been
convicted for the offence under Section 323/34 of the IPC which is
absolutely justified and needs no interference.
8.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record of the learned trial Court.
9.
It is alleged that when the injured persons returning back to their
house along with timber for construction of new house, on the way
the accused persons restrained them and assaulted by lathi and
axe. It is the case of the prosecution that the timber was being
brought by Ramavtar PW-5 and when he was being wrongfully
restrained he made noise and then the other injured persons
including Dular Singh came there to intervene. When they
intervened they were also assaulted by the accused persons.
10.
Dular Singh PW-3 has stated in his evidence that when he
reached on the spot the accused persons were assaulting
Ramavtar by lathi, danda and Rohit assaulted him by danda and
Purushottam assaulted him by axe, thereafter, he fled away from
the place. He denied previous dispute between them. The
prosecution has emphasised for imposing conviction of the
accused persons under Section 307 of the IPC with respect to the
injuries caused to Dular Singh PW-3. It is not the case that the
accused persons have intentionally caused injuries to Dular
Singh, but it is the case that Dular Singh intervened and he too
was assaulted by the accused persons and after receiving injuries
he fled away from the place.
11.
PW-5 Ramavtar who was the person who had taken the timber in
his tractor has stated in his evidence that the accused persons
have restrained them by saying that the will not permit to go
through from that way and then altercation started between them.
When he raised voice for help then his uncle Gulal, father Hem
Singh and mother Kumari Bai and brother Pukhraj came and then
the accused persons also started assaulting them and by the
assault made by the accused persons they received injuries on
various parts of their body. In cross-examination he admitted that
6 months back he, Pukhraj and Gend Singh assaulted Laxman by
which he received fracture in his leg and he is facing trial. He
admitted that prior to the incident, they were having no any
dispute with the accused persons and there is no dispute with
respect to passing through the way. Certain discrepancies have
been admitted by him in his police statement as well as Court
statement. He also admitted that after the first incident the
accused persons have not tried to again assault them.
12.
PW-2 Gend Singh is also a witness who had gone there after
hearing the alarm raised by Ramavtar PW-5 and when they
intervened altercation started and the accused persons assaulted
him also. He admitted in his cross-examination that there was a
dispute with the accused persons since 30 years with respect to
the land. He further admitted ;that in the tractor Ramavtar was
alone there and they were working in the field. He also admitted
that before the incident the accused persons have lodged a report
against them and police had taken action against them. Certain
contradictions have also been abstracted from his statement
made before police by the defence.
13.
PW-11 Doctor Sushma Gond who medically examined the injured
persons has stated that she examined injured Kumari Bai PW-4
and found pain and swelling on left thigh which was simple in
nature, the injury of Gend Singh was pain and swelling on right
writs joint and thumb and abrasion over left index finger which are
also simple in nature. The injured Dular Singh also received
incised would on head, lacerated wound and pain and swelling
over left forearm. Though the injury was opined that it was
grievous in nature, but she referred the injured Dular Singh to
higher center for expert advice. Doctor PW-11 has admitted that
she has not mentioned in the MLC report Ex.-P/11 as to in which
part of his head Dular Singh received injury, even the part of the
head on which the lacerated wound was found has also not been
mentioned. Dular Singh was admitted in the hospital only for two
days. There is no X-ray report or CT scan report produced by the
prosecution to prove that Dular Singh received any grievous injury
or fracture on his body and even the injury on any vital part of
body of Dular Singh could not be proved by the prosecution and
therefore, considering the nature of evidence the learned trial
Court instead of convicting the accused persons for the offence
under Section 307/34 of the IPC convicted them for the offence
under Section 323/34 of the IPC, the learned trial Court has also
considered the evidence with respect to offence under Section
294, 506B and 341/34 of the IPC and acquitted the accused
persons for the offence under Section 294 and 506B of the IPC
and convicted for the offence under Section 341/34 of the IPC, in
which we do not find any perversity or illegality.
14.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Jafarudheen and
Ors Vs. State of Kerala, (2022) 8 SCC 440, has considered the
scope of interference in appeal against acquittal in judgment at
Para 25 which reads as under:"25. While dealing with an appeal against acquittal
by invoking Section 378 Cr.P.C., the appellate
court has to consider whether the trial court's view
can be termed as a possible one, particularly
when evidence on record has been analysed. The
reason is that an order of acquittal adds up to the
presumption of innocence in favour of the
accused. Thus, the appellate court has to be
relatively slow in reversing the order of the trial
court
rendering
acquittal. Therefore,
presumption in favour of the
the
accused does not
get weakened but only strengthened. Such a
double presumption that ensures in favour of the
accused has to be disturbed only by thorough
scrutiny on the accepted legal parameters."
15.
Recently, applying the law governing the scope of interference in
an appeal against acquittal, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of State of Rajasthan Vs. Kistoora Ram, 2022 SCC
OnLine SC 984, has held as follows:"8. The scope of interference in an appeal against
acquittal is very limited. Unless it is found that the
view taken by the Court is impossible or perverse,
it is not permissible to interfere with the finding of
acquittal. Equally if two views are possible, it is
not permissible to set aside an order of acquittal,
merely because the
Appellate Court finds the
way of conviction to be more probable. The
interference would be warranted only if the view
taken is not possible at all."
16.
The Trial Court has elaborately discussed the evidence led by the
prosecution and after analyzing the entire evidence led by the
prosecution, acquitted the accused persons from the aforesaid
offence after giving them the benefit of doubt. Therefore, the
argument of learned counsel for the appellant and the statements
made by the prosecution witnesses in their court evidence makes
the prosecution case suspicious and is not credible.
17.
After considering the material available on record as well as the
elaborate judgment passed by the Court below and being very
much conscious of the existing legal position as held in case of
Jafarudheen (supra) and Kistoora Ram (supra) that in an appeal
against acquittal, if two views are possible on the basis by the
evidence laid by the prosecution and the trial court taking one
view favoured the accused, reversion on the finding of acquittal by
the
appellate court
taking
the
other
possible view
into
consideration, is not permissible in law.
18.
From careful perusal of the record, this Court does not find any
perversity in the consideration of the learned trial Court while
passing the impugned judgment of acquittal. We are therefore of
the considered opinion that the judgment impugned, acquitting the
respondents/accused persons from the offence under Section
294, 506B of the IPC and instead of Section 307/34 of the IPC
convicting them under Section 323/34 and Section 341/34 of the
IPC is just and proper and does not call for any interference.
Accordingly, the acquittal appeal filed by the appellant is hereby
dismissed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Aadil
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review