Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:6098
SAGRIKA
AGRAWAL
Digitally signed
by SAGRIKA
AGRAWAL
Date:
2026.02.13
10:52:41 +0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ACQA No. 383 of 2025
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through - Police Station Ajak, Ambikapur, District- Surguja
(C.G.)
... Appellant (s)
versus
1 - Bhola Prasad Yadav S/o Maniram Yadav Aged About 47 Years R/o VillageKudaridih, Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
2 - Gangaram S/o Maniram Yadav Aged About 36 Years R/o Village- Kudaridih,
Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
3 - Mahesh Yadav S/o Maniram Yadav Aged About 32 Years R/o Village- Kudaridih,
Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
4 - Tripurari Yadav S/o Keshav Yadav Aged About 31 Years R/o Village- Kudaridih,
Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
5 - Raju Yadav S/o Maniram Yadav Aged About 37 Years R/o Village- Kudaridih,
Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
6 - Keshav Prasad S/o Maniram Yadav Aged About 55 Years R/o Village- Kudaridih,
Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
7 - Sanjay Yadav S/o Bhola Prasad Yadav Aged About 24 Years R/o VillageKudaridih, Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
8 - Chhotu Prasad S/o Keshav Prasad Yadav Aged About 22 Years R/o VillageKudaridih, Junglepara, Police Station - Kamleshwarpur, District- Surguja (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
For appellant (s)
:
Ms. Supriya Upasane, Govt. Advocate
S.B. Hon’ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
03.02.2026
1.
Heard on admission.
2.
Present is an acquittal appeal filed by the State under Section 378(1) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 against the impugned judgment of
acquittal dated 26.12.2019, passed by learned Special Judge (under the
Scheduled Castes And Schedule Tribes Prevention of Atrocities Act) Surguja
Place Ambikapur in Special Sessions Case (Atrocities) No. 79/2017, whereby
the respondents/accused persons have been acquitted from the offences
under Section 147, 249/149 (3 counts), 506/149 (3 counts), 323/149(3
counts), 186, 353/149 (3 counts) and 332/149 (3 counts) of IPC. and Section
3(1)(r) on (3 counts), 3(1)(s) on (3 counts) and 3(2)(v-a) on (3 counts) of
Scheduled Caste & Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, (in
short “SC/ST Act”), by giving them the benefit of doubt.
3.
The prosecution case in brief is that on 28.02.2016 at about 16:30 hours
during the inspection of a tubewell at village Kudarideeh, Jangalpara
Mainpat, the respondent/accused persons formed an unlawful assembly and
committed marpeet with the complaint Sunil Kumar Sonpipare (PW-2) and
also assaulted Patwari Arvind Paikra (PW-6) and Pradeep Bharti clerk (PW9) by which they received injuries. The respondent/accused persons also
abused and threatened them. A written complaint was lodged by Sunil Kumar
Sonpipare (PW-2) on 28.02.2016 on which an unnumbered FIR (Ex.P/5) was
registered at Police Station Kamleshwarpur for the offence under Section
147, 186, 294, 323, and 353 of IPC and 3(1)(x) of SC/ST Act, against eight
named and other accused persons. The inured persons were sent for their
medical examination to Govt. Hospital, Ambikapur where the injured Sunil
Kumar Sonpipare (PW-2) have been medically examined by Dr. Jagrani
Lakda (PW-1), who gave her report (Ex.P/1). During the medical examination
of the complainant doctor has found pain, abrasion, contusion and
tenderness on various parts of the body of the complainant and opined that
the injuries are simple in nature. The other injured Arvind Singh and Pradeep
Kumar Bharti were also sent for their medical examination to Govt. Hospital,
Ambikapur where they have also been examined by PW-1 Dr. Jagrani Lakda
who found simple injuries on their body and gave report (Ex.P/2 and Ex.P/3)
respectively. The numbered FIR (Ex.P/11) was registered at Police Station
AJK, Ambikapur, Surguja against the 8 accused persons. The injured
persons were again medically examined by Dr Jai Kumar Patel (PW/7) who
gave their MLC report (Ex-P/13A, 14A and 15A) and found simple injuries on
their body. The social status certificate of the injured persons were seized by
the Police. Statement of the witnesses were recorded, accused persons were
arrested and after completion of usual investigation, charge-sheet was filed
before the learned trial Court for the offence under Section 147, 186, 353,
332, 494 and 506 of IPC and Section 3 (1)(r)(s) and 3(2)(v-a) of SC/ST Act.
4.
The learned trial Court has framed charge against the accused persons for
the offence under Sections 147, 294/149 (thrice), 506/149 (thrice), 323/149
(thrice), 186, 343/149 (thrice), 332/149 (thrice) of IPC and Section 3(1)(r)
(thrice), 3(1)(s) (thrice) and 3(2)(v-a) (thrice) of SC/ST Act. The respondents/
accused persons denied the charge and claimed trial.
5.
The prosecution has examined as many as 14 witnesses. The statement of
the accused persons under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. have also been recorded
in which they denied the circumstances appears against them, pleaded
innocence and have submitted that the complainant- Sunil Kumar Sonpipare
demanding Rs. 46,000/- for return of tube-well pump and cable sets and
when they failed to give him money, he falsely implicated them in the offence.
The other accused persons have also stated that since they helped the
accused Bhola Yadav, they have also been falsely implicated in the offence.
6.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence, the learned trial
Court has acquitted the accused persons by giving them the benefit of doubt
vide judgment dated 26.12.2019, which is under challenge in the present
acquittal appeal.
7. Learned counsel for the appellant/ State would submit that there are
overvelming evidence against the respondents/ accused persons that
they committed the offence. Merely on the minor discrepancies or
inconsistencies, the evidence of prosecution witnesses, particularly the
evidence of injured persons, cannot be disbelieved. The (PW/2) Sunil
Kumar Sonpipare, (PW/6) Arvind Singh and (PW/9) Pradeep Kumar
Bharti are the govt. employee and they may not have any animosity
with the accused persons and they were discharging their duties to
prevent illegal digging of tube-well. When the injured persons tried to
stop the accused persons from illegal digging of tube-well, they
committed the offence and obstructed the complainant in discharging
the public money. The (PW/1) Dr. Jagrani Lakra had duly proved the
injury found on the body of the complainant, yet the learned trial Court
has disbelieved the evidence of the witnesses and the accused
persons have been acquitted by giving them benefit of doubt, which is
erroneous and their acquittal is liable to be set aside.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the appellant and perused the record
of the trial Court.
9. From perusal of the impugned judgment passed by learned trial Court,
it transpires that the there are material discrepancies in the evidence of
(PW/2) Sunil Kumar Sonpipare, (PW/6) Arvind Singh and (PW/9)
Pradeep Kumar Bharti. (PW/2) Sunil Kumar Sonpipare/ complainant
admitted in his evidence that on 23.02.2016, he had gone to the spot
and seized the submersible pump and its connecting wire in
discharging of its official duty but he again visited to the spot on
28.02.2016. When he already seized the material on 23.02.2016, there
was no reason for revisiting the spot on 28.02.2016 that too without
any authority or without any order issued by the officer concerned. The
learned trial Court has also considered the evidence of PW/6 Arvind
Singh who admitted in his evidence that when they received a
complaint that the accused persons were using the submarciv pump by
digging illegal tube-well, they went on the spot and during their
inception, the complainant/ Sunil Kumar Sonpipare, who was the
Nayab Tahsildar took the accused Bhola Yadav on the side, where the
Bhola Yadav went unconscious and fell down. Thereafter, a mob was
gathered there. (PW/9) Pradeep Kumar Bharati, did not identify the
other accused persons except Bhola Yadav. The learned trial Court
further considered that when the submersible pump and connecting
wire was already seized on 23.02.2016 and there was no reason to
revisit the spot which supposed the defence person that Sunil Kumar
Sonpipare demanded Rs. 40,000/- from the accused Bhola Yadav and
when he refused to give the money, he took him to the side and tried to
press his neck by which Bhola Yadav went unconcious and fell down.
Learned trial Court has further considered that the complainant was
medically examined by doctor thrice and if the incident was actually
occurred, there was no need to repeat medical examination of the
complainant. The learned trial Court has also considered that on
28.02.2016, when Sunil Kumar Sonpipare was medically examined by
the doctor, only two external injuries were found on the body whereas
on 01.03.2016 when he was again examined by the doctor, six injuries
were found on the body. They further considered that there is no
evidence that at the time when the injured were sent for its medical
examination, his cloths were not torned, however, the torned cloths and
sweater of the complainant/ Sunil Kumar Sonpipare have been seized
by the prosectuion, in which it appears to be a concocted story
developed by the prosecution.
10. The
learned trial Court after adverting the entire facts and
circumstances of the case, as well as evidence of prosecution,
acquitted the accused persons, by giving them the benefit of doubt, in
which this Court does not find any perversity or illegality.
11. Applying the law governing the scope of interference in an appeal
acquittal, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “State of
Rajasthan Vs. Kistoora Ram” reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC
984, has held as follows:“8. The scope of
interference in an appeal
against acquittal is very limited. Unless it is
found that the view taken by the Court is
impossible or perverse, it is not permissible to
interfere with the finding of acquittal. Equally if
two views are possible, it is not permissible to
set aside an order of acquittal, merely because
the Appellate Court finds the way of conviction
to be more probable. The interference would be
warranted only if the view taken is not possible
at all.”
12.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Jafarudheen and
Ors Vs. State of Kerala, (2022) 8 SCC 440, has considered the
scope of interference in appeal against acquittal in judgment at
Para 25 which reads as under:
“25. While dealing with an appeal against
acquittal by invoking Section 378 Cr.P.C. the
appellate court has to consider whether the trial
court’s view can be termed as a possible one,
particularly when evidence on record has been
analysed. The reason is that an order of
acquittal adds up to the presumption of
innocence in favour of the accused. Thus, the
appellate court has to be relatively slow in
reversing the order of the trial court rendering
acquittal. Therefore, the presumption in favour
of the accused does not get weakened but only
strengthened. Such as double presumption that
ensures in favour of the accused has to be
disturbed only by thorough scrutiny on the
accepted legal parameters.”
13. After considering the material available on record, as well as the
elaborate judgment passed by the trial Court and being very much
conscious about the legal position as held by Hon'ble Supreme Court
in cases of Kistoora Ram (supra), and Jafarudheen (supra), in an
appeal against the acquittal, if two views are possible on the basis of
evidence led by the prosecution, and the trial Court taking one view,
revert the accused, the version of the finding of acquittal by the
appellate Court taking the other possible view for consideration, is not
permissible in the law. This Court, therefore, of the considered opinion
that the judgment impugned, acquitting the accused respondents, is
just and proper and does not call for any interference.
14. Accordingly, appeal filed by the State, against the accused respondents
is hereby dismissed.
15. Record of the trial court along with copy of this judgment be sent back
to the trial Court concerned.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
sagrika
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review