Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed
by
AMIT
PATEL
2026:CGHC:9271-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ACQA No. 519 of 2018
Nitin Kumar Limbom @ Mukku S/o Nirmal Kumar Aged About 35 Years R/o
Gouri Nagar, Chikhli, District- Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh. ( Victim/ Injured ),
District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
--- Appellant
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Station House Officer, Police StationBasantpur, District- Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh
2 - Abhishek Chouhan @ Shaiki S/o Mahendra Singh Chouhan Aged About
28 Years R/o Tulsipur, Police Station- Kotwali, District- Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
3 - Jugal Kishore Thakur@ Jugal S/o Bhagat Singh Thakur Aged About 21
Years Caste Gond, R/o Indira Nagar, Ward No.- 31, Police StationBasantpur, District- Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh.,
4 - Ghanshyam Vishwakarma S/o Late Ramnath Vishwakarma Aged About
31 Years
R/o
Nandai
Chowk,
Police
Station-
Basantpur,
District-
Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
5 - Lavkesh Patel@ Pappu S/o Horilal Patel Aged About 32 Years R/o
Diwanpara,
Ward
No.
21,
Gandhi
Chowk,
Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
District-
Rajnandgaon,
6 - Ronit Meshram @ Monu S/o Late Dharamdas Meshram Aged About 22
Years R/o Ward No.11, Station Para, Sheetla Mandir Gali, O.P.- Chikhli,
Police Station- Kotwali, District- Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh., District :
Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
7 - Sonu Bahadur@ Nar Bahadur@ Sonu Thapa S/o Shyam Bahadur Aged
About 33 Years R/o Station Para, Ward No.13, Solah Kholi, Near Bapoo
School, O.P.- Chikhli, District- Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh., District :
Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
ACQA No. 524 of 2018
State Of Chhattisgarh Through The In-charge Police Station Basantpur
District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh, District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
---Appellant
Versus
1 - Abhishek Chouhan @ Shanki S/o Mahendra Singh Chouhan Aged About
28 Years R/o Tulsipur Police Station Kotwali District Rajnandgaon
Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
2 - Jugal Kishore Thakur @Jugal S/o Bhagat Singh Thakur Aged About 21
Years Caste Gond, R/o Indira Nagar Ward No.31 Police Station Basantpur
District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
3 - Ghanshyam Vishwakarma S/o Late Ramnath Vishwakarma Aged About
31 Years R/o Nandai Chowk Police Station Basantpur District Rajnandgaon
Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
4 - Lavkesh Patel @Pappu S/o Horilal Patel Aged About 32 Years R/o
Diwanpara Ward No.21 Gandhi Chowk District Rajnandgaon Chhatisgarh.,
District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
5 - Ronit Meshram @Monu S/o Late Dharamdas Meshram Aged About 22
Years R/o Ward No.11 Station Para Shitla Mandir Lane O. P. Chikhli Police
Station Kotwali District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh
6 - Sonu Bahadur @Nar Bahadur @Sonu Thapa S/o Shyam Bahadur Aged
About 33 Years R/o Station Para Ward No. 13 Chkhli District Rajnandgaon
Chhattisgarh., District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
CRA No. 915 of 2018
Sonu Bahadur @ Nar Bahadur @ Sonu Thapa S/o Shyam Bahadur Aged
About 33 Years R/o Station Para, Ward No. 13solah Kholi, Near Bapu School
O. P. Chikhli, District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh, District : Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh
---Appellant
Versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through The Station House Officer, Police Station
Basantpur, District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh, District : Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent (s)
For Appellants
: Mr. Rudrapratap Dubey on behalf of Mr. Goutam
Khetrapal, Advocate in ACQA No. 519/2018, Mr.
Atanu Ghosh, Dy. G.A. in ACQA No. 524/2018
and Mr. Sunil Otwani, Sr. Advocate along with Mr.
Amit Soni, Advocate in CRA No.915/2018.
For Respondents/State : Mr. Atanu Ghosh, Dy. G.A. in ACQA No.
519/2018 and in CRA No. 915/2018
Hon’ble Smt. Justice Rajani Dubey, J.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Radhakishan Agrawal, J.
Judgment on Board
23.02.2026
Per, Rajani Dubey, J.
1.
Since the aforesaid appeals arise out of the judgment dated
12.02.2018 passed by learned Sessions Judge, Rajnandgaon in S.T.
No.80/2015, they are being disposed of by this common judgment. By
the impugned judgment, accused Abhishek Chouhan @ Shanki, Jugal,
Ghanshyam, Lavkesh and Ronit were acquitted of offence under
Sections 307/34 and 120-B, 212 of IPC and Section 25 (1-B)(a) and
27 of Arms Act, 1959, whereas accused/ Sonu Bahadur @ Nar
Bahadur @ Sonu Thapa was convicted under Section 307 of IPC and
Section 25 (1-B) (a) of the Arms Act, 1959 and sentenced as under:
Conviction
Sentence
U/S 307 of IPC
R.I. for 10 years and fine amount
of Rs. 50,000/-, in default thereof
to suffer additional imprisonment
for 01 year.
U/S 25(1-B) (a) of Arms
R.I. for 03 years and fine amount
Act, 1959
of Rs. 1,000/-, in default thereof
to suffer additional imprisonment
for 01 year.
Both the sentences were directed to run concurrently.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that on 27th July 2015, the Police Control
Room, Rajnandgaon received telephonic as well as wireless
information that a gunshot was fired at Funwara Chowk, Jamatpara,
and that an injured person, namely Munku, had been sent to the
Government District Hospital, Rajnandgaon for medical treatment.
Acting upon the said information, the police proceeded to the
Government District Hospital, Rajnandgaon and recorded the
statement of the injured- Nitin Limbom alias Mukku. The injured stated
that on 27th July 2015 at about 6:00 p.m., he had gone to Body Tech
Gym situated near Funwara Chowk, Jamatpara, in his Swift car. After
exercising for approximately one and a quarter hours, he left for home
at approximately 7:20 p.m. and was walking towards his Swift car
when Sonu Thapa, accompanied by another co-accused person,
approached him on a motorcycle and straightway gave him threat by
saying, "I will kill you today." As the injured ran towards his car to save
his life, Sonu Thapa fired at him with a pistol, which was in his
possession. Three bullets struck him, injuring his back, waist, right
armpit and left hand. After firing the shots, the accused Sonu and coaccused fled from the spot on a motorcycle, whereupon the injured
drove himself to the hospital for medical treatment. On being informed
of the said incident by the injured/complainant, a dehati nalishi was
registered at Police Station Basantpur vide Ex. P/3 and F.I.R. was also
registered vide Ex. P/3-A. During the course of investigation, one
empty cartridge was seized from the spot. The bullet extracted from
the body of the injured/complainant during medical treatment was
preserved by the attending doctor and taken into custody. The bloodstained clothes worn by the injured at the time of the incident were
duly seized and forwarded to the Forensic Science Laboratory, Raipur
for chemical examination. A spot map was prepared. The statements
of the accused persons were recorded and seizure proceedings were
also conducted. Upon collection of sufficient incriminating material
against the accused, they were arrested, and the statements of the
prosecution witnesses were recorded and after completion of usual
investigation, charge-sheet under Sections 307/34 and 120-B of IPC
and Section 25 (1-B) (a) and 27 of Arms Act, 1959 was filed against
the accused persons Abhishek, Jugal, Ghanshyam, Ronit and Sonu,
whereas the charge-sheet was filed against the accused Lavkesh for
offence under Sections 307/34, 120-B and 212 of IPC and Section 25
(1-B) (a) and 27 of Arms Act, 1959. The accused persons abjured
their guilt and prayed for trial.
3.
In order to establish the charges against the accused, the prosecution
has examined as many as 42 witnesses. The statements under
Section 313 of Cr.P.C. of the accused have been recorded, in which
they denied the incriminating charges leveled against them and
pleaded their innocence that they have been falsely implicated in this
case.
4.
After hearing counsel for the respective parties and appreciation of
oral and documentary evidence on record, the learned trial Court while
acquitting
the
accused
Abhishek
Thakur
@
Shanky,
Jugal,
Ghanshyam, Ronit and Lavkesh of all the charges, convicted and
sentenced the accused
Sonu Bahadur @ Nar Bahadur @ Sonu
Thapa as mentioned in the inaugural paragraph of this judgment.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellant/complainant in ACQA No. 519/2018
submits that the impugned judgment of acquittal is bad in law and
facts, hence the same is liable to be set aside. The Learned Trial Court
has failed to appreciate the evidence recorded in its true and correct
perspective and the prosecution had proved its case beyond all
reasonable doubts against the respondents No. 2 to 6. Learned trial
Court has failed to appreciate the statement of Ravi Sahu, who is
witness of conspiracy and he supported the case of prosecution, but
the learned trial Court without appreciating the statement of this
witnesses, has acquitted the respondents no. 2 to 6 of the offence
under Section 120-B and 307/34 of IPC. He would further submit that
learned trial Court has failed to appreciate the statement of witness
Dinesh Maheshwari (PW-1), who has has categorically stated about
involvement of respondents no. 2 & 3 in alleged commission of crime.
Learned trial Court has also failed to appreciate that respondent Nos.
2 to 7 hatched conspiracy with each other for committing murder of the
appellant/complainant.
Therefore,
looking
to
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case, the judgment of acquittal of the learned trial
Court is perverse and is liable to be set aside.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant/State in ACQA No. 524/2018
submits that learned trial Court has failed to consider the substantial
fact that the prosecution case is based upon the version propounded
by the eye witnesses as well as medical evidence, which clearly prove
that the accused persons have committed the said offence. According
to the version of the eye witnesses namely Dinesh Maheshwari (PW-1)
and Ravi Sahu (PW-3) the accused Sonu Thapa came in a bike (motor
cycle) along with one other person and made gunshot on the
complainant, further the medical evidence, i.e. MLC report given by Dr.
Rahul Singram (PW-15) it is clear that the injury caused to the
injured/complainant was due to gunshot. In the investigation, the
involvement of the present respondents in the crime in question have
been prima facie made out and on the basis of material evidences the
above said offence has been constituted against the respondents,
however, the learned trial Court has not considered the case of the
prosecution
in
proper
perspective
matter
and
acquitted
the
respondents. Therefore, looking to the facts and circumstances of the
case, the judgment and finding of the learned trial Court is perverse
and is liable to be set aside.
7.
In CRA No. 915/2018, learned Sr. Counsel submits that the impugned
judgment of the learned trial Court is bad, perverse and against the law
as well as facts of the case. Learned trial Court has failed to appreciate
that there are so many contradictions and omissions in the statements
of the prosecution witnesses. The necessary ingredients constituting
offence under Section 307 of the IPC and Section 25(1-B)(a) of the
Arms Act are missing in the present case. The appellant has been
convicted solely on the basis of circumstantial evidence, and the chain
of circumstances required to conclusively establish the appellant's guilt
is incomplete. Therefore, the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence passed by the learned trial Court is liable to be set aside.
Alternatively, he submits that if this Court ultimately comes to
the conclusion that the conviction of the appellant is proper,
then, considering the fact that the incident took place in the
year 2015, this appeal is pending since 2018, the appellant
is now aged more than 40 years; the appellant remained in
jail for more than 03 years and 10 months and he did not
misuse the liberty while being on bail, the jail sentence
awarded to the appellant may be reduced to the period
already undergone by him.
8.
Ex adverso, learned counsel for the State supporting the impugned
judgment submits that the learned trial Court minutely appreciated the
oral and documentary evidence and has rightly convicted and
sentenced the appellant in CRA No. 915/2018, but wrongly acquitted
the other co-accused persons of all the charges.
9.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
10.
It is clear from the record of the learned Trial Court that it framed
charges under Sections 307/34 and 120-B of IPC and Section 25 (1-B)
(a) and 27 of Arms Act, 1959 against the accused Abhishek Thakur @
Shanky, Jugal, Ghanshyam, Ronit and Sonu, whereas accused
Lavkesh was charged under Sections 307/34, 120-B and 212 of IPC
and Section 25 (1-B) (a) and 27 of Arms Act, 1959. After appreciation
of oral and documentary evidence available on record, learned trial
Court while acquitting co-accused Abhishek Thakur @ Shanky, Jugal,
Ghanshyam, Ronit and Lavkesh of all the charges, convicted and
sentenced the only accused Sonu Bahadur @ Nar Bahadur @ Sonu
Thapa as mentioned in the inaugural paragraph of this judgment.
11.
PW-1, Dinesh Maheshwari has stated that on the evening of the
incident, at around 7:30 p.m., he was at Funwara Chowk near
Gurudwara with his friend Ravi, when he suddenly heard a sound
resembling a firecracker. He observed Sonu Thapa arrive on a
motorcycle with another person. Sonu Thapa was armed with a pistol
and fired at Mukku alias Nitin. After the firing, accused Sonu Thapa and
his acquaintance fled towards another motorcycle, in which coaccused Jugal was driving the motorcycle.
12.
PW-2, complainant/injured- Nitin Kumar Limbom @ Mukku has stated
that on the date of the incident, i.e., 27.07.2015, he had gone to the
gym at Funwara Chowk, Rajnandgaon. He left the gym at around 7:15
p.m. and had parked his Swift car nearby. While walking towards his
car, carrying a bag in one hand and drinking a protein shake in the
other, he noticed the accused seated on a motorcycle at some
distance from his vehicle. He further stated that he heard a voice from
behind saying, “Suno Mukku Bhai.” When he turned around, he saw a
boy named Sonu Thapa sitting on a motorcycle and he took out a
pistol from his waist, loaded it and told him that “ he would kill him
today, he will not leave him” and he fired a bullet at him due to which,
he sustained injuries on his body. Thereafter, he drove his car himself
to the hospital for medical treatment.
13.
PW-3 Ravi Sahu has stated that on the date of incident, he heard the
sound of firing and he saw that the accused Sonu Thapa was firing
with a pistol upon Nitin @ Mukku.
14.
PW-4 Srijan Lal Sahu has stated that approximately three months
prior, at about 7:00–7:30 p.m., he saw Mukku Nepali entering through
Gate No. 1 of the District Hospital in a blood-soaked condition. Upon
being asked about the incident, Mukku informed him that the accused
Thapa and other co-accused had shot him.
15.
PW-15 Dr. Rahul Singh Roy and PW- 41 Dr. Runa Singh have
examined the complainant/injured- Nitin Kumar Limbu (PW-2) on
27.07.2015 and found gunshot injuries upon the body of the injured,
gave their reports vide Exs. P/24 & Ex. P/84 respectively.
16.
PW- 42, Investigating Officer- Rajesh Chaudhary has lodged the
dehati nalishi vide Ex. P/3 at District Hospital, Rajnandgaon and as per
statement of injured/complainant- Nitin Limbu @ Munku.
17.
Close scrutiny of statements of injured/complainant Nitin Limbu @
Munku (PW-2) and other eye- witnesses, clearly shows that all the
witnesses have stated against the accused Sonu Thapa and saw that
other co-accused persons fled from the spot. Furthermore, in crossexamination, the witnesses conceded to the defense's suggestion that,
following the sound of like firecracker, there was stampede.
18.
Thus, the learned trial Court after minutely appreciating the statements
of all the witnesses and all documents rightly acquitted the other coaccused persons of all the charges as there is no any cogent and
clinching evidence proved by the prosecution against them.
19.
The Hon’ble Apex Court vide its judgment dated 12.02.2024 (Criminal
Appeal No 1162 of 2011) passed in Mallappa and Ors. Versus State
of Karnataka has held in para 36 as under:“36. Our criminal jurisprudence is essentially based on the
promise that no innocent shall be condemned as guilty. All
the safeguards and the jurisprudential values of criminal
law, are intended to prevent any failure of justice. The
principles which come into play while deciding an appeal
from acquittal could be summarized as:(i) Appreciation of evidence is the core element of a criminal
trial and such appreciation must be comprehensive-inclusive of all vidence, oral and documentary;
(ii) Partial or selective appreciation of evidence may result
in a miscarriage of justice and is in itself a ground of
challenge;
(iii) If the Court, after appreciation of evidence, finds that
two views are possible, the one in favour of the accused
shall ordinarily be followed;
(iv) If the view of the Trial Court is a legally plausible view,
mere possibility of a contrary view shall not justify the
reversal of acquittal;
(v) If the appellate Court is inclined to reverse the acquittal
in appeal on a re-appreciation of evidence, it must
specifically address all the reasons given by the Trial Court
for acquittal and must cover all the facts;
(vi) In a case of reversal from acquittal to conviction, the
appellate Court must demonstrate an illegality, perversity or
error of law or fact in the decision of the Trial Court.”
20.
Keeping in view the aforesaid legal proposition of as well and looking
to the statements of witnesses, this Court is also of the view that the
findings recorded by the learned Trial Court are based on proper
appreciation of oral and documentary evidence. That apart, it is settled
position of law that the scope of interference in exercise of revisional
powers of the High Court is quite limited inasmuch as it has to only
verify that whether there is any material irregularity and/or illegality
coupled with arbitrariness or perverseness in the impugned order or
not. In the present cases, no such circumstance is there warranting
interference by this Court. Accordingly, the acquittal appeals are
devoid of any merits and the same are liable to be and are hereby
dismissed.
21.
As regards Criminal Appeal of accused/ Sonu Bahadur@ Nar Bahadur
@ Sonu Thapa, it is clear the injured/complainant- Nitin Kumar
Limbom @ Mukku stated against the accused Sonu, other eyewitnesses have also supported that the accused Sonu shot him with
country made pistol and pistol was seized from the accused Sonu and
ballistic expert and F.S.L. report have also supported the prosecution
case. PW-41 Dr. Runa Singh and PW-15 Rahul Singh Roy found
gunshot injuries upon the body of the injured. Thus, learned trial Court
rightly convicted the accused Sonu for offence under Section 307 of
IPC and 25 (1-B) of the Arms Act, 1959, we find no illegality or
irregularity in the said findings recorded by learned Trial Court.
22.
As regards sentence, it is clear that the incident took place in the year
2015 and criminal appeal is pending since 2018. The appellant is now
aged more than 40 years; and he remained in jail for more than 03
years and 10 months, he did not misuse the liberty while being on bail,
he is facing the lis since 2015 i.e. for about more than 10 years and no
useful purpose would be served in again sending him to jail, therefore,
in the interest of justice, it would be appropriate if the sentence
imposed upon him is reduced to the period already undergone by him.
23.
On the basis of aforesaid discussions,
•
Ex consequenti, the acquittal appeals filed by the complainant
and the State being devoid of any substance are hereby
dismissed.
•
The criminal appeal filed by the appellant Sonu stands allowed
in part while maintaining the conviction of the appellant for
offence under Section 307 of IPC and Section 25 (1-B) (a) of
Arms Act, 1959 and the sentenced imposed under the Arms Act,
the substantive jail sentence under Section 307 of IPC is hereby
reduced to the period already undergone by him. However, the
fine amount imposed upon him under the section with default
sentenced by learned trial Court shall remain intact. The
impugned judgment stands modified to the above extent.
The appellant is reported to be on bail. However, keeping in
view the provisions of Section 481 of BNSS, 2023 the appellant
is directed to furnish a personal bond for a sum of Rs. 25,000/with one surety in the like amount before the Court concerned
which shall be effective for a period of six months along with an
undertaking that in the event of filing of special leave petition
against the instant judgment or for grant of leave, the aforesaid
appellant on receipt of notice thereon shall appear before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court.
The trial Court record along with a copy of this judgment be sent
back immediately to the trial Court concerned for compliance and
necessary action.
AMIT PATEL
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Rajani Dubey)
JUDGE
(Radhakishan Agrawal )
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review