Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 13.07.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 17.07.2026
CRL.A. 250/2017
STATE GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Manjeet Arya, APP for the State.
Versus
SURAJ @ MACHHAR
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Vaibhav Gulia, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA
JUDGMENT
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA, J.
1.
This appeal under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (the Cr.P.C.), by the State in Sessions Case No.
06 of 2014 on the file of the Additional Sessions Judge-04 and
Special Judge, NDPS, South East, Saket Courts, New Delhi,
assails the judgment dated 09.03.2015 as per which the sole
accused
has
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
been
acquitted
of
the
offences
punishable
underSections 392, 394 read with Section 34 and Section 397 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
2.
The prosecution case is that on 12.02.2014 at about
11:15 p.m., near the under-construction underpass at C-Block
Jhuggi, Okhla Industrial Area-II, Delhi, the accused, acting in
furtherance of his common intention with his two associates,
namely, Bittu @ Chusa and Bineet @ Binny (both Child in
Conflict with Law), robbed PW2 of his belongings. During the
commission of the robbery, it is alleged that hurt was caused to
PW2 and that the accused, along with his associates, used a deadly
weapon, that is, knife. Hence, as per the charge-sheet/final report,
the accused is alleged to have committed the offences punishable
under Sections 392, 397, 411 read with Section 34 IPC.
3.
On the basis of Ext. PW2/A FIS/FIR of PW2 given on
13.02.2014, Crime No. 105 of 2014, Okhla Industrial Area Police
Station, that is, Ext. PW1/A FIR was registered by PW1, Assistant
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
Sub-Inspector. PW10, Sub-Inspector, conducted investigation into
the crime and on completion of the same, filed the chargesheet/final report alleging commission of the offences punishable
under the aforesaid Sections.
4.
When the accused was produced before the committal
court, all the copies of the prosecution records were furnished to
him as contemplated under Section 207 Cr.P.C. The case was
committed to the Court of Sessions under Section 209 Cr.P.C. vide
order dated 30.04.2014.
5.
After hearing both sides, the trial court, vide order
dated 15.05.2014, framed a Charge under Sections 392, 394 read
with Section 34 and Section 397 IPC, which was read over and
explained to him, to which he pleaded not guilty.
6.
On behalf of the prosecution, PWs. 1 to 10 were
examined and Exts. PW1/A-B, PW2/A-C, PW3/A, PW 6/A-E,
PW6/E1-E2, PW6/F, PW7/A and PW10/Awere marked.
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
7.
After the close of the prosecution evidence, the accused
was questioned under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. regarding the
incriminating circumstances appearing against himin the evidence
led by the prosecution. He denied all those circumstances and
maintained his innocence. He submitted that he had a quarrel with
PW2 about four to five days prior to the registration of the case,
owing to which the latter falsely implicated him. PW4 and PW9
deposed against him as they are friends of PW2. He was picked up
from his house by the police and taken to the police station and
shown to PW2 and PW9.
8.
After questioning the accused under Section 313(1)(b)
Cr.P.C., compliance of Section 232 Cr.P.C. was mandatory. In the
case on hand, no hearing as contemplated under Section 232
Cr.P.C. is seen to have been done by the trial court. However, noncompliance of the said provision does not ipso facto vitiate the
proceedings, unless omission to comply with the same is shown to
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
have resulted in serious and substantial prejudice to the accused.
(See Moidu K. vs. State of Kerala, 2009 (3) KHC 89 : 2009
SCC OnLine Ker 2888). Here, the accused has no case that noncompliance of Section 232 Cr.P.C has caused any prejudice to
him.
9.
No oral or documentary evidence was adduced by the
accused in support of his case.
10.
Upon consideration of the oral and documentary
evidence and after hearing both sides, the trial court, vide the
impugned judgment dated 09.03.2015, acquitted the accused under
Section 235(1) Cr.P.C. of the offences punishable under Sections
392, 394 read with Section 34 and Section 397 IPC. Aggrieved, the
State has preferred this appeal.
11.
It was submitted by the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor for the State that the impugned judgment is contrary to
the facts and circumstances of the case, is bad in law as the trial
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
court has failed to appreciate the materials on record and,
therefore, liable to be set aside.
12.
It was submitted by the learned counsel for the
respondent/accused that there is no infirmity in the judgment
calling for an interference by this Court.
13.
Heard both sides and perused the materials on record.
14.
The only point that arises for consideration in this
appeal is whether there is any infirmity in the impugned judgment
calling for an interference by this Court.
15.
I will refer to the oral and documentary evidence relied
on by the prosecution in support of the case. Ext. PW2/A the
FIS/FIR of PW2 recorded in Hindi on the date of the incident, i.e.,
13.02.2014, translated reads thus: “On 12.02.2014 at around 11:00
p.m., after finishing our work, I, along with my colleagues Gautam
(PW4) and Jitender (PW9), was going to the house of Jitender
(PW9) in Village Tehkhand, Delhi. At around 11:15 p.m., while
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
walking from C-Block Okhla Phase-II through the jhuggis toward
Tehkhand and when we reached near the underpass, one of the
three boys gathered there around a fire (aag sek rahe the) asked
me for a matchbox, whichI refused. One of the boys caught hold of
me by my collar. When I resisted, the boy, who was approximately
20 to 21 years old, and another boy, whose age was around 18 to
19 years, repeatedly punched and kicked me and pulled out
₹4,000/- from the front pocket of my pants. The third boy, who was
also approximately 20 to 21 years old, took out my white
Micromax-445 mobile phone from the right pocket of my pants.
Meanwhile, those three boys also threatened and pushed Gautam
(PW4) and Jitender (PW9) back. My mobile phone contained a
SIM card bearing no. 9718986033. All the three boys then fled
toward the jhuggis of C-Block, Okhla Phase-II. We searched for
them but could not find them. Shortly after, Virendra (PW5), who
works with us, arrived there and called the police. The three boys
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
beat me up and snatched my money and mobile phone. Strict legal
action be taken against them.”
16.
PW2 when examined before the court, deposed that on
12.02.2014, at about 11:00 -11:15 p.m., after finishing his work,
he, along with his colleagues, namely, Gautam (PW4) and Jitender
(PW9), were on their way to the house of Jitender (PW9) at
Village Tekhand on foot. On their way through the jhuggis, when
they reached near a flyover which was still under construction,
they noticed three people sitting around a fire (aag sek rahe the).
One of thethree boys asked him for a matchbox. As he was not
carrying one, he refused. The three boys caught hold of him.
Jitender (PW9) and Gautam Ram (PW4) attempted to rescue him,
but when one of the boys showed a knife to them, they fled the
spot, leaving him behind. The three boys then took his purse
containing ₹4,000/-; his Voter Identity Card, and his mobile phone,
a white-coloured Micromax 455 touchscreen handset with SIM no.
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
9718986033, from his pocket. One of the boys also slapped him on
his face. All the three boys fled towards C-Block, Phase-II Jhuggis
after robbing him of his belongings. As he proceeded towards
Jitender’s (PW9) house, he met Jitender (PW9) and Gautam (PW4)
on the way. Virender (PW5), who was also working with them,
met them on the way. He told the entire incident to Virender
(PW5), who informed the police. The police arrived at the spot,
and he narrated the incident to the police officials. The next day,
i.e., on 13.02.2014, he accompanied the police and showed them
the place of occurrence. Ext. PW2/B site plan was prepared by the
police. PW2 identified the accused as one of the robbers.
16.1 PW2 in his cross-examination denied that it was dark at
the scene of occurrence. PW2 admitted that he can only identify
one of the robbers and not the others. After the incident, he had
seen the accused for the first time at the police station, where he
had been called by Parveen Kumar (PW10), Sub-Inspector, for the
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
purpose of identification. He denied the suggestion that PW10 had
told him that the accused was the culprit. According to PW2, he
was able to identify the accused as he had seen him in the jhuggis
near the place of occurrence even before the incident and was,
therefore, acquainted with the latter. PW2 further deposed that it
was the accused herein who had assaulted him at which time he
had seen the latter clearly and therefore possible to identify him.
17.
PW4, an eye-witness, deposed that on 12.02.2014, at
about 11:00 p.m., after finishing work, he, along with Rajesh
(PW2) and Jitender (PW9), were returning to Tekhand Village on
foot. At about 11:15 p.m., as they reached near an underpass which
was under construction, they saw three boys sitting around a fire
(aag sek rahe the). The boys asked for a matchbox, but they did
not respond. Rajesh (PW2), who was behind him, started moving
fast. Then the three boys started scuffling with Rajesh (PW2) and
began snatching his belongings. One of the boys pointed a knife
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
towards himand asked him and Jitender (PW9) to run away.
Hence, he and Jitender (PW9) ran away, but the boys caught hold
of Rajesh (PW2). When they reached a little ahead, they met one
of their colleagues, namely, Virender (PW5). They informed PW5
about the incident. When they returned to the place where the
incident had occurred, they saw Rajesh (PW2) coming alone.
Rajesh (PW2) told them that his Micromax mobile phone and
purse containing ₹4,000/- had been snatched by the three boys.
Virender (PW5) informed the police, who reached the spot and
recorded his statement as well as the statements of Rajesh (PW2)
and Jitender (PW9). PW4 was unable to identify the offenders.
According to PW4, he had not seen them properly as it was dark.
He identified Ext. MO-1 mobile phone of PW2.
17.1 The prosecutor is seen to have sought permission of the
trial court to put questions as put in cross-examination to PW4
under Section 154 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, on the ground
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
that he was resiling from his previous statement. Permission was
granted by the trial court. On further examination, PW4 admitted
that the incident had occurred on 12.02.2014. He admitted that the
person who had asked fora matchbox had shown a knife; that one
boy had given a fist blow on Rajesh’s (PW2) face and had taken
away the latter’s purse. PW4 admitted that the third boy took out
Rajesh’s (PW2) mobile phone from his right pant pocket.
Thereafter, the three boys ran away towards C-Block. He admitted
that Rajesh (PW2) had told them that his purse contained ₹4,000/-.
He admitted that, in his examination-in-chief, he could not
recollect some of the above facts due to passage of time.
17.2 PW4 in his cross-examination admitted that Rajesh
(PW2) had not purchased Ext. MO-1 mobile phone in his presence,
but he had seen PW2 using the same. He admitted that when the
mobile phone and purse were snatched from PW2, he was not
present at the scene of occurrence. He admitted that he, along with
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
Jitender (PW9), had taken to their heels in order to save
themselves as one of the robbers showed them a knife. He
admitted that not only was it darkness, but there was heavy fog
also on the night of the incident.
18.
PW9, another eye-witness, deposed that on 12.02.2014,
he, along with his colleagues, namely, Rajesh (PW2) and Gautam
(PW4), were returning home on foot to Tekhand. At about 11:15
p.m., when they reached the under-construction underpass near the
jhuggi area at Okhla, Phase-II, they saw three persons warming
themselves by a fire (alao i.e., fire par taap rahe the). One of the
said persons asked Rajesh (PW2) for a matchbox. Rajesh (PW2)
refused as he did not have a matchbox. Immediately thereafter, the
three persons apprehended Rajesh (PW2) and started beating him.
When he and Gautam (PW4) tried to intervene, one of the boys
took a knife and placed it on Gautam’s (PW4) abdomen. One of
the boys took the mobile phone from the right pocket of Rajesh’s
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
(PW2) pants, while another boy took the purse from the latter’s
pant pocket. One of the boys also fisted Rajesh (PW2). Out of fear,
he and Gautam (PW4) fled from the spot. When the police reached
the spot, he, along with the police, searched for the robbers, but
they could not be found. On 16.02.2014, he accompanied the
police to the jhuggi area. When they reached in front of C-Block,
Okhla, Phase-II, he saw one of the robbers and pointed him to the
police. The said person, that is, the accused herein, was
apprehended by the police. PW9 identified the accused before the
trial court. The accused was arrested vide Ext. PW6/C arrest memo
and his personal search was conducted vide memo Ext. PW6/D.
Ext. PW6/E disclosure statement of the accused was recorded
pursuant to which, the knife was recovered from the accused’s
jhuggi, where it was lying beneath a takhat. The knife was seized,
and a sketch was prepared. PW9 identified Ext. MO-2 knife before
the trial court.
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
18.1. PW9 in his cross examination admitted that he took to
his heels when one of the robbers took out the knife. He admitted
that he along with the police had never visited the scene for a
second time. The police came to his workplace on 16.02.2014 and
took him to the jhuggi of the accused. According to PW9, the
incident took place in the night, but there was light from the
electric post. There was no fog. PW9 admitted that he cannot
identify the other two boys involved in the incident. The accused
had uttered “chaku marro”, and hence the reason he was able to
identify the former. He had gone to the place of occurrence for the
second time with police official Parveen (PW10). He had seen the
accused at the time of the incident; then at the police station, and
thereafter in the court.
19.
PW5, Virender Kumar Yadav, deposed that he was
unable to recall the exact date of the incident. In February 2014,
after finishing his work while on his way home, at about 11:30
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
p.m., when he reached the underpass near the Power House,
Okhla, Phase-II, he met his colleagues, Rajesh (PW2), Gautam
(PW4) and Jitender (PW9). They told him that three persons had
robbed Rajesh (PW2) of his mobile phone and had fled from the
spot. He called the police from his mobile phone bearing no.
9711268487. The police made inquiries from him in this regard,
and his statement was recorded.
19.1. PW5 in his cross-examination deposed that it was quite
dark and there was heavy fog on the night of the incident.
20.
PW10, Sub-Inspector, Okhla Industrial Area police
station,the Investigating Officer (IO), deposed regarding the
various steps taken during the course of investigation. He arrested
the accused with the help of PW9. During the course of
interrogation, he recorded Ext. PW6/E disclosure statement of the
accused. The accused led him to a jhuggi in the area of New
Sanjay Camp, Okhla Phase-II, where a takhat was lying. From
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
underneath the takhat, the accused took one knife and handed it
over to him. PW9 identified the knife as the one used in the
commission of the offence. He prepared Ext. PW6/A sketch of the
knife and seized the same vide Ext. PW6/B seizure memo.
21.
Section 386(1) Cr.P.C dealing with the power of the
Appellate Court says that the Court may in an appeal from an order
of acquittal, reverse such order and direct that further inquiry be
made, or that the accused may be re-tried or committed for trial, as
the case may be, or find the accused guilty and pass sentence on
him according to law. The general principles regarding the powers
of the appellate court while dealing with an appeal against
acquittal are:- firstly, the appellate court has the power to review,
reappreciate and reconsider the evidence upon which the order of
acquittal is founded. Secondly, the Code puts no limitation,
restriction or condition on exercise of such power and an appellate
court on the evidence before it, may reach its own conclusion, both
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
on questions of fact and of law. Thirdly, various expressions, such
as, “substantial and compelling reasons”, “good and sufficient
grounds”, “very strong circumstances”, “distorted conclusions”,
“glaring mistakes”, etc. are not intended to curtail the extensive
powers of an appellate court in an appeal against acquittal. Such
phraseologies are more in the nature of “flourishes of language” to
emphasise the reluctance of an appellate court to interfere with an
acquittal than to curtail the power of the court to review the
evidence and to come to its own conclusion. Fourthly, an appellate
court, however, must bear in mind that in the case of acquittal,
there is a double presumption in favour of the accused, that is, (i)
the presumption of innocence is available to him under the
fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that every person
shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved guilty by a
competent court of law, (ii) the accused having secured his
acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is further reinforced,
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial court. Lastly, if two
reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis of the evidence on
record, the appellate court should not disturb the finding of
acquittal recorded by the trial court (See Babu Sahebogouda
Rudragoudar and others v. State of Karnataka (2024) 8 SCC
149, Rajesh Prasad v. State of Bihar (2022) 3 SCC 471,
Chandrappa vs. State of Karnataka, (2007) 4 SCC 415).
21.1 In H.D. Sundara v. State of Karnataka (2023) 9 SCC
581, it has been held that the appellate court, while deciding an
appeal against acquittal, after reappreciating the evidence, is
required to consider whether the view taken by the trial court is a
possible view which could have been taken on the basis of the
evidence on record. If the view taken is a possible view, the
appellate court cannot overturn the order of acquittal on the ground
that another view was also possible. The appellate court can
interfere with the order of acquittal only if it comes to a finding
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
that the only conclusion which can be recorded on the basis of the
evidence on record was that the guilt of the accused was proved
beyond reasonable doubt and that no other conclusion was
possible. Thus, it is beyond the pale of doubt that the scope of
interference by an appellate court for reversing the judgment of
acquittal recorded by the trial court in favour of the accused has to
be exercised within the four corners of the following principles: (i)
the judgment of acquittal suffers from patent perversity; (ii) the
same is based on a misreading/omission to consider material
evidence on record; and (iii) no two reasonable views are possible
and only the view consistent with the guilt of the accused is
possible from the evidence available on record.
22.
As noticed earlier, the accused has been charged by the
trial court for the offences punishable under “Sections 392, 394
read with Section 34 and Section 397 IPC”. The prosecution
primarily rests upon the testimony of PW2, PW4, PW5 and PW9.
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
23.
In Ext. PW2/A FIS/FIR, PW2 says that he can identify
the robbers if they are shown to him. He has no case of any prior
acquaintance. No identification marks of the robbers are also seen
stated in the FIR. However, PW2 in the box has a new case that he
was acquainted with the accused herein as he had seen him on
earlier occasions also and hence the reason why he was able to
identify the accused. But this aspect is conspicuously absent in
Ext. PW2/A FIS/FIR. According to PW2, the incident took place
at about 11:00-11:15 PM on 12.02.2014. It would certainly have
been dark at the time of the incident. There is no reference to any
source of light at the place of occurrence in Ext. PW2/A FIS/FIR.
PW4, as well as PW9, the alleged eyewitnesses, admit that it was
dark at the scene of occurrence. PW5, another witness who came
to the scene of occurrence immediately after the occurrence,
admits that it was not only dark but there was also heavy fog.
PW9, has a case which the other witnesses do not have. According
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
to PW9, there was light from an electric post situated nearby. It is
only PW2 and PW9 who have identified the accused herein.
However, in the light of the aforesaid aspects, the identification of
the accused by the said persons is highly doubtful. PW9 has no
case that he is in any way acquainted with the accused or that he
had at any point of time had the occasion to see or meet the
accused before the date of incident. PW9 admitted in his crossexamination that as soon as the accused had drawn the knife, he
had taken to his heels. Therefore, it is doubtful whether PW9 had
actually seen the accused as claimed by him.
24.
According to PW10, the Investigating Officer (I.O.),
Ext. PW6/E is the disclosure statement based on which the knife
used for the crime was seized from the accused. However, on
going through Ext. PW6/E statement, it can be seen that it is a
totally inadmissible statement in the light of the bar contained
under Section 25 of the Evidence Act, and therefore it ought not to
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
have been marked or brought in evidence. Further, the mobile
phone alleged to have been robbed from PW2 was admittedly
recovered/seized from one of the alleged associates of the accused,
namely, one Bittu (Child in Conflict with Law). The same was
never recovered from the accused herein. In the light of the
aforesaid unsatisfactory evidence, the trial court has acquitted the
accused.
25.
In an appeal against acquittal, interference is warranted
only when the view taken by the trial court is perverse or wholly
unreasonable. The appreciation of evidence by the trial court,
holding that the prosecution failed to establish the identity of the
accused beyond reasonable doubt, is a plausible view based on the
evidence on record. There is no perversity or omission or
misreading of the material(s) on record by the trial court.
26.
Hence, no ground for interference into the impugned
judgment has been made out.
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
27.
In the result, the appeal sans merit is dismissed.
28.
Application(s), if any, pending shall stand closed.
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA
(JUDGE)
JULY 17, 2026
p’ma
CRL.A. 250/2017
Signed By:RAMAN
SHARMA
10:56:40
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review