Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
1.
Letters Patent Appeal No.1445 of 2023
In
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.8568 of 2019
======================================================
State Bank of India through the Chairman, State Bank of India, Corporate
Centre, Madam Cama Road, Nariman Point, Mumbai - 400021.
2.
The Chief General Manager and Reviewing Authority, State Bank of India,
Local Head Office, West Gandhi Maidan, Patna - 800001.
3.
The General Manager (Network-1) and Appellate Authority, State Bank of
India, Local Head Office, West Gandhi Maidan, Patna - 800001.
4.
The Deputy General Manager, (B and O) and Disciplinary Authority, State
Bank of India, Zonal Office, J.C. Road, Patna.
5.
The Regional Manager, State Bank of India, RBO, Patna.
... ... Appellant/s
Versus
Manoj Kumar Choudhary S/o Shri Lal Babu Choudhary, Resident of
Kahartoli, Chowk Shikarpur, P.O. Begumpur, P.S. Chowk, Patna City, Dist. –
Patna.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Appellant/s
:
Mrs. Namrata Mishra, Sr. Advocate
Ms. Archana Jha, Advocate
For the Respondent/s
:
Mr. Bipin Krishna Singh, Advocate
Mr. Kundan Kumar Sinha, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MOHIT KUMAR SHAH
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SOURENDRA PANDEY
ORAL JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SOURENDRA PANDEY)
Date : 09-09-2026
Heard Smt Namrata Mishra, learned Senior counsel
duly assisted by
Ms. Archana Jha, learned counsel for the
appellant and Mr. Bipin Krishna Singh, learned counsel for the
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
2/17
respondent.
2. The present intra-court appeal has been preferred
against the judgment/order dated 12.09.2023 passed by the
learned Single Judge in CWJC No. 8568 of 2019, whereby the
learned Single Judge has set aside the order of punishment dated
16.08.2017 awarded by the disciplinary authority, the appellate
order dated 18.10.2017 and the order dated 29.05.2018,
whereby
the
review
petition
filed
by
the
writ
petitioner/respondent had been rejected as also has directed for
grant of consequential benefits.
3. The brief facts of the case, as per the connected writ
petition, is to the effect that the writ petitioner/respondent joined
the service of State Bank of India/appellant No. 1 as Clerk-cumCashier on 11.04.1994, after having been found successful in the
written competitive examination and interview. The writ
petitioner/respondent was promoted to the officer cadre in
Junior Management Grade Scale-I, after a written examination
and interview, on 25.3.2008 and thereafter, he was promoted to
MMGS-II in the officer cadre in June 2015, pursuant to a
written examination and interview.
4.
During
the
service
period
of
the
writ
petitioner/respondent as Service Manager at Marufganj Branch,
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
3/17
the Government of India issued a Gazette Notification dated
08.11.2016, whereby the Rs.500/- and Rs.1,000/- denominations
of banknotes of the existing series issued by the Reserve Bank
of India ceased to be a legal tender with effect from 09.11.2016.
The Government, however, had given a window of fifty days,
until 30th of December 2016, to deposit or exchange the
demonetized banknotes, causing panic among the public as well
as the bankers, as there were frequent modifications in deposits
and exchange rules.
5. It was during such period that the appellant Bank
observed certain irregularities at Marufganj Branch and on the
instructions of the controlling officer, the Branch Manager of
the
branch
called
for
an explanation
from
the writ
petitioner/respondent vide Letter No. BM/38 dated 07.12.2016,
to which the writ petitioner submitted his reply. Further
clarification was sought from the writ petitioner/respondent by
the Branch Manager vide letter dated 14.12.2016, pursuant to
the instructions received from the Regional Manager vide letter
dated 13.12.2016 and the petitioner again submitted his
clarification, as contained in his reply dated 16.12.2016.
6. After having received the replies of the writ
petitioner/respondent to the explanation letters served upon him
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
4/17
by the Branch Manager, the Regional Manager called for an
explanation directly from the petitioner/respondent vide Letter
No. G/678 dated 27.12.2016, to which the petitioner again
submitted his reply on 12.01.2017.
7. The case of the writ petitioner/respondent is that,
even prior to the submission of his reply on 12.01.2017, the
Disciplinary Authority-cum-Deputy General Manager (B&O),
placed the writ petitioner/respondent under suspension by Letter
No. DGM (B&O)/P/DPS/SUP/81 dated 29.12.2016. The said
letter contained an allegation that during the tenure of the writ
petitioner/respondent as Service Manager at State Bank of India,
Marufganj
Branch,
gross
irregularities/negligence
were
observed on his part, inasmuch as, non-adherence to the bank's
extant instructions post-demonetization and resultantly 92
number of drafts were issued favouring a few companies,
payable at Delhi and Kolkata, for Rs.49,000/- and Rs.49,500/respectively with cash receipts of SBNs in the denomination of
Rs.1,000/- and Rs.500/- from persons of unknown identity.
8.
It
was
thus
alleged
that
the
writ
petitioner/respondent acted with mala fide intention and
authorized
and
effected
such
transactions
to
facilitate
unscrupulous persons illegally, in gross violation of the extant
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
5/17
instructions of the Bank, hence failed to discharge his duties
with utmost integrity, honesty and diligence, thereby it
prejudiced the interest of the Bank in violation of Rule 50(4) of
the State Bank of India Officers' Service Rules.
9. The petitioner/respondent submitted his appeal
against the suspension order before the competent Appellate
Authority, i.e., the General Manager (NW-I) -cum- Appellate
Authority, through his representation dated 12.02.2017, however
the said appeal was rejected and the same was communicated to
the petitioner vide letter dated 23.02.2017.
10. Thereafter, the authorities initiated departmental
proceedings against the writ petitioner/respondent and a chargesheet under cover of Letter No. DGM (B&O)/P/DPS/SUP/97
dated
18.03.2017
was
served
upon
the
writ
petitioner/respondent, wherein two allegations/charges were
levelled against the petitioner/respondent. The charges are
reproduced hereunder:
(i)
You
violated
the
RBI
instructions/guidlines and permitted third party to
deposit in other accounts without any authority letter
and KYC eg. A/C no. 3339133005 for Rs.2.00 lac,
(ii) A/c No. 3361659632 For Rs.7.50 lac, (iii) A/c no.
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
6/17
1030830271
for
Rs.13.50
lac,
(iv)
A/c
no.
3219094619 for Rs.2.00 lac, (v) A/c no. 3347628990
for Rs.2.00 lac etc. on 11.11.2016 & (1) A/c no.
3261776980 for Rs.2.50 lac, (ii) A/c no. 1030830271
for Rs.2.50 Rs.2.50 lac, (ii) A/c no. 3433874616 for
Rs.4.00 lac, (iii) A/c no. 3435845813 for Rs.2.15 lac
on 10.11.2016. lac
(ii)
You
violated
the
RBI
instructions/guidelines on issuance of draft through
cash deposit on various dates and permitted to issue
drafts on various dates frequently through fictitious
persons as KYC is not evidenced in vouchers and
authorized & signed the drafts. The details of drafts
issued as under:
Sl.
No.
Face
value
(Rs..)
Total (Rs.)
Favouring
Status
No.
of
Dra
ft
49500/-
3960000/-
Stopped
49000/-
196000/-
44400/-
88800/-
10000/-
60000/-
Various
Parties
Mangala
m
Organic
G.D.
Goenka P.
School
Various
Govt.
Dept.
Total
Paid
Paid
Unpaid
Rs.4304800/-
11. The said letter contained the articles of charge,
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
7/17
stating that, while posted as Service Manager at Marufganj
Branch between 28.12.2014 to 26.12.2016, the writ petitioner/
respondent failed to discharge his duties with utmost devotion
and diligence and acted in a manner unbecoming of an officer,
which prejudiced the interests of the Bank, in violation of Rule
50(4) of the State Bank of India Officers' Service Rules.
12. The writ petitioner/respondent submitted his reply
to the charge-sheet, denying the allegations and charges levelled
against him, through his reply dated 30.03.2017 and requested
the authority to exonerate him from the allegations, as the same
were not based on facts.
13. Pursuant to the reply furnished by the writ
petitioner/respondent,
the
authorities
initiated
inquiry
proceedings
the
petitioner/respondent,
which
against
commenced on 10.04.2017 and after a thorough inquiry, the
inquiry officer had submitted his enquiry report dated
16.06.2017 finding both the charges to have not been proved. A
copy
of
the
inquiry
report
was
forwarded
to
the
petitioner/respondent through a letter dated 17.06.2017 and the
petitioner/respondent was asked to submit his reply on the
findings of the inquiry officer/disciplinary authority.
14. The petitioner submitted his representation dated
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
8/17
19.06.2017 to the Disciplinary Authority-cum-Deputy General
Manager, requesting therein that, in view of the findings arrived
at by the inquiry officer with regard to the charges, he may be
exonerated of such charges and his period of suspension may be
treated as on duty.
15. The specific case of the writ petitioner/respondent
is that, while the inquiry report was being forwarded to the writ
petitioner/respondent, there was no finding of disagreement
noted in the letter dated 17.06.2017. However, the Disciplinary
Authority-cum-Deputy
General
Manager
(B&O),
as
an
afterthought, communicated to the petitioner/respondent vide
Letter No. DGM(B&O)/P/DPS/SUP/20 dated 11.07.2017,
informing him that he along with others had not agreed with the
findings of the inquiry officer in respect of allegation No. 1 and
allegation No. 2, and held that the allegations are conclusively
proved.
16. The writ petitioner/respondent submitted his
detailed representation in respect of the findings of the
disciplinary authority through representations dated 12.07.2017
and requested to exonerate him of all the charges.
17. The Disciplinary Authority-cum-Deputy General
Manager (B&O), through the impugned Letter No. DGM
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
9/17
(B&O)/P/DPS/SUP/30 dated 16.08.2017, inflicted a punishment
of “CENSURE” in terms of Rule 67(A) of the State Bank of
India Officers' Service Rules and further clarified that the period
of suspension would not be treated as on duty.
18. The writ petitioner/respondent, being aggrieved by
the order of punishment passed by the disciplinary authority,
submitted
his
appeal
through
his
representation
dated
18.09.2017 before the General Manager (Network-I)-cumAppellate Authority, pointing out the deficiencies in the
impugned order. The representation in the form of an appeal did
not cut much ice with the appellate authority, who rejected the
appeal of the petitioner/respondent by his speaking order, as
contained in the impugned Letter No. HR/A&R/2557 dated
18.10.2017.
19. Thereafter, the petitioner preferred a review
petition on 20.04.2018, however the same was also rejected by
an order 29.05.2018 and the orders inflicting punishment as well
as the appellate order were not interfered with.
20. The grievance of the writ petitioner/respondent, as
per the writ petition, was primarily on the point that, after
submission of the inquiry report, the disciplinary authority,
without adducing any disagreement note, issued a second show
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
10/17
caused notice to the writ petitioner/respondent and no reasoning
whatsoever was initially given by the disciplinary authority.
21. It is also the case of the writ petitioner/respondent
that once the reply of the petitioner/respondent was received by
the disciplinary authority, submitted on 19.06.2017, as an
afterthought
another
letter
was
communicated
to
the
petitioner/respondent, wherein the disciplinary authority has
merely stated that he along with others did not agree with the
findings of the inquiry officer, which goes on to show that the
disciplinary authority did not take an independent view on the
report of the inquiry officer and had not applied his mind and
cited any reasons for disagreement with the inquiry report.
22.
It
is
also
the
contention
of
the
writ
petitioner/respondent that none of the authorities, i.e., the
disciplinary authority, appellate authority or reviewing authority,
had applied their independent judicious mind to arrive at a
different finding from that of the inquiry officer.
23. The connected writ petition was heard by the
learned Single Judge and by a judgment dated 12.09.2023, the
writ petition filed by the writ petitioner/respondent was allowed
and the orders passed by the disciplinary authority, appellate
authority and reviewing authority were quashed, holding that
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
11/17
the conclusions of the said authorities were without any material
basis, perverse and were passed without assigning any reason
and therefore, they were legally unsustainable.
24. It is on being aggrieved by the said judgment the
present appeal has been preferred.
25. The learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of
the appellants has submitted that the learned Single Judge has
not considered the stand of the Bank, as taken in the counter
affidavit filed on behalf of the Bank, especially the fact that
Office Letter/Order No. 13 dated 27.04.2016 was duly signed by
the respondent, wherein advice was given to the officers that
drafts should be prepared only through bank accounts, but the
writ petitioner/respondent had prepared the drafts through cash.
26. It has further been submitted that the learned
Single Judge failed to consider the admission undertaken by the
writ petitioner/respondent, as contained in Annexure-5 of the
writ petition, wherein he had accepted that, on account of
inadvertence, such drafts were issued upon accepting cash.
27. The learned senior counsel further pointed out that
the disciplinary authority had noted the fact that, during the
inquiry, with respect to the deposit of Rs.2,15,000/- on
10.11.2016 in one of the accounts, KYC was not obtained at the
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
12/17
time of deposit and was authorized at a later point of time by the
writ petitioner/respondent, which was in clear violation of the
notification issued by the Bank.
28. It has been asserted that, taking everything into
account, the writ petitioner/respondent has been inflicted only
with a minor punishment of “CENSURE” by the disciplinary
authority, considering the lapses/negligence that was observed
on the part of the writ petitioner/respondent while discharging
his official duties.
29. It has lastly been submitted that the learned Single
Judge ought to have remanded the matter back to the authorities
for proceeding afresh in the matter, after having found the order
of punishment, appellate order as well as the order of the
reviewing authority to be perverse and non-speaking orders.
30. Having heard the learned counsel for the
appellants and on meticulous perusal of the materials available
on the record with the connected writ application, we find that
the inquiry officer, while considering the first charge, had taken
into account that, out of eight accounts seven accounts were
current accounts of proprietary firms and the deposit slips
contained the signatures of the proprietors and as regards the
eighth account, it was observed that the same was a savings
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
13/17
bank account and in respect of the deposit made therein, KYC
and the authority letter had been obtained on a later date.
31. We also take note of the findings of the inquiry
officer with respect to the second charge, wherein the writ
petitioner/respondent had taken a specific stand that there was
no separate instructions requiring the obtaining of KYC while
issuing of drafts at the relevant time, nor was there any
instructions prohibiting the issuance of drafts against SBNs of
any denomination and thereby the second charge was also not
found to be proved.
32. On perusal of the order inflicting punishment
dated 16.08.2017, as contained in Annexure-1 of the writ
petition, it is apparent that no consideration whatsoever has been
made to the reply submitted by the writ petitioner/respondent on
12.07.2017, wherein he had replied to each and every charge,
including the disagreement note.
33. From the order dated 16.08.2017, passed by the
disciplinary authority, it is evident that the two charges have
been reproduced ad-verbatim and merely observing that he
agrees with the submissions made by the official, as also no new
facts has been brought on record, the article of charges have
been held to be proved, however no reason has been assigned to
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
14/17
differ from the findings of the enquiry officer, muchless the
submissions of the writ petitioner having been dealt with apart
from there being no justification to hold the writ petitioner
guilty of the two charges levelled against him. Equally, from a
perusal of Annexure-2 and Annexure-3, i.e., the appellate order
dated 18.10.2017 and the order of the reviewing authority dated
29.05.2018, respectively, it is apparent that almost similar kinds
of orders have been passed by the said two authorities and
therefore, the said orders are solely based on a premise that no
new fact has been brought on record by the delinquent/writ
petitioner/respondent. Thus, the said orders passed by the
disciplinary authority, the appellate authority and the reviewing
authority are perverse and based on irrelevant materials as also
founded on no cogent evidence, hence are unsustainable in the
eyes of law.
34. We concur with the findings of the learned Single
Judge that a delinquent is not required to bring on record new
facts at the time of consideration of his appeal to dispel the
charges rather the order of the disciplinary authority is
challenged on the basis of the materials on record and the
assessment made by the disciplinary authority of such materials.
35. From the entire conspectus of the case as also
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
15/17
taking into consideration the arguments advanced by the Ld.
Senior counsel for the appellants, it can be gathered that the
appellants have not disputed the fact that the order passed by the
disciplinary authority dated 16.08.2017 is not only unreasoned
but also without reference to any material, however it has been
alternatively argued by the learned Senior counsel for the
appellants that the matter should have been remanded by the
learned Single Judge to the disciplinary authority for fresh
consideration. In this regard it would suffice to state that firstly
the charges have not stood proved as is apparent from the
enquiry report dated 16.06.2017 and secondly now almost ten
years have passed by, since the departmental proceeding was
initiated against the writ petitioner/respondent, who is also on
the verge of retirement, hence no useful purposes would be served
by remitting the matter back for reconsideration on such a set of
charges in which merely a minor punishment has been inflicted.
36. In the case of Allahabad Bank and Others versus
Krishna Narayan Tewari and Others, reported in (2017) 2 SCC
308 the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has held in Paragraph 8
as under:“8. There is no quarrel with the
proposition that in cases where the High
Court finds the enquiry to be deficient, either
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
16/17
procedurally or otherwise, the proper course
always is to remand the matter back to the
authority concerned to redo the same afresh.
That course could have been followed even
in the present case. The matter could be
remanded back to the disciplinary authority
or to the enquiry officer for a proper enquiry
and a fresh report and order. But that course
may not have been the only course open in a
given situation. There may be situations
where because of a long time-lag or such
other supervening circumstances the writ
court considers it unfair, harsh or otherwise
unnecessary to direct a fresh enquiry or
fresh order by the competent authority. That
is precisely what the High Court has done in
the case at hand.”
37. In the present case the enquiry officer had not
found the charges proved against the writ petitioner/Respondent
on the premise that there was no material against the writ
petitioner/respondent, thus remanding the matter back to the
appellants would also amount to giving the employer a premium
to improve upon their case, thereby causing undue harassment
and being unfair to the writ petitioner/respondent.
38. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of
the case and for the foregoing reasons, we do not find any
Patna High Court L.P.A No.1445 of 2023 dt.09-09-2026
17/17
perversity or illegality in the order dated 12.09.2023 passed by
the learned Single Judge in CWJC No. 8568 of 2019, hence the
present appeal stands dismissed being bereft of any merit.
(Mohit Kumar Shah, J)
(Sourendra Pandey, J)
manoj/tannuAFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
AFR
NA
06.10.2026
NA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review