Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~J* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 26th February 2026
+
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024, CRL.M.A. 20405/2024
SRK DEVBUILD PVT LTD THROUGH ITS LIQUIDATOR MR.
RAVI KAPOOR
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Chandra Shekhar Yadav and Mr.
Astitva Srivastava, Advocates.
versus
GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shaswat Awasthi, Adv.for R2.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI
J U D G M E N T
ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI J.
By way of the present petition filed under section 482 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure 1973 („Cr.P.C.‟), the petitioner seeks
quashing of summoning order dated 23.08.2018 passed by the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate-01, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi in case
bearing CC NI Act No. 12918/2018 in proceedings under section 138
of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 („NI Act‟). The petitioner
also challenges order dated 07.06.2023 passed in the same
proceedings, whereby the learned Magistrate has dismissed an
application filed by the Official Liquidator of the petitioner-company
seeking stay of proceedings.
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
2.
Notice on this petition was issued vidé order dated 15.07.2024 and
proceedings in case bearing CC No. 12918/2018 were stayed qua the
petitioner. Written Submissions dated 05.05.2025 and 06.05.2025
have been filed respectively on behalf of the petitioner and respondent
No.2.
3.
The court has heard Mr. Chandra Shekhar Yadav and Mr. Astitva
Srivastava, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner; and Mr.
Shashwat Awasthi, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.2,
who is the contesting respondent in the matter. Considering the nature
of the case, the State has no role in the matter.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
4.
Mr. Chandra Shekhar Yadav has submitted, that vidé order dated
03.01.2020 passed by the learned National Company Law Tribunal
(„NCLT‟), Indore Bench at Ahmedabad, Corporate Insolvency
Resolution Process („CIRP‟) was initiated against the petitioner
company; and thereafter vidé order dated 26.02.2021, liquidation of
the company was ordered; and accordingly, in view of section 33(5)
of the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 („IBC‟), the institution of
any suit or other legal proceedings against the company was barred.
5.
Furthermore, it has been submitted, that the cheque that is the basis of
the criminal complaint under section 138 of the NI Act, viz., Cheque
No. 000011 dated 05.06.2018 for Rs. 2 crores, was drawn on the
personal account of Accused No. 2 Mr. Subhash Chand Aggarwal,
and not on the petitioner company‟s bank account; and therefore, the
company could never have been arrayed as an accused in the criminal
complaint.
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
6.
Learned counsel has also argued, that the criminal complaint did not
contain any specific allegation imputing any liability upon the
petitioner company; nor had the complainant invoked vicarious
liability on the part of accused No. 2 arising from any default on the
part of the company; nor had the complainant invoked section 141 of
the NI Act in the criminal complaint. In this regard, learned counsel
has placed reliance on the decisions of the Supreme Court in P.J.
Agro Tech Ltd. and Others vs. Water Base Ltd. 1 , Inder Mohan
Goswami & Anr. vs. State of Uttaranchal 2 Pepsi Foods Ltd. & Anr.
vs. Special Judicial Magistrate & Ors 3 to submit, that the
summoning of an accused in a criminal case is a serious matter and a
summoning order must reflect the Magistrate’s considered satisfaction
with regard to an offence being made-out. It has been argued that a
summoning order under section 138 of the NI Act cannot be passed
mechanically or against a non-drawer of the cheque, without evidence
of any complicity in the offence.
7.
In furtherance of their argument, learned counsel for the petitioner has
drawn attention to the relevant extract of the impugned summoning
order, which reads as under:
“Evidence by way of affidavit tendered by AR of complaint.
Original documents have been filed on record alongwith the
complaint. Statement of AR of complaint recorded separately.
Documents have been exhibited. Pre-summoning evidence closed on
behalf of AR complainant.
(2010) 12 SCC 146, paras 7 and 9
(2007) 12 SCC 1
(1998) 5 SCC 749
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
“Arguments on the point of summoning have been heard at
length. Complaint and documents rendered in evidence of the
complaint have been perused. All the statutory requirements for
summoning of the accused for the commission of offence
punishable U/s 138 NIA Act have been complied with. The present
complaint case has been filed within the statutory period of
limitation. After perusal of the entire record, this court is of the
considered opinion that a prima facie case for the commission of
offence punishable u/s 138 of NI Act is made out against the
accused. I therefore, take cognizance of the offence punishable u/s
138 NI Act, 1881.
“Issue summons to the accused on filing of PF/EC/AD/Speed
Post returnable on 21.03.2019.
“Steps be taken within three weeks.”
(emphasis supplied)
8.
Most importantly, learned counsel has submitted that vidé order dated
06.05.2024 passed by a Co-ordinate Bench in CRL.M.C. 3618/2024,
proceedings qua co-accused Mrs. Gulab Chand Agarwal, who is one
of the Directors of the petitioner-company, have been stayed.
9.
Therefore, the petitioner has argued, that the petitioner-company
could not have been summonsed under section 138 of the NI Act,
since it was not the “drawer” of the cheque under section 7 of the NI
Act. It has accordingly been urged, that the impugned summoning
order dated 23.08.2018 is vague and has been passed mechanically,
without referring to the essential statutory ingredients for making-out
an offence against the petitioner company under section 138 of the NI
Act.
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT NO.2
10.
At the outset, Mr. Shashwat Awasthi, learned counsel has argued that
the petitioner‟s challenge to the impugned summoning order suffers
from gross, unexplained delay, given that the present petition came to
be filed on 14.05.2024, just before the stage of framing of notice,
though the petitioner-company was admitted to insolvency on
03.01.2020 and their plea for stay of the proceedings was rejected by
the learned Magistrate vidé order dated 07.06.2023.
11.
In this vein, learned counsel has drawn attention to the conduct of the
accused persons, to submit, that due to continued non-appearance on
behalf of the petitioner-company, the learned Magistrate was
constrained to issue bailable warrants against the directors of the
petitioner-company on 24.03.2021; followed by non-bailable warrants
on 11.04.2022; and, lastly, process was also issued under section 82
of the Cr.P.C. against accused Nos. 2 and 3, who are directors of the
petitioner-company on 19.09.2022. Furthermore, learned counsel has
submitted, that despite this court having clarified vidé order dated
15.07.2024, that the proceedings before the learned Magistrate have
not been stayed qua Subhash Chand Agarwal, who is the signatory of
the cheque, the said accused person has persistently defaulted in
appearance before the learned Magistrate.
12.
Mr. Awasthi has accordingly submitted, that the present petition
ought to be dismissed even solely by reason of the conduct of the
accused persons; and for the inordinate delay in filing the petition. In
support of this submission, learned counsel has drawn attention to the
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
decision of a Co-ordinate Bench of this court in Sanyam Bhushan &
Anr. vs. State (NCT of Delhi)& Anr.4
13.
Insofar as the impugned summoning order is concerned, learned
counsel has submitted, that the learned Magistrate has duly recorded
his prima facie satisfaction for issuing summons after perusing the
complaint, the supporting affidavit, the original cheque, and the
cheque return memo. Learned counsel submits, that the subject
cheque for Rs. 2 crores was issued by accused No.2 in discharge of a
legally enforceable liability arising from various commercial
agreements, including a Personal Guarantee Deed dated 31.03.2017
and the subject cheque reflects the composite liability of the
petitioner-company.
14.
It has been submitted, that the complaint was filed within the period
of limitation, after the statutory notice was duly issued by the
complainant and received by the accused persons. Furthermore, the
complaint discloses the common and composite liability of the
petitioner-company as well as of accused Nos. 2 and 3, who are the
directors of the petitioner-company; and the learned Magistrate has
rightly summonsed all the said persons as accused, keeping in mind
the vicarious liability arising under section 141 of the NI Act.
15.
Most importantly, Mr. Awasthi has submitted, that order dated
07.06.2023, whereby the learned Magistrate has rejected the
petitioner‟s plea seeking stay of proceedings, is a speaking and
2024 SCC OnLine Del 4545, paras 45 and 46
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
reasoned order in-line with the judgment of the Supreme Court in P.
Mohanraj vs. Shah Brothers Ispat (P) Ltd.5
16.
Reference has also been made by learned counsel for the respondent
to Sudeep Jain vs. M/s. ECE Industries Ltd.6, to submit that though
the court has advocated greater scrutiny by Magistrates at the presummoning stage, to ensure prima-facie satisfaction under section
141 NI Act without mechanically arraying parties in criminal
complaint, in the present case the learned Magistrate has exercised
requisite attention and consideration before issuing summons to the
accused persons.
LEGAL LANDSCAPE
17.
Examining the relevant legal landscape, in Sunil Todi vs. State of
Gujarat,7 the Supreme Court has inter-alia observed as follows:
“41. In Birla Corpn. Ltd. v. Adventz Investments & Holdings
Ltd. [Birla Corpn. Ltd. v. Adventz Investments & Holdings Ltd.,
(2019) 16 SCC 610 : (2020) 2 SCC (Civ) 713 : (2020) 2 SCC (Cri)
828], the earlier decisions which have been referred to above were
cited in the course of the judgment. The Court noted : (SCC p. 628,
para 26)
“26. The scope of enquiry under this section is extremely
restricted only to finding out the truth or otherwise of the allegations
made in the complaint in order to determine whether process should be
issued or not under Section 204 CrPC or whether the complaint should
be dismissed by resorting to Section 203 CrPC on the footing that there
is no sufficient ground for proceeding on the basis of the statements of
the complainant and of his witnesses, if any. At the stage of enquiry
under Section 202 CrPC, the Magistrate is only concerned with the
allegations made in the complaint or the evidence in support of the
(2021) 6 SCC 258
2013 SCC OnLine Del 1804
(2022) 16 SCC 762
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
averments in the complaint to satisfy himself that there is sufficient
ground for proceeding against the accused.”
*****
“46. In the present case, the Magistrate has adverted to:
(i) The complaint;
(ii) The affidavit filed by the complainant;
(iii) The evidence as per evidence list and; and
(iv) The submissions of the complainant.
“47. The order passed by the Magistrate cannot be held to
be invalid as betraying a non-application of mind. In Chief
Controller of Imports & Exports v. Roshanlal Agarwal [Chief
Controller of Imports & Exports v. Roshanlal Agarwal, (2003) 4
SCC 139 : 2003 SCC (Cri) 788], this Court has held that in
determining the question as to whether process is to be issued, the
Magistrate has to be satisfied whether there is sufficient ground
for proceeding and not whether there is sufficient ground for
conviction. Whether the evidence is adequate for supporting the
conviction can only be determined at the trial. [See also in this
context the decision in Bhushan Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi)
[Bhushan Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2012) 5 SCC 424 :
(2012) 2 SCC (Cri) 872].”
(emphasis supplied)
18.
In its judgment in Mehmood Ul Rehman vs. Khazir Mohammad
Tunda & Ors., 8 while relying on the celebrated judgment of the
Supreme Court in Pepsi Foods Ltd., and emphasizing the seriousness
of setting in motion the process of criminal law against a person, the
Supreme Court has reiterated the following:
“20. The extensive reference to the case law would clearly
show that cognizance of an offence on complaint is taken for the
purpose of issuing process to the accused. Since it is a process of
taking judicial notice of certain facts which constitute an offence,
there has to be application of mind as to whether the allegations in
(2015) 12 SCC 420
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
the complaint, when considered along with the statements
recorded or the inquiry conducted thereon, would constitute
violation of law so as to call a person to appear before the criminal
court. It is not a mechanical process or matter of course. As held
by this Court in Pepsi Foods Ltd. [Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. Judicial
Magistrate, (1998) 5 SCC 749 : 1998 SCC (Cri) 1400] to set in
motion the process of criminal law against a person is a serious
matter.
*****
“22. The steps taken by the Magistrate under Section
190(1)(a) CrPC followed by Section 204 CrPC should reflect that
the Magistrate has applied his mind to the facts and the statements
and he is satisfied that there is ground for proceeding further in
the matter by asking the person against whom the violation of law
is alleged, to appear before the court. The satisfaction on the
ground for proceeding would mean that the facts alleged in the
complaint would constitute an offence, and when considered along
with the statements recorded, would, prima facie, make the accused
answerable before the court. No doubt, no formal order or a
speaking order is required to be passed at that stage. The Code of
Criminal Procedure requires speaking order to be passed under
Section 203 CrPC when the complaint is dismissed and that too the
reasons need to be stated only briefly. In other words, the
Magistrate is not to act as a post office in taking cognizance of each
and every complaint filed before him and issue process as a matter
of course. There must be sufficient indication in the order passed
by the Magistrate that he is satisfied that the allegations in the
complaint constitute an offence and when considered along with the
statements recorded and the result of inquiry or report of
investigation under Section 202 CrPC, if any, the accused is
answerable before the criminal court, there is ground for
proceeding against the accused under Section 204 CrPC, by issuing
process for appearance. The application of mind is best
demonstrated by disclosure of mind on the satisfaction. If there is
no such indication in a case where the Magistrate proceeds under
Sections 190/204 CrPC, the High Court under Section 482 CrPC
is bound to invoke its inherent power in order to prevent abuse of
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
the power of the criminal court. To be called to appear before the
criminal court as an accused is serious matter affecting one's
dignity, self-respect and image in society. Hence, the process of
criminal court shall not be made a weapon of harassment.
“23. Having gone through the order passed by the
Magistrate, we are satisfied that there is no indication on the
application of mind by the learned Magistrate in taking cognizance
and issuing process to the appellants. The contention that the
application of mind has to be inferred cannot be appreciated. The
further contention that without application of mind, the process will
not be issued cannot also be appreciated. Though no formal or
speaking or reasoned orders are required at the stage of Sections
190/204 CrPC, there must be sufficient indication on the
application of mind by the Magistrate to the facts constituting
commission of an offence and the statements recorded under
Section 200 CrPC so as to proceed against the offender. No doubt,
the High Court is right in holding that the veracity of the allegations
is a question of evidence. The question is not about veracity of the
allegations, but whether the respondents are answerable at all
before the criminal court. There is no indication in that regard in
the order passed by the learned Magistrate.”
(emphasis supplied)
1.
19.
Furthermore, in its recent judgment in JM Laboratories & Ors/ vs.
State of A.P. & Anr.,9 the Supreme Court has re-enunciated that a
summoning order passed by a Magistrate should reflect his
application of mind in the following words:
“8. In the judgment and order of even date in criminal
appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 2345 of 2024 titled “INOX Air
Products Limited Now Known as INOX Air Products Private
Limited v. The State of Andhra Pradesh”, we have observed thus:
“33. It could be seen from the aforesaid order that except
recording the submissions of the complainant, no reasons are
2025 SCC OnLine SC 208
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
recorded for issuing the process against the accused persons.
“34. In this respect, it will be relevant to refer to the
following observations of this Court in the case of Pepsi Foods
Ltd. v. Special Judicial Magistrate (1998) 5 SCC 749 (supra):
“28. Summoning of an accused in a criminal case is
a serious matter. Criminal law cannot be set into motion as a matter of
course. It is not that the complainant has to bring only two witnesses to
support his allegations in the complaint to have the criminal law set
into motion. The order of the Magistrate summoning the accused must
reflect that he has applied his mind to the facts of the case and the law
applicable thereto. He has to examine the nature of allegations made in
the complaint and the evidence both oral and documentary in support
thereof and would that be sufficient for the complainant to succeed in
bringing charge home to the accused. It is not that the Magistrate is a
silent spectator at the time of recording of preliminary evidence before
summoning of the accused. The Magistrate has to carefully scrutinise the
evidence brought on record and may even himself put questions to the
complainant and his witnesses to elicit answers to find out the
truthfulness of the allegations or otherwise and then examine if any
offence is prima facie committed by all or any of the accused.”
*****
“37. Recently, a Bench of this Court to which one of us (Gavai, J.)
was a Member, in the case of Lalankumar Singh v. State of Maharashtra
2022 SCC OnLine SC 1383 (supra), has observed thus:
“38. The order of issuance of process is not an empty formality.
The Magistrate is required to apply his mind as to whether sufficient
ground for proceeding exists in the case or not. The formation of such an
opinion is required to be stated in the order itself. The order is liable to
be set aside if no reasons are given therein while coming to the
conclusion that there is a prima facie case against the accused. No
doubt, that the order need not contain detailed reasons. A reference in
this respect could be made to the judgment of this Court in the case of
Sunil Bharti Mittal v. Central Bureau of Investigation, which reads thus:
*****
“53.However, the words “sufficient ground for
proceeding” appearing in Section 204 are of immense importance. It is
these words which amply suggest that an opinion is to be formed only
after due application of mind that there is sufficient basis for proceeding
against the said accused and formation of such an opinion is to be stated
in the order itself. The order is liable to be set aside if no reason is given
therein while coming to the conclusion that there is prima facie case
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
against the accused, though the order need not contain detailed reasons.
A fortiori, the order would be bad in law if the reason given turns out to
be ex facie incorrect.”
*****
“9. In the present case also, no reasons even for the
namesake have been assigned by the learned Magistrate. The
summoning order is totally a non-speaking one. We therefore find
that in light of the view taken by us in criminal appeal arising out of
SLP (Crl.) No. 2345 of 2024 titled “INOX Air Products Limited
Now Known as INOX Air Products Private Limited v. The State of
Andhra Pradesh”, and the legal position as has been laid down by
this Court in a catena of judgments including in the cases of Pepsi
Foods Ltd. v. Special Judicial Magistrate, Sunil Bharti Mittal v.
Central Bureau of Investigation, Mehmood Ul Rehman v. Khazir
Mohammad Tunda and Krishna Lal Chawla v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, the present appeal deserves to be allowed.”
(emphasis supplied)
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
20.
Though much has been argued on behalf of the petitioner-company in
challenge to summoning order dated 23.08.2018, the material
considerations that emerge for purposes of the present decision are the
following:
20.1. The subject cheque, though admittedly drawn on the personal
account of one of the directors-Mr. Subhash Chand Aggarwal,
was drawn inter alia in accordance with the Deed of Personal
Guarantee dated 31.03.2017, whereby the said director had
stood guarantee for performance by the petitioner-company of
certain obligations. Therefore, it is not possible to infer, least of
all at this stage, that the subject cheque was not issued in
discharge of a debt or liability owed by the petitioner-company.
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
20.2. The subject cheque was dated 05.06.2018 and was dishonoured
by way of Return Memo dated 08.06.2018.
20.3. The record shows that the petitioner-company went under
moratorium in CIRP proceedings on 03.01.2020; and thereafter,
went into liquidation on 26.02.2021. Therefore, the CIRP
proceedings and the liquidation proceedings happened after
more than about 02 years of the issuance and dishonour of the
subject cheque.
20.4. The liability of the petitioner-company under section 138 of the
NI Act, as may come to be determined in the course of the trial,
arose well before the CIRP or liquidation proceedings, and
therefore, whether or not that liability would be effaced by
subsequent events, would have to be seen in the course of the
trial, subject to the provisions of the IBC inter-alia sections
33(5) and 35(1)(k) of that statute.
20.5. The stay of proceedings against another director of the
petitioner-company, Mrs. Gulab Chand Aggarwal (accused
No.3), vidé order dated 06.05.2024 passed in CRL.M.C. No.
3618/2024 would also have no bearing on the present matter.
20.6. Furthermore, testing the summoning order on the anvil of the
settled law as per the judicial precedents discussed above,
would show that that though the Magistrate is required to
consider the averments in the complaint and the material and
evidence that comes on record, the Magistrate is not required to
give detailed reasons at the stage of issuing summons in
proceedings under section 138 of the NI Act.
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
21. In the present case, though the Magistrate has omitted to narrate in the
impugned summoning order as to how a prima-facie case is made-out
against the petitioner-company, considering that the summoning order
is dated 23.08.2018, and since this court has perused the complaint, the
requisite documents, including the subject cheque, the cheque
dishonour memo, and the statutory notice issued under section 138 of
the NI Act, that have been placed before it, this court would refrain
from interfering with the impugned summoning order, though the
ingredients of the offence do not find any mention in it.
22. As a sequitur of the above, the petition is dismissed.
23. The stay of proceedings before the learned Magistrate qua the
petitioner-company, as directed vidé order dated 15.07.2024, stands
vacated.
24. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed-of.
ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI, J
FEBRUARY 26, 2026
HMJ
Signed By:DIVYA
SHARMA
Signing
Date:26.02.2026 15:04
CRL.M.C. 5337/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review