Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Reetobroto Kumar Mitra
WPA 28984 of 2026
Srikanta Chakraborty and another
Vs.
The State of West Beangal and others.
For the Petitioners
: Mr. Anindya Lahiri,
Mr. Arkadeb Biswas,
Mr. Subhomoy Paul,
Mr. Anish Chakraborty,
Mr. Biplab Pal.
For the State
: Mr. Piush Chaturvedi,
Mr. Anujit Mookherji.
Heard on : 12.10.2026, 14.10.2026,
Judgment on : 15th October 2026.
The Court:
1. The petitioners are the candidates who had applied for the
recruitment process for Constable in the West Bengal Police,
initiated by the West Bengal Recruitment Board in the year 2024.
2. Though
this
process
of
recruitment
was
initiated
by
an
Advertisement issued sometime in 2024, the petitioners have
chosen to challenge this recruitment process at this stage,
sometime in September 2026. The reason for the late challenge
has been ascribed to a change of circumstances emanating from
a judgment of this Hon’ble Court in WPO 16 of 2011 (Kamal
Chandra Das Vs. State of West Bengal & Ors.).
3. By virtue of this judgment, the prevalent list of OBC-A and OBCB, which included various sub-castes was set aside and the vast
multitude of classification was restricted to 66 classes only.
4. All candidates belonging to OBC-A & OBC-B, depending on their
class/caste were either included as OBC candidates or were
excluded, thereby putting them in the unreserved list.
5. It is these excluded candidates who are beyond the OBC list by
virtue of the said judgment, who has been given an opportunity to
participate in the recruitment process as Economically Weaker
Section (EWS) candidates. It is this categorization or at least the
opportunity given to such excluded candidates to avail the EWS
category, that has been challenged in this writ-petition.
6. Mr. Lahiri, learned senior Advocate appearing for the petitioners,
has made the following submissions:
(a) The inclusion or the leave granted to such left out
candidates who are termed as unreserved candidates to
include themselves in the EWS category tantamounts to
changing the rules of the game, post commencement of the
game.
(b) By including or at least permitting such candidates to
be included in the EWS category, the original EWS
candidates will have to face a stiffer competition, thereby
impeding their chances and the opportunity of the original
EWS category candidates to have any chance of in the
recruitment process.
(c) EWS categorization is not by birth, such as the
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes candidates. Their
status may change on a yearly basis, depending on their
income and asset declaration, on account whereof the
excluded candidates from the OBC-A and OBC-B list
cannot be permitted to take advantage of reservation under
the EWS category. The advertisement in Clause 3(b) clearly
mentioned the following:
“3. RESERVATION OF VACANCIES:
(a)……….
(b) In terms of Memorandum NO. 9659-BCW/MR52/2019 dated 18.05.2023 of Backward Classes
Welfare Department, Govt. of West Bengal, the
candidates from Economically Weaker Sections (EWSs),
if shortlisted for interview must produce INCOME and
ASSET CERTIFICATE issued by the competent authority
for the Financial Year 2023-2024 or onwards during
checking of testimonials on the date of Interview. The
date of issuance of such certificate must be between
01.04.2023 and 31.03.2024. Candidates seeking
reservation under EWS category must produce that
certificate as per specified format (Annexure-C) as
enclosed herewith. Non production of valid INCOME
and ASSET CERTIFICARE warrants ineligibility of a
candidate under EWS category. However, he/she will be
considered under UR category at the time of final
selection subject to fulfillment of selection criteria.
INCOME and ASSET CERTIFICATE issued from states
other than West Bengal shall not be considered and
such candidate will be treated under Unserved
category.”
(d) The advertisement clearly states that the EWS certificate
should be for the financial year 2023-24 or onwards during
checking of testimonials on the date of interview and that
the date of issuance of such certificate must be between 1st
April 2023 and 31st March 2024. Thus, the excluded
candidates from the OBC-A & OBC-B list cannot under any
circumstances fall within the zone of consideration as EWS
candidates, as, EWS certificate has to be for the financial
year 2023-24 issued between 1st April 2023 and 31st March
2024. On this date, the excluded candidates were all OBC-A
and OBC-B. Thus, these candidates who have been given
this leverage to participate in the recruitment process
under the EWS category sometime in 2026 cannot fulfill the
afore-stated criteria and must necessarily fail.
(e) Alternatively, if their candidatures under the EWS
category is to be considered, these dates have to be altered,
thereby resulting in a clear alteration of the rules of the
game. This is impermissible.
(f) According to him, relying on the Office Memo No. 325PAR(AR)/3P-1/2019 dated 9th July 2019, the eligibility
criteria as contained in clause 5 thereof and particularly 5(i)
disables a person under the OBC category along with other
reserved categories to be treated as an EWS category
candidate.
(g) The Office Memo No. 36039/1/2019-Estt (Res) dated
31st January 2019 also clarifies under clause 5 that while
treating reservations for EWS in direct recruitment in civil
posts and services in the Government of India particularly,
in clause 5.3 thereof, the crucial date has been defined as
the date for submitting income and asset certificate by the
candidate as the closing date for receipt of application for
the post, except in cases where the crucial date is fixed
otherwise. On the basis of this, the crucial date, according
to him, is between 1st April 2023 and 31st March 2024.
(h) He has also placed reliance on the published FAQ
(Frequently Asked Question) dated September 19, 2022,
where the crucial date and the disclosure thereof have been
defined in answer to question 21.
(i) He has also relied upon the notice of 14th September
bearing
number
WBPRB/NOTICE-2026/10
(CONS._LC-KP-24). According to him, this notice is a device
by which the rules of the game have been tweaked after the
game has commenced.
(j) He has placed reliance on the following decisions: (1)
(2024) 2 SCC 605 (Union Public Service Commission vs.
Gaurav Singh and others), (2) 2025 SCC OnLine SC 757
(Sakshi Arha v. Rajasthan High Court and Others) and (3)
MAT 1320 of 2026 (Shreyasi Dhang vs. The State of West
Bengal and Ors.), decided on 12th August 2026.
7. Mr. Chaturvedi, learned senior advocate appearing for the State
respondents, has made the following submissions:
i. He has filed a report pursuant to the direction of this Court
which is kept on record. From the report it appears that several
candidates belonging to the erstwhile OBC-A and OBC-B
category have changed their classification/category to EWS.
ii. A further number of 1251 candidates including both male and
female aspirants have also opted for the EWS category. These
candidates in terms of the report belong to the unreserved
category.
iii. According to him, the candidates mentioned in paragraph 1 of
the report are those who are excluded from the entire list of
candidates by virtue of the judgment in Amal Kumar Das
(supra). Hence, they were permitted to exercise the option and
opted for EWS category.
iv. The candidates mentioned in paragraph 2 of the report are
those who belong to the unreserved category but opted for the
EWS category after the second window for category up-dation.
The second window remained operative from 14th September
2026 till 21st September 2026 and was thereafter extended till
26th September 2026.
v. He further submits that the notice for recruitment of 2024
(which has been set out hereinbefore) does not limit the
credentials of an EWS candidate to any particular year or for
the financial year 2023-24. This, since, the timelines have been
enlarged in the advertisement itself as financial year 2023-24
“or onwards”. According to him, this phrase "or onwards"
means and indeed refers to an extended timeline, on account
whereof the timeline for the relevant year cannot be given a
restrictive interpretation to mean 2023-24 only.
vi. He has further indicated that the timeline of issuance of
certificate between 1st April 2023 and 31st March 2024 cannot
be construed as a crucial date and is indeed nothing but an
example relating to financial year 2023-2024. This is obvious
as
this
would
completely
disable
a
valid
or
workable
interpretation, in line with the phrase "or onwards". In other
words, if the financial year was 2023-24 “or onwards”, the
same would also relate to financial years 2024-25 and 20252026. For these subsequent years, the timeline between 1st
April 2023 and 31st March 2024 would render a rather
redundant interpretation. This time to obtain the EWS
certificate as given is merely an example relatable to the given
financial year 2023-24.
vii. He has also placed reliance on clause 4 note 8 (bullet note) at
page 24 of the writ petition to demonstrate that this phrase
"onwards" was not a mistake or an indiscriminate usage by the
authorities. This bullet point also specifies that the income and
asset certificate has to be for the year 2023-24 or onwards.
viii. He has also placed reliance on a notice of August 12, 2026 at
page 51 of the writ petition whereby the notification number
945 BCW/MR-23/2026 dated 18th May 2026, has been issued
granting leave to the candidates belonging to OBC category
have to produce particular certificates, which are specified and
are stipulated.
ix. He has also placed reliance on a decision of a Coordinate
Bench of this Hon’ble Court in WPA 2877 of 2026 (Sudipta
Chakraborty and others vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors.)
where an identical clause was challenged in the West Bengal
Police Recruitment Board. It did not find favor with the learned
Judge and was dismissed holding that the EWS certificates
issued for the financial year 2022-23 till the date of interview in
the year 2026 has to be taken as a valid and benefit of
reservation ought to be given to such candidates who produced
such certificate.
8.
Mr. Chaturvedi has declined to file any affidavit-in-opposition, as
the same is not required. Accordingly, since the matter revolves
around on point of law and the facts are not in dispute, he has
declined to file an affidavit. However, the report filed by the State
is kept on record.
9. I have heard the learned Advocates for the parties and considered
the documents and decisions relied upon by them.
10. The petitioners are aggrieved that the authority has extended the
benefit of reservation to the candidates who are not entitled to
such benefit on the date of commencement of the recruitment
process.
11. This is the only issue which has been raised as of other issues are
in aid of proving that these candidates who have subsequently
benefited from the EWS categorization were not thereby entitled
on the date of the publication of the advertisement of the
recruitment notice. To understand this issue, it is absolutely
imperative that a decision of the Hon’ble Division Bench and the
manner in which it has been challenged and thereafter withdrawn
is enumerated.
12. The government decision to include various sub-castes and subcategories into the OBC list, thereby expanding and enlarging the
list to OBC-A and OBC-B was challenged before this Court by
way of a writ petition, which was finally allowed.
13. By this decision, several of the sub-categories and sub-castes,
which have been classified as OBC A and OBC B were set aside
and 66 categories were classified as OBC candidates. Thus, all
candidates purporting to fall within the classification of OBC A
and OBC B were removed from such classification or rather the
classification itself (OBC A and OBC B) was removed. Thus, there
were to be only OBC candidates. This decision was rendered
sometime in May 2024.
14. Without getting into the intricacies of the challenge, the challenge
itself before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in India was withdrawn
sometime in May 2026, on account whereof the decision in Kamal
Chandra Das (supra) attained finality.
15. A question therefore arose as to what would be the status of those
persons who had participated in the recruitment process, which
commenced just prior to the judgment in Kamal Chandra Das
(supra) in the ongoing process. The persons who had participated
as OBC A and OBC B candidates would have to exercise an
option to become OBC candidates if their respective class were
included in the list of 66 classes of OBC or if they were excluded
from that list, they would be considered as unreserved category.
16. To facilitate this process, the State Government provided a
window. This window was given to these excluded candidates to
afford themselves into the EWS category upon fulfillment of all
other eligibility criteria. If they failed, they would be considered as
unreserved candidates.
17. It is true that this would tantamount to changing the rules of the
game, if the advertisement had specified a crucial date for
obtaining the income and asset certificate from the competent
authority or a crucial timeline for which the income and asset
certificate would be applicable.
18. None of these dates are fixed. The advertisement itself says that
the income and asset certificate to be issued by the competent
authority would be for the financial year 2023-24 “or onwards”.
Onwards in the dictionary parlance would mean a period beyond
the period indicated. The period indicated herein, 2023-24, and
onwards would mean any time thereafter till it is specified. The
second date which is the time for obtaining such certificate on 1st
April 2023 and 31st March 2024 is also not a fixed timeline and
cannot be construed as a crucial date, as the same has to be read
in consonance with the phrase “or onwards”. If onwards were to
be construed as any time after the specified financial year, the
given timeline to obtain the certificate between 1st April 2023 to
31st March 2024, would be absolutely redundant. This is merely
an indicator.
19. This would also stand to reason as the timeline could not have
been specified, in view of the fact that the recruitment process
which commenced sometime in 2024 is still in progress. The
interview for the candidates took place in 2026. Thus, to limit the
financial credentials of an EWS category relating back to the year
2023-2024 would be a complete non-starter, as the present
eligibility is to be considered for recruitment in 2026. It is
precisely for this reason that the window had been kept open in
the advertisement itself. Thus, by permitting the excluded
candidates of the OBC A and OBC B list to participate as EWS
candidates, the rules of the game have not in any manner been
altered. In fact, on the contrary, if the State or the Board were to
say that these timelines were fixed, in spite of the phrase “or
onwards”, that would result in change of the rules of the game.
20. The submission of the petitioners that the petitioners are being
put to more restricted terms as the competition of the same
number of posts will increase, is clearly not a ground to deny the
eligible candidates for competing in the recruitment process.
21. Of course, without in any manner deterring or disabling the
principles of equity and fairplay in such process. The candidates
who were excluded from the OBC A and OBC B list as a result of
the decision of this Hon’ble Court, which occurred after the
recruitment process had commenced and these candidates all
participated as OBC A and OBC B, as they were included therein.
Though the subsequent change cannot be a ground to afford any
further opportunities to such candidates, in this particular case,
there is no additional or convoluted opportunity which has been
granted to this person. These persons have merely been given an
opportunity to produce the requisite certificate pronouncing them
as EWS candidates, upon fulfilling all other eligibility criteria. It is
not as if by merely producing the EWS certificates, these
candidates would automatically get appointment or that the
candidates like the petitioners or similarly situated would be
denied their opportunity of recruitment.
22. The candidates in the unreserved category who have also
participated as EWS subsequently have also been given the
opportunity,
as
enshrined
in
the
recruitment
notice/advertisement published. It cannot be said that these
persons were given an additional or any extra leverage beyond the
terms of the advertisement.
23. If the statement of the petitioners is to be accepted, then persons
in the unreserved category would also feel deprived, as the
candidates who havge been excluded from the list of OBC-A and
OBC-B would be treated as unreserved candidates. In that event,
these candidates would be left with no opportunity to participate
in the recruitment process at all. This interpretation cannot be
given.
24. The petitioners had the right to challenge the recruitment notice
on the ground that no fixed date had been provided as the
“crucial date”. The petitioners have chosen for more than two
years not to challenge such advertisement. Having in fact
participated in the process without any protest or demur, they
cannot at this belated stage challenge the same on the ground of
the “commencement of the process” or “the crucial date” not
being fixed, or not being to their liking.
25. The decision in MAT 320 of 2026 relates to the OBC certificates
and the treatment to be meted out to such persons as general
category candidates. This decision does not relate to any EWS
candidate or the excluded candidates being treated as such.
26. In the decision of Sakshi Arha (supra) it refers to the creamy and
non-creamy layers and their categorization which was quite
unconnected with the facts of this case and is therefore of no
application.
27. In the decision of Gaurav Singh and others (supra), the question
of income and asset certificate and the date of such application
has been construed as the financial year prior to the year of
application and the closing date for receipt of applications for the
post, except in cases where a different crucial date was fixed. It is
precisely the case here, as a date has been fixed by the
authorities, which, however, is not rigid. Such date has been kept
open-ended as will appear from the phrase “or onwards”.
28. The
decision
relied
upon
by
the
respondent
of
Sudipta
Chakraborty and others (supra) is clear that the crucial date
cannot be taken as the last date of filing application form for
recruitment. It is clear that in this case as well the expression
except in cases where crucial date is fixed otherwise will have to
be construed in accordance with the recruitment notice.
29. The recruitment notice herein is clear and unequivocal that there
is no rigid crucial date.
30. This court was unable to find any clause requiring an uploading
or production of EWS certificates prior to the date of interview. In
fact, the recruitment notice itself (clause 3(b)) specified that the
checking of testimonials would be on the date of the interview.
Thus, if the requisite certificates were produced and placed for
investigation on the date of interview, the stipulations of the
recruitment notice is sufficiently complied.
31. The petitioners had participated in the process and had never
questioned this issue of presenting testimonials on the date of the
interview. Thus, the petitioners at this belated stage cannot seek
to challenge the same having participated therein that the crucial
date should be construed as a prior date and not the date of
interview.
32. In view of the aforesaid discussions and deliberations, the
following conclusions are inevitable:
A. All EWS certificates issued for the financial year 2023-2024, till
the date of interview has to be taken as valid and the benefit of
reservation has to be given to such candidates who present such
certificates, as long as they are otherwise eligible.
B. The candidates who have been given an opportunity to present
EWS certificates, bereft of the fact of their earlier classification or
categorization, have to satisfy the requirement of acceptable and
valid credentials as on the date of interview.
C. Mere participation in a process does not give the petitioners
any right to challenge or question the same, having once
participated in such process.
D. Once the petitioners had participated in the recruitment
process without any protest or demur, they cannot question the
same.
E. The petitioners were aware of these conditions when they
participated in the same in 2024 and have done so without
questioning
the
process
and
was
thereby
estopped
from
contouring to the contrary.
33. In view of the afore-stated findings and conclusions, the writpetition fails and is accordingly dismissed.
34. There shall, however, no order as to costs.
35. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
given to the parties on priority basis.
(Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review