Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.48 of 2023
Sri Yeahia Khan & others
.........Petitioner(s);
Versus
Sri Idrish Khan & another
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
.........Respondent(s)
Mr. P.K. Dhar, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. J. Islam, Advocate,
Mr. R. Debnath, Advocate.
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
CRP No.11 of 2024
Idrish Khan
.........Petitioner(s);
Versus
Yeahia Khan & others
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Dhar, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. J. Islam, Advocate,
Mr. R. Debnath, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
14/03/2024
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The order dated 05.08.2023 passed by the Principal Secretary,
Revenue Department, Government of Tripura in Case No.02/Appeal/REV/P.
Secy/2023 under Section 93 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 is under challenge by
both the private parties i.e. the appellant/petitioner herein in CRP No.11/2024
and the opposite parties/petitioners herein in CRP No.48/2023.
3.
The petitioner in CRP No.11/2024 Sri Idrish Khan initially
approached the District Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti for cancellation of
allotment of land in Khatian No.544 of Mouja Dhaliarkandi allotted in favour
of Abdul Azij Khan, S/o Sanjar Khan of Baburbazar, Kailashahar. The learned
District Magistrate & Collector heard the Case No. Rev/Revision/49/2022
under Section 95 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 read with Rule 12 of the Tripura
Land Allotment Rule, 1980 and rejected the prayer with an observation that the
land in question was allotted to one Abdul Azij Khan, S/o Sanjar Khan during
revision survey and settlement period in the year 1986. After 35 years, the
applicant claimed that the aforesaid land is required to be reverted as khas land.
The learned Court of District Collector, Unakoti did not find any valid
documents in support of the claim made by the applicant. Therefore, the
proceedings were rejected. The learned DM & Collector recorded that no
correction is required. Being aggrieved, the applicant Idrish Khan approached
the learned Secretary, Revenue in appeal under Section 93 of the TLR & LR
Act, 1960. The opposite parties also appeared. The learned Secretary directed
the DM & Collector, Unakoti to inquire into the physical possession and submit
a report on the status of 1.55 acres of land in Khatian No.544 of Mouja
Dhaliarkandi. The DM & Collector submitted his report vide letter dated
27.07.2023. The inquiry about the status of 1.55 acres of land was conducted
through the Deputy Collector, O/o the SDM, Kailashahar in presence of the
appellant, the respondents and local people. The status of physical possession
of the suit land as per the inquiry report was incorporated in a tabular chart in
the impugned order which is also being extracted hereunder:
Name
of
possessor
Idrish Khan
Yeahia Khan
RS plot
No.
1468/p
1471/p
1468/p
1471/p
1477/p
Area in possession
(in) acre
0.18
0.03
0.06
0.08
0.19
0.10
0.11
Total area under
possession (in) acre
0.27
0.48
Dewan Khan
Joynob Bibi
Disputed land
4.
1477/p
1471/p
0.20
0.15
0.14
0.20
0.11
Total area
0.20
0.15
0.45
1.55 acre.
The learned Secretary, Revenue found that the allottee or his legal
heirs had no possession over 0.62 acres of land in RS Plot No.1468/P, 1471/P,
1477/P, 1483 and 910 of Mouja Dhaliarkandi. The Appellate Authority–
Secretary, Revenue therefore came to the conclusion that the allottee or his
legal heirs violated the condition no.4 of the allotment order that the allotted
land has to be under cultivation within 5 years from the date of allotment i.e.
1984. He also held that as per Rule 12(vi) of the TLR & LR (Allotment of land)
Rules, 1980, the allotment of land of 0.18 acres in RS Plot No.1468, 0.03 acres
in RS Plot No.1471, 0.20 acres in RS Plot No.1477, 0.06 acres in RS Plot
No.1483 and 0.15 acres in RS Plot No.910; in total 0.62 acres of land recorded
in Khatian No.544 of Mouja Dhaliarkandi were cancelled as being in violation
of the condition no.4 of the Allotment Rules, 1980. The DM & Collector,
Unakoti was directed to arrange for incorporating the 0.62 acres of land in the
khas khatian of Mouja Dhaliarkandi deleting the said area from the allottee in
Khatian No.544 of the same mouja.
5.
On the part of the petitioners Yeahia Khan & others in CRP
No.48/2023, Mr. P.K. Dhar, learned senior counsel has asserted that the
impugned order was passed without any opportunity to file objection. The
report of the DM & Collector, Unakoti relied upon by the learned Secretary,
Revenue is incorrect. Petitioners are in physical possession of certain area in the
1.55 acres of allotted land in Mouja Dhaliarkandi. He submits that had an
opportunity been granted to the petitioners Yeahia Khan & others, they would
have been able to adduce evidence and demonstrate before the learned
Secretary, Revenue that the report of DM & Collector, Unakoti relied upon by
him is factually incorrect. Therefore, the impugned order be interfered and the
matter be remanded to the Secretary, Revenue to decide it afresh.
6.
On the part of the petitioner Idrish Khan in CRP No.11/2024, who
is also respondent in CRP No.48/2023, reliance is placed upon the report dated
30.05.2022 of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar which reveals that
RS Plot No.1471/P and 1483 measuring 0.20 acres of Khatian No.544 of
Dhaliarkandi Mouja is in peaceful possession of the petitioner Md. Idrish Khan,
S/o Dilbar Khan by construction of dwelling house and cultivating fruit bearing
trees and plantation of Agar trees on the said plot. The Sub-Divisional
Magistrate further opined that RS. Plot No.1471/P and 1483 area measuring
0.20 acres of Khatian No.544 of Dhaliarkandi Mouja may be reverted to khas
land if the authority approves. It is submitted that the DM & Collector, Unakoti
however rejected the prayer outrightly and did not allow any reversion of the
allotted land as khas land. Being aggrieved, the applicant Idrish Khan
approached the Secretary, Revenue, who on the basis of tabular chart, has
opined that 0.18 acres of land in RS Plot No.1468/P is in violation of allotment
rules and has cancelled the entry and directed it to be recorded as khas land in
khas khatian of Mouja Dhaliarkandi. As such, there is an apparent contradiction
in the report submitted by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar and the
report submitted by the DM & Collector, Unakoti on the basis of which, the
learned Secretary, Revenue has cancelled 0.62 acres of land in Khatian No.544
of that mouja. The petitioner is aggrieved as the entire land in that mouja ought
to have been reverted as khas as the opposite parties Sri Yeahia Khan & others,
successors of the original allottee, are in violation of the Allotment Rules, 1980.
7.
In CRP No.48/2023, the District Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti
was impleaded as an opposite party since the issue related to correction of land
records under the TLR & LR Act, 1960 where the concerned authorities of the
State are necessary parties. Any correction in the entry of khatian is to be made
after proper observance of the rules and procedure by the District Magistrate &
Collector of the concerned district.
8.
The Counter Affidavit of the official respondent in CRP
No.48/2023 inter alia states that the report furnished by the DM & Collector,
Unakoti reveals that the legal heirs of the original allottee Abdul Azij Khan are
not in possession of 1.55 acres of land entirely as per the inquiry report. 0.62
acres of land out of 1.55 acres are under possession of different individuals
which is in contravention of the Allotment Rules, 1980. The Appellate
Authority i.e. the Principal Secretary, Revenue, upon being satisfied with the
documents/inquiry report and after extending enough scope of hearing to both
the parties, passed the order on 05.08.2023 with a direction to cancel 0.62 acres
of land from Khatian No.544 and to record it in khas khatian as it was found
under occupation of different individuals in violation of the Allotment Rules of
1980.
9.
Mr. Karnajit De, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
State, submits that the order of the learned Secretary, Revenue is proper in the
eye of law. It is based upon an official inquiry report of the DM & Collector,
Unakoti. The field inquiry conducted through the office of Deputy Collector,
O/o the SDM, Kailashahar reveals that certain area i.e. 0.62 acres of the allotted
land of 1.55 acres in Khatian No.544 of Mouja Dhaliarkandi are not in
occupation of the legal heirs of the original allottee. Therefore, the learned
Secretary, Revenue rightly ordered cancellation of the entries in the name of the
original allottee and directed it to be converted as khas land so far as 0.62 acres
in Khatian No.544 of Mouja Dhaliarkandi is concerned. Therefore, the
impugned order does not suffer from any error. It is further submitted that in
case any of the parties dispute the inquiry report, the matter can only be
adjudicated in a properly constituted civil suit where parties can adduce oral
and documentary evidence for a declaration regarding their physical possession
on the allotted land in question. Therefore, this Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India may not enter into inquiry on facts in absence of any
admissible, cogent and contrary material adduced by the parties.
10.
On consideration of rival submission of the parties and upon going
through the pleadings on record, this Court finds that the impugned order is
based on an enquiry conducted by the Secretary, Revenue through the District
Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti on the status of physical possession of 1.55
acres of land in Khatian No.544 of Mouja Dhaliarkandi which was allotted in
the name of the original allottee Abdul Azij Khan, the predecessor of Sri
Yeahia Khan & others in the year 1984. The physical inquiry report revealed
that considerable portion of the land totaling 0.62 acres are in the hands of
strangers who are neither the legal heirs of the original allottee, nor have any
valid basis to continue with the possession. Based on this report, the impugned
order has been passed.
11.
The petitioners in CRP No.48/2023 Sri Yeahia Khan & others
dispute the inquiry report submitted by the DM & Collector, Unakoti on facts. I
am afraid this Court cannot enter into inquiry on fact in exercise of power under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India. Under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India, this Court is required to keep the inferior authorities within bounds of
their jurisdiction and to interfere only if the orders are patently without
jurisdiction or in excess of jurisdiction or while exercising such powers, the
inferior authority has taken into consideration extraneous materials rendering
the finding perverse in the eye of law. There are no contrary documents to show
that the physical inquiry report of the DM & Collector, Unakoti was incorrect
on facts. Even if the petitioners Yeahia Khan & others or any other private party
contest the physical inquiry report submitted by the DM & Collector, Unakoti,
this issue of disputed question of fact can only be raised and adjudicated in a
properly constituted suit where parties are free to adduce oral and documentary
evidence in support of their case. Therefore, this Court does not find any ground
to interfere in the impugned order.
12.
These revision petitions are accordingly dismissed. Pending
application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pijush/
signed by MUNNA SAHA
MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2024.03.18 11:57:15 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review