Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!"
%
%
& $
'
!
"
!
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
#
!
!
!
$!
%
!
&
'
!
"
!
!
$
#
-2-
!
)
$
$
(
$
!
#
$
$
$
!
!
!
"
!
"
!
#
!
*
"
$$
!
$
!
)
#
)
) " #"+#
#$
$
#
!
&
$
!
"
$
!
!
# "
!
$
!
,
#
!
$
!
!
!
"
!
#
"
,
!
%#
$
-
-
.
%
%
/01 23404056 01 70839 :693;
561404:4056 57
( =69
) 57 4/3
690= 45 >:=1/ 4/3 </=;?3 1/334 =?=0614 4/3
234040563; =<<:139 06
;40<831
;3?0143;39 +A
5;;
=;0106? 5:4 57
5B=A:B4= !580<3
;0@3
=8=+:;=?0 75; 4/3
57736<3 2:601/=+83 :693; 13<4056 )" #"+# 57 !;3C364056 57
5;;:24056
<4
&
" @369@364
<4 E# 236906? 56 4/3 7083 57 !;8
=8=+:;=?0
# "75; 1/5;4 D4/3 !
014;0<4 =69
3110561
5:;4
-3-
/3
=+;09?39
7=<41
<5@28=06=64 ;312569364
9:<=4056=8
61404:4056
/3 1=09
5<034A 75;
:;=8 =69
;+=6
01 4/3
4/3
<=13
=;3
4/3
3<;34=;A 57
5/=6
=F=
61404:4056 01 ;:6606? :693;
3C3852@364
<4056
=8=+:;=?0
/06?1 14559 4/:1 06 5;93; 45 ?;=64 4/3 1402369 45 4/3 14:93641
7;5@
4/3
234040563; =<<:139
5<0=8
33;31/
387=;3
32=;4@364
4/3
=90?3; :139 45 C3;07A =69 28=<3
4/3 ;3<5;91 +375;3 4/3 /0?/3; =:4/5;04031 75; 901+:;13@364 57
1402369 45 4/3
=6B =<<5:641 57 4/3 14:93641
1402369 75; 4/3 A3=;
234040563; 93@=6939
<<5;906?8A 4/3
& G=1 1=6<405639 =4 4/=4 40@3 4/3
0883?=8 ?;=4070<=4056 7;5@ 4G5
14:93641 75; 901+:;13@364 57 4/30; 1402369
'
=4 =+5:4
-
2@
;312569364
C010439 4/3 5770<3 57 4/3 234040563; +A 1G04</06? 56 4/3
C50<3 ;3<5;93; 06 /01 @5+083 2/563 =69 @34 4/3 234040563;
4/=4 40@3 4/3 234040563; 93@=6939
7;5@ ;312569364
5G3C3; /3 G04/ =6 =11:;=6<3 57 2=A@364 57 4/3 1=@3
8374 4/3 5770<3 =69 859?39 4/3 <5@28=064 +375;3 ;312569364
1=@3
!580<3 =856? G04/ 4/3 C50<3 ;3<5;93; 56
G=1
;3?0143;39
;0@3
/3
=?=0614
4/3
-4-
234040563; 75; 4/3 57736<3 2:601/=+83 :693;
!
<4
/3;3=743; 56
3<4056 )" #"+# 57
;312569364
!580<3
<569:<439 364;:14@364 2=6</=6=@= =69 4/3;3=743; <569:<439
4/3 4;=2 2;5<33906?1 56 4/3 1=@3 9=A 1:<<3117:88A =69
;3<5C3;39 4=06439 @563A 57
=4 4/3 0614=6<3 57
234040563; =69 <=:?/4 /589 /0@ !:;1:=648A
5B=A:B4= 5770<0=81
G=1/39 4/3 /=691 57 =<<:139 G/0</ 4:;639 0645 206B <585;
G/0</ 36C01=?39 4/=4 =<<:139 /=9 =<<32439 4/3 +;0+3 =@5:64
=1 23; /01 93@=69
/3;3=743; ;312569364
!580<3 9;=G6
2=6</=6=@= =69 =;;31439 4/3 234040563; =69 2;59:<39 /0@
+375;3 4/3 83=;639
F:90<0=8 <:1459A
!580<3
8=09
23<0=8 %:9?3 =69 4/3;3+A 1364 /0@ 45
743; <5@283406? 06C3140?=4056
</=;?3
=75;3@36405639 57736<3
01 +375;3 4/01
1/334
=?=0614
;312569364
/0@
75;
4/3
??;03C39 +A 4/3 1=@3 4/3 234040563;
5:;4 45 >:=1/ 4/3 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 /0@
3=;9 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563; =69 83=;639
23<0=8 <5:6138 75; ;312569364
2=;4 7;5@ :;?06? 13C3;=8 <5643640561
83=;639
<5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563; <56436939 4/=4 56 23;:1=8 57 4/3
</=;?3 1/334 @=43;0=81 65 57736<3 /=1 +336 @=93 5:4 =?=0614
-5-
4/3 234040563; :693;
3<4056 )"=# 57 4/3 !
2;513<:4056 7=0839 45 28=<3
06?;3903641 57 4/3 57736<3 0 3
<4
106<3 4/3
@=43;0=81 45 2;5C3 4/3
"=# 93@=69 "+# =<<324=6<3 =69
"<# G5;B 364;:14@364 5; G5;B 236906?
<<5;906? 45 /0@ =4 65
25064
93@=6939
40@3
4/3
?;=4070<=4056
=69
;312569364
4/3
234040563;
/=1
<56C3;1=4056
=883?398A
4/3
0883?=8
;3<5;939
+A
95 654 901<8513 1:</ <56C3;1=4056 =1 14=439 06
4/3 4;=2 @=/=H=; +A 4/3 6C3140?=4056
770<3; =69 4/3 2=6</
G04631131
(
3 7:;4/3; <56436939 4/=4 4/3 4=06439 @563A G=1
=883?398A ;3<5C3;39 7;5@ 4/3 4=+83 57 4/3 234040563;
/=691 57 234040563; G3;3 G=1/39 G04/
/5:?/ 4/3
590:@ +0<=;+56=43
158:4056 4/3 1=@3 909 654 4:;6 0645 206B <585; $:;4/3; 4/3;3
G=1 65 G5;B 57 ;312569364
364;:1439 45 4/3 234040563;
9:;06? 4;=2 =69 4/3 ;3<5;91 G3;3 130H39 7;5@ = 90773;364 5770<3
6 1:</ <0;<:@14=6<3 4/3 2;513<:4056 :443;8A 7=0839 45 28=<3
@=43;0=81 45 2;5C3 4/3 93@=69
=<<324=6<3 =69
G5;B 236936<A +A 4/3 234040563;
)
3 7:;4/3; <56436939 4/=4
6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1
06 4/3
32=;4@364=8
4/3 36>:0;A ;325;4 1:+@04439 +A 4/3
-6-
32=;4@364=8
6>:0;A
3I563;=439 4/3 234040563; 7;5@ 4/3
</=;?31 83C3839 =?=0614 /0@
56 4/3 F:9?@364 57 4/3
6 1:</ <0;<:@14=6<3 +A ;38A06?
56J+83
23I
5:;4 06 4/3 <=13 57
;325;439 06 !"!" #$%
&'&
/3 1:+@041 4/=4 4/3 14=69=;9 57 2;557 06 <;0@06=8
2;5<33906?1 01 @:</ /0?/3; 4/=6 932=;4@364=8 2;5<33906?1 =69
4/3 932=;4@364=8 2;5<33906?1 041387 3I563;=439 <56406:=4056 57
<;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3 234040563; 01 654/06? +:4 =+:13
57 2;5<311 57
5:;4
<<5;906?8A /3 2;=A1 45 =885G 4/3 23404056
83=;639
4/01
23<0=8 <5:6138 75; ;312569364
5B=A:B4= <56436939 4/=4 04 01 1344839 25104056 57 8=G +A
5:;4 =69 4/3
23I
5:;4 06 <=436= 57 F:9?@3641
4/=4 3I563;=4056 57 93806>:364
5C3;6@364 3@285A33 06 4/3
32=;4@364=8
56J+83
6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 <=6654 +A 041387 7:;601/ =
?;5:69 45 >:=1/ 4/3 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1
3C36 07 +54/ 4/3
2;5<33906?1 =;3 75:6939 56 4/3 1=@3 134 57 7=<41
<<5;906? 45
/0@ 06 4/3 0614=64 <=13 =88 4/3 G04631131 /=C3 1:225;439 06 4/3
32=;4@364=8
=1 /389 +A 4/3
6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 =69 06 1:</ <0;<:@14=6<3
56J+83
23I
5:;4 06 4/3 <=13 57
(
)
-7-
*
#
+
%- # % ...&"/...&.0!"!1"
G04631131 4:;639 /514083 +375;3 4/3
=
<=13
()
,
G/3;3
4/3
32=;4@364=8
6>:0;A
2;5<33906?1 4/5:?/ 4/3 =<<:139 01 3I563;=439 4/3 <;0@06=8
</=;?31
<=6654
32=;4@364=8
+3
>:=1/39
/3
3I563;=4056
6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 9531 654
4/3
7:;601/ =
?;5:69 75; 9;52206? <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1 @5;3 2=;40<:8=;8A 06
4;=2 <=131
5G3C3; 06 4/3 0614=64 <=13 =88 4/3 G04631131 /=C3
1:225;439 06 4/3
3C3;A
32=;4@364=8
25110+0804A
2;5<33906?1
4/3@
6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 =69 4/3;3
1:225;406?
6 1:</ <0;<:@14=6<3
4/3
<;0@06=8
/3 2;=A1 45 901@011 4/3
23404056
&
/=C3 ?0C36 @A =6I05:1 <561093;=4056 +54/ 56 4/3
1:+@0110561 @=93 +A 4/3 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 ;3123<40C3
2=;4031 =69 4/3 95<:@3641 @=93 =C=08=+83 +375;3 4/01
5:;4
6 23;:1=8 57 4/3 <5@28=064 =69 </=;?3 1/334
@=43;0=81 04 01 654 06 9012:43 4/=4 4/3 234040563; 3I563;=439 06
4/3
32=;4@364=8
6>:0;A
G04631131 /=C3 1:225;439
2;5<33906?1
9312043
=88
4/3
4 01 =815 654 06 9012:43
4/3
-8-
G04631131 06 4/3
32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 =;3 =815 4/3
G04631131 06 4/3 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1
4 01 1344839 25104056 57 8=G +A 4/3
5:;4 06 4/3 <=13 57 2
56J+83
23I
3* )
;325;439 06 !".. #'%
56. 4/=4 4/3
=9F:90<=4056 2;5<33906?1 =69 4/3 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1 =;3
06932369364 06 6=4:;3 45 3=</ 54/3; =69 4/3 706906? =?=0614 4/3
23;156 7=<06? 2;513<:4056 06 4/3 =9F:90<=4056 2;5<33906?1 01 654
+06906? 56 4/3 2;5<33906?1 75; <;0@06=8 2;513<:4056
0614=64 <=13
6 4/3
106<3 =88 4/3 G04631131 /=C3 1:225;439 06 4/3
32=;4@364=8
6>:0;A
2;5<33906?1
>:=1/06?
<;0@06=8
2;5<33906?1 9531 654 =;013 4/5:?/ 4/3 234040563; 3I563;=439 06
4/3
32=;4@364=8 2;5<33906?1
/3
56J+83
23I
5:;4 06 4/3 <=13 57
(
,
#
%-
.""860!"!'
.!88&0!"!' /389 4/=4 06 = <=13 ;3?0143;39 :693; 4/3
123<0=8 14=4:43 0 3
!
<4 >:=1/06? 57 4/3 57736<31 :693; 4/3
1=09 =<4 G5:89 /=C3 = ?;=C3 =69 1:+14=640=8 0@2=<4 654 F:14 56
4/3 2=;4031 06C58C39 +:4 =815 56 4/3 15<034A =4 8=;?3
-9-
'
$:;4/3; 4/3
56.+83
#!""5% .'
51"
23I
5:;4 06 <=13 57
) * 3
;325;439 06
/389 06 2=;=?;=2/
=69 & =1
75885G1-
!
"
#
$
#
!
&'
& '
& '
!#
"
%
$
#
$
%
$
$
%
(
$
! #
!
!
"
#
#
$
#
#
!
$
! )
!
#
*
#
$
#
!
!
%
,
,
!#
+,
#
+ &
!
!#
' -
!
- 10 -
#
!
%
$
"
!
%
$
"
$
$
$
%
%
*
#
%
$
%
$
#
"
$
%
$
#
%
$ %
,
"
!
.
$
,
!
-
%
!
#
$
,
-
!
$
$
,
/
!
#
*
!
$ #
!
$
#
#
!
,
$
$
$
!
$
!
!
!
!# !
)
- 11 -
#
$
$
# #
!
!
$
#
$
!
!
%
,
!
&
2 3
5066 7
&4 ' #
0' "
!
#
89:
<
$
!
; ! $
*"; &06= '
!
!
$ $
#
$
#
$
!
$
,
"
$
$
$
-
!
!
$
"
#
!
!
#
!
!
,
$
!
>
<
&066='
>
&0666'
$
,
$
&
#
!
2 4
/
# ;
506697
= =
#
*";
896 ;
< % % #
! ?
5066:7 =
>
# 1
>
*";
@
# 1
- 12 -
5066=7 A
A9: ;
# B
>
<
5066A7
86A
#
>
#
&? #
(
*"; &066='
6 8
; %
< % % #
(
506667 8
:6'
>
#
"
$
!
!
$
!
/
$
-
!
%
$
#
!
!
$
!
$
!
!
C
#
$
#
,
#
#
!
&
5066 7 8
"
' # 3
80A
D
$
#
$
,
$
$
$
#
$
$
#
+&
#
$
$
!
'
- 13 -
$
$ #
/
$
E$
$
!
!
#
$
$
F
6 4/3 0614=64 <=13 =1 901<:1139 1:2;= 4/3 2;0@=;A
06?;3903641 57 4/3 57736<3 2:601/=+83 :693;
!
3<4056 )" #"+# 57
<4 01 @=93 5:4 +A 4/3 2;513<:4056 =69 4/3 1=@3 /=1 45 +3
431439 06 = 934=0839 4;0=8
/01
5:;4 <=6654 <569:<4 = @060 4;0=8
=4 4/01 14=?3 45 /589 4/=4 G/34/3; 4/3 =<<:1=4056 @=93 =?=0614
4/3 234040563; G088 2;5C3 5; 654
1/334 @=43;0=81
6 =6 3640;3 23;:1=8 57 </=;?3
=@ 57 4/3 C03G 4/=4 <56406:=4056 57 <;0@06=8
2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3 234040563; G088 654 =@5:64 45 =+:13 57
2;5<311 57
/3
5:;4
<<5;906?8A
;04 !3404056 01
2;5<339 45 2=11 4/3 75885G06?-
*+
&
%
'
%
5-
5-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review