Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION N O: 4333 OF 2025
Petition Under Article 227 of Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the
order dated 16-10-2025 passed in l.A.No. 182 ol 2024 in O.S.No. 1S0 of 20iS on
the file of the Court of the Principal Senior Civil Judge, at Mancherial.
Between:
Sri Vala Srinivas Rao, S/o. V.Mohan Rao, Age.46 years, Occ. Business, R/o
Gouthami Nagar, Mancherial post and Mandal, Mancherial District.
Vangapalli_Purnachander Rgo, S/o Janardhan Rao, Aged. 46 years, Occ.
Business, R/o Hamali Vada, Mancherial post and Mandal: Manche;ial District.
...PETITIONER/ Respondent Nos. 5 & 6
AND
1. Nuzhat Zamani, (Died) per LRs, R/o. H.No 21-1-98, Chennur Road,
Mancherial Town and Mandal, Mancherial District.
2. Mohd. Sadatur Rahman, S/o Late lr/ohd. Dasthagir, Age. 51 years, Occ.
Private Employee, R/o. H.No.21-1-98. Chennur Road,-Manctierial Town and
Mandal, Mancherial District.
3 ltghd Ateequr Rahman, S/o.Late Mohd. Dasthagir, Age. 49 years, Occ.
Private Emplovee,R/o. 11.No.21-1-98. Chennur Rbad, Manchbrial iown and
Mandal, Mancherial District.
4. l,/ohd. Zameerur Rahman, S/o.Late Mohd. Dasthagt, Age. 47 years, Occ_
Private Employee, R/o. H.No.21-'1-98. Chennur Road, t\ifancheiial Town and
Mandal, Mancherial District.
5 Nikhat SadiqLra,-Wo Mohd. Lateefur Rahman, Age. 42 years, Occ. House
wife, R/o. H.No.21-'l-98. Chennur Road, Mancheiial Town and Mandal,
lt/ancherial District.
6. The District Collector, [Vlancherial District, Mancherial.
7. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Mancherial, Mancherial District.
B. The Tahsilciar, Mancherial Mandal and District. .. Respondents/
Respondent Nos. 1 to 3
9. Saiciula Narsaiah, S/o.Devanna, R/o. H.No.2-BBIC, Rayapur K Village,
Lohesra Mandal, Mancherial District - 504 208.
--,
10. Madasu Venuoooal. S/o Bapu,
4-g" lZ years, Occ. Sirr, areni Employee,
Rio.Qr.No.T2-82', M'arket erea, rrrrlnoa-rliii'ibli"ro
[4 ,ndat, Mancheriat
District.
11. lVlarapalli Ashok Reddy, S/o.M.Narsimha Reddy,
Aqe , years Occ.
Business, R/o. CC C N6spur, tttrnihlr[inrintai, i,riin", )ra t
l
Disrrict
...RESPONDENTS/ Resl ondents No.4,7 & g
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section '15'r cpc praying that in the c r
umstances stated in
the affidavit fired in support of the petition, ine Higr, court m,
o"-pL"."o to grrnt
stay of all further proceedings in o.S. No. 150 oi20i5, on ti : fire
or tne eriricipat
senior civil Judge, at Mancheriar, pending disposar of the rbove
cruii nevilion
Petition and pass such other order or ord6rs as this Honorr
rbre court deems fit
and proper in the interest of justice, as otherwise, the pet r ,nur.
*iii uu prt to
irreparable loss and injury.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI. M. R. S. SRINIVAS
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2 to S : SRI C. KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 6 to 11: _
The Court made the foilowing ORDER:
-J
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON,BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI{A
- CIVIL REVISION PETITIoN No. 4333 OF 2025
o,9.oL.2026
Between:
Vala Srinivasa Rao & another
. Petitioners
And
Nuzhat Zamani (died) Per LRs
and others
..... Respondents
ORDER:
Aggrieved by the order dated 16. lO.2O25 in 1 A' No'
182 of 2024 in O.S. No. 15O of 2015 on the file of the Principal
Senior Civil Judge, Mancherial, appointing an Advocate
Commissioner, this Civil Rcvrsion Petition is filed by the
unsuccessful Defendants 4 and 5 in Lhe suit'
2.
For the sake of convenience, parties are referred to
as arrayed in the suit.
3.
The case of plaintiffs is that they are the absolute
owners and possessors of dry land in Survey No' 42 to an extent
of Ac. 2.35 guntas, situated at Naspur Village, Mancherial Town
\
_'ri
and Mandal, Adilabad District. When Revenu': arulhorities
(De fendants
1 to 3) tried to dispossess plaintrf s lrom the
schedule lancls without following due process of Lr .', they hled
Writ Petition No. 1 11 12 of 2Ol3 which was dispost r of by order
dated 23.O3.2O13 directing not to disposscss l) rintiff No l
except in accordance with iaw after putting her cr notice and
giving an opportunity of being heard. Desp I :, Revenue
authorities issued Form-D 1 and proceedings date'i 13 05 '2013
assigning plaintiff s land in favour of the 4t 1 clefendant,
therefore, plaintiffs filed Contempt Case No. 161fi ol 2013' In
this Contemltt Case, Revenue off-rcials filed a r additional
counter along vvith a Plan showing plaintiffs' lar I in BLUE
colour and the land allotted to Defendant No 4 in BROWN
colour and contended that both are different Iar ls' On the
strength of the counter, this Court closed the Contt: rpt Case by
order dated 1O.04.20 15.
3.
1.
Lzrter, plaintiffs filed another Conten- l t Case No'
102 1 of 2015 stating that Revenue authorities plar :d fraud by
manipulating the Plan, showing the schedule rl property
elsewhere in Illue Colour, while the fact remains tt rt schedule
of property zts shown in Brown colour on ly tc avoid the
consequences of contempt' This Court while closing
the case by
order dated 3 I .07.20 15 has 'observed that 'the question
whether the land shown in brown colour belongs to
petitioner or
tothe4tl,respondentisextraneoustotheclrderpassedinthe
writPetition.ThisCourtwhileexaminingwhetherornotthe
petitigner was dispossessed in violation of the order
passed in
Writ Petition, cannot, in summary procecdings under the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, adjuclicate whether
the land
shown in the map in brown colour belongs to petitioner
or to the
fourth respondent. These are all matters for adjudication
in a
civil suit Iiled before the Competent Civil Court' " ''
3.2.
In tune r'r'ith the observations in the Contempt
Case, plaintiffs filed O'S' No l5O of 2015 before
the Senior Civil
Judge at Mancherial, under Sectio n 26' Order-VII RuleC.P.C., for declaration of title in respect of schedule of
.,
1 of
property
and that schedule of property is located in Brown Colour in
the
Plan and for consequential injunction' ln the said suit'
plaintiffs hled the subject Application under Order XXVI Rule 9
read with Sec. 151 CPC to appoint Advocate Commissioner
to
trace out the fact that suit schedule boundaries or boundary
named persons or their legal heirs identity available in brown
\\
-
and blue colour of the location map, for adjuc i ation of the
case. Learne'd Assistant Government Pleader for )cfendants 1
to 3 (Reventre authorities) has not objected for a 1 pointment of
Advocate Commissioner. However, the unoffrcial )efendants 5
and 6 filed counter afhdavit contesting the IA rlleging that
plaintiffs can prove their case by adducing coz nt oral and
documentaq' evidence but not by resorting to ap lointment of
Advocate Commissioner and by way of ap1 rintmcrit of
Commissiont:r the party is not expected to gather :l c evidencc,
3.3.
'lhe court below allowed the I.A. by tL r order under
Revision holdlng that to declare the title of thc r r-rit schedule
property, thr:re should not be ambiguity with lt lard to suit
schedule pr()perty. Therefore, it is necessary tt .lppoint an
Advocate Commissioner to give clarity to adjudi,: tc the case.
Challenging r,he said order, this Revision is filed.
4.
I{eard learned counsel for petitione- Sri M.R.S.
Srinivas. He argues that trial Court failed to urr lcrstand thc
scope and significance of Section 73 and Order X) VI Rule 9 of
CPC. In a dispute regarding boundaries and id: rtihcation of
neighbouring owners must be established lr
oral and
documentary evidence but not by way of local inve; igation, that
'- :t
-
toobeforecross-examinationofPW3.ThesubjectApplication
was taken out only [o cover up the lacunas as plaintiffs failed to
adduce proper evidence in their favour'
4.7.
In support of his contentions, lcarned counsel relied
on the judgments it Yenugonda Bal Redd'g u' Manemmal '
Batdhu Naragdna RoLo a. Batchu Venkata Narasirnha Raoz
and So:rala Jain v. Sangu Gangadhars '
5.
Heard Sri C. Kumar, iearned counsel for plaintiffs -
Respondents 1 to 5. To justify his contenlions, he relied on the
judgments in Haryana Waqf Board u' Shcnti Sarupa '
P. Sreedeui a. II\LN Venkata Lo'kshmi Narrrsimha Praso.ds '
Shaik Zareend Kaso:m a. Patan Sado,b Khan6, Smt' A'
Loxmd.mmd a. S771t. A. VenkatannmaT, M. Yadaiah u. M.
Hilkammas; AdoLrsh Constnrctions, Hgderabad t)'
' lzotll 2 ALD 472
' (20 to) s RLo 8s
r
1zo to; s ALD r97
' (2008)8 scc 67 I
' 202016l ALD 99 (TSl (DB)
" 201il4) ALD 231
' zotogtl ALT 795 (sB)
^ zozzlzl ALD 299 (TSl
-
Qolrnaantnnisa Begume, Singidi Ram Reatt'y u' Kota
Sudhakar GuPtalo.
lior better understanding, Order XXV Rule-9 CPC
is extracted below:
Commissions to m(,,ke local inaestigations
In any sult in which the Court deems a local rt .estigation to
be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating a ry matter in
dispute, or ,t[ ascertaining the market-value of any 1lt< )ert\', or the
amount of anY mesne profrts or damages or annual rt profits, the
Court may issttc a commission to such person as it thinl{ , fit directing
him to make such investigation and to report thereon to tlr Court
I)rovided that, where the State Government I i ; madc rules
as to the persons to rvhom such commission shall be issL'd the Colrrt
shall be bourrd [rY such rules."
In the factual scenario, it is necessary o look at the
judgments r<:lied on by the respective counsel.
ln Yenugonda Bal Reddg's case (sr-rJ, r), it is held
that appointment of advocate commissioner for r< -ing physical
features ancl for local investigation amounts t( ' collection of
er.idcnce by the petitioner and is not permissiblc
nder lari.,. In
the case on hand, plaintiffs allege manipulation : map by the
Rev6nue authorities. Therefore, there is no error
" zozzl+1AlD I 12 (TS)
tozo231+1ALD 346 (TS)
-r appointing
-7
-
an advocate commissioner to resolve the dispute as to whether
there is manipulation of map or not.
In Batchu Naragana Rao's case and Sarald
Jain's case, it is observed that appointment of advocate
7.1.
commissi.oner to identify the suit schedule property and to fix
boundaries is found fault. As stated above advocate
commissioner is appointed in the case on hand only to resolve
the dispute of manipulation of map. Thus, the judgments relied
on by Defendants (Petitioners herein) are of no help to them'
7.2.
ln Haryana Waqf Boards case, thc Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that in a case of demarcation of disputed
land, it is appropriate for the Court to direct investigation by
appointing a local Commissioner under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC-
7.3.
ln P. Sreedeui's case, a learned Division Bench of
this Court held that when there is a dispute of localizaLion or
demarcation of property, the best course of action is lo appoint
an Advocate Commissioner/ Surveyor for localization'
In Shaik Zareena Kasann's case (supra), this
Court held that whenever there is a dispute regarding
7.4.
boundaries or physical features of the property or any allegation
-
ofencroachrrlen[aSnarratedbyonepartyandclislutedbythe
the
other, the fircts have to be physically verifred' lecause
recitals of ttLc documents may not reveal the t- e lacts
and
measuring of Iand on the spot by a Surv': or/Advocate
Commissiontrr may become necessary'
7.5.
ln Smt. A. Laxm,,',rrnta's case (supr: , this Court
justified the reppointment o[ an Advocate Conr nissioner to
resolve the tssue relating to correctness or oth(
-wise of the
sketch map said to have been ltled by one party'
7.6.
ln M' Yatdariah's case (supra), this C: lrt held that
Section 75 CPC deals with appointment rf Advocate
be
Commissiont:r and envisages that a Commiss r' ner can
appointed to zrid the Court, as such, a Commis:; >ner may bc
appointed to cxamine any person, to make local inr :stigation'
to
examine or adjust accounts, to make a partil-i') r ' to holcl a
scientific or lechnical or expert investigation, to c-: rduct sale of
property, in the circumstances mentioned therein 'r to perform
a ministerial act.
7.7.
ln Adarsh Constructionsls case (supr '), this Court
held that thcre is no absolute bar for appointme;r of Advocate
Commission,:r in a suit for injunction simplicitor' :ither in the
course of trial or during enquiry in
a temporary injunctton
petrtlon.
7.a.
In Singidi Ram Reddgis case (supra)' this Court
held that 'the argument advanced by
the counsel for the revision
petitioners is liable to be rejected' in
view of the facts of the
present case, wherein the relief that
is being claimed by the
a specific plea that the
plaintiff is for permanent injunction with
subject land is an agricultural land'
whereas the defence in the
written statement is to the effect that the
deed from the original
the boundaries in the subsequent sale
sale deed in the above factual scenario'
for deciding the lis in
the suit, the appointment of an Advocate
certainly be helpful as the dispute
plaintiff has changed
Commissioner would
regarding the boundaries of
the suit schedule property will be appreciated
with the help of
the report that may bc filed by the Advocate-Commissioner''
8.
From the above judgments' the principles
to be
culminatedare,i)thereisnobarinappointinganAdvocate
Commissioner in a civil suit; ii) when
the boundaries and the
exact location of the suit schedule land
appointment of Advocate Commissioner
is in dispute'
will be more helpful for
the court to decide the lis; iii) in case of
demarcation of land'
l0
appointment ol Advocate Commissioner is much t t lpful; and iv)
to resolve thc issue relating to correctness or o[l] rwise of the
sketch map said to have been hled by one party, a1 lointment of
Advocate Cornmissioner is justifiab[e.
9.
Il is also to be seen, Order XXVI lule 9 CPC
empowers Courts to appoint commissiolr; for local
investigations when necessary to elucidate matter in dispute,
ascertain property values, or determine mestt profits or
damages. This provision ensures that Courts can I rtain precise
and direct information from the loctts in qu: facilitating
informed and just dccisions. However, appoi .l ment o[ a
Commissioncr under tl-ris Rule is discretionary anc depends on
the specifics of each catse. Courts consider the Ir cessity ol a
local investigation to resolve the dispute effe: ivel1'. For
instance, in boundarv disputes or cases invr I 'ing alleged
encroachments, a Commissioner's report can prorri : : crucial on
site insights lhat are otherwise unattainable.
10.
In the case on hand, plaintiffs dispr te the map
(land shown in blue colour/ brown colour) proc r ced by the
Revenue authorities. Therefore, to make local i .vestigation,
identify the suit schedule land and its boundarir: , the Court
II
below appointed an Advocate Commissioner. This Court hnds
no flaw in such an action in the factual scenario of the extant
case, hence is of the opinion that this Revision does not merit
consideraIion
The Civil Revision Petition is therefore, dismissed.
No costs
t2
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed
sd N.CHA NDRA SEKHAR
DEPU TY REGISTRAR
/ITRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Principal Senior
Civil Judge' at Mancherial'
2. The District Collector'
Mancherial District' Mancherial'
District
Officer' Mancherial' Mancherial
Divisional
Revenue
3. The
and District'
4. The Tahsrldar' Mancherial Mandal
Advocate IOPUCI
5. One CC to SRI M R S SRINIVAS'
6. Two CD CoPies
kul
M/
HIGH COURT
DATED:09/01t2026
F
t i1
4t6
Ii ri8
)
l-
I
2{126
C)
-)..
t
ORDER
CRP.No.4333 of 2025
DISMTSSING THE CIVIL RE\/ISION
$
\"n
Lt
PETITION
\r
: ;PATC ,-rd)1
ti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review