Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010598312022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3521]
WEDNESDAY, THE ELEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE Y. LAKSHMANA RAO
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NOs: 1022 and 1042 of 2022
Between:
...PETITIONER
Moram Srinivasa Rao
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
The State of Andhra Pradesh
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. V.Sai Kumar
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. S.Syam Sunder Rao SC cum Spl P.P. For ACB
2. Public Prosecutor (AP)
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 1042/2022
Between:
...PETITIONER
Sri Vadapalli Adinarayana Murthy
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. K B Ramanna Dora
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. S.Syam Sunder Rao SC cum Spl P.P. For ACB
...RESPONDENT(S)
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
2. Public Prosecutor
The Court made the following:
COMMON ORDER:
These two Criminal Revision Cases are heard and disposed of by this
common order, as they arise out of one calendar case, albeit filed by two
accused, namely Accused Officer Nos. 6 and 7.
2.
Criminal Revision Case No.1022 of 2022 is filed by Accused Officer
No.7 and Criminal Revision Case No.1042 of 2022 is filed by Accused Officer
No.6, challenging the order passed in Crl.M.P.No.1027 of 2013 (filed by
Accused Officer No.7) and Crl.M.P.No.133 of 2014 (filed by Accused Officer
No.6) in C.C.No.15 of 2023 by the learned Special Judge for SPE and ACB
Cases-cum-III Additional District Judge, Vijayawada (for brevity, “the Trial
Court”), whereby petitions filed under Section 239 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (for brevity, “the Cr.P.C.”) seeking their discharge in Crime
No.9A/2001/ACB/VJA/2001 were dismissed. The aforementioned crime was
registered for the alleged offences punishable under Sections 13(2) read with
13(1)(c) and 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for brevity,
“the PC Act”) and Sections 418, 420, and 477A of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (for brevity, “the IPC”).
3.
The respondent/complainant laid a charge sheet against the petitioners
and other accused alleging that they colluded with Accused Officer No.4, the
then MRO, Ponnuru, in issuing land enjoyment certificates certifying that each
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
beneficiary had Ac.0.75 cents of land under their enjoyment, thereby cheating
and causing wrongful loss to the Government exchequer. It is submitted that
the petitioner/Accused Officer No.6 was not competent to issue land
enjoyment certificates, as only the MRO was empowered to do so. The District
Collector, Guntur, appointed the MRO, Ponnuru, as the enquiry officer to
conduct an enquiry into the alleged irregularities said to have been committed
by the petitioner/AO6 in the year 2000. Pursuant thereto, the MRO, Ponnuru
conducted the enquiry and submitted a report recommending action against
the petitioner. However, the District Collector removed the Petitioner/Accused
Officer No.6 from service, even though he had no role in issuing the
enjoyment certificates.
4.
Sri V. Sai Kumar, learned counsel for the Petitioner/AO7 submits that
the petitioner has been wrongly arrayed as Accused Officer No.7, even though
the entire criminal proceedings originated from a vigilance enquiry based on a
newspaper report and a subsequent report of the District Collector, in which
the petitioner was not even named. It is contended that the FIR registered in
Crime No. 9/ACB-VJA/2001 was initially closed in 2005 due to non-filing of
charge sheet within time, yet a charge sheet was filed belatedly in 2013, long
after the alleged incident, when several accused officers had either retired or
passed away.
5.
The petitioner, who was working only as a Village Development Officer,
had no authority to issue land enjoyment certificates and merely acted in
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
accordance with the instructions of his superior officers. There is no allegation
of receipt of any bribe, pecuniary advantage, or misappropriation of funds by
the petitioner, and even the charge sheet attributes no substantive role to him
except a vague procedural lapse.
6.
It is further submitted that the learned trial court failed to appreciate that
the essential ingredients of the offences under „the PC Act.,‟ and „the I.P.C.,
are not made out against the petitioner. The validity and existence of sanction
for prosecution under G.O.Ms. No. 88 dated 29.03.2012 were neither
furnished to the petitioner nor examined by the court below while deciding the
discharge petition under Section 239 of „the Cr.P.C‟. The impugned order
dismissing the discharge petition was passed mechanically, without
considering the vigilance report, the absence of specific allegations, or the
petitioner‟s limited role as a subordinate officer. The continuation of criminal
proceedings against the petitioner, therefore, amounts to an abuse of process
of law and causes grave injustice, warranting interference by this Court in
revision.
7.
Sri K.B. Ramanna Dora, the learned counsel for the Petitioner/AO6
submits that though nearly thirteen officials were allegedly involved in the
matter, the petitioner/AO-6 alone was removed from service, causing grave
injustice. The petitioner has already been subjected to departmental
punishment for the very same allegations, despite there being no finding of
irregularity, misappropriation of Government funds, or disobedience of
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
superior officers on his part. In the absence of any material to show that the
petitioner derived any pecuniary benefit or played any substantive role in the
alleged offences, the continuation of criminal proceedings amounts to an
abuse of process of law. Accordingly, the petitioner/AO6 prays for his
discharge from the case.
8.
Sri K.B. Ramanna Dora, learned counsel for the Petitioner/AO6 submits
that the petitioner, who was working as a Village Administrative Officer at the
relevant point of time, has been unnecessarily implicated as Accused No. 6,
despite there being no specific role attributed to him in the alleged offences. It
is contended that the only allegation against the petitioner in the charge sheet
is that he allegedly colluded with Accused Officer No. 4 in issuing land
enjoyment certificates. However, the petitioner was not competent to issue
such certificates and had no authority except to act as a subordinate. There is
no allegation whatsoever that the petitioner received any bribe, pecuniary
benefit, or misappropriated any government funds, nor is there any material to
establish collusion with the beneficiaries, who themselves have not been
arrayed as accused.
9.
It is further submitted that even if the entire charge sheet allegations are
accepted at face value, no offence under „the IPC.,‟ or „the PC Act.,‟ is made
out against the petitioner, and continuation of criminal proceedings would
amount to abuse of process of law.
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
10.
The learned counsel further submits that the petitioner has already
suffered departmental punishment merely for counter-signing certificates and
that the criminal prosecution is unsustainable in the absence of any
incriminating material. The learned trial court, while dismissing the discharge
petition under Section 239 of „the Cr.P.C.,‟ failed to appreciate the absence of
prima facie evidence and proceeded on assumptions and presumptions.
Therefore, the impugned order is liable to be set aside and the petitioner
deserves to be discharged in the interest of justice.
11.
Per contra, Sri S. Sham Sundar Rao, the learned Special Public
Prosecutor for ACB appearing for Respondent No.1 argued that as there was
a prima facie case made out against the Petitioners, the learned Trial Court
did not discharge the Petitioners. There were own admissions of the
Petitioners that they issued encroachment certificates though they had no
authority which shows that they colluded with other accused in commission of
the alleged offences. The learned Special Public Prosecutor further submits
that the Petitioners/AO7 and AO3 cannot through the blame on AO4 inasmuch
as before completion of documentation the Petitioner/AO7 and AO3 have to
satisfy with the contents of the certificates issued by AO4. Therefore, along
with AO3 and AO4 the Petitioner/AO7 is responsible for their negligence and
discharging their duties, as a result the entire scandal was taken place as their
exists a prima facie case against the Petitioner/AO7 it is urged to dismiss the
petitions.
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
12.
The learned Special Public Prosecutor appearing for ACB before the
learned Trial Court filed a counter on behalf of the prosecution contending
that, on the basis of the complaint lodged by the District Collector, Guntur
dated 23.03.2001, an enquiry was conducted. In the enquiry report, the
Enquiry Officer opined that all the accused officers, including the
petitioner/Accused Officer No.6, were involved in large-scale irregularities,
misuse, and misappropriation of Government funds in the implementation of
the Land Development Scheme at Potharlanka Village, resulting in a loss of
approximately Rs.34,00,000/- to the Government exchequer.
13.
It was further stated that the accused officers were responsible for the
loss of Government money and that prosecution under „the PC Act.,‟ was
recommended. It was furthermore contended that, in the said enquiry, the
petitioner/AO6 along with other accused were held responsible for the
irregularities and misappropriation of funds belonging to the SC Corporation.
The prosecution asserted that the removal of the petitioner/AO6 from service
was independent of and unconnected with the criminal prosecution. On these
grounds, the prosecution prayed for dismissal of the petition.
14.
The learned Trial Court, after considering the material on record and
conducting an enquiry, declined to discharge the petitioners and dismissed the
petitions, holding that a prima facie case was made out against them.
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
15.
Thoughtful consideration is bestowed on the arguments advanced by
the learned counsel for the Petitioners and the learned Special Public
Prosecutor. I have perused the record.
16.
Now the point for consideration is:
“Whether the orders in Crl.M.Nos.1027 of 2013 and 133 of 2014
dated 06.10.2022 in C.C.No.15 of 2023 passed by the learned
Special Judge for SPE and ACB Cases-cum-III Additional District
Judge, Vijayawada, are correct, legal, and proper with respect to
its finding, or order, and there are any material irregularities? And
to what relief?”
17.
It is alleged that the MRO and MDO, Kollur, issued false certificates in
favour of 375 beneficiaries certifying that each beneficiary individually
possessed Ac. 0.75 cents of land. It is further alleged that while issuing such
certificates, the revenue officials failed to verify the total extent of land held by
each beneficiary and whether the same tallied with the existing cultivable land.
The officers who conducted subsequent inspections merely relied upon the
earlier reports without independent verification. The petitioners, being
government servants, had discharged their duties in the larger interest of the
State, and mere dereliction or irregularity in discharge of official duties, in the
absence of concrete evidence of misappropriation with conspiracy, cannot be
fastened criminal liability upon them.
18.
The higher and supervising officials had sufficient opportunity and
scope to verify, scrutinize, and supervise the work done and the documents
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
issued by the petitioners. However, it appears that the supervising authorities
failed to discharge their duties and instead sought to attribute blame to the
petitioners by alleging their involvement in the so-called called scandal. Even
assuming that there was dereliction of duty or procedural irregularity, the
petitioners cannot be subjected to criminal prosecution in the absence of any
material establishing misappropriation of government funds or receipt of
pecuniary benefit dishonestly or fraudulently.
19.
The Vigilance and Enforcement report dated 01.12.1999 primarily
alleges improper verification of land ownership and reliance on certificates
issued by the MRO, Kollur, and in fact fixes responsibility mainly on the MRO
and MDO. Mere negligence or improper verification, at best, would warrant
departmental action and not launching criminal prosecution.
20.
It is undisputed, a fortiori, that the beneficiaries were in possession of
the land and that three departments, namely the SC Corporation, Panchayat
Raj Department, and Revenue Department, were required to act in
coordination. The enquiry commenced on 23.11.1998, the FIR was registered
on 02.05.2001, sanction was accorded by the Government on 29.03.2012,
and the charge sheet was filed in 2013, whereupon the discharge petition was
immediately filed and came to be dismissed only on 06.10.2022 after nearly
nine years.
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
21.
Though it is alleged that due to improper documentation loans were
granted to persons not entitled, it is not in dispute that the land was under
cultivation. Even as per the Vigilance and Enforcement report, the land was
assigned to the Adi Andhra Cooperative Society for collective cultivation by
SC and BC communities, and though individual possession may not strictly
arise, 375 beneficiaries were collectively in possession of about 274 acres of
land.
22.
It is pertinent to note that a learned Single Judge of this Court, in
Komarapuri Gangachalam v. Government of Andhra Pradesh 1, allowed
the revision case filed by Accused Officer No.1 setting aside the order refusing
discharge passed in Crl.M.P.No.480 of 2013 in C.C.No.15 of 2013 by the
learned Trial Court. Accused Officer No.1 was the Executive Director of the
SC Corporation during the relevant period, i.e., from 15.08.1996 to
18.09.1997.
23.
In Komarapuri Gangachalam supra at paragraph No.21, it was
observed that the attribution against the revision petitioner/Accused Officer
No.1 was confined to his failure to diligently monitor the utilization of funds.
Thus, what was alleged against him was essentially an administrative lapse.
Mere administrative failure cannot be equated to a criminal offence unless
there is material, and allegations based on such material, indicating fraudulent
or dishonest intention. In the case on hand, the essential criminal element is
Criminal Revision Case No.983 of 2023 dated 12.12.2024
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
not made out from the allegations or the material placed before the Court. The
other allegation was that he released funds through a lower cadre officer
instead of a higher cadre officer. Such a lapse on the administrative side may
warrant appropriate departmental or administrative action. However, the
allegations do not indicate that this lapse was committed with an intention to
misappropriate the funds or to enable other officers to do so.
24.
In the instant case also, the allegation against Accused Officer No.6 is
that he issued land enjoyment certificates illegally in collusion with Accused
Officer No.4. Accused Officer No.6 has admitted about issuance of the
enjoyment certificates. However, he contends that the same were issued on
the oral instructions of Accused Officer No.4. Even assuming that Accused
Officer No.6 issued the enjoyment certificates, the same would, at best,
warrant disciplinary action, including setting aside of such certificates. There is
no material on record to show that Accused Officer No.6 misappropriated any
Government funds, nor is there any evidence indicating the extent of alleged
misappropriation attributable to him. Accused Officer No.6 is aged about 70
years and had worked as the Village Administrative Officer of Potharlanka
Village, Kollur Mandal, more than one and a half decades ago
25.
Similarly, Accused Officer No.7 is aged about 61 years and was working
as Village Development Officer/Village Secretary. There is no material on
record to show that Accused Officer No.7 indulged in any misappropriation of
Government funds in conspiracy with other accused. There are no specific
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
allegations against him either in the complaint or in the charge sheet to that
effect. Therefore, he cannot also be subjected to criminal prosecution. It is
undisputed that Accused Officer No.7, along with Accused Officer No.3, was
required to satisfy themselves about the contents of the certificates issued by
Accused Officer No.4 before completion of the documentation. Such lapse, if
any, amounts to administrative dereliction or negligence in the discharge of
official duties and cannot be construed as sharing a common intention with the
other accused to misappropriate Government funds. Even assuming that
Accused Officer No.7 discharged his duties in a derelict manner, the same
would warrant only departmental action and not criminal prosecution. Mere
improper verification of the documents prepared by Accused Officer No.4
cannot be attributed to Accused Officer No.7 so as to fasten criminal liability
for the offences punishable under Sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(c) and
13(1)(d) of „the PC Act.,‟ and Sections 418, 420, and 477A of „the I.P.C‟. There
is no prima facie material available against the petitioners to proceed further
by framing charges. The order passed by the learned Trial Court is perverse
and unsustainable in law and, therefore, liable to be interfered with and set
aside.
26.
In the result, the Criminal Revisions Cases are allowed setting aside the
orders passed in Crl.M.P.Nos.1027 of 2013 and 133 of 2014 and the
Petitioners/AO6 and AO7 are discharged from C.C.15 of 2013 on the file of
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
the learned Special Judge for SPE and ACB Cases-Cum-III Additional District
Judge, Vijayawada. No order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
Dr.Y. LAKSHMANA RAO, J.
Date: 11.02.2026
KMS
Dr.YLR, J
Crl.R.C.Nos.1022 and 1042 of 2022
Dated 11.02.2026
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE Y. LAKSHMANA RAO
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NOs: 1022 and 1042 of 2022
Date: 11.02.2026
KMS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review