Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
LA App. No.108 of 2019
Sri Uttam Majumder,
Son of Sri Milan Behari Majumder, of No-1 College Road, Sarasima,
P.O. Sarasima, P.S. Belonia, District South Tripura, Pin 799155. At
present residing at Ker Chowmuhani, T.G. Road, Ramnagar Road
No.-2, P.O. Ramnagar, P.S. West Agartala, District West Tripura,
Pin 799002.
……… Claimant Petitioner/Appellant(s)
–Versus–
1.
The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction),
N.F. Railway, Agartala, West Tripura, Badharghat Railway Station,
P.O. Siddhi Ashram, P.S. Amtali, District West Tripura.
………Appellants-Respondent(s)
2.
The Land Acquisition Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia, P.O. Belonia, P.S. Belonia, District South
Tripura, Pin 799155.
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. J. Rajesh, Advocate.
Mr. N. Majumder, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI.
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Date of hearing
:
5th February, 2024.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
13th March, 2024.
YES
Whether fit for reporting
NO
√
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
A land area of 1.97 acre (of class chara and tilla) under
plot Nos.5636/6349/p and 5636/6350/p of Mouja Sarasima, South
Tripura was acquired vide notification No.9(05)-REV/ACQ/XII/2012
dated 15.03.2012 by the Government for construction of a new
railway line from Agartala to Sabroom.
[2]
The
LA
Collector
collected
certain
sale
deeds
to
determine the compensation but ultimately discarded all those
deeds on the ground that location of those lands were not nearer to
the acquired land and ultimately basing on the valuation chart, as
maintained by the Government, assessed the valuation of the
acquired
land
@Rs.4,00,000/-
per
kani.
An
amount
of
Rs.3,22,400/- was also awarded by him as value of 403 numbers of
rubber trees and further Rs.1000/- for 5 nos. of mango trees,
Rs.120/- for one karai tree, Rs.450/- for one Garjan tree and
Rs.150/- for 2 nos. of Teak tree totalling Rs.3,24,120/-.
[3]
The appellant insisted for reference under Section 18 of
the LA Act before the LA Court and accordingly, after hearing, the
LA Judge awarded compensation @Rs.6,00,000/- per kani. The
appellant was also allowed to receive compensation for 403
numbers of rubber trees @Rs.8,500/- for each tree, Rs.1,000/- for
one koroi tree, Rs.1000/- for one garjan tree of diameter 2 inches
and further Rs.1,000/- for two numbers of garjan trees of diameter
1 inch, Rs.1,500/- for five numbers of mango saplings and Rs.300/for two numbers of teak saplings, totalling Rs.34,30,300/-.
[4]
This Court earlier in this appeal decided compensation
for land @Rs.10,00,000/- per kani and the cost of each rubber tree
@Rs.10,000/-. Value of other trees as assessed by the LA Judge
was, however, kept unaltered.
[5]
The appellant, thereafter, preferred Civil Appeal No.6280
of 2023 with SLP(C) No.15550 of 2022 and finally, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court vide order dated 27.09.2023 remanded the matter
for fresh determination of market value of the acquired land
keeping in view of the exemplars relied upon by the appellant
before the Land Acquisition Collector/Reference Court. The relevant
portion of observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court is extracted
herein below:
“12.
It appears to us that the High Court ought not to
have determined the compensation only on the basis of
one sale instance or the amount claimed by the
appellants in their reference under Section 18 of the
Act. All that the High Court was required to do was to
consider the sale instances and then determine as to
whether all the sale instances or any one of them is
comparable with the acquired land for the purpose of
assessing the fair and just market value of the acquired
land.
13.
For the reasons aforestated, the appeals are
allowed in part, the impugned judgments dated
16.07.2021 and 07.07.2021 are set aside and the
matters are remanded to the High Court for a fresh
determination of the market value of the acquired land
of the appellants keeping in view the exemplars relied
upon
by
them
before
the
Land
Acquisition
Collector/Reference Court.
14.
It goes without saying that the High Court will
not reduce the compensation already awarded to the
appellants at the rate of Rs.10,00,000/- per kani.
15.
We request the High Court to re-determine the
rate of compensation within a period of four months
from the date of appearance of the parties before the
High Court.
16.
It is clarified that we have not expressed any
opinion on the merits of the appellant’s claim.
17.
As
a
result,
the
pending
applications also stand disposed of.”
interlocutory
[6]
On remand, after reopening the hearing of the case, the
claimant
adduced
one
additional
evidence
i.e.
report
dated
27.11.2023 issued by the Executive Engineer, Belonia Division,
PWD(R&B), Belonia, South Tripura along with a hard copy of one
google map showing aerial distance of the acquired plot with some
other plots (marked as Exbt.4/1 and Exbt.4/2 respectively). The
Executive Engineer, Belonia Division, PWD(R&B), Belonia, South
Tripura was also examined as PW-2 but his status would be PW-4.
Registry is to make necessary correction(s) in his evidence sheet in
this regard.
[7]
During hearing, Mr. J. Rajesh, learned counsel argued
that the appellant took possession of the acquired land from one
Shanti Dutta and his wife, Sukla Dutta, for 99 years vide Lease
Deed No.1-2055 dated 18.11.2002 (Exbt.1 series) and developed
the land by planting rubber trees therein against huge costing and
when the expected time for tapping such rubber came, the land
was acquired to the utter deprivation of the appellant. According to
him, the LA Collector did not prove any sale exemplar to contradict
the sale exemplars as proved by the appellant and, therefore, the
said sale exemplars are most reliable. He also tried to show the
distance of plots involved in one of those sale exemplars from the
acquired land relying on said Exbt.4/1 and Exbt.4/2. Finally, he
referred to the following decisions of Hon’ble Apex Court:
(i)
Mahesh
Dattatray
Thirthkar
vs.
State
of
Maharashtra, (2009) 11 SCC 141- At Para-47 it was observed
that minor inconsistency in the testimony of witness do not warrant
non-reliance of the same.
(ii)
Chandrashekar (Dead) by LRS. & Ors. vs.
Land Acquisition Officer & Anr., (2012) 1 SCC 390- Hon’ble
Supreme Court at Para 22 reiterated the principles as enunciated in
Lal Chand vs. Union of India, (2009) 15 SCC 769 and A.P. Housing
Board vs. K. Manohar Reddy, (2010) 12 SCC 707, that while
applying the sale consideration of a small piece of developed land
to determine the market value of a large tract of undeveloped
acquired land, deductions between 20% to 75% can be made. But
in 2009 in Subh Ram case, Apex Court restricted deduction on
account of the “first component” or development, as also, on
account of the “second component” of development to 33
(iii)
% each.
Ashok Kumar & Anr. vs. State of Haryana,
(2016) 4 SCC 544- In this case, Hon’ble Supreme Court at Para 7
held that a higher compensation than what is claimed by the
applicant in his pleading can be awarded by the Court and it is the
duty of the court to award just and fair compensation taking into
consideration the true market value and other relevant factors,
irrespective of claim made by the owner.
Finally, learned counsel prayed for a higher rate of
compensation @Rs.40,00,000/- per kani for the land.
[8]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. S.G.I. for NF Railway, on
the other hand, argued that the map as produced under Exbt.4/2
by the appellant did not demonstrate the physical distance between
the lands of sale exemplars and the acquired land and nothing was
proved by the appellant to show such actual physical distance.
According to him, aerial distance cannot be taken into consideration
for determining the market value. Learned Dy. S.G.I. also argued
that maximum sale exemplars, as relied on by the appellant, are
transacted for residential purposes i.e. for bastu (tilla) class of land
which could not form the basis for determination of compensation.
Referring to cross-examination of the present appellant, learned
Dy. S.G.I. submitted that according to the appellant himself,
acquired land was situated at a distance of 2.5 Km from Belonia
Municipality area and therefore, the acquired land was situated
within undeveloped area having no potentiality.
[9]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. S.G.I. finally referred to
the following decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court:
(a) Kiran
Tandon
vs.
Allahabad
Development
Authority & Anr., (2004) 10 SCC 745- At para-10 it was
observed by the Apex Court that Collector’s award under Section
11 is nothing more than an offer of compensation made by the
Government to the claimants and burden of proving that the
amount of compensation awarded by the Collector is inadequate
lies upon the claimant and he is in the position of a plaintiff.
(b) Shaji Kuriakose & Anr. vs. Indian Oil Corpn.
Ltd. & Ors., (2001) 7 SCC 650- At Para-3 it was observed that
while determining the valuation of land under comparable sales
method, the following factors are required to be fulfilled:
(1) the sale must be a genuine transaction,
(2) the sale deed must have been executed at the time
proximate to the date of issue of notification under Section 4
of the Act,
(3) the land covered by the sale must be in the vicinity of the
acquired land,
(4) the land covered by the sales must be similar to the
acquired land, and
(5) that the size of plot of the land covered by the sales be
comparable to the land acquired.
The Hon’ble Apex Court further observed that if all these
factors are satisfied, then there is no reason why the sale value of
the land covered by the sales be not given for the acquired land.
However, if there is dissimilarity in regard to locality, shape, site or
nature of land between land covered by sales and land acquired, it
is open to the court to proportionately reduce the compensation for
acquired land to what is reflected in the sales, depending upon the
disadvantages attached with the acquired land.
(c) Ravinder Narain & Anr. vs. Union of India,
(2003) 4 SCC 481- At para-9, it was observed that if the following
principles of fixation of market value with reference to comparable
sale are made, the element of speculation can be reduced to a
minimum:
(i)
when sale is within a reasonable time of the date
of notification under Section 4(1);
(ii) it should be a bona fide transaction;
(iii) it should be of the land acquired or of the land
adjacent to the land acquired; and
(iv) it should possess similar advantages.
Same principle was also reiterated in Karnataka Urban
Water
Supply
&
Drainage
Board
&
Ors.
vs.
K.S.
Gangadharappa & Anr., (2009) 11 SCC 164, as referred by
learned Dy. S.G.I.
(d)
Major General Kapil Mehra & Ors. vs. Union of
India & Anr., (2015) 2 SCC 262- At para-10 it was observed by
the Apex Court that while fixing the market value of the acquired
land, the land acquisition officer is required to keep in mind the
following factors: (i) existing geographical situation of the land; (ii)
existing use of the land; (iii) already available advantages, like
proximity to National or State Highway or road and/or developed
area; and (iv) market value of other land situated in the same
locality/village/area or adjacent or very near to the acquired land.
(e) Lal Chand vs. Union of India & Anr., (2009) 15
SCC 769- At para-13 it was observed that the percentage of
“deduction for development” to be made to arrive at the market
value of large tracts of undeveloped agricultural land (with potential
for development), with reference to the sale price of small
developed plots, varies between 20% to 75% of the price of such
developed plots, the percentage depending upon the nature of
development of the layout in which the exemplar plots are situated.
(f) M/s. Printers House Pvt. Ltd. vs. Mst. Saiyadan
(Deceased) by L. Rs. & Ors., AIR 1994 SC 1160- The relevant
observation at Para-30 as referred was that for determination of
compensation on the basis of comparable sales method, the
proximity of land of sale exemplar to the acquired land assumes
great significance.
Taking recourse to all these decisions of the Apex Court,
learned Dy. S.G.I. submits that the appellant is not entitled to
further enhanced compensation.
[10]
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. also made
similar submission. However, he supported the report of the
Executive Engineer, PWD as marked under Exbt.4/1 and 4/2.
[11]
The claimant proved 5 (five) numbers of sale exemplars
under Exbt.2 series during hearing before the learned LA Judge to
support his claim. Some sheets of revenue map, as proved under
Exbt.2 series, also do not indicate the location of plots of sale
exemplars and the acquired plot to show the approximate distance
between
them.
However,
the
Exbt.4/2
(additional
evidence)
indicates the approximate distance (aerial distance) of one sale
exemplar, under Exbt.2 series bearing no.1-1535 dated 09.12.2010
from the acquired land. From this map, plot of another sale
exemplar bearing no.1-1483 dated 19.11.2010 may also be
guessed. The description of said 5 sale exemplars as relied on by
the appellant is reflected in a chart below:
Exbt.
No.
Deed No.
Plot No.
Class
Area
Sold
Value (in
Rs.)
Rate (in
Rs.)
Approximate
Distance
between
acquired Plot
and plots
under
Exhibits
series
No. 1-1366
dated
25.10.2010
Rubber
garden
(Chankhala
Lunga)
0.08
Acre
1,50,000/-
7,50,000/per kani
Not available
series
No.1-1483
dated
19.11.2010
Bagan
(Tilla)
0.06
Acre
1,50,000/-
10 lakhs
per kani
Not available
series
No.1-1533
dated
15.12.2010
Bastu
(Tilla)
0.09
Acre
6,75,000/-
30 lakhs
per kani
Maybe 1.8
Km or so
series
No.1-164
dated
10.02.2011
Lunga
0.13
Acre
1,79,000/-
5,50,000/per kani
Not available
series
No.1-1535
dated
09.12.2010
2927/8358
0.01
Acre
1,50,000/-
60 lakhs
per kani
1.8 km
[12]
Bagan
(Tilla)
Remark
, if any
----
NorthPWD
Road
----
----
NorthNazrul
market of
Tripura
Govt.
According to appellant, originally the acquired land was
barren land which was turned into a rubber garden by making
necessary development.
So, for all practical purposes, it can be
presumed that he had turned the acquired land (except chara
class) practically into bagan (tilla) class of land. Out of 5 sale
exemplars
under
Exbt.2
series,
sale
deed
No.1-1366
dated
25.10.2010, No.1-164 dated 10.02.2011 and No.1-1533 dated
15.12.2010 relate to different classes of land other than bagan
(tilla) or chara classes of land. Only, the deed No.1-1483 dated
19.11.2010 and deed No.1-1535 dated 09.12.2010 relates to
bagan (tilla) class of land and the former was transacted
@Rs.10,00,000/- per kani whereas the latter was transacted
@Rs.60,00,000/- per kani. Both the sale deeds are contemporary
in time and executed in the year 2010.
[13]
In Land Acquisition Officer, Kammarapally Village,
Nizamabad District, A.P. vs. Nookala Rajamallu & Ors.,
(2003) 12 SCC 334- At para-6 of the judgment, it was observed
by the Apex Court that where large area is the subject-matter of
acquisition, rate at which small plots are sold cannot be said to be a
safe criterion. It cannot, however, be laid down as an absolute
proposition that rates fixed for small plots cannot be the basis for
fixation of the rate. For example, where there is no other material,
it may in appropriate cases be open to the adjudicating court to
make comparison of prices paid for small plots of land. However, in
such cases necessary deductions/adjustments have to be made
while determining the prices.
[14]
In Mehrawal Khewaji Trust (Regd.) Faridkot & Ors.
vs. State of Punjab & Ors., 2012 AIR SCW 2822, at para-15, it
was also observed by the Apex Court that when there are several
exemplars with reference to similar lands (emphasis added), it is
the general rule that the highest of the exemplars, if it is satisfied,
that it is a bona fide transaction has to be considered and accepted.
When the land is being compulsorily taken away from a person, he
is entitled to the highest value which similar land in the locality is
shown to have fetched in a bona fide transaction entered into
between a willing purchaser and a willing seller near about the time
of the acquisition. It was also observed that it would seem to be
only
fair
that
transactions
are
where
relied
the
sale-deeds
pertaining
on
behalf
the
of
to
different
Government,
the
transaction representing the highest value should be preferred to
the rest unless there are strong circumstances justifying a different
course and it is not desirable to take an average of various saledeeds
placed
before
the
authority/court
for
fixing
fair
compensation.
[15]
The land under two sale deeds bearing no.1-1483 dated
19.11.2010 and bearing no.1-1535 dated 09.12.2010 are related to
Bagan (tilla) class of land. The distance of land under deed no.11483 from acquired land is not discernible from the map and said
land was transacted @ Rs.10 lakh per kani. The land of deed no.11535 is situated at a distance of 1.8 km from the acquired land and
was transacted @ Rs.60,00,000/- per kani. There is nothing in the
evidence to suggest that said transaction was not a bona fide
transaction. However, as per the map under Ext.4/2, said land is
situated at College Square area and much closer to the office of
D.M. & Collector, South Tripura. Hotel, Colleges, temples etc. are
nearer to it. The assessment note of the L.A. Collector also reflects
this deed and also another sale deed where lands of bagan (tilla)
class were sold @ Rs.60,00,000/- per kani. Therefore, transaction
at such rate is not unusual in that mouja. In light of the principle as
laid in Mehrawal Khewaji Trust (Regd.) Faridkot & Ors.
(Supra), deed no.1-1535 dated 09.12.2010 (Exbt.2 series) is
taken into consideration subject to necessary deduction. Said deed
was executed for a very small tract of land of area 0.01 acre and it
is situated just adjacent to Najrul market as constructed by Govt.
of Tripura. Therefore, it appears to be located in a commercial
area. Further, the appellant in his cross-examination had admitted
that the acquired land was situated at a distance of 2.5 Km from
Belonia Municipal area. 30% deduction, therefore, is required to be
made on that count considering higher potentiality of the land.
Considering the long distance between land of said deed and the
acquired plot, 20% is deducted and considering small area of land
sold under said sale exemplar, further 20% is deducted. Thus, total
deduction required to be made comes to (30%+20%+20%) =70%.
Market
value of
acquired land
is, therefore, determined at
(Rs.60,00,000 -70% of Rs.60,00,000)= Rs.18,00,000/- per kani.
No further benefit of escalation of price is given to the appellant.
The award passed by the L.A. Judge is completely bereft of
reasoning, and even there is no discussion of said deed no.1-1535
dated 09.12.2010 in the judgment. The L.A. Judge has mentioned
some other sale exemplars in the judgment, going beyond the
evidence.
[16]
Learned Dy. S.G.I. though argued that the aerial
distance of acquired plot from the sale exemplar could not be taken
into consideration but such a plea was not convincing as the
revenue map also demonstrates the distance measured by scale
and not the physical distance based on road connectivity.
In the result, the compensation for the value of land is
accordingly decided @Rs.18,00,000/- per kani. The value of rubber
trees is maintained @ Rs.10,000/- each. The rate of other trees
shall remain same as determined by the L.A. Judge. The present
appellant shall get 75% of compensation as deriving from the land
value and rest 25% will go to the original owners of the land. The
compensation for the trees will be disbursed to the appellant only.
Needless to say, the compensation shall carry 30% solatium and
other statutory interests and additional compensation as awarded
by the LA Judge, South Tripura, Belonia.
The instant appeal is accordingly disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
Registry is to re-consign the LCRs with a copy of this
judgment.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE BANERJEE
Date: 2024.03.14 15:17:18 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review